Why i choose Punch over Exter. I work in city and rural areas. 1) exter's front bumper can touch ground or stones on bad roads. 2) very soft suspension can causes bumpy ride on bad rod in fast speed. ( I have to rush to hospital some time ) 3) exter's back seat gives you experience that you sat very low as compared to punch. 4) exter gives you less mileage than punch.. Feature wise Exter is good. But I have to reject it because of point number 1 and point number 3.
Spend 1 lakh on a good driving school & learn to be a better driver then. It is stupidity to buy a car basis of how it will perform in its last few microseconds before being destroyed in a crash. You are paying 2 lakh extra for a feature which will never even be used during the lifetime of the car if you're a good driver. All these crash tests are done in controlled environments at speeds of 60-80 kmph so the cars are designed to pass these tests. If any of these controlled variables change in real life, one can't predict how the car will behave. for e.g. if the passengers sitting in the back seat don't wear seat belts (which I have not seen anyone in India ever wearing), during a crash their bodies will fly forward & crash into the windshield or front seats & kill everyone. The cars are not designed to save front passengers from flying bodies coming from the back during a frontal impact.
@@omcena you're not very smart, are you? I said flying passenger bodies from the back often kill even the driver who's wearing a seat belt and has air bags because the 5* rating only works if everyone in the car is wearing seat belts. Guess bad drivers like you can only hope that your car keeps you safe because your driving skills are crap. Also, the Punch is rated 5* as per old standards. As per the new GNCAP standard, 6 air bags are necessary for 5* rating. The Punch you're driving only comes with 2 air bags which makes it a 3* car as per the latest standard. The Exter comes with 6 air bags standard btw.
Tata Punch's biggest disadvantage is their crap After Sales Service which in itself will create at least a 1 lakh difference in value between both cars. I have heard so many experiences of Tata customers where Tata Service Centers damaged their new cars during the 1st free service. Good new cars start having problems after the 1st servicing at a Tata Service Center.
Hi Author, Please guide me in AMT which is best Punch or Exter. I don’t require sunroof but I require keyless and other decent features. My budget is 10Lakhs
after watching your video multiple time.. finally i bought exter..thanks v3cars....& a suggestion for your website, it needs to be more handy(in comparing section) 😊
V3 Cars team always create usually video.. thank you In constant of both Car Tata punch has added advantage of Safety rating.which gives upper hand in market no doubt top selling car in India 😊
@@12345ashoo It's the matter of the platform on which the car has been made. Punch's platform secured five stars. Moreover, Exter is based on Grand i10 Nios platform which secured two stars few years ago.
Aadarsh explain on what grounds punch got 5 star…don’t just go by NCAP, creta bhi 2 star hai jo punch se zyada strong build hai…or uska i10ke platform, se koi lena jai😊, inform urself more…just a friendly suggestion
@@karan8015yes, dab jata hai, iska solution sirf ₹1000 ke ek rubber cap,se ho jata hai jo suspension ko hard ke deta hai Also, jab car dabti hai tou tyre sirf hood ke Andre jata hai jiska disadvantage tab hai jab alloy wheel lagaye ho…jo heavy hota hai ₹1000 spend karke suspension pe rubber cap lagwa and its done
What about suspension , ride and handling , build quality?? Doesn’t make any sense of cost … add these parameters too otherwise this is incomplete comparison
Agree…real life use parameters ko bhi consider karma chahiye, these aspects u mentioned have not been covered…I guess the anchor set a ground rule to compare basis cost of ownership & value but in end real-time functioning aspects ko miss kar diya
Let’s wait for year end or two more quarters to see Exter sales..and then it will be a justified comparison, abhi Exter ko launch hue sirf ek saal hua hai
Still comparing exter n punch? Exter - no SUV look both interior n exterior. But 4cylinder 1.2 Kappa engine is always better than 3 cylinder revotron engine in punch. Punch has good tyre profile and good stability than exter.. Rest are almost same in both... Now buyers need to decide... Nothing to compare no more...
6 airbags is good when the car structure is strong. You can be safe in punch even with 2 airbags, Exter will not save you in 6 airbags if the steel structure is weak. Bed mattress will protect you from earthquake but if the whole building cracks down mattress is not enough to not save you.
We've rated both the cars objectively, and given you a delta between the value that each of these cars justify. All the subjective stuff, be it safety, ride, handling, etc. (whatever suits whom) -- you can choose whether it's worth the premium you're paying for the lower value car or not.
@@A_n_i_r_b_a_n 5-10 years ago no one looked into safety nd build quality, Suzuki cars give more mileage cause of being light due to poor build quality thin metal.., the money saved used on quality of finishing even if they are hard plastics , they appear good to eye but inside hollow
Kia carens mein new variants introduce hue hai both in petrol and diesel and also new mt in diesel. Please make a video on it.. which will be value for money variant in diesel manual??
I bought exter amt sxo, connect, 1 month back ,after watching v3cars reviews, and now fully satisfied in all aspects ❤❤
Why i choose Punch over Exter. I work in city and rural areas.
1) exter's front bumper can touch ground or stones on bad roads.
2) very soft suspension can causes bumpy ride on bad rod in fast speed. ( I have to rush to hospital some time )
3) exter's back seat gives you experience that you sat very low as compared to punch.
4) exter gives you less mileage than punch..
Feature wise Exter is good. But I have to reject it because of point number 1 and point number 3.
Exter for better ownership experience
Proud owner of Exter very.smooth great features and reliable service of Hyundai
Punch is the best anytime I just riding it and I’m proud of my decision drove exter also but wasn’t satisfied
V3 CarS rocks with data , Appreciated Definitely Many Efforts behind..
Support You ❤
We're excited to hear that you're finding our content useful. Don't forget to subscribe to our UA-cam channel.
The best comparison video, helped me choose a car and I bought a Hyundai Exter SX......
Thank you ❤
The main thing u left safety, punch is proper 5 star rated car, I would pay extra 2 lakhs for safety as it can't be bought again
6:30 me kya bataya he bhai fir? Video to dekhlo poora ki har jagah bas 5 star-5 star karna he
@@abhinavdante dekha hei pura video, baat hei ki u can't value safety
Spend 1 lakh on a good driving school & learn to be a better driver then. It is stupidity to buy a car basis of how it will perform in its last few microseconds before being destroyed in a crash. You are paying 2 lakh extra for a feature which will never even be used during the lifetime of the car if you're a good driver.
All these crash tests are done in controlled environments at speeds of 60-80 kmph so the cars are designed to pass these tests. If any of these controlled variables change in real life, one can't predict how the car will behave. for e.g. if the passengers sitting in the back seat don't wear seat belts (which I have not seen anyone in India ever wearing), during a crash their bodies will fly forward & crash into the windshield or front seats & kill everyone. The cars are not designed to save front passengers from flying bodies coming from the back during a frontal impact.
@@MegaRazzzz it's not how safe u drive it's the road, let me be safe 1st passengers later
@@omcena you're not very smart, are you? I said flying passenger bodies from the back often kill even the driver who's wearing a seat belt and has air bags because the 5* rating only works if everyone in the car is wearing seat belts. Guess bad drivers like you can only hope that your car keeps you safe because your driving skills are crap.
Also, the Punch is rated 5* as per old standards. As per the new GNCAP standard, 6 air bags are necessary for 5* rating. The Punch you're driving only comes with 2 air bags which makes it a 3* car as per the latest standard.
The Exter comes with 6 air bags standard btw.
Tata Punch's biggest disadvantage is their crap After Sales Service which in itself will create at least a 1 lakh difference in value between both cars. I have heard so many experiences of Tata customers where Tata Service Centers damaged their new cars during the 1st free service. Good new cars start having problems after the 1st servicing at a Tata Service Center.
Exter best hai.. Kyoki car ka dil engine important h or primium feel alag
Exter has mileage of 18.3 on 4.5k kilometres on average.
Punch is always on top in the above segment....
Customer knows the better value offers in all aspects...
Hi Author, Please guide me in AMT which is best Punch or Exter.
I don’t require sunroof but I require keyless and other decent features. My budget is 10Lakhs
after watching your video multiple time.. finally i bought exter..thanks v3cars....& a suggestion for your website, it needs to be more handy(in comparing section) 😊
Exter - Very smooth and refined engine ❤ . Very good city car.
V3 Cars team always create usually video.. thank you
In constant of both Car Tata punch has added advantage of Safety rating.which gives upper hand in market no doubt top selling car in India 😊
this cannel makes the best comparison videos
Comparison comes to an end when the one car provides better safety.
It is just matter of certificate. Exter does have all safety features punch have. Don't judge straight away
@@12345ashoo Safety features are different from build quality. During the impact, the build quality acts primarily followed by the safety features.
@@12345ashoo It's the matter of the platform on which the car has been made. Punch's platform secured five stars. Moreover, Exter is based on Grand i10 Nios platform which secured two stars few years ago.
Aadarsh explain on what grounds punch got 5 star…don’t just go by NCAP, creta bhi 2 star hai jo punch se zyada strong build hai…or uska i10ke platform, se koi lena jai😊, inform urself more…just a friendly suggestion
Best channel for car guidance .. very well explanations ..great going bhai 👍👍👍
Proud owner of EXTER SX. Soft gears, noiseless cabin, seating comfort ❤
Saare reviewers bta rahe h k peeche waha suspension dab jata peeche 3 log baithne pe. Kya ye sach h?
@@karan8015yes, dab jata hai, iska solution sirf ₹1000 ke ek rubber cap,se ho jata hai jo suspension ko hard ke deta hai
Also, jab car dabti hai tou tyre sirf hood ke Andre jata hai jiska disadvantage tab hai jab alloy wheel lagaye ho…jo heavy hota hai
₹1000 spend karke suspension pe rubber cap lagwa and its done
@@karan8015nahi
Depending on usage - City driving Exter and on highway Punch
Obviously PUNCH❤
What about suspension , ride and handling , build quality?? Doesn’t make any sense of cost … add these parameters too otherwise this is incomplete comparison
Agree…real life use parameters ko bhi consider karma chahiye, these aspects u mentioned have not been covered…I guess the anchor set a ground rule to compare basis cost of ownership & value but in end real-time functioning aspects ko miss kar diya
Tata Punch have 5 star safety rating and safety must be first priority 😊
What is more better 5 star or feature? & u will take correct decision
Lekin har mahine punch
Exter se jyda hi sale ho rhi h ais akyu?
Production capacity
5 स्टार सेफ्टी, छोटी हैरियर 😹😹😹
So 👊 Is No 1 largest selling SUV...👍
Which car would have a better resale value?
Punch is selling 2x more units monthly compared to Exter. So obviously the demand for punch is higher
Let’s wait for year end or two more quarters to see Exter sales..and then it will be a justified comparison, abhi Exter ko launch hue sirf ek saal hua hai
Table color and classification need improvement.
Very good comparison
❤❤❤ Nice vedio. Great job , but Carb weight missing, also resale value.❤
We're excited to hear that you're finding our content useful. Don't forget to subscribe to our UA-cam channel.
I bought punch couple of months ago. I am really enjoying the experience. Exter is good but more height space less safety and built quality.
I will always go with TATA then going with korean car. No korea cars.
Haa 3 sal buad ,rust ka wait krrna .Aur
What about exter's travel height problem?
Please make video on comparison ln balino and punch
Plz reply exter build quality ???
I buy new car in Diwali
Punch has superior build quality than Exter. If you are only looking at build quality
Still comparing exter n punch?
Exter - no SUV look both interior n exterior. But 4cylinder 1.2 Kappa engine is always better than 3 cylinder revotron engine in punch.
Punch has good tyre profile and good stability than exter..
Rest are almost same in both...
Now buyers need to decide... Nothing to compare no more...
Sir also tell about star rating comparison
5 ⭐ for V3 Cars
Need creta sO vs elevate zx
Test drive link?
Exter ❤
Paji hath jod ra hun, kiger ka bhi video bna do
We'll do it soon
@@V3cars-Official thank you for the reply guys, my dad is hell bent on buying wagon r. I want to show him your analysis video to persuade otherwise.
3XO vs Nexon
Safety Gurantee in Punch Life hai jahan hai.....
Exter gives you 6 air bags don't believe news from what's app University 😅
6 airbags is good when the car structure is strong. You can be safe in punch even with 2 airbags, Exter will not save you in 6 airbags if the steel structure is weak.
Bed mattress will protect you from earthquake but if the whole building cracks down mattress is not enough to not save you.
@@soumyasuvramitra it's hundai we are talking about not Maruti 😂😂😂😂
What about safety
Make video on new kia carens 2024 varient
Kia Carens Petrol Variants Explained | Premium, Prestige/Plus, Luxury O, Luxury/Plus, X-line
ua-cam.com/video/Ep10nE2KJj8/v-deo.html
Neither for looks
Safety is not considered in cost value which is a very important factor
We've rated both the cars objectively, and given you a delta between the value that each of these cars justify. All the subjective stuff, be it safety, ride, handling, etc. (whatever suits whom) -- you can choose whether it's worth the premium you're paying for the lower value car or not.
agreed
@@V3cars-Official No one wants to buy an unsafe car, it should be included nd given some value
@@omcena Btw, Suzuki is the highest selling brand in India.
@@A_n_i_r_b_a_n 5-10 years ago no one looked into safety nd build quality, Suzuki cars give more mileage cause of being light due to poor build quality thin metal.., the money saved used on quality of finishing even if they are hard plastics , they appear good to eye but inside hollow
Bhai Punch hi lenge.
Punch, 5* rating in safety
Punch
Toyota taisor ki video please 😶🌫️
Toyota Taisor Variants Explained | E, S, S+, G & V | The Ultimate Analysis | April 2024
ua-cam.com/video/aNEgXnL1a34/v-deo.html
👍
❤❤
GNCP😂exter
Exter's road appearance is not good. Looks very small and not impressive. But Punch looks bold and nice on roads and great preformance as well.
Always Hyundai. Tata has a reputation of doing R & D on customers. Tata features are not reliable and of poor quality.
हुडई का दिल पीओके के लिए धडकता है देशद्रोही कंपनी😢😢😢
Kia carens mein new variants introduce hue hai both in petrol and diesel and also new mt in diesel. Please make a video on it.. which will be value for money variant in diesel manual??
Kia Carens Petrol Variants Explained | Premium, Prestige/Plus, Luxury O, Luxury/Plus, X-line
ua-cam.com/video/Ep10nE2KJj8/v-deo.html