Exter vs Punch vs Fronx - Which One to Buy? | MotoCast EP - 70 | Tamil Podcast | MotoWagon.

Поділитися
Вставка

КОМЕНТАРІ • 475

  • @thanjaieesan291
    @thanjaieesan291 Рік тому +76

    இதுவே பரவாயில்லை. பழைய செட்டப்பில் மற்ற இருவருடைய குரல் கிணற்றுக்குள் இருந்து வரும்☺

  • @barathseshadri5563
    @barathseshadri5563 Рік тому +28

    I am watching so many car reviews across india in Hindi, English etc. I have never come across such intellectual dialogues, comparisons, details, engineering information, mainly car parts vocabulary being discussed! Car details made simple and as it says ‘for common man’!
    Motowagon has also helped me make up my mind to choose my new car Baleno Alpha AGS. I am taking delivery today! 🎉
    Keep up the great work Motowagon! A big fan of your videos! Thank you!

  • @kaushikramkumar
    @kaushikramkumar Рік тому +86

    My vote is for the old table setup!

  • @vinodkumarmanoharan8429
    @vinodkumarmanoharan8429 Рік тому +11

    Owning Tata Punch Accomplish Manual from Jan2022, happy with my decision. Service is good in Coimbatore SGA. 80% of my rides are on hills (Ooty, kothagiri, Gudalur) and giving 12 to 14 mileage.. 19 to 20 in highways

    • @VidhyashankarL
      @VidhyashankarL 21 день тому

      I am planning to buy Punch Accomplish AMT, how is the after sales service. What is the mileage within city. Thanks

  • @TheSkpprabhu
    @TheSkpprabhu Рік тому +21

    Setup doesnt matter, the content matters that is where you guys rock 😀- By a nermayana motofam and proud owner of Citroen C3 Turbo. Was planning for the Hosur auto expo but could not make it..

  • @NemysisPrime
    @NemysisPrime Рік тому +51

    I'm a punch AMT owner.. You are right... The lower mid range is indeed weak.. But I'm happy with the car as this car is for my father who is more than 60 y.o. And he is a light footed driver. So in his context, his safety is more important than excellent engine performance. By his driving he extracts 16-18kmpl mileage from the punch( 3rd service involving oil and oil filter change while air filter and spark plug cleaning done) , while punch itself has good safety in terms of ncap rating.. I have a good peace of mind... Also my service centre is also good.. So overall, for me it was a good buy...

    • @sivaram6406
      @sivaram6406 Рік тому +4

      Where is your service center please mention the name

    • @NemysisPrime
      @NemysisPrime Рік тому +5

      @@sivaram6406 Adisakthi Tata Motors, Nagavara, Bengaluru

    • @DevNarayanan217
      @DevNarayanan217 Рік тому +3

      In tn not up to level brother

    • @riyainteriordesigners7
      @riyainteriordesigners7 Рік тому +3

      16- 28 kmpl😂 . Me 2 I own it, but it gives 9-10 kmpl...

    • @NemysisPrime
      @NemysisPrime Рік тому +2

      @@riyainteriordesigners7 after 3rd service you'll start getting upwards of 14kmpl...

  • @ravnamar3576
    @ravnamar3576 Рік тому +8

    Yesterday I got my Punch back home after it got accident with lorry... Customer care service insurance car was somewhat good than expected but I want to tell that is Safety in Punch. Driver door right back door was totally collapsed but I didn't even got a scratch. Then through insurance I got my car back after 20 days with brand new look. I'm so happy for it. I admit that engine is seemed to not so power due to its curb weight. Before Punch I own i10 old version, I could not imagine the happening if that accident happened while I'm driving i10. So
    o for good performance and best safety and comfort and butter smooth handling I'm so happy and satisfied with Punch. Great thanks to SGA Motors Cbe and Karruppusamy brother for his service guidance.

  • @rhishikishoretkc
    @rhishikishoretkc Рік тому +7

    This setup is good. Continue in this way. Good content btw.

  • @satheeshr8478
    @satheeshr8478 Рік тому +8

    I prefer table setup. Regarding cladding, older Brezza's was better than the new one. No worries about length of the Podcast. Always ready to listen till the end 💚😊

  • @geraldinechithrakalarex3173
    @geraldinechithrakalarex3173 Рік тому +1

    Setup present one good
    Both interacting people open up and speak loudly boldly and clearly
    Finally list out on behalf of motofamily in perspective of your opinion in display mode
    Keep rocking 🎉best wishes to the whole team!

  • @roshancbe5502
    @roshancbe5502 8 місяців тому

    Bro, I had lot of other options in my mind... almost finalizing on i10 sportz... suddenly I fixed my mind on EXTER. Wonderful discussion, got addicted to this Motocast. Thanks for your insight.

  • @JohnVianniSinger
    @JohnVianniSinger 11 місяців тому +1

    Superb content as usual.. Well informative and good analysis and comparisons.!! Cheers motowagon team..

  • @satish2723
    @satish2723 Рік тому +1

    This is the first time I’m watching your podcast, this is really awesome. Saw your EXTER review and that was excellent, made my mind to buy it 👌👌👌👌

  • @haroonrasheed4592
    @haroonrasheed4592 Рік тому

    Thanks Mr.Asir, i am the person which i spoke to you at Hosur AutoExpo about Tata service issue, once again thanks for bringing this point as a discussion in you podcast.

  • @kayden1672
    @kayden1672 Рік тому +1

    Well said. Ms spoiled breeze with huge plastic cladding. Same applies to punch. Previous breeze was the best sun4m suv.

  • @user-to9io8px6n
    @user-to9io8px6n Рік тому +1

    This is the better setup. Gives the feel of conversation.

  • @davidwilson5589
    @davidwilson5589 Рік тому +2

    You guys are right I am from Marthandam.. Never like the improper square clading, gimmick features, sun roof etc

  • @RAJKUMARRAJARATHNAMSUBRAMANIAN

    28:55 Bottom car image is good looking when compared to the top one. Send this image to the Hyundai design team. Well done bro👏👏👏👏👏

  • @ALIYYILA
    @ALIYYILA Рік тому +5

    Sitting on the Driver's seat of Fronx makes us feel like being in a well. But, I do not know about the other two.

  • @KK-xd7bg
    @KK-xd7bg 10 місяців тому +1

    Super review as usual! Asir you always rock with proper analysis!

  • @AbhinandSundararajan
    @AbhinandSundararajan Рік тому +1

    Super comparison bris. Aana C3, Kiger, Magnite, Punch nu vandhuttu Exter a marandhutteenga for "when to buy which car" 😅. No issues rest of the video told that.

  • @srvijaytnj
    @srvijaytnj Рік тому

    The new setup is very good and very attractive too.The conversation about yourself is very well reached. Please use this setup sir.. Thanks always for your support 🙏🙏🙏🙏

  • @eswaramoorthy782
    @eswaramoorthy782 11 місяців тому

    After long days i heard podcast.
    Especially briefing about most selling compact SUV's practicality is so informative.

  • @japan91
    @japan91 Рік тому +33

    All observation are really ground level.... Hyundai never taught tata will surpass them one day.. Now this nightmare made them produce exter... They never thought altroz will ditch i20 sales... Now punch sales alarmed them.. Thats why they made exter with loads of feature.

    • @philiptm1243
      @philiptm1243 Рік тому

      True n Studied Observation..👌👍👍

  • @balajia3592
    @balajia3592 Рік тому +3

    Have been waiting for this! First view! Thank you

  • @rajunarayanan3827
    @rajunarayanan3827 Рік тому

    Indha setup super ah iruku bro. Orey oru round table center la vecha complete ayidum😃👌

  • @raghavank.s1456
    @raghavank.s1456 Рік тому +2

    Only today we are able to see clearly the other two persons's faces. Let it continue this same way in the future too.

  • @karanbas
    @karanbas Рік тому +1

    yes I agree with you regarding the cladding design, it looks unfinished. and I too like the dechroming.

  • @bibo181108
    @bibo181108 Рік тому +1

    I own a punch and I m happy with my buying decision as it serves my Purpose.

  • @prasanthpalani3697
    @prasanthpalani3697 Рік тому

    This frame is cool and now it looks like perfect discussion panel. I wish to see this frame ❤

  • @Gangaraj.P
    @Gangaraj.P 11 місяців тому +1

    கடந்த ஞாயிற்றுக்கிழமை அருகிலுள்ள ஹுய்ண்டாய் ஷோரூமிற்குச் சென்றேன். புதிதாக அறிமுகப்படுத்தப்பட்ட Exter பற்றி விற்பனை நிர்வாகிக்கு எந்த புரிதலும் இல்லை. எக்ஸ்டரைப் பற்றி தெரிந்துகொள்ள உங்கள் Exter Drivereview மற்றும் Motocast எபிசோட் 70ஐப் பார்க்கும்படி நான் அவருக்குப் பரிந்துரைத்திருந்தேன். இன்று நான் அதே ஷோரூமுக்கு சென்றிருந்தேன், தெளிவான மதிப்பாய்வுக்கு MotoWagon சேனலுக்கு நன்றி என்று நிர்வாகி கூறினார். நான் அவர்களிடம் சொன்னேன், சேனல் உரிமையாளர்கள் கார்களை விரும்புகிறார்கள், அவர்கள் UA-cam சந்தாதாரர்களுடன் பகிர்ந்து கொள்வதில் மகிழ்ச்சி அடைகிறார்கள், நீங்கள் அவர்களைப் பின்தொடர வேண்டும். எனவே அவரது வேலை முன்னேற்றத்திற்காக தொடர்ந்து கற்றலை மேற்கொள்ளுமாறு நான் அவருக்கு அறிவுறுத்தினேன். உங்கள் வீடியோக்கள் என்னைப் போன்றவர்களுக்கு கார்களைப் பற்றி தெரிந்து கொள்வதற்காகவே. ஆனால் கார் துறையில் உள்ளவர்களுக்கு ஒரு வரப்பிரசாதம். நன்றி, இந்த சேவையை தொடரவும்

  • @colourskids7560
    @colourskids7560 Рік тому

    F2F better than previous one please continue the same all the best ❤

  • @rajeshathimoolam
    @rajeshathimoolam Рік тому

    Finally..my words accepted.
    U people changed the setup.Good to see

  • @muthukrishnanm8280
    @muthukrishnanm8280 Рік тому +3

    Most expected podcast 😊 Thanks a lot Anna 🎉

  • @SharkFishSF
    @SharkFishSF Рік тому

    Cladding is functional. When wheel hits stone, cladding can be changed easily instead of body work.

  • @kaushikramkumar
    @kaushikramkumar Рік тому +4

    @Asir sir. Been following you since recent times only (as I recently bought a car and started following you post that) so dont know if I can call myself a 'Nermaiyana MotoFam' but waiting from morning for this video! Keep up the good work. @motowagon

  • @vijayjayamani1674
    @vijayjayamani1674 Рік тому +1

    Indha setup continue pannunga nallairuku🎉

  • @kesavanmoorthykvalasu
    @kesavanmoorthykvalasu Рік тому +9

    I own 2013 grand i10.. thinking about buying a new car.. obviously my family priority is "safety".. for me exter is more appealing.. pricing also reasonable

  • @NirmalrajR
    @NirmalrajR Рік тому +5

    I would suggest cut the frame into half.. Show until head and torso level !
    Also Cover the screen like 30 percent each ...
    May be Asir bro at center and all 3 facing towards camera and turning just heads.. Now whole body is inclined away from camera..
    Pleasing to see.. you guys are eager to improve a lot 👏

  • @dharmarajmanickam4139
    @dharmarajmanickam4139 Рік тому

    Hi sir, I have a question . I saw your video for grand vitara. Is really good to buy a grand vitara(base variant)?

  • @ThushiMj
    @ThushiMj Рік тому

    My 1st car was 2018 i20 kappa 1.2 and I've sold that crap and got a diesel ritz on 2020 and now got an Ignis Delta and living happily 😍

  • @mnpramoth
    @mnpramoth Рік тому

    Suggestion from Nermayanamotofam
    Go with this setup but look after your backrest.. may hurt for long podcast.
    It would have been better and more informative podcast if you had presented with all the models comparison table in a slide..
    Thanks for details 🎉🎉

  • @abiramgurusamy1820
    @abiramgurusamy1820 11 місяців тому

    Nice Video
    Current setup looks good I would suggest to continue
    I liked the verdict as well.

  • @vishnuprasanth6631
    @vishnuprasanth6631 Рік тому +1

    Is the AMT good for the 1.2Ltr Kappa engine? Or the manual transmission is better? What does Motowagon team suggests?

  • @The_Simple_King
    @The_Simple_King Рік тому +1

    Good Discussion....
    Very useful....
    This setup is good

  • @sivaraman865
    @sivaraman865 Рік тому +1

    I feel companies are using Cladding as part of cost-cutting. Most of the bottom part around the car is completely covered in plastic cladding.

  • @samsingh7312
    @samsingh7312 Рік тому

    Table is good Enough because it's easy for you to look up to notes and give us with more information and statistics filled content

  • @rajaselvam6414
    @rajaselvam6414 Рік тому +1

    Bro ithu nalla irukku..Continue pannallam..This is my personal opinion...👌👌

  • @tamiltechrockers6007
    @tamiltechrockers6007 Рік тому +2

    Vera level 😍 topic asir bro ❤

  • @kingwin7658
    @kingwin7658 Рік тому +1

    Can you please check when 3 adults sit in the rear seat, does the Exter's real wheel arch gets so close to the wheels? Hope there wont be any defect in the suspension.

  • @kabilankabilan1299
    @kabilankabilan1299 Рік тому +1

    Superb conversation doubt's cleared..

  • @12345678jai
    @12345678jai Рік тому

    Really good setup 👌 to view easily for veiwers

  • @shortsmyview
    @shortsmyview Рік тому +1

    Guys I’m using nexon for 2 years yes service centre problem is there but now I’m leaving in FLP Tata kolathur they treating customer with care and excellent service like maruthi ..so many people to follow up I found this on maruthi only which is my previous brand ❤

  • @nithinn2012
    @nithinn2012 Рік тому

    This place is looking good! Please continue here!😊

  • @elangomalavan2276
    @elangomalavan2276 Рік тому +7

    Setup semma😂also the topic is to the point.

  • @manivikey447
    @manivikey447 Рік тому

    Set up is ur own convenient which includes ur budget also, for me content matters congratulations keep on doing nice contents.... ❤❤❤❤

  • @yugansamy
    @yugansamy Рік тому +2

    ippadiya continue pannunga.. this is nice. you may add a guest/present participant to give more contrarian points to make the cast interesting!!

  • @will_iam2489
    @will_iam2489 Рік тому +2

    That edited Exeter 👏👏 #NermaiyanaMotofam

  • @aleanderantony919
    @aleanderantony919 11 місяців тому

    For this setup, more lighting is required.
    Segment ah pirichi menjitinga....
    Decisions can be easily made out of this podcast. Nandrigal pala.

  • @NemysisPrime
    @NemysisPrime Рік тому +2

    Excellent analysis sir 🙏

  • @akash_thangavel3218
    @akash_thangavel3218 Рік тому +6

    I owe TATA Altroz xz petrol variant, My 1st service was on last week, personally I feel comfortable with the service and customer satisfaction. What I feel is still we can't blame the service because in feedback I have addressed the time management is not good in the service (TATA Motors Connection Aspiration) application, I got an immediate reply from the showroom for apologize the issue (Dindigul Kaveri Motors). They are doing good 40:00

  • @arulsakthivel6099
    @arulsakthivel6099 Рік тому

    This set up is OK, but the bar type tall chairs looks you're rushing to somewhere rather comfort and relax conversation. I agree with Mr. Danny on recent designs.I still like elite i20, Motor vikatan magazine always says i20 அழகன் on their reviews when youtube channels were not in popular. Safety wise TATA is best, as my personal experience Tata tiago save my ungle from major accident. The car got major damage but he completely all right inside the car.Thanks to Tata tank like built.

  • @sanjeevanselvaraj2003
    @sanjeevanselvaraj2003 11 місяців тому

    Anna .... Old table set up is always ultimate .... new one set aagala 💥❣️❤

  • @rajarams4823
    @rajarams4823 Рік тому

    Nice discussion..for me always suzuki...👍👍👍

  • @mks7224
    @mks7224 Рік тому +1

    This style is really great 😂 please keep it up

  • @chathapuramganesanvenkatsu3168
    @chathapuramganesanvenkatsu3168 11 місяців тому

    Good output.
    Nice report.
    Best wishes

  • @kevinmohan3391
    @kevinmohan3391 Рік тому +1

    Nice to see altogether 😊.

  • @BK1997ap
    @BK1997ap Рік тому

    S we hate crome but second top end le adhu oru periya feature mari crome door handles kuduthudranga many companies...adha oru optional ah companies mathuna nalla irukum

  • @NirmalrajR
    @NirmalrajR Рік тому +2

    Long lasting/ Classical design ku poravanga.. Budget/Common people eh kedayathu bro... !
    Only an enthusiast or luxury ppl look for long lasting classics.
    It's exactly like iphone vs android users.
    There is mass market for quirky design phones like oppo/vivo.. Because these are not performance high products to speak for itself..
    Only these quirky stuff separates them and keep people interested/excited !

  • @Dan11172
    @Dan11172 Рік тому

    This way of presentation is good bro .. continue like this

  • @RAMKUMARSHANMUGAM-df2nv
    @RAMKUMARSHANMUGAM-df2nv Рік тому +1

    Bro! Anyday car oda service reliability romba important athu vanthu maruti mathiri yaarum kooduka mudiyathu! Service center la daily 100 car ku mela vanthalum avanga atha super ah pannuranga enga periyappa tata altroz vachurukaru athula sensor la problemnala car start agala athuku avaru tata road side assistance ku call panna response eh romba neram ila! Aparama call attend panni 14 hrs mela aparama vanthu attend pannuranga service centre avaru veetula irunthu just 5 kms surrounding la iruku irunthalum avanga atha consider pannave ila! Ithu thaan matha car manufacturers kum maruti kum ulla vidyasam...
    Maruti Suzuki ah india epavum adichuka mudiyathu athuku innu evanum porakala porakavum mattanga

  • @KMK-rk9qw
    @KMK-rk9qw Рік тому +1

    My VOTE for New this type presentation. Because we can see all are three face reactions also
    😅

  • @subashbose3341
    @subashbose3341 Рік тому +1

    This setup looks fine ❤

  • @justinmjv1954
    @justinmjv1954 Рік тому

    New set up is fine. If you use seperate mike for each one we can hear all the members voice clearly. Most of our people will go after fuel economy only. It will take time to change. As usual Tata is going to suffer in the service sector. Overall podcast super ... One word used in correct time is "பம்முது" .

  • @geraldinechithrakalarex3173
    @geraldinechithrakalarex3173 Рік тому +1

    You can also recommend main city services availability
    Say for example Chennai moreover many service centre but remote city less

  • @prasanna625
    @prasanna625 Рік тому

    I Suggest to have a mini round table for such podcast discussions with this set up. It will be much more comfortable for discussions.

  • @pragadeeeswaranpragadeeswa2522

    Nice and cool topic enjoyed the points..

  • @shiyaamsm7755
    @shiyaamsm7755 8 місяців тому

    Very good video.. informative and speaking reality than only facts

  • @thestressless0307
    @thestressless0307 Рік тому +7

    HUYNDAI's current success is there products are developed from their effort from team's heart,mark my words hyundai N series will dominate m series and amg in next 20 years, happy to be a hyundai n and n line series fanboy from scratch.

  • @envisageds
    @envisageds Рік тому

    police station setup madhiri irukkuppa.. nalla irukku :)

  • @hrajkumar2980
    @hrajkumar2980 Рік тому +2

    Nice analysis. I suggest for voice clarity..all of you may have an individual mic🎙️

  • @praveenthramamurthy4598
    @praveenthramamurthy4598 Рік тому

    Maintaining a chrome body cladding is very tough, example in Alcazar chrome in grill is vey tough to maintain

  • @saffronpanda1735
    @saffronpanda1735 Рік тому +8

    I bought punch. I am happy with it. However i would have test driven exter as well if it got released before

  • @MugeshRaju
    @MugeshRaju Рік тому +1

    Square wheel cladding suits well for Jeep Compass. Car makers are trying to provide a SUV like appearance for smaller cars, but it's actually spoiling the cute looks of smaller cars. Even for Brezza it doesn't suit.

  • @prks1982
    @prks1982 11 місяців тому

    Great content, I was expecting this, kindly start the same with all the categories mid-size SUV creata category, for me this category will be equally good, all you need to see is who offer better price and service, safety over the category will be the same. driving dynamics will be only this which differentiates them, better to do a test drive on all the models before coming to a conclusion. I personally like punch. but I did not drive Exter or fronx, i can't comment on this, please do a test drive for your selection among these.

  • @Narray5
    @Narray5 Рік тому +1

    This setup is good, giving them space..

  • @afzhalahmed1210
    @afzhalahmed1210 Рік тому +1

    I like this setup. I own an Amaze.

  • @rajkumardoss
    @rajkumardoss 10 місяців тому

    Hi, very knowledgable informative review ,great help for a potential buyer to arrive at informed decision, would encourage the team to do it in English, will benefit many across the Country.

  • @joshuaschwarzenegger4914
    @joshuaschwarzenegger4914 Рік тому +1

    Good wishes! We used to have a 2013 santro xing, exter very much reminds us of that. High stance, tall boy design. I think it should have been the original successor to the old santro. I think santro xing owners would very much see the similarity! Have a nice day gentlemen

  • @ark7625
    @ark7625 Рік тому

    Nice discussion 👏

  • @ShasthriSubramaniam
    @ShasthriSubramaniam Рік тому +7

    If Suzuki provides Alpha+ Trim for FRONX 1.2litre then my choice would be FRONX. BTW setup is good #nermaiyanamotofam

    • @RajeshKumar-gy8wu
      @RajeshKumar-gy8wu 8 місяців тому

      It won't happen as it might affect Baleno and fronx turbo sales..

  • @dheenaprakasam1742
    @dheenaprakasam1742 11 місяців тому

    My vote is for this new setup!

  • @franklinthambijose.s2010
    @franklinthambijose.s2010 Рік тому +2

    well explained brothers........old setup is better than this......

  • @TheKing-yd2st
    @TheKing-yd2st Рік тому +1

    This setup is super 👌

  • @svrajasekarsv
    @svrajasekarsv Рік тому +2

    In this price range Nissan magnite and Renault Kiger are the better choice, instead going for a micro SUV.
    4 star GNCAP , better cabin space , Modern features like 360 camera , drive modes etc.

    • @NemysisPrime
      @NemysisPrime Рік тому +2

      Magnite /kiger are better only if you take the turbo 1l..NA engine is not worth

  • @parthasarathyknp8859
    @parthasarathyknp8859 Рік тому

    You must have a table… with miniature cars flower vases….this will give a professional look.

  • @haripranesh3308
    @haripranesh3308 Рік тому +3

    Agreed on the Brezza's thick wheel cladding. Personally I don't like it, since it dominates the metal body colour, also looks like too much plastic visible in light coloured options. Made the side look of Brezza quite unpleasant..

  • @shivagurumuthu598
    @shivagurumuthu598 Рік тому +1

    Set up okay 👍 it would be great if you could add a round table ❤

  • @davidwilson5589
    @davidwilson5589 Рік тому +4

    I am owned Brezza 2016 model running 2.6lakhs smoothly no issue and my friend bought Brezza petrol really felt about the mileage... really new gen cars missed engine like 1.3 diesel fiat engine

    • @gokulbala3096
      @gokulbala3096 Рік тому +1

      Yes we miss all great and efficient engines

    • @rrkatheer
      @rrkatheer 9 місяців тому

      It’s because of emission norms that Fiat engines couldn’t meet

  • @pradeepvijy
    @pradeepvijy Рік тому

    Similar setup with one table in centre lae vetcha nalla irukkum...