Most Value-for-money SUV Under Rs 7 Lakh | Kiger vs Punch vs Exter

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 11 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 116

  • @prateek1208
    @prateek1208 7 місяців тому +56

    Kiger is seriously underrated

    • @harisht2774
      @harisht2774 7 місяців тому +10

      And under powered.... Good product needs decent engine.

    • @prateek1208
      @prateek1208 7 місяців тому +2

      @@harisht2774 true

    • @ratnadeepsaha7675
      @ratnadeepsaha7675 7 місяців тому

      ​​@@harisht2774you can buy the turbo engine if you need power

    • @bokinlego
      @bokinlego 7 місяців тому +20

      ​@harisht2774 100% wrong! This is what happens when ppl compare cars by looking at stats on paper only. Been a Kiger owner since Nov, 23. On paper, Kiger NA MT has only 71 bhp and 96 hp compared to Sonet NA MT's 82 bhp and 115 hp. But in real life, Kiger is significantly more powerful. At sloped road, where my kiger climbs at 3rd gear with AC on, my friend's new Sonet have to shift down to 2nd gear even without AC off. Same driver. Same with acceleration.
      Don't get me wrong! I'm not defending Kiger or Renault like Tata Fanboys do with theirs but just correcting facts. So, is Kiger better than Sonet? Not really!
      Main reasons why Renault finds it hard to Kiger even 1k unit per month in India are:
      1. Pathetic Interior cabin quality. The plastics used and the finishing are way too poor. Grab any plastic parts with joints like door handle, front arm rest, infotainment cashing, door plastic panel etc and they'll squeak and make crackling sounds. My 3 year old nephew's toy car has better plastic quality and finish. Inside Kiger, you're never gonna feel upmarket or premium at all. This is actually, Renault india's strategy blunder. They're capable of providing decent interior quality as evident from their European cars but they've decided to underestimate Indian market so much that it has backfired in form of low sales. People nowadays are concerned about interior finish too. Even Punch, known for poor interior quality has better quality than Kiger! The result is that the body sound starts coming up very soon, literally within just a few couple of months from purchasing.
      2. Very high NVH and rough cluth and gear levers. First, the vibration is too high inside the cabin especially while at idle. Second, the the Noise level is too high especially while driving at highways. Third, gear level is as rough as that of trucks and tractors. Fourth, clutch is too heavy esp in traffic.
      3. No any facelift update by Renault even after 3 years. Same old cheap chinese generic tablet infotainment. No sunroof. Poor AC. Very poor headlights with no any option for upgrading etc.
      Of course, it has its pros too like the best looking in the segment, large boot space management, 205 ground clearance, good driving experience, decent features according to price etc. But the above mentioned 3 Cons significantly outweighs these Pros translating in very poor sales and low resale value.
      Verdict: Never buy any Renault car until they completely restart their approach wrt Indian market which seems impossible. Of course, there will be 100 reasons why one shouldn't buy Kiger but lack of power should definitely not be one of them. At 9-10 lakh, there's not really any good option. Current 3 year old punch with no any facelift is too outdated. As for Exter, if the idea is to buy a compact or micro SUV, stay 10 miles away from Exter - it's just a raised i10 hatchback. So, it's best to stretch the budget a little bit and go for Nexon, Xuv 3XO, Sonet or Venue.

    • @kartikaysingh5746
      @kartikaysingh5746 7 місяців тому

      Brother your comment is so apt

  • @jpyadav6099
    @jpyadav6099 7 місяців тому +16

    Kiger having Brilliant propositions n better value for money with awesome looks in comparison with others. Best to buy

  • @nareshnaik2449
    @nareshnaik2449 7 місяців тому +16

    I always prefer v3 cars for reference data about cars and perfect comprehensive data in variants explained videos, Thanks for your work,

  • @karanpatro
    @karanpatro 7 місяців тому +11

    I love kiger & magnite

  • @sravangandreti
    @sravangandreti 7 місяців тому +14

    Please make comparison of high end versions of kiger punch and exter as well

  • @saraswatrahul73
    @saraswatrahul73 25 днів тому +2

    Kiger is real tiger ❤

  • @kdsix9
    @kdsix9 7 місяців тому +12

    Please make video of best car in all segments under 10 lakh

  • @engagement1303
    @engagement1303 7 місяців тому +8

    Proud owner of Renault kiger🩵
    Kiger is really a tiger✨ no doubt the turbo engine of kiger perform more then sufficient power👍 have best in segment boot space even more then ecosports, nexon, breeza etc best in segment ground clearance 205 mm , have very decent cabin space even more then its competitors like nexon, venue, breeza, xuv300 etc & if i talk about the looks of kiger🫡 hats of to reno.... Its amazing & kiger provide maximum features like keyless entry, 8 inches touch screen, tyre pressure monitoring, cooled glove box, rear ac winds & rear hand rest which is countable in luxurious accessories 🫡 & if we talk about safety provide by reno which is also very impressive because kiger get 4⭐ rating in global ncap crash test ✨ so... We can say its a safe car also.... & Reno provide 4 airbags in kiger so... We can say kiger is really value for money & very decent product of Renault ✨ so... Everyone should go for this beast also.... In this segment this is the only compact suv which provide alot of things according to its price segment 🫡 definitely everyone should consider this beautiful beast✨

  • @aromals1
    @aromals1 7 місяців тому +3

    Go for EXTER -very smooth and refined engine. Also comes with paddle shifters.

  • @vaibhavwadhwa1777
    @vaibhavwadhwa1777 7 місяців тому +1

    Finally !! This is what a lot of viewers were waiting for. Great that you came up with this.

  • @RAJUSIRONLINECLASSES
    @RAJUSIRONLINECLASSES 4 місяці тому

    I have kiger RXL and I m really Happy to have it... Till today

  • @abhinavavatsyayana9
    @abhinavavatsyayana9 7 місяців тому +6

    I love kiger. ❤❤
    From Nepal

  • @MerajAnwer
    @MerajAnwer 7 місяців тому +1

    The fact that such valuable analysis is available free of charge is mind-blowing. Keep up the fantastic work V3Cars team, you're awesome!!

    • @V3cars-Official
      @V3cars-Official  7 місяців тому

      We're excited to hear that you're finding our content useful. Don't forget to subscribe to our UA-cam channel.

  • @manojpathak3121
    @manojpathak3121 7 місяців тому +2

    Why Magnite was not included!!

  • @nitsnik
    @nitsnik 7 місяців тому +4

    Thanks. That's a good video. But is Magnite a better one than Kiger at this price point?

    • @V3cars-Official
      @V3cars-Official  7 місяців тому

      We're excited to hear that you're finding our content useful. Don't forget to subscribe to our UA-cam channel.

    • @nitsnik
      @nitsnik 7 місяців тому

      @@V3cars-Official already 👍 done

  • @ashishchandel2282
    @ashishchandel2282 7 місяців тому +2

    Exter is best in overall terms features drivability milage and after sale service

  • @logan4441
    @logan4441 7 місяців тому +2

    You are best channel for car buyers

    • @V3cars-Official
      @V3cars-Official  7 місяців тому

      We're excited to hear that you're finding our content useful. Don't forget to subscribe to our UA-cam channel.

  • @manojvikram2651
    @manojvikram2651 6 місяців тому

    These kind of videos are always welcome 😁

  • @SHAHNAWAZKHAN-on2vu
    @SHAHNAWAZKHAN-on2vu 7 місяців тому +2

    Kiger actually sits in a segment one above... thus Even the top model RXZ is a VFM model in that segment considering the space looks & features

    • @engagement1303
      @engagement1303 7 місяців тому +1

      Exactly Proud owner of Renault kiger🩵
      Kiger is really a tiger✨ no doubt the turbo engine of kiger perform more then sufficient power👍 have best in segment boot space even more then ecosports, nexon, breeza etc best in segment ground clearance 205 mm , have very decent cabin space even more then its competitors like nexon, venue, breeza, xuv300 etc & if i talk about the looks of kiger🫡 hats of to reno.... Its amazing & kiger provide maximum features like keyless entry, 8 inches touch screen, tyre pressure monitoring, cooled glove box, rear ac winds & rear hand rest which is countable in luxurious accessories 🫡 & if we talk about safety provide by reno which is also very impressive because kiger get 4⭐ rating in global ncap crash test ✨ so... We can say its a safe car also.... & Reno provide 4 airbags in kiger so... We can say kiger is really value for money & very decent product of Renault ✨ so... Everyone should go for this beast also.... In this segment this is the only compact suv which provide alot of things according to its price segment 🫡 definitely everyone should consider this beautiful beast✨

  • @vachan7069
    @vachan7069 2 місяці тому

    Why is Magnite not in this comparision ??

  • @mohnishr481
    @mohnishr481 7 місяців тому +2

    Keep making more such videos

    • @V3cars-Official
      @V3cars-Official  7 місяців тому

      We're excited to hear that you're finding our content useful. Don't forget to subscribe to our UA-cam channel.

  • @08devD
    @08devD 7 місяців тому +1

    Why C3 not included?

  • @AkashY-s3b
    @AkashY-s3b 3 місяці тому

    Why is magnite not in the list plz make a new vedio with it

  • @walkeprashant16
    @walkeprashant16 7 місяців тому +1

    build quality???

  • @nshakeels
    @nshakeels 7 місяців тому +2

    X3o, Nexon, Sonet aur Brezza me sabse reliable and refined PETROL Engine kiska hai? And Brezza aur Astor sprint me 1.5 NA petrol engine me jyada reliable and performance wise kaun better hai... Pls reply

    • @mayur5021
      @mayur5021 7 місяців тому +1

      Brezza ka best h sonet of venue ka bhi accha h but small engine h dono ka same hi h i10 wala bakki dono mene chalayi nhi h

  • @TheSujanroy
    @TheSujanroy 7 місяців тому +1

    Lovely and rational comparison. I would still go for the Exter because 1) higher resale 2) best after sales experience 3) better retained quality and durability 4) 4 cylinder smoothness. Agreed that points 2 & 3 cannot be quantified but point 1 alone will be sufficient to bring the Hyundai to No. 1 position

    • @V3cars-Official
      @V3cars-Official  7 місяців тому

      We're excited to hear that you're finding our content useful. Don't forget to subscribe to our UA-cam channel.

  • @Pranjight-rc9jh
    @Pranjight-rc9jh 7 місяців тому +4

    Kiger ❤❤

  • @suhasfiragannavar2079
    @suhasfiragannavar2079 7 місяців тому +1

    Bhai koi bhi car mai engine uska jan ahai Aur driving experience ke hisab se exter is most refined engine with 6 airbag standard deliver more value with best quality and service network

  • @santoshkumar115
    @santoshkumar115 5 місяців тому

    Can you do same for automatic

  • @karanpatro
    @karanpatro 7 місяців тому

    My favourite & VFM: magnite then kiger

  • @karanpatro
    @karanpatro 7 місяців тому

    My favourite Channel & Video, please believe me I always compare (Magnite vs kiger vs exter vs punch).

    • @V3cars-Official
      @V3cars-Official  7 місяців тому

      We're excited to hear that you're finding our content useful. Don't forget to subscribe to our UA-cam channel.

  • @manikantapeta1314
    @manikantapeta1314 7 місяців тому +2

    People expect high engine power not considering their practical usage.

  • @Abhishek-lz4mj
    @Abhishek-lz4mj 7 місяців тому +1

    What about c3

  • @bankingyouths
    @bankingyouths 4 місяці тому

    So is it justified to compare a 1 litre engine car with 1.2 litre. My alto has 1 litre engine how can kiger deliver me better driving experience

  • @varunpandey2380
    @varunpandey2380 7 місяців тому

    One comparison bw Brezza, Nexon, 3X0

  • @syogn96
    @syogn96 7 місяців тому

    Sir MG ASTOR CVT 1.5L NA enginer efficiency ka bhi ek video kariye ga please

  • @rajeevpeter4406
    @rajeevpeter4406 Місяць тому

    I booked kiger limited edition already.

  • @SSSS111-l8w
    @SSSS111-l8w 7 місяців тому +1

    Sir, punch facelift kab aa rahi hai

  • @amol85zambare
    @amol85zambare 4 місяці тому

    Nice comparison

  • @AyushNiranjan
    @AyushNiranjan 7 місяців тому +2

    Best is the Magnite as it offers all of the benefits of Kiger while looking much premium.
    If you add 78k get xv variant and it is just amazing
    Fog lamp
    Diamond cut alloy
    Key less entry push start
    Touch infotainment with wireless Android auto car play
    Rear AC
    Arm rest
    Led headlamp
    And much more

  • @fr4den
    @fr4den 7 місяців тому +2

    kiger or magnite?

  • @shvmkumar1
    @shvmkumar1 7 місяців тому

    Please make similar comparisons video for B2 segment SUV as well

  • @kausikghosal6585
    @kausikghosal6585 2 місяці тому

    Excellent...

  • @nikchavan9845
    @nikchavan9845 7 місяців тому

    If kiger is a winner then magnite will surely beat all these cars. Even at 6.60L you will get magnite AMT version means feature plus conveinence. Magnite.. The most underrated car.

  • @makwana.gaurav
    @makwana.gaurav 7 місяців тому

    I really love the comparison videos made by you.
    However I would highly appreciate if the Safety Rating should also be considered before making the verdict.

    • @V3cars-Official
      @V3cars-Official  7 місяців тому

      We're excited to hear that you're finding our content useful. Don't forget to subscribe to our UA-cam channel.

  • @Vibe_Nomad
    @Vibe_Nomad 7 місяців тому

    What about Magnite ? The most Vfm vehicle in this range

    • @Pranjight-rc9jh
      @Pranjight-rc9jh 7 місяців тому

      Kiger magnite Same car bro

    • @Vibe_Nomad
      @Vibe_Nomad 7 місяців тому

      @@Pranjight-rc9jh not really, Magnite has a better Vfm
      proposition with better design.

    • @Pranjight-rc9jh
      @Pranjight-rc9jh 7 місяців тому

      @@Vibe_Nomad magnite outdated steering response worse or to much vibration,France design kiger best

  • @aadarsh_ks
    @aadarsh_ks 7 місяців тому

    We exceeded ARAI claimed mileage of Tata Punch.

  • @arcotarunkumar
    @arcotarunkumar 7 місяців тому

    Please compare with Magnite

  • @GauravGupta-tx7kc
    @GauravGupta-tx7kc 7 місяців тому

    Why did you forget to mention Nissan Magnite?
    It's really a good package in such price.

    • @venukrithish007
      @venukrithish007 7 місяців тому

      Almost same car. You can easily pick magnite as well

  • @harshvora9534
    @harshvora9534 7 місяців тому

    Kiger features wise is good. But the mileage they claim is half of what it's claiming.
    I own a kiger and the two down side is power of kiger and milege.

  • @pranay220
    @pranay220 7 місяців тому

    Nissan Magnite will be most value for money if you count the base amt Variant

  • @DrDre-sy2kv
    @DrDre-sy2kv 7 місяців тому

    Ya to 4 cylinder ya 3 cylinder 6 gear C3 turbo.

  • @techpulsar
    @techpulsar 5 місяців тому

    Kiger & magnet❤❤❤

  • @maxoutrinku
    @maxoutrinku 4 місяці тому

    Good 👍

  • @_RSA111
    @_RSA111 25 днів тому

    This is entirely wrong comparison and miscalculated. I own Renault and been driving since last 4 years. Cars looks are awesome though, but only looks will not give overall satisfaction.
    1.Maitainance cost is high.
    2. Technical expertise at Service center not so skilled, although they are polite.
    3. Parts are costly.
    4. Sluggish engine compared to 4 cylinder, clearly evident in bumper to bumper traffic.
    Not sure about Tata cars so will avoid talking about it.
    About Hyundai Exter, its engine is very much refined, for highway/city definitely worth it.

  • @creatal808
    @creatal808 7 місяців тому

    C3 should have been considered.

  • @Razique_Khan
    @Razique_Khan 7 місяців тому +1

    #Kiger should be available 1L turbo from base variant

  • @asingh6271
    @asingh6271 7 місяців тому

    Sir 3xo ka diesel varient ka comparison laao.. aapne sirf petrol ka laya hai

    • @V3cars-Official
      @V3cars-Official  6 місяців тому

      XUV3XO Diesel Variants Explained video will be out soon. In the meantime, you can read about it on our website - use the link below
      www.v3cars.com/variant-explained/mahindra-xuv3xo-diesel-variants-explained-which-one-to-buy

  • @santanukumar5220
    @santanukumar5220 3 місяці тому

    Kiger turbo rxt is the best at price around 7.5 lac

  • @ashishgaikwad7721
    @ashishgaikwad7721 3 місяці тому

    Tata Punch iCNG

  • @yoyodude-aoe2726
    @yoyodude-aoe2726 7 місяців тому

    Save some more and grt xuv3XO

  • @shashankdubey88788
    @shashankdubey88788 7 місяців тому

    But kiger 1 l engine hai..engine to dil hai car ka.. Or renult ki after sales service resale me dum nahi

  • @buddhipanwar
    @buddhipanwar 7 місяців тому

    Magnite XL

  • @maheshkamejaliya2263
    @maheshkamejaliya2263 7 місяців тому

    Osm video

  • @rafeekmorankala7028
    @rafeekmorankala7028 7 місяців тому

    Punch now 20 above mileage

  • @kshitijmaheshwary7668
    @kshitijmaheshwary7668 7 місяців тому

    Kiger has 1000cc engine....less power for an SUV...not worth it. Exter or punch much better choice

  • @Amit-0051
    @Amit-0051 7 місяців тому +1

    None all are due for face lifts

  • @kishorevispute3230
    @kishorevispute3230 4 місяці тому

    Kigar Nice car

  • @rohanagrawal5752
    @rohanagrawal5752 7 місяців тому

    Please stop calling these jacked up hatchbacks as SUVs.

  • @Amit_Kumar_Trivedi
    @Amit_Kumar_Trivedi 7 місяців тому

    Kiger ki magnite se itni badi to nahi lagti dekhne mein. Ye kaise hua bootspace mein?

  • @KNKUMARKUMAR-pu4ho
    @KNKUMARKUMAR-pu4ho 4 місяці тому

    I want loan 100%

  • @contender111111
    @contender111111 5 місяців тому

    Kiger rocks

  • @devrajsingh1123
    @devrajsingh1123 2 місяці тому

    Magnite

  • @krishnamohan6350
    @krishnamohan6350 7 місяців тому

    Exter

  • @tarunsingh6292
    @tarunsingh6292 7 місяців тому +3

    Better to go for Exter. 1.2 Ltr 4 cylinder engine and peace of mind with Hyundai. About Kiger that engine of 1 Ltr is useless and how much it can even last. Ac performance too not good in that. Below 1.2 Ltr engines not good for AC performance unless size of car is small. Ac might trip more on 3 cylinder engines

    • @dami1903
      @dami1903 7 місяців тому

      Aisa to kbhi ni hua 3 saal me

  • @rajoosolanky780
    @rajoosolanky780 7 місяців тому +1

    Bhaisaab amongst all the 3 Kiger is nothing but a sub 4mt premium Hatch with compact hatch Kwid's 3-Cylinder 1.0 Engine which offers high NVH levels than the other 2 in comparision. Its foolishness to compare Kiger with Punch & Exter.
    Kigers offers the smallest engine, hence they have to offer features to compensate against competition.
    Whereas Hyundai offer the best 4 Cylinder Refined engine, hence it will offer least maintenance. Hyundai also offers the best Quality After-Sales Services & Network.
    To be honest it seems you are baised or it's paid a paid promotion for Kiger.
    Your your calculation are also bent towards Pros against many Cons of Kiger.
    Forget about all your calculations the sales nos. Per Month sums up everything.
    Sales nos Per month are :
    Kiger less than 1000 Units
    Punch over 18,000 Units
    Exter over 8,000 Units.
    Inspite of Kiger offering the best feature list.
    Do you think Indians buyers are fools to not understand what they are investing in.
    Stop misleading people with your calculations.
    😛😜🤣😂

  • @karanpatro
    @karanpatro 7 місяців тому

    I hate Hyundai

  • @abinashbubu
    @abinashbubu 7 місяців тому

    The materials used in Reno Kiger is of sub standard quality , the look n feel also pretty bad, steering control very bad, suspension also third class, so don't buy Kiger only for its less value, buy exter or punch

  • @engagement1303
    @engagement1303 7 місяців тому

    Proud owner of Renault kiger🩵
    Kiger is really a tiger✨ no doubt the turbo engine of kiger perform more then sufficient power👍 have best in segment boot space even more then ecosports, nexon, breeza etc best in segment ground clearance 205 mm , have very decent cabin space even more then its competitors like nexon, venue, breeza, xuv300 etc & if i talk about the looks of kiger🫡 hats of to reno.... Its amazing & kiger provide maximum features like keyless entry, 8 inches touch screen, tyre pressure monitoring, cooled glove box, rear ac winds & rear hand rest which is countable in luxurious accessories 🫡 & if we talk about safety provide by reno which is also very impressive because kiger get 4⭐ rating in global ncap crash test ✨ so... We can say its a safe car also.... & Reno provide 4 airbags in kiger so... We can say kiger is really value for money & very decent product of Renault ✨ so... Everyone should go for this beast also.... In this segment this is the only compact suv which provide alot of things according to its price segment 🫡 definitely everyone should consider this beautiful beast✨