Girls Und Panzer's Perfect Use Of Stereotypes

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 1 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 216

  • @ferrariman195
    @ferrariman195 Рік тому +501

    As a brit I love how St gloriana is portrayed its never offensive and always makes me smile

    • @PotatoSolutions
      @PotatoSolutions Рік тому +57

      Having lived in the UK and traveled across the country for a little over a year I will say, Anchovy’s assessment of British food is an understatement. The UK has absolutely repulsive and disgusting food.

    • @thanhool
      @thanhool Рік тому +18

      As an american i love Saunders school.

    • @kiddingjust6946
      @kiddingjust6946 Рік тому +16

      @@PotatoSolutions everyone only talks about the bad stuff when we have some pretty good stuff, nobody eats the fish stuff here

    • @komisiantikorupsikoruptord6257
      @komisiantikorupsikoruptord6257 Рік тому

      ​@@kiddingjust6946 still bad food. But good teh

    • @stevetheduck1425
      @stevetheduck1425 Рік тому +8

      @@PotatoSolutions As a Brit, having lived here all my life, except for trips to Germany, the Netherlands, Japan and briefly France, I can say that Britons have their own ideas about food, but will accept anything the world has to offer.
      Within four miles of where I live, there are Chinese, Japanese, Thai, Italian, Polish, Ukrainian, Romanian, Turkish and Spanish restaurants. I don't live in London, either.
      A town I left some years back had twenty-one different denominations of church, temple, meeting house and so on on the same street, as well.
      I wonder if we're getting it right of course, but I think that answer is for others to judge.

  • @ODST_Parker
    @ODST_Parker 10 місяців тому +130

    There's a joke I love that goes something like, "Be the American that Japan thinks you are."
    Basically, when it comes to national stereotypes, instead of being mean-spirited about it like a lot of media, especially nowadays, Japan has often portrayed America as an exaggerated version of our own positive stereotypes. It makes fun, but in the best way.
    I'm proud to be represented by flag-waving, freedom-loving, burger-eating, gun-toting, over-the-top maniacs who will kick ass and shake hands afterwards, win or lose. It's nice to remember our best qualities through the eyes of others.

    • @KEBB-ho7fr
      @KEBB-ho7fr 7 місяців тому +5

      couldn't agree more

    • @TheDarkChrysalis
      @TheDarkChrysalis 3 дні тому

      Metal Wolf Chaos is the most american game ever and made in japan too

    • @redacted8983
      @redacted8983 2 дні тому

      the yanks aren't gonna beat the gun-toting allegations

  • @UrbanCohort
    @UrbanCohort Рік тому +176

    I like that even in the stereotypes there is variation. The loud and cheerful Saunders has the cool, collected sniper (gunner) character; the self-assured and endearingly overbearing Pravda has the motherly figure; even the unflappable and dignified Gloriana has an impetuous, rough-around-the-edges character. It's stereotypes played for good, healthy fun, but they aren't all cast from the same mold, and I appreciate that.

  • @inductivegrunt94
    @inductivegrunt94 Рік тому +261

    The stereotypes really help the show out so much. It really gives everyone unique characters and help them out in the long run. Kuromorimine is stoic and precise, Saunders is loud and over friendly, St Gloriana is calm and elegant, Pravda being overly Russian, Chihatan is brave and courageous, Anzio being a little incompetent, but very food focused and happy to share it, BC Freedom having their endless French Civil War, and so much more. It gives everyone unique character and helps make them stand out compared to everyone else, so that viewers don't get girls confused with one another. Even Ooarai does this with each team being from a different club, or friend group like rabbit and anglerfish teams, to help differentiate the teams from one another. The stereotypes really were fun and enjoyable to watch and see everyone interact together based on the cultures they were based on.
    And Keizuko, Mika's school, is based on Finland. But Mika and Jouko represent the stereotype the best as the Finnish stereotype is that they are very quiet individuals and don't interact much socially/casually. Again, showing how well Girls und Panzer plays off of the stereotypes in a positive way.
    Can't wait for this Saturday for the next Dream Tank Match livestream. And it will be the end of the story mode, leaving only Domination for all the schools, and the various challenge modes and other stuff you can do in it. See you then, Ascendant, and take care.

    • @randomstuff4997
      @randomstuff4997 Рік тому +2

      it was a really nice show, wish crunchyroll had it

    • @ferrariman195
      @ferrariman195 Рік тому +3

      ​@@randomstuff4997I wish Netflix would put the show back on

    • @podemosurss8316
      @podemosurss8316 Рік тому +25

      "Pravda being overly Russian"
      *Overly SOVIET Russian. And according to expanded material, it's because they're a lot into roleplay.
      Also, it's not that Anzio is incompetent, it's that they're there for the fun of the game.

    • @TakenWithout
      @TakenWithout Рік тому +2

      “Stoic and Precise” still can’t hit a moving target though! Guess even stereotypes lose to plot armour

  • @oxishimaruxo
    @oxishimaruxo Рік тому +178

    While I was visiting the Yokohama Gundam Factory, one of the workers there asked me if I was an American. I didn't speak any English to the guy and I'm Hispanic. Apparently me eating popcorn out of the Haro popcorn bucket gave it away. Wasn't aware that was a stereotype, and then I remembered the scene where Kay is watching the match while eating popcorn.

    • @mcfarofinha134
      @mcfarofinha134 Рік тому +22

      The main stereotype I've noticed while living here, and how I'm usually outed as american is the fact we basically are always eating something lol. Especially the fact that we often eat while walking, something the japanese are less inclined to do. The stereotypes they have of brazilians (my other nationality) are a lot less fun tho

    • @oxishimaruxo
      @oxishimaruxo Рік тому +10

      @@mcfarofinha134 there's also the friendly and outgoing stereotype, despite the large number of introverts in the States. Could also be that they just don't encounter American introverts

    • @convergeman7825
      @convergeman7825 Рік тому +8

      @@oxishimaruxo Maybe because introverts are generally less inclined to travel often and stay in other countries for long periods of time? I appreciate every introvert is different though so this may not be the case.

  • @serpentinious7745
    @serpentinious7745 Рік тому +38

    Sanders is enthusiastic, carefree, fields a lot of guns, are chatty, and have big hearts. As an American, I wholeheartedly approve.
    They're also taller than everyone else, which I find amusing.

  • @ar3klis
    @ar3klis Рік тому +114

    About the Finnish stereotype school, and cannot unsee it when you realize, is that they are themed after characters from Moomins.

    • @avroarchitect1793
      @avroarchitect1793 Рік тому +3

      What is Moomins?

    • @zapdent4742
      @zapdent4742 Рік тому +12

      @@avroarchitect1793 its a Finnish cartoon en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moomin_(1990_TV_series)

    • @vanukas8783
      @vanukas8783 Рік тому +5

      ​@@avroarchitect1793it's hard to explain, they're characters made by Tove Jansson. Google them to see what they look like

    • @Some_Guy6
      @Some_Guy6 Рік тому

      @@zapdent4742 They are white trolls.

    • @illliiiiillliii6265
      @illliiiiillliii6265 10 місяців тому +2

      Who are the characters supposed to be? the Kantele girl is obviously Snufkin but the other two I'm not sure. The blonde girl maybe moomin troll?

  • @Warrior-Of-Virtue
    @Warrior-Of-Virtue Рік тому +220

    If I had to nail Oarai down, I think they're supposed to represent a ragtag guerilla army. This fits with them almost always being outnumbered, the fact that their team uses a hodgepodge of tanks, and their unconventional tactics. Even their relationships with the other teams kind of fits that mold. Since guerillas are usually loyal to a cause or ideology rather than a specific country, their allegiances can be very fluid. It's far from unheard of for a guerilla army to find itself fighting shoulder to shoulder with someone they were fighting against just a few months earlier and vice versa.

    • @Revkor
      @Revkor Рік тому +21

      not to mention a few of their tanks were a quick fix or failed designes like the M3 or the Proche Tiger

    • @Menhtrol
      @Menhtrol Рік тому +8

      That actually makes a hell of a lot of sense. 😆😆

    • @pizzasharkguy3807
      @pizzasharkguy3807 11 місяців тому +2

      GOOD MORNIN' VIETNAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAM

    • @m4rionettealastor702
      @m4rionettealastor702 6 місяців тому +5

      Another thing to mention is that Oorai/Oarai have been shown to excel in urban environments, something that also fits a ragtag guerilla army, although if we're going by WWII, Oarai is most likely a Resistance group like the Polish Resistance.

  • @CaptainScorchMane
    @CaptainScorchMane Рік тому +45

    I think it's genuinely incredible that one show managed to have such a HUGE cast, and I don't dislike a single one of them, at all.

    • @thekrimsonchin6023
      @thekrimsonchin6023 11 місяців тому

      That's what I'm saying. They literally have a few industry giants in their cast. It's wild.

  • @yogsothoth915
    @yogsothoth915 Рік тому +114

    The Finnish are from being overly philosophical and, as I understand it, fighting Russia, then later in the war joining Germany and getting some tanks, then later in the war taking Germany's tanks and using them to fight Germany. They also took Russia's tanks. They took a lot of stuff.
    Also, a fun thing people miss that Miho's mom, with her demand to always advance and her poofy pants, is just as much Milf Hitler as Anchovy is pigtailed Mussolini

    • @Jawslehoff
      @Jawslehoff Рік тому +40

      "Milf Hitler" sounds so freaking cursed lmao

    • @yogsothoth915
      @yogsothoth915 Рік тому +7

      @Jaws it is, but I needed something that stuck as well as pigtailed Mussolini. Lol

    • @iaminsideyourwalls2021
      @iaminsideyourwalls2021 Рік тому +6

      @@yogsothoth915 I guess Katyusha is Stalin if he had a Napoleon complex

    • @yogsothoth915
      @yogsothoth915 Рік тому +2

      @@iaminsideyourwalls2021 "if" .?

    • @iaminsideyourwalls2021
      @iaminsideyourwalls2021 Рік тому +1

      @@yogsothoth915 You know how Napoleon is short at the time? And who else is short in GuP and is also anime little girl Stalin?

  • @Troubleshooter11
    @Troubleshooter11 Рік тому +26

    The stereotypes are brilliant, i love them.
    As a Dutchman, i wonder how the show would have portrayed us. I imagine the tank crews would constantly act "stoned", have absolutely no filter in their interaction with others and wear woodenshoes all the time, their tanks would be an odd collection of allied tanks with ambiphious modifications which prompts an obsession to turn EVERY battle into a naval battle, their aircraft carrier would have constant flooding issues which are kept in check by a battery of windmills and their characters would constantly be trying to trade random crap with the other schools.
    Actually, that would be effing hilarious.

    • @SyuaibZulkarnain
      @SyuaibZulkarnain 8 місяців тому +4

      Lmao that really sounds like an actual school in GuP universe

    • @MM22966
      @MM22966 7 місяців тому +1

      Well, what were the Dutch like around the 1940's?

    • @irvancrocs1753
      @irvancrocs1753 7 місяців тому

      I bet there is a huge windmill on their ship..

    • @Packless1
      @Packless1 3 місяці тому

      ...and pulling camping-trailers behind their tanks...! ;-)

  • @InquisitorThomas
    @InquisitorThomas Рік тому +106

    So Klara is a Russian girl who goes to Japanese School where they pretend to be Russian?

    • @ascendantfiction7220
      @ascendantfiction7220  Рік тому +31

      Yeah, pretty much. 😂

    • @ahnafusaid8028
      @ahnafusaid8028 6 місяців тому +4

      She served in the Russian Army iirc

    • @AlphaJnx
      @AlphaJnx 4 місяці тому

      ​@@ascendantfiction7220 Funny how She can't speak Russian

    • @ascendantfiction7220
      @ascendantfiction7220  4 місяці тому +7

      @@AlphaJnx Klara and her voice actress are both quite literally Russian, so I’m pretty sure they can lol. Katyusha on the other hand….

    • @AlphaJnx
      @AlphaJnx 4 місяці тому +2

      @@ascendantfiction7220 i meant Katyusha

  • @jiemileng7745
    @jiemileng7745 Рік тому +78

    Indeed, the world would be a better place if people understood that sometimes it's ok to make fun. Another great video.

    • @girlgarde
      @girlgarde Рік тому

      Well, the Japanese flat out reject WOKE culture which is good so they don't mind playfully making fun of others or being made fun provided it's done tastefully.

  • @TheKenji2221
    @TheKenji2221 10 місяців тому +9

    As a French, I really love BC Freedom school.
    Their stereotypes are on point yet pretty funny and serve the story well. While also giving memorable characters.

  • @trigger740
    @trigger740 Рік тому +12

    Australia has a Koala as their commander.

  • @GundAficionadOZero
    @GundAficionadOZero Рік тому +16

    Something I like about GUP is that despite being of different nationalities, they respect each other and get along well, thanks to that they can ally themselves when they need it, like in the movie where they all came together to help Oarai, it's a pity that doesn't happen in real life.

  • @lewycraft
    @lewycraft Рік тому +23

    Also i will add how well Polish stereotypes are presented in GuP Mangas. From Ribbon Warrior to Saga of Pravda, Bonple is presented as a proud school that can hardly come to any agreement, as always someone veto important decisions, like buying better tanks. They are also extremly skilled, mostly being outmatched due to much worse equipment and lack of funding. Perfect summary of Polish history is simple way.

  • @PaintyMainy
    @PaintyMainy Рік тому +12

    Continuation High School(Sometimes called Jatkosota High School) plays off from Finland during WW2 with Winter War and Continuation War themes. Especially as Finland was quite poor during those times, so they stole Russian equipment and Germany lent them equipment as well during the wars. That is most likely where the kleptomanic personality of the school comes from.
    Then fun character references etc.
    First of all, Mika, Aki, and Mikko are all Finnish male names. To my knowledge they aren't references to any bigger Finnish personalities though(Mika Häkkinen was quite legendary F1 racer but that's all that comes to mind right now). Also their designs reference Moomin characters: Mika is Snufkin, Aki is Moomintroll, and Mikko is Little My.
    Mika plays Kantele, a Finnish instrument. The song she plays often is "Säkkjärven Polkka" which is a polka played a lot during Continuation War to combat radio-controlled Soviet mines(It's a long story, just google it). Her birthday is November 30th which was the starting day of Winter War.
    Also Continuation High School's sniper Jouko(Finnish male name as well) with her nickname "White Witch" is a clear reference to Finnish Winter War soldier/sniper SImo Häyhä who was called "White Death". Also Continuation High School gunners being good *might* be reference to Simo Häyhä as well.
    There's probably much more stuff and some of the Trivia from Wiki might be stretching a bit. Still entertaining stuff and small references which makes a Finn like me happy.
    Finnish stereotypes are fun, only missing alcohol and PERKELE and it would be 10/10. Der Film scene is one of the funniest and most epic things I know and I always get giddy when rewatching it.
    Wait, you actually read the whole thing? Respect.

    • @madeinheaven-ti8jy
      @madeinheaven-ti8jy 8 місяців тому +1

      yep i read the whole thing. As a swede, because we border finland i know a lot about them and i loved how the were introduced for me i think that the one who created the anime/manga did a very good job in researching about all the cultuers and giving it to all the diffrent characters in the show.

    • @quyphuongtay
      @quyphuongtay День тому

      Just a random Vietnamese wanderer here, I actually read all of this, but can remember all, it's nice info for me, at least the show just like promote some specific culture for most people (like me) who don't know anything about Finnish or other country culture, even they're joke but it's good and healthy

  • @aperturemichelle
    @aperturemichelle 10 місяців тому +5

    its a good use of the ''Show don't tell'' phrase and im all for it as its definitively a thing.

  • @podemosurss8316
    @podemosurss8316 Рік тому +44

    5:08 That's not an insult, it's an objective description.

    • @the_tactician9858
      @the_tactician9858 Рік тому +10

      I will never not like English breakfast. I know it's fatty, greasy, comes out of tin cans and is an affront to the culinary world... but fuck me is it good to eat.

    • @stevetheduck1425
      @stevetheduck1425 Рік тому +5

      @@the_tactician9858 Not out of tins: eggs, sausages (if they were hot dogs, yes, from tins, but those are anathema to a fry-up), bacon rashers, mushrooms, tomatoes (usually fresh sliced large whole tomatoes, but peeled tomatoes can come in tins).
      From tins: the beans (pre-cooked and warmed up haricot beans in tomato sauce).
      Also, the only fat should be cut off the rashers of bacon and be the only thing left on the plate, and the 'grease' is vegetable cooking oil, like groundnut oil.
      This may be, in fact, why it's so good to eat. - and you're welcome to try the many, many local variations, including hash browns, 'bubble and squeak', black pudding, chips, mushy peas (can come from a tin), and other less famous stuff.

  • @firetruck1255
    @firetruck1255 Рік тому +36

    Americans being overly friendly is one that flies under the radar, but is really surprising. As a British Air Cadet (our equivalent to the Civil Air Patrol) i got to go to one of the biggest airshows in the country, RIAT, twice with them and being part of the crew running the event. Without a doubt, the American aircrews were always the friendliest. With most nations that attended theyd be happy to show us cadets around their aircraft, but we'd have to ask first. The American crews would practically race each other to the rope to ask us across. On the Saturday i believe it was of the 2017 show, i did a shift in the main tent where crews and buyers hospitality was, the purpose of RIAT is to sell planes after all. The F-22 display pilot walks down the hall, and completely unprovoked shakes my hand and gives me the the patch off his shoulder as a souvenir. Most other pilots would say hello at most, we were basically just there to keep the place clean.
    That same year my flight (4 people) got a full guided tour of one of the B-52s in show, again with the crew jumping at the opportunity to show us around. All the people we met there were brilliant, but just how much the Americans stood out will never leave me

  • @Tetrix0
    @Tetrix0 Рік тому +61

    The australian team was the funniest.

    • @rgd963
      @rgd963 11 місяців тому +8

      And busty!

    • @irvancrocs1753
      @irvancrocs1753 7 місяців тому +8

      @@rgd963 The busty team is spain..

    • @Ka0rus
      @Ka0rus 6 місяців тому +7

      Sorry, i dont understand your point
      Let me ask to a Koala
      Oh now i understand, thanks Koala-kun, he understand aussies
      Personally i laugh so much with the Koala reference xDDD

    • @ahnafusaid8028
      @ahnafusaid8028 6 місяців тому +1

      The commander says thus:

  • @Someguyhere111
    @Someguyhere111 Рік тому +12

    It's sad so many people brush off this show with a simple "High school girls in tanks? That's silly. This is cringe." So many fun characters and great comedy.

    • @fakecubed
      @fakecubed 11 місяців тому +6

      But it's surprisingly deep, subverts a lot of the dumb anime tropes and pokes fun at them (but still respects the audience that likes that stuff), and has a ton of very real history embedded into practically every scene.

    • @Zoloft77
      @Zoloft77 Місяць тому

      ​@fakecubed There's surprisingly better character development between some characters and teams than most of the tropes found in the school activities genre of anime. For me, I once called it, K-On with tanks.

  • @flyingfalcon8999
    @flyingfalcon8999 Рік тому +108

    Ok, I'll be the one to point it out. Jouko is basically a teenage female tankery Simo.

  • @thatoneyeeter
    @thatoneyeeter Рік тому +14

    if you insult everyone, then you insult noone

  • @nwalsh3
    @nwalsh3 Рік тому +45

    Continuation plays up the Finnish stereotype of being very calm, always, or often, sitting in the sauna, a word that is Finnish in origin). The hat that Mika wears is a hat that you would wear in a classic Finnish sauna, and also a Russian Banja. The instrument she plays is also of nordic origin and the song played in Der Film, Säkkijärven polkka, was used by the Finns to clear russian acoustic mines during the winter war. :)

    • @sergiomendoza251
      @sergiomendoza251 Рік тому +4

      And with unexpected strategies like the white witch (also the robbery).

  • @BulletBill64
    @BulletBill64 Рік тому +26

    While most of the schools are play acting, the American school actually has a lot of children from American troops stationed in Japan.

  • @hfar_in_the_sky
    @hfar_in_the_sky Рік тому +4

    It also helps I think that every school gets an awesome moment in the franchise at some point or another, which reinforces the fact it’s all in good fun

  • @Manuelslayor
    @Manuelslayor Рік тому +4

    The song played by the finish girls is säkkijärven polka or hoever you write that. It was playd in tanks as it could block the activation of radio controled mines. There was a specific mobile radio signaling tower which constantly signaleld the song from August 1941 to February 1942. During this time it was played about 15'000 times

  • @moffjendob6796
    @moffjendob6796 Рік тому +8

    Honestly, the distinctiveness of the characters is why I love GuP and really couldn't get into HaiFuri (besides obligatory Wilhelmina). Giant casts... but in one, you can keep track. In the other, you can break them up by... department?

  • @drewdederer8965
    @drewdederer8965 Рік тому +27

    There is also the fact that some of the schools "lead" teams are in some way a parody of another work. The Finns, for example, are supposed to represent the Moomins (who are a lot more well known IN Japan than the US) . BC Freedom of course has Marie, but the faction leaders are based on "Lady Oscar" and "Andre" from "Rose of Versailles" (thus all the shipping). Saunders is an unusual case. It's not 100% clear for the "Americans" but Kaworu Shintani (Area 88) did a series called "Desert Rose" about an all-female anti-terrorist team. One of the more popular secondary characters was Irene Saunders, a cute, oversexed, ex-Marine perpetually seen blowing blue bubblegum bubbles.

    • @dphalanx7465
      @dphalanx7465 Рік тому

      Holy crap! Somebody who knows Desert Rose! I loved that manga and collected it back when fan translations were just getting started.

    • @AndrewDederer
      @AndrewDederer Рік тому +1

      @@dphalanx7465 You should look up Kyoto Video. He did a review (mostly of the manga) that alerted me to it (I go WAY back with Area 88, and I own Both formats of Butobi CPU, but Cleopatra DC never did much for me. So I was shocked I'd never heard of "Rose" I was NOT surprised that there is an official Crossover with Gunsmith Cats. Desert Rose isn't THAT important in of itself, but it clearly influenced a lot of series that came later. A couple of panels from the late "Italian Arc" got "homaged" in a fairly early "Gunslinger Girl" story. And as I said above, seeing Irene, made the whole American team fall into place.

  • @Mattiniord
    @Mattiniord 11 місяців тому +4

    There are indeed many finnish stereotypes in Jatkosota. Being silent and almost shy is one that is... well, speaking from expirience, not such a stereotype. Finns generally do talk less, or should I say, make less small talk than most people. This also goes for North Sweden which has a strong finnish influence. Now, finns can talk and be very passionate about things that are interesting and relevant! Talking just for talkings sake is seen a bit like waisting energy. Finns are also seen as very calm and collected, but in the end very helpful when push comes to shove. A bad stereotype you thankfully do not see in Girls und panzer but that exists in Sweden, especially those with less finnish influence is that finns will pull a knife when angered. One important stereotype that is infact also hailed as a national trait among the finns is the concept of "Sisu". Sisu can be translated as determination but that does not really covers it. Sisu is the determination in face of adversity to never quit and never give in. But it is not just stubborness or getting rough. Sisu means to keep going when everything seem lost, but to also to keep your head cool and try to do the best out of every situation. It is really about never giving up the fight but to keep fighting as well as you can, in a way that gives you at least a chance of getting out on top. So Sisu is very much about mental resilience, much more than mere physical resilience.
    You can see it in Der Film. Jatkosota only comes with their BT-42, because they could not contact their schoolship. But they came anyway with what they had on and. They are not going to let Oarai fight alone. They are very soft spoken and do not say much, but what they say is meaningful. One thing that also is shown is the use of speaking in understatements, something common in Finland and North Sweden. When seeing the Karl and its escort they calmly realize they should help and declare their intention.
    The song played on the kantele is a finnish classic, Sääkijärven Polkka. This song has a special meaning to the finns due to a special episode during the Contiuation war. In 1941 the finns managed to recapture Viborg (Viipuri) from the Soviet union. But Soviet engineers had rigged several large bombs that were to be triggered remotely via radio. The finns got wind of this and the relevant frequencies. So they had to continously jam those frequencies as bomb squads searched for the bombs. As the story goes, the team in charge of the jamming got the idea to make a continious broadcast of music and the record they had at their disposal was "Sääkijärven Polkka". So they started blasting it over the frequences and I guess they either had two gramophones or had to be bloody quick in getting the record going again. But as the story goes, they ended up continually playing the song until att bombs were found and disarmed.
    How much of that is true and what has been embellished over the years I do not know. But the hectict nature of the song do give a feel for a desperate race against time. And the song remains a very important part of finnish culture and is today connected to the episode. And with their fighting spirit.

  • @stevetheduck1425
    @stevetheduck1425 Рік тому +5

    Part of the history of Japan's interactions with other countries is involved. Japan's modernisation in the 19th century involved Dutch medicine, French military science, then Prussian military science, then alliance with Germany.
    Their Navy was modelled upon the British Royal Navy and they bought examples of many British tanks in the 1920s and 1930s, so that their WWII tanks can be compared to improvements on the Vickers Light and Medium Tanks.
    Later post-WWII their interactions tended to open up further, with the US being the most close to them.
    I'm a bit surprised that there is no Dutch presence in GuP.

    • @matthiuskoenig3378
      @matthiuskoenig3378 4 місяці тому

      There is no Dutch presence because the Dutch didn't really have tanks in ww2. All the tanks they had were in the Dutch East indies. So a Dutch East indies school is much more likely.

  • @podemosurss8316
    @podemosurss8316 Рік тому +20

    If you liked that in GuP, I can only recommend you Hetalia. It's a show about countries being depicted as people, and half of the show is making fun of national stereotypes. It's extremely funny.
    The one thing that I dislike about GuP is that the Spanish-themed academy (Blue Division) isn't featured enough! Also, it being named after an INFANTRY division is a bit much. It should have been called "Brunete Academy".

    • @alicjacaban2226
      @alicjacaban2226 Рік тому +1

      Hope than We get more Nyo!talia and Poland.Po is called Phoenix but get 0 screentime.i cannot wait for Ribbon warrior getting animated.(2nd manga series of girls und panzer)Polish school is rocking there😎.check out near light teaser and Pv.Poland is called Kazimierz there .imagine winged hussars in anime wersion.(other nations are interesing too.see Il Siracusano animation and trailer, Lethania: embers or Shadow of Ursus )Yup Arknights is great.i cannot wait for 2nd season of anime

    • @mcfarofinha134
      @mcfarofinha134 Рік тому +3

      imo that one is less respectful of the countries it's stereotyping, to the point it's uncomfortably close to racism lol

    • @podemosurss8316
      @podemosurss8316 Рік тому +3

      @@mcfarofinha134 When every country is insulted, does it count as racism? I like how Spain is portrayed. He's funny.

  • @Sr._Rubio
    @Sr._Rubio 8 місяців тому +2

    I Would have loved to see an Spanish Themed school, being very friendly having a incredible humour and never literally NEVER taking anything seriously... And always eating TAPASSS

  • @alizvondhordez4314
    @alizvondhordez4314 Рік тому +3

    That finnish white death sniper fell great that das finale without Miho team

  • @rekire___
    @rekire___ 8 місяців тому +1

    The taste of their food and the face of their women made British man the best sailor in the world

  • @TheMrPeteChannel
    @TheMrPeteChannel Рік тому +4

    99% of the girls are "ethnic Japanese" despite having things like blonde hair & blue eyes. 1 girl is from Russia another 1 is half German & one is half Italian i think. Also Anchovy did say she was from the "land of fashion & good food" so she might of been born in Italy despite being ethnic Japanese.

  • @ezri1529
    @ezri1529 10 місяців тому +1

    So no one's gonna talk about the Australian tank crews with their commander being a literal koala?

  • @stevetheduck1425
    @stevetheduck1425 9 місяців тому +1

    Italy complaining about British 'cuisine'. It's not even an English word.
    British food, if it exists, tends to be roast meat, vegetables and too many carbs.
    To compensate, we have the entire world's fast foods in every town.
    This Brit has noticed, all joking aside, that British food tends to be 'boiled in a pot / cauldron' to make stored veg and meat 'go further' by making it a broth, soup or stew.
    Prepared food tends to be ways of preserving food for later: jams, preserves, puddings, sausages, baked pastry like the Cornish pasty, or deep-fried fish in batter ( tempura to the Japanese ).
    Cold winters and wet the rest of the year placed an emphasis on stored or preserved foods, not fresh items. This is why we love things like strawberries, damsons, fresh eggs, hundreds of kinds of cheese, biscuits scones and other baked goods, etc.

  • @neurofiedyamato8763
    @neurofiedyamato8763 Рік тому +4

    They also use these stereotypes as a source of character development where certain characters break out of the mold like Miho, Anzio and Chihatan going for a method distinct from their usual when there is pressure for them to improve

  • @Geshiko-GuP
    @Geshiko-GuP Рік тому +1

    I was always happy when St Gloriana just suddenly popped up, I knew they were about to give some calm and intellectual comment over a cup of tea while WW2 Tanks break the laws of physics in the field

  • @williamlarned883
    @williamlarned883 Рік тому +25

    I understand the stereotype that Kay represents. American girls being tall, with long blonde hair and large breasts. Also, Saunders girls are obsessed with fast food, and drinking soda

    • @fakecubed
      @fakecubed 11 місяців тому +4

      They're friendly, and they're rich, and they have cheerleaders at every conceivable type of sporting event including tankery.

  • @SwordlordRoy
    @SwordlordRoy Рік тому +2

    Huh, don't know why I'm surprised to find you have a UA-cam channel, but here I am stumbling upon it. I'm a backer of both waves of the Light unto Another World novel Kickstarters. ^_^;;
    Great video by the way!

    • @ascendantfiction7220
      @ascendantfiction7220  Рік тому

      Haha cool to see you here! I only started making serious UA-cam content back in November, so after the last Kickstarter. Hope you’ve been enjoying the series, and look out for the Kickstarter launch for my first manga!

  • @gurdimeikenskjaldi5060
    @gurdimeikenskjaldi5060 5 місяців тому

    I'm very glad to have found this video. It's not just good GuP content, but especially the whole stereotypes thing: matters like stereotypes, cultural appropriation etc have been so abused in these last years, and weaponized, that sometimes I feel I'm going insane. Talking about that matter you basically said exactly, 101% the same exact thing I feel about it (it's almost scary xD) but you spelled it in a better, better and better way I could ever come up with ^^

  • @xn6469
    @xn6469 Рік тому +17

    The stereotypes actually give every school a unique characteristic

    • @fakecubed
      @fakecubed 11 місяців тому +3

      And make for great historical reference fodder.

  • @terrorcop101
    @terrorcop101 Рік тому +3

    Preach it, brother!
    Edit: By the way, just started book 3 of Light Unto the World and am very much enjoying it, apart from a couple details that I can work with.

  • @Duraltia
    @Duraltia Рік тому +2

    Should have a look at the Anime _Upotte!!_ which kinda runs a similar theme with Weapons from different Nations and Generations acting like Girls.
    Doesn't quite reach the quality of GuP but it's still a fun watch ( and if I recall correctly a bit Ecchi 🤔 )

  • @nerissacrawford8017
    @nerissacrawford8017 Рік тому +5

    I am a Brit and for me personally the bit with the tea is true.

  • @RDPONY
    @RDPONY 6 місяців тому

    Im polish and I love how in Bonple High School girls have names after popular food from our country xD Jajka, Uszka and Pierogi. Or mention of hussaria and story about vicrory against second team of pravda despite their huge number advantage. And cant mantion bear Wojtek in school Emblem.

  • @mutthaam2396
    @mutthaam2396 9 місяців тому +1

    Outstanding!

  • @DouglasMeloche
    @DouglasMeloche 6 місяців тому

    love self aware humor that unapologetically makes fun of everyone

  • @takenname8053
    @takenname8053 Рік тому +2

    SUPER NICE, they really made the stereotypes fun!

  • @Slav729
    @Slav729 Рік тому

    When first see Saunders Kay ordered this "RUSH THE ENEMY I DONT CARE IF YOU GET KNOCKED OUT BUT RUSH"

  • @crazeguy26
    @crazeguy26 Рік тому +1

    the Miho school has no real cultural is show as the tanks are mismatch of tanks from every class and country. M3 Lee, Hetzer, Panzer4?, Stug, Tiger (P), Char B1 Bis, Type 89B, Type 3 Chi-Nu, Mark 4.

  • @solarflare623
    @solarflare623 Рік тому +1

    Honestly as an American I’m perfectly fine with American stereotypes.

  • @Niitroxyde
    @Niitroxyde 6 місяців тому

    I'm always hard pressed to find a person represented by a stereotype in these sort of shows (and in general) being offended, curiously enough. As a French, BC Freedom might be my favorite school in this serie, and it's purely because of the stereotypes, it was just way too funny.

  • @lukas54cz71
    @lukas54cz71 Рік тому

    Finns had that sniper in white coat hidden in the mountains.

  • @MartinKelly-bx6ft
    @MartinKelly-bx6ft 9 місяців тому +1

    I'm not going to lie I kind of wish that anzio girls constantly move their hands around while they were talking also kind of bummed out that St gloriana's never had at least one or two members of their team that were either Scottish Welsh or Irish stereotypes seriously after all during the second world war at least if I remember it correctly the British ruled over the Scottish and the Welsh and they only have a little bit of the Irish Island left granted it's Northern Ireland which ironically is less north than normal Ireland also kind of disappointed that they didn't make the Australian team at least make one reference to stealing something

  • @tankenjoyer9175
    @tankenjoyer9175 7 місяців тому

    thats a real factor for enjoying this anime, it has Culture into it, even its a pretty straightfoward stereotype they are used in the right way its just perfect for whoever appreciate World war 2 history and the culture of it

  • @Comedy_Gold
    @Comedy_Gold 9 місяців тому

    Fun fact: This video appears in the Expermintal AI results when you google "Girls Und Panzer"

  • @kolpere1625
    @kolpere1625 4 місяці тому

    Best country stereotypes: Spain´s School. What a laugh i had meeting the franco´s spanish foreigner using the "Legión" uniforms. Completely an improvement from the original.

  • @chrisschultz8598
    @chrisschultz8598 Рік тому +9

    I dunno man All Japanese? I don't know of many blonde-haired, blue-eyed Japanese out there. I see this as international schools collected together to give the girls a broader education and, of course, tank battles. But otherwise, I agree with you. GuP has a very gentle way with international stereotyped humor, further softened because, hey, they're just waifus who wanna have fun.

    • @Kiwi-Araga
      @Kiwi-Araga Рік тому +3

      A few are foreign students or their ethnicity relates to their school. For example, Klara is Russian and Nonna is fluent in Russian so they have dialogues in Russian (I'm assuming that Nonna wants to improve her Russian so she's enjoying talking with a native). You can find others in the manga.

    • @chrisschultz8598
      @chrisschultz8598 Рік тому

      @@Kiwi-Araga JUST as I suspected. It changes nothing. I still enjoy the GuP.

    • @lick816
      @lick816 Рік тому +4

      What I heard was that all the schools are actually Japanese, but Saunders also has kids of Americans stationed in Okinawa, hence the blond hair blue eyes.

    • @lordjazoijua94
      @lordjazoijua94 Рік тому +2

      Dyed hair and contact lenses.

    • @chrisschultz8598
      @chrisschultz8598 Рік тому

      @@lordjazoijua94 Aha! The secret comes out!

  • @samoldfield5220
    @samoldfield5220 Рік тому

    Kay from saunders is an American exchange student. Also the Saunders stereotypes are "rich" "hypercompetitive" and "lots of food".

    • @fakecubed
      @fakecubed 11 місяців тому +1

      But also very friendly.

  • @Hound851
    @Hound851 5 місяців тому

    I cant remember her name, but the girl with long hair is breaking the fourth wall. 3:28 Just a small thing I noticed.

  • @stevetheduck1425
    @stevetheduck1425 9 місяців тому

    Finn stereotype: a calm, non-foolish intensity, coupled with a strong inward-looking self-reliance and wide skill base.
    As a Brit, I feel these guys get it right. ;-)

  • @Ki42shiN001
    @Ki42shiN001 Рік тому

    I'm a type of man that I cant have more than 3 things memorized in my head.
    And It's a life-span miracle that I could successfully remember all these many characters names in one Anime.

    • @stevetheduck1425
      @stevetheduck1425 9 місяців тому +1

      A memory trick that I find works: associate a name ( or anything, really ) with a place you know, and set these places as a 'journey' in your head: this street, this turning, that tree, that cinema, etc. Then, remembering the first one triggers all the others.
      Another: imagine all the characters as faces on posters / billboards along the route.
      Another: link them by imaging each doing something to the the next: a looks at b, b slaps c, c prods d, etc.
      By engaging visual memory and place memory, your memory is multiplied.

    • @Ki42shiN001
      @Ki42shiN001 8 місяців тому

      @@stevetheduck1425
      Intriguing. Linking things along to the on-coming places of my familiar route is a completely new idea for me.
      I've already invented myself an idea of linking numbers to the famous sports players jersey number.
      But your idea could also solve the difficulty of memorizing order of the events.
      Yeah, I need to hang posters onto the corners of my imaginary journey. Maybe... my daily work procedure can be helpful for another reason or I can select more scenic journey course as a basic platform.
      Thank you. 😊

  • @madeinheaven-ti8jy
    @madeinheaven-ti8jy 8 місяців тому

    i wish they had a swedish themed school. As a swede i feel like we don't get so much attention like the others

  • @matthiuskoenig3378
    @matthiuskoenig3378 4 місяці тому

    You forget the 'americans are cheaters' stereotype that the anime also plays into

  • @LocalDiscordCatgirl
    @LocalDiscordCatgirl Рік тому +1

    No comments about the Australian team? Wow.

  • @kingwolf9447
    @kingwolf9447 Рік тому +1

    How many years old is Girls und Panzer and we still have people talking a bit about it?

    • @polishcameron
      @polishcameron 5 місяців тому

      As off 2024 it is 12 years old

  • @AkiZukiLenn
    @AkiZukiLenn Рік тому

    I love how oorai literally have rommel.

  • @sergiomendoza251
    @sergiomendoza251 Рік тому

    Mika and her team are the Finland people.

  • @ComradeDylan-801st
    @ComradeDylan-801st 4 місяці тому

    Or just look at the tanks they use

  • @idontknoq4813
    @idontknoq4813 8 місяців тому

    How the fuck does the mic quality fluctuate throughout the video?

  • @endlesspath250
    @endlesspath250 8 місяців тому

    Wait. This is all LARPing? So, it's kinda like The Venture Bros. in that regard?

  • @redacted8983
    @redacted8983 2 дні тому

    The only student who isn't Japanese is Klara

  • @jesssss7154
    @jesssss7154 Рік тому +1

    So where does this idea that they're all actually Japanese girls cosplaying the nationalities their school represents? I don't remember reading that in the mangas.

  • @TheGodlikeDragon
    @TheGodlikeDragon Рік тому

    Wonder how Sweden would be portrayed in Girls Und Panzer? Sweden had tanks, but never participated during WW2, only prepared defense if they even got attacked

  • @teaeff8898
    @teaeff8898 Рік тому

    My Smart Dolls love LARPing to GundP. 😁

  • @monkegud6829
    @monkegud6829 9 місяців тому +1

    it's racism, acceptable racism

  • @thevictoryoverhimself7298
    @thevictoryoverhimself7298 Рік тому +8

    If you’re looking for another “cute girls do war things” anime, check out “Lycoris Recoil” from summer 2022. It was an absolute banger of an anime basically John wick with cute girls.

    • @ascendantfiction7220
      @ascendantfiction7220  Рік тому +1

      I've seen it! Missed it when it first came out, but binged it all a couple months later. I really enjoyed it. I'll probably do at least a couple videos on it at some point.

    • @thevictoryoverhimself7298
      @thevictoryoverhimself7298 Рік тому +2

      @@ascendantfiction7220 do them sooner rather than later and I’ll subscribe right away :)

  • @rebelbatdave5993
    @rebelbatdave5993 Рік тому

    LOVE ANZIO ,K! and THE TANKETTS!

  • @alejandroid5575
    @alejandroid5575 Рік тому

    Thanks!!

  • @kingghidorah102
    @kingghidorah102 Рік тому

    Somehow they made me fall in love with the american one, maybe bcz she had a gyaru vibe to her

  • @vankristlabs
    @vankristlabs 6 місяців тому

    Yeah idk about all that.

  • @thegamingcobra1059
    @thegamingcobra1059 11 місяців тому +1

    Bro why's it sound like you have your nose plugged

    • @stevetheduck1425
      @stevetheduck1425 9 місяців тому

      Nasal problems are to be expected if you live in a a city or have not experienced summer in the country.

  • @PfalzD3
    @PfalzD3 10 місяців тому +1

    Anchovy's right. Britain has the worst cuisine.

    • @stevetheduck1425
      @stevetheduck1425 9 місяців тому

      Cooking, it's cooking.
      'Cuisine' is French for 'kitchen style', broadly speaking.
      We're not above swiping vocabulary that we like, such as 'depeche mode' and 'kiosk'. - and much more: lying on a divan on the verandah wearing pyjamas, eating chutney, looking at the jungle, listening to a pundit on the radio... it goes on and on. We're fun, folks.

  • @Surplus-guy
    @Surplus-guy Рік тому

    It's funny how all the "finnish" persons names are mens names

  • @Ka0rus
    @Ka0rus 6 місяців тому

    2 days ago i was watching Das Finale (Continuation vs Oarai)
    Like GUP fan, it's common for me se lot of stereotypes (common, Japan it's racist as fuck but something this exaggerated racism it's funny because sometimes it's 50% fake/50% true and the "true aspect" make fun)
    Example, Ponchomon from Digimon (the most mexican stereotype EVER)
    And literally i fall from my chair when Katyusha say "Hey, that KV-1 was our KV-1 before?, THEY STOLE OUR TANKS" (in referencia to how Finland was smart and stole lot of equipment from soviets)
    And in the middle of the battle, KV-1 lose his side armor at turret and expose his Pravda logo
    NO WAY, THEY REALLY STOLE A TANK (like Finland with a lot of KV-1s and T-34s)
    And Clara explained that was more like a "compensation" (in reference to suomi-russian war compensation)
    I laugh so much with the references

  • @Bob-qk2zg
    @Bob-qk2zg Рік тому +1

    I couldn't get past the munitions. Even if the shells had no explosives, the impacts would probably injure the girls inside. You can't flip a tank and nobody gets hurt.

  • @johndurham2459
    @johndurham2459 8 місяців тому

    This show is the reason I would be bored with real woman.

  • @weehornman2000
    @weehornman2000 Рік тому +2

    Meanwhile the GuP fanbase...

  • @kingwolf9447
    @kingwolf9447 Рік тому +2

    I find it weird how many of the tanks are able to use their Machineguns, implying there has likely been a girl in the past hit by a bullet...

    • @dphalanx7465
      @dphalanx7465 Рік тому +6

      Low pressure, rubber bullets, LOL.

    • @rhysofsneezingdragon1758
      @rhysofsneezingdragon1758 Рік тому

      Didn't Pravda fire on yukari and Erwin with the main gun once?

    • @kingwolf9447
      @kingwolf9447 Рік тому +1

      @@rhysofsneezingdragon1758 Alisa I think she is fired the 50 Cal Mg off the Sherman back at them

  • @awaisabdulrehman
    @awaisabdulrehman Рік тому +5

    The only bad thing about the Senshado Sakusen is the time the girls became idols just to pander to otakus, even though that was not needed since the entire franchise is so good. A mobile game like Blue Archive is supposed to be doing ideas like that.

  • @riccardomoroni3359
    @riccardomoroni3359 Рік тому +1

    Yandere?