I'm guessing the writers, for $h!ts and giggles, decided to play upon the fact that Ferdinand Porsche designed it, and decided to give it characteristics more befitting a 911...
I may be late to reply since I seen this video a few months ago and watching it back because the edit is funny. Reason is that the tanks have internal carbon armour. They said earlier they had that armour inside the tanks to protect the crew. Basically if the shells hit that armour it actives that their disabled (white flag pop up)most likely.
beyond the whole "reinforced for safety" thing The mkiv would need a completely new engine design, the mkiv engine was not only terrible, it was right in the middle of the crew compartment so it would just spit toxic fumes everywhere. So everyone needed masks to make sure they didnt get deathly ill from it (they still would)
Im surprised the Hetzer wasn't mentioned. The amount of tomfoolery it got up to against kuromorimine in the main series was crazy, and you have to acknowledge the fact that the pres. team is a fucking black horse, like they have single handedly clutched up in some the most critical moments of the series
Well, it was interesting to watch, even all of us know that in GuP, all of the tanks are unrealistic. Imo, the Hetzer has to be mentioned, cuz it manages to hold a freacking Maus and knock out the Karl-Gerat while jumping.
Actually, the Ha-Go featured there has a Type 1 47mm AT gun, which some Ha-Gos were retrofitted with, that has an armor penetration rating of 3 inches at 250m. In WWII, BT-7 and Crusader tanks actually achieved the airtime depicted. The former even achieved a distance of 42 meters on one leap and the latter 15.
Please provide evidence that its the 47mm AT gun. As much as I want to believe and im fine if it did. My source is Girls und Panzer Fandom and War Thunder. Hence 37mm gun. Note. The only known Type 1 47mm was fitted to the Chi Ha Kai aka the ones that took out the 2 matildas at the start of the match. gup.fandom.com/wiki/Type_97_Chi-Ha
@@TheRoarinSpitty I got my tanks mixed up. It was only the Chi-ha that received that particular upgrade (although there were plans to create a tank destroyer variant of the Ha-go using the 47mm).
Funnily enough the BT-42 is actually the slowest of all the BT tanks. Due to how the BT-42 is in the show, I could imagine the BT-2 being so retardedly fast that even in the show people would be questioning its speed.
While it wasn't listed. The Hetzer that the Student Council has. That tank was such a damn troll it was able to Lift the Maus to allow the type 89 to get ontop of it once it got baited to shoot and the panzer 4 shot it in the back it was launched by the cv33 to take out the Karl. Oh and it also caused mass confusion among Kuromorimine's tank line by just driving inbetween two tanks and causing panic while also repeatably tracking some of their tanks until Maho noticed it and was like "Tank at 4 oclock"
The entirety of Girls und Panzer just doesn't make any sense. But it's just that awesome. It breaks every rule of tanks it possibly could, and then some. But that's okay, se love the anime inspite of the nonsense, because of the nonsense, or both. So it's really not a problem for those that don't mind the sheer quantity of broken logic the anime has. And for the Panzer IV, it's the tank of the protagonist so the sheer amount of hilarious nonsense and leaps of logic it can perform is par for the course. Nothing wrong with that in an anime about cute girls driving early 20th century tanks in a sports competition.
I know that girls un panzer is unrealistic but why did they gave heavy and medium tank massive speed boost and making the other tanks able to drift for god sake they are tank not sports cars... But at least the tanks are visually good and accurate to the real life counterparts I have to give it to them damn even the inside of the tanks are accurate
I completely agree with you on the Panzer IV H. Because of them surviving so many shells that has been thrown at them like biggest plot armor. Which I think it would make more sense if they were in a Panther 8,8cm instead since some tanks are technically within the Shenzado's rules.
It's also a World of Warships thing, some Light Cruisers have just as much armor as 16mm! They do take massive damage from HE Shells, but when they get the jumpscare on Battleships that didn't had the time to switch shells, and fire at them massive AP Shells, those just go in, go out on the other side, end in the water dealing no damage, while the Battleship gets busted by Torpedoes fired at Point Blanc range 😂
I agree with the Type 95 Ha-Go being broken, but the Type 97 Chi-Ha can also count because of one particular tank that got about three seconds of screen-time in Das Finale Part 2. The tank in question is Koala Forest's AC-1 (Australian Cruiser Mk1) "Sentinel", which both of Chi-Ha's tanks need to get at stupid range, basically point blank, to even kill an AC1, which could kill them before they even come into range with their 40mm QF 2-pounder gun (this is based on the historical usage of Australian forces with the QF 2-pounder against Japanese tanks in the Pacific. There's even a photo of a Ha-Go destroyed by that gun).
2:29 I think at such a close range, the Ha-Go's gun could probably penetrate the turret ring of a Matilda. There is a confirmed, historical case of an M8 Greyhound knocking out a Tiger with its 37mm cannon. This was a shot into the rear of the Tiger from a distance of about a dozen yards (10~ meters)
I was waited for IS-2 Pravda. Which is has good armour and nice gun and can stop Pershing's turret turning also enough for protect the Churchill and Some Pravda tanks as sheild
As a tank enjoyer.... What the fuck did I see? I mean I knew that this anime is far from real but now I have no words. The drift was the most realistic scene in Girls und Panzer, though over-made, is possible with a tank, the suspension and the tracks wouldn't like it though.
It's not an Hotel, it's a store run by an old man, and it's not the first time it happends, he and his friend who owns the shop nearby, are always at Tank matches hoping that their store gets destroyed, so that the city will rebuild it for free, that way they can have it customized following the latest trends. It's a pretty absurd thing but the two friends have pretty hilarious reactions when one or both stores gets destroyed 😂😂😂
Amaretto and Pepperoni easily are some of the most skilled crew members in the entire show. Pepperoni pulling off the skipping and rollercoaster in Der Film, and Amaretto pulling off the Crusader dunk in Das Finale, that's top tier shit.
I give a little leeway with the Tiger, because it's said in series that the auto club crew has modded it out the wazoo. But yeah, no matter how you slice it, no way it can do vtol. Maybe they salvaged the control panel from an aircraft with vtol?
Actually, I believe all engines have been heavily modified... I'm not sure if the source says it, but it's my headcannon that each tank in Sensha-do gets an engine that on flat, smooth terrain gives all tanks equal speed. Now, on rough terrain the lighter tanks still will excel, but when in the city you will see the ridiculous stunts with speed we know and... love? tolerate? (also maybe there are some classification on different speed classes based on weight... that is, if we classify the Churchill as the same weight class as the Mathilda's and Panzer IV's)
The BT-42 is based on the BT-7. the longest jump of the tank was 42 meters long and it was made by bt-7. so it was theoretically possible for him to jump. бт-42 создан на основе бт-7. самый длинный прыжок танка был длинной 42 метра и его совершил бт-7. так что это в теории его прыжок был возможен.
While I agree that the tanks defying top speed is a problem, it's a constant problem done with all the tanks. Also in Der Film a member of Leopon team says something that implies that modifications to the tanks are allowed within certain guidelines.
For your number 10 picks, it could be that the engine for both tanks were either given a upgrade completely remodeled or just replaced with a better one. Just saying, but you are right that the original models showed not be going that fast.
I think we have learned, don't question the automotive club. They can do a lot with a mechanical failure, even repairing it on the move once and never have to repair it again in any subsequent battles. I also had read somewhere that its plausible that the WWII tanks they use could have been upgraded with modern engines and transmissions to improve mechanical reliability. Of which I doubt, but there's a lot of strange occurrences that happened that would make modern upgrades the more realistic than whatever else happens in the show.
THIS VIDEO INSPIRED ME TO MAKE A TANK GAME WHERE YOU CAN DO CRAZY BULLCRAP WITH TANKS And let's hope I stick to it and actually do something cool in my life for once.
Kinda agree with duck team, because in spin-off manga Girls und Panzer: Ribbon Warrior, Miho Nishizumi declared that the Duck Team is Ooarai's highest-skilled team due to landing the most hits during the 63rd Sensha-dõ Tournament. XD about Ha-go maybe tho they use 37 mm Gun Type 98 with "GOLD Ammo" in WOT they have pen 60mm dont know tho ~ about its realistic or not XD but they once collab with WOT so yeah its just IMO
Dude, the tiger P and when Hanna shot the two tanks 1. The Germans thought they needed more horsepower so it was heavy but can overheat quick 2. The bullet penetrated the tank leaving half left bouncing off into another that’s why
The speed buffs are due to engine tuning. It's even explicitly spelled out in one episode of the original series, and further explained in the manga versions. The Armor is massively structurally reinforced to ensure the shells don't penetrate to make Senshado safe, as explained in the mangas. But this structural strengthening also allows for some more Hijinx like transporting another tank on their back (you thought the Italian tankette having a crusader on it's back is bad? How about the Hetzer lifting up the fricking Maus?) or near-misses that would incapacitate a real tank to continue unimpeded. The jumps, drifting and water skipping however are not explained. The increased engine power output certainly allows for a bit more air time than the original tanks did, but that's about it. Edit: The Type 95 Ha-Go penetrating the Matilda's turret is explained by it's main gun at that point, which is clearly the 47mm AT gun, as the original 37mm gun looks very different and this one has the very distinctive gun mantle of the 47mm gun. This is probably due to a conversion to the Type 4 Ke-Nu, which is a Ha-Go with Chi-Ha turret. The conversion of that tank happened off-screen, and instead of thr Chi-Ha's 57mm short-barreled gun they installed the Shinhoto Chi-Ha's long-barreled 47mm gun, which I'm actually not sure actually existed IRL.
The Automotive Club doesn't get enough credit for how much they can get fixed and upgraded with what only 4 or 5 girls. Doubly so when Miho keeps doing aggressive stunts like that to her Panzer IV.
Did you know the Higo has a doorbell because one of the rivets will be disguised as a doorbell so a Japanese soldier could deliver food to the tank members
The neat part is the animators r probably addicted to anime girls,explaining alot of stuff why the girls r not getting either bruises,broken bones, concussion, or worse than that..death, out of all of that drift,tank flipping and jumping
You know, by this point it should be obvious those are lightweight modern material replicas with stupidly overpowered modern engines and basically indestructible hulls made for the sport and not actual historical tanks, they just don't behave like historical tanks at all
Don't you underestimate the Automative Club. They do all the work before and after the match and practice. I wouldn't be surprised they tampered a lot of parts and scrapes all the scraps metal of destroyed and unusable tanks. Just look at the Anglerfish tank, it's all done by the Automotive Club. It's basically 2 tanks in one body.
I might not be as harsh on these things because I got into tanks as a result of Girls und Panzer and not the other way around, but am I the only one who just kind of... doesn't really see this as a problem? Sure, I do occasionally find some of the sillier occurrences unnecessary myself, but I just think realism is not what I want from this anime, I wouldn't want battles played purely on technological superiority and even if tactics were somehow to close the gap, realistic armored warfare tactics would often fall under the purview of boring but practical. Way I see it, every tank in GuP represents not the tank that was actually built and produced, but rather what they were supposed to be in their designers' mind, trascending the limits of what could be feasibly manufactured. The CV33 is fast and nimble because that's what it was intended to be, same for the Crusader, the WWI tanks get to be the heavy powerhouses or small, mayhem-wreaking gremlins they were thought to be at the time, and so on. In this way, every tank gets to shine in their own right and you're not punished for appreciating a subpar design (as often happens in tank related talk... people seem to hate it when you enjoy tanks that weren't the best on the battlefield)
We should also consider the fact that the movie adopted a chaos theory approach... (Which means anything goes cause it's an anime with slightly broken physics)
The FT-17? Absolutely possible. When Guderian slammed thru the Ardennes and headed straight towards Paris with the entire Motorinfantrie in tow, he managed to secure tons upon tons of FT-17 that had been upgraded during the Interwar years with better engines. Some of them were even used as training tanks or straight up pushed for front-line service before more Panzer III and IV could be sent to the front. Realistically speaking, the FT-17 with the engine upgrade was said to have been able to do 15kmh which itself wasn't horrible within Interwar years and the same doctrine as the British was using but when it came to the Germans, it was painfully slow. Regardless, it was still pretty much correct that it would match certain early WWII tanks. However, the same could be said for the Mk IV which should be the only one in the tenth spot. That BT-42 jumping that far was due to the actual record the Russians did with their BT-5 during their demonstration run and the GuP animators and writers were paying homage to that. So what they did was take a BT-5, removed everything unnecessary and lighten it, jump it from a ramp and landed it quite far, somehow landing it a world record for the longest distance jumped in a tank which hasn't been broken yet. Better still, when everyone was doubting the Christie suspension, that god damn bugger was still drivable after that massive jump which made the Russians believe in it more and built even more tanks with that suspension layout.
There was moment where a jagdpanzer drove under the maus. Its 26 tonnes would've been squashed by the maus's 100+ tonnes. yet it drove away with slight denting and no damage to its barrel
10/9/8/7/5.4: Tanks in GuP don't care about speed, this is seen with pretty much every single vehicle in it. 7: The Pz III can (according to WT (Which isn't that realistic but the easiest simulator to use)) pen the front plate of a T-34-85 firing from 10* above it, which it almost certainly acheived. 6: Fair point, but they didn't shoot the turret ring, they shot the engine. The type 89 vs ha-go scene was kinda silly. 5: 5.1: 57 ton tank going kinda fast is probably not good for the old stone brick bridge 5.2: Guess so, but the plot decides when a tank dies. 5.3: Nyoom. 5.4/.5: Line 1. 5.6: Yours doesn't? 4: The CV33s are super light, and there's a scene where one that got flipped over is manually pushed back by the crew. 3: The fuel tanks are external, and it is a tank. This should be self explanatory as to why it didnt die 2: 2.1: "Medium" as classified by the IJA, but only 11t. The crusader by comparison weighs 20t. 2.2: That shot almost certainly looked like just HE (didn't even hit the vehicle) which even by the KV-2, could not "pen" it from there (Again, WT, grain of salt.) 1: Main character
The l3 under the weight of a crusader tank, and under any circumstances in this anime would be crushed to death due to it, being a part of the size of a bench
Don't go with warthunder penetration stats at all. They don't line up with actual testing data. We can argue about different testing criteria all day but the margin of error with different testing standards and armor quality is still smaller than the deviation WT penetration statistics are from real life data. WT is most egregious with smaller low velocity guns like the Ha-go and I-go tanks. They are way off and can't penetrate even tissue paper. I'll just put it out there at point blank range, a armor piercing 50cal BMG round is provably capable of matching Warthunder's Ha-go stated penetration. That's enough said on that. The Panzer IV Ausf D is insanely overpowered. It's paper thin rear plate stopped a Stug III's shot at like 50m(at best?) flat on? The STuG III can penetrate that level of armor at any practical combat range. This was like episode 3 I think? Been awhile.
I've said it before and I'll say it again for the class. There is nothing in the rules of Sensha-do that is against the modification and replacement of the engines as long as the technology used was available in and before 1945. The FT-17 and Mk IV can go as fast as they damn want. Same with the Pershing, BT-42, Crusader, I-Go, etc. Anything on this list that is a feat of speed, you're allowed to modify your innards.
They gave the Tiger P to the automobile club girls because of the unreliable engine and they said that rules only restricted engine modifications and didn't say anything about the motor so I expect them to have replaced the motor with a hyperwarp or something.
The Ani is very fun to watch though, nice video by the way I just can't stop laughing when I realize how broken their tanks are, just started playing war thunder and I just can't imagine those tanks drifting and flying.😅😅😅😅
i agree with the ww1 tanks like how are they gonna go that fast like 55 to 60 mph (normal ww2 tank speed) and how does it go that fast. I don't understand why this anime series broke the speed physics. And first off, tanks don't drift irl i haven't seen a tank go i need to get some tofu, ok i have officially lost my braincells watching these. Nascar style? really nascar fans are really impresed that a tank from ww2 can do wall ride and holy its now a plane?
I love how you mentioned the "Porsche Tiger escaped the ARL-44s NASCAR style." As a fan of this motorsport, I am delighted.
I'm guessing the writers, for $h!ts and giggles, decided to play upon the fact that Ferdinand Porsche designed it, and decided to give it characteristics more befitting a 911...
the fact the FT and MKIV can take a hit and not be killed by any of these tanks is the biggest BS
fr, not to mention the fact it doesnt even have 30mm armor anywhere yet is able to tank hits from Chi-ha Kai's
Also some tanks can keep up with each other when one of them are slower
I may be late to reply since I seen this video a few months ago and watching it back because the edit is funny.
Reason is that the tanks have internal carbon armour. They said earlier they had that armour inside the tanks to protect the crew. Basically if the shells hit that armour it actives that their disabled (white flag pop up)most likely.
Who is gonna tell them the tanks are reinforced with carbon
beyond the whole "reinforced for safety" thing
The mkiv would need a completely new engine design, the mkiv engine was not only terrible, it was right in the middle of the crew compartment so it would just spit toxic fumes everywhere. So everyone needed masks to make sure they didnt get deathly ill from it (they still would)
Im surprised the Hetzer wasn't mentioned. The amount of tomfoolery it got up to against kuromorimine in the main series was crazy, and you have to acknowledge the fact that the pres. team is a fucking black horse, like they have single handedly clutched up in some the most critical moments of the series
Taking on the entire Pravda team in their breakout, as well as holding up a friggin MAUS...
The fact that they didn't get crushed by the 180 ton maus was already impressive
It lifting the maus was obserd
plus it withstood having an entire maus propped up on its upper plate
8mm of armour across the entire rear 😅
Dude we understand Girls Und Panzer says, "Physics? ... Hold my Sake!"
I love that they went full mad Max on the Panzer action
Well, it was interesting to watch, even all of us know that in GuP, all of the tanks are unrealistic.
Imo, the Hetzer has to be mentioned, cuz it manages to hold a freacking Maus and knock out the Karl-Gerat while jumping.
Technically, the Karl takeout would be possible, if the shell was loaded in the arty's gun and you scored a lucky enough shot right in the main gun.
Actually, the Ha-Go featured there has a Type 1 47mm AT gun, which some Ha-Gos were retrofitted with, that has an armor penetration rating of 3 inches at 250m.
In WWII, BT-7 and Crusader tanks actually achieved the airtime depicted. The former even achieved a distance of 42 meters on one leap and the latter 15.
Please provide evidence that its the 47mm AT gun.
As much as I want to believe and im fine if it did.
My source is Girls und Panzer Fandom and War Thunder. Hence 37mm gun.
Note.
The only known Type 1 47mm was fitted to the Chi Ha Kai aka the ones that took out the 2 matildas at the start of the match.
gup.fandom.com/wiki/Type_97_Chi-Ha
@@TheRoarinSpitty I got my tanks mixed up. It was only the Chi-ha that received that particular upgrade (although there were plans to create a tank destroyer variant of the Ha-go using the 47mm).
its all good. just making sure Xd
@@Myomer104 The case of the BT-42 let's see that the turret and gun will add more weight than the BT-7 so it will lose air time.
Funnily enough the BT-42 is actually the slowest of all the BT tanks.
Due to how the BT-42 is in the show, I could imagine the BT-2 being so retardedly fast that even in the show people would be questioning its speed.
The V-TOL on the Porsche Tiger is for when the server ping and packet loss are too high.
POV: gaijins local server hamster dies
The vtol on porche tiger is a lagswitch😂😂
Maus is the most broken when it comes to speed and turning
Excuse me what?! Speed and turning everyone knows the maus is flipping slow as heck
@@isee9574I believe they were being sarcastic
@@isee9574 r/wooooooosh
While it wasn't listed. The Hetzer that the Student Council has.
That tank was such a damn troll it was able to Lift the Maus to allow the type 89 to get ontop of it once it got baited to shoot and the panzer 4 shot it in the back
it was launched by the cv33 to take out the Karl.
Oh and it also caused mass confusion among Kuromorimine's tank line by just driving inbetween two tanks and causing panic while also repeatably tracking some of their tanks until Maho noticed it and was like "Tank at 4 oclock"
Total troll ex machina lol
If you shoot on M4 Sherman in the side armour, with basically anything, even if it’s only a 40 mm cannon, you will be able to in penetrate it
The entirety of Girls und Panzer just doesn't make any sense. But it's just that awesome. It breaks every rule of tanks it possibly could, and then some. But that's okay, se love the anime inspite of the nonsense, because of the nonsense, or both. So it's really not a problem for those that don't mind the sheer quantity of broken logic the anime has.
And for the Panzer IV, it's the tank of the protagonist so the sheer amount of hilarious nonsense and leaps of logic it can perform is par for the course. Nothing wrong with that in an anime about cute girls driving early 20th century tanks in a sports competition.
I know that girls un panzer is unrealistic but why did they gave heavy and medium tank massive speed boost and making the other tanks able to drift for god sake they are tank not sports cars...
But at least the tanks are visually good and accurate to the real life counterparts I have to give it to them damn even the inside of the tanks are accurate
Why did I make my comment so long
Tank are sports cars, look at Tank biathlons 😂
Imagine the maus can keep up with the hetzer just to get the revenge in the TV series in the later episode of the finale lol
Because speed makes the battle's more interesting for mainstream viewers
I completely agree with you on the Panzer IV H. Because of them surviving so many shells that has been thrown at them like biggest plot armor. Which I think it would make more sense if they were in a Panther 8,8cm instead since some tanks are technically within the Shenzado's rules.
I for one am a fan of the absurd physics of the tanks, watching them drift, jump and roll over as if they were tiny toys handled by kids.
The BT-42 Just proves that "no armor best armor" term by War thunder.
It's also a World of Warships thing, some Light Cruisers have just as much armor as 16mm! They do take massive damage from HE Shells, but when they get the jumpscare on Battleships that didn't had the time to switch shells, and fire at them massive AP Shells, those just go in, go out on the other side, end in the water dealing no damage, while the Battleship gets busted by Torpedoes fired at Point Blanc range 😂
I agree with the Type 95 Ha-Go being broken, but the Type 97 Chi-Ha can also count because of one particular tank that got about three seconds of screen-time in Das Finale Part 2. The tank in question is Koala Forest's AC-1 (Australian Cruiser Mk1) "Sentinel", which both of Chi-Ha's tanks need to get at stupid range, basically point blank, to even kill an AC1, which could kill them before they even come into range with their 40mm QF 2-pounder gun (this is based on the historical usage of Australian forces with the QF 2-pounder against Japanese tanks in the Pacific. There's even a photo of a Ha-Go destroyed by that gun).
1 word. TOTSUGEKI
3:20 BAHAHAHA! Ohhh fuck, I needed that! Thanks for the laugh, I'm still grinning like an idiot from seeing that "Back to the Future 2" tank!
2:29 I think at such a close range, the Ha-Go's gun could probably penetrate the turret ring of a Matilda.
There is a confirmed, historical case of an M8 Greyhound knocking out a Tiger with its 37mm cannon. This was a shot into the rear of the Tiger from a distance of about a dozen yards (10~ meters)
I was waited for IS-2 Pravda. Which is has good armour and nice gun and can stop Pershing's turret turning also enough for protect the Churchill and Some Pravda tanks as sheild
As a tank enjoyer.... What the fuck did I see? I mean I knew that this anime is far from real but now I have no words. The drift was the most realistic scene in Girls und Panzer, though over-made, is possible with a tank, the suspension and the tracks wouldn't like it though.
5:06 that's actually a hotel that collapsed
It's not an Hotel, it's a store run by an old man, and it's not the first time it happends, he and his friend who owns the shop nearby, are always at Tank matches hoping that their store gets destroyed, so that the city will rebuild it for free, that way they can have it customized following the latest trends. It's a pretty absurd thing but the two friends have pretty hilarious reactions when one or both stores gets destroyed 😂😂😂
I'm just happy they included the Polish 7TP in the show it's always been my favorite tank of World War II. Just wish they'd of built more or them.
Amaretto and Pepperoni easily are some of the most skilled crew members in the entire show. Pepperoni pulling off the skipping and rollercoaster in Der Film, and Amaretto pulling off the Crusader dunk in Das Finale, that's top tier shit.
Can we take a moment to appreciate the driver and gunner of the centurion
the driver was Takumi from the beginning and the shooter was Jom Wick
Girls Und Panzer Churchill: "I am speed."
That pz-4 plot armor is so thick Maus can only cry tears of envy while sitting in a dark corner lol.
I give a little leeway with the Tiger, because it's said in series that the auto club crew has modded it out the wazoo. But yeah, no matter how you slice it, no way it can do vtol.
Maybe they salvaged the control panel from an aircraft with vtol?
Actually, I believe all engines have been heavily modified... I'm not sure if the source says it, but it's my headcannon that each tank in Sensha-do gets an engine that on flat, smooth terrain gives all tanks equal speed. Now, on rough terrain the lighter tanks still will excel, but when in the city you will see the ridiculous stunts with speed we know and... love? tolerate? (also maybe there are some classification on different speed classes based on weight... that is, if we classify the Churchill as the same weight class as the Mathilda's and Panzer IV's)
I think its just a joke switch. Alot of car guys do that
@@the_tactician9858 the rules only said not to modify the engine so the automotive club modded the motor iirc, and probably some other stuff
You had me dead on the ground with the tiger V-Tol XD
I love the small italian tankettes they are just one big meme
The BT-42 is based on the BT-7. the longest jump of the tank was 42 meters long and it was made by bt-7. so it was theoretically possible for him to jump.
бт-42 создан на основе бт-7. самый длинный прыжок танка был длинной 42 метра и его совершил бт-7. так что это в теории его прыжок был возможен.
While I agree that the tanks defying top speed is a problem, it's a constant problem done with all the tanks. Also in Der Film a member of Leopon team says something that implies that modifications to the tanks are allowed within certain guidelines.
yep no engine but motor/ trans yes, and the tigerp has a eletric motor driving it
This made me laugh so hard! I wish there was more!
Good video mate, TRUELY enjoyed it 😂😂 omg I can’t stop laughing
hehe well theres gonna be another deep dive GuP video coming soon.
@@TheRoarinSpitty Hell yea! can't wait mate!
Well, one that I think is broken to a fair bit is the Ferd... THE THING CLIMBED A HILL WITHOUT ENGINE ISSUES...
I just always chalked it up to them upgrading the life out of those tanks off-screen so their faster and can drift
3:44 german engineering at its finest
The bt-42 was pretty realistic aside from the airtime
1:50 oh that is just a normal day in warthunder
fun fact: you actually can drift a tank, the metal based tracks one that is
For the record, the longest ever jump in a tank was preformed by a BT-7 at an outstandingly mindbreaking 42 meters.
The way they STARTED drifting was amazing
For your number 10 picks, it could be that the engine for both tanks were either given a upgrade completely remodeled or just replaced with a better one. Just saying, but you are right that the original models showed not be going that fast.
I think we have learned, don't question the automotive club. They can do a lot with a mechanical failure, even repairing it on the move once and never have to repair it again in any subsequent battles. I also had read somewhere that its plausible that the WWII tanks they use could have been upgraded with modern engines and transmissions to improve mechanical reliability. Of which I doubt, but there's a lot of strange occurrences that happened that would make modern upgrades the more realistic than whatever else happens in the show.
THIS VIDEO INSPIRED ME TO MAKE A TANK GAME WHERE YOU CAN DO CRAZY BULLCRAP WITH TANKS
And let's hope I stick to it and actually do something cool in my life for once.
Never thought I’d see this video
5:53
if that was the Kv-2 then this was one of the smallest explosions he can made
Kinda agree with duck team, because in spin-off manga Girls und Panzer: Ribbon Warrior, Miho Nishizumi declared that the Duck Team is Ooarai's highest-skilled team due to landing the most hits during the 63rd Sensha-dõ Tournament. XD about Ha-go maybe tho they use 37 mm Gun Type 98 with "GOLD Ammo" in WOT they have pen 60mm dont know tho ~ about its realistic or not XD but they once collab with WOT so yeah its just IMO
Dude, the tiger P and when Hanna shot the two tanks 1. The Germans thought they needed more horsepower so it was heavy but can overheat quick 2. The bullet penetrated the tank leaving half left bouncing off into another that’s why
I really love this anime series. Rewatch multiple times never got bored. But my favorite is the movie it's just so perfect
The speed buffs are due to engine tuning. It's even explicitly spelled out in one episode of the original series, and further explained in the manga versions.
The Armor is massively structurally reinforced to ensure the shells don't penetrate to make Senshado safe, as explained in the mangas. But this structural strengthening also allows for some more Hijinx like transporting another tank on their back (you thought the Italian tankette having a crusader on it's back is bad? How about the Hetzer lifting up the fricking Maus?) or near-misses that would incapacitate a real tank to continue unimpeded.
The jumps, drifting and water skipping however are not explained. The increased engine power output certainly allows for a bit more air time than the original tanks did, but that's about it.
Edit: The Type 95 Ha-Go penetrating the Matilda's turret is explained by it's main gun at that point, which is clearly the 47mm AT gun, as the original 37mm gun looks very different and this one has the very distinctive gun mantle of the 47mm gun. This is probably due to a conversion to the Type 4 Ke-Nu, which is a Ha-Go with Chi-Ha turret. The conversion of that tank happened off-screen, and instead of thr Chi-Ha's 57mm short-barreled gun they installed the Shinhoto Chi-Ha's long-barreled 47mm gun, which I'm actually not sure actually existed IRL.
Plot twist:they put scaled down modern day tank engines in their tanks to make them go that fast
The Automotive Club doesn't get enough credit for how much they can get fixed and upgraded with what only 4 or 5 girls. Doubly so when Miho keeps doing aggressive stunts like that to her Panzer IV.
The really took " german science is the world finest" to another level
Did you know the Higo has a doorbell because one of the rivets will be disguised as a doorbell so a Japanese soldier could deliver food to the tank members
Alice is probably the best girl lol and Erika commanding the Pz 3.L killing the Pravda flag tank is the reason why it can kill it
The neat part is the animators r probably addicted to anime girls,explaining alot of stuff why the girls r not getting either bruises,broken bones, concussion, or worse than that..death, out of all of that drift,tank flipping and jumping
Mark V irl: Bro wait a minute, iam trying to move
the gup Tank is inspired by the gameplay of world of tanks but i still love it
You know, by this point it should be obvious those are lightweight modern material replicas with stupidly overpowered modern engines and basically indestructible hulls made for the sport and not actual historical tanks, they just don't behave like historical tanks at all
this is what makes GUP special guys ;)
The Hetzer didn't even get an honorable mention for jacking up a Maus? That's serious wedge power.
Don't you underestimate the Automative Club. They do all the work before and after the match and practice. I wouldn't be surprised they tampered a lot of parts and scrapes all the scraps metal of destroyed and unusable tanks. Just look at the Anglerfish tank, it's all done by the Automotive Club. It's basically 2 tanks in one body.
I might not be as harsh on these things because I got into tanks as a result of Girls und Panzer and not the other way around, but am I the only one who just kind of... doesn't really see this as a problem? Sure, I do occasionally find some of the sillier occurrences unnecessary myself, but I just think realism is not what I want from this anime, I wouldn't want battles played purely on technological superiority and even if tactics were somehow to close the gap, realistic armored warfare tactics would often fall under the purview of boring but practical.
Way I see it, every tank in GuP represents not the tank that was actually built and produced, but rather what they were supposed to be in their designers' mind, trascending the limits of what could be feasibly manufactured. The CV33 is fast and nimble because that's what it was intended to be, same for the Crusader, the WWI tanks get to be the heavy powerhouses or small, mayhem-wreaking gremlins they were thought to be at the time, and so on. In this way, every tank gets to shine in their own right and you're not punished for appreciating a subpar design (as often happens in tank related talk... people seem to hate it when you enjoy tanks that weren't the best on the battlefield)
The porche tiger having a STEALTH mode killed me
I feel like the BT 42 can be called the most broken now after Das Finale part 4 where it LITERALLY WENT DOWN A MOUNTAIN ON SKIS.
We should also consider the fact that the movie adopted a chaos theory approach... (Which means anything goes cause it's an anime with slightly broken physics)
I actually know something for the mark 1 and ft17 speed I think they upgraded the engines
Shooting while driving makes the gun extremely inaccurate. Also Why does every tank go like 200kmh in every occasion?
"IT HAS V-TOL!?" got me rolling
2:18 A~~ctually, Ha-go didn't hit the matilda's turret ring , but its engine hood from above , but still... odd
The FT-17? Absolutely possible.
When Guderian slammed thru the Ardennes and headed straight towards Paris with the entire Motorinfantrie in tow, he managed to secure tons upon tons of FT-17 that had been upgraded during the Interwar years with better engines. Some of them were even used as training tanks or straight up pushed for front-line service before more Panzer III and IV could be sent to the front. Realistically speaking, the FT-17 with the engine upgrade was said to have been able to do 15kmh which itself wasn't horrible within Interwar years and the same doctrine as the British was using but when it came to the Germans, it was painfully slow.
Regardless, it was still pretty much correct that it would match certain early WWII tanks. However, the same could be said for the Mk IV which should be the only one in the tenth spot.
That BT-42 jumping that far was due to the actual record the Russians did with their BT-5 during their demonstration run and the GuP animators and writers were paying homage to that.
So what they did was take a BT-5, removed everything unnecessary and lighten it, jump it from a ramp and landed it quite far, somehow landing it a world record for the longest distance jumped in a tank which hasn't been broken yet. Better still, when everyone was doubting the Christie suspension, that god damn bugger was still drivable after that massive jump which made the Russians believe in it more and built even more tanks with that suspension layout.
Watching this made me wanna watch this anime again.
3:34 "you have been disconnected from the server"
If they added the maus It would be the only tank I would actually be able to legitimately go underwater, and come out alive
There was moment where a jagdpanzer drove under the maus. Its 26 tonnes would've been squashed by the maus's 100+ tonnes. yet it drove away with slight denting and no damage to its barrel
The kv-2 is the most broken tank in the entire series because IT can nuke a building with one shell and some gun powder
The Cent MK1 is what happens if you say it is a mk1 but under the hood you find a chally 2 and spiked tea
10/9/8/7/5.4: Tanks in GuP don't care about speed, this is seen with pretty much every single vehicle in it.
7: The Pz III can (according to WT (Which isn't that realistic but the easiest simulator to use)) pen the front plate of a T-34-85 firing from 10* above it, which it almost certainly acheived.
6: Fair point, but they didn't shoot the turret ring, they shot the engine. The type 89 vs ha-go scene was kinda silly.
5: 5.1: 57 ton tank going kinda fast is probably not good for the old stone brick bridge
5.2: Guess so, but the plot decides when a tank dies.
5.3: Nyoom.
5.4/.5: Line 1.
5.6: Yours doesn't?
4: The CV33s are super light, and there's a scene where one that got flipped over is manually pushed back by the crew.
3: The fuel tanks are external, and it is a tank. This should be self explanatory as to why it didnt die
2: 2.1: "Medium" as classified by the IJA, but only 11t. The crusader by comparison weighs 20t.
2.2: That shot almost certainly looked like just HE (didn't even hit the vehicle) which even by the KV-2, could not "pen" it from there (Again, WT, grain of salt.)
1: Main character
the KV-2 casually being a submarine
The l3 under the weight of a crusader tank, and under any circumstances in this anime would be crushed to death due to it, being a part of the size of a bench
Glory on you dude...i'm cracked up here...gonna wacth it again.
the tank that shot the Matilda tank is Type 89b I-Go Ko with 57 mm Type 90 cannon
Tiger P: Wunderwaffe! (Wonder weapon)
You forgot to mention the sideskirts of Anglerfish act like ERA and voiding an uncanny number of shots
Don't go with warthunder penetration stats at all. They don't line up with actual testing data. We can argue about different testing criteria all day but the margin of error with different testing standards and armor quality is still smaller than the deviation WT penetration statistics are from real life data. WT is most egregious with smaller low velocity guns like the Ha-go and I-go tanks. They are way off and can't penetrate even tissue paper. I'll just put it out there at point blank range, a armor piercing 50cal BMG round is provably capable of matching Warthunder's Ha-go stated penetration. That's enough said on that.
The Panzer IV Ausf D is insanely overpowered. It's paper thin rear plate stopped a Stug III's shot at like 50m(at best?) flat on? The STuG III can penetrate that level of armor at any practical combat range. This was like episode 3 I think? Been awhile.
There's only ONE thing to explain all that: PLOT ARMOR! The ULTIMATE armor anywhere (except Real Life, of course)!
Girls und panzer, phycics sponcored by World of Tanks (blitz)
Pz iv h has spaced armor, steel armor and plot armor, of course it’d be that OP in GuP 👀
One thing I want to mention the ARL-44 was made after WW2 so I have no idea how it’s allowed
Development began just before the end of World War II.
Have we mentioned these tanks are capable of surviving a 600mm shell from a Karl
I can imagine the money disappearing into thin air after the battles
the centurion can in fact just do that trust me bro.
I've said it before and I'll say it again for the class. There is nothing in the rules of Sensha-do that is against the modification and replacement of the engines as long as the technology used was available in and before 1945. The FT-17 and Mk IV can go as fast as they damn want. Same with the Pershing, BT-42, Crusader, I-Go, etc. Anything on this list that is a feat of speed, you're allowed to modify your innards.
They gave the Tiger P to the automobile club girls because of the unreliable engine and they said that rules only restricted engine modifications and didn't say anything about the motor so I expect them to have replaced the motor with a hyperwarp or something.
The only way the HA-GO could pen the Matilda turret ring was if it had already shot or it was damaged.
The Ani is very fun to watch though, nice video by the way I just can't stop laughing when I realize how broken their tanks are, just started playing war thunder and I just can't imagine those tanks drifting and flying.😅😅😅😅
Did you know the tiger Porsche in its practice tests were frequent to set ablaze?
That one tigers traversing speed was weirdly fast😂
The WWI tanks probably just had improved engines.
i agree with the ww1 tanks like how are they gonna go that fast like 55 to 60 mph (normal ww2 tank speed) and how does it go that fast. I don't understand why this anime series broke the speed physics. And first off, tanks don't drift irl i haven't seen a tank go i need to get some tofu, ok i have officially lost my braincells watching these. Nascar style? really nascar fans are really impresed that a tank from ww2 can do wall ride and holy its now a plane?
3:30 POV: 999 ping
Mistake 2:18 i think it hit the side where the engine is, not the turret ring