Gupta ji, you are ULTRA RICH and have big corporate sponsors, never been raided by ED/CBI and hardly ever got any notice from the I&B ministry for any content. It is unfair on your part to solicit subscriptions from aam aadmi. We prefer to support Ravish Kumar, Dhruv Rathee, Akash Banerjee, Sakshi Joshi, News Laundry, The Wire etc. @ThePrintIndia would qualify for subscription from aam aadmi only if you are raided by ED/CBI atleast thrice for different cases and atleast three notices for defamation from big corporates and BJP govt.
Having worked in Rwanda for couple of years and studying the genocide closely , whats happening in Manipur gives me chills. Its like replacing Houthu and Tutsi with Kuki and Meitei . Hope it doesnt come to that. Books have been written how the psychology of individuals in mobs gets shaped during such times and they just see the other as monster leaving aside all principles of ethics and morality and humanity. The violence and retribution becomes the only drivers . After things cool down they regret it and are unable to explain what possessed them at those times. Hope you can do an episode on the psychology of mob violence with some known pychologists who studied such phenonenon. Great work so far by your team
@@raghusharma3091 The High court reached out to the Manipur State Govt to give Metis ST status. The Kukis thinking that they are veto supported by Cong, China, Myanmar takes to violence as against the HC order. The Meitis stood firm and gave it back. Stop ur selective politics
@@vm3306 where in my entire comment i blamed any of the tribes . I am talking about mob violence. Get ur head out of sand and smell coffee please. Thankyou
I applaud your consistent coverage of Manipur violence. Indian TV media is dead. I stopped watching it since 2016. I rely on your good journalism. Thank you for it. Once I get my money, I will definitely join the channel as paying customer.
Media has never been part of any big changes that happened in this world, take Indian independence for example the media of that time was completely under British control and it was only used for their propaganda or everywhere in this world they have been used for propaganda but still the world changed so don't bother media is nothing but bullshit.
India is a diverse country and there are so many faultlines in Indian societies; between castes, between communities, etc. Hence there is always potential of fighting between communities. What is expected from government is to control these. Just like the quarrels between siblings are managed by parents. In democracy, the government is the parent. If the parent takes sides between sons, then only God can save the other son. That same thing happened in Manipur.
Nation survived 75 years of divisive politics of congress-communist-muslim alliance. There is hope after all. Vote for Modi in 2024, keep the hope alive.
Oh it is current day Gandhis- name who got thus done along with the Chinese by supporting the Kukis for violence against Meitis to get ST status as per High Court order. By the way the Gandhis knows how to break laws
Yhe do u know Rajasthan stand number 1 in rape case ..It is exposed itself by congess minister. And do u know what Congress did they removed that minister for telling truth..And above all no one ask resignation of Ashok ghelot because he is from congress
Why is Manipur literacy so low that ppl here are so fuc**d up and ready to kill each other? What were governments doing since Manipur became part of India? Don't just put blame on BJP.
@@ratanshetty9870 Ok so ils it okay for anyone to rape your women folk j7st bcoz it is felt that someone from your caste or family m8ght have done some kind of sexual violence. Trust me there are many who would love to do that. And you then give the same logic. You are really born of a Sanskari hindu, only that you have multiple father's.
Maybe, maybe not. This CM is totally shameless. Also Gujrat was a 2-3 days affair. Similar stuff happened in Mumbai before. Also Modi did not make such comments.
Yes same pattern, victimization of one community which is minority in population and political representation. Here Arms are going from police station, in Gujrat were distributed by political leaders. Abhi to just ek video aaya hai bahar, my friends from manipur from both meiti and kuki. And i can analayze difference between life standard of these 2 community, meiti have high standards and are financially well off ,though it is true they cannot buy land in hilly area.
Shekhar Gupta also plays up to the govt.due to fear. The only difference is that the intellectual highground take by the editorial of Print gives it a good cover as facade. Scared of stating the truth in an unadulterated form? It has taken m9nths for them to address the Pam's silence that too rather indirectly. BJP created the problem through the RSS activities in the last 10 years. They crafted the defections and destabilized the govt. Any other govt. would have been sacked long back.
Modi and Shah haven't understood Manipur. They do not know what to do with Biren Singh. Taking advantage of this, Biren Singh is doing whatever he pleases. Biren has become the CM of Meitei Manipur. The question is who is the CM of Kuki Manipur?
Modi and Shar haven't understood Bengal, Rajasthan and Chhatishgarh. Mumtaz Bano, Priyanka Gandi and Rahul Gandhi are taking advantage of it. Who is the CM of hindus in Bengal, Rajasthan and Chhatishgarh ?
Abe bhosdike.. kukis are not native to Manipur. They illegally immigrated from Burma. If you create dharmashala in your country, this is what happens. Also most of the poppy is produced by Muslims and kukis. Meitis have very little presence.
@@bkk5153 The fight is between TMC cadres and BJP cadres in West Bengal. There are Hindu people in TMC too. However, in Manipur, there is an ethnic fight between two communities. Meiteis and Kukis are fighting a civil war with sophisticated weapons.
Pls also talk about Rape case in West bengal and above all Rajasthan is declared number 1 state in rape. Cases .and most of rape happening on Dalit women .Do u know yesterday Ashok ghelot removed his minister for telling truth about this report ..Instead of working on cause they removed that minister .No one talk because it is not BJP ruled state
@@ratanshetty9870 yes we will talk about it before that ask your PM why did he kept quite for 77 days even after the incident happened , had the video not come out in open he would have been in his LA LA LAND OR BARBIE WORLD which is full of bigotry, ask him how the roits are happening in Manipur when there is so much police presence the police to citizen ratio is the highest in Manipur without state GOVT complicity the roits wouldn't have happened that's why we SOUTH Indians have kicked out MODI from Bangalore we do the same all over SOUTH India
Appreciation post! Shekar sir we are from Andhra Pradesh, we respect the print and your team for such wonderful coverage and of majority of the matters. Right now the ground reality of Andhra Pradesh is horrible. Kindly cover the story of the murder of Lok Sabha MP Vivekananda Reddy. There is a larger conspiracy involving the central government itself.
This godi media has a habit of blaming Congress and Minorities, but never the RSS supported Hindu terrorists who were allowed to Loot from police stations over 4000 assault rifles. The army was not allowed to bring the situation under control as then the RSS supporters would have been at the receiving end.
@@curiouskid1547: Who allowed the Hindus to loot over 4000 assault rifles and 6 lakhs bullets from the police stations? Why are they not recovered to date? Why has the Army not been bought to bring peace in almost 3 months? Why don't we see any Hindu Meiteli girls complaining about rape?
Stop spreading false info. Its ethnic violence between two tribes . Also manipur was under 10 years of blockade under congress rule where prices of essentials shot up. Petrol was sold at 2000rs litre once upon a time. Situation is far better now
Those who are demanding why Modi is not controlling the violence in Manipur are living in a dream. Why would Modi control violence when it is helping his politics. Crafty politicians like Modi always prefer polarization between community like Hindu-Muslim, Hindu-Christian. For Modi, his political interests are more important than the life and dignity of religious minority.
This is the truth. The more polarized the politics in Manipur becomes, the more likely it will boost BJP's political prospects in the state. So, its better to add fuel to fire and watch it burn further.
@@moncliffeekuban9187BJP has 10 mlas from kuki community. It kuki who played a role in bjp winning manipur. Biren singh was congressman who jumped ship
@@karthika560 Bro, there are some Kuki BJP MLAs but the main base of BJP in Manipur is Meitei, not Kuki. Its obvious that Biren Singh is leaning into divisive politics to consolidate power.
The print created several episodes on Manipur but nothing on West Bengal panchayat election violence, killing, rape etc. Unbiased media, look other way if it is non-BJP state.
It is so sorry that when North East started integrating so well with rest of India and BJP did a lot to make it happen that Manipur is now going through this .
Talk about West bengal, Rajasthan, Chattisgarh, Jharkhand. Selective politics has gone way too long. The people has understood this dirty selective politics
1 video has shocked my conscience and I am pretty sure there are many like me who feel hapless about this whole situation. When I lie awake at night I think out of pure selfish reason that if BJP can bring communal tension to such a disgusting & brutal level in Manipur it can do and is doing the same in my state that I love so much for the hunger for votes among sangis is so great. As time passes and brave journalists who are not in a leash of sangh or in debt to sangh for their iPhone pro max bigger houses better cars make their way to Manipur more information will come out don't know whether I will be able to digest it or not. What is worse so much information will not come out.......the pain of being a manipuri
@@ThePrintIndia i should be thanking you for the coverage of manipur. It is by far the most comprehensive one i found among the media. This is the type of journalism we need to keep things balanced and progressing
W Under which govt have such things not happened? In fact all the women of India should bycott 2024 elections and demand every political party to provide safety to the women not 1000 or 2000 Rs .
@@niharikakhare8763ut no other govt. does PR management and protects the culprits (CM Biren). Imo, vote the current govt out to show them, this is not acceptable.
Do you mean to say once converted by missionaries people of North East loose their ethnic identity and become peace loving?? Or oposite they happened since British rule and continued by Congress responsible for this divide?
Back in school , i read about the rwanda genocide between hutu and tutsi. These looks mostly same happening in manipur. Also, I did not knew that meiteis were the people who wanted to start revolution in manipur in 70's
Out of 44 groups listed as Terrorist Outfits by Ministry of Home Affairs India. Six of them are Meitei terrorist group PLA, PREPAK, MPLF, KCP, KYKL, UNLF. Not a single Kuki insurgent groups in the list. And the Meitei along with the CM Biren called us 'Terrorist'. Shameless people.
Shekhar Sir, please acknowledge, understand and tell the entire nation that President's Rule is necessary at this moment. Then, Parliament can bring about permanent solution and end to the communal conflict in Manipur, the best and only feasible solution which will ensure lasting peace in Manipur and northeast is to divide Manipur on ethnic lines and enactment of another States Reorganization Bill:- 1) Churachandpur and Pherzawl districts to be made part of Mizoram. 2) Senapati district to be made part of Nagaland. 3) Chandel, Tengnoupal, Kangpokpi, Ukhrul, Kamjong, Tamenglong and Noney districts remain in Manipur but as separate territorial councils on the lines of Bodoland with full 6th schedule provisions.
Many meetei tweets and statement on social media handles are slowly deleting these days including CM and activists. Just wonder what kindly of brain they carry without even second thought to spread hatred and lies.
The complexity of the region is mind boggling to say the least. You're right in saying that the so called Hindi heartland kind of politics is not going to work there. I think Mr Modi and Amit Shah should sit together with all the stakeholders in the region and very objectively work out a solution. Which I think is going to be quite a challenge but necessary.😐
Top pet will be come out soon in this case. Up to 2020 Shekhar Gupta said Narendra Modi and his team do not have any kind of knowledge in economy The pact will be come out soon in this case. Up to 2020 Shekhar Gupta said that Narendra Modi and his team do not have any kind of knowledge in economy.
Women of India are shamed at what is happening in Manipur, with what happened with the women wrestlers, with the fear they have to live in TODAY's India! They will surely make their choice in the upcoming election!
Pls also talk about Rape case in West bengal and above all Rajasthan is declared number 1 state in rape. Cases .and most of rape happening on Dalit women .Do u know yesterday Ashok ghelot removed his minister for telling truth about this report ..Instead of working on cause they removed that minister .No one talk because it is not BJP ruled state
SC ST reservations was only for Hindus, however in north east since chacha allowed rampant conversion using money , violence, intimidation and exclusion of Hindus it has caused resentment. This was remedied by recent court orders, so Kuki started violence which is called secular by media and retaliation by meities is called communal. Woman are greatest and saddest victims of violence anywhere. Only humanity can save us not religion from violence
Mrs Shekhar Gupta, you should explain how demography was changing in north east, and when you talk about asam, difference between reasons of hindu migrants and Muslims migrants. Also while talking about caa, please explain who should give shelter to hindu migrants from Bangladesh when they are running for life if not India. Also explain how hindu population reduced in neighboring countries. If you want to be true please explain all this.
SOMDUTTA YOU MUST BE IN ADMINISTRATION AS A NATIONAL SECURITY ADVISOR TO SAVE THE COUNTRY FROM STUPIDS LIKE YOU & INDIA. BLOODY FOOLS YOU WILL BE NOWHERE IN DAY'S TO COME.
@@bhaarateeyakannadiga134no point wishing them any wisdom. They r brainwashed. This govt is ths only govt that gave importance to north east, which of course was not liked by opposition. Congress role in flaring up this conflict is nowhere been talked about.
SG, HAVE YOU SEEN THE VIDEO WHERE THE DECAPITATED HEAD OF A KUKI GUY IS HUNG ON THE FENCE?? THAT'S AS HEARTWRENCHING AS THE KUKI WOMEN'S VIDEO. AT THE SAME TIME, PLEASE DO AN EPISODE ON THE SIMILAR PARADING OF HALF-NAKED WOMEN IN MALDA, WEST BENGAL.
I don't understand why you people are bringing in Bengal with Manipur. It Manipur rape and humiliation was used as a weapon against the Kukis. As per the CM there have been hundreds of such cases. And the governnment hid these cases and was indifferent for two months. NONE OF THESE THINGS HAPPENED IN THE BENGAL INCIDENT. What happened in Bengal was mob violence because the women were identified as a women. The media immediately picked it up but no FIR has been written. Both are completely different cases. If you people even have an ounce of shame stop diverting the topic from Manipur.
Moral of the story if there's anything moral here,no matter which politician is in power & wherever they are in power what only matters is staying in power and seeking more & more power,damn the citizens, damn the country & to the hell with the fundamental promise that any government makes to its citizens which is to keep them safe,this reality may come in different forms & shape but it is the basic reality & that's heartbreaking.
Pls also talk about Rape case in West bengal and above all Rajasthan is declared number 1 state in rape. Cases .and most of rape happening on Dalit women .Do u know yesterday Ashok ghelot removed his minister for telling truth about this report ..Instead of working on cause they removed that minister .No one talk because it is not BJP ruled state
Completely different situation. One is about government apathy and indifference, the other is about mob violence. Rape and violence are normal in India. If the video were 1 day old, no one would have batted an eye. But since the government was sleeping for two months, people are rightfully angry about the situation in Manipur.
@@vm3306 wait till you guys get paid back in every region. All the religious persecution in the name of Hindu rashtra will yet again prove Newton's third law to be the real science
Christian & church ka naam le liya❤. Resources of indian armed foreced had been utilised to counter Christian militants for almost 30 years. Now BJP is playing smartly they have replaced armed forces with their counterparts. Hindi mein ek kahawat hai,"saanp bhi mar jaye aur lathi bhi na tute." How these handlful Christian dare to go against Indian Union .This is not possible without external support. 😢 Your opinion is highly biased. BJP will remove this northeast problem forever without using indian armed force resources. Armed forces are not there to fight with civilians. Bjp had taught lessons to extremists in J&K and similarly they will taught same lessons to Northeast militants who had dare to go against Indian Union. Muslims & Christian must learn from other minorities like parsi & jains. Parsi & Jains are affluent & have influential they can build their own country if they wish but they have never adopted this path because there's no external resources who can manipulate them. This is the truth.
Inflammatory! I would suggest that this presentation be structured with a problem and solution rather than finger-pointing (implied). One thing is for sure: the current CM needs to go, and the president's rule needs to be implemented. Maybe for 3- 4 years. Focus on Kashmir like redevelopment. Any violence should be dealt with brutally and in an even-handed manner after sufficient warning to the miscreants. Human lives should matter. This basic tenet needs to be impressed upon the leaders, and they have to look at the bigger picture of the state and the nation.
Although a NI column, the clarity and analysis here is fittin of a CTC episode. Also, thanks a lot for the superb Manipur coverage, have found your reportage to be one of the most exhaustive. Glad to support such journalism !
The pet will be come out soon in this case. Up to 2020 Shekhar Gupta saying that Narendra Modi and his team do not have any kind of knowledge in economy.
MANIPUR SITUATION IN SHORT - More than 79 days passed. No improvement. Death 142+,missing 17+, person with bullet injury 200+,displaced people 70,000+, people on relief camp 50,000+, houses burnt 40,000+. Root cause - 1. Narco Terrorism and 2. Illegal immigrants. Worst part - kuki militants use Snipers, drones, land mines, vehicle-borne improvised explosive device (VBIED) etc. Sophisticated weapons coming from Myanmar to attack meiteis at foothills area, that even Indian army don't use. Started from kuki dominated area Churchandpur on 27 April destroyed New Gym Centre to be anaugurated by CM. 28 April, all CCTV of entire town demolished to falsify evidence. 3rd May,2023 - 12+ localities of meiteis completely wiped out from there(ethnic cleansing). Land reforms act 1960. Exclusion of hilly(tribal) status of meitei in 1949 when Manipur merged with Indian union, because of that meitei can not buy land in hilly areas and also in valley that is once owned by tribal. Meetei population 52% live in only 7% land including all other communities. Finally, meitei's would probably become kasmere pandit. Kuki militants are very powerful now with drug money and church support internationally. It's a national security threat. Mizoram in support. They get help from Myanmar, Bangladesh cos of ethnic relationships. They want a kuki land taking a part of India, Bangladesh, Myanmar. It's a clash between - "Indigenous and non-Indigenous". Meitei's have 2000+ year old Indigenous culture and civilization. People woke up only after the video went viral. Interesting. Where is "Linthoingambi"(a 17 year old meitei girl from Tera, missing since the violence started)? Can anyone answer? A meitei grandmother Sorokhaibam Ibetombi(80) was "BURNT ALIVE" in Serou, that nobody talks about. Everyone should look at both sides and the details. No one talks of burning many 200 years old Meitei Temples(Mandirs). 4 churches are burnt by kuki only. 250 + Churches burnt were of meitei's only, that nobody mentioned. Many Meitei pastor houses were burnt in Churchandpur. Couple of facts - 1. Who carries gun AK47 on peace rally ? 2. At 2.15pm imp office building burnt on 3rd May in ccpur. 3. By 3.43pm houses at boljang and torbung started burning. Hearing the news, meteis reacted by late evening after 9pm and 4May. 4 questions 1. Why did kuki militants forced civilians to buy guns for every household in kuki dominated areas, the last 1 to 2 years? 2. Why was the CCTV cameras vandalized on 28th April, 2023 for entire Churchandpur town, before big event 3 rd May, 2023? 3. Why maximum Kuki's were on leave starting last week of April 2023 working in the valley? 4. Why they use Zomi Revolutionary Army flag in last rally, are they still Indian? I am sure, everyone is sensible enough to understand the facts, if it was a well planned or not. "Facts never lie". 3rd May was just an excuse. Central government hasn't done anything yet to contain the violence. Letting people to kill each other. People of Manipur are dying in extremely worst situation. Let there be justice and punish culprits on both sides. Solution - 1. Revoke SOO 2. Pass NRC 3. Build strong border 4. Restore Meitei Tribal status to equalize land issue 5. Improve VDF to protect foothill villages.
Can we also have an episode on the consistent violence in West Bengal and what are the causes for it? It appears to be a persistent issue and no government has done anything to improve the situation?
@@vm3306 Don't worry... Your number will also come. Once you'll are exploited to become terrorist n ur children to land behind bars you r now n in future as well will find ur masters children enjoying world tour n foreign studies etc. And when ur children r out of jail n our puncture stolen will only be filled by u n ur ilks. The weed effect gutter nationalism are for arshole like you only.
Shekhar and ThePrint never uttered a word for 100s killed in Bengal under Mumtaz Bano - not a word for exact same crimes in Rajasthan, Chhatishgarh, Bihar. Eventually, the curtain has been peeled off and true vultures are out - Shekhar earning his keep from congress-communist-muslim alliance - eh ?
Just don't decide that print is neutral just because of this one video.Initially a print wad neutral, but slowly, they became godi media.now 100% godi media.This one or 2 video, the print is still godi media.
You can't escape identity, esp when groups are so assertive of it. The % share of Hindus in Manipur declined from 62% to 41% (1961-2011), while the share of Christians rose from 19% to 41%. The change was mostly due to illegal immigration from Myanmar and migration from Nagaland. Times have changed tribals are not backward anymore. All groups are feeling aggrieved. Dividing the state is the only solution now. It would create long-term security issues but those could be tackled.
@@bhagwancapitalism1057 Bengali Hindus mostly came in 1971 as refugees, they fled there because of religious persecution from the pakistan army who did genocide on Bengali Hindus. Another thing even present Bangladesh is also not friendly to Hindus in Bangladesh.
See all know what happened at gujarath because of it is Muslims so Indians didn’t critisise so now the are against lower cast Christian communist that rss vicharadara says..
When in a country there are intellectual discussions like in Jaipur dialogue, then this country has a high moral ground. No matter what happens on the ground. Gupta jee is a veiled bakht intellectual and one can understand his compulsions.....
Bastard.... its you people who have made manipur what it is today. Your sanatani vaishnav Meitis have demonstrated greatness of santanis to the whole world.
The manipuries wanted change thats why they voted BJP to power. But BJP didn't do what they promised to do and now we are blaming the previous government. What sought of analysis is this. 9 plus years is enough to make a major change. Now people say foreign hand now what is the central intelligence lead by Doval is doing. All the BJP leaders are silent in this matter which clearly echoing their failure
Congress got 60+ years ... I think so that's enough time to develop a nation... at least at the basic level And we know how much development Congress did lol
Biren Singh is a leader at drama. Let’s see the reason here.On July 7th, he stage a big drama wherein the fake supporters (which I’m sure were paid by him and his party)stopped his convoy and tore his resignation paper while on his way to the Governor’s house (which is 150 metres approx) from his official residence. Now the big contrary is that on 19th July,the same supporters wanted to meet him but were denied which is even shocking than Pakistan’s flop drama. Now it’s up to the people to judge the Dramatic and thick faced behaviour of Biren Singh (Bitler).Jai Hind.
How intellectually gupta jee avoids any comment on the ruling government at the center or leadership......really Gupta jee has a real bakht intellectual subordination.... But unfortunately there are still people who call this wired shielding, The analysis.....Rst in peace that intellect ,u deserve gupta jee intellect.
Absolutely. He pretends to be a neutral analyst, but leaves out selectively grave and condemnable issues and will sugarcoat. This kind of veiled selective ‘journalism’ that avoids naming people responsible is more dangerous than outright liars like Republic TV.
Absolutely. He still tiptoes around not calling out Modi and BJP for their all out divisiveness and arrogance. He heard him using Congress more than bjp or Modi. Such a coward
Now that PM Modi himself has broken his silence, we can expect the violence will stop soon. We should not forget that his whistles, silences, and body language are inspirations for many right wing activists in the country. It was reported during Gujarat riot that some activists claimed that they were given a free run for 3 days by Modiji after Godhra incident.
I am Gujarati and my village had one Muslim shop. The shop keeper was honest person. Mob came from outside. Said the same thing. Burnt his shop. Supporters were his rival shopkeepers. People went into frenzy and stolen from that shop. I remember scenes vividly despite being young. He has tendency to not commenting on any issue that is serious and controversial. He avoided commenting and taking hard action for political reasons. He also applied same strategy in case mob lynching, beef killings, Farmer's protest and CAA protest. He doesn't trust media. He believes that they are manipulative. He is no democrat since he runs away from debate on such issues in parliament as well. I voted for Modi in 2019. I will not for him. I like his foreign policy but his domestic policy is not good for India anymore. Either he needs a lesson in humility or we are doomed in perpetual division
Unfortunately our political leaders are on a path of putting our Nation in disrepute! India has never been spewed with so much communal hatred specially by using our TV Media & BJP IT Cell!
@@IndiaTides i agree with you. He is a chalak lombdi putting on tiger's skin. He is a low level businessman who says and ruthlessly wants to cash crisis. He doesn't have any scruples and without power he is zero.
He is one supplicant ‘journalist’ who doesn’t have the guts to hold the government or the PM accountable. This is the level of ‘journalism’ we have today in India unfortunately. His ‘fair and balanced’ approach is the play down transgressions of a downright evil government and include other entities in the mix to further dilute and deflect responsibility.
Pls also talk about Rape case in West bengal and above all Rajasthan is declared number 1 state in rape. Cases .and most of rape happening on Dalit women .Do u know yesterday Ashok ghelot removed his minister for telling truth about this report ..Instead of working on cause they removed that minister .No one talk because it is not BJP ruled state
@@kumark214Pls also talk about Rape case in West bengal and above all Rajasthan is declared number 1 state in rape. Cases .and most of rape happening on Dalit women .Do u know yesterday Ashok ghelot removed his minister for telling truth about this report ..Instead of working on cause they removed that minister .No one talk because it is not BJP ruled state
One of the best explanations of Manipur situation so far. Any reasonable person capable of logical thinking can tell who is anti-national in Manipur. Keep telling the truth and be the voice of the voiceless minorities.
I would like to disagree. Yes you are right BJP plays divisive politics and it has caused and will cause further violence and divide the North East. But all BJP care is about winning elections. And they'll do anything. Of course CAA caused huge violence in Assam. And yet they did bag the Assam's SLA election pretty much without a fight. I call their ideology works. Mark my words they'll bag the next Manipur SLA too. People easily buy their divisive politics. Everyone with a shred of common sense knows the violence in Manipur is based on ethnicity. Yet BJP's IT cell added a communal angle too. Upcoming General Election is the only hurdle to their agenda.
If BJP is dividing communally then what about Congress , TMC and their joker fact cheekers who amplified religion of victims . Shekhar Ji you need better analysis .. can’t have cake and eat too .
Main issues are of illegal foreigners, Drug Mafia & last but not the least the Church. Mind you there are no tribals in Northeast as we see in Chattisgarh or Jharkhand or MP. They are all developed English speaking folks. 🙏🙏 जय श्री कृष्णा
I am sure it is not a mere Kukki Meiti problem ; The incident in May is a consequence of serious issues ; I think Govt is caught up with more serious problems of Non-stop serious Arms Supplies to Kukkis , Drugs production and peddling , Influx from nearby country , External forces trying to isolate North East etc ; Current Govt had fairly reasonably built infrastructure, connected it to Bangladesh port etc ; Current Govt is instrumental in destroying 300 MUSD worth of Drug plants ; Our Army also played its part to control Collatrel public damages given the sensitivity of the area ; Blaming the current govt squarely is purely political; Of course in war , love and in politics anything is correct ;
Non-stop supplies of weapons? The Kuki militants are in talk with GOI under SoO. Unlike the Meitei terrorist who killed alot of Indian soldiers and wanted to be separate from Indian Union. About poppy the drug Lord a meitei politicians along with the CM is involved. Go and check google.
@@minatonamikaze6587 Google is not a reliable source of Information; My information is also from Videos in You tube ; My point is , What is the root cause and what is the solution ; Disturbance is really due to ethnic clash ??? Is it due to Drug peddling ?? Is it for isolating NE from mainstream by external forces for their land expansion ??? Is it purely political mileage ??? ( highly possible ) Why NE is always burning and sensitive ??? What type of leadership is needed ??? Is Army rule under president is the right choice ???
Your reference to Cong ways are misplaced and unwarranted. Here we are talking about Modi government and state government. These two are squarely failed the Manipuris. They have been in power for long enough to undo what wrongs congress may have done. So lets call spade a spade. By comparing tge BJP with Cong, you are giving escape route to Modi ji. Its him and him alone at whose door step, the buck stops.
There is many incidents where small Methai children killed, Adult male female extra , Before kuki started huge killing spree Methai mentioned to police that they already started violence before months ago. Majority of Methai villages wipe out where small kuki Rome army but NO NEWS because????????? There is many churches spreading videos images before this incident and promoting haterad but we are secular.
Exclusive content, privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for special benefits: theprint.in/subscribe/
Done, Thank you Mr. Gupta for all that you do and for the Print.
If you want subscriptions, you need to remove ALL the ads from your videos.
Gupta ji, you are ULTRA RICH and have big corporate sponsors, never been raided by ED/CBI and hardly ever got any notice from the I&B ministry for any content.
It is unfair on your part to solicit subscriptions from aam aadmi.
We prefer to support Ravish Kumar, Dhruv Rathee, Akash Banerjee, Sakshi Joshi, News Laundry, The Wire etc.
@ThePrintIndia would qualify for subscription from aam aadmi only if you are raided by ED/CBI atleast thrice for different cases and atleast three notices for defamation from big corporates and BJP govt.
ua-cam.com/video/WdgAyWMowB0/v-deo.html
Here’s the real intention behind “Separate Administration”
ua-cam.com/video/057TwFlGz10/v-deo.html
Having worked in Rwanda for couple of years and studying the genocide closely , whats happening in Manipur gives me chills. Its like replacing Houthu and Tutsi with Kuki and Meitei . Hope it doesnt come to that. Books have been written how the psychology of individuals in mobs gets shaped during such times and they just see the other as monster leaving aside all principles of ethics and morality and humanity. The violence and retribution becomes the only drivers . After things cool down they regret it and are unable to explain what possessed them at those times. Hope you can do an episode on the psychology of mob violence with some known pychologists who studied such phenonenon. Great work so far by your team
Don't forget West Bengal, Rajasthan
@@vm3306 its not tribe conflict in wb and Rajasthan .
Well explained! That’s why we need educated political leadership!
@@raghusharma3091
The High court reached out to the Manipur State Govt to give Metis ST status.
The Kukis thinking that they are veto supported by Cong, China, Myanmar takes to violence as against the HC order.
The Meitis stood firm and gave it back.
Stop ur selective politics
@@vm3306 where in my entire comment i blamed any of the tribes . I am talking about mob violence. Get ur head out of sand and smell coffee please. Thankyou
I applaud your consistent coverage of Manipur violence. Indian TV media is dead. I stopped watching it since 2016. I rely on your good journalism.
Thank you for it. Once I get my money, I will definitely join the channel as paying customer.
Only a miracle can save this country now
Media has never been part of any big changes that happened in this world, take Indian independence for example the media of that time was completely under British control and it was only used for their propaganda or everywhere in this world they have been used for propaganda but still the world changed so don't bother media is nothing but bullshit.
@@Vizorfammiracle happened in 2014 else Kashmir would have already gone . Please cry more
@@lastleaf5282t's better now if Manipur also goes along with ......
You are 100 persent correct sir India media is dead. The Indian media persons not having any ethics
India is a diverse country and there are so many faultlines in Indian societies; between castes, between communities, etc. Hence there is always potential of fighting between communities. What is expected from government is to control these. Just like the quarrels between siblings are managed by parents. In democracy, the government is the parent. If the parent takes sides between sons, then only God can save the other son. That same thing happened in Manipur.
So true.
So, when your sibling fights among yourself do your parents just watch the fight, even if it's bloodshed, killing they don't care??
Politicians cannot add value to the Nation, they can only survive on divisive politics..
100% 👍👍
I h@te hindustanis, assamese, north eastern, pakistanis, muslims and bangladeshis.
Divisive politics is perhaps the greatest threat to national security
Nation survived 75 years of divisive politics of congress-communist-muslim alliance. There is hope after all. Vote for Modi in 2024, keep the hope alive.
No fake news Christian style followed by Uno, msm , bollywood , shekhar, is greatest threat to humanity.
That’s true but the root cause is division itself by religions etc rather than the inhabitants
Who gave the Hindu Meithile over 4000 assult rifels from police station if not the BJP government?
who gave same number of weapons to kukis ?? 🙄 myanmmar ??
it wasnt just meiteis that looted, kukis did too on top of the weapons they got from myanmar
@@Diasasterwhat the government is doing then? Spread anarchy? Idiots.
Do you know the DGP is kuki?
@@rao521: He has to take orders from his boss, A Brahmin RSS appointee.
For a change, BJP admirers have not accused Nehru for the almost civil war situation in Manipur! 😂😂
Cuz they r rational unlike dimwits like u who r only here for selective outrage. Khan market is active again
Oh it is current day Gandhis- name who got thus done along with the Chinese by supporting the Kukis for violence against Meitis to get ST status as per High Court order.
By the way the Gandhis knows how to break laws
@@vm3306 You either forgot your meds or IT is paying you for your hard work
😂😂😂modi is their God don't give them ideas they will use it .
@@gauravdas6741 is it true rahul visited manipur most recently. how many more times will this product will be relaunched.
Keep up the good work!
😅
Dear Sajal,
Thank you for your invaluable contribution towards ThePrint's journalism.
Literal Gujarat 2.0 they are using the toolkit again to create a new issue but they forgot people are much better connected
Hinduism can be my identity but I am a HUMAN first.
Then support meiteis who are restructured to 10% of their area.
Chutiye clash if for ethnicity
ARE YOU YOU A STAKEHOLDERS OF SECULAR COMPANY. MY FOOT FOR YOUR COMMENT
@@YgjohhHfjg-oe3euYou belong to fanatic radical Party follower.
@@YgjohhHfjg-oe3eu give it to me
Biren Singh agrees hundreds of sexual cases in Manipur still he is CM material for BJP. Mera Bharat Mahan.
Yhe do u know Rajasthan stand number 1 in rape case ..It is exposed itself by congess minister. And do u know what Congress did they removed that minister for telling truth..And above all no one ask resignation of Ashok ghelot because he is from congress
and Vishwaguru in Amritkal to boot😢😢😢
Why is Manipur literacy so low that ppl here are so fuc**d up and ready to kill each other? What were governments doing since Manipur became part of India? Don't just put blame on BJP.
@@ratanshetty9870so called rajput morality and dignity must be lie then 😢
@@ratanshetty9870 Ok so ils it okay for anyone to rape your women folk j7st bcoz it is felt that someone from your caste or family m8ght have done some kind of sexual violence.
Trust me there are many who would love to do that. And you then give the same logic.
You are really born of a Sanskari hindu, only that you have multiple father's.
Can we see parallels between Gujarat 2002 riots where no one was convicted and 2023 Manipur riots
Problem lies with majority
Maybe, maybe not. This CM is totally shameless. Also Gujrat was a 2-3 days affair. Similar stuff happened in Mumbai before. Also Modi did not make such comments.
No one was convicted? WTF!
exactly
Yes same pattern, victimization of one community which is minority in population and political representation. Here Arms are going from police station, in Gujrat were distributed by political leaders. Abhi to just ek video aaya hai bahar, my friends from manipur from both meiti and kuki. And i can analayze difference between life standard of these 2 community, meiti have high standards and are financially well off ,though it is true they cannot buy land in hilly area.
This is real journalism which is sadly missing from the mainstream media.
What bullcrap
Yeh dalaal hai
Shekhar Gupta also plays up to the govt.due to fear. The only difference is that the intellectual highground take by the editorial of Print gives it a good cover as facade. Scared of stating the truth in an unadulterated form?
It has taken m9nths for them to address the Pam's silence that too rather indirectly. BJP created the problem through the RSS activities in the last 10 years. They crafted the defections and destabilized the govt. Any other govt. would have been sacked long back.
created a civil war...bring in ache din
SG is an old war horse - he knows how to butter the bread!! In the recent 'man ki bath' me, Manipur ke bare me kuch bhi nahi!!
People has become very silent. They are having family to feed. Very few people are critical of central government.
ED, PD, BD....😮
go take care of punjab and make it safe from K
Modi and Shah haven't understood Manipur. They do not know what to do with Biren Singh. Taking advantage of this, Biren Singh is doing whatever he pleases. Biren has become the CM of Meitei Manipur. The question is who is the CM of Kuki Manipur?
Poppy is the CM of Kukkis
Modi and Shar haven't understood Bengal, Rajasthan and Chhatishgarh. Mumtaz Bano, Priyanka Gandi and Rahul Gandhi are taking advantage of it. Who is the CM of hindus in Bengal, Rajasthan and Chhatishgarh ?
Abe bhosdike.. kukis are not native to Manipur. They illegally immigrated from Burma.
If you create dharmashala in your country, this is what happens.
Also most of the poppy is produced by Muslims and kukis. Meitis have very little presence.
@@bkk5153 The fight is between TMC cadres and BJP cadres in West Bengal. There are Hindu people in TMC too. However, in Manipur, there is an ethnic fight between two communities. Meiteis and Kukis are fighting a civil war with sophisticated weapons.
@@sailendradewan There is no fight between TMC cadres and others - it is all one-sided. Mumtaz Bano has her lashkar who are taking out hindus !
Congress actually fixed a lot of problems in Manipur before bjp. Bjp just took over and reaped the benefits.
And then made it horrendously worse.
Ulta..made it worse..bjp is fixing
Oh really ! Congress the most divisive and communal party has done nothing for manipur , in fact entire NE
Congress is the reason for all the problems .plz smell ur coffee..
The people have to decide now if we want a United India or one divided by politician on lines of religion, cast, language etc..
Why dont you preach this to majority of this country?
@@TheGreatVivek7 You are right.
The present govt has created a united India. No idea what you are talking about 🤷
Want stoppage in language divide? Why don't you learn hindi
Who divided India based on religion kiddo ? Ask ur abbus about reality. Don't teach us about these things
MODI will come and cry on the TV screens and seek votes in the name of religion unfortunately we have dramabaaz as our top leaders
Pls also talk about Rape case in West bengal and above all Rajasthan is declared number 1 state in rape. Cases .and most of rape happening on Dalit women .Do u know yesterday Ashok ghelot removed his minister for telling truth about this report ..Instead of working on cause they removed that minister .No one talk because it is not BJP ruled state
@@ratanshetty9870 yes we will talk about it before that ask your PM why did he kept quite for 77 days even after the incident happened , had the video not come out in open he would have been in his LA LA LAND OR BARBIE WORLD which is full of bigotry, ask him how the roits are happening in Manipur when there is so much police presence the police to citizen ratio is the highest in Manipur without state GOVT complicity the roits wouldn't have happened that's why we SOUTH Indians have kicked out MODI from Bangalore we do the same all over SOUTH India
Appreciation post!
Shekar sir we are from Andhra Pradesh, we respect the print and your team for such wonderful coverage and of majority of the matters.
Right now the ground reality of Andhra Pradesh is horrible.
Kindly cover the story of the murder of Lok Sabha MP Vivekananda Reddy.
There is a larger conspiracy involving the central government itself.
Thank you, The Print for all your persistence, hard work and resilience for true journalism.
Love from Mizoram ❤
This godi media has a habit of blaming Congress and Minorities, but never the RSS supported Hindu terrorists who were allowed to Loot from police stations over 4000 assault rifles. The army was not allowed to bring the situation under control as then the RSS supporters would have been at the receiving end.
There is no Hindu terrorism there. Its the meitei community. Stop seeing everything from religious angle.
@@curiouskid1547: Who allowed the Hindus to loot over 4000 assault rifles and 6 lakhs bullets from the police stations? Why are they not recovered to date? Why has the Army not been bought to bring peace in almost 3 months?
Why don't we see any Hindu Meiteli girls complaining about rape?
@@curiouskid1547 There is hindu terrorism.
Stop spreading false info. Its ethnic violence between two tribes . Also manipur was under 10 years of blockade under congress rule where prices of essentials shot up. Petrol was sold at 2000rs litre once upon a time. Situation is far better now
There is no RSS in Manipur. Meitei Hindus have their own separatist groups. RSS would not support anti-India separatist group.
Thanks!
Dear Tamna,
Thank you for contributing to ThePrint's journalism.
Those who are demanding why Modi is not controlling the violence in Manipur are living in a dream. Why would Modi control violence when it is helping his politics. Crafty politicians like Modi always prefer polarization between community like Hindu-Muslim, Hindu-Christian. For Modi, his political interests are more important than the life and dignity of religious minority.
This is the truth. The more polarized the politics in Manipur becomes, the more likely it will boost BJP's political prospects in the state. So, its better to add fuel to fire and watch it burn further.
Sadly true!
He is consolidating his voter based , his their political carrier is based on this strategies
@@moncliffeekuban9187BJP has 10 mlas from kuki community. It kuki who played a role in bjp winning manipur. Biren singh was congressman who jumped ship
@@karthika560 Bro, there are some Kuki BJP MLAs but the main base of BJP in Manipur is Meitei, not Kuki. Its obvious that Biren Singh is leaning into divisive politics to consolidate power.
PM Modi ji has to do Manipur ki baat .
Citizens of India are deeply disturbed by unmentionable turn of events .
How about West Bengal, Rajasthan ki baat
AFSPA?
@@vm3306 Whataboutery won’t gain you any brownie points !!
@@tapemaj yr selective reporting is getting u white points
The print created several episodes on Manipur but nothing on West Bengal panchayat election violence, killing, rape etc. Unbiased media, look other way if it is non-BJP state.
It is so sorry that when North East started integrating so well with rest of India and BJP did a lot to make it happen that Manipur is now going through this .
The mount of coverage the print gave Manipur shows how independent it is.
If anything bjp has worsened manipur. Their plan is to take the whole country down the same path.
Same path of communal politics..
Talk about West bengal, Rajasthan, Chattisgarh, Jharkhand.
Selective politics has gone way too long.
The people has understood this dirty selective politics
@@mg.f.9023 Abdul show ur papers
@@vm3306hey troll, why don’t you go back to your hole and leave adult conversations to mature intelligent people.
Right. So situation was better with Afspa and blockades?
1 video has shocked my conscience and I am pretty sure there are many like me who feel hapless about this whole situation. When I lie awake at night I think out of pure selfish reason that if BJP can bring communal tension to such a disgusting & brutal level in Manipur it can do and is doing the same in my state that I love so much for the hunger for votes among sangis is so great. As time passes and brave journalists who are not in a leash of sangh or in debt to sangh for their iPhone pro max bigger houses better cars make their way to Manipur more information will come out don't know whether I will be able to digest it or not. What is worse so much information will not come out.......the pain of being a manipuri
lol
Thanks
Dear Shounak,
Thank you for your generous contribution to ThePrint's journalism.
@@ThePrintIndia i should be thanking you for the coverage of manipur. It is by far the most comprehensive one i found among the media. This is the type of journalism we need to keep things balanced and progressing
मैं भी इस देश का गुनहगार हूं🙏
क्योंकि मैंने भी बीजेपी को वोट किया था😢
पर अब और नहीं, कभी नहीं 🙏
W
Under which govt have such things not happened?
In fact all the women of India should bycott 2024 elections and demand every political party to provide safety to the women not 1000 or 2000 Rs .
@@niharikakhare8763 attitude matters not crime, crime kabhi bhi ho sakta hai lekin govt ka bad ka response firk Lata hai....
@@Sk-cr2bl true . But every govt tries to hush such incidents under the carpet unless it is forced to take action.
@@niharikakhare8763ut no other govt. does PR management and protects the culprits (CM Biren).
Imo, vote the current govt out to show them, this is not acceptable.
Chal saale sapai
We need this kind journalism
Do you mean to say once converted by missionaries people of North East loose their ethnic identity and become peace loving?? Or oposite they happened since British rule and continued by Congress responsible for this divide?
Back in school , i read about the rwanda genocide between hutu and tutsi. These looks mostly same happening in manipur. Also, I did not knew that meiteis were the people who wanted to start revolution in manipur in 70's
Out of 44 groups listed as Terrorist Outfits by Ministry of Home Affairs India. Six of them are Meitei terrorist group PLA, PREPAK, MPLF, KCP, KYKL, UNLF. Not a single Kuki insurgent groups in the list.
And the Meitei along with the CM Biren called us 'Terrorist'. Shameless people.
Better to give separate states for Mehties & Kukis
But Biren blame Christians, Myanmar and China 😂😂
Shekhar Sir, please acknowledge, understand and tell the entire nation that President's Rule is necessary at this moment. Then, Parliament can bring about permanent solution and end to the communal conflict in Manipur, the best and only feasible solution which will ensure lasting peace in Manipur and northeast is to divide Manipur on ethnic lines and enactment of another States Reorganization Bill:- 1) Churachandpur and Pherzawl districts to be made part of Mizoram. 2) Senapati district to be made part of Nagaland. 3) Chandel, Tengnoupal, Kangpokpi, Ukhrul, Kamjong, Tamenglong and Noney districts remain in Manipur but as separate territorial councils on the lines of Bodoland with full 6th schedule provisions.
Shame on sanghi hindutva govt, please save this country the democracy is in dang
My foot evenglist drug lord
Then you have not seen Congress cursed rule … problem with 90s generation is they think either they are jokers or other are jokers
Does ur B stand for Balaji?
Yeah save this country from dumb like you
@@lastleaf5282 Right. Sekhar ji himself covered Neillie.
Many meetei tweets and statement on social media handles are slowly deleting these days including CM and activists. Just wonder what kindly of brain they carry without even second thought to spread hatred and lies.
SANGHIS and those brainwashed by them can resort to this only.
Appreciate your depth of knowledge and experience to put out facts against the lies being told by the government.
True you are not seeing many other truths as you don't want to see.
The complexity of the region is mind boggling to say the least. You're right in saying that the so called Hindi heartland kind of politics is not going to work there. I think Mr Modi and Amit Shah should sit together with all the stakeholders in the region and very objectively work out a solution. Which I think is going to be quite a challenge but necessary.😐
Top pet will be come out soon in this case. Up to 2020 Shekhar Gupta said Narendra Modi and his team do not have any kind of knowledge in economy The pact will be come out soon in this case. Up to 2020 Shekhar Gupta said that Narendra Modi and his team do not have any kind of knowledge in economy.
Women of India are shamed at what is happening in Manipur, with what happened with the women wrestlers, with the fear they have to live in TODAY's India! They will surely make their choice in the upcoming election!
My dear two incidents can not create dystopian Worldview. These kind of scandal happen time to time in every where.
@@alexryan43244
Happens every where but a Nation's leader not uttering a word for months doesn't happen every where!
Pls also talk about Rape case in West bengal and above all Rajasthan is declared number 1 state in rape. Cases .and most of rape happening on Dalit women .Do u know yesterday Ashok ghelot removed his minister for telling truth about this report ..Instead of working on cause they removed that minister .No one talk because it is not BJP ruled state
@@ratanshetty9870
PM Modi has to show the way by standing for truth! and giving protection & justice to women .
@@mg.f.9023 hell yeah he should be accountable for a lots of stuff including this one
SC ST reservations was only for Hindus, however in north east since chacha allowed rampant conversion using money , violence, intimidation and exclusion of Hindus it has caused resentment. This was remedied by recent court orders, so Kuki started violence which is called secular by media and retaliation by meities is called communal.
Woman are greatest and saddest victims of violence anywhere. Only humanity can save us not religion from violence
Superb factual presentation and heroic effort by Print!
Thank you!
There is a limit, to vested interests.
Be careful SG lots of bhakts watch print so bring Nehru-Gandhi and gokhale and other congress leaders involvement ....🤐🤐🤐🤐
Thank you for this episode!
Mrs Shekhar Gupta, you should explain how demography was changing in north east, and when you talk about asam, difference between reasons of hindu migrants and Muslims migrants. Also while talking about caa, please explain who should give shelter to hindu migrants from Bangladesh when they are running for life if not India. Also explain how hindu population reduced in neighboring countries. If you want to be true please explain all this.
Modi and BJP government is the greatest threat to National security India has faced for a while.
May God bless you with wisdom
SOMDUTTA YOU MUST BE IN ADMINISTRATION AS A NATIONAL SECURITY ADVISOR TO SAVE THE COUNTRY FROM STUPIDS LIKE YOU & INDIA. BLOODY FOOLS YOU WILL BE NOWHERE IN DAY'S TO COME.
@@bhaarateeyakannadiga134no point wishing them any wisdom. They r brainwashed. This govt is ths only govt that gave importance to north east, which of course was not liked by opposition. Congress role in flaring up this conflict is nowhere been talked about.
This Sir is a very informative , thought-provoking and meticulously researched video.
SG, HAVE YOU SEEN THE VIDEO WHERE THE DECAPITATED HEAD OF A KUKI GUY IS HUNG ON THE FENCE?? THAT'S AS HEARTWRENCHING AS THE KUKI WOMEN'S VIDEO. AT THE SAME TIME, PLEASE DO AN EPISODE ON THE SIMILAR PARADING OF HALF-NAKED WOMEN IN MALDA, WEST BENGAL.
I don't understand why you people are bringing in Bengal with Manipur. It Manipur rape and humiliation was used as a weapon against the Kukis. As per the CM there have been hundreds of such cases. And the governnment hid these cases and was indifferent for two months. NONE OF THESE THINGS HAPPENED IN THE BENGAL INCIDENT. What happened in Bengal was mob violence because the women were identified as a women. The media immediately picked it up but no FIR has been written.
Both are completely different cases. If you people even have an ounce of shame stop diverting the topic from Manipur.
similar atrocities have been committed by both sides. Lets condemn all.
Why not obv quota for one caste and one st
Moral of the story if there's anything moral here,no matter which politician is in power & wherever they are in power what only matters is staying in power and seeking more & more power,damn the citizens, damn the country & to the hell with the fundamental promise that any government makes to its citizens which is to keep them safe,this reality may come in different forms & shape but it is the basic reality & that's heartbreaking.
Always been and will always be that way. Sad but true..
Pls also talk about Rape case in West bengal and above all Rajasthan is declared number 1 state in rape. Cases .and most of rape happening on Dalit women .Do u know yesterday Ashok ghelot removed his minister for telling truth about this report ..Instead of working on cause they removed that minister .No one talk because it is not BJP ruled state
Chup Gobar bhakt ... ekdum chup
@@anuragchakraborty8766chup Ji-hadi.... Bhaag yahan se
Nobody ( also media)tell about same like Manipur incident happen in
malda district, Wes Bengal..😔
2 state but different judge angle...why?
Completely different situation. One is about government apathy and indifference, the other is about mob violence. Rape and violence are normal in India. If the video were 1 day old, no one would have batted an eye. But since the government was sleeping for two months, people are rightfully angry about the situation in Manipur.
While both should be condemned they are completely diff situations
Even BBC has described this as a drug and terror problem. Shekhar, please do your home work.
When did the BBC become the hallmark of journalism? 😂
Manipur 2023 has been a repeat of the "Gujarat Godhra Model" from day ONE
godhra first then gujarat was pay back.
@@vm3306 wait till you guys get paid back in every region. All the religious persecution in the name of Hindu rashtra will yet again prove Newton's third law to be the real science
Christian & church ka naam le liya❤. Resources of indian armed foreced had been utilised to counter Christian militants for almost 30 years.
Now BJP is playing smartly they have replaced armed forces with their counterparts.
Hindi mein ek kahawat hai,"saanp bhi mar jaye aur lathi bhi na tute."
How these handlful Christian dare to go against Indian Union .This is not possible without external support. 😢
Your opinion is highly biased. BJP will remove this northeast problem forever without using indian armed force resources.
Armed forces are not there to fight with civilians. Bjp had taught lessons to extremists in J&K and similarly they will taught same lessons to Northeast militants who had dare to go against Indian Union.
Muslims & Christian must learn from other minorities like parsi & jains. Parsi & Jains are affluent & have influential they can build their own country if they wish but they have never adopted this path because there's no external resources who can manipulate them. This is the truth.
Never brought on home ministry. Just amazing
He is Too afraid to Take on Shah and Modi Directly.
Remaining faithful to your calling very much appreciated.Keep up the objectivity.
Inflammatory! I would suggest that this presentation be structured with a problem and solution rather than finger-pointing (implied). One thing is for sure: the current CM needs to go, and the president's rule needs to be implemented. Maybe for 3- 4 years. Focus on Kashmir like redevelopment. Any violence should be dealt with brutally and in an even-handed manner after sufficient warning to the miscreants. Human lives should matter. This basic tenet needs to be impressed upon the leaders, and they have to look at the bigger picture of the state and the nation.
Invaluable analysis and information! Thank you.
Both GUJARAT and MANIPUR HORROR & TERROR one and the same under the same LEADERSHIP
This is the Gujarat model they have in intimidating and eliminating minorities.
WHY ARE YOU SCARED OF PM & HM. SHAME ON YOU
Although a NI column, the clarity and analysis here is fittin of a CTC episode.
Also, thanks a lot for the superb Manipur coverage, have found your reportage to be one of the most exhaustive. Glad to support such journalism !
Thank you for the kind words, Prabhav, and thank you also for supporting our journalism...best wishes, Shekhar
The pet will be come out soon in this case. Up to 2020 Shekhar Gupta saying that Narendra Modi and his team do not have any kind of knowledge in economy.
MANIPUR SITUATION IN SHORT - More than 79 days passed. No improvement. Death 142+,missing 17+, person with bullet injury 200+,displaced people 70,000+, people on relief camp 50,000+, houses burnt 40,000+.
Root cause - 1. Narco Terrorism and 2. Illegal immigrants. Worst part - kuki militants use Snipers, drones, land mines, vehicle-borne improvised explosive device (VBIED) etc. Sophisticated weapons coming from Myanmar to attack meiteis at foothills area, that even Indian army don't use.
Started from kuki dominated area Churchandpur on 27 April destroyed New Gym Centre to be anaugurated by CM. 28 April, all CCTV of entire town demolished to falsify evidence. 3rd May,2023 - 12+ localities of meiteis completely wiped out from there(ethnic cleansing).
Land reforms act 1960. Exclusion of hilly(tribal) status of meitei in 1949 when Manipur merged with Indian union, because of that meitei can not buy land in hilly areas and also in valley that is once owned by tribal. Meetei population 52% live in only 7% land including all other communities. Finally, meitei's would probably become kasmere pandit.
Kuki militants are very powerful now with drug money and church support internationally. It's a national security threat. Mizoram in support. They get help from Myanmar, Bangladesh cos of ethnic relationships. They want a kuki land taking a part of India, Bangladesh, Myanmar. It's a clash between - "Indigenous and non-Indigenous". Meitei's have 2000+ year old Indigenous culture and civilization.
People woke up only after the video went viral. Interesting. Where is "Linthoingambi"(a 17 year old meitei girl from Tera, missing since the violence started)? Can anyone answer? A meitei grandmother Sorokhaibam Ibetombi(80) was "BURNT ALIVE" in Serou, that nobody talks about. Everyone should look at both sides and the details.
No one talks of burning many 200 years old Meitei Temples(Mandirs). 4 churches are burnt by kuki only. 250 + Churches burnt were of meitei's only, that nobody mentioned. Many Meitei pastor houses were burnt in Churchandpur.
Couple of facts - 1. Who carries gun AK47 on peace rally ?
2. At 2.15pm imp office building burnt on 3rd May in ccpur.
3. By 3.43pm houses at boljang and torbung started burning. Hearing the news, meteis reacted by late evening after 9pm and 4May.
4 questions
1. Why did kuki militants forced civilians to buy guns for every household in kuki dominated areas, the last 1 to 2 years?
2. Why was the CCTV cameras vandalized on 28th April, 2023 for entire Churchandpur town, before big event 3 rd May, 2023?
3. Why maximum Kuki's were on leave starting last week of April 2023 working in the valley?
4. Why they use Zomi Revolutionary Army flag in last rally, are they still Indian?
I am sure, everyone is sensible enough to understand the facts, if it was a well planned or not. "Facts never lie". 3rd May was just an excuse.
Central government hasn't done anything yet to contain the violence. Letting people to kill each other. People of Manipur are dying in extremely worst situation. Let there be justice and punish culprits on both sides.
Solution - 1. Revoke SOO 2. Pass NRC 3. Build strong border 4. Restore Meitei Tribal status to equalize land issue 5. Improve VDF to protect foothill villages.
Can we also have an episode on the consistent violence in West Bengal and what are the causes for it? It appears to be a persistent issue and no government has done anything to improve the situation?
Stop your whatabouttery nonsense.
Another 2 rupalli IT cell chintu
@@stingehte yr free tyre puncture services are no longer reqd
@@vm3306
Don't worry... Your number will also come. Once you'll are exploited to become terrorist n ur children to land behind bars you r now n in future as well will find ur masters children enjoying world tour n foreign studies etc.
And when ur children r out of jail n our puncture stolen will only be filled by u n ur ilks.
The weed effect gutter nationalism are for arshole like you only.
Shekhar and ThePrint never uttered a word for 100s killed in Bengal under Mumtaz Bano - not a word for exact same crimes in Rajasthan, Chhatishgarh, Bihar. Eventually, the curtain has been peeled off and true vultures are out - Shekhar earning his keep from congress-communist-muslim alliance - eh ?
Thankyou sekarsir for the wonderful coverage on Manipur violence.Ihave have never seen honest journalism like your print.thank you once again.
Thank you for watching and writing in, Prakash. Your support means a lot...best wishes, Shekhar
Just don't decide that print is neutral just because of this one video.Initially a print wad neutral, but slowly, they became godi media.now 100% godi media.This one or 2 video, the print is still godi media.
Shekhar sir you sound so much like a psychoanalyst trained in culture in this video. Glad and grateful that you created this.
The report says a lot less than it should have.
The print anti national as always. Shekhar so happy. Father of anti national media
You can't escape identity, esp when groups are so assertive of it. The % share of Hindus in Manipur declined from 62% to 41% (1961-2011), while the share of Christians rose from 19% to 41%. The change was mostly due to illegal immigration from Myanmar and migration from Nagaland. Times have changed tribals are not backward anymore. All groups are feeling aggrieved. Dividing the state is the only solution now. It would create long-term security issues but those could be tackled.
What about indigenous tripura people becoming minority in their own land because of hindu Bengali immigrants from Bangladesh???
If Hinduism is so strong have good suppot system why would they convert. Stop trying to label with these stats.
@@bhagwancapitalism1057 Bengali Hindus mostly came in 1971 as refugees, they fled there because of religious persecution from the pakistan army who did genocide on Bengali Hindus.
Another thing even present Bangladesh is also not friendly to Hindus in Bangladesh.
Stop your communal and idiotic statistics. It means nothing.
Chup!
See all know what happened at gujarath because of it is Muslims so Indians didn’t critisise so now the are against lower cast Christian communist that rss vicharadara says..
When in a country there are intellectual discussions like in Jaipur dialogue, then this country has a high moral ground. No matter what happens on the ground.
Gupta jee is a veiled bakht intellectual and one can understand his compulsions.....
At least some people can see him in true light. I thought I was the only one who regarded him as a bhakt.
See the difference if there is any between gupta jee and pawn chewing intellectual analyst of modern India..
ua-cam.com/video/9g_IPsCJZHA/v-deo.html
Bastard.... its you people who have made manipur what it is today. Your sanatani vaishnav Meitis have demonstrated greatness of santanis to the whole world.
@@curiouskid1547he is liberal
Agree he is a BHAKTH and so I don't watch him.
How did the violence start? Who started it and and for what reason?
Shame for govt. It took 3 months and a viral shameful video to wake this govt
All media should be know the origin of ethnic crisis and history of manipur before discussing.
The manipuries wanted change thats why they voted BJP to power. But BJP didn't do what they promised to do and now we are blaming the previous government. What sought of analysis is this. 9 plus years is enough to make a major change. Now people say foreign hand now what is the central intelligence lead by Doval is doing. All the BJP leaders are silent in this matter which clearly echoing their failure
Congress got 60+ years ... I think so that's enough time to develop a nation... at least at the basic level
And we know how much development Congress did lol
You didn't question 60+ yrs and all of a sudden you considered 9 yrs 🤣
Biren Singh is a leader at drama. Let’s see the reason here.On July 7th, he stage a big drama wherein the fake supporters (which I’m sure were paid by him and his party)stopped his convoy and tore his resignation paper while on his way to the Governor’s house (which is 150 metres approx) from his official residence. Now the big contrary is that on 19th July,the same supporters wanted to meet him but were denied which is even shocking than Pakistan’s flop drama. Now it’s up to the people to judge the Dramatic and thick faced behaviour of Biren Singh (Bitler).Jai Hind.
How intellectually gupta jee avoids any comment on the ruling government at the center or leadership......really Gupta jee has a real bakht intellectual subordination....
But unfortunately there are still people who call this wired shielding, The analysis.....Rst in peace that intellect ,u deserve gupta jee intellect.
Absolutely. He pretends to be a neutral analyst, but leaves out selectively grave and condemnable issues and will sugarcoat. This kind of veiled selective ‘journalism’ that avoids naming people responsible is more dangerous than outright liars like Republic TV.
Absolutely. He still tiptoes around not calling out Modi and BJP for their all out divisiveness and arrogance. He heard him using Congress more than bjp or Modi. Such a coward
@@sujithkumar2041 Just bcoz ur biased doesn't mean the facts are.
@@anirudhsharma9555 just because you are venal and stupid doesn’t mean others are.
Forget Manipur, Modiji is ruling India. Bharat is doing amazing.
Now that PM Modi himself has broken his silence, we can expect the violence will stop soon. We should not forget that his whistles, silences, and body language are inspirations for many right wing activists in the country. It was reported during Gujarat riot that some activists claimed that they were given a free run for 3 days by Modiji after Godhra incident.
Your profile picture and your comment put you in a category of no question.
Very True!
I am Gujarati and my village had one Muslim shop. The shop keeper was honest person. Mob came from outside. Said the same thing. Burnt his shop. Supporters were his rival shopkeepers.
People went into frenzy and stolen from that shop. I remember scenes vividly despite being young.
He has tendency to not commenting on any issue that is serious and controversial. He avoided commenting and taking hard action for political reasons. He also applied same strategy in case mob lynching, beef killings, Farmer's protest and CAA protest. He doesn't trust media. He believes that they are manipulative. He is no democrat since he runs away from debate on such issues in parliament as well. I voted for Modi in 2019. I will not for him. I like his foreign policy but his domestic policy is not good for India anymore. Either he needs a lesson in humility or we are doomed in perpetual division
Unfortunately our political leaders are on a path of putting our Nation in disrepute!
India has never been spewed with so much communal hatred specially by using our TV Media & BJP IT Cell!
@@IndiaTides i agree with you. He is a chalak lombdi putting on tiger's skin. He is a low level businessman who says and ruthlessly wants to cash crisis. He doesn't have any scruples and without power he is zero.
With 300 odd churches burnt on May 3rd and 4th, here we are listening to a Hindu apologetic.
Shekhar sir came across as afraid to put the blame on BJP, and hence just included previous administrations in the mix too
He is one supplicant ‘journalist’ who doesn’t have the guts to hold the government or the PM accountable. This is the level of ‘journalism’ we have today in India unfortunately. His ‘fair and balanced’ approach is the play down transgressions of a downright evil government and include other entities in the mix to further dilute and deflect responsibility.
Pls also talk about Rape case in West bengal and above all Rajasthan is declared number 1 state in rape. Cases .and most of rape happening on Dalit women .Do u know yesterday Ashok ghelot removed his minister for telling truth about this report ..Instead of working on cause they removed that minister .No one talk because it is not BJP ruled state
@@kumark214Pls also talk about Rape case in West bengal and above all Rajasthan is declared number 1 state in rape. Cases .and most of rape happening on Dalit women .Do u know yesterday Ashok ghelot removed his minister for telling truth about this report ..Instead of working on cause they removed that minister .No one talk because it is not BJP ruled state
@@ratanshetty9870 hey troll, go somewhere else to spread your anti Indian whatabouttery nonsense.
@@ratanshetty9870 bye bye troll
One of the best explanations of Manipur situation so far. Any reasonable person capable of logical thinking can tell who is anti-national in Manipur. Keep telling the truth and be the voice of the voiceless minorities.
I would like to disagree. Yes you are right BJP plays divisive politics and it has caused and will cause further violence and divide the North East. But all BJP care is about winning elections. And they'll do anything. Of course CAA caused huge violence in Assam. And yet they did bag the Assam's SLA election pretty much without a fight. I call their ideology works. Mark my words they'll bag the next Manipur SLA too. People easily buy their divisive politics. Everyone with a shred of common sense knows the violence in Manipur is based on ethnicity. Yet BJP's IT cell added a communal angle too. Upcoming General Election is the only hurdle to their agenda.
If i'm cm in manipur I will resign before may 4th
Okay if you call kuki refugees, poppy planters, can we call meitei as meitei rapist?
Aggressors becomes victims.
Metis gave it back.
Abdul yr never at peace
@@vm3306 its the meitei what goes around comes around
@@vm3306 typical gaumutra savarkar bhakt spotted
@@peace2560
Then why are u the kukis crying
@@bhagwancapitalism1057 typical south pig snorting.🐷🐖
this so called politician should resign immediately...
If BJP is dividing communally then what about Congress , TMC and their joker fact cheekers who amplified religion of victims . Shekhar Ji you need better analysis .. can’t have cake and eat too .
Main issues are of illegal foreigners, Drug Mafia & last but not the least the Church.
Mind you there are no tribals in Northeast as we see in Chattisgarh or Jharkhand or MP. They are all developed English speaking folks.
🙏🙏
जय श्री कृष्णा
I am sure it is not a mere Kukki Meiti problem ; The incident in May is a consequence of serious issues ; I think Govt is caught up with more serious problems of Non-stop serious Arms Supplies to Kukkis , Drugs production and peddling , Influx from nearby country , External forces trying to isolate North East etc ; Current Govt had fairly reasonably built infrastructure, connected it to Bangladesh port etc ; Current Govt is instrumental in destroying 300 MUSD worth of Drug plants ; Our Army also played its part to control Collatrel public damages given the sensitivity of the area ; Blaming the current govt squarely is purely political; Of course in war , love and in politics anything is correct ;
Non-stop supplies of weapons? The Kuki militants are in talk with GOI under SoO. Unlike the Meitei terrorist who killed alot of Indian soldiers and wanted to be separate from Indian Union. About poppy the drug Lord a meitei politicians along with the CM is involved. Go and check google.
@@minatonamikaze6587 Google is not a reliable source of Information; My information is also from Videos in You tube ; My point is , What is the root cause and what is the solution ; Disturbance is really due to ethnic clash ??? Is it due to Drug peddling ?? Is it for isolating NE from mainstream by external forces for their land expansion ??? Is it purely political mileage ??? ( highly possible ) Why NE is always burning and sensitive ??? What type of leadership is needed ??? Is Army rule under president is the right choice ???
Toolkit in action
Journalists are anything but unbiased. You lost me when you opposed CAA.
So u are here to watch this video or only for comment?
Very good analysis.
Your reference to Cong ways are misplaced and unwarranted. Here we are talking about Modi government and state government. These two are squarely failed the Manipuris. They have been in power for long enough to undo what wrongs congress may have done. So lets call spade a spade. By comparing tge BJP with Cong, you are giving escape route to Modi ji.
Its him and him alone at whose door step, the buck stops.
Things that took generations/decades to form cannot be changed in a few years. As humans that is a high ask.
Useless analysis .sekarji u not doing justice.
I support Metis and they deserve their right for ST status, so back off
@@rch6956
Abdul go to Pakistan
@@vm3306 sanghi go back to ur island, this is not about religion but rather about peace and humanity
Awesome explanation about the history of militancy in the state. Clearly one size fits all did not work at the least not here.
That's why I like print only authentic new channel
Shame on you Shekhar for trying to monkey balance here. You should be asking tough incisive questions to the govt and not try to instead rationalise.
Ok then what does “CONGRESS PARTY” did for Manipur
just seeing by “SEE EAST” policy
There is many incidents where small Methai children killed, Adult male female extra , Before kuki started huge killing spree Methai mentioned to police that they already started violence before months ago. Majority of Methai villages wipe out where small kuki Rome army but NO NEWS because????????? There is many churches spreading videos images before this incident and promoting haterad but we are secular.