Manipur Violence 2023 | Why Law & Order is Missing?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 6 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 3,8 тис.

  • @langfeitravellers3051
    @langfeitravellers3051 Рік тому +2028

    I am from Manipur. She had done deep research before making her video. I really appreciate you for making this kind of video to make the people of India understand an important part of India.

    • @sishirbindu5335
      @sishirbindu5335 Рік тому +76

      Are people there safe now? Is everything normal? Prayers for all of you🙏

    • @langfeitravellers3051
      @langfeitravellers3051 Рік тому +44

      I hope it should be better. Thank you.

    • @_FinologyLegal
      @_FinologyLegal  Рік тому +264

      Thank you 🙏🏼 I hope you and your family are safe! 🙌

    • @gnam9924
      @gnam9924 Рік тому +194

      I'm a meitei who belong to the general category and I've so many friends who are the same. Please try to be clear when you post something so sensitive. A tribal scoring a 300/800 (ST loaded fam) in CUET got in a top tier college in DU while my brother, who scored a 690/800 barely got in a good college in DU. How in the world is this fair? Reservation needs to go.

    • @AyushSingh-c7c
      @AyushSingh-c7c Рік тому +44

      ​@@_FinologyLegalyou're ignoring one aspect, which is Christian Missionaries

  • @techtrails3863
    @techtrails3863 Рік тому +181

    I recently watched many videos on the Manipur violence and conflict between the ethnic groups. All the UA-cam creators have put in serious effort to study the situation and we really appreciate it and one suggestion from my side is that all the serious creators can discuss this situation on a single forum and try to find the solution for it and present it to the government which can be very helpful to unite our country and help Manipur.

    • @shams6271
      @shams6271 Рік тому +3

      Unite the country. Deep fissures is already present in current regime between various ethnic and religious groups in our country and you talk to unity. An ideal solution is not a solution at all.
      For uniting a country as big and as populous as ours, the political class needs to shun the religious and identity politics first, then after any solution can be put on table. Till then the fate of religious and ethnic minorities will be just like Tamilians in Sri Lanka Hindus in Pakistan and Afghanistan.😊😊😊

    • @questionnowho
      @questionnowho Рік тому +4

      The manipur clash took placed between the two tribal groups one is meitei another is kukie.Meitei has more than 2000 years old history in manipur their kings and ancestors once ruled the entire manipur . Mostly there are various religious people in meitei groups such as sanmahi , Buddhist,hindus and muslim also. kookies are Christian in majority and they have only 100 or 200 years history in manipur, record says that british helped them to sattle in manipur. The kookies get benifits of sc/ St reservation and they get facilities in government job they can buy land in entire manipur whether the meitei doesn't have any sc/St reservation even they can not buy their land in kookie's area. The conflict happens when meitei start demanding sc/St reservation for them and court also gave statement in favour of them. Some people highlighting this issue with religious angle whether the both group worship places being destroyed and women and children affected in this clash .
      And somebody portrayed this act as a hinduvta act then from which religion angle what should I say about the British and islamic invaders act ,what happened with girja tikko in kashmir what radical religion group act was that?
      Manipuri act is inhuman and gruesome and the ignorance of the central gov is totally shameful .
      But I have to say the western organization is hypocrite they become silent on various issues

  • @gyanitakeshari3621
    @gyanitakeshari3621 Рік тому

    Very efficiently simplified! Thank you!

  • @tushar4252
    @tushar4252 Рік тому +740

    There are only 2 UA-camrs whom I trust the most.
    1- Priya Jain ma'am
    2.- Nitish Rajput Sir
    I have no second doubt on the information the present as it is totally unbiased and true❤
    Thanku for doing such research and helping us understand things more beautifully with great depth

    • @NitishDiwakar
      @NitishDiwakar Рік тому +10

      You mistyped. Its Nitish Kumar Diwakar. ☺️

    • @snehal3358
      @snehal3358 Рік тому +2

      PZzzzzz

    • @suzainhaque7951
      @suzainhaque7951 Рік тому +75

      Search for soch by mohak

    • @rajanghumaan
      @rajanghumaan Рік тому +105

      Add Dhruv Rathee to the list ⚡🔥

    • @ashish345-m2t
      @ashish345-m2t Рік тому

      ​@@rajanghumaanvo aap party ka chamcha hai😂😂 wahi se dhruv ko funding milti hai😂😂

  • @anitasoans728
    @anitasoans728 Рік тому +193

    It is encouraging to see a few young youtubers like yourself, make sensible videos about situations or happenings in our country while most of the mainstream media have become tabloid journalist and clowns who have no ethics, no respect for journalism, do not even know how to conduct a decent debate on their shows.

    • @arpanConYT
      @arpanConYT Рік тому

      its not he faults of the anchors but those participants

    • @tusharikarawat
      @tusharikarawat Рік тому +1

      😅 0:39

    • @skj4210
      @skj4210 Рік тому

      &***India belonged to Dravidians, Dalits and Tribals before the Aryan invasion.The Aryans have enslaved and massacred millions of Indians to steal their land and wealth. The immoral, violent and greedy Aryan invaders from central Asia should leave India in peace, at least in the modern age.***&

    • @PhilavaKeishing
      @PhilavaKeishing 9 місяців тому

      She is not a normal UA-camr, she is a law experts.

  • @ruhitakhtar2696
    @ruhitakhtar2696 Рік тому +1

    Very informative detailed video.I appreciate your efforts😊

  • @Remy4556
    @Remy4556 Рік тому +370

    Honestly...people say that NE India is "The Paradise Unexplored"...but coming to ground reality, there is too much bitterness among all the 7 sisters and very high degree of political insurgency. Long negligence by the Central Govt led to this situation as of today ....I hope the Modi Govt looks into the matter instead of having State Dinner at the White House or enjoy Bastille Day celebration in Paris.
    142 innocent souls hv already lost their lives

    • @debashishchakrabarty7134
      @debashishchakrabarty7134 Рік тому +27

      Why blame Government of India and Modiji ? What were the local leaders doing?

    • @adnyat
      @adnyat Рік тому +23

      It's fair to say govt should pay attention which it is already paying.
      But should the Modi govt stop 'enjoying' all other 'work' and just focus on Manipur alone? Is that how you run a country?
      Have some maturity in understanding that there is difference in travelling for work and travelling on vacation. If the problem is complicated and deep rooted in several years the solution cannot be a quick fix.
      Even a CEO of a company can prioritize his work but can't stop all other activities and focus on just one thing for long time. That's the difference in an employee and a head of company/state.

    • @uranus5481
      @uranus5481 Рік тому +20

      @@adnyat Who elects the PM? The US? France? No, it's their own Indian people to look after the people of his governance. Just know Democracy is of the people, for the people and by the people. We know he's been doing such a great work for the upliftment of the country but your family is more important than your external works. Is it funny that around 142 people had lost their life but he hasn't mutter any word?? He spoke about Train incident, HP disaster but the problem in Manipur is already 70 days but he keep on silent. Be in the position of the victims you will know and feel the need of talk of the PM.

    • @adnyat
      @adnyat Рік тому +19

      @@uranus5481 I never knew that our PM goes to US, France to work for their citizens!
      You need to grow up buddy. At least think before you type.
      Law & order is a state subject. So your questions should be addressed to CM. PM can help on request but cannot intervene/act unless presidential rule is imposed. That's how our democracy is designed to work. A responsible person would never comment on any sensitive, complicated & burning issue, but will work on it quietly.
      One more thing. Are you aware of the recent riots in France? It did not stop them from inviting a PM of other country. This is something you need to understand. These are official visits, not personal visits. Both leaders understand what's important for their own nation. Just check the list of agreements signed in this visit.
      On a side note, you can ask an employee to work on one task dedicatedly. A CEO cannot take such liberty.

    • @adnyat
      @adnyat Рік тому +5

      @@ankddaas6570 Talking about seats and elections... As per your logic, BJP is foolish to invest so much in infrastructure development of NE. No seats right?
      I can agree if there are any facts, but not on your propaganda for sure.

  • @vishnutiwari962
    @vishnutiwari962 Рік тому +53

    Best video to understand what happen inside Manipur and what is the reason behind all these consequences 👍❤️

  • @sanjayp7100
    @sanjayp7100 Рік тому

    U r always loud and clear. Putting the subject after deep research.

  • @subratrai2878
    @subratrai2878 Рік тому +50

    I appreciate the amount of hard work and research behind this analytical information presented so beautifully.
    Great work ❤️

  • @veesaga9355
    @veesaga9355 Рік тому +75

    Thanks for covering the Manipur issue. But there are a lot of misinformation in this video. Some of which are:
    1. The clash is between Meiteis and Kukis, Nagas are not involved- which also proves its not about ST demand.
    2. The main issue is the termination of SoO agreement between the State government and the armed kuki militants. The State government withrew from it because the SoO millitants had broken ground rules of the agreement, like extortion of money from civilians and involvement in poppy trade.
    3. In case meiteis get ST demand, they would automatically give up OBC and SC- which most meiteis don't even have in the first place.
    4. The violence had started more than a month before May 3rd with the burning of reserved forests, forest offices, public property, open gym, etc by kuki millitants and radicals.

    • @carpediem6842
      @carpediem6842 Рік тому +18

      Woah woah, I think you for got to mention the Meitei militants too- the Arambai Tengol who has been wrecking havoc in the hill areas with the help of strippers Meirq Paibis

    • @brianmouses28
      @brianmouses28 Рік тому +1

      Our seva giving kuki sisters have strong moral lessons to teach us

    • @aldofhilter8833
      @aldofhilter8833 Рік тому +1

      I shared this news to my village in Myanmar , they were so touched that everyone destroyed their poppy farms and even Myanmar military junta renounced themselves to an ascetic . Thank you for such an eye opening knowledge 🌹

    • @nandakishworshagolshem5575
      @nandakishworshagolshem5575 9 місяців тому

      @@carpediem6842 that was later. The epicentre is kuki narco terrorist and illegal immigrants. Which the indigenous people raise a voice to stop poppy plantation and illegal immigrants.

    • @wanwan453
      @wanwan453 9 місяців тому

      If you spit up the sky, it will fall back on your face. That's what you got in return. Arambai Tengol are not militants they are people's movement​@@carpediem6842

  • @jaikishansmspl39
    @jaikishansmspl39 Рік тому

    Pretty good post with authentic content which most people do not know. Frankly, I too did not know about the restrictions in the purchase of land in the hill area.

  • @vinaybhadouriya
    @vinaybhadouriya Рік тому +230

    Actually my father is in CRPF so I'm little bit stressed. He is going for stopping that violence.😢❤

    • @Z.Nagami
      @Z.Nagami Рік тому +22

      God guide your father brother 🙏

    • @erwinsmith5796
      @erwinsmith5796 Рік тому +10

      ​@@Z.Nagamibeta agar God hote to inn logo ko bhi guide krte don't give false hope

    • @erwinsmith5796
      @erwinsmith5796 Рік тому +14

      Trust your father he will handle the situation very well

    • @deepaksingh-oz3rz
      @deepaksingh-oz3rz Рік тому +11

      Salute to your father for his noble action, hope ha is alright

    • @vinaybhadouriya
      @vinaybhadouriya Рік тому +2

      I also believe that

  • @nabeel9020
    @nabeel9020 Рік тому +226

    "No riot can continue for more than 24 hours unless the state wants it to continue" : Vibhuti N Rai IPS (In his book Shahar mein curfew)

    • @truthseeker2833
      @truthseeker2833 Рік тому

      propaganda ppl. Will hide it buddy

    • @truthseeker2833
      @truthseeker2833 Рік тому +17

      she didn't even care to mention the women of manipur and what has happened to them... n how absurd is the idea of cutting the Internet... n how NCW is a failure... what are the responsibilities of State Government and the centre in such a situation

    • @Chup-mh9hs
      @Chup-mh9hs Рік тому

      @@truthseeker2833
      She is modi sponsored , she doesnot care about those women. These people are evil from inside , they still believe in caste system

    • @apatil47
      @apatil47 Рік тому +9

      ​@@truthseeker2833Indian Army has taken control of state.. That's the best thing we can do as a country.. And only solution is to solve their reservation problem.. Other wise people will continue this.. Already 10+ years passed

    • @wonji5385
      @wonji5385 Рік тому +18

      kuki tribe's demands are illogical . nagas are stronger position in Nagaland. even they get ST status. Then why not Meiti.

  • @heli856
    @heli856 10 місяців тому +7

    Thank you so much di, I had manipur crisis as my ecnomics project in class 11th and this video helped me in making ways to solve the problem and your videos are easy to understand

  • @creativehub6068
    @creativehub6068 Рік тому +69

    The best explanation video of manipur crises ever seen with such interesting facts and visuals 🙌👏 Thank u for your great efforts ma'am ☺️❤️

    • @_FinologyLegal
      @_FinologyLegal  Рік тому +13

      🙏🙌❤️ Thank you so much!

    • @joyketanroy1008
      @joyketanroy1008 Рік тому +1

      ​@@_FinologyLegal❤

    • @vsmworld11
      @vsmworld11 Рік тому +1

      ​@@_FinologyLegalThamnail wali photo mein app bohot acchi lag rahi ho ❤😊😊

    • @tokitomuimui
      @tokitomuimui Рік тому +2

      West bangal violence par bhi toh kuch bolo 😢

    • @vkgk01
      @vkgk01 Рік тому

      ​@@vsmworld11sala tharki 😂😂

  • @SomShikhar
    @SomShikhar Рік тому +51

    🔥🔥Humble request Priya Ma'am🙏🏻🙏🏻 Please regularly make more such socio-political videos consistently 🙏🏻🙏🏻🥺🥺

    • @_FinologyLegal
      @_FinologyLegal  Рік тому +7

      🙌❤️👍

    • @tokitomuimui
      @tokitomuimui Рік тому +4

      West bangal violence par bhi toh kuch bolo😢

    • @gaurakshsinghi9219
      @gaurakshsinghi9219 Рік тому

      @@tokitomuimui ek na scale hota hai violence ka jiske according 9 par sri lanka jaise civil war ho sakta hai aur uss scale mein manipur 7 pe hai manipur ki situation index mein kaafi kharaab hai

  • @monikamakwana9663
    @monikamakwana9663 10 місяців тому +1

    Appreciable👍🥰

  • @lunalisapotsangbam5194
    @lunalisapotsangbam5194 Рік тому +32

    Thanks, ma'am for bringing up the complex issue of Manipur with such precision and crispness. I would add only two points: (i) the crux of the problem is the large-scale illegal Kuki immigrants from Myanmar over the period of time including armed militants, with which the Indian Govt has signed SoO agreement, due to which the Central Armed forces and the State Armed forces cannot attack or fire at these Kuki militants. (ii) The Myanmar-India border in Manipur is a porous border, which means no protection, no fencing, and hence free passage. Until the Govt suspends the SoO agreement and stops the heavily armed Kuki militants from killing more people, the situation is not going to change. As you rightly pointed out, there are hands of Foreign designs in this Manipur mayhem, where the violence has been used as a means to an end, where the end is a separate state for the Kukis. And once that materialises, we can well understand what is going to happen to India- you have already mentioned the Golden Triangle.

  • @superblaze9979
    @superblaze9979 Рік тому +20

    Thank you Ma'am as always no fabricated narratives, blame games but actual truths.

  • @omkar_gouda
    @omkar_gouda Рік тому

    The best understand i have seen ...i totalling love it the way u explain the matters❤❤

  • @kamilsayeed9867
    @kamilsayeed9867 Рік тому +4

    Excellent content... Thanks for making a video on this!

  • @user-bg5jp4kr8f
    @user-bg5jp4kr8f Рік тому +7

    Not essentially for buying lands at the hills (as the tendency of people is to come down at the valley) but more on safeguarding the lands left at the valley. The socio economic conditions of many households inside urban areas have become so bad that we are witnessing families selling off ancestral lands and shifting to other places due to financial constraints. We must stop seeing this situation as a "majoritarian" community lashing out to the minority but an indigenous community cry for help, rather the tears have dried up and turned into flames of frustration.

  • @RahulSingh-zz8gf
    @RahulSingh-zz8gf Рік тому

    A thorough and very detailed information. Thanks for your efforts.

  • @santosh.inaoba
    @santosh.inaoba Рік тому +80

    Thank you Priya ji for making such a beautiful, easily understandable by every sections of the society & unbiased video on Manipur issue. Really appreciate it.👍 My opinion goes to 2nd option of your list rather going for Brahmastra option😊.

    • @lunalisapotsangbam5194
      @lunalisapotsangbam5194 Рік тому

      Manipur is already under Article 355. The State govt is a mere puppet acting on behalf of the Union Govt. So its the Union Govt that has to act tough and take tough decisions for the welfare of the people of Manipur in particular, and for India in general. Because this issue cannot be looked at only as a State issue. If not tackled at this right time, it will have ramifications on our Country's security and integrity. Pls don't forget, China and the Burmese hand wrt the Golden Triangle!

  • @dnyaneshwarjadhav4315
    @dnyaneshwarjadhav4315 Рік тому +59

    Thanks for making this video....
    That helped me to understand with broader pov , solutions also will help me to write a content full essay 👍
    Thanks again 🙏
    Please bring more topics like that 💯

    • @_FinologyLegal
      @_FinologyLegal  Рік тому +3

      🙌💯!

    • @Blue.star1
      @Blue.star1 Рік тому

      @@_FinologyLegal Priyooo your hand came out of my screen @00:01 . You want solution ? Give Manipur back to British as Indians can't rule properly . Priyoo tell this to British

    • @AspirantKanishka
      @AspirantKanishka Рік тому +3

      @@_FinologyLegal dee ! One video on illegal immigration in India and how it is affecting the country.

    • @BABA-ORUC1761
      @BABA-ORUC1761 Рік тому

      ​@@_FinologyLegal Mrs Priya why didn't you mention the Gujarat massacre or all other riots were Hindutva goons massacred innocent civilians including women and children???
      Why this bigotry??
      Typical Brahmanical bigotry.

    • @Captaingamez-333
      @Captaingamez-333 Рік тому

      ​@@_FinologyLegal😂

  • @sharmalalit19
    @sharmalalit19 Рік тому

    Great info...your video qualities are improving day by day

  • @harshsoni9545
    @harshsoni9545 Рік тому +12

    Thanks for acquainting us with the actual veracity, really this information is praiseworthy , govt should look into from this perspective to mitigate and banish the crisis and turmoil of Manipur🙂

  • @shantiluke
    @shantiluke Рік тому +6

    I really appreciate the effort put on this video. Its well balanced and constructive.

  • @tanishashastri4789
    @tanishashastri4789 Рік тому

    the way you explain things is just amazing. Keep it up

  • @KanchanSingh-ep8dt
    @KanchanSingh-ep8dt Рік тому +20

    When our mainstream news channels are busy in spreading gossip like news, there are a few who inform n update us always. Thanks for your sincere efforts ❤

  • @dr.kamal.diwan89
    @dr.kamal.diwan89 Рік тому +14

    Excellent explained, hope Manipur gets normal soon.

  • @rajanroyyadav163
    @rajanroyyadav163 Рік тому

    An informative video which is explained in such a way that even an small boy can understand it easily.

  • @factbiz8425
    @factbiz8425 Рік тому +4

    This video literally deserves more views 😭

  • @MrHAPU-lp8eh
    @MrHAPU-lp8eh Рік тому +10

    Around 1-2% of total meiteis of 35 lakhs gets SC status, it's just for name sake. And those staying at rural areas and fall under below poverty line gets the OBC status which is around 50% rest are General category.

  • @karuna8145
    @karuna8145 Рік тому

    You explain the problems along with solution with given an optimistic point of view that everything will be fine very soon.

  • @sradhanjalimohapatra8680
    @sradhanjalimohapatra8680 Рік тому +13

    Nobody never discussed such a deep and important Matter in such simple words and relevant examples......... I don't have words to thank you mam... you are a great teacher indeed..... may God gives you more power and strength ❤

  • @chakpole6052
    @chakpole6052 Рік тому +6

    Hearty Congratulations ! Fantastic information ! Always ! Keep up the Excellent work ! Ms Priya Jain ! God Bless !

  • @123honest
    @123honest 7 місяців тому

    OMG ! This video is so so so good. Please continue making videos on such informative current affair issues.

  • @pallaviborse6323
    @pallaviborse6323 Рік тому +7

    You're a gem priya! I just hope all this suffering ends soon..

  • @sonalikisku6098
    @sonalikisku6098 Рік тому +10

    Honestly you have explained it so well ma'am. Including solutions. I totally agree with it and hope / pray that circumstances gets better in Manipur. More of these interesting/useful videos please ma'am. Thank you so much for such videos. ❤️😊

    • @sandhyamahapatra8883
      @sandhyamahapatra8883 Рік тому

      Separate council and alternative crop idea is better than last one . There have been imposing 10 times president rule but we all see violence is still continued. So rather than last one we need a long term solution. Thank u

  • @Bikoroma
    @Bikoroma 9 місяців тому

    Thanks Priya Jain, you have explained everything in such a short time.

  • @harshdeepsingh5427
    @harshdeepsingh5427 Рік тому +6

    Good to finally listen to someone speak about anything on UA-cam without random background music which totally affects your thought process.
    This style lets you form your own opinions regardless of the topic inline manipulation almost all creators do

  • @anupchanda7065
    @anupchanda7065 Рік тому +6

    Actually through this video she explains a full fledged UPSC question answer writing. Great job sister 🇮🇳

    • @lol311
      @lol311 Рік тому +1

      😂 Preparing UPSC exam from this UA-cam channel?
      It's good but for general viewers.
      bro you need better channels.

  • @rocks4889
    @rocks4889 Рік тому

    Thanku so much... You gave a broad and great explanation, listed all the issues going on there and the solutions too.. It was really a great Video..❤😊

  • @sharanjeetkaur4176
    @sharanjeetkaur4176 Рік тому +39

    Really appreciate your efforts... Keep posting such informative videos. Generally the media doesn't bring forth the real issues. Like you talked about drugs and poppy cultivation. This issue has not been highlighted much. Therefore narrowing down everyone's perception and these things are keeping everyone away from reality.

    • @1millionviews-gr1lr
      @1millionviews-gr1lr Рік тому +1

      Already been highlighted by some youtuber but not in depth ..

  • @nkurdhiman
    @nkurdhiman Рік тому +5

    Deep research and ideas. Thanks for the video.❤

  • @jananielango
    @jananielango Рік тому

    Sincere thanks for adding subtitles.

  • @karthikthota9238
    @karthikthota9238 Рік тому +5

    Please add the subtitles asap. Luv ur content❤

  • @lianshoute
    @lianshoute Рік тому +130

    It amuses me how outsiders have been able to simplify things just from their own perspective or only from the information they've been fed with, when in reality it has been so complex for the inhabitants. Then again, there is "ground reality" and "virtual reality" and both are never the same.

    • @kangkana5744
      @kangkana5744 Рік тому +5

      Agree.

    • @Potato-go4yf
      @Potato-go4yf Рік тому +17

      Can u explain the issue from your point of view or ground reality???
      I would like to know

    • @mntunglut3096
      @mntunglut3096 Рік тому

      Exactly 👍👍

    • @lunalisapotsangbam5194
      @lunalisapotsangbam5194 Рік тому +23

      If you wish you argue, first point out the alleged fact in her presentation, and bring on your argument. Prove that she is factually wrong in at least one point. Otherwise, you would amuse me

    • @monjyotiboro.
      @monjyotiboro. Рік тому +10

      Prove your point

  • @sanjaygarg386
    @sanjaygarg386 Рік тому

    Excellant info and superb presentation Priya .... keep it up ... Sanjay Garg

  • @Pooja-mh1pc
    @Pooja-mh1pc Рік тому +4

    Hope this issue gets solved..asap! Very informative

  • @sanjayshinde05
    @sanjayshinde05 Рік тому +4

    Now I understood the whole matter
    Your explanation is so simple and understandable ❤️❤️

  • @prinkalkikani3480
    @prinkalkikani3480 Рік тому +1

    You are simply awesome

  • @BameChandam
    @BameChandam Рік тому +39

    Thank u for putting up the video i am from manipur n abt that long term solution i have a opinion i.e To introduce northeast India history to our schooling syllabus coz most of the people form main land india doesn’t know about it n bcoz of that the decision makers doesn’t have much idea on northeast issues

    • @GODDARAJ
      @GODDARAJ Рік тому +3

      Agreed

    • @294darshitasrivastava4
      @294darshitasrivastava4 Рік тому +2

      Ya right maine bhi apne school time p jitna Mughals aur Britishers k bare m padha hai uska shayad hi 1% pure India k bare m puri book m kahin sahi s likha hoga 😅😶

    • @mrinalbiswas2280
      @mrinalbiswas2280 Рік тому +3

      I am from NE , I am all for including NE history in education but that is not going to solve the issue. The real reason for problems in NE are
      1. Divisive politics of local positions, which unfortunately all political parties has been keeping this alive, in the name of minority majority.
      2. India’s policy of reservation based on caste and tribe. I am all for affirmative action but not based on tribe/caste.
      3. Influence of Christianity in tribal areas they look at themselves different from Hindu/Buddhist.
      Long term solution - remove all special provisions, tribe , caste based special treatment. Let every citizen be same in the eye of rule of law. Yes, we should have welfare for the needy not based on tribe/caste.

    • @BameChandam
      @BameChandam Рік тому

      @@mrinalbiswas2280 i totally agree with u wt i was saying was its the first n most easy steps gov can take up

    • @ajitmishra8984
      @ajitmishra8984 Рік тому

      ​@@mrinalbiswas2280o

  • @akhil6095
    @akhil6095 Рік тому +8

    Please try to include English subtitles so that we can share the videos in our circles as well!

    • @lmaoidgaf
      @lmaoidgaf Рік тому +1

      English subtitles are present

    • @akhil6095
      @akhil6095 Рік тому

      ​@@lmaoidgafmaybe they have added recently
      Thanks for the update

  • @Aditya-zw6if
    @Aditya-zw6if 5 місяців тому

    This is an amazing video explaination and insight:)

  • @ajaygunjra8563
    @ajaygunjra8563 Рік тому +6

    I am your older subscriber, i am following you since 2019.
    I show lots of videos on Manipur violence but your video is very understandable and relatable.
    Thankyou for making wonderful video, I request you to making video on current related issues.
    🙏🙏🙏

  • @kayaeki
    @kayaeki Рік тому +4

    The information was so clearly conveyed without any biases, insane videos quality !

  • @chanchalgupta1683
    @chanchalgupta1683 Рік тому

    Appreciated your efforts for making this video

  • @sanjeevjboss
    @sanjeevjboss Рік тому +12

    Wonderful video! Depth, clarity, objectivity, finesse..and most importantly heart/conscience...it has it all! It's amazing to see the great content youngsters are coming up with amidst all the toxic tv news channels who are focused only on TRPs.

  • @shantisapam6390
    @shantisapam6390 Рік тому +22

    Very nicely covered in a very short duration. Well done Priyaji. Really enjoyed listening to you. Four factors for Manipur's present crisis are-Drug cartel, poppy cultivation clearing the reserve forest, illegal migraines, which the central govt should take seriously as it will be a national security problem. Other reasons like ST status demanded by Meities, seems and projected as the main reason for the clash, but it is not so. Buying land in the hills and settling by Meities, forming a village, is next to impossible if allowed also. Reasons are many for this. There is no religion angle is absolutely ruled out as some people are trying to bring religion. Anyway a very good video. Hats off

    • @shiroyasha_007
      @shiroyasha_007 Рік тому

      cWhat she forgot to mention that Meitei community already has 2/3 seats in terms of representation in the legislative assembly and even the CM is from the same community.

    • @bikksh2650
      @bikksh2650 Рік тому

      ​@@shiroyasha_007that's is base on limitation act and accordingly to population.Mizo are ST while they are majority by 80%

  • @barshad..musicalfountain359

    Your way of explanation is outstanding...😊❤

  • @vinitfirke2201
    @vinitfirke2201 Рік тому +84

    I second your solution on making a Union of North East states just like EU. Once the community leader debate with each other, an universal acceptable situation will be developed. Though it may take years, its possible.
    2. Making Union of North East states can give some kind of autonomy to those states and hence extremism may also be reduced to certain extent.

    • @tokitomuimui
      @tokitomuimui Рік тому +5

      West bangal violence par bhi toh kuch bolo😢

    • @meraj-ul-haque4883
      @meraj-ul-haque4883 Рік тому +4

      It will be worse brother once they get together they may start asking for independence

    • @vinitfirke2201
      @vinitfirke2201 Рік тому +3

      @@meraj-ul-haque4883 This possibility is what prevents Indian Leaders to make this decision. This and the loss of power from northeast politics.
      2. Coming to the independence question, only Nagaland is asking for independence. Other northeastern states are still under the control of the government. Extremism is there but minimal, then again you cannot completely eradicate it.
      3. If things like Manipur, and Mizo-Assam crash constantly happen and the government does nothing but enact the APSA act, then obviously people will lose their trust in government/governmental bodies.
      4. Best way is to provide them with some sort of autonomy by forming a union. Making a country is not a piece of cake. The leaders know that and with the union asking for independence will be reduced to certain extent.

    • @dota2freaks
      @dota2freaks Рік тому +6

      ​@@tokitomuimuido you know West bengal conflict is nothing compared to his recent Manipur situation there's is suspicions of external influence like China, Burma and Drug lords of golden triangle. West Bengal conflict is just for panchayat vote. But if Manipur breaks North East will break.

    • @lmaoidgaf
      @lmaoidgaf Рік тому +1

      ​@@dota2freaksexactly idk why its not as talked in mainstream media yet 😢
      Its been more than 3 months, still No President Rule, or even acknowledgement clearly, like its even not yet!!

  • @rajeshravindran
    @rajeshravindran Рік тому +13

    Very well explained, hope people get normalcy back soon

  • @mrigrajmmahanand8466
    @mrigrajmmahanand8466 Рік тому

    So simply explained. Thank you

  • @immuanding14
    @immuanding14 Рік тому +8

    A lot of people keep sharing the things they just saw without any research and that is also a very big problem

  • @jayantasharma9116
    @jayantasharma9116 Рік тому +4

    Thanks priya for giving a good and reliable information for the current situation of my state manipur and thanks again for being sensitive about the issue and not hurting the feelings of any community ,you are a gem.

  • @mamtajoseph3862
    @mamtajoseph3862 Рік тому

    Thank you for the detailed analysis.

  • @monishkambey
    @monishkambey Рік тому +10

    *Praying for Manipur*
    Love from *Arunachal Pradesh*

  • @akashroy800
    @akashroy800 Рік тому +108

    We need article 356 in Manipur .
    State government misguide and central government irresponsiblity 😅

    • @aviksarkarq4293
      @aviksarkarq4293 Рік тому +6

      What do you think might be the reason that central govt is not willing to enforce 356 in Manipur I dont see any loss of them in doing that

    • @mummy5490
      @mummy5490 Рік тому +17

      Yaa they will fight for reservation, poppy cultivation..but blame government..hadh hai

    • @im_Mokshita
      @im_Mokshita Рік тому +8

      Today the Meiteis have two major grievances one they feel their culture and language is under threat and second is they feel their state demography is changing too because of illegal kuki's migration frok myanmar ...The Meiteised say they feel besieged....so what their solution they want to be declared as Scheduled tribe , the kuki's as already in ST ..the way they want same designation now this would give them quotes in colleges nd in government jobs ...the kuki's say don't even think about it as he saw Meiteis were rulers they enjoyed political power...the kuki's ask why do they need reservation now all this brings us a present day pictures...

    • @rimy1233
      @rimy1233 Рік тому

      @@im_Mokshita provide st but ensure kukis are not deprived and tightened the borders to prevent myanmmar kukis from coming in. tho it would be complex

    • @akashroy800
      @akashroy800 Рік тому +7

      According to Indian Constitution .
      1. Every Citizen Have the fundamental rights to move and reside and settle any part of India .
      ( So maiti community people can't buy property in hilly areas , it is against their rights )
      2 . But Also their is another fundamental rights that - government can impose law for the development of sebc people .
      But make any law that is just , reasonable and valid ( That's why we need the phrase - Due process of law in article 21 ).
      For this maiti community people face Discrimination .
      Another problem is our media and irresponsiblity of the central government .
      They are busy in the conflict between ruling party vs ( Rahul Gandhi, kejriwal , Mamata Banerjee, shinde , nitis yadav )
      Govt. Should see the current situation on Manipur.
      .
      .
      .
      .
      Hope this conflict finish as soon as possible.
      We love every Maiti , Kuki ,Naga community people ♥️

  • @Jiteshormeitei
    @Jiteshormeitei Рік тому

    Love from Manipur❤ and may your channel grow more larger🎉

  • @ashishtiwari562
    @ashishtiwari562 Рік тому +4

    Dear mam
    A separate body called North Eastern council is already existing with Union Home minister as Chairman & precisely that body is there to address all issues that u have raised..The road ahead is to ensure effective functioning of that body 😊

  • @Sahinbola75
    @Sahinbola75 Рік тому +6

    Only when we are ready to see beyond our narrow communal mindset will we able to live harmoniously. As a Manipuri, I would urge everyone to work towards bringing development and peace so that everyone can have equal opportunities.

  • @rolishmoirangthem9440
    @rolishmoirangthem9440 8 місяців тому

    Thanks mem for creating such factual vdo,keep it up 👍

  • @rajsinghbais5106
    @rajsinghbais5106 Рік тому +4

    Why is nobody talking about Bengal 🤔 manipur is facing violence because of disputes between two communities but in case of Bengal it is purely done by a single party

    • @ankddaas6570
      @ankddaas6570 Рік тому +3

      It is nothing
      All panchayat elections in wb are same... All political parties are involved on it.... So no one will discuss about it... Every one knows about this

    • @AjayDas-xm8tb
      @AjayDas-xm8tb Рік тому +1

      ​@@ankddaas6570you are right

  • @sweetychingakham7191
    @sweetychingakham7191 Рік тому +24

    One point is missing here that is meitei community are considered as GENERAL CATEGORY only few are getting OBC and SC status

    • @theundisputed96310
      @theundisputed96310 Рік тому +2

      She will never talk about that she is a godi youtuber

    • @VishalMaurya
      @VishalMaurya Рік тому +2

      It doesn't mean you will start civil war

    • @johnortiz3649
      @johnortiz3649 Рік тому +2

      @@VishalMaurya we didnt start the war the kukis did

    • @VishalMaurya
      @VishalMaurya Рік тому

      @@johnortiz3649 that's I'm saying

    • @sweetychingakham7191
      @sweetychingakham7191 Рік тому +1

      @@VishalMaurya If you don't know the complete story then try to know it first. We meiteis never started the war and never attack them we are just defending our own village, our people that's it till now. It's been more than 78 days the violence broke out, more than 200 people are murdered, many villages, temples are burnt by illegal kuki immigrants and now they are playing victim card as other mainland India's people started knowing the truth.

  • @chandankalita4169
    @chandankalita4169 Рік тому

    All at a Glance, very precise

  • @SD-oe6vv
    @SD-oe6vv Рік тому +11

    BJP minister met top UA-camrs and she could be one of them, from now on in every video she will defend BJP for any crime they committed. BeerBicep is taking it to another level.

    • @DarkMasterEdits-Mashups
      @DarkMasterEdits-Mashups Рік тому

      Why beerbicep???

    • @mka2032
      @mka2032 Рік тому

      Is there any organization whi decides who is partial and impartial
      I think you are that organization 😂

  • @bishnupriya9848
    @bishnupriya9848 Рік тому +7

    Kuki communities are outsiders, but they enjoy reservation and land rights. Meiteis are original habitants but they are the most deprived in their own state.

    • @sunflower46309
      @sunflower46309 Рік тому

      Biren number follower

    • @MrSubtleEdn
      @MrSubtleEdn Рік тому

      Your so called outsiders/refugees words have been heard constantly since dishonourable cm biren singh came to power. It is a newly used words by the meiteis. Your fabricated documentation won't change the identities of the indigenous tribals like kuki_zo.
      Have you seen the tweet of your leader, Pramod singh? Citing the kuki_zo as outsiders, many of their politicians are on sale, let's buy them, let's create a fake document and called them refugees, when their intellectuals are silent and their people are sleeping, someday they will get confused, let's annahilate them, this and that etc. We the kuki_zo are not as dumb as your leaders think. Pity on you. You exposed your pompous ego everywhere when you are easily brainwashed by your leaders. Shame on you all. Ask the history of the kuki-zo to your grandfathers above 70+ yrs they will tell you the truth that kukis have been living since ancestral times, not your new greedy leaders who simply want to destroy the bonds between the two communities through fake documents. Shame on you for your greed and ignorance.

    • @MrSubtleEdn
      @MrSubtleEdn Рік тому

      The saddest thing is, the meitei itself believes in the fake documents and allegations made by their leaders, if not peace would have prevailed in the state. Sowing the seeds of enmity to their people leads to this violence as it has bore fruits. I am a man, I will stand adamant with my viewpoint as long as the sky is blue, not like mud which can be shaped and changed to any desired shape as the potter pleases. Shame on you for you have been brainwashed and hypnotized. Wake up from your slumber and start embracing the fact, truth and history. History cannot be changed no matter how one tries. 😢

    • @MrSubtleEdn
      @MrSubtleEdn Рік тому

      So sorry that you've been incorrigibly manipulated by your greedy leaders.
      You can buy our politicians but not the people, identity and history, pity on you 😢

    • @sunflower46309
      @sunflower46309 Рік тому

      @@MrSubtleEdn I mean you people have leaders like pramot singh who's the most dumbest person upto date. Funny how you're being the one incorrigibly manipulated by your politicians especially when you have a cm who the queen of dramas and a cm who slept with his concubine younger sister. You can't change what you're people have done too. Pity on you tch2 especially for having leaders like pramot singh

  • @chintanvora4447
    @chintanvora4447 Рік тому

    Explained very nicely and to the point

  • @VishalVarma_14
    @VishalVarma_14 Рік тому +4

    I'm CA student but love to watch your videos di.

  • @pralaymanna7300
    @pralaymanna7300 Рік тому +8

    The issue can be solved easily if the government construct different states for them.

    • @Z.Nagami
      @Z.Nagami Рік тому +1

      The only option to solution

  • @nsarkar80
    @nsarkar80 Рік тому

    thanks for such really informative and comprehensive discussion on this very important issue

  • @prernarawat528
    @prernarawat528 Рік тому +8

    Somehow Meitis are right Being in majority they have only 10% land of state . If Kukis can buy land in vallery then why not meitis . . Atleast land acquistion should be allowed .Also meitis have right to preserve their culture . Noone against the upliftment of kukis but we cant ignore keitis concern because they are in better position.

    • @sunflower46309
      @sunflower46309 Рік тому

      Meiteis with SC, OBC already in their power, they're the most developing community in Imphal, Manipur. The 10% land was divided during the British rule hence they have the 10% rule. In villages like Kangpokpi and Churachanpur they have lands and buildings there. On May 3rd when we were about to go on our rally they initiated a counter rally where they were against us, we didn't say anything but when we went ahead with our rally which was supposed to be peaceful, they burnt our Kuki centenary Gate which is a commemoration for the Anglo Kuki war. They then chased our people out of Imphal brutally raped our woman burnt our people alive, shot a old women in church and they clamied she was a terrorist which was lies bc I knew that old lady ever since I was young, they beheaded our brother David and the list goes on

    • @sunflower46309
      @sunflower46309 Рік тому

      Not only that their so called arambai tengols "freedom fighters" guided meiteis to steal from the Kuki people. Note this: Kuki people have left behind everything, every single hardwork they've been saving up for years. They then went ahead to burn our churches and houses. They beheaded an innocent man. They say they want peace but can't stop sending people to villages where kuki people are taking refuge in and then they blame us again when we protect ourselves again. The chanting of "Kill Kukis" still rings in my head till this day

  • @aryansingh6236
    @aryansingh6236 Рік тому +6

    I think through power sharing method problem can be sort out and that can be done by providing a platform for leaders of all communities to come up with their problems and solutions.

  • @JyotiSharma-wx6hi
    @JyotiSharma-wx6hi Рік тому

    Your explanations are mind-blowing 🤘🤘❤️

  • @rkhmar5723
    @rkhmar5723 Рік тому +8

    mam, your information on internet connectivity is wrong. Connectivity is available Only valley areas of Manipur not in hills areas. That is the reason why you can see so many false informations being given in the social media about the tribals of Manipur and it is being deliberately done even in your youtube channel in the comment section.

  • @antikukiBirensingh
    @antikukiBirensingh Рік тому +5

    Manipur voilence is defined as ethnic cleansing against minority kuki by majority meitei community ....

  • @sakshigupta7054
    @sakshigupta7054 Рік тому

    thnk uh soo mch mam.... i was searching fr a detailed article fr my answer writing on manipur incidence... and i got ur video will scrolling... and seriously glad to see this... my half of the problem is solved... thnk uh soo mch mam🙏

  • @somorjitthongam5212
    @somorjitthongam5212 Рік тому +4

    Three questions to admin:
    Why is Honorable PM silent?
    After due consideration of all views, do our demands, being myself from Meitei community as well, be treated as unlawful?
    I am a soldier of Indian Army. I come to know that even the Rapid Acton Forces (RAF) team & Assam Rifles do not protect Meitei Community. They even attack Meitei people. What is your opinion in this scenario?

  • @rakeshdeka3497
    @rakeshdeka3497 Рік тому +22

    Half taught history gives different opinions.Kindly do learn about Kukis and their origination and how even after being settled and given land to live in they still need more and also the orginal inhabitants Meities are being always discarded.Not only about Meities but in rest of North-East there are many such problems with different indigenous communities due to illegal migration which was supported by govts only for vote bank.Its jst a ticking bomb down here.

    • @sarikachaudhury1756
      @sarikachaudhury1756 Рік тому

    • @haokip3408
      @haokip3408 Рік тому +1

      Hi bro who give land to the kuki???? Meitei are in valley and kuki are in hills. No meitei Or any other given to kuki... That their land... Pls without knowing don't spread lies

    • @rakeshdeka3497
      @rakeshdeka3497 Рік тому +2

      @@haokip3408 can any Indian go to Myanmar and claim 90% of its land and also have the right to keep that land in such a way that people of Myanmar can't even buy those 90% land?Also it is not only about land but also resources and jobs as Kukis get better job opportunities just for being ST and when even Supreme Court gives ST to Maiteis than what can be the reason for such outrage against them?I do condemn the fate of those two Kuki ladies and even ask govt to take strict actions against such hinious crime but it doesn't mean all those illegal immigrants gets all the facilities in whole of North-East.Its the only reason i have started liking AAP govt of Delhi coz it has done the same thing Delhi has been doing to us North-East people for 75 yrs and turning delhi into a illegal bangladeshi hub coz pain is only felt when one's own body gets hurt.

    • @haokip3408
      @haokip3408 Рік тому +1

      @@rakeshdeka3497 what do you mean???

    • @adoringfan6995
      @adoringfan6995 Рік тому

      Meities are war criminals.

  • @chandanpandey2290
    @chandanpandey2290 Рік тому

    Hat's off to you ma'am...aap ne full doubt clear kr deya aap ne...

  • @clintonfair8920
    @clintonfair8920 Рік тому +3

    Recession is most likely the result of an external factor. For the first time in decades, the United States is losing its clout as a federal reserve currency. They don't have any more economies to use to control inflation, and less money is being spent on stock and oil trading than in the past. They all lend support to the idea that a new multilateral world order is in the works.

    • @admln1350
      @admln1350 Рік тому

      Keep this in the back of your mind. There are good days and bad days. It's a zero-sum game, but keep this advice in mind: spend wisely, invest wisely, and diversify your holdings so that when one performs poorly, the others do as well. This can be accomplished by hiring a knowledgeable specialist whose platform provides a wide range of investment options. By doing so, you leave little room for regrets and may even gain more.

    • @victorandrade8980
      @victorandrade8980 Рік тому

      @@admln1350 Nobody knows anything; You need to create your own process, manage risk, and stick to the plan, through thick or thin, While also continuously learning from mistakes and improving

  • @rajanghumaan
    @rajanghumaan Рік тому +4

    Meiteis should be given the right to purchase land in hilly areas, it is completely unfair that their population is higher and they have the limited land, and also the other communities can purchase land in their areas, the Idea of reservation is the main issue everywhere in the country, Dr. Ambedkar gave this idea just for 10 years after the commencement of the constitution but now, after every 10 years the Central govt passes an amendment and increase the reservation for 10 years more, this has become a convention, no political party can stop this reservation now for the sake of their vote bank, it's a Pathetic Condition for General people to live here. 🙏

    • @vinayak1855
      @vinayak1855 Рік тому

      Isliye bjp govt sabko equality dena chahati hai including meities aur sab log sirf modi ko blame karte hai

  • @saikatdas8235
    @saikatdas8235 Рік тому

    Wow. Kya bat. Love ur thoughts, Sister. U right ly explore the issue.

  • @seikho89
    @seikho89 Рік тому +9

    problems of immigration ( Assam) and drugs (Punjab) are present in other states , any state government has enough means to deal with it. the only difference in manipur is that.. the state government along with the valley dwelling people have used the excuse/opportunity of drugs, immigration and false data to seize the lands and rights of hills people.

    • @drpop_25
      @drpop_25 Рік тому +4

      Both immigration issues and drug issue is happening in Manipur

  • @aloo872
    @aloo872 Рік тому +4

    Come to Bengal..murder and violence is such a normal thing over here...that even media dosent cover it these days..

  • @vaibhavmane4802
    @vaibhavmane4802 Рік тому

    Very nice explanation 🎉🎉🎉
    Thank you very much 😊

  • @bkfariste
    @bkfariste Рік тому

    Beautifully explained di