River Song's timeline 2016 version

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 1 січ 2016
  • As the Doctor said, we need a bigger flow chart!!
    sottotitoli in italiano ^^
    ..
    1- I DID NOT make up the order of the timeline... I took it from the BBC OFFICIAL VERSION, from 6x13 Confidential, it's exactly the same. I just added The Time of The Doctor, The Husbands of River Song, First Night and The Angels Take Manhattan.
    2- I didn't add Rain Gods and Last Night because we don't know when they are set for River.
    3- There isn't Melody's regeneration, but I added an annotation, it's the best I can do... sorry, I won't take down the video
    ... and THANK YOU guys! I don't deserve all your kind words ❤❤❤
    ****
    DISCLAIMER: All the clips are from BBC Doctor Who, and so are the soundtracks. I do not own any materal used in this video. All copyrights go to respectful owners. (c) I dont own anything just the editing (: Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use
  • Розваги

КОМЕНТАРІ • 1,3 тис.

  • @appleoutlaw
    @appleoutlaw  7 років тому +262

    The episode from 5:21 to 5:46 is a mini-episode, First Night.
    It's set during River's first night in Stormcage :D
    0:00 - 1:00 - 6x07
    1:00 - 1:10 - 6x01
    1:10 - 3:57 - 6x08
    3:58 - 4:12 - 6x12
    4:13 - 5:20 - 6x13
    5:21 - 5:46 - First Night
    5:47 - 6:28 - 6x07
    6:29 - 7:08 - 6x07
    7:08 - 8:12 - 6x01
    8:13 - 8:54 - 6x02
    8:55 - 9:37 - 5x12/5x13
    9:38 - 10:34 - 5x04/5x05
    10:35 - 11:11 - 6x13
    11:12 - 12:40 - 7x05
    12:41 - 14:11 - The Husbands of River Song
    14:12 - 16:54 - 4x08/4x09
    16:55 - 18:34 - 7x13

    • @aravchubsbaba
      @aravchubsbaba 4 роки тому +3

      apple outlaw you skipped melody’s first regeneration

    • @delbrown9223
      @delbrown9223 4 роки тому +2

      apple outlaw do you mean 14:04 4x8/4x9 of river song

    • @silvertongue1144
      @silvertongue1144 4 роки тому +1

      thank you

    • @mollycblaeser
      @mollycblaeser Рік тому

      OMG THANK YOU! Despite not watching Doctor Who, I have now fallen in love with River Song & want to buy all her episodes.

  • @ZDPONE
    @ZDPONE 7 років тому +1196

    I actually met her last year at DragonCon. I dressed as the 11th Doctor and when I got to her table I yelled out "RIVER!" And then she yelled out "Husband!!!" Best day of my life!!! Lol then she asked if I had suspenders. I showed her and then nearly lost my eye as she pulled one of em and it popped off! Then Rory (who was there at an adjacent table) called out "Headline: River Song blinds fan!"
    Best day of my life!!!

    • @appleoutlaw
      @appleoutlaw  7 років тому +67

      ZDdoesMC XD She looks like an amazing and very funny person!! I so want to meet her 😍

    • @ZDPONE
      @ZDPONE 7 років тому +30

      Oh yeah. She's very funny XD

    • @PolyBiBadger
      @PolyBiBadger 6 років тому +5

      ZD That’s amazing!

    • @btvsfan07
      @btvsfan07 5 років тому +76

      I thought I was prepared to meet her, I thought I had composed myself and wouldn’t fanboy... but damnit the second it was my turn to meet her, she whipped her head directly at me after taking a drink of coffee, looked me dead in the eye, and said “Hello Sweetie”....
      I instantly turned into a blithering idiot. She laughed, I laughed, she signed a photo for me and a photo for my cousin (I nabbed one for her as a Christmas present, and she totally cried when I gave it to her), then she gave me the sweetest hug. Alex Kingston is a treasure.

    • @DragonsRule06
      @DragonsRule06 5 років тому +20

      Fangirling/boying is an unstoppable force.

  • @peteratanassov9088
    @peteratanassov9088 8 років тому +1379

    Say what you will about Moffat, but this is hands down the best time-travel love story EVER written!

    • @YeahItzLA
      @YeahItzLA 8 років тому +16

      +Merlin nd u made a stupid comment

    • @smidget5843
      @smidget5843 8 років тому +15

      +Merlin moffat hasnt been great but some of his stuff has been fantastic. capaldis storys have literally all been shite apart from the two davros episodes

    • @HomelessSoldierMan
      @HomelessSoldierMan 8 років тому +9

      +smidget whittington rivers husbands was nice

    • @smidget5843
      @smidget5843 8 років тому

      Homeless Soldier yeah that was good.

    • @smidget5843
      @smidget5843 8 років тому +3

      ***** disagree completely.

  • @isaacwoodward5338
    @isaacwoodward5338 7 років тому +718

    Who thinks watching the river death scene is more tragic now that they had future episodes together

    • @TheDeathbladeRs
      @TheDeathbladeRs 7 років тому +73

      Literally everyone, which is why we searched for this in the first place, probably.

    • @amyclarke41
      @amyclarke41 7 років тому +2

      Isaac Woodward aww

    • @dragonforce2724
      @dragonforce2724 5 років тому +6

      im not crying you are crying

    • @cardsfanboy
      @cardsfanboy 4 роки тому +4

      absolutely... that scene resonates so much more powerfully now than it did at the time... these videos of the timeline of River Song do her so much more justice than the bits and pieces we get of the character. This would be a decent made for TV movie if they expand it out to two hours, add in a few non-doctor who moments etc.

  • @StormageddonTMS
    @StormageddonTMS 7 років тому +559

    "Time can be rewritten"
    "Not those times, not one line, don't you dare"
    Best lines of river song

    • @maggierowland9914
      @maggierowland9914 6 років тому +25

      Stormageddon do u notice how in Matt smiths last scene when he regenerate he says he won’t forget ‘one line’

    • @ronruddick2972
      @ronruddick2972 5 років тому +4

      Some people have a bad habit of forgetting things...

    • @renenk4824
      @renenk4824 4 роки тому +1

      Really did make me tear up

  • @Matilda127
    @Matilda127 8 років тому +921

    and suddenly the words ÿou turned up on my doorstep with a haircut and a new suit" hurts so much more

    • @TheFounderUtopia
      @TheFounderUtopia 7 років тому +111

      I like how in retrospect we can see that she considers the Tardis to be her doorstep. XD

    • @Stephen._.Chapman
      @Stephen._.Chapman 7 років тому +34

      I think she means king Hydroflax's ship at the start of last year's Christmas special.

    • @amblehhh
      @amblehhh 7 років тому +33

      CheesyMeat ikr. i like how the 12th connected all the way to the 10th. 9 yaers away😂

    • @munc90
      @munc90 7 років тому +15

      Abbeh_ Amberh for doctor it was 5 billion years.

    • @amblehhh
      @amblehhh 7 років тому +2

      Hahahaha ikr!

  • @GrahamDianaty
    @GrahamDianaty 8 років тому +367

    Mother of god, the fact that the writer team did this backwards. On purpose. Damn.

  • @avineshwadhwa
    @avineshwadhwa 7 років тому +386

    River "Of course I am his wife." Amy continues " yea and I am his ....... MOTHER-IN-LAW"
    That gets me everytime!!!!

    • @bemasaberwyn55
      @bemasaberwyn55 4 роки тому +6

      I love River's delivery of I think mummy might need another drink

  • @mirandalyndeegaming3303
    @mirandalyndeegaming3303 8 років тому +439

    I can't even imagine how hard it would be to truly love someone and then see them have no idea who you are...

    • @tonijlynch8724
      @tonijlynch8724 7 років тому +35

      It's comparable to loving someone with Alzheimer's Disease. The older she got , the more he forgot her :(

    • @krashbarber5552
      @krashbarber5552 6 років тому +2

      Toni Lynch-Bradish no it's the younger he is

    • @rebekahlucas9835
      @rebekahlucas9835 4 роки тому +4

      JoBeCrazy which in turn means the older she is since they meet in reverse?

  • @kikie0413
    @kikie0413 7 років тому +165

    I like how in the Christmas special she was begging him to find a way to change time, but in the Library he was like "time can be rewritten" and she was like " not those time, not one line don't you dare" because she finally got her happy ending with the Doctor, 24 years worth of it.

    • @austinkenway9079
      @austinkenway9079 4 роки тому +21

      It is also explains why 12 didn't try to save her, coz she already convinced him not to, all those years ago in the library when he was 10, and he knew he technically saved her anyway.

  • @thewolfpack7009
    @thewolfpack7009 7 років тому +306

    River needs a spin off show all about her adventures before she died.

    • @appleoutlaw
      @appleoutlaw  7 років тому +10

      The Wolf pack agreed XD

    • @meowmeow6676
      @meowmeow6676 4 роки тому +9

      Big Finish is a thing, y'know

    • @sleepynic8376
      @sleepynic8376 4 роки тому +4

      She have one but it's only audio

    • @julieeverett7442
      @julieeverett7442 4 роки тому +4

      I want to see 12th come back and their night on derilium (that lasted 24 years!)

    • @julieeverett7442
      @julieeverett7442 4 роки тому +3

      @@sleepynic8376 meeting up with all the doctors, 7th was a hoot!

  • @aprilr4418
    @aprilr4418 8 років тому +697

    It's alright, I didn't need my heart anyways.

    • @cryptlord99
      @cryptlord99 8 років тому +32

      Timelords have two anyway ;D

    • @rainbowsam2335
      @rainbowsam2335 8 років тому

      +Grell Sutcliff Why you do this to me with that name and pic?!?!

    • @the_cyber_dalek1143
      @the_cyber_dalek1143 7 років тому +1

      Grell Sutcliff i still got on ;)

    • @TimeLords910
      @TimeLords910 7 років тому +1

      Grell Sutcliff 2herats

  • @TheAmericanDragn
    @TheAmericanDragn 8 років тому +705

    River Song is one of my favorite characters in Doctor Who.
    That being said, if we never see her again in the series, I'd be okay with that. The Husbands of River Song finally concluded her story arc by the Doctor giving her the Sonic Screwdriver and I can now rest easy since that finally happened. :)

    • @ValpasKankaristo
      @ValpasKankaristo 8 років тому +3

      Agreed

    • @landfish7a
      @landfish7a 8 років тому +27

      +James Justus I think the ending left it open for her to come back if they really wanted to, as she could potentially reappear as long as it's at some point during her last 24 year night. On that note, I'd be happy either way, I love her character and I think it'd be great fun to have her back but this was quite the perfect ending.

    • @Phoenix-bi9bn
      @Phoenix-bi9bn 8 років тому +5

      +James Justus Same. She was ok but overrated for me. All I wanted was to see the first or last meeting and the sonic and I was happy for her character to be done with after that

    • @boringperson-zb8vy
      @boringperson-zb8vy 8 років тому +10

      She does have the chance to come back, but the problem there is that she told Ten that "The last time I saw you was on Darilium". Unless of course, we see a past version of her.

    • @ValpasKankaristo
      @ValpasKankaristo 8 років тому +9

      ***** But then the Doctor can't tell her Who he is.
      *Unless*...
      The Doctor regenerates into a face he has already used once. Hence the rumors of Smith returning.
      Mind = Blown

  • @barbarahala3925
    @barbarahala3925 7 років тому +177

    When you first see Silence in the Library, and Forest of the Dead you see it through the Eyes of the Doctor and that you get a hint of what their story was, and you felt the sadness but when you watch all of Rivers stories through out the series and then watch those two episodes again, your watching it though River's eye and your heartbreaks even more.

  • @prettylikeusual
    @prettylikeusual 8 років тому +335

    It's cool how River knew everything while we didn't, and they actually made everything she said come true. Even the screw driver part

    • @jessicalandrey8421
      @jessicalandrey8421 8 років тому +23

      It's so cool! And even cooler watching the series over again knowing what she knows!

    • @amandaostman8481
      @amandaostman8481 7 років тому +7

      Jordy Peach There's a clever man behind this.

    • @karyth09
      @karyth09 7 років тому +4

      I am just waiting for her to make her reappearance, cause we haven't seen where and when the Doctor tells her his name. Uhu x3 and when she introduces him to handcuff.

    • @tideoftime
      @tideoftime 7 років тому +10

      We'll likely never see River again -- her meeting with 12 is truly the "knot that ties the string" of their temporal interactions: she didn't recognize him, which meant she had no previous interactions with his (or later) incarnation(s), and he knows that their "date" (a 24 year-long relationship/marriage) is the last time that *he* will see "her* in his personal timeline. Moffat has pretty much wrapped up River's storyline. (She can, of course, re-appear a la' some anniversary special wherein things are done for the sake of getting some people back together, but that, too, is unlikely.) She referenced his telling her his name in TNotD, and that essentially relegates it to an off-screen occurrence (as is the case with most of their referenced interactions -- we only get a handful of "future hints" that play out onscreen, with most such references never occurring but left to the viewers' imaginations... as it should be... ;) ).

    • @markrawls129
      @markrawls129 7 років тому +6

      he tells her as part of the wedding ceramony

  • @JennieKerfuffle
    @JennieKerfuffle 8 років тому +260

    God, this is the most heartbreaking relationship to ever exist in the universe. Could you imagine living a life in which the love of your life as you know them gradually fades away from you, then finally doesn't know you at all? And then you realize that they've known when and where you were going to die the entire time they knew you. Ugh if I had two hearts they'd both be breaking.

    • @TheMoonRover
      @TheMoonRover 7 років тому +8

      Have you read The Time Traveller's Wife? It's a very similar idea and is where Steven Moffat got the idea from.

    • @shahanibraga7498
      @shahanibraga7498 4 роки тому +5

      Still a better ship than the abomination that is Doctor/Rose lol.

  • @ScsigsGaming
    @ScsigsGaming 8 років тому +353

    Why do I have the feeling they might do a DVD & Blu-Ray compilation of these episodes in chronological, from River's perspective, for those that actually like this relationship.

    • @craigkirk89
      @craigkirk89 8 років тому +51

      I would buy that. I would love to watch from rivers viewpoint

    • @craigkirk89
      @craigkirk89 8 років тому +11

      I would buy that. I would love to watch from rivers viewpoint

    • @Normabd
      @Normabd 8 років тому +4

      +Captain Kirk I would also!

    • @homeschoolingrules1
      @homeschoolingrules1 8 років тому +3

      +Scsigs G (ScsigsGaming) That would be awesome! Although, some of the season 6 episodes would be repeats with adult River and young Melody.

    • @ScsigsGaming
      @ScsigsGaming 8 років тому +1

      Not really. Once they're there once, they don't need to be repeated.

  • @nzrockboi
    @nzrockboi 8 років тому +148

    Husbands of River Song was Extremely satisfying, what I'd been looking forward to since the Library. The final date was almost exactly as I had imagined for close on 8 years. An older, calmer Doctor to Tennant. The screwdriver gift. The twilight romance viewing the towers. I had even pictured fairy lights everywhere, but mostly in the night sky. All of it was there. And how great were Twelve and River together!!

  • @HeidiGriffin1216
    @HeidiGriffin1216 8 років тому +101

    That part that's just before a Good Man Goes to War, the way River reacts to seeing Rory again, makes me believe that for her it's just after Angels Take Manhattan. Because, she's seeing her father again, after she just saw him die.

  • @nikkicat254
    @nikkicat254 7 років тому +339

    With all the great characters Doctor Who has had over the years, including classic Who, to me, River Song was the greatest! Because of how they managed to entwine her in so many different stories, and create this unique mythology around her, that in the end actually made sense! I hope we get to see some more of her with the present Doctor! Of course I admit, part of what made her so good was who played her, Alex Kingston played her so wonderfully and with such sass and class at the same time, I can't imagine anyone else ever playing her! I still wish they would give her, her own series! Even a limited series would be wonderful!

    • @solunaqua3475
      @solunaqua3475 7 років тому +5

      Clara Johnson Like 'Sarah Jane Adventures' and 'Torchwood'!

    • @sarahsaharasarah2015
      @sarahsaharasarah2015 7 років тому +26

      Clara Johnson I really want a mini serie about the time of darilium .

    • @PepalaPow23
      @PepalaPow23 7 років тому +9

      I'd like a really kick arse animated series like the one off done during the 10's run voiced by Alex & which ever Doctor they choose.
      Something that could show just what a bad-arse she really was. I want to know what she did to make the Darlek beg for mercy. I mean, she made a DARLEK beg her for MERCY!! That's got to be some bad-arse story lines there!
      Oh & my other favourite River line:
      11th: I saw Cleopatra
      River: She mentioned you
      11th: What did she say?
      River: Put down that gun
      11th: Did you?
      River: Eventually
      Professor River Song, BAD-ARSE!

  • @BJ_Freeplay
    @BJ_Freeplay 7 років тому +119

    And now thinking back... When she sees ten, I mean, oh man. That hurts so badly now

  • @potat04
    @potat04 8 років тому +206

    I LOVE RIVER'S HAIR SO MUCH

  • @samcollins5655
    @samcollins5655 7 років тому +15

    "Hello Sweetie"
    "Get out"
    Ruthless, David Tennant. Absolutely ruthless.

  • @lisah4021
    @lisah4021 8 років тому +107

    Hello Sweetie.
    Goodbye Sweetie.
    Don't mind me crying over here :,(

  • @theredwolf101
    @theredwolf101 8 років тому +52

    oh my goodness I don't know how I didn't realize this before, her first words to the Doctor were "Hello Sweetie" and the last, when she's jus t a projection from the library through clara, are "goodbye sweetie" I am so not okay :'(

  • @alisynz4836
    @alisynz4836 8 років тому +433

    you forgot the part where she regenerated in the allyway as a little kid.

  • @rainbowsam2335
    @rainbowsam2335 8 років тому +384

    no matter how many times I watch it, I still cry at Angels Take Manhattan

    • @CareyHAuthor
      @CareyHAuthor 8 років тому +15

      I know! Amy and Rory are my favorite companions. I even want to name my daughter Amelia if I have one.

    • @rainbowsam2335
      @rainbowsam2335 7 років тому +5

      NerdWriterGirl1984 same. The main character in one of the books I'm writing is named Amelia, she's part Scottish, and she has red hair. Totally not based off of Amelia Pond at all

    • @CareyHAuthor
      @CareyHAuthor 7 років тому +2

      ThaChristianGirl Sam Haha, in my book, my main character's grandmother is Scottish and used to have red hair. I'll admit, she's what I think Amy Pond would be like in her 80s. Still spunky and snarky. I love writing for her. I want to get more into her backstory further on in the series.

    • @rainbowsam2335
      @rainbowsam2335 7 років тому +1

      NerdWriterGirl1984 lol 80's Amelia Pond. That would be awesome

    • @karyth09
      @karyth09 7 років тому +1

      Well, it was a painful one! damn, I cry too

  • @ishaandw
    @ishaandw 7 років тому +103

    The last time river sees the doctor is the second last time the doctor sees river.
    The last time the doctor sees river is the third last time river sees the doctor.
    The first time the doctor sees river is the second last time river sees the doctor.

    • @hannahfrost9752
      @hannahfrost9752 7 років тому +2

      Ishaan Basu

    • @benjaminshearlock9582
      @benjaminshearlock9582 7 років тому +4

      The last time the doctor sees river is the second last time

    • @AnythingButOrdinairy
      @AnythingButOrdinairy 7 років тому +6

      In the words of Kathryn Janeway: "Time travel. ...the future is the past, the past is the future, it all gives me a headache."

  • @Witchpandawa
    @Witchpandawa 7 років тому +91

    I miss River! *cries uncontrollably* TToTT

    • @SB-iy9vn
      @SB-iy9vn 7 років тому +1

      cries so much that it makes the pop corn taste good.

  • @AliSiddiqui55
    @AliSiddiqui55 8 років тому +151

    "The Night and the Doctor" episodes are canon, and in fact 'First Night' is specifically referenced in 'The Husbands of River Song', when River speaks of the Doctor's constant cancelling of their dinner at the singing towers of Darillium, including "that time there were two of you".

    • @appleoutlaw
      @appleoutlaw  8 років тому +12

      Thank you! I had heard otherwise, but I've checked and you're right! ;)
      Well... I suppose it makes the timeline more canon than before!! Yay!!

    • @StormsparkPegasus
      @StormsparkPegasus 8 років тому +6

      +EconGeekProductions That was technically First Night and Last Night, at 2 different points in 11's timestream. She said that at the end of Last Night, 11 cancelled the plans to go there at the last minute (hoping to postpone her death).

    • @sininelevant
      @sininelevant 8 років тому +30

      +EconGeekProductions I wonder if the Doctor and River would have arguments and the Doctor would get angry and be like "OK THIS IS IT I'M TAKING YOU TO DARILLIUM"

    • @LukeAllenFilm
      @LukeAllenFilm 8 років тому

      +Hfhifenfrrs Wjchosdho haha

  • @blaisineful
    @blaisineful 8 років тому +209

    The Doctor and River Song, the second greatest love story in the Universe.

    • @micahgomez9419
      @micahgomez9419 8 років тому +4

      The first? Lol

    • @blaisineful
      @blaisineful 8 років тому +103

      Amy and Rory of course.

    • @annehmbar
      @annehmbar 8 років тому

      +geowyn Kinsey true T^T they were great

    • @josselinbobinet7521
      @josselinbobinet7521 8 років тому +17

      Never forget Rose...

    • @blaisineful
      @blaisineful 8 років тому +55

      He gave Rose his unwanted clone, he married River.

  • @squiddysparklez1989
    @squiddysparklez1989 8 років тому +38

    when doctor who finishes they should release the doctors and rivers diarys. that would be epic

  • @nechemicaldisco9121
    @nechemicaldisco9121 8 років тому +144

    am i the only one who sobbed their eyes out during this?

  • @rayoflite52yahoo
    @rayoflite52yahoo 8 років тому +95

    Incredible editing. I think BBC should hire you to make "easter eggs" to add to the dvd series of Doctor Who. THIS was just as emotionally entertaining as a full-on episode. Thank you for this gift -this re-creation!

    • @appleoutlaw
      @appleoutlaw  8 років тому +17

      This means so much to me!!! Thank you!! :D

  • @Joeh2o
    @Joeh2o 7 років тому +26

    I cried like a baby when he took her to the singing towers...oh the feels

  • @argella1300
    @argella1300 7 років тому +361

    What always annoyed me is that there's any easy way around visiting the Ponds in the 30s after they were zapped there by the Angels. Instead of landing the TARDIS in Manhattan, land it somewhere else close by, like in Newark, Brooklyn, Yonkers, or Weehawken and take a cab into town or something. The Doctor is smart enough to figure out public transit.

    • @010timeboy27
      @010timeboy27 7 років тому +186

      I'm sure there's a wibbilly wobbly timey wimey reason

    • @animegirl4love
      @animegirl4love 7 років тому +24

      Some theorize that he actually did this, because in one episode Rory mentions leaving his watch somewhere, and he the next episode they're hiding in that place. I forget what the place was called, someone's bedroom.

    • @meathir4921
      @meathir4921 7 років тому +8

      +DreamingElfling Or he could just go before approx. 60+however old the gravestone is years (so work out where they got zapped to and go before then) and just wait for them to arrive.

    • @ordinarytree4678
      @ordinarytree4678 7 років тому +43

      yeah exactly. All the melodrama was kind silly since there are plenty of loopholes to the whole "Can't enter manhattan" thing. Hell, the doctor could just send River back to pick them up if he cant do it!

    • @meathir4921
      @meathir4921 7 років тому +4

      Ok, no, that's disproven, as River uses the TARDIS to travel.

  • @calvindonnahoo2035
    @calvindonnahoo2035 4 роки тому +4

    Its crazy, how when you watch the series the first time through, her death is sad yes, but you have NO idea the impact she has on the story. When you get to the towers, it all rushes back, and you can't help but go back to the library as well, and watching her for the last time really, really conveys emotions we just don't get normally, then she gets one last goodbye with the man she loves, truly one of the most amazing, tragic, beautiful love stories there ever was and ever will be.

  • @ViperRob
    @ViperRob 8 років тому +13

    So 12 gave River that xmas sonic gift, so that later (from her perspective) the 10th Doc can pick it up and use it to save her.... nice time loop there

  • @CymruJedi
    @CymruJedi 7 років тому +10

    As much as I haven't enjoyed Moffats more recent seasons, this storyline is still one of his greatest achievements

  • @DarkNight-np2md
    @DarkNight-np2md 7 років тому +23

    54 people are missing a second heartbeat

  • @joel.jpgvid
    @joel.jpgvid 3 роки тому +2

    14:17 - "Who are you?"
    at the time, we were all asking the same question. River's identity being a complete unknown, yet she knew him better than he knew himself to a certain degree. She was more of a mystery than a character. But, now after seeing their adventures together, their love story, 12 and River's night on Derillium, etc.
    That quote just breaks my heart completely.

  • @kynoceph
    @kynoceph 7 років тому +7

    There are a few times that an actor and a role coincide in such a way that it is just perfect...Alex Kingston and River Song is an example.

  • @gingerbychoice8967
    @gingerbychoice8967 7 років тому +43

    Will someone finally get her out of that library?! It's about time!! God, I miss River :(

    • @ann6303
      @ann6303 7 років тому +2

      Agent Orange the good thing is that when he realizes he can save her he can go to the past so River doesn't have to wait. The weird is that Moffat's Christmas episode told us about River. So what if this will be Moffat's final episode on Doctor Who??

  • @amblehhh
    @amblehhh 7 років тому +5

    When the 10th, was saying "Who are you?" I was shouting"SHHEEEE ISSSSS YOUUUURRRR WIFFFFEEEEEEE!"

  • @enriquearaujosr.7584
    @enriquearaujosr.7584 7 років тому +37

    I love this show. so many feels. I never seen anything that has made me so emotional. the doctor helped me with kind of therapy, when I lost my mum :( the shows made me feel everything would be OK in the end.

    • @appleoutlaw
      @appleoutlaw  7 років тому +2

      Thank you so much! And I'm also so sorry, I understand the feeling... DW helped me a lot, too!

    • @enriquearaujosr.7584
      @enriquearaujosr.7584 7 років тому +1

      Nctyabc - aww sorry. thanks

    • @enriquearaujosr.7584
      @enriquearaujosr.7584 7 років тому +3

      Nctyabc - I can't wait for this year's Christmas special. :)

    • @appleoutlaw
      @appleoutlaw  7 років тому +3

      Enrique Araujo Me too!! There is so little time left!! 😍

    • @enriquearaujosr.7584
      @enriquearaujosr.7584 7 років тому

      Nctyabc - I know. I feel like it's been for ever :(

  • @holohulolo
    @holohulolo 7 років тому +15

    I had almost forgotten the scene where she was uploaded into that library, that is the first time we see her isn't it? After watching that scene at the singing tower and then seeing the library scene, it's really sad that the doctor knew how and when she was gonna go the whole time. I never really thought about it when watching. I feel like watching the series again, keeping in mind how the doctor knew all along how it's going to end.

  • @jonsumner5899
    @jonsumner5899 7 років тому +10

    I love River Song and want to see more of River

  • @kathleenburnsgriggs5717
    @kathleenburnsgriggs5717 7 років тому +52

    Wonderfully, wonderfully done! Thank you! Of all the past central characters, I miss River Song the most so, thank you, again. :D

    • @appleoutlaw
      @appleoutlaw  7 років тому +4

      Kathleen Burns Griggs thank youu!!! it really, really means a lot!!! 💜

  • @Seyna91
    @Seyna91 7 років тому +5

    I wish they had developed Rory and River's relationship more. I would've loved to see Rory actually be a father to River

  • @borgCube100
    @borgCube100 7 років тому +8

    Even at the end of it all, River was consoling the Doctor.

  • @darcybrummett7004
    @darcybrummett7004 8 років тому +21

    18:23 Sometimes the Doctor can be so clueless.

    • @Sophia-mm5zh
      @Sophia-mm5zh 4 роки тому

      what does she mean when she says spoilers at 18:23? it's probably obvious but I'm not getting it 😂

  • @potat04
    @potat04 8 років тому +12

    I DUG UP YOUR BONES! Best Line Ever!

    • @Slackow
      @Slackow 8 років тому +3

      I think it was: "I'm an archeologist from the future. I dug you up."

    • @potat04
      @potat04 8 років тому +1

      +Cowslayer6789 potato tomato😜😜😜😜😜😜

  • @MrMelodyCold
    @MrMelodyCold 7 років тому +8

    the scene with 10th just break my heart

  • @Slackow
    @Slackow 8 років тому +68

    The sad thing is river can't come back. Husbands is the last place we'll ever see. Because he can't show up after at all, the last time she saw him was the towers before ten, also can't be before because she thinks he only has 12 faces, but he wouldn't have any of those faces she'd have to not know who he is for the entire episode which would really suck.

    • @StormsparkPegasus
      @StormsparkPegasus 8 років тому +13

      +Cowslayer6789 Actually, in Husbands she indicates that she has taken the TARDIS and returned it several times without the Doctor being aware. So it's possible.

    • @Slackow
      @Slackow 8 років тому +6

      but they cant interact each other, because the doctor would have a face she can't recognize, and can't tell here that he got a new cycle because in husbands she thinks he only has one.

    • @TheWorldjoy
      @TheWorldjoy 8 років тому +5

      +Cowslayer6789 They have 24 years together. I believe thats enough time to have some fun haha

    • @Slackow
      @Slackow 8 років тому +1

      BlaBlaBla Noodles depends which type of years they mean. Good point though, as 10 only lived for like 6 years, and 8 for one movie.

    • @StormsparkPegasus
      @StormsparkPegasus 8 років тому +21

      +Cowslayer6789 That's not really true. Davies and Moffat have both stated that we only see a tiny fraction of the Doctor's adventures. 9 lived for over 100 years, we just didn't see most of his adventures. 11 lived for something like 1100 years. Anytime you see the TARDIS disappear, and the camera is not inside it, the Doctor could be going anywhere, and spend any amount of time there he wants (even centuries) before the next episode starts. It is a time machine after all.

  • @bloodraven.77
    @bloodraven.77 6 років тому +1

    Part of me never was comfortable with the fact that River's last outing from our POV was with the Twelfth Doctor, and her last outing from her POV was with the Tenth Doctor, especially since she shared such a profound bond with Eleven. But I completely forgot that her last moments were with the Eleventh Doctor as an echo, which seems like a fitting end to the character. Spends 20 years with 12, dies with 10, and fades with 11. It really is beautiful.

  • @DravenGal
    @DravenGal 8 років тому

    So many tears. So many feels. ::stares at heart that was ripped out and is now pumping sadly on the floor:: That was a nice touch, the "..you know who I am?" "Who are you?" reversal...

  • @vic5015
    @vic5015 7 років тому +5

    river is such a badass! just watched the episode where The Doctor reboots the universe
    Amy: what happened to the Dalek?
    River, showing all the emotion of a kid who just stepped on an ant: It died.
    damn, lady, you just made a DALEK beg for mercy, then killed it anyway? that's some Dalek-level cold. remind me NEVER to get on your bad side.

  • @SarahTrala
    @SarahTrala 8 років тому +26

    Damn it. I don't know how I found you or this channel but now I'm bawling.

    • @appleoutlaw
      @appleoutlaw  8 років тому +1

      ahhahah thank you so much!!!!😀

  • @amcdo224
    @amcdo224 4 роки тому +1

    "The man who gave me this journal is the kind of man who'd know how many page's would be needed"

  • @jonmutanen8896
    @jonmutanen8896 8 років тому +1

    Simply amazing! Rive Song was a fantastic character in the show! I also love how each of the Doctor's companions play a role in his life. I wonder what the new companion's role will be. GOODBYE, SWEETIE...

  • @NicolasMHarrison
    @NicolasMHarrison 8 років тому +49

    you forgot the scene where young astronaut becomes young melody, you know, the regeneration scene in the astronaut episode at the end.

    • @xolotlnephthys
      @xolotlnephthys 8 років тому +7

      +Nicolas Harrison Actually, the product of that regeneration is not the melody in let's kill hitler, since it was in 69/70s which would make melody over 40. It would have to been an intermediate regeneration, which would have had to travel to england and die in/near Ledworth in order to meet amy/rory in the 90s.

    • @NicolasMHarrison
      @NicolasMHarrison 8 років тому +1

      Either way you should have had it in the time line

    • @ScottMajidi
      @ScottMajidi 8 років тому +1

      +Xolotl Nephthys thats not right. She says as shs's regenerating from mels to river "the last time i did this, i ended up a toddler, in the middle of new york." you're probably right about it being an intermediate regeneration, but then that throws in to question why she'd live to about her 30s, then regenerate back into a toddler in new york, then somehow grow up again and travel to england. I want to know what happened there.
      My theory up till this point is after she regenerated, she was just picked up by Madam Kovarian and dropped into ledworth straight afterwards, but was still left to find Rory and Amy.

    • @xoAllonsy
      @xoAllonsy 8 років тому

      +Scotty M She's half human. The regeneration may be a little different for that reason alone.

    • @darcybrummett7004
      @darcybrummett7004 8 років тому

      +xoAllonsy She's totally human who gained the ability to regenerate because of being conceived while the Tardis was traveling through the time vortex. I think. But she's completely human.

  • @Eheklo
    @Eheklo 7 років тому +5

    Ah, Dr. Who. The most epic and glorious achievement of mankind's creativity.

  • @BenFix79
    @BenFix79 8 років тому +12

    Excellent. Thank you. This is like a public service!

  • @ngatiramona
    @ngatiramona 7 років тому +25

    Thank you so much for putting all her timeline together. Very much appreciated. Happy holidays!

    • @appleoutlaw
      @appleoutlaw  7 років тому +4

      ngatiramona thank youu! this comment made my day! :) happy holidays to you, too!

  • @redbear108
    @redbear108 8 років тому +34

    This made me cry so hard

    • @appleoutlaw
      @appleoutlaw  8 років тому +3

      I'm sorry! I didn't mean to upset anyone! :) But River's story is so sad!

    • @redbear108
      @redbear108 8 років тому

      it wasn't your fault i'm just a cry baby when it comes to doctor who

    • @gxhavoczz479
      @gxhavoczz479 8 років тому

      +Артем Парыгин yeah the one in the street with that homeless guy

    • @slayer1982
      @slayer1982 8 років тому +1

      I made it all the way to 13 saying "Hello Sweetie." Then the water flowed!

  • @misssue7032
    @misssue7032 7 років тому +12

    I'm still kinda lost lol. That's Doctor Who for ya.

  • @Skhruffy
    @Skhruffy 4 роки тому +1

    I haven't watched Doctor Who in such a long time, I think was sometime in the middle of Capaldi's first season. Just out of curiosity I watched this and it brought tears to my eyes years after I stopped watching.

  • @pilarbaselgabayo2484
    @pilarbaselgabayo2484 8 років тому +5

    I wonder how many people realize that when she sees the Doctor's death as an invited guest, she knows perfectly well what's going to happen. She tries to stop herself from saving the Doctor but she can't, so after his death she actually tries to kill the astronaut. I just realized she knew she was killing herself and she didn't care because she didn't deserve life after hurting the Doctor

    • @pinkperfectpeach7544
      @pinkperfectpeach7544 4 роки тому

      Pilar Baselga Bayo no the doctor tells astronaut river that the future her was watching them and doesn’t remember this

  • @babtist58
    @babtist58 7 років тому +20

    May I say this upload is awesome, a generous helping of one of my favorite characters. I've been looking for this one for some time! well done and thank you.

    • @appleoutlaw
      @appleoutlaw  7 років тому +3

      babtist58 Thank youuu! I'm so glad you liked it!

  • @JoeHamelin
    @JoeHamelin 7 років тому +4

    Great timeline. Such a hard character to keep track of. Good job, AO!

    • @appleoutlaw
      @appleoutlaw  7 років тому

      Thank you!! You don't know how happy your comment makes me! :)

  • @nzrockboi
    @nzrockboi 8 років тому +1

    Also, when Last Night came out I felt so cheated! I thought that was the moment I'd been waiting for, and then it was compacted into a short special, showing nothing that River mentioned in Library. So Husbands was a massive, Amazing relief

  • @subinmdr
    @subinmdr 7 років тому +1

    15:00 WTF thats where I had heard about The Singing Towers of Darillion. I couldn't remember that when watching last Christmas special. Made me cry all over again😢😢

  • @TheWrongTiga
    @TheWrongTiga 8 років тому +8

    GOOD BYE SWEETIE HAS KILLED ME

  • @ghosttroop115
    @ghosttroop115 7 років тому +18

    you forgot when river (as a child) regeneration into mels

  • @christopherramsey7027
    @christopherramsey7027 4 роки тому +3

    I love how she's been "Melody Pond" instead of "Melody Williams" this whole time just because the Doctor assumed Rory took Amy's name.

  • @coolzgoku
    @coolzgoku 8 років тому +1

    This just made me want to watch all of doctor who again, but from River's perspective.

  • @passerbytanuki2456
    @passerbytanuki2456 7 років тому +56

    and his name was Geronimo all along :/ ;^P X""D

  • @SJPDurham
    @SJPDurham 7 років тому +8

    I cried.

  • @mountaintiger6945
    @mountaintiger6945 3 роки тому +1

    Of all the characters through all the years of the Doctor (and I'm lucky to have seen them all) she was the most amazing and wonderful of them. 💖💗💝💞

  • @mewanthachandinathranasing5119
    @mewanthachandinathranasing5119 8 років тому +1

    It just bring tears to my eye. I even used to call my gril frien river. 😭😭

  • @SanDeeMcGeek
    @SanDeeMcGeek 7 років тому +3

    i love river so much

  • @Katalyzt
    @Katalyzt 8 років тому +16

    Epic! Save for Sarah Jane Smith, Professor River Song is the greatest companion in all of Doctor Who. ᵔᴥᵔ ★★★★★
    Katalyzt

    • @julieeverett7442
      @julieeverett7442 4 роки тому

      Sarah Jane, the Brig and River the greatest companions the doctor ever had

  • @alyssajucel93
    @alyssajucel93 7 років тому +1

    I don't know why I let myself watch these things. This is such a great show. 😢

  • @gregdoble4302
    @gregdoble4302 7 років тому

    River Song and the Love she and the Dr. have is timeless. Such an endless story of Love & Grief :(

  • @endhai
    @endhai 7 років тому +10

    Prof- River Song is the most intresting femal character.

  • @Humaricslastcall
    @Humaricslastcall 7 років тому +8

    The Bootstrap Paradox can be a son of a bitch sometimes...

  • @charlielogan2897
    @charlielogan2897 7 років тому

    No matter how many times I watch this video, I always cry at the scenes and admire the amazing editing!!! You have done brilliant research to put this all together, so thanks!!! I'm always coming back to it xoxo

  • @thecanberean
    @thecanberean 7 років тому

    Nicely put together. Thanks a lot.
    You made me go and watch SITL/FOTD once again with its magic ending. Best ending ever, I reckon, of any Dr Who adventure.

  • @AnnBearForFreedom
    @AnnBearForFreedom 8 років тому +10

    Didn't you miss the "toddler regenerating in New York City" during the Moon one with Matt and the Ponds? Sorry for the vagueness, I do know my Who, but I'm terrible with names....

    • @ThomasFuchs7
      @ThomasFuchs7 8 років тому +1

      Right! I knew there are things missing. It is The Day of the Moon.

  • @subbtopp
    @subbtopp 7 років тому +11

    aww. that was really enjoyable. thank you

    • @appleoutlaw
      @appleoutlaw  7 років тому +1

      subbtopp thanks to you!!! 😁

  • @CarenLinn
    @CarenLinn 8 років тому

    I love this, thank you for putting this together.

  • @Ainiewainy
    @Ainiewainy 6 років тому +2

    River Song, Melody Pond. I'm debating to name a future daugter Melody River after her. Have always been a big River fan! The actress playing River has been a role model for me since she was on ER!

  • @RiverAlexandraSong
    @RiverAlexandraSong 7 років тому +5

    I think its lovely and trust me I keep a diary - and there are so many more things. You did a brilliant job

    • @appleoutlaw
      @appleoutlaw  7 років тому

      Yey!! I'm so happy you liked it! Thank you River!

    • @RiverAlexandraSong
      @RiverAlexandraSong 7 років тому +2

      you are so welcome !! Happy Easter as "he" would say...

  • @TheLuluTrue
    @TheLuluTrue 7 років тому +4

    I'm not crying, you are!

  • @robwalton7749
    @robwalton7749 7 років тому +1

    Matt Smith, Shakespearean to the end. Genius, genius, genius!!!

  • @susan-of6xd
    @susan-of6xd 3 місяці тому

    River Song. A beautiful and tragic part of the Doctor’s story.❤😊😢

  • @CDHfilms
    @CDHfilms 7 років тому +10

    Anyone ever try watching these episodes in this exact order?!

  • @mendelgreene4369
    @mendelgreene4369 8 років тому +28

    Still a better love story than Twilight.

    • @thetwelfthdoctor9892
      @thetwelfthdoctor9892 6 років тому

      even the love between coffee and milk is a better love story than Twilight xD

    • @julieeverett7442
      @julieeverett7442 4 роки тому

      of course, I think anything would be

  • @amandacerrato7566
    @amandacerrato7566 8 років тому +1

    IT ALL MAKES SENSE NOW i was all confused but now!!! WHATTTTT

  • @peterjivotovski1828
    @peterjivotovski1828 7 років тому

    This clears up so much thank you for making this.