Physics | AC II vs AC Mirage
Вставка
- Опубліковано 11 жов 2023
- It is shocking to find that Assassin's Creed 2 released all the way back in 2009 actually has some physics elements that are better than Assassin's Creed Mirage released in 2023. #assassinscreedmirage #assassinscreed #assassinscreed2
- Ігри
physics wasn't invented yet
Good point
It came with the renaissance
Issac Newton wasn't born yet so it checks out.
How do they have gravity
Isaac Newton wasn't born yet
Man, Ac 2 ost is so damn good
In the first ones defense, it looks far more sturdy than AC2 platforms. The ones in AC2 are thin, both rope and board wise, but those ones in AC Mirage look reinforced with thicker rope.
that would change absolutely nothing though
@@obiwanfisher537When the weight of the wood is greater than the person standing on it it wouldn't move as well if it was suspended with rope.
that's not how physics work tho
True, believe it or not I even did some calculations to figure how it would behave because of the way it's hanged, the one in AC 2 looks like it should actually move like that but in Mirage not so much. But the reality is (at least as far as I understand- I've studied advanced level physics in college tho) the one in Mirage should move but not as far as it does in AC2.
If you look closely you can see that in AC2 the point where the ropes are tied together is about the height of Ezio but in Mirage it's about double the height of Basim.
Now imagine if it's tied way closer to the platform, more than that of AC2. The platform would surely tilt way more and could possibly triple Ezio down. So when the angle between the platform and the ropes are lower it should tilt more but what if it's 90 degrees and hung with individual ropes and the ropes wouldn't stretch, then the platform wouldn't tilt at all. So Mirage is in-between these two scenarios closer to the 90 degrees one, so it would tilt but not as much it does in AC2, Attack Titan
@@Pyrodorah That would still do fuck all. It's not a fixed object, it swings. And if you jump on it, it will swing and tilt a little.
They should stop improved graphics.
Why not both
lol it does kinda make sense assassin's creed 2 had a budget of a whopping 24 million dollars
ac mirage on the other hand has a more limited budget
right but i think if you tried to make AC 2 now a days you wouldnt need a budget of 24 million at all, or even 24 million to make stuff have physics
Yh but this could also mean that Valhalla doesn't have it either, if it does have structures like that
It's not a budget problem, it's laziness
@@vivekpluch yeah I think that's because they thought mirage will be a failure so they didn't put a lot of work into it
@@vivekpluch it is either lazy or dateline
How the hell does a game released 14 years ago have dome of the beat parkour in the franchise than the newest games? I’m not hating on it since i’ve honestly been enjoying mirage, but unfortunately it is undeniable that the parkour, one of AC’s signature features has degraded highly
Mirage is actually less down graded than the previous three games
@@IDRlFTERI that i agree. I also have high hopes for AC Codename Red. Hopefully parkour as good as the classic games returns in the game since Ubisoft also seems to be investing a lot into the game
@@Yoda3000 Japan wasn't necessarily a good place for parkour. There's a lot of open spaces, which is one of the reasons Ubisoft refused to make an AC game set in Japan quite some time ago. Now, things have changed, and since Codename Red will be the "next big RPG" Assassin's Creed game, it will most likely be like Valhalla in terms of open spaces.
These small comparision is good to be noticed .. But does it really matter .... Did that small physics detail Affect any of the good gameplay and not so good story ...
People shouldn't get upset on this and just enjoy this game
Of course not I did definitely notice it while playing both of the games but it didn't affect the enjoyability of the game, I'm enjoying Mirage way more than I thought I would. But it's also the fact that devs don't put much attention to detail as they have done before is kind of also sad. For example I remember well that in Origins Bayek's clothes get wet corresponding to the level he was deep in the water, it was not perfect but it was there. But in Mirage this happens only if Basim's full submerged or like after the swimming mechanics get triggered
If you do more, add the Year the game came out with the logo. Gives the video more Lifetime, And it would be cool to look at this 6 years from now.
Thanks for the tip, definitely gonna do it
Thank you@@IDRlFTERI
These kinds of comparison videos are pretty misleading if I’m honest, they don’t factor in a thousand other things, just barebones physics gameplay
I mean the video is about comparing two similar scenarios and showing how it differs, that's what a comparison is, "the thousand other things" doesn't affect this specific scenario
@@IDRlFTERI yes but the title makes it seem like there's a clear cut picture between quality
@@zenthous9568 the video's title suggests a 14-year gap between the two games and the thumbnail hints at a physics comparison. And when viewers watch the video, they'll discover that one of the physics elements has been downgraded over the years. It's important to note that I didn't mention anywhere that other aspects of the games are bad. In fact, just by looking at the video, you can see that the graphic quality has improved significantly, and the overall smoothness of animations has also seen a substantial enhancement.
I see your point, but it's more about how some people jump to conclusions based on assumptions rather than how the video is presented. I've responded to everyone who made such assumptions by highlighting that Mirage is not a bad game at all. In fact, if you're new to the series, you might enjoy Mirage even more than Assassin's Creed 2
@@IDRlFTERI I just think that in nearly every case the title ‘these two games are 14 years apart’ always implies the older game being portrayed as better without fair representation through one feature. It doesn’t make sense to make a video about downgrading something irrelevant to the core gameplay like leaf physics or something, because it paints a picture that you think this game is superior. this may not be intentional but a lot of other people do similar videos which definitely do
@@IDRlFTERI I think it is mainly jumping to conclusions, because that’s what people do in life. If you create a video like this your opinion of the entire game is kind of misrepresented and so leads to this kind of argument. Not that’s it’s your fault I just don’t think this kind of video is great
I told everyone that mirage is going to be shit, and had huge fights here on youtube with people chanting "THEY'RE GOING BACK TO THE ROOTS THEY'RE GOING BACK TO THE ROOTS" and now look at this shit.... I don't care for AC any more. I might maybe play Hexe as I am german and it's set in Germany, but other than that AC can suck it.
It's not shit even though this detail isn't there, if you liked older AC games you'd definitely will enjoy this, Mirage is way more of an Assassin Creed than any of the RPG games including Origins
@@IDRlFTERI It's shit. Too much fantasy BS in there with the teleporation and stuff. Not to mention the downgrades from previous games in animations.
And you were still completly wrong
I agree its sad to see no physic but when you remember that it was to be a valhalla dlc so had less time and budget Bordeau made a good job
@@asahisynthesis7366 What was I completely wrong about?
@@asahisynthesis7366 What was I completely wrong about?
not reaslistic too, 1. because you jump many times the rope may break because of weight. 2. its shaking not hard enough. Conclusion: both suck and pseudo physics like this are useless in games because its don't really change gameplay
Realistic enough, though what you said about it not affecting gameplay is true. Games can't have 100% realistic physics, just like with graphics. None of the games we play feature 100% realistic graphics, but we don't go around saying pseudo graphics like this are useless in games. We accept what's there to the degree they have done it and appreciate it
wrong. We can get much better graphic and physics but if we combine both that would cost much more perfomance, thats why you add something and remove or change engine@@IDRlFTERI
HAHAHA where is the uncherted then?
The what
@@IDRlFTERI uncheeeeerted