Mine actually told the truth before going in a coma she pushed me off my deck was so close laughing and spitting in my face first shot broke her nose second a 2x4 smashed her orbital and fractured her skull I drug myself and chair to an out of county hospital to have 37 staples replaced scanned to make sure no pins or screws pulled out my spine was released that night 3 weeks later she was released to jail the violent little leprechaun caught a felony abuse of the handicap charge
People please, please be careful who you date. At the first sign of violence leave them. Do not stay with them, it will get worse, you can not change them. Learn how to protect yourself, and make your home safer. Get alarms, cameras, etc. Amie's sounds like a wonderful, loving person, and her friends, and family loved her. The world is less dim because her light was taken away.
I hate how they can just smear the reputation of whoever they feel like. Like when Casey Anthony’s team accused her dad of sexual molestation & ultimately killing Kaylee…
@@lindseyloo5155 bet ya can't guess who told them that lie funny how it started with why she hadn't left her daughter alone with "those people for a month" to it had to be them remember she claimed she told her mother when she was young but mommy dearest did nothing and since he was a cop she couldn't trust them to help
They did the exact thing when my sister was unalived. I was 3rd witness up and I put a stop to that immediately. Unfortunately although we knew 100 per cent that he killed her and their were 150 prosecution witnesses he was found not guilty. It was a joke.
It's shameful, the direction of argument of defence counsel of Pursehouse. If Amie initiated the attack, rightly so. What was a stranger doing, breaking into her house?
Even if she attacked him first which I don’t believe, she would have had a right to do so as he was the intruder lying in wait. Horrifying. The whole thing.
Defence attorney here, both those attorneys representing the accused should be disbarred for raising defences which make ZERO SENSE in law! Absolutely ridiculous! RIP Amy ⚘️
It’s gobsmacking to me that roommate Michael didn’t rush upstairs to help his friend and roommate who was screaming… what a wuss… bet he regrets it big time today.
That really made me me not understand him. Me and my friends may not be able to fend off an attacker of one of us but we would damn sure try. I love my best friend more than some family members and I would risk my life to help her.
😂 ahahaha. The wife and I just said the same thing! Like how? How do you not go look, listen, or ask what's going on? Hopefully he changes something about himself and works to never remain helpless again. Bonkers, she'd have survived. Especially considering where she was found.
ikr! i grew up watching my mom get the crap beat out of her so whenever i hear a woman scream or yell, i'm heading in that direction before i even have a thought as to what's going on. i would be damned if i could witness or at least hear a woman in distress and not do anything. i know everyone reacts differently to violence but his statement in the beginning ''i knew i had to make a break for it'' says he was scared and trying to get out of there but had he even tried to help her, she may still be here.
The roommate heard her screaming for help and did absolutely nothing to help her except run to a neighbours house to call the police? Too late roommate?
@@belladonna5904 that is not the point. It's not a matter of asking if what he did was logical. It's asking if it was normal. Is it a normal reaction? It's certaintly not. The natural reaction is to rush to her defense. Does it mean he lied? Not necessarily but it does make you wonder. I haven't finished watching the whole video yet. I just started, but my first reaction when I heard him explain what happened was immediate suspicion.
@henryposadas3309 yeah but if you don't know what You're up against or if the person has a weapon, I don't know that most men would just rush in there. His first instinct probably was to get help for that reason.
@belladonna5904 You rush and find out what is happening . . You scream, shout make a noise bang on the door or something to make a distraction of sorts . . You DO NOT run away ever
A lot of this seems to stem from jealousy. Gareth was extremely jealous of Amy’s success along with a big dose of misogyny . This damaged and emotionally immature man felt entitled to access to Amy whenever he felt like it.
She was gorgeous!!! And charismatic and intelligent and succesful....😢 the more i watch these shows the more i realize that beauty talent and charisma are more prone to attracting narcistic psychopaths as romantic partners. They are attracted to the light and cant stand annyone else having it if they are not the one. Ladies we have to be so carefull who we let in our lives....😮😢. Rip beautyful angel ❤
Oh my God she was so beautiful and stunning! It is hard to watch these anymore. All these amazing beautiful people just snuffed out like dogs. It is absolutely infuriating and heartbreaking!!!
I'm a Man, and I am disgusted by people like this POS and he's not a Man, We don't claim him as one of our own. Also the roommate? Real men protect women and children and the vulnerable.
The roommate seems feminine but still man enough to try that roid freak would've killed them both over the balcony making it look like they were having sex on the balcony and fell overthe way he puffed up before trial his muscles were roids
@OGRuth they were just roommates and apparently it wasn't unusual for the cat to knock things over and break them and I have no obligation to defend anyone but myself without a gun I'm not going to confront capitan roid rage over a roommate I have no responsibility to protect since I'm not f**king it and who I have no say over what freaks it has coming in and out its room
She had cameras or at least one but it shut off right before Gareth entered the house. He was an IT guy. I'm assuming he cut the feed before breaking into her house. I can't recall if she had an alarm system. I think she did but it was off because her roommate was home at the time.
Wow… rambling on??? Wtf?? I heard clearly my friend has been attacked.. I heard it. She was thrown to the floor. He’s trying to be as quick as possible because his friend needs help immediately. Cops are so tough as long as there’s no real danger. Go be a cop and help
More and more it proves to me that even if a woman leaves their abuser she is still in danger. Sorry to say but once you have been in a relationship with one of these men, you are now their property unless he say otherwise.
Absolutely ! A man or a mouse 🐁 ?! A man would of thought ahead to protect that household by using his 2nd Amendment Right ! Unless, he’s a felon of course.
This happens on so many occasions. People who have been in know danger and could have saved a person. Stop walking away and a lot more lives could be saved.
Not gonna lie, hearing this case from other creators made me so so mad at the room-mate. actually SEEING his reaction I can and see the terror and flightiness in him. I can hear how scared he is. I had no idea.
I disagree. He failed. Survivors guilt for sure, but he listened to his friend and roommate being beaten to death and ran away. He is an outright coward. He can never be trusted again. He proved he cannot be relied up when it matters. Zero instinct to help or protect. His instinct was to protect himself. Selfish beyond doubt. All the sudden when police are with him he cares to help, when he is useless at that point. Strange. I hope he pushes to change that, or tries perhaps. It is maddening to think she may have thought "my friend/roommate is right downstairs. I just gotta stay alive long enough" It's wonderful that God forgives. Just my opinion though.
Oh heck. The last part of your comments made me want to cry. I never thought of that. And in all possibilitie she thought her scream would get him to help her. @@MissMy5.0
'Michael H did all the right things' ... Who wouldn't run upstairs to help a woman in distress?? He doesn't have survivor's guilt, he's guilty because he chose to run away from his friend in distress like a coward. I wouldn't be able to live with that.
I could live with myself in that house I've lived in a 1920s Dr office/hospital with blood stains on the floor I lived in a mortuary while converting it to a handicap accessible house had a tent and my vehicle in the back of an old cemetery while fixing where yotes digging mice had stones leaning I filled the holes with gravel quick quickcrete and dirt picked up others after leveling the base drilling rebar holes and epoxy them back together then put chainlink fence around the 3 sides that were barbwire
He did hear it, but he thought it was Aime’s cat knocking something over. As a cat owner for most of my life, I’ve heard many odd sounds in the middle of the night and had to go see what’s going on. So far, it’s always been a cat doing late-night cat stuff.
I know everyone’s entitled to a defense, but cases like this make me feel such anger at them. The ridiculous stories they come up with are embarrassing and hurtful. Shane on them.
this story is somewhat similar to one i have on my channel. a Vietnamese lady by name Nguyen Thi Xian who traveled to Belgium to see her "boyfriend", only to be killed by him and her body burnt beyond recognition. this is all in a bid to cover-up the affair to prevent his live-in girlfriend in Belgium from finding out. something he could have just ghosted her and that will be the end. the family back in Vietnam were worried sick, not knowing their daughter was no more. the case took the police an extra 4 years to uncover the culprit. a very sad case. people are just awful these days.😪☹
Wow this is so sad the woman that was murdered her mother won't even let her father speak every time he tries to speak she cut him off let him have a say too it was his daughter to sorry for you guys is lost may she rest in peace and fly high in the sky with the angels God bless
I could not sit there and hear screaming and not run to her room to help her. He said he couldnt find his phone to call 911 but they wouldnt have gotten there fast enough. Every home should have a home defense gun/weapon. I walked in on a home invasion in my home. I sleep with a gun now. And a Belgian Malinois. I just could not sit there hearing my roommate/friend scream and not react. Of course it's easy to do a "post mortem" but let us use this horrifying , tragic death as a tool to save future victims. Even getting a big dog helps. I pray her family finds peace knowing their precious daughter is with God, doing therapy in Heaven. May she Rest in Peace.
the irony that she broke off her engagement bc she was scared of her ex while she wouldve probably been more save if she hadnt been alone and went through w it😔
I think i met this womderful gal at a show.....and she was taken from us during an event that i almost lost my life too ....an abuser who couldnt handle being told no Rest in power Dr Amy. Horns up
If she had just had a gun locked and loaded and ready to use. This is horrific and should not have happened. Unfortunately, here in CA, she would have gotten in trouble for using the gun to defend herself.
sadly you get what you fear. Leaving a celebrity relationship because of fear of a stalker is stupid. At least a celebrity has 5e money to put up safeguards and protection barriers.
I’ve been jealous, I’ve been extremely upset over the way a relationship has ended, I’ve never considered killing a woman. I will never understand these people
How sad. The guy obviously needed help and he never got it, let’s face it his obsession wasn’t with correct thinking. She was beautiful and didn’t need to die.
This case is heartbreaking. However the defense has nothing but bad facts to work with and an obligation to vigorously defend their client. I would rather have them smear the victim a little bit than not if it helps a conviction stick.
This sounds like the movie” fear” came to real life .. he even looks like mark wahlburg .. so sad when a person gets so obsessed with someone they literally won’t let them go live without them 😡😢 it’s even sadder that she was helping ppl with these similar issues and she got stuck with someone who should have been a patient .. r.i.p beautiful
This makes me feel sad about Amie. She was so smart and ❤️ very stunning lady. Her parents are so heartbroken 😭 I'm so sorry for your loss of Amie. RIP sweet angel 😇
Gareth’s mother saying to Amie’s mother that she was sorry about “what HAD HAPPENED to her daughter” 🤦♀️ shows she is still in denial that her monster of a son MURDERED Amie! The way she worded it, she speaks as if it was an accident
It's impossible to definitively say how many people were killed by individuals who were themselves killed by nicotine, as there are no reliable statistics tracking such a specific scenario; however, the most relevant example would be the case of Erzsébet Papp, also known as "The Nicotine Killer," a Hungarian serial killer who poisoned four people with nicotine, leading to her own execution for her crimes. Key points to remember: No large-scale data exists: There is no comprehensive data tracking deaths caused by people who were themselves killed by nicotine poisoning. Erzsébet Papp case: The only well-known instance where someone directly killed others using nicotine poisoning is the case of Erzsébet Papp, who murdered four people. Nicotine is primarily lethal through smoking: Most deaths related to nicotine are due to long-term tobacco use, not direct poisoning of others. Smoking - Our World in Data The WHO estimates that more than 8 million people die prematurely yearly from tobacco use. This is the latest available WHO estima... Our World in Data Nicotine poisoning - Wikipedia E-cigarette exposure cases in the US National Poison Data System increased greatly between 2010 and 2014, peaking at 3,742 in 2014... Wikipedia Erzsébet Papp - Wikipedia Erzsébet Papp (January 28, 1935 - January 23, 1962), known as The Nicotine Killer or her married name "Mrs. János Holhos", was a H... Wikipedia Show all This is for informational purposes only. For medical advice or diagnosis, consult a professional. Generative AI is experimental.
RIP Amie- you are a light in this world. we DESPERATELY NEED STRONGER LAWS PROTECTION DATABASES MANDATORY MINIMUMS EASE OF ACCESS MORE ALLOWABLE EVIDENCE ALL ABUSE IS DANGEROUS- ITS A SLOPE. I had to fight for my life and I still live in fear of him daily. Its HORRIBLE. People deserve lifetime protection too. THE STATISTICS ARE HORRIFYING ❤
Why did he refer to her as a roommate? There was two separate apartments within one building. Stalking laws have to be changed and judges need to take the issue of stalking more seriously no matter what the job of the the complainant. I think when the first judge saw that she was a sex therapist, he ignored the seriousness of her concerns. I believe she would still be alive if that first protective ordered had been in place.
@isabelpark7650 In the U.S. it's I3.99 a month which is just about 3.50 a week. Some of us don't want to pay another monthly bill especially to Google.
What a heartbreaking episode. Such a beautiful young lady with a bright brilliant future. And what a loser of an ex boyfriend…. I hope he’s enjoying his 3 hots and a cot….😂
She was so beautiful, in-and outside, and her parents are so lovable! 🥰
Of course he blamed her. Abusers always think they're the victim. Amy had such a bright future ahead of her. This was heartbreaking.
Mine actually told the truth before going in a coma she pushed me off my deck was so close laughing and spitting in my face first shot broke her nose second a 2x4 smashed her orbital and fractured her skull I drug myself and chair to an out of county hospital to have 37 staples replaced scanned to make sure no pins or screws pulled out my spine was released that night 3 weeks later she was released to jail the violent little leprechaun caught a felony abuse of the handicap charge
There’s always two sides to the story. The victims are rarely innocent. I doubt she was an angel. 😇
@sirvilhelmofyonderland there's usually 3 sides the victims the suspects and the truth
@@davidwoermansr oh yeah. The truth is in there somewhere.
@sirvilhelmofyonderland I'm sure both sides tell part of it
People please, please be careful who you date. At the first sign of violence leave them. Do not stay with them, it will get worse, you can not change them. Learn how to protect yourself, and make your home safer. Get alarms, cameras, etc. Amie's sounds like a wonderful, loving person, and her friends, and family loved her. The world is less dim because her light was taken away.
But people are not listening.
My goodness she is absolutely beautiful ❤I am so very sorry for your loss such a beautiful young lady
Her parents are such lovely people. And Amie had so many many friends who loved her so much. What a loss.💔
I feel bad for her parents they actually picked her since they couldn't make 1
She was bad news. Women need accountability. It’s crazy she gave marriage advice… insane
I hate the way the defense will smear the reputation of the victim! Easily done when the victim isn’t there to defend themselves 🤦♀️😡😢
Unfortunately that's their job and a necessary job in the criminal justice system
I hate how they can just smear the reputation of whoever they feel like. Like when Casey Anthony’s team accused her dad of sexual molestation & ultimately killing Kaylee…
@@lindseyloo5155 bet ya can't guess who told them that lie funny how it started with why she hadn't left her daughter alone with "those people for a month" to it had to be them remember she claimed she told her mother when she was young but mommy dearest did nothing and since he was a cop she couldn't trust them to help
They did the exact thing when my sister was unalived. I was 3rd witness up and I put a stop to that immediately. Unfortunately although we knew 100 per cent that he killed her and their were 150 prosecution witnesses he was found not guilty. It was a joke.
@isabelpark7650 that had to be the world's most incompetent prosecution team I feel bad for that
Even if some of these are reruns, I love them. They’re very well put together. ❤
Yes, God bless these victims and their loving families.
It's shameful, the direction of argument of defence counsel of Pursehouse. If Amie initiated the attack, rightly so. What was a stranger doing, breaking into her house?
Even if she attacked him first which I don’t believe, she would have had a right to do so as he was the intruder lying in wait. Horrifying. The whole thing.
Defence attorney here, both those attorneys representing the accused should be disbarred for raising defences which make ZERO SENSE in law! Absolutely ridiculous!
RIP Amy ⚘️
Agree. Not an attorney but that defense was a clown act 🤡
It’s gobsmacking to me that roommate Michael didn’t rush upstairs to help his friend and roommate who was screaming… what a wuss… bet he regrets it big time today.
Heart braking.
That really made me me not understand him. Me and my friends may not be able to fend off an attacker of one of us but we would damn sure try. I love my best friend more than some family members and I would risk my life to help her.
😂 ahahaha. The wife and I just said the same thing! Like how? How do you not go look, listen, or ask what's going on? Hopefully he changes something about himself and works to never remain helpless again. Bonkers, she'd have survived. Especially considering where she was found.
ikr! i grew up watching my mom get the crap beat out of her so whenever i hear a woman scream or yell, i'm heading in that direction before i even have a thought as to what's going on. i would be damned if i could witness or at least hear a woman in distress and not do anything. i know everyone reacts differently to violence but his statement in the beginning ''i knew i had to make a break for it'' says he was scared and trying to get out of there but had he even tried to help her, she may still be here.
What a coward! And said he couldn't find his phone to call poice . Very upsetting
We as a developed society should have zero tolerance for domestic violence of ANY kind. Until we do that no is safe from being murdered.
No. Don't let him get out. He's not ready. Family is not going to help
Devastatingly sad. Her poor dad, there at the end. man
The roommate heard her screaming for help and did absolutely nothing to help her except run to a neighbours house to call the police? Too late roommate?
I bet she would have run to help him if she had heard him screaming for help.
What else was he suppose to do? He didn't even know what was going on. Was he suppose to go up there and get killed too?
@@belladonna5904 that is not the point. It's not a matter of asking if what he did was logical. It's asking if it was normal. Is it a normal reaction? It's certaintly not. The natural reaction is to rush to her defense. Does it mean he lied? Not necessarily but it does make you wonder.
I haven't finished watching the whole video yet. I just started, but my first reaction when I heard him explain what happened was immediate suspicion.
@henryposadas3309 yeah but if you don't know what You're up against or if the person has a weapon, I don't know that most men would just rush in there. His first instinct probably was to get help for that reason.
@belladonna5904 You rush and find out what is happening . . You scream, shout make a noise bang on the door or something to make a distraction of sorts . . You DO NOT run away ever
A lot of this seems to stem from jealousy. Gareth was extremely jealous of Amy’s success along with a big dose of misogyny . This damaged and emotionally immature man felt entitled to access to Amy whenever he felt like it.
She was gorgeous!!! And charismatic and intelligent and succesful....😢 the more i watch these shows the more i realize that beauty talent and charisma are more prone to attracting narcistic psychopaths as romantic partners. They are attracted to the light and cant stand annyone else having it if they are not the one. Ladies we have to be so carefull who we let in our lives....😮😢. Rip beautyful angel ❤
Oh my God she was so beautiful and stunning! It is hard to watch these anymore. All these amazing beautiful people just snuffed out like dogs. It is absolutely infuriating and heartbreaking!!!
I'm a Man, and I am disgusted by people like this POS and he's not a Man, We don't claim him as one of our own. Also the roommate? Real men protect women and children and the vulnerable.
The roommate seems feminine but still man enough to try that roid freak would've killed them both over the balcony making it look like they were having sex on the balcony and fell overthe way he puffed up before trial his muscles were roids
The roommate seemed to be a feminine guy but still a guy road rage guy was an animal not a man
Exactly. He heard a loud noise downstairs at 9pm. Im sure you would have investigated. I am female and Id have to make sure everything was ok.
Ty
@OGRuth they were just roommates and apparently it wasn't unusual for the cat to knock things over and break them and I have no obligation to defend anyone but myself without a gun I'm not going to confront capitan roid rage over a roommate I have no responsibility to protect since I'm not f**king it and who I have no say over what freaks it has coming in and out its room
He didn't even try and save her?
Everyone for themselves!
nope he just heard screaming and thought I have to save myself
I just started watching but I found it odd that her roomate heard her screaming and he didn't rush up to help her?
What lovely parents ❤
Why didn't she get a house alarm and cameras???
She had cameras or at least one but it shut off right before Gareth entered the house. He was an IT guy. I'm assuming he cut the feed before breaking into her house. I can't recall if she had an alarm system. I think she did but it was off because her roommate was home at the time.
Wow… rambling on??? Wtf?? I heard clearly my friend has been attacked.. I heard it. She was thrown to the floor. He’s trying to be as quick as possible because his friend needs help immediately. Cops are so tough as long as there’s no real danger. Go be a cop and help
So so true....
These websites that put people's phone number and address online should be STOPPED! It's dangerous!
More and more it proves to me that even if a woman leaves their abuser she is still in danger. Sorry to say but once you have been in a relationship with one of these men, you are now their property unless he say otherwise.
The roommate guy was too cowardly to defend her. And he felt guilty about it.
Imagine if her roomate had been "The Rock" and not a beta wimp.
Absolutely ! A man or a mouse 🐁 ?! A man would of thought ahead to protect that household by using his 2nd Amendment Right ! Unless, he’s a felon of course.
So easy to judge.
This happens on so many occasions. People who have been in know danger and could have saved a person. Stop walking away and a lot more lives could be saved.
Not gonna lie, hearing this case from other creators made me so so mad at the room-mate. actually SEEING his reaction I can and see the terror and flightiness in him. I can hear how scared he is. I had no idea.
I disagree. He failed. Survivors guilt for sure, but he listened to his friend and roommate being beaten to death and ran away. He is an outright coward. He can never be trusted again. He proved he cannot be relied up when it matters. Zero instinct to help or protect. His instinct was to protect himself. Selfish beyond doubt. All the sudden when police are with him he cares to help, when he is useless at that point. Strange. I hope he pushes to change that, or tries perhaps. It is maddening to think she may have thought "my friend/roommate is right downstairs. I just gotta stay alive long enough" It's wonderful that God forgives. Just my opinion though.
Oh heck. The last part of your comments made me want to cry. I never thought of that. And in all possibilitie she thought her scream would get him to help her. @@MissMy5.0
When she knew she was in danger and dealing with a crazy person and sent herself an email to document the situation. ❤
He destroyed her life and his life just because he couldn't move on.
⏱️ Timestamps by TimeSkip ⏱️
00:00:00 - Introduction to Amy's Story
00:02:00 - Emergency Response and Chaos
00:04:07 - Police Investigation Begins
00:06:47 - Michael's Account of the Night
00:10:50 - Amy's Background and Family
00:12:37 - Amy's Relationship with Gareth
00:17:01 - Amy's Legacy and Reputation
00:19:15 - Amy's New Relationship
00:21:00 - Emily Sears' Perspective
00:22:24 - Gareth's Confrontation with Amy
00:25:55 - Details of the Attack
00:27:51 - Prosecutors' Case Against Gareth
00:29:41 - Defense's Claims and Strategies
00:31:58 - Prosecution's Evidence Presentation
00:33:53 - Defense's Closing Arguments
00:35:29 - Jury Deliberation Process
00:37:31 - Impact on Amy's Family and Friends
00:39:41 - Calls for Legal Reform
00:41:34 - Investigation Begins: Amy's Attack
00:46:45 - Drew Carey's Connection to Amy
00:48:27 - Trial Insights and New Evidence
00:52:13 - Michael Herman's Experience
00:56:03 - Surveillance Footage and Planning
01:00:07 - Gareth's Changing Stories
01:02:48 - Defense's Blame the Victim Strategy
01:04:53 - Nicotine Syringe Evidence Explained
01:07:10 - Verdict and Impact Statement
'Michael H did all the right things' ... Who wouldn't run upstairs to help a woman in distress?? He doesn't have survivor's guilt, he's guilty because he chose to run away from his friend in distress like a coward. I wouldn't be able to live with that.
I could live with myself in that house I've lived in a 1920s Dr office/hospital with blood stains on the floor I lived in a mortuary while converting it to a handicap accessible house had a tent and my vehicle in the back of an old cemetery while fixing where yotes digging mice had stones leaning I filled the holes with gravel quick quickcrete and dirt picked up others after leveling the base drilling rebar holes and epoxy them back together then put chainlink fence around the 3 sides that were barbwire
So the dude is sleeping and didn't hear the glass break and the intruders entering? Is that possible?
He did hear it, but he thought it was Aime’s cat knocking something over. As a cat owner for most of my life, I’ve heard many odd sounds in the middle of the night and had to go see what’s going on. So far, it’s always been a cat doing late-night cat stuff.
YOU COULD BE NEXT TO ME ARGUING AND I WONT HEAR IT...SOME PEOPLE ARE HARD SLEEPERS. I SLEEP THREW ANYTHING 😢
Part of me thinks that his defense hated him so much they just couldn’t give a good defense because that was laughable
Rip Amy 🙏❤️🌹🌻🌹❤️ Deep condoglianze for the family and Friends, May God bless you 💞
he is such a wimp that he didnt help her!!!
I'm sure you would do the same 😅 you can just throw words like this until something like this happens to you. 😂
Devastating 😢. These people who obsess are so utterly dangerous. What is most disturbing is when they blame the victim to justify their actions. Sick
48 Hours is incredibly well produced and easy to follow.
Broke Drew Cary's heart.
😢
I know everyone’s entitled to a defense, but cases like this make me feel such anger at them. The ridiculous stories they come up with are embarrassing and hurtful. Shane on them.
this story is somewhat similar to one i have on my channel. a Vietnamese lady by name Nguyen Thi Xian who traveled to Belgium to see her "boyfriend", only to be killed by him and her body burnt beyond recognition. this is all in a bid to cover-up the affair to prevent his live-in girlfriend in Belgium from finding out. something he could have just ghosted her and that will be the end. the family back in Vietnam were worried sick, not knowing their daughter was no more. the case took the police an extra 4 years to uncover the culprit. a very sad case. people are just awful these days.😪☹
Wow this is so sad the woman that was murdered her mother won't even let her father speak every time he tries to speak she cut him off let him have a say too it was his daughter to sorry for you guys is lost may she rest in peace and fly high in the sky with the angels God bless
I could not sit there and hear screaming and not run to her room to help her. He said he couldnt find his phone to call 911 but they wouldnt have gotten there fast enough. Every home should have a home defense gun/weapon. I walked in on a home invasion in my home. I sleep with a gun now. And a Belgian Malinois. I just could not sit there hearing my roommate/friend scream and not react. Of course it's easy to do a "post mortem" but let us use this horrifying , tragic death as a tool to save future victims. Even getting a big dog helps. I pray her family finds peace knowing their precious daughter is with God, doing therapy in Heaven. May she Rest in Peace.
the irony that she broke off her engagement bc she was scared of her ex while she wouldve probably been more save if she hadnt been alone and went through w it😔
I think i met this womderful gal at a show.....and she was taken from us during an event that i almost lost my life too ....an abuser who couldnt handle being told no
Rest in power Dr Amy. Horns up
yay! another repeat! another re-run!
911 call is all wrong. Why not call and say I need a ambulance!! She needs help.?? She was already dead and he knew that!! 😢
Whata beautiful woman she was 😢
If she had just had a gun locked and loaded and ready to use. This is horrific and should not have happened. Unfortunately, here in CA, she would have gotten in trouble for using the gun to defend herself.
sadly you get what you fear. Leaving a celebrity relationship because of fear of a stalker is stupid. At least a celebrity has 5e money to put up safeguards and protection barriers.
No need to call what she did stupid. Seems unnecessary.
How can you be a marriage counselor if you're not married?
She was married previously
There are men who are OB/GYN’s who don’t have vaginas. They go to school.
The roommate ran away are u kidding me!!!weak man unreal
Really Could NOT See This
Girl With Drew Barrymore.
Drew Carey
i remember when this happened. i’m sorry filir her family
I’ve been jealous, I’ve been extremely upset over the way a relationship has ended, I’ve never considered killing a woman. I will never understand these people
I wonder why people don't want to be witnesses in America with cops like these? Mystery
Amie wouldnt have turned out to be such a spectacular woman if it had not been for her parents
What?
How sad. The guy obviously needed help and he never got it, let’s face it his obsession wasn’t with correct thinking. She was beautiful and didn’t need to die.
Lucky the camera caught him
Her mother was a very beautiful young lady. She’s attractive now, but was quite gorgeous when she was younger.
Love 48 hours. Wish the music would be turned down so I could hear the people talk better
So she dated him because he was handsome and ignored the warning signs. Ladies, wise up. ⬆️
Ihave this Episode memorized almost! Stop the reruns
The roommate should go on trial for the revocation of his man card. After the guilty verdict, change his name to Michele.
Yes I was shocked he didn't at least try to see where she was and if she was okay or shout out her name or something!
🎉❤🎉🎉❤🎉 THANK YOU 🎉❤🎉❤🎉🎉😮
Beautiful girl.
He looks like he's hearing the defense stories for the first time as well.
My heart breaks for her parents, family , and friends.
Drew could have protected her
This case is heartbreaking. However the defense has nothing but bad facts to work with and an obligation to vigorously defend their client. I would rather have them smear the victim a little bit than not if it helps a conviction stick.
Relationship violence is difficult
This sounds like the movie” fear” came to real life .. he even looks like mark wahlburg .. so sad when a person gets so obsessed with someone they literally won’t let them go live without them 😡😢 it’s even sadder that she was helping ppl with these similar issues and she got stuck with someone who should have been a patient .. r.i.p beautiful
Well before he blew up and looks like life was unkind to him since too !!!
He was professional killer he knew about the Nicotine injection 😢
this is re-upload
Ironic and sad.
❤ sorry for your loss RIP Amy
Aime was absolutely amazing, beautiful and intelligent.
Justice always for Aimee.
RIP Aime
Why do they keep posting the same episode over and over ?
This makes me feel sad about Amie. She was so smart and ❤️ very stunning lady. Her parents are so heartbroken 😭 I'm so sorry for your loss of Amie. RIP sweet angel 😇
Roommate is the reason she is dead.He should of been charged to.F'in coward.
Amie ❤ 🙏
This case broke me.
This is an incredibly tragic story for the Harwick family
Love from italy 😢
What a beautiful human being , Rip Amie.
Narcissist self loving psycho if he's kept hold of her for that long. I hope he rots.
Gareth’s mother saying to Amie’s mother that she was sorry about “what HAD HAPPENED to her daughter”
🤦♀️ shows she is still in denial that her monster of a son MURDERED Amie! The way she worded it, she speaks as if it was an accident
It's impossible to definitively say how many people were killed by individuals who were themselves killed by nicotine, as there are no reliable statistics tracking such a specific scenario; however, the most relevant example would be the case of Erzsébet Papp, also known as "The Nicotine Killer," a Hungarian serial killer who poisoned four people with nicotine, leading to her own execution for her crimes.
Key points to remember:
No large-scale data exists:
There is no comprehensive data tracking deaths caused by people who were themselves killed by nicotine poisoning.
Erzsébet Papp case:
The only well-known instance where someone directly killed others using nicotine poisoning is the case of Erzsébet Papp, who murdered four people.
Nicotine is primarily lethal through smoking:
Most deaths related to nicotine are due to long-term tobacco use, not direct poisoning of others.
Smoking - Our World in Data
The WHO estimates that more than 8 million people die prematurely yearly from tobacco use. This is the latest available WHO estima...
Our World in Data
Nicotine poisoning - Wikipedia
E-cigarette exposure cases in the US National Poison Data System increased greatly between 2010 and 2014, peaking at 3,742 in 2014...
Wikipedia
Erzsébet Papp - Wikipedia
Erzsébet Papp (January 28, 1935 - January 23, 1962), known as The Nicotine Killer or her married name "Mrs. János Holhos", was a H...
Wikipedia
Show all
This is for informational purposes only. For medical advice or diagnosis, consult a professional. Generative AI is experimental.
Life is so unfair 😔 her parents don’t deserve to go through this!
Anne Marie sears is turning the attention on to herself instead of Amy
RIP Amie- you are a light in this world.
we DESPERATELY NEED STRONGER LAWS PROTECTION DATABASES MANDATORY MINIMUMS EASE OF ACCESS MORE ALLOWABLE EVIDENCE ALL ABUSE IS DANGEROUS- ITS A SLOPE. I had to fight for my life and I still live in fear of him daily. Its HORRIBLE. People deserve lifetime protection too. THE STATISTICS ARE HORRIFYING ❤
The absence of faith in these people is obvious. Praying they’ll find peace.
I'm Erin Moriarty 👂
😢 such a beautiful woman. She looked fo full of life. So souful and feminine. A rose in this ugly world. R.I.P
How big of a loser do you have to be to live every day just planning to hurt someone you cant have.
Why did he refer to her as a roommate? There was two separate apartments within one building. Stalking laws have to be changed and judges need to take the issue of stalking more seriously no matter what the job of the the complainant. I think when the first judge saw that she was a sex therapist, he ignored the seriousness of her concerns. I believe she would still be alive if that first protective ordered had been in place.
WOW does he look different at trial! I me ean WOW! Little 🐖 has been eating well in jail. SMH. Sickening
Omg 48 hours please stop the ads every 2 minutes!
Spend 2 bucks a week and you won't get them. It's worth it.
@isabelpark7650 In the U.S. it's I3.99 a month which is just about 3.50 a week. Some of us don't want to pay another monthly bill especially to Google.
@@annb8296Fair enough. There is also Ad Block which is about 3 bucks a month
What a heartbreaking episode.
Such a beautiful young lady with a bright brilliant future.
And what a loser of an ex boyfriend….
I hope he’s enjoying his 3 hots and a cot….😂
I can’t watch this because his cowardice is making me EXTREMELY angry