I met Siouxsie once, when she was on tour as the Creatures in the States. The theater was packed, but after the show, not even one percent gathered round where she would be signing autographs. I l know because I stayed to see her. So much worth it, too bad I was just another guy with social anxiety, not saying much but willing to see Siouxsie face to face for a moment in time. Pun intended, my lovely foe. I wish I had words, but, even if I did, she only really had time to sign autographs for people there. At least she did that, how can you forget when Siouxsie is just a few feet from you. How come this is one memory that will be, "Close to you til the last beat of my heart"? I just keep wading in the heart shaped pool of pain, not knowing any better to get out. Hey, that is what 30 years of social anxiety will do to you, you know? I am always delayed, kiss them for me.
The consensus, over the many years, is that: THIS is the definitive version of "Sin In My Heart". I heard Nocturne in 1985, and I agree. I love how, in this performance, Siouxsie is so in the moment, yet, seems so cool and non-reflective over what she just did..."This is what I do, and this is who I am...nothing more, nothing less." I hope she plays that (magical, majestic) Blue Tear Drop Semi-Acoustic electric guitar again, in the very near future. It's a part of her and her musical legacy.
@@anthonyyoutubefan7567 i agree with you, this is the best version of Sin In My Heart ever. I like 1981 Cologne live version too but this with Robert Smith its perfect.
@@pressureworks yes but he's seldom mentioned within the realm of rock despite him being a very unique drummer. For me, he's seldom talked about when people run off names of great drummers, hence my OP. .
I was there on the Friday show,,it was amazing,perfect,,,and the support band Fad Gadget was awesome,,Budgies drums left a ringing in my ears all night,,the railings we held on to at the top floor amazing,,,the logo jumping was only about 3 to 5 rows from the front,,,,A super night to remember,,,,
Have a look at the videos of McGeoch doing Sin in my Heart a couple of years earlier. Smith does well with his interpretation of it but McGeoch was a god.
Thank you for sharing this classic track syrex33, it is the clearest sound and video i have seen of a young Siouxsie Sioux, for this particular track Awesome! (Trouble is with this song, sadly and prematurely over too soon).
They're from the Nocturne live CD and DVD recorded in the Royal Albert Hall. I saw them for about 9 euros on the internet. You should check the other video's aswell, Helter Skelter, Eve White/Eve Black, Painted Bird and Spellbound will impress you. There's also a complete set from 81 on youtube by user skywalker 74. Nearly the same set, couple of other songs. ENJOY! P.S. why doesn't it show my comment when I reply...pfff
Another live version of that masterpiece of violent lust, Sin in My Heart, by SATB. This one from 1983. The tortured genius John McGeoch has been replaced by Robert Smith. We see Smith's absolute technical mastery, down to his spare, martial movements on stage even. He is like a samurai sword master with his guitar. McGeoch was more like a being merged with his guitar, becoming the instrument itself. Smith is magnificent. I prefer McGeoch.
I refuse to decide which one I like better. They're both geniuses, and their playing styles are so different that it's not even an apples to apples comparison. More like apples to bicycles. I happen to like both apples and bicycles.
stevobath The Banshees sacking of John started the long slow demise of both parties. They should have cut back on the touring - to rest John AND Siouxsie - and managed that amazing lineup better. Neither recaptured the brilliance of those two short years.
stevobath it probably did save him, but while he was alive they never called him back to rejoin even after john got sobered up, It must have bothered him to be released like that, he was good in PIL but sadly he never was the same like he was in the banshees era
I’ve fallen down a Siouxsie and the Banshees rabbit-hole, and I will never leave
I have been down that hole since the winter of 1982. It is glorious down here, join us.
I met Siouxsie once, when she was on tour as the Creatures in the States. The theater was packed, but after the show, not even one percent gathered round where she would be signing autographs. I l know because I stayed to see her. So much worth it, too bad I was just another guy with social anxiety, not saying much but willing to see Siouxsie face to face for a moment in time. Pun intended, my lovely foe. I wish I had words, but, even if I did, she only really had time to sign autographs for people there. At least she did that, how can you forget when Siouxsie is just a few feet from you. How come this is one memory that will be, "Close to you til the last beat of my heart"? I just keep wading in the heart shaped pool of pain, not knowing any better to get out. Hey, that is what 30 years of social anxiety will do to you, you know? I am always delayed, kiss them for me.
Budgie is a rock solid drummer, a machine. Severin is a no frills, steady bassist and Siouxsie is just delicious!
And, Smith was brilliant.
@@JRStephens5005 no shit.
Another Siouxsie eargasm!
Great guitar interplay between Siouxsie and Robert Smith.
Typically great Siouxsie vocal penetration. Rocks!
i love you mom
Nocturne is the best live album I own. Bought in December 1983 and still listen once a month minimum. I love this version of this song
The consensus, over the many years, is that: THIS is the definitive version of "Sin In My Heart". I heard Nocturne in 1985, and I agree. I love how, in this performance, Siouxsie is so in the moment, yet, seems so cool and non-reflective over what she just did..."This is what I do, and this is who I am...nothing more, nothing less." I hope she plays that (magical, majestic) Blue Tear Drop Semi-Acoustic electric guitar again, in the very near future. It's a part of her and her musical legacy.
@@anthonyyoutubefan7567 i agree with you, this is the best version of Sin In My Heart ever. I like 1981 Cologne live version too but this with Robert Smith its perfect.
Budgie is one under rated drummer
Largactyl Kid not at all. He's still highly regarded.
@@pressureworks yes but he's seldom mentioned within the realm of rock despite him being a very unique drummer. For me, he's seldom talked about when people run off names of great drummers, hence my OP. .
You Joker maybe, but matters not. The fact that countless fans dig him is in the end, all that matters.
Amazing performance such a strong sound for 83?! Crazy shit I love the 80’s 90’s music forever!
Her voice in night shift definitely has so much emotion and the the whole band is amazing.
I was there on the Friday show,,it was amazing,perfect,,,and the support band Fad Gadget was awesome,,Budgies drums left a ringing in my ears all night,,the railings we held on to at the top floor amazing,,,the logo jumping was only about 3 to 5 rows from the front,,,,A super night to remember,,,,
Robert kills it. He does a fantastic job.
Have a look at the videos of McGeoch doing Sin in my Heart a couple of years earlier. Smith does well with his interpretation of it but McGeoch was a god.
@@65BigNorm agreed - McGeoch created the guitar part and Smith does a good cover - nowhere near as good a performance as the original folks in 1981
Wow !! ❤️💋great to see Siouxsie play guitar she should play more often please
THIS MUST HAVE BEEN ONE OF THE BEST GIGS EVER!! AMAZING ENERGY... IN THE DARK
Man, they sound good here. I wish she had played guitar more often.
The more i listen to this wonderful band the more i adore their music ❤️
Me too
Her voice is SO powerful , Truly the Queen 👑
Es un lujo ver a siouxie y Robert smith juntos.
How come the quality of the 40 year old footage is so good?
Better hope to die before get old,didnt make it....
Siouxsie could kick Chuck Norris’ a** with her voice
Last person standing deathmatch
She is an absolute phenom.. an enigma.. by far one of the greatest musicians to ever play. Her band as well.
Siouxsie and her Banshees are truly Iconic! This sound is one of a kind, this will always be one of my favourite tracks of theirs.
Never realised Siouxsie was playing guitar on this. She makes it look simple with that one finger chord :)
Magistral la doña Susan
Oh, to have been there.
Excellent. Nearly 30 years since I first listened to this. Still love it.
Siouxsie and the Banshees.... A divine sin penetrates my heart like a dagger...
It didn’t get any better than that, pure class
Mis Banshees favoritos con el gran Robert Smith
Love Siouxsie and her blue guitar!!!
What's a great voice
Greatest of all time!
BONE FUCKING CHILLING WITH THE DRUMMS AND SYNTHSS GUITAR ROBERT Does superb
Absolutely Love Siouxsie & the Banchees
If I had heard this I would have kept my 383 Cuda'! Cruising around listening to Souixie & banchees!
Sioux for ever!
BANSHEES FOREVER 1985 BABY
Great performance! Thank you.
Saw them live in Paris December 1982 I was 13 yo
Thank you for sharing this classic track syrex33, it is the clearest sound and video i have seen of a young Siouxsie Sioux, for this particular track Awesome! (Trouble is with this song, sadly and prematurely over too soon).
Regardless what people say, I like Robert Smith on guitar, however I prefer John McGeoch.
They're from the Nocturne live CD and DVD recorded in the Royal Albert Hall. I saw them for about 9 euros on the internet.
You should check the other video's aswell, Helter Skelter, Eve White/Eve Black, Painted Bird and Spellbound will impress you. There's also a complete set from 81 on youtube by user skywalker 74. Nearly the same set, couple of other songs. ENJOY!
P.S. why doesn't it show my comment when I reply...pfff
Great video! I got to tell you some of Robert's guitar playing made me think of Daniel Ash's guitar playing in Bauhaus' Bela Lugosi's Dead.
it doesn't get much better than this!
Best version!
Never has been.. never will be a better performance than this.
I wish I were there, fuck, I was born too late!
i love her! the one and only
Sends shivers up my spine
Just amazing!
Absolutely brilliant
Increible!
...fascinate!!!
Beautiful but sinister music. I have always loved it, but it really is a guilty pleasure. Haha.
Awesome!
hermosa canción
Da hora essa música rock 🤩🤩👍
ESPECTACULAR !!!!!! :D :D :D Gracias por subirlo.
great
Year: 2083 - In the future people still listening SATB. Hello people do futuro! Como que tá aí? (I'm dEAD)
..as usual :-)
Whoever directed this is pointing the camera at the wrong place. Budgie should be on screen for 95% of this.
But then we would no longer be witnesses to the spectacle of Siouxie absolutely killing it on guitar.
Another live version of that masterpiece of violent lust, Sin in My Heart, by SATB. This one from 1983. The tortured genius John McGeoch has been replaced by Robert Smith. We see Smith's absolute technical mastery, down to his spare, martial movements on stage even. He is like a samurai sword master with his guitar. McGeoch was more like a being merged with his guitar, becoming the instrument itself. Smith is magnificent. I prefer McGeoch.
I prefer Robert Smith.
I refuse to decide which one I like better. They're both geniuses, and their playing styles are so different that it's not even an apples to apples comparison. More like apples to bicycles. I happen to like both apples and bicycles.
💎
❤❤
pj harvey...eat your heart out.
Yeah, she could never hold her own next to Sioux.
@stettpl It's more pointy and elavated that probably what you're more used to.
Didn't know Sioux could play guitar
Awesome performance. :)
40 years later - Siouxsie still posses that Vox teardrop and plays it on stage.
ua-cam.com/video/WU_X7yDIAB8/v-deo.html
The Cure in their height of fame and brilliance but the lead singer with a cult following still knew his place
Got a bit of Patti Smith in it this performance, which is not a bad thing
In the dark..
she looks sooooooocoll with a guitar^^
The sequel to this moment was during Meltdown 2013, when she strapped it on again, performing, "Paradise Place".
where's robert? I can't notice his raggy hair
Should not have sacked McGeoch, should you...
They didn't sack him. He had a nervous breakdown.
stevobath they did sack him after his breakdown which he passed out on stage, he was fired because of his drinking
LightFromADeadStar I think it was more underhand than just sacking him out right though. Still, I think it probably saved Johns life at the time?
stevobath The Banshees sacking of John started the long slow demise of both parties. They should have cut back on the touring - to rest John AND Siouxsie - and managed that amazing lineup better. Neither recaptured the brilliance of those two short years.
stevobath it probably did save him, but while he was alive they never called him back to rejoin even after john got sobered up, It must have bothered him to be released like that, he was good in PIL but sadly he never was the same like he was in the banshees era
they really think they gulch
I like the line up with John mcgeoch better
John McKay was better.
Budgies drums are lost here... not like other performances
GULCH
john will always be a better banshee then robert
they're both beautiful. just enjoy the music.
I disagree.