No, but it is a good version, a little bit soft for me. Dylan's version is head and shoulders above it. He is telling a tale, and I believe it and am there with him.
Some how, i punch in one word and transition from Texas music (Freddie Fender) to HHF!. i had the awesome experience to catch them in downtown Denver, CO, USA - summer of 1993. Free show, city park of some sort, and one band member didn't have passport. End Result! Great Show, and i have been a Hot House Fan ever since! Love to all the fans and to the power of music! Left Eye Gibby
I,'ve asked that question myself.The sheer amount of talent on this island and it's getting better by the year. There is an explanation but I do not have it.
Such a good song, everyone wants to sing it, from Dylan to Daniel. I sing it in the bath. Such a great song all versions, i love em all, keep singing!!!!!
this song was recorded for a BBC/ RTE show called "Bringing It All Back Home." If anyone has the clip from the show please upload it. It is such a haunting and emotional song. This song can be found on double cd soundtrack to the series of the same name. it's well worth adding to your collection.
God Harper,. Had toned We thoughts we could Play And when, we do,. We could Find, them, as to whether A day, and then the room Was founded, again The married, hes no wherever Only, peace, ❤❤❤
It is a dam good version. It was totally different, from Paul Brady's and Christy Moores version. This was also important. The Hothouse Flowers, always had great respect for our music and song tradition.
Michael Dineen All this talk about "our" music and "our" tradition isn't healthy- as Liam himself once said: "Traditional music doesn't belong to me - I belong to it!"
Wow an amazing version first time i heard this i was used to paul bradys version but i think liam o maonlai's is better. Think ill be using this version when singing it cheers dude ;)
The definition of cultural appropriation: Taking a folk song from Louisiana... Slap an Irish twist on it because of a pop cover in the 70s that had marginal success... Throw up a picture of the Irish coastline despite the song literally being set in the Louisiana swamps... Then pass it off as if everything about what I just wrote was normal.
Would there even be folk songs from Louisiana if it wasn't musicians from one genre finding inspiration from musicians of another? This a respectful rendition by some excellent performers. Try to enjoy!
Unrecognizable- This is a terrible version of this song- its like a choirboy singing when the whole spirit of this song begs it to be catarwhalled like a sea shanty!
the best version of this song i ever heard
Fantastic band. Had the pleasure of sharing a taxi from Dublin Airport with Liam on All Ireland final day 2017
Just seen the flowers perform this live last night. Filled my heart ❤ Amazing.
Phenomenal. Beyond words.....!
by far the finest version thanks
It's Lìam's amazing vòìce and the sax which give this version a dimension of its own
No, but it is a good version, a little bit soft for me.
Dylan's version is head and shoulders above it.
He is telling a tale, and I believe it and am there with him.
@@torvilasulvstle362 No - you and Dylan got lost - but you have each other for company and that's a consolation - Tis Xmas, be of good cheer
@@cahillgreg Good Xmas to you too!
Stunning version of a beautiful song, been a favourite for years, Liam absolutely nails it !
Got to see them play it live in Santa Barbara, California after Liam asked the audience for any request. I yelled this one out....thanks Liam!
Thanks for posting this......the best version I have heard'
I came across it on the TV programme "Bringing it all Back Home"
I first heard it on a Disney special about Irish music in America in about 1995.
It doesn't get any better. Thanks for sharing.
Finally, this beautiful song from Hot House Flowers. The sax is amazing. Thank you so much for posting.
Leo Barnes sex plays beautifully off Liam's vocals :)
Some how, i punch in one word and transition from Texas music (Freddie Fender) to HHF!.
i had the awesome experience to catch them in downtown Denver, CO, USA - summer of 1993.
Free show, city park of some sort, and one band member didn't have passport.
End Result! Great Show, and i have been a Hot House Fan ever since! Love to all the fans and to the power of music!
Left Eye Gibby
The man from Strabane (Brady) does an excellent version but this is tops! The sax and piano steals it.
When listening an artist I just listen and do not 'compare'...this is terrific.
Thanks for sharing joe ....beautiful xx
Liam's voice is the embodiment of folk
How is that there are so many great Irish bands and singer/songwriters?
I,'ve asked that question myself.The sheer amount of talent on this island and it's getting better by the year. There is an explanation but I do not have it.
we come from a nation of singer songwriters :) it really has carried through the years
The Irish Celtic, and as such throughout their history always the performing arts. It' s genetic.
Guinness, Jameson, and heartbreak
@@bryansbtsongs106
Dolt.
this song was made for him...the music lets the vocals tell you the story off the song..
beautiful vision of this song....loving it : )
Beautiful, very haunting, wish I was standing on that beach dreaming
Such a good song, everyone wants to sing it, from Dylan to Daniel. I sing it in the bath.
Such a great song all versions, i love em all, keep singing!!!!!
Sandro the Hothouse Wildflower 👍
Because
My Favourite Version since i heard on the documentary "Bringing it all home" thanks for uploading....compaverick
An excellent double tape of that documentary has long gone - but iTunes might be worth a trawl?
this song was recorded for a BBC/ RTE show called "Bringing It All Back Home." If anyone has the clip from the show please upload it. It is such a haunting and emotional song. This song can be found on double cd soundtrack to the series of the same name. it's well worth adding to your collection.
Kindness and without expectation, why don't we sing about more? Well we have this song, and there is no better version than this.
Still listening 2021
Love this Version
Liam so unique you all over - first time hearing it & will not be my last
Wonderful.
God Harper,. Had toned
We thoughts we could Play
And when, we do,. We could
Find, them, as to whether
A day, and then the room
Was founded, again
The married, hes no wherever
Only, peace, ❤❤❤
Well I was on Ballyconneely Beach near Clifden recently and hanker after that too
I ❤❤❤ hold a storm
But i Cant alone,.
It is a dam good version. It was totally different, from Paul Brady's and Christy Moores version. This was also important. The Hothouse Flowers, always had great respect for our music and song tradition.
True
Gigi Zabel
It was just another way' of referring to the music we have in Ireland.
Michael Dineen
All this talk about "our" music and "our" tradition isn't healthy- as Liam himself once said: "Traditional music doesn't belong to me - I belong to it!"
Personally I don't hear where the major difference is in this version. He sings the melody the same way PBrady does.
thanks for posting
love the sax solo
even the mention of cowen singing this doesn't put me of it :p
Wonderfull rendition
Also heard this on the BBC/RTE documentary series back in the 90's. I wish they'd re-run that sometime.
Bringing it all back home :)
Coastal scenes of Ireland but singing about Louisiana. There you have it.
what can I say, brought the Sage in Newcastle alive. well worth going to see them.
❤❤❤
Some voice, some song, some hard to sing for me hahaha but I love it.
all about a memory of falling in love and being crushed. classic
Wow an amazing version first time i heard this i was used to paul bradys version but i think liam o maonlai's is better. Think ill be using this version when singing it cheers dude ;)
❤
haunting.....in a good way
thanks to compaverick for uploading this version it's my favorite especialy the sax solo
Is this Liam O'Maonlai singing?
yes
yea,yea,yea,compaverick uploaded it but I asked him to thanks again comp
@cesnor - Yeah, it's Liam
WRITTEN IN OR FOR NAWLINS?
MET A GUY IN PAT OS SAID HE WROTE A SONG CALLED LADY OF PONCHARTRAIN
only 981 hits??? and x factor prob has millions.....doesnt make much sense.....thanks for posting.....love the sax solo.....
By boat passed you in the storm
And i came wouded, and you walked over me Fanø Danmark
You sick crew so i hire no one
I pased England ireland as a dark shade
The definition of cultural appropriation: Taking a folk song from Louisiana... Slap an Irish twist on it because of a pop cover in the 70s that had marginal success... Throw up a picture of the Irish coastline despite the song literally being set in the Louisiana swamps... Then pass it off as if everything about what I just wrote was normal.
Is that Downhill Strand Co. Londonderry?...🤔
Would there even be folk songs from Louisiana if it wasn't musicians from one genre finding inspiration from musicians of another? This a respectful rendition by some excellent performers. Try to enjoy!
Really nice version, but its cadence and rhythm is exactly like Paul Bradys version. Think Paul bradys version is what made this song what it is.
Botney band
Unrecognizable- This is a terrible version of this song- its like a choirboy singing when the whole spirit of this song begs it to be catarwhalled like a sea shanty!