Is Hornby's New Turbomotive Worth £240? | Unboxing & Review
Вставка
- Опубліковано 15 лип 2024
- Get a Turbomotive here: bit.ly/46Ahp8d (Affiliate)
A full review of Hornby's all new Stanier LMS "Turbomotive"
Become a Sam'sTrains engineer here: / @samstrains
Get your Sam'sTrains merch: teespring.com/stores/bullmane...
Thanks for watching!
Email: samstrains@outlook.com
Instagram: / samstrainsofficial
Facebook: / samstrains
Twitter: / samstrains
0:00 Intro
4:38 Unboxing
10:32 Prototype Info
13:00 Detail
22:44 Mechanism
27:47 Performance
33:42 Haulage
41:48 Ratings
46:03 Final Thoughts - Авто та транспорт
That's more expensive than a lot of washing machines and they have a huge motor, loads of metal, lots of lights and cleans my undies 😮.
You're right - you can buy a heck of a lot for that amount of money!
Thanks for watching, Sam :)
This is the greatest comment on the internet
Great comment 👍🏻 😂
A Hornby washing machine would probably be about £5,000!
Do you know when I said that on the Hornby Forum I got loads of people moaning at me. Then you get the comparisons with German and US models which are more expensive. When other manufacturers can make better models for less then it shows how expensive they are. Incidentally, I bought the sound one, ordered it about a year ago and the front bogie derails on my layout. Interestingly Sam, considering that all the rivet counters complain about your test track neither this nor the P2 derailed during your reviews, but it did regularly on my and others layouts. So your layout can't be that bad.
I've been into model railways/ tramways for about 50 years but the prices now are crazy.
I as a pensioner live on £500 a month , how can any independent modeller afford something like that
I agree with you - I do have to ask whether these prices are really necessary. Also, as nice as the extra features are, I wonder if the model would be better without them, and sold more cheaply?
Thanks for watching, Sam :)
cheers from germany mate...but how can you live on 500 gbp anyway...modeller or not..??...all the best from here to you....
Yes, I agree with you, but most model hobbies are very expensive these days. Just plastic model kits are pretty costly.
I'd expect a newly tooled, well-running, and nicely detailed loco to be around 200 quid these days.
The thing that irks me the most is selling old models at similar prices. Tooling costs should be recovered in early runs, then re-runs should be cheaper.
I feel your pain. As an LMS guy, I'd love one of these - but can't afford it this year. I blew my budget on an Accurascale class 31.
The reality is manufacturers are not a charity, they have to make a profit and will sell at whatever price people will pay, regardless of those on lower incomes., and sorry to say those that can't afford the prices are not their target market.
We are in fact very lucky in the UK. If you compare Hornby and other UK manufacturers with Piko, Roco, Märklin, Trix, Brawa, Fleischmann etc you will see most of their prices are nearly double what we pay in the UK.
In reality model railway prices have risen less than many other manufactured goods.
Fellow pensioner here; there is no way I can justify these hideous prices. But, do I need a Turbomotive? Well, possibly. But, if you think about it, all it is is a Princess Royal minus its Walschaerts valve gear plus a bit of casing covering the forward and reverse turbines.
So, take a Lizzie remove its valve gear and cylinders and you have a choice of fashioning your own casings from metal or even, as I do, from balsa wood soaked in wood hardener from a woodrot repair kit and sanded really smooth. I have used the technique over many years to produce sports car bodies not made by "cheaper" makers. Follow with 6 to 8 thin coats of paint, hand rubbed, and apply lining via a bow pen or lining tool. Result: one Turbomotive at a bargain price!
Hi Sam, a couple of points from an LMS anorak. You say a couple of times this was rebuilt as a standard Princess, but actually Princess Anne, as it was called, was also unique. It had a more Duchess like steam chest and cylinders. It is good that the radiator flap at the front moves because on the real thing it would be up when running but down when idle.
You might be able to tell me if the train classification lamps are illuminated in daytime running like so many expect from what many here call "headlights".
@@johnd8892 the loco's lamps should be lit at all times while running for working through tunnels. they are purely for marking the train class and each end of the train but provide no illumination. Modern image traction will have the high intensity lights fitted which provide some degree of illumination but i'm not sure how they compare to a car headlight.
Destroyed in the Harrow collision.
I’m still feeling sick paying $600 for a brass hybrid BLI locomotive, had to destroy receipt before wife found it 😬😵
hahaha blimey... good thinking on the receipt! ;D
Thanks for watching, Sam :)
Jew pay cash or card?
Hornby's prices have been really skyrocketing lately. I was discouraged from getting my own APT set, but luckily I was able to pick one up pre-owned from Hattons for almost half of the price. What a steal!
I feel like Hornby should be featuring fan-driven smoke units at these price points. :\
Even at that price you paid too much. Train collections Worldwide have lost value.
@@robertcornelius3514 eh 214 pounds for a 5-car APT seems fine.
Meanwhile in China model railway companies are making DCC fitted China Railways diesels with sound, smoke units, cab lights, dashboard lights, engine room lights, bogie inspection lights and working roof fans for under 200 pounds. I know it sounds crazy but it's true. Oh and the whole body is diecast too.
That's what you Brits get when the factory making your models is half a globe away lol.
Through the camera, the light on the back looks very authentic for oil lamps. They aren't bright at all in real life!
Washing machines sell by the million so costs spread by the million, I used to see the turbo at Stafford on Saturday mornings, roughly 11.15 off to Liverpool, grime covered, blinkers fitted, as i was about 11 or 12 years old it really intreaged me, I yearned to see it and everything else in full LMS livery and now I can, I'm 86, not in good health and I absolutely love it and all the beautiful LMS stuff that modelling allows, thank you to all manufacturers and to you Sam for showing all the stuff that you do Pete
Nice recollection, the real loco must of been a sight for sore eyes.
I was living at Watford when the multiple Harrow collision occurred. Princess Anne, then newly converted to conventional drive was totally destroyed.
I'm an American (Texan). At RRP (not counting shipping and keeping VAT, cuz some shops exclude it for overseas orders, some don't) it comes out to $323 USD (21 hrs of work for me before taxes).
For around that price (give or take a couple bucks & still excluding shipping) I can buy:
Approximately 1,300 rounds of 9mm ammunition
About 40 meals from various fast food restaurants (Subway footlong sandwiches, entire pizzas, hamburgers w/ drink & fries [chips for yall Brits])
A decent pistol chambered in .22LR and about 650 rounds of said ammunition (did buy the pistol as a birthday present to myself)
4,875 rounds of .22LR ammunition (very underpowered round. More for fun/training at a shooting range than self defense)
With an additional 20-30 bucks I can buy a very basic AR-15 rifle, fully assembled (kits can be cheaper if you find good deals)
Granted, Texas-based Gun Nut may not have the best price comparisons for yall Brits, but entire weapons or easily 2 week's worth of (admittedly unhealthy) meals.
Hornby what the hell are yall on man.
Yeah that's right - it's a crazy amount of money! I get there are serious costs involved, but there are also other manufacturers who manage to come up with much better prices!
Thanks for watching, Sam :)
2 years ago I bought my son his first car for exactly this price 😂. It’s a 1994 Renault 21 2.1L turbo diesel with a full service history and every option available at the time.
He’s still using it regularly to do 500 mile trips from home to university on the other side of France.
The bag of plastic parts is clearly a new common accessories pack - it's identical to the one that came in the P2 boxes, and I imagine the brake rigging is standardised for any Pacific locomotive.
Anyone thinking of buying this for a DCC layout should add the price tag for Hornby's new 21-pin decoder too - ouch! You're into Broadway Limited kind of money already!
Typical of Hornby to create a heavy model at last & then they go & skimp on the motor's horse-power! I think I'll stick to my trusty old Tri-ang-Hornby Princess. She may be a little noisy at 60 ++ years old but she still looks a treat & runs like there's no tomorrow! Turbo...eat yet heart out! & ;good luck if you decide to re-spray the Turbo-Tender to match the front end colour lol. Great video thanks Sam. You have come a long way with your presentation since the early days on your channel...just sooooo professional & thorough these days. The picture & sound quality has got so much better. Keep up the good work my son. Cheers. A.
Hey Sam! Great and honest review here, as always.
I do have a tip for you. I own one of the Dublo range Scotsman centenary models, which have diecast bodies. I had to run it in for longer at a slightly higher speed to fully loosen up the mechanism (roughly 45 mins in each direction, at 55-60 speed). Once I had done that, it performed exactly the same as my main range A1 with decent crawl and good torque. The more I ran it, the more it started to match my other Hornby locos in performance. Hope this helps!
Many thanks my friend - and thanks for these tips... might as well give this some more running and see what happens then, cheers for that,
Thanks for watching, Sam :)
Another great review, I have been following your show for some time now and must say you are developing it to amazing levels, especially the 3d printing side, I watch every show as soon as they are released, great entertainment, keep up the great work.
As soon as i saw this on hornby a model world, i knew you would eventually review it, such a stunning model, and as always a great video
hahaha yeah no doubt about it - and stunning indeed!! :D
Thanks for watching, Sam :)
Great video, fella. Always good to see modelling happening. Can't wait to see the next video with trains running round
Sam, about a year ago we in the US got our own steam turbine locomotive from BLI, the PRR S2, I paid $800 for it, mostly made of brass. I would love to see your thoughts on one, especially after reviewing this locomotive.
hi sam. going to keep this short and bitter sweet. back lamp i noticed that while driving forward it lit up white when it should be red and in revers it lit up red when it should be white. hornby shoddy finished product.
Oh interesting - I'll have to double check that... it's so hard to see with the naked eye you wouldn't notice!
Thanks for watching, Sam :)
Samuel's TRAINS is back at it again with another obscure model locomotive.
Awesome video Sam, The reason steam turbines don't work on locomotives is that at High speed they're great, but at low speed, they're terrible. This is why all US Steam Turbine locomotives were never successful. At Least William Stainer's attempt was somewhat successful.
Again a great and honest review thank you Sam.
Just ordered the DCC/sound fitted version. As soon as it gets to Los Angeles I’ll give it a run and update this reply. Thanks for sharing your thoughts with us.
Much appreciated. All the best from California 👍
Hornby is pricing itself out existence. It is only a matter of time.
As I model the Liverpool
to Manchester line I’ve nagged Hornby for years to produce it. Yes it’s expensive but, I allowed this in my budgeting for this year. So for me it’s worth it. The front hinged plate was to allow more air into the radiator for an oil bath that lubricated the turbines.
Ahh fantastic - well it's a great model, I'm sure you'll enjoy it!
Thanks for watching, Sam :)
@@SamsTrains ...and the locomotive usually ran with the air intake open. Which is probably why they made it an option to open or close it. Take a look at pictures of the loco running, you can almost always see the plate at an angle (open).
The maroon livery is stunning.
This completes my collection of every Stanier pacific
This sealed the deal for me, I’m sticking to my plarail for the foreseeable future!
I have been wanting one of these for ages
I made one of these with a Crownline conversion kit on a Hornby Princess Royal. This is in a different league. I love those lamps!
Ahh fantastic - yeah the lamps are quite impressive aren't they??
Thanks for watching, Sam :)
No. The lamps are not realistic. On the real thing they are barely visible, even head on. Three lamps would only be carried on royal trains and when hauling a train no lamp would be carried on the tender. . @@SamsTrains
Good review Sam , well done
Hello Sam, a very informative and useful review of an unusual loco for which thank you. I believe that Hornby Doublo experience a similar problem with the liveries of the loco vs tender due to the fact that the paint performed differently when applied to a diecast metal loco body vs a plastic bodied tender. Sounds like today's Hornby is experiencing the same issue. Thanks again.
Just awesome! Such a lovely model.
Your reviews helped me choose between the Turbomotive and the W1 when I was visiting from across the pond (I went with the Turbomotive, obviously, and I love it!) Thank You!
Awesome video today Sam beautiful locomotive I think I might get the br black one
Sam love your videos and your layout
Thank you Alex! :D
Awesome review Sam!
Thank you! :D
For about 490 pounds I bought a "used" (model was clean, box looked like it may have been opened twice) Broadway Limited Paragon 2 UP-1 4-12-2, which is DCC and sound, is (I believe) a brass hybrid, and if it's not the whole thing is metal, has a smoke unit in it and even has working class lights.
It's a better value than the past several things you've reviewed from Hornby but I don't know how good of a value it is considering that I bought a brand new BLI Reading T-1 for an extra 100 USD that also has sound, smoke and all
I had no idea she was involved at Harrow and Wealdstone, that was a neat tidbit to learn!
Amazing detail and paintwork
About the front coupling, I think it might just be a spare? Given the very small reverse turbine you'd never run a train tender-first with it so that mean there's less demand for a front coupling? Just my conjecture. Fantastic video as always! :)
Well the front lamps are certainly a quality feature, and quite expensive to have fitted by the retailers, a real shame that the rest of it doesn't really match that one specific feature.
You certainly convinced me to save my money on this for the foreseeable future!
Awesome video Sam's trains
Thanks Brian! :D
Factory fitted lighting on a steam locomotive is a new standard. I don’t try think it justifies the cost, but just when I thought we had reached “peak model,” we get this.
Hi sam
I hope you and Chloe are well?
I've just received mine like 2 mins ago.
Where the exploded diagram I do like to look at them.
From what I can see from mine it looks amazing
Defo heavy
I'll continue watching yours after I have recorded the detail parts of mine
Thank you for sharing your models with us
Keep safe ARP
Thanks my friend, hope you and yours are well too! Very heavy indeed, good luck with yours! :D
Thanks for watching, Sam :)
I remember the old R066 Hornby Duchess of Sutherland coming out in 1977 - that had working front headlamps to...
Thanks for the review Sam it's a lovely model but too expensive. I saw another review where the front was a bit warped and the front bufferbeam was sloping upwards. I think I see it on this one too. Maybe it's because of the sponge? All the best.
Thanks for sharing! That's interesting - I did look for that but didn't see anything... will double check!
Thanks for watching, Sam :)
Another lovely video sam well done great camera work as usual I am really looking forward to seeing your next video I hope you get a nice video next time also when is your next video going to be on UA-cam bye for now Philip
Loved your presentation. If you are a Hornby member last weekend Hornby were providing 30% back as a reward for future purchases
I had a hunch you might get straight in there and review this model this week. It is not that pretty but is very unusual so Hornby should be praised for making it. It is VERY expensive and it is a shame that the motor could be better. I guess this one was developed before the P2. Overall, having seen your review, I think it is a better, more interesting model than I had previously thought.
Hmm very nice my friend. Love the color. And wow it's to expensive. But I do like it. Keep being awesome my friend. My train should be here in a few days. Trains are the best.
240£!! Thats crazy especially for young or new modelers if i wanted to buy it (which i do but wont 😂) converted to candian dollars its 400!
Great video as always -TC5
If you are going to buy one the sound fitted ones are best value,. You basically get the sound upgrade for about £40.00 compared to nearly £70 if you bought it separate. It is the Hornby HM7000 sound but there is no chuff rate to worry about with this model so it sounds ok.
Hi Sam. At the price this loco must be aimed at the glass case collector market! As a layout item, the slowing down on curves is a detracting feature! I don't think I shall be ordering one, but this unusual loco in an attractive LMS livery makes a great Sam's Trains loco review! Thanks for uploading.
It does seem that way Allen, true! Glad you enjoyed the review anyway my friend,
Thanks for watching, Sam :)
my guess is that the reason they changed the coupler on the tender is due to the diecast body being more heavy then the plastic one, which to be fair i like that version as it more sturdy, looks like the tender light has some stuff blocking it maybe paint? not sure
A very Lovely & interesting Loco Sam!!! 🙂🚂🚂🚂
Nice loco, as for the price it's the oldest marketing trick in the book. Start with a high MSRP and then put them on sale, the consumer thinks they are getting a deal yet the manufacturer and retailer still make a big bundle.
For me Sam I has to be the lights, I absolutely love that feature.
Cheers Jasper & Willow
I do too - they look great don't they? Or the ones that you can see do!
Thanks for watching, Sam :)
Great review Sam. it's a nice model to much money for me though but the fan's of Hornby will buy it :)
I love it sam but unfortunately hornby had the opportunity to build a bench mark loco and cut corners in the process, still want one but hopefully the rrp will drop back will consider one then ,great review as always 👍
Maybe the tender is from a Princess Royal Class, or something similar,as the buffers don't match the loco, as the loco has the square buffers while the tender has the circle buffers
That is correct to prototype
In real life I guess it would have been... the model doesn't match the new Princess tender though, so I think it may be new tooled... perhaps not the chassis too, that looks like the same one as before!
Thanks for watching, Sam :)
Honestly it’s kinda cool to see that Hornby are going the American model maker route with much more metal on their models
Sam you have a massive collection
haha thank you!
I notice that part of the drop shadow on the 6 is missing. I would think that your experience designing and manufacturing the LNWR single will give you a better idea of costs/potential profit.
I think the fact they have working lights is a pretty cool feature for such a odd looking locomotive
I agree - that's definitely a step up!
Thanks for watching, Sam :)
If this was £190 I would buy one today. However it's performance is a concern. I bought 2 of the new streamlined Coronations and the 9 coach set. There was so much drag due to the lights that it ran on my flat layout at a scale speed of 30mph. I had waited for these since 1980. I ended up selling the lot.
I still find it more surprising that lighting on locos is so rare from Hornby. I have a 1981 catalogue from Märklin and almost all the locos have lights.
However, I guess that lighting if more complicated in Britain, because the marker lights can de variably lit depending on conditions.
Having said that, I just love lit up trains, even if the lighting is not prototypical.
Lighting on Marklin trains goes back to the 1950s, and probably earlier.
Capacitive touch requires a dielectric (insulator) between you and the sensor (basically a metal pad) to work properly - think how those new hobs/stoves work with the glass plate. So yes, entirely possible for the tender to be plastic AND have capacitive touch sensing for the lamp enable :)
As an aside, it's crazy how much can get in the way of capacitive touch regarding this dielectric - certain types of plastics work better than others; too much moisture content (i.e. in wood) can disrupt it; metallic paints will render it useless, etc.
One thing that could have attributed to the dramatic improvement in standards is there being new blood at the top.
Great looking model of a distinctive, if short lived, prototype. The LMS red ones seem to be flying off the shelves.
Decent overall review here Sam, as an owner of one of these models my one being the BR black one I can say it is definitely worth the price being asked, it could be hornbys best locomotive to date and in my opinion it is, the features included on it are incredible the best one in my opinion being the lamps that light up on the front, I’m very happy with mine so in my opinion it is worth what is being asked for it, you may reject the excuse that one offs always command a high price but unfortunately to have these models of one off we have to be willing to pay.
Thanks a lot David - glad to hear you're so happy with yours - and I agree it is one of their best given all of the weight etc, great stuff! I only reject that models like this are unpopular and therefore bumped up in price to cover the costs - from what I've seen they're very popular!
Thanks for watching, Sam :)
Hi Sam! Long time no comments from me! 😅
That is a nice looking loco, though I do agree that they could have done a better job with the colour matching…. In the fiction of your model railway, you could always just say that the last time she went for her general overhaul they had to use two different paint batches! 😂
On the other hand, at £250 (or more!) Hornby really does need to fit a better motor…. Especially if Turbomotive was supposed to be a mixed-traffic or express loco!
I’m definitely not likely to buy one, even 2nd-hand…. Though that is mainly because it’s NOT Japanese N-scale!
Wow, i was so close to buying one of these... Then i seen that torque. I can't believe the manufacturers keep doing that. What's the point of having good weight when it can't pull itself? You should do a motor swap episode on this loco Sam!
Superb looking locomotive, this. Not sure about the price but it looks like one of Hornby’s best
So amazing video
Thanks Justin! :D
I always love the princess royal class locos
Beautiful locomotive
Great reviw dear Sam,as always you make.The loco is beautiful...for the price unfortunately i think it is correct even if this it forces us to make increasingly painful choices about what to buy, which model to prefer and what to give up. Production costs in China have also increased and workers prefer to work in other high tech sectors that are more profitable for them. All this increasingly impoverishes our hobby.Big thumbs up,Alberto 👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍😊😊😊😊😊😊🚂🚂🚂🚂
“Quarter of a grand” 😂 that’s one way to emphasize how expensive it is! It does look beautiful though. Shame about the lights
haha yep... crazy isn't it? Lights are a great idea... they're just not implemented that brilliantly here,
Thanks for watching, Sam :)
Hi Sam. I can top your most expensive steam loco ever. I’ve recently bought a pre-owned Johnson 1P in crimson lake with no decoder from Hattons. It cost me £271 - an eye-watering sum! It was certainly in mint condition but the model railway world appears to have gone crazy!! Kind regards. Chris
You guys need to protest Hornby. For that price in the states we get DCC & sound, all sorts of lights, like headlights, ditch lights, walkway lights, & number board lights. I would never pay that price for just a plain steam engine that’s only DCC ready.
with how heavy the loco is and with how complex it is, I feel it would have been PERFECT to put dual motors tied together out of sync to give smooth power inputs and a lot of power to the driving wheels.
Fabulous model Sam and a superb review as always.
As long as "we" keep buying 'em at these prices, then nothing will change.
Easy for me to say, as I'm not a fan of this model's looks. But could I resist a model at this price that I really liked and wanted? Hmmm.... probably not!
I'm with you. Not a fan of the design (looks strange with no valve gear) so wouldn't buy one even if it was half the price. What I struggle to understand is that this must be so much easier and cheaper to produce given the lack of valve gear, why are Hornby charging such a premium price? I can only think that the demand will be there because of the unique nature of the prototype, so can charge what they believe they can get away with. As you rightly say, if 'we' keep buying them at these prices, then nothing is going to change.
@@delboy1727Charging what the market will bear. I think that's the second (?) third (?) lesson in capitalism:
Release a product at a high initial price, watch as people buy it, over time adjust your price to meet demand, and maximize profit.
Sam, your whining about Hornby prices is so boring and tedious. Get over it!! Your videos are coming so boring always harping about prices
hi sam , i am trying to build a model loco from scratch, as from where i belong ...the concept of model railroading simply doesn't exist..so sourcing loco , rolling stock and tracks is very difficult. I bought a bachmann "Rail cheif" set for 380 £ from amazon , but the quality is not worth the price ..so i decided to build my own loco ,including the motorizing unit along with the gears . ill be using a resin 3d printer to print all of the parts, but i am not sure which resin to use , as some resin shink too much . Your last video gave me the inspiration to try it my self . So in the next followup video of the project you are working on , can u please inculde what type of resin u will be usin and the what type of motor u will use to power the loco ...thanks for making such amazing content ❤
Another excellent review Sam and overall it looks a very nice model.
Price: One thing to be aware of is that by far the biggest cost when making models is labour. The diecast boiler AND running plate will increase the cost, but not to such a huge extent that it justifies the price IMO.
The lights are a very nice touch, I wouldn't expect those add much to the cost in terms of parts, although if it's not automated and they need fitting by hand that would increase labour costs.
It is over priced IMO, though Hornby aren't quite as bad as Bachmann in that regard. However both Accurascale and Dapol are able to make diecast, detailed locos at a considerably lower prices which shows it can be done.
Additionally the model shops sometimes sell old stock at considerable discounts which is a good indication on how big a mark up the two big manufacturers make.
Because it's a fairly unique loco I suspect these will sell out fairly quickly, especially the LMS maroon version. However personally I'm not willing, nor can I afford to pay that price, so will hope to pick one up secondhand for a more reasonable cost in the future.
If not I've already got three standard Princesses in various liveries which only cost me about £110-125 each secondhand and in boxed mint condition. They have firebox flicker, but not the working lamps or diecast body. However I prefer their looks with the valve gear and increased detail.
Loco-tender connection: My guess is these were designed just before Hornby changed to the new connection. Hornby use a variety of factories in China and some have been more affected by shut downs for Covid than others depending on the region. I expect those models whose production has been delayed such as the 2MT will all have the old connection.
Thank you - it sure is a nice model! You're right - I'm not an expert but from what I understand the cost of injection moulded plastic parts vs die cast metal parts isn't much different... it's mainly going to be the cost of material that makes the difference... so a pound or two at the most. I agree Hornby aren't quite as bad as Bachmann - at least there's a real attempt here to add value for money in many areas, same can't always be said for Bachmann. Thanks a lot for sharing,
Cheers,
Sam :)
Well said, though I still don’t think the cost is that well justified, and it is still VERY overpriced. I personally think some of Bachmann’s models still offer better value, though not all…
Lovely piece.. which carriages were those please Sam? Hornby prices are very high, there are ones on their site for £320!
Strange how history repeats it'self, i am very old and can remember the Hornby Dublo locos had diecast bodies and plastic tenders.
The issue with the bodies was the low quality metal used to make them, over the years if handled too much they just crumbled away.
Now Hornby made made a "New" diecast body loco at a crazy price and more than a few quality issues.
So much for progress!, at this price we have a right to expect close to perfection, there is no way i would pay this sort of money
for any loco.
Hey Sam, excellent video as always, I was just wondering how come lights are a first on british model locos when here in australia lights have been a premium for a while now
It's not a first on British models, Diesel models have had them for ages, and the Heljan Garrett also has them. Fact is that on the real thing back in those days, these were oil lamps, very dim, and not visible at all in daylight (did they even light them during daytime?) so how useful it is making them light up on a model is debatable, unless you are going to model night running in the dark.
Something I would really like to see in your reviews would be a DCC test along side your DC test. Have you ever considered adding that?
I would also be interested to see if that improves the torque, but why Hornby insist on using such cheap weak motors is beyond me.
@@eisenbau Agreed
It would be interesting, but then he’s kinda reviewing the decoder, and not the locomotive…
@@modelrailfan37 No. Thats not how that works. That would be like saying hes reviewing analog and not the locomotive. Its just an interface difference, and sometimes that matters with each and every model. Its good to test both.
@@dalecherne5377 true, he would have to use the same decoder each time though.
I've got an idea for a Halloween running session video you could do. Run trains in Halloween colors like you did in one of your Christmas running sessions
That's an awesome idea - love it Robert! :D
Thanks for watching, Sam :)
Do you have a video on mixed era layouts? I'm thinking of digging out my old LMS mostly steam models (from my mum's loft where they've been for over 20 years) to start a layout again but my tastes have changed (and prices increased) so want a nice way of enjoying different eras (trains/rolling stock as well a scenery).
There’s a lot of new/hidden/unadvertised features cropping up in hornby locos, this lighting package I don’t remember seeing advertised, the strange sensor in the p2, I wonder what loco we’ll first see this all together on from hornby? (Dare not think of the price though)
Agreed that the price is a bit steep for a loco with features that make it hard to justify it, better off waiting for a drop in price. Otherwise it's a decent locomotive that stands out from the usual offerings (Princess Royal class, A1 & A3 pacific's, Manor class).
A point I'd like to make on behalf of Hornby that to a degree reflects positively on their prices. They innovate and that costs money with english designers on english wages and that money has to be recovered. The lighting is not perfect, but it is an innovation, as is the neat touch switch in the tender (and soon coaches i guess), decent crew, bluetooth controllers, TT, new smoke generator ideas, Skaledale etc. - even Steam Punk. The odd 'miss' still has to be recovered. What is Bachmann innovating within their high prices?
Well decent quality is one thing...
But yer the Model Railway Hobby is being screwed over and its better off to be trying to find stuff second hand than to pick up stuff new... At least older stuff is more robust and looks much nicer to me.
Modern Hornby despite all the fancy bells and whistles are really throwing themselves up hill and will be in for a shock once all of the older modellers sell up or pass away leaving then with younger people who will not so willing to pay up for over priced models and begging for a bail out. This is why they need to bring back a good budget range and bring us back to the time when wagons costed at least £5 to £10s decently and locos where at least £35 to £50...
Innovation costs money, but if the innovative feature (the lamps) doesn’t work, then my question is why bother? Also, Hornby products are currently made in China, unless your talking about the design team, which is based in the U.K. Bachmann isn’t really innovating that much, but their prices aren’t nearly as high as this, and they have really improved, particularly with their steam locos, in the past 3-4 years. Also, Dapol have innovated a lot, and yet their models are far cheaper than this.
I love old Hornby locomotives, and kipper the breakfast in Texas.
Very interesting, good features for a £180 loco.
I’d like to hear what you’d think of Athearn here in the States lol. The American Hornby.
Sam you missed a trick here. The sound fitted loco is only £50 more expensive which makes it cheaper than some other sound fitted locos.
BUT the sound is AMAZING! The only thing I can compare it to is Hawkwinds “Silver Machine”! It really sounds like nothing else.
It’s a Triple Sound chip but we couldn’t fault it. Being DCC it also solved some of the running issues you had.
Take a listen, I’m sure someone will post a video.
Then go and buy a HM7000 chip and download the “Turbomotive” sound track. (I don’t know if it’s been released yet)
Not to mention, the speed doesn’t look bad. The real thing only ever did about 62 mph. I think how realistically it’s running is a check in my book.
There is some cool features, but a couple of DCC questions, does the Hornby Bluetooth chip fit it (you should do this for all Hornby releases), and whats on the soundfile for the speakers? If the loco no longer exists what did they use for the source sound?
I Managed to get the hornby flying Scotsman train set for only £150 on the Hornby website
I’ve bought the BR lined black version and it pairs beautifully with the previous “Rovex” edition Princess Elizabeth from a few years ago. Hoping they produce 46202 in her final form as the rebuilt Princess Anne soon.
when are you getting a stop watch sam ?? like my old works used to do ,, days since last accident .. you can have minutes before something falls off or breaks
Hi Sam, It could be hoped that there may be a chance they will produce a railroad version of this engine minus some of the bells and whistles that have put the price up.