Absolutely. It was sad to see Stephen go but Sandi was the best choice to take on the role from him and she has been superb. She manages to share enough of his traits (smart, witty etc) that she fits the job really well but still very much has her own charm and personality too. Feels kinda strange it's already been about 8 years since she became host. :O
It always saddened me that Stephen never came back as a panelist after Sandi became host. I would love to have seen the banter when the shoe was on the other foot, so to speak.
I was a lumberjack for fifteen years. We used to ask ourselves, "If a tree falls over in the forest and there is no one to hear it fall, can they prove that I had anything to do with it?"
Sir Edmund Hillary was a wonderful humble man who generously worked for years for the people of Nepal unlike other climbers who just used them and left behind nothing except their rubbish on the mountain. He was adored by the Nepalese, and New Zealanders alike.He usually wins our fave Kiwi polls. 😊
Stephen and Sandi bring completely different styles to their position and each one made the show infinitely watchable. I love the diverse guest roster that has appeared since Sandis role stared.
Everest climber Lincoln Hall, who was presumed dead and abandoned at 8700m. The next morning a group of climbers found him changing his clothes, alive, awake, and almost naked. He survived Everest to Found the Australian Himalayan Foundation
@htmc2022 neither the poster nor the policeman suggested in the slightest that they were unsympathetic. Who wouldn't be when people lost so much? At the same time some of it was opportunistic, botnput of necessity, as with the person quoted in the show.who bemoaned the loss of opportunity to steal after the war ended.
Judy Holliday always played really "dumb blondes" even though she was an extremely intelligent woman. I have read a description of her as "surpassingly intelligent". One year when my dad was filling in the census form he asked me what I wanted him to put as my religion (he was a very detail oriented man). I was going through a bit of a phase at the time, so I told him "Templar Knight". I like to think that somewhere in the archives, I am recorded as one of the few hundred Templar Knights in the UK...
@@cola_kidd1955not sure who Sheridan is? Sandi's son is Theo, and has appeared on the show - he was in the front row and she sat on his knee, to the shock of the audience until he answered a question with 'yes mum' 😄
I've been saying the same thing about the tennis grand slam tournaments for years, it's the same at all four, women only play best of 3 sets while men play best of 5, and I do not understand why. Not only is it unfair to award the same prize money for playing less, but there's no reason why women couldn't also play best of 5 sets, especially now final sets go to tiebreaks in all four tournaments and not just at the US open.
I know! I think she's so underrated 😕 I also think you can see in these clips why they wanted Sandi when Stephen left - her rapport with Alan is obvious even then (and I think that's part of why I love her series' so much) ❤
The Einstein face-mould is actually _Really_ interesting! (RI, not QI) - maybe disqualify it? 32:14 It is amazing to watch though. - We don't see things as they really are - We see things as WE really are!
Lets please clarify one thing for all eternity. If a sound is made, then it is utterly beside the point if it was heard or not for the obvious reason that sound is not a figment of imagination (usually), but rather a product of causality that can be measured. Therefore it is a thing which makes it real, period.
Fred MacAuley He said: "Fair fa' your honest, sonsie face, Great chieftain the puddin'-race! Aboon them a' ye tak yer place, Painch, tripe, or thairm: Weel are ye wordy a grace As lang's my airm."
(@ 38:00) Is it not the impact of the tree hitting the ground and the wood cracking that causes the sound waves. Therefore, does the presence of a listening ear become irrelevant. Its like what the little guy said, the sound of lightning cracking may not hit your ear drum for several seconds, does that mean the sound didn't exist until then? Because I reckon those closer to the lightning would beg to differ.🤔👩🎓👩🏫
I have seen documentaries on the hijra. They don't all identify as transgender, as some identify at 3rd sex, neither male nor female, and some as intersex. We see the same with muxhe in Mexico. Personally, I have trouble of Westerners labeling non-Western groups as the gender markers doesn’t necessarily apply. Something to think about.
Around 40.00: "if a tree falls in a forest and no one hears it": none of them discuss "no one". What, no creature from creepers to flyers was present when the tree fell? The question needs refining imo. Get rid of the forest and tree, and form a cleaner enquiry. _Walks up and down library, gesticulating wrathfully._
I think the main objection I have is that they're using the same word with different meanings, as Stephen pointed out but his guest totally missed; to a physicist, a "sound" is the vibration, and there is always vibration of molecules, whereas to a neurologist, a "sound" is the experience of the vibrations at the eardrum. Same word, entirely different meaning - which results in a discussion that just goes around in circles, without either side understanding that the other side also understands. Which does make me wonder exactly what meaning the original bishop meant, too.
The chief elf is wrong about the tree falling in a forest. Sound is the vibrations in the air, not the observation of those vibrations. That is like saying light doesn't exist until you see it.
So I went and looked at the whole line of David thing, cus I remember being taught about Mary being related to David via her relation to his great great grandparents Boaz and Ruth in children's church. As it turned out, it's kinda worse. It seems both Joseph and Mary are thought, by some to be related to David directly through his sons, though after "many generations" making them distant cousins.
I thought Edmund Hillary's berating of Mark Ingalls (double amputee) for Climbing Everest and passing David Sharp, who was still alive but barely conscious, was unfair. There was nothing Mark could do given that he really had no legs and others had mistaken David for Green Boots. The hard part of Everest is staying alive, the easy part is the climbing. Both are necessary but a lot get lost, fall and die.
20:00 I have always stated that Joseph and Mary going to Bethlehem for a census makes little sense, but going to stay with relatives when you can't reconcile the number of months you've been married to the birth date of your baby to your neighbors~ even the most ignorant peasant can count nine months; it was common in those days to move to relatives elsewhere and to tell the folks two weeks away an earlier anniversary date, then as a journeyman carpenter he could go away for a couple years, by the time the family returns eight or ten years later who's to tell a month or two off...?
Wow, I am.Australian and didn't know that. Obviously wasn't trained well enough by great-grandpa in how to properly dispose of a body (no doubt there is a section about it somewhere in that darn book!)
Lots of people have grown up hearing lazy male comics get big laughs about fat women, loud women, lazy women, and ugly women. There’s an old standard, “Take my wife *pause* please. *hold for laughs*”. Because female comedians often don’t tell this type of lazy joke, some people don’t think they are funny. That’s the comedy they grew up with. Therefore, if comedy isn’t making fun of women in some way, they don’t find it funny. There’s a way you can still make fun of women in comedy, as a male. You just have to say something sexist, then say ooooo. The implication is “look at me, I’m being a bad boy”. That allows you to still make fun of women, and get away with that type of lazy humour. I can think of many funny, female comics. A lot of them appear on QI. Sarah Millican is one I enjoy immensely.
… and right on queue, a “joke” about women talking too much. Oh, I’m sorry sir. Were the two women having a conversation that took attention away from you? Time to tell a lazy joke at their expense! Oh well done you.
And no male comedian has ever made a joke at their own expense, have they? You're really stretching here trying to play the part of the noble defender of women.
Pack your bags! We’re going on a guilt trip! This is such a load of horse manure, you are talking about I don’t know, decades ago. The only comedian who does jokes on women, yawn, are female comedians. And only the real good ones know how to expand to other topics and are actually funny! Usually I find most female comedians a bore exactly for that reason, this fanny focused victim card playing lazy comedy is usually restricted to female comedians themselves only.
@@Argeaux2this comment is so dumb I don’t know where to begin. The assignment within this episode was earning extra points for being loud mouthing the other team. Hence this joke and it was a golden one, perfectly placed within the episode boys vs girls.
it's impossible to remove all the organisms that hear from the forest. The tree itself can hear itself fall, as can all the bugs, squirrels, plants, etc
That sound clip really pisses me off because he obnoxiously goes "well the definition of sound is what happens in the ear" and makes repeated arrogant remarks about the question being easy... but thats not the definition of sound. The definition of sound is "vibrations that CAN be heard by an animal or person", and the vibrations a tree produces could be heard by an ear if one were present therefore it does produce a sound. Arrogance that you are right usually betrays an unsureness as to if you are wrong.
Sound is oscillating variations in pressure that makes our eardrums vibrate and that is what we hear as sound. So it only becomes sound if there is eardrum to pick up the vibration and a brain to interpret it as sound.
So if the noise of a falling tree is recorded digitally with nobody around to hear it, and then the recording is played back to a human, it is only sound on the playback but not during the actual tree fall? I'm sorry but that is utterly ridiculous. Sound is sound, regardless of whether it is observed by the ears or not. We can look at a graphical output of a microphone and observe the sound with our eyes even though we haven't heard it. The physics definition of sound is much more sensible than trying to define it with psychology.
Comedy requires ridicule and self ridicule. Not many women are bold enough to be the butt of the joke in front of a large audience, or even ridicule others in that context. It goes against their nurturing tendencies. That's probably why Holly Walsh, Jo Brand, Kathy Burke, Sarah Millican, Sara Pascoe, Morgana Robinson, Sandi on QI and the presenter Claudia Winkleman are so beloved in the UK and Aus. Wish more people appreciated that.
Don't ever forget, Wimbledon could make the women play more sets but they do not want to because of the scheduling nightmare. Women have offered to do so in the past. In fact, I suspect some tournaments would like the men to agree to do best 2 out 3 but they refuse and no grand slam is willing to do it because they're afraid of a loss of prestige. So you have a conundrum. But it isn't the women's fault. This is systemic.
@@jamesedmonds7519 can you please share two URLs of scientific that studies in one field that describe the correlation and that describe the lack of correlation?
Never seen before in warfare is misleading. Because submarines were already used in the American Civil War. Although these submarines were pretty simple and small compared to those used in WW 1 they were already submarines.
Plenty of ears hear the sound...it's only a "hypothetical question" if we only credit the existence of a sound if it's registered by a human ear. However, as physical reality, sound waves exist, irrespective of personal perspective.
2 місяці тому
I think these people will love to know a play of Dario Fo that talks about Jesus in the exile, where egiptian kids call him "Palestine"
I believe John Hodgman tried to get an American version of QI made. Never happened, but I think he was a big reason why the show got on BBC America. As to why an extra panelist, they probably had already booked everyone else and he was available only for that particular taping of the show or something like that.
I feel sorry for all the deer's and animals in the forest that don't hear that tree fall down just because us humans can't hear it, so it doesn't make a sound.
Bits? What bits? This discussion of a goose as a wiper of “knock holes” is a hoot. (Pun intended). But what are the men talking about “bits”? This must be a male thing. I’m flummoxed. Is there a man out there who can explain this to me, please?
If you mean the part at 8:20 he's talking about the "bits" of poo, it would "get all the bits" meaning be able to clean thoroughly. I think it was partly in reference to Sean's earlier comment about the scorpion having a sharp point so it could dig into any folds of skin (the "knibbly bits"), which you tend to get if you have haemorrhoids, which approximately half the population will have at some point in their lives by age 50.
It was better with Stephen sorry if you don't agree but it just was, having said that you could not get a better replacement than Sandi she is brilliant. Unfortunately the guests are now just not as good and the reasons are easy to see, I just watch repeats, thank god for Dave lol
How is “Jedi” any more ridiculous than “Christian”? They were both imagined and fabricated by people. Maybe it’s about popularity.. if enough people do a ridiculous thing, they have to be taken seriously 🤦🏻♂️
Most democratic countries with freedom of religion have some relatively broad, but objective, criteria that a congregation has to meet to be registered as an official religion and receive the benefits of being a registered religion. "Jedi" does not fulfill these criteria, and since it's a government census there is no official way to register "Jedi". You are of course free to consider yourself a Jedi nonetheless, but in matters of bookkeeping, it isn't a registered religion. :)
Because there is no one with a sincere belief in the Jedi religion, unlike the millions of people with a sincere and heartfelt belief in the Christian faith.
@@johnwhite1356 80-odd million people had a sincere and heartfelt belief in Mrs Hitler's little boy! That proved to be about as much benefit to the human race as a belief in some non-existent Sky Pilot! 🙄😱😵💫
Speaking as a Christian, the way I look at it is this. If you are right all that awaits us when we die is oblivion. If I am right, I will be going to Heaven and you will not.
@grahamhume5953 With respect, what if both of us are wrong, and Islam is right? Or Hinduism? Or Buddhism? Or everyone's wrong. Maybe Zeus and Jupiter are really pissed that no one's worshipping them anymore. You're burning with the rest of us, buddy.
In a forest there are loads of animals that have ear drums. A tree falling in the forest with no humans there, it'd still have loads of animals there that can hear a tree fall. Stupid analogy.
I always thought that if anyone could replace Stephen Fry, we couldn't get any better than Sandy
Absolutely. It was sad to see Stephen go but Sandi was the best choice to take on the role from him and she has been superb. She manages to share enough of his traits (smart, witty etc) that she fits the job really well but still very much has her own charm and personality too. Feels kinda strange it's already been about 8 years since she became host. :O
Go, Sandi! But, we so miss Stephen! He’s everywhere, though❤️🇨🇦❤️
What if I told you that as much as I love Stephen on QI, I like Sandi just a little bit more?
Sandi is brilliant
I'd love to see Stephen as a guest now
That would be glorious!!!!!!!
They've just celebrated the 300th show. He didn't make an appearance for that, so I doubt he'd be a guest.
@@bookie5667 I don't expect to see it, I just think it'd be cool if we did
I think he’s moved on
Stunning idea
We have truly been blessed by having two of the most intelligent and funny people on tv present this programme.
Really?? I don't remember turning up there.
Was I drunk?
@@Clavers1369 no, just dreaming apparently! 🤣🤣🙄
The episodes with both Stephen and Sandi are the absolute best ones. They riff off eachother in such a fun way
Johnny Vegas is no fool even though he works hard to convince viewers otherwise.
Watching Qi made me realise this. Very unique way of looking at things.
He's pulling a Norm Macdonald
It's known as a 'comedy character' or 'persona'. It's not a new thing.
I think comedian are often very clever you only need to watch how quick thinking the panel is.
@@samuelgarrod8327 Thanks for the news flash; I didn't notice any mention of its being a new thing.
It always saddened me that Stephen never came back as a panelist after Sandi became host. I would love to have seen the banter when the shoe was on the other foot, so to speak.
I was a lumberjack for fifteen years. We used to ask ourselves, "If a tree falls over in the forest and there is no one to hear it fall, can they prove that I had anything to do with it?"
Sir Edmund Hillary was a wonderful humble man who generously worked for years for the people of Nepal unlike other climbers who just used them and left behind nothing except their rubbish on the mountain. He was adored by the Nepalese, and New Zealanders alike.He usually wins our fave Kiwi polls. 😊
QI needs to get Stephen Fry on as a guest, if need be it could be to support Comic Relief or Children in Need etc.
Apparently he is reluctant. But hopefully at some stage before the final series they can persuade him.
Good idea but I think he might answer all the questions lol
What if he doesn’t want to do it?
(Reportedly, he doesn’t.)
@@Argeaux2 then he won't be on it. My guess is that he will make a special appearance when they get to Z and he'll be on the final episode
They are on U now. It's going to be a long time to get to Z.
We've never had any really funny ,intelligent shows like this in the usa.
Well, first you need to have some funny & intelligent people..... 😜
They spend quite a bit of time talking about whipping thier but with different animals. Nothing intelligent going on here.
@@SatansSimgma don't knock it till you try it 😉
@@SatansSimgma whipping? You didn’t pay attention did you
I wonder why. It’s the Trump effect.😂
Jack Dee timing perfection
Stephen and Sandi bring completely different styles to their position and each one made the show infinitely watchable. I love the diverse guest roster that has appeared since Sandis role stared.
Their best interaction has to be the "MicroMort" - Sandi's exasperated "how does the thousenth banana kill you?" was beautiful.
Jack Dee with possibly the greatest game show comeback line - EVER!
One of the least funny things ever said on a panel show.
They missed the bit with Sandi getting upset about micro-morts and bananas. :)
And her granddads party eye ... and the chainsaw first used to aid childbirth ...
@@Gzeebo I feel unwell!
Party eye was hysterical!!
"I'm going out now, and I won't come back until they match"
So good. Esp interaction between regulars😂😂😂❤
God l love QI so much,its so much fun.❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
These are gold!!
Everest climber Lincoln Hall, who was presumed dead and abandoned at 8700m. The next morning a group of climbers found him changing his clothes, alive, awake, and almost naked. He survived Everest to Found the Australian Himalayan Foundation
Re Lincoln Hall. Who cares???!!!!!
@@SuzetteGrist I'm sure his wife cared a lot especially when he phoned her to say goodbye for the last time, only to do a Lazarus.
Ahh, so someone HAS survived the hypothermic strip down?
I wonder if he ever talked about it afterwards?
@@SuzetteGrist well I found that an interesting piece of info- no need to be nasty because no one cares about you Karen.
My dad was a police officer in the Eastend of London in WW2 and he told me that 75% of his duties were investigating looting!
@htmc2022 neither the poster nor the policeman suggested in the slightest that they were unsympathetic. Who wouldn't be when people lost so much? At the same time some of it was opportunistic, botnput of necessity, as with the person quoted in the show.who bemoaned the loss of opportunity to steal after the war ended.
i was looking for this exact type of video about a week ago thats wild
I like how the goose neck quotation was ready to go on his cards
That’s because Sandi is an all-knowing genius badass and beat him to it
Wonderful language by Rabelais: 'Bum napkin for the nock hole' 😁
Always a treat! 💙🌻💙
Agree with you always a great.❤❤❤❤❤
Sandi thinks that she is not attractive. What rot! Sandi is an extremely handsome woman with a ‘drop dead’ sense of humour.
Judy Holliday always played really "dumb blondes" even though she was an extremely intelligent woman. I have read a description of her as "surpassingly intelligent".
One year when my dad was filling in the census form he asked me what I wanted him to put as my religion (he was a very detail oriented man). I was going through a bit of a phase at the time, so I told him "Templar Knight". I like to think that somewhere in the archives, I am recorded as one of the few hundred Templar Knights in the UK...
Ease the train up against the wall 😂😂😂😂
never noticed before but when they are talking about the book scouting for boys Sandi is wearing scrabble cufflinks with her initials on them
Cufflinks like that are usually a gift from someone (I know she has a son, he was on the show one time)
@@zetetick395 Sheridan has never been seen on the show
@@cola_kidd1955not sure who Sheridan is? Sandi's son is Theo, and has appeared on the show - he was in the front row and she sat on his knee, to the shock of the audience until he answered a question with 'yes mum' 😄
@@tracey8021 just ignore my comment commented on the wrong video lol
I've been saying the same thing about the tennis grand slam tournaments for years, it's the same at all four, women only play best of 3 sets while men play best of 5, and I do not understand why. Not only is it unfair to award the same prize money for playing less, but there's no reason why women couldn't also play best of 5 sets, especially now final sets go to tiebreaks in all four tournaments and not just at the US open.
Johhny Vegas, misunderstood Genius!
Sandi is a delight
I know! I think she's so underrated 😕 I also think you can see in these clips why they wanted Sandi when Stephen left - her rapport with Alan is obvious even then (and I think that's part of why I love her series' so much) ❤
I couldn't think of anyone else that could just slot right in after Stephen left! She is absolutely brilliant.
Stephen's charm is impossible to replace, but Sandi makes a damn fine effort. She's a great host.
Agree she is a great host too ,I love them both.❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Lily Tomlin never made herself look stupid. When she played Edith Ann it was straight as an arrow
39:10 Sandi little “stephen” 🥹
I'll just EASE this running horse to the side of a wall 😂😂😂
The Einstein face-mould is actually _Really_ interesting! (RI, not QI) - maybe disqualify it? 32:14 It is amazing to watch though.
- We don't see things as they really are - We see things as WE really are!
Lets please clarify one thing for all eternity. If a sound is made, then it is utterly beside the point if it was heard or not for the obvious reason that sound is not a figment of imagination (usually), but rather a product of causality that can be measured. Therefore it is a thing which makes it real, period.
@@mortanos8938 of course a tree makes a sound, whether it’s heard or not. This is one of the sillier philosophy questions. Linda ❤️🍷🦆
Non brit here.. Who is the guy at 50:50 telling the haggis poem? I thought I understood English quite well but I am so lost...
Fred MacAuley
He said:
"Fair fa' your honest, sonsie face, Great chieftain the puddin'-race! Aboon them a' ye tak yer place, Painch, tripe, or thairm: Weel are ye wordy a grace As lang's my airm."
(@ 38:00) Is it not the impact of the tree hitting the ground and the wood cracking that causes the sound waves. Therefore, does the presence of a listening ear become irrelevant. Its like what the little guy said, the sound of lightning cracking may not hit your ear drum for several seconds, does that mean the sound didn't exist until then? Because I reckon those closer to the lightning would beg to differ.🤔👩🎓👩🏫
1:30 - funniest line ever on QI
He set it up perfectly at 1:13 when he tried to interupt saying "Is it..." then waited another 17 seconds to hit his buzzer 🤣
Jack Dee is awesome.
British humour is often too subtle for many people to understand, let alone appreciate.
I suspect that Americans might make heavy weather of this…. 🇬🇧
Even Brits?
A knob gag is a knob gag. Grow up.
I have seen documentaries on the hijra. They don't all identify as transgender, as some identify at 3rd sex, neither male nor female, and some as intersex. We see the same with muxhe in Mexico.
Personally, I have trouble of Westerners labeling non-Western groups as the gender markers doesn’t necessarily apply.
Something to think about.
That 3rd gender could probably be translated as “non-binary,” though that might not encompass the same exact meaning.
Wanda Sykes best comedian I have ever seen.
We really need to breed Stephen & Sandi. Both for the genius offspring, and for the hilarious awkwardness of the conception..... 😂
Yes I love them both so much.❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
You seeing a lot of therapists. Hopefully.
I have to do this, mother, I'm a tax inspector
Around 40.00: "if a tree falls in a forest and no one hears it": none of them discuss "no one". What, no creature from creepers to flyers was present when the tree fell? The question needs refining imo. Get rid of the forest and tree, and form a cleaner enquiry.
_Walks up and down library, gesticulating wrathfully._
Actually, Sandi did say, "Is a forest ever empty?" I think that's exactly where she was going.
I think the main objection I have is that they're using the same word with different meanings, as Stephen pointed out but his guest totally missed; to a physicist, a "sound" is the vibration, and there is always vibration of molecules, whereas to a neurologist, a "sound" is the experience of the vibrations at the eardrum. Same word, entirely different meaning - which results in a discussion that just goes around in circles, without either side understanding that the other side also understands.
Which does make me wonder exactly what meaning the original bishop meant, too.
44:54 who’s this fella next to Alan who (at least in this edit) never says a word?
Fred MacAulay
The chief elf is wrong about the tree falling in a forest. Sound is the vibrations in the air, not the observation of those vibrations. That is like saying light doesn't exist until you see it.
That’s (the light bit) exactly what that guy was saying, which is some of the silliest nonsense I have ever heard
So I went and looked at the whole line of David thing, cus I remember being taught about Mary being related to David via her relation to his great great grandparents Boaz and Ruth in children's church.
As it turned out, it's kinda worse. It seems both Joseph and Mary are thought, by some to be related to David directly through his sons, though after "many generations" making them distant cousins.
The Transgender tax squad is a fascinating piece of creative thinking by a government! Wow!
I thought Edmund Hillary's berating of Mark Ingalls (double amputee) for Climbing Everest and passing David Sharp, who was still alive but barely conscious, was unfair. There was nothing Mark could do given that he really had no legs and others had mistaken David for Green Boots. The hard part of Everest is staying alive, the easy part is the climbing. Both are necessary but a lot get lost, fall and die.
20:00 I have always stated that Joseph and Mary going to Bethlehem for a census makes little sense, but going to stay with relatives when you can't reconcile the number of months you've been married to the birth date of your baby to your neighbors~ even the most ignorant peasant can count nine months; it was common in those days to move to relatives elsewhere and to tell the folks two weeks away an earlier anniversary date, then as a journeyman carpenter he could go away for a couple years, by the time the family returns eight or ten years later who's to tell a month or two off...?
11:10 They probably didn't deliver news paper like in One Piece.
Goose abuse 😂
Now it honks in a whole new way!
Baden-Puwell's great grandson is currently in prison in Australia after being convicted of the murder of his wife.
Wow, I am.Australian and didn't know that. Obviously wasn't trained well enough by great-grandpa in how to properly dispose of a body (no doubt there is a section about it somewhere in that darn book!)
This was the Gerard Baden-Clay case. It was quite a high profile case, but never realised he was Baden-Powell's great grandson.
If a tree falls in the forest and no one is there to hear it. Whose fault is it?
Lots of people have grown up hearing lazy male comics get big laughs about fat women, loud women, lazy women, and ugly women.
There’s an old standard, “Take my wife *pause* please. *hold for laughs*”.
Because female comedians often don’t tell this type of lazy joke, some people don’t think they are funny.
That’s the comedy they grew up with. Therefore, if comedy isn’t making fun of women in some way, they don’t find it funny.
There’s a way you can still make fun of women in comedy, as a male. You just have to say something sexist, then say ooooo.
The implication is “look at me, I’m being a bad boy”. That allows you to still make fun of women, and get away with that type of lazy humour.
I can think of many funny, female comics. A lot of them appear on QI.
Sarah Millican is one I enjoy immensely.
… and right on queue, a “joke” about women talking too much.
Oh, I’m sorry sir. Were the two women having a conversation that took attention away from you?
Time to tell a lazy joke at their expense! Oh well done you.
And no male comedian has ever made a joke at their own expense, have they? You're really stretching here trying to play the part of the noble defender of women.
Pack your bags! We’re going on a guilt trip!
This is such a load of horse manure, you are talking about I don’t know, decades ago. The only comedian who does jokes on women, yawn, are female comedians. And only the real good ones know how to expand to other topics and are actually funny!
Usually I find most female comedians a bore exactly for that reason, this fanny focused victim card playing lazy comedy is usually restricted to female comedians themselves only.
@@Argeaux2this comment is so dumb I don’t know where to begin. The assignment within this episode was earning extra points for being loud mouthing the other team. Hence this joke and it was a golden one, perfectly placed within the episode boys vs girls.
@@Argeaux2 everyone was laughing while you’re on your keyboard white-knighting. Watch the whole damn episode
I was one of the 14 who put Sith.
it's impossible to remove all the organisms that hear from the forest. The tree itself can hear itself fall, as can all the bugs, squirrels, plants, etc
That sound clip really pisses me off because he obnoxiously goes "well the definition of sound is what happens in the ear" and makes repeated arrogant remarks about the question being easy... but thats not the definition of sound. The definition of sound is "vibrations that CAN be heard by an animal or person", and the vibrations a tree produces could be heard by an ear if one were present therefore it does produce a sound.
Arrogance that you are right usually betrays an unsureness as to if you are wrong.
Sound is oscillating variations in pressure that makes our eardrums vibrate and that is what we hear as sound. So it only becomes sound if there is eardrum to pick up the vibration and a brain to interpret it as sound.
So if the noise of a falling tree is recorded digitally with nobody around to hear it, and then the recording is played back to a human, it is only sound on the playback but not during the actual tree fall?
I'm sorry but that is utterly ridiculous. Sound is sound, regardless of whether it is observed by the ears or not. We can look at a graphical output of a microphone and observe the sound with our eyes even though we haven't heard it. The physics definition of sound is much more sensible than trying to define it with psychology.
Jack Dee is the best 😂
New Zealand no longer entices British comedians to freeze to death as the secret is now out.
💙🌻💙
Comedy requires ridicule and self ridicule. Not many women are bold enough to be the butt of the joke in front of a large audience, or even ridicule others in that context. It goes against their nurturing tendencies. That's probably why Holly Walsh, Jo Brand, Kathy Burke, Sarah Millican, Sara Pascoe, Morgana Robinson, Sandi on QI and the presenter Claudia Winkleman are so beloved in the UK and Aus. Wish more people appreciated that.
ASDIC Early name for Sonar Anti Submarine detection invented in 1917.
Ronni Ancona is gorgeous.
Don't ever forget, Wimbledon could make the women play more sets but they do not want to because of the scheduling nightmare. Women have offered to do so in the past. In fact, I suspect some tournaments would like the men to agree to do best 2 out 3 but they refuse and no grand slam is willing to do it because they're afraid of a loss of prestige. So you have a conundrum. But it isn't the women's fault. This is systemic.
Jack, fucking brilliant.😊
5:30 Stephen just put the nail is the coffin of the wage gap there...
In one particular sport... Generally speaking, the wage gap is a very real thing.
@@jamesedmonds7519 can you please share two URLs of scientific that studies in one field that describe the correlation and that describe the lack of correlation?
Documentary of the wild haggis - ua-cam.com/video/X13cWg2pqSw/v-deo.html
Is it true that female clowns synchronize unicycles?
They first have to hash out which is the alpha-clown
@@zetetick395The alpha clown is the one with the largest honkers.
right truncable prime is 9973
end 11-04-43
left truncable is prime 9973
end 11-04-43
Never seen before in warfare is misleading. Because submarines were already used in the American Civil War. Although these submarines were pretty simple and small compared to those used in WW 1 they were already submarines.
Somehow, please adapt QI Legends into a trivia video game! 🎮
I would give just about anything for Fry to appear as a guest one of these days.
Plenty of ears hear the sound...it's only a "hypothetical question" if we only credit the existence of a sound if it's registered by a human ear. However, as physical reality, sound waves exist, irrespective of personal perspective.
I think these people will love to know a play of Dario Fo that talks about Jesus in the exile, where egiptian kids call him "Palestine"
Bay gulls 😮
They wouldn't do their part - hence the white feathers
Why was there 3 people on Sandi's team?
I believe John Hodgman tried to get an American version of QI made. Never happened, but I think he was a big reason why the show got on BBC America. As to why an extra panelist, they probably had already booked everyone else and he was available only for that particular taping of the show or something like that.
@@jripuleI think you are correct. That is how I remember it. 🇬🇧👍
Oh no! @19:35 You mean ... the Bible isn't 100% factually accurate?!?! 🤔🙄
Try leaving your zone and see the world. We’re funny and intelligent here in New Zealand. Linda
I find Sandi very funny.
She certainly has a dry smart wit…
I feel sorry for all the deer's and animals in the forest that don't hear that tree fall down just because us humans can't hear it, so it doesn't make a sound.
Point at flash repairs
I understand that Jack Dee’s comment about women comedians was a joke, but come on - how do you get Giles Brandreth, for instance, to stop talking?
Bits? What bits? This discussion of a goose as a wiper of “knock holes” is a hoot. (Pun intended). But what are the men talking about “bits”? This must be a male thing. I’m flummoxed. Is there a man out there who can explain this to me, please?
If you mean the part at 8:20 he's talking about the "bits" of poo, it would "get all the bits" meaning be able to clean thoroughly. I think it was partly in reference to Sean's earlier comment about the scorpion having a sharp point so it could dig into any folds of skin (the "knibbly bits"), which you tend to get if you have haemorrhoids, which approximately half the population will have at some point in their lives by age 50.
Men come largely un-assembled. Bits can come off if not properly attached.
This finished far too early!
I love Dee on ISIHAC
Turkey didnt exist in the time of Saint Nicholas
It was better with Stephen sorry if you don't agree but it just was, having said that you could not get a better replacement than Sandi she is brilliant. Unfortunately the guests are now just not as good and the reasons are easy to see, I just watch repeats, thank god for Dave lol
They're as good as each other for me
11:05 thank you for what?!?
These clips are taken from the UA-cam channel, which ends with an outro from the host Sandi Toksvig
@@Ursi_ yup, but did they have to cut it so badly? Lol
I mean, not hating Sandi but I prefer Stephen as host
The very first clip explains a lot about post SF QI.
Women laugh more at men 🤭😊🤣🤣🤣🤣🤔really 🤭🐦
John Lloyd is correct
so the answer to the first question: because the bbc sure as shit werent going to be front runners on any egalitarian nonsense ifg.......
No body in Yorkshire thinks puddings zhout he a protected name
In relation to the clownfish the male starts to change sex within twenty four hours
How is “Jedi” any more ridiculous than “Christian”?
They were both imagined and fabricated by people. Maybe it’s about popularity.. if enough people do a ridiculous thing, they have to be taken seriously 🤦🏻♂️
Most democratic countries with freedom of religion have some relatively broad, but objective, criteria that a congregation has to meet to be registered as an official religion and receive the benefits of being a registered religion.
"Jedi" does not fulfill these criteria, and since it's a government census there is no official way to register "Jedi".
You are of course free to consider yourself a Jedi nonetheless, but in matters of bookkeeping, it isn't a registered religion. :)
Because there is no one with a sincere belief in the Jedi religion, unlike the millions of people with a sincere and heartfelt belief in the Christian faith.
@@johnwhite1356 80-odd million people had a sincere and heartfelt belief in Mrs Hitler's little boy! That proved to be about as much benefit to the human race as a belief in some non-existent Sky Pilot! 🙄😱😵💫
Speaking as a Christian, the way I look at it is this. If you are right all that awaits us when we die is oblivion. If I am right, I will be going to Heaven and you will not.
@grahamhume5953 With respect, what if both of us are wrong, and Islam is right? Or Hinduism? Or Buddhism? Or everyone's wrong. Maybe Zeus and Jupiter are really pissed that no one's worshipping them anymore. You're burning with the rest of us, buddy.
In a forest there are loads of animals that have ear drums.
A tree falling in the forest with no humans there, it'd still have loads of animals there that can hear a tree fall.
Stupid analogy.
My guy... it's implicit that there's *nothing* around to hear the sound.