LINES vs. NO LINES vs. SOME LINES: 3 Methods Compared!

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 6 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 90

  • @leipzigergnom
    @leipzigergnom 4 роки тому +54

    When I was a kid I tried to look really closely to see if objects in real life had black outlines. They didn't 😅

    • @leipzigergnom
      @leipzigergnom 4 роки тому +3

      @Itz_Eleanor Playz Awesome :D
      It's weird, the things you think of as a kid.

  • @EVITANDY
    @EVITANDY 4 роки тому +9

    “ Focus”. Is a good word to describe what you’re talking about

  • @Lord_Raymund
    @Lord_Raymund 4 роки тому +51

    I like some things in all of them, none are perfect. The first one is smooth, the second is crisp, and the last one balanced.

    • @yofu2969
      @yofu2969 4 роки тому +3

      No. Lines are Jesus.

    • @MrMaksibon
      @MrMaksibon 4 роки тому +1

      in fact, the line is the border, and it is on each of the three pictures. I think the key is the thickness of the lines, draftsmanship

  • @Val17282
    @Val17282 4 роки тому +26

    I hadn't watched your videos in a looking time, I'm so glad I returned to this wonder channel😊

  • @DaveWhitmore421
    @DaveWhitmore421 4 роки тому +3

    the middle pic was line over kill. I like the effect of the third pic the best where the lines helped emphasise that the top half was solid and much of the lower half was just a reflection. Great video!

  • @TrapSmoove
    @TrapSmoove 4 роки тому +2

    Thank you for still doing videos I grew up watching you, Happy New Year and Decade🎉‼🇺🇸

  • @animattions64
    @animattions64 4 роки тому +2

    You should make a video showing the difference between black outlines and colored outlines on manga/anime art. Not sure how it'll be a how-to-draw video, but I've used colored outlines for several years now.

  • @gamerguy425
    @gamerguy425 4 роки тому +2

    This is something I struggle immensely thinking about the best way around. I can only really do lineless stuff in acrylic paint, not any other medium.

  • @dwightlady
    @dwightlady 4 роки тому +6

    Thank you for making this one, I've been doing the lines around everything illustrations and you made mevrealky reconsider that. I also think the second illustration has a stained glass window look to it, which, if you're going for that look could be great too. Butbi seecwhat you're getting at with the lines having a real purpose and not just outlining everything.

  • @postalmike
    @postalmike 4 роки тому +12

    Sometimes you just have to know where to draw the line!

  • @jessicaturner5175
    @jessicaturner5175 4 роки тому +2

    Hi Mark! Can you do a realism challenge by drawing the One Ring from Lord of the Rings?

  • @cometmoon
    @cometmoon 4 роки тому +1

    LOL! Love the voice Mark does for Old Man Time-Lasp XD

  • @jennifernewmanart
    @jennifernewmanart 4 роки тому +1

    Great video , I always struggle with to leave lines, add lines or not in my artwork , this was great to see 😊 I definitly like 1 and 3

  • @Awesomemelon.
    @Awesomemelon. 4 роки тому

    I haven't watched your videos since 2014,its great to see your still here making great content

  • @michellelee9123
    @michellelee9123 4 роки тому +1

    Well done! This was usual and very needed! Thank you Mark and happy new year!

  • @noemidelagarza6646
    @noemidelagarza6646 4 роки тому +5

    Thanks for the video it was actually really helpful

  • @Mr.misterr
    @Mr.misterr 4 роки тому +8

    Thank you for teaching us🙏🏻☻
    I learned how to draw from your tutorials.•w•

  • @robertburtonrobinson7063
    @robertburtonrobinson7063 4 роки тому

    Thanks for another very helpful video, Mark! I recently purchased and read the six Kindle versions of your Brody's Ghost series. Loved it!

  • @WhyIsZy
    @WhyIsZy 4 роки тому +2

    Mark Crilley: Let's do a time lapse
    Me: Please say old man time lapse please
    Mark Crilley: Bring in old man time lapse
    Me: CALLED IT!

  • @Exarhadsgfds
    @Exarhadsgfds 4 роки тому

    Adding lines to an image gives it sort of a more "sharpened" look. I always got the feeling that by selectively lining the scene you can direct the reader's view in that scene to what you feel is important. Lining a skater and not lining his reflection sort of draws your view in towards the skater and gives the reflection the appearance of haziness, the same as you'd get in real life if something was in your peripheral vision compared to something you were looking at... A very effective way of directing the readers attention. Movies do this all the time with focus lenses when they focus in on a specific person and blur out everyone else.

  • @himmy_turner_
    @himmy_turner_ 3 роки тому

    i’ve watching your channel since i was 7 i’m 15 now you have taught me how to draw and now i’m passing on your vids to my little cousin keep uploading

  • @albertross2456
    @albertross2456 2 роки тому

    I gotta say, #3 selective lines really pops and looks the best for foreground, Background and reflection

  • @johnpaulespiritu7267
    @johnpaulespiritu7267 4 роки тому +1

    Mark happy new year!!!! Lets freaking slay this year. >:D drawing while watching ur vids!!

  • @mluminoth6379
    @mluminoth6379 4 роки тому

    Holy shit this guy is still here and still killing it

  • @albertross2456
    @albertross2456 2 роки тому

    I'm loving that #3 so much

  • @sillygoose9054
    @sillygoose9054 4 роки тому

    Love the idea Mark. Thanks for the content, hope you and the family are all doing great.

  • @CreativeSteve69
    @CreativeSteve69 4 роки тому +1

    Happy New Years/Decade Mark. One of my most top new years resulution after takinga fun figure drawing class in fall last year, I am dedicating myself to try n draw once a day to keep things fresh in mind. :)

  • @vassiakoutsoukos5257
    @vassiakoutsoukos5257 4 роки тому +2

    Can you make a tutorial on how to draw a fox

  • @ayme5868
    @ayme5868 4 роки тому +3

    the middle pic looked like he was balancing on air and there was a parallel universe below him

  • @adrianbowden4439
    @adrianbowden4439 4 роки тому

    Thank you Mark ..... Happy New Year & keep up the good work !

  • @NathanielBTM
    @NathanielBTM 4 роки тому

    Damn... I've been watching your videos for around 12 - 13 years... Crazy when I think about it, I just turned 22 in February.

  • @andrewgarfield9898
    @andrewgarfield9898 4 роки тому +10

    I prefer the one with the lines. It just looks so much neater and clean.

    • @maureenhubbard9575
      @maureenhubbard9575 4 роки тому

      Hey, your name Andrew Garfield is a good one! like it!!!

  • @MrJ5151
    @MrJ5151 4 роки тому +1

    Thanks Mark!

  • @Miquiztli_tochtli
    @Miquiztli_tochtli 19 днів тому

    Outlines are like the "horizons"of objects. Every solid object has a bunch of little horizons in 3d

  • @mohammedalnayar
    @mohammedalnayar 4 роки тому

    Being selective about lines is important.. lines adds weight to the object, texture and as used here if something is transparent or solid.
    When inking i usually consider lines as shadows and not outlines. That way an object wont have "shadows" near the highlight but only defined near the darkest regions

  • @rachelm7525
    @rachelm7525 4 роки тому +3

    Well, Happy New Decade! 😃

  • @devonteedwards2093
    @devonteedwards2093 4 роки тому +3

    This is something i can try out

  • @sirenj3172
    @sirenj3172 4 роки тому +2

    How do you make the three images exactly the same!!?!! 😭😭

  • @betuna9487
    @betuna9487 4 роки тому +1

    And then he blessed us with a new video

  • @ronnieterwilliger6463
    @ronnieterwilliger6463 4 роки тому +2

    Dear mark I hope that you see this I was wondering did you turn your book Brody's ghost into a movie on Netflix called "bring it on, ghost" if not I have the bad feeling that somebody stole your content I urge you to check this out

  • @peteannells4218
    @peteannells4218 4 роки тому

    An illustration might have lines, as do cartoons, to simplify and clarify the image, but a realistic drawing would only have a line where a line exists. No black lines round realistic paintings! Reflestions are always darker (less light) with compressed tonal variation, and the same height as the object (so the ones on the right are wrong) .

  • @GangStalker17
    @GangStalker17 4 роки тому

    Perfect video for me rn THANKS MARK!

  • @merkules6
    @merkules6 4 роки тому

    What I think really kept me back somewhat was hearing in a movie/series some art teacher tell his student that she shouldn't use lines in her work. I was just a kid then but took it to heart and started to avoid lines, only using them when sketching. Now that I'm much older I feel like I've shaken that mindset off and discovered lines again. And I loooove them.

  • @AporiaLester
    @AporiaLester 4 роки тому

    Awesome video, as usualy. Did you ever make a video about line thickness? Like when you draw a line stronger or weaker at certain points to emphasize weight/force of a punch for example. That'd be very interesting.

  • @alexanderbeaton2128
    @alexanderbeaton2128 4 роки тому +1

    I really want to get back to doing watercolour, and penceil after watching the video. New Years Resolution. Make small habits. Make it fun.

  • @Catsoupvlogs
    @Catsoupvlogs 4 роки тому

    Happy new year mark Crilly💚

  • @CloudlessStudio
    @CloudlessStudio 4 роки тому +1

    I draw lines everywhere like in 2

  • @melopsittacus4047
    @melopsittacus4047 4 роки тому

    Nice video, I usually draw only lines but I really like it if there are a couple of lines/some lines 👍👍 btw i just found out that I am subscribed for almost 5 years, like wow

  • @sanyogoo6017
    @sanyogoo6017 4 роки тому +6

    Me: Mark still master in 2020

  • @albertross2456
    @albertross2456 2 роки тому

    I'm gonna order that drawing lesson book

  • @gamaltk
    @gamaltk 4 роки тому +1

    Coming here from recommended subscriptions

  • @dylansearcy3966
    @dylansearcy3966 4 роки тому

    Will you ever do anymore animal tutorials? Because I was hoping you could do a tutorial on something like dinosaur legs.

  • @normas_sketchbook
    @normas_sketchbook 4 роки тому

    Your videos are very motivating for me.
    Why are the lines black? Why not green for the trees, brown for the fence etc.?

  • @SuselLee
    @SuselLee 4 роки тому +2

    This was a good tip. I am going to be selective .

  • @ashutosharyan3000
    @ashutosharyan3000 4 роки тому +1

    Hey mark,can you please make a video on how to show motion in art?

  • @buttsmcgee9517
    @buttsmcgee9517 4 роки тому

    I love your channel so friggen much but PLEAAAASSSEEEEEEE can you do more chibby art tutoriels? I love them so muvh and i have dramaticcly improved.

  • @manal9348
    @manal9348 4 роки тому +2

    nice

  • @dianeo
    @dianeo 4 роки тому

    Great topic. Very helpful!

  • @ldraww3581
    @ldraww3581 4 роки тому

    awesome video !

  • @janetmcdaniel2755
    @janetmcdaniel2755 4 роки тому +1

    I myself don't care for lines it appears 'to me' too kiddish work...maybe do occasional lines like on the wood fence.....and lighter on the mountains and trees. Crilley you are the best...will definitely look for your lessons books.....shading is my most interest and doing drawing from pictures....wish you would do a step by step on sketching from photos

  • @evanmichaelhardin
    @evanmichaelhardin 4 роки тому

    It’s 2020 and I still haven’t seen my illustration of Old Man Timelapse. I reckon he looks like Mark as an old man.

  • @ramizshould
    @ramizshould 4 роки тому

    Awesome markcrilley

  • @michaelhaire7319
    @michaelhaire7319 4 роки тому +1

    Hey mark

  • @BliffleSplick
    @BliffleSplick 4 роки тому

    A fourth option would be putting lines where it would be shadowed as well

  • @santoshsamala1965
    @santoshsamala1965 4 роки тому

    Happy belated new year

  • @apesounds5509
    @apesounds5509 4 роки тому

    Its 2020 and we still can't have 1080p

  • @QuiteDecent
    @QuiteDecent 4 роки тому

    The first photo is from an iPhone, the second photo is from a Samsung, and the third photo is from a Google Pixel.

  • @aleksartsrozniegame
    @aleksartsrozniegame 4 роки тому +1

    Your drawing own OC characters?😊

  • @kartiksharma2818
    @kartiksharma2818 4 роки тому +1

    You are the best
    Why don't you do much manga stuff

  • @123rockfan
    @123rockfan 4 роки тому

    I think the first is a little strange looking, sorry Mark, I really like the lined version though

  • @verageren
    @verageren 4 роки тому +1

    Hi Mark, when will you start on Twitch? Even Bob Ross is a regular streamer nowadays, with a dedicated following I might add.

    • @rachellynncreates2703
      @rachellynncreates2703 4 роки тому

      gilbertvrancken bob ross is streaming live huh..? Now that’s an interesting development...

  • @tadanarilee6003
    @tadanarilee6003 4 роки тому

    No line is look amazing

  • @Hiraghm
    @Hiraghm 4 роки тому

    sigh... the new decade doesn't start until next year.

    • @BliffleSplick
      @BliffleSplick 4 роки тому

      Whether we're taught it directly or not, we all start counting at 0.

  • @brandonjones7151
    @brandonjones7151 4 роки тому

    I wanted to ask this question Is 20 too old to learn how to draw and be an animator?

  • @KannazukiAMV
    @KannazukiAMV 4 роки тому

    yeah 2020 😎🌍

  • @NinhNguyen-op4dj
    @NinhNguyen-op4dj 4 роки тому

    Chúc Mừng Năm Mới ,Ninh chúc Họa Sĩ mạnh khỏe ,hạnh phúc.

  • @googleboyvinayakchandra8354
    @googleboyvinayakchandra8354 4 роки тому

    Please draw a dinosaur

  • @TheLazysketcher
    @TheLazysketcher 4 роки тому

    Aw! I thought you were gonna talk about guidelines vs no guidelines! Disappointed!

  • @MR.Ash9r
    @MR.Ash9r 4 роки тому +2

    #1✌😂

  • @ليٰان-ث9ل4ث
    @ليٰان-ث9ل4ث 4 роки тому +1

    اول

  • @YOURBAEQUIN
    @YOURBAEQUIN 4 роки тому +1

    Mann Nobody IN THIS WORLD IS DUMB enough to makethise thicc linearts for EVERY part of their art!!

    • @Jombo56
      @Jombo56 4 роки тому +1

      you'd be surprised at how many beginners think it's necessary