Not a question of which is better, they are not designed for the same use. The orbital is better for sanding large areas and not leaving any swirl marks. The palm sander is for lighter duty finish work typically over smaller areas.
I purchased a used one as the piece is a bit pricey, but the machine ua-cam.com/users/postUgkxG6fbm3cHBd7CNTjk5D-dwYe9c9tCB9ZN has surpassed my expectations. We sand small parts by hand often, sized around 1"x1/2," and specifically look for a piece that's designed to be vertical. The motor has plenty of torque and great speed settings. The only inconvenience I had is that the disk measures 5" where we trim 6" stick-and-sand disks down easily by mounting it then cutting with a box cutter.
Thanks for the comment! I was able to put some pressure on the edge of the random orbital sander but not quite as much as the palm sander because that is when the sandpaper started to walk on me. Do you have an issue with this? If not, what brand of sandpaper do you use?
Tilt the random orbital sander to get the edges eh???? My dear sir, if you have done this and leave a flawless finish, you are amazing. I am a hobbyist and a relatively new to woodworking. I will make this quick and easy, I dont have the guts to try that stunt sir. I am too scared to ruin my Pieces.
You've compared 2 different sanders and 2 different sandpapers simultaneously, so you can't really draw performance conclusions. The 3M sandpaper is far superior to whatever comes with the Black and Decker. The newer ceramic based 3M sandpapers (especially the net/mesh style) are especially great. Cubitron branded 3M
If you can only buy one, get the 1/4 sheet palm sander simply because you can tackle large areas too. The square shape lets you get into corners. Orbitals have a tendency to wander all over the place. If you get both, that's ideal. Wait for deals .
The DeWalt 1/4 sheet palm sander is the sander I use and I have never felt the urge to replace it, and of course I like that the sheet costs less than the "velcro" one. Maybe one day I will have both.
Very helpful. You mentioned that the pad on the palm sander was starting to wear. I'm wondering if that can be replaced to rejuvenate the sander. Thanks.
Had escaped an unboxing video before watching this at first was like oh shi- here we go again but alas you share the same sentiment for unboxing vids. Good video btw was helpful.
Looking at palm sander your Dewalt or harder to get Makita BO4556K [dust bag issue small diameter connection ] or the also hard to get expensive Bosch GSS 140-1A. How well does the Dewalt collect dust ?? Other reviews say its a problem , do u agree ??
Well, I’ve never noticed a huge problem, but you also have to use the hole maker it comes with before it will collect dust. I bet those people aren’t using it
@@DIYMAN hi Just purchased the Dewalt collects dust like my 6inch Random orbital 50-70% . Dust collection 8 outta 10 . Bag attachment is way way better than Makita [small hole=hard to empty with only a spring retainer clip]. Paint prep 8 outta 10 . Gets the job done just a little slow [ to be expected ] . Good Long cord . Paper install good . Good power does NOT load motor when used with 60g paper . Cheers for your help .
My 6 inch R/O Bosch [blue industrial version ] GEX 150 AC Professional Variable Speed is faster on bigger jobs than the Dewalt 1/4 sheet , But the smaller unit I will use for detail work /paint prep . Different applications .
I don’t know I don’t I like the sheet sander too much. I always have problems using sheets sanders. If sheet came off, it was always a b**** to get it back on. Random orbital sander, I never had that problem with.
So do you think that the palm sander would be better to use over the orbital sander to sand the fascia boards around my house? I always hear that orbital Sanders can leave swirl marks in the wood, what do you suggest sir?
Sorry for late comment. Just wanted to clarify, a random orbital sander is supposed to remove most visible swirl patterns due to its random nature. A regular orbital sander is essentially the same as a palm sander I'm pretty sure. So to limit swirls, random orbital is likely your best bet.
I don’t understand this video. Asking which sander is better is like asking which one is better, a 3/4 ton or 1 ton truck. Depends on the intended use. Random Orbital and 1/4 sheet finishing sanders are intended for different applications
This is totally wrong i think. Especially when using large grit sand papers. Orbit sander is better in that case and for finishing purposes(using fine sand papers) sheet sander is better. (I don't have much experience but this is what I felt)
Nije pošteno. Dvije vrste brusnog papira (60 i 120) od dva različita proizvođača. Ko se imalo razumije u obradu drveta znao je u startu koji će biti rezultat ali ne zbog stroja nego zbog papira.
Definitely not a good comparison those Sanders are two different Sanders for a reason🤣..... then you're going to put a Black & Decker up against a DeWalt??? Laughs out Loud..... you might want to throw that lil $29 orange thing away and get you a real orbital Sander atleast Dewalt or Makita.... and if your balling get you a Mirka sander..... but anyhow keep up the awesome consumer reporting👍🏽💯
Thanks man! I appreciate the comment! I agree, it may not have been the fairest comparison, but hopefully people are getting value out of the video somehow. Lol. I would like to upgrade the orbital soon, I don’t like how the paper drifts. I’m just curious if brand name sanders do the same?
Not a question of which is better, they are not designed for the same use. The orbital is better for sanding large areas and not leaving any swirl marks. The palm sander is for lighter duty finish work typically over smaller areas.
Great point. Thank you
u can use the palm sander for the same things you can use the orbital and if ur making swirl marks use a higher grit or stop edging 😂
So you’re saying the random orbital sander is better at large areas AND it doesn’t leave swirl marks? Sounds like a winner to me lol
I purchased a used one as the piece is a bit pricey, but the machine ua-cam.com/users/postUgkxG6fbm3cHBd7CNTjk5D-dwYe9c9tCB9ZN has surpassed my expectations. We sand small parts by hand often, sized around 1"x1/2," and specifically look for a piece that's designed to be vertical. The motor has plenty of torque and great speed settings. The only inconvenience I had is that the disk measures 5" where we trim 6" stick-and-sand disks down easily by mounting it then cutting with a box cutter.
You can tilt a random orbit sander to hit tough spots. Gives you more pressure at the edge. Have done this for twenty years without issue.
Thanks for the comment! I was able to put some pressure on the edge of the random orbital sander but not quite as much as the palm sander because that is when the sandpaper started to walk on me. Do you have an issue with this? If not, what brand of sandpaper do you use?
Tilt the random orbital sander to get the edges eh????
My dear sir, if you have done this and leave a flawless finish, you are amazing. I am a hobbyist and a relatively new to woodworking.
I will make this quick and easy, I dont have the guts to try that stunt sir. I am too scared to ruin my Pieces.
You've compared 2 different sanders and 2 different sandpapers simultaneously, so you can't really draw performance conclusions. The 3M sandpaper is far superior to whatever comes with the Black and Decker. The newer ceramic based 3M sandpapers (especially the net/mesh style) are especially great. Cubitron branded 3M
If you can only buy one, get the 1/4 sheet palm sander simply because you can tackle large areas too. The square shape lets you get into corners. Orbitals have a tendency to wander all over the place. If you get both, that's ideal. Wait for deals .
BTW you did refer to Velcro as hook & loop during your video, LOL. Thank you for an informative video.
Lol, dang it! I’m already brainwashed. You’re welcome!
The DeWalt 1/4 sheet palm sander is the sander I use and I have never felt the urge to replace it, and of course I like that the sheet costs less than the "velcro" one. Maybe one day I will have both.
Yeah, I really like mine. My wife found this random orbital sander on sale for $10 so I had to go for it
Very helpful. You mentioned that the pad on the palm sander was starting to wear. I'm wondering if that can be replaced to rejuvenate the sander. Thanks.
I’m not sure. I’ll have to look into that
Much aprecited thet you took the time to made this extraordinary video tutorial ! 🏆🏆🏆
You’re welcome!
Had escaped an unboxing video before watching this at first was like oh shi- here we go again but alas you share the same sentiment for unboxing vids. Good video btw was helpful.
😂 they’ve always driven me nuts
I've had my palm sander for years and didn't realize the function of the plastic pin plate. Who knew?? Thank you
Thanks for information
Looking at palm sander your Dewalt or harder to get Makita BO4556K [dust bag issue small diameter connection ] or the also hard to get expensive Bosch GSS 140-1A.
How well does the Dewalt collect dust ?? Other reviews say its a problem , do u agree ??
Well, I’ve never noticed a huge problem, but you also have to use the hole maker it comes with before it will collect dust. I bet those people aren’t using it
@@DIYMAN hi Just purchased the Dewalt collects dust like my 6inch Random orbital 50-70% . Dust collection 8 outta 10 . Bag attachment is way way better than Makita [small hole=hard to empty with only a spring retainer clip]. Paint prep 8 outta 10 . Gets the job done just a little slow [ to be expected ] . Good Long cord . Paper install good . Good power does NOT load motor when used with 60g paper .
Cheers for your help .
My 6 inch R/O Bosch [blue industrial version ] GEX 150 AC Professional Variable Speed is faster on bigger jobs than the Dewalt 1/4 sheet , But the smaller unit I will use for detail work /paint prep . Different applications .
Which one is better for painting (car/bike) works?
I don’t know I don’t I like the sheet sander too much. I always have problems using sheets sanders. If sheet came off, it was always a b**** to get it back on. Random orbital sander, I never had that problem with.
So do you think that the palm sander would be better to use over the orbital sander to sand the fascia boards around my house? I always hear that orbital Sanders can leave swirl marks in the wood, what do you suggest sir?
Yes. They can both leave marks like that, but it’s a lot easier to sand with the grain with a palm sander
Sorry for late comment. Just wanted to clarify, a random orbital sander is supposed to remove most visible swirl patterns due to its random nature.
A regular orbital sander is essentially the same as a palm sander I'm pretty sure.
So to limit swirls, random orbital is likely your best bet.
When you are cycling through sandpaper grits it is much faster to use the hook and loop sandpaper.
Definitely
Great video! What watch are you wearing?
Thank you so much! It’s made by Casio. It’s a pretty good one
Hey I just saw on a diy hack to clear the sawdust on sandpaper use an eraser on it to remove sawdust. I would try it but don't have a sander YET!
I’m going to have to try this! Thanks!
A brass or steel wire brush works well too.
I don’t understand this video. Asking which sander is better is like asking which one is better, a 3/4 ton or 1 ton truck. Depends on the intended use.
Random Orbital and 1/4 sheet finishing sanders are intended for different applications
Apples vs oranges because Dewalt is so much better than awful Black & Decker.
Thanks for that
You’re welcome!
This is totally wrong i think. Especially when using large grit sand papers. Orbit sander is better in that case and for finishing purposes(using fine sand papers) sheet sander is better.
(I don't have much experience but this is what I felt)
True
Nije pošteno. Dvije vrste brusnog papira (60 i 120) od dva različita proizvođača. Ko se imalo razumije u obradu drveta znao je u startu koji će biti rezultat ali ne zbog stroja nego zbog papira.
That's mean actually which one is better?
Which one reffer by you for me?
I will order that.plz tell me.
If you do a lot of heavy duty wood removal, I’d get the Dewalt quarter sheet sander
@@DIYMAN yes I have total 18 pcs door and window palla. But I have used on this 80+120 already.
I want to use purpose of sanding with polish time
Definitely not a good comparison those Sanders are two different Sanders for a reason🤣..... then you're going to put a Black & Decker up against a DeWalt??? Laughs out Loud..... you might want to throw that lil $29 orange thing away and get you a real orbital Sander atleast Dewalt or Makita.... and if your balling get you a Mirka sander..... but anyhow keep up the awesome consumer reporting👍🏽💯
Thanks man! I appreciate the comment! I agree, it may not have been the fairest comparison, but hopefully people are getting value out of the video somehow. Lol. I would like to upgrade the orbital soon, I don’t like how the paper drifts. I’m just curious if brand name sanders do the same?
@@DIYMAN I have the current model variable speed 2.5 amp Bosch. I use Gator discs and the paper starts exactly where you put it.
@@michaelpagliara6959 thank you! I might have to try that guy
Thank you bro
No problem!
Amen to the velcro comment hahaha
You don't need to record unboxing, just friggin compare......!!
Exactly
Alva View