RD Yes, she sells it like a pro. She says today she was so much more innocent than her character back then and she really didn't know what she was doing. Well, she sure fooled me - and the Academy. She got an Oscar nomination for this part.
I always feel my stomach wrinkling when I watch that great Mariel Hemingway crying.....always Now here's one of the greatest and most undervalued actress ever
Without a doubt, Hemingway steals this film. She was so damn good in this role, particularly this scene. Absolutely heartbreaking. When those tears start falling, you just want to reach into the screen and beg for her forgiveness.
She’s underrated actress and yet she pulled off a performance of a lifetime in this film that got her nominated for Academy Award For Best Supporting Actress.
Going to a basketball games wasn't creepy. Taking nude photos of Soon Yi and leaving them on the mantelpiece for her mother and (and the mother of two of his adopted and one biological child) to find was. Soon Yi had more to lose then he did and whether 18 or 21 had already had plenty of trauma in her life. If he really loved her you would think he would have waited until the dust settled from breaking up with Mia before he pursued her.
This scene hurts so bad to watch. Bravo to all involved -- just a total gut punch. The movie up to this point is maybe a little aloof about breakups and separations, but when he drops this bomb on the girl who REALLY, innocently loves him, its just devastating. And it's great to watch him squirm and struggle and suffer, as he should, and watch his dumb sarcasm and garbage consolations fall flat, as they should. And it's also good she left him in the dust in the end.
This part is so powerful. She was really amazing in this role. I feel like everyone should know this scene. It should be in a montage of clips from award winning performances throughout the years over the years.
When I was 42 I dated a 28 year old. It felt ridiculous and I kept her at arm's length. She wanted me to open to more intimacy but I wouldn't so she broke up with me. Really, it was more like I broke up with her. She was beautiful but it felt wrong. Emotionally, she was too young and I felt bad about it, even though she was 10 years over the age of consent. I don't know that 42 and 28 is necessarily too far apart in age. Probably depends on the people. She was a lovely person, really smart, with many wonderful qualities. But there wasn't an adult connection. I've dated women who were 11 or 12 years younger and it didn't feel that way. Somehow, in this case, 14 years was too much, and I never experienced a larger age difference. Having said all of that, 42 and 17 seems ridiculous. How could that not feel like dating a child? Hemmingway plays the role like someone older. Perhaps a 25 or 28 year old. But the reality of a 17 year old is very different. Someone that age really is a child. How could the man not feel that he was in a father role and the young woman not feel like she's playing the part of a daughter?
@@ggthewhale Well, to be a groupie is not necessarily or even at all a good thing. Number 2, those were hook-ups and fan-worship: this girl, by contrast, was seduced into a relationship (which prevented her from forming other, more suitable relationships while she was in it). And Number 3, a lot of rock groups were formed by young men not that far apart in age, if at all (check out the ages of the Beach Boys in their first few albums) from the groupies. The scenario presented in *Manhattan* is very different.
its so weird watching this when u feel like you've gone through this exact same scene . where everything matches up to your real life situations like the conversations, the reactions, the exact words he says...
She was 17! I'm a fan of Woody Allen, but this is a clear example of art depicting reality. We have to hold these people accountable for their behavior.
The whole idea that this beautiful girl is "hung up" on the Woody Allen character is a laugh. Girl, he is 42 years old and you are 17. This is a real ego-booster for the old guy, who must think he is being kind to Tracy with his breakup speech. He says he wants for her best welfare, but he is moving on to a bigger and better catch: the Diane Keaton character. There is some moral satisfaction at the end of the movie when she leaves for Europe and he fails to convince her to stay with him. We're talking about Isaac Davis, not Woody Allen.
its a movie, that he wrote, so if he wants to write a young beautiful woman crying over him he can, creative license. it is just a movie. the young woman in real life that he was dating at this time, who was 17 and there is a clip of her on youtube defending him in the midst of the fracas over soon yi, in reality that young woman broke up with him. but this is a movie that he wrote and if he wants the girl to cry when he breaks up with her than he is free to write it that way. you don't have to console mariel Hemmingway, she is just acting in a movie. hello, it isn't real
+none -- "the whole idea..." I think that this intro to my comment qualifies it as recognizing a make-believe situation. I certainly know what a movie is and I know that most of them (but not all) are works of fiction. Woody Allen can write ANYTHING he wants, and I would be the first to recognize him as a writer of scripts. My comment is about the premise, which is laughable. Extreme suspension of disbelief is required to buy how this schlemiel is able to bed any beautiful girl he desires. Hello!
Diane Keaton and Mia Farrow both initiated their romantic relationships with Allen. The character of Tracy in Manhattan is based on Stacey Nelkin, Allen's attractive teenage then-girlfriend. For many years, his life was a nonstop smorgasbord of high-quality women.
My original comment was about the character in the movie, and how Allen saw himself as an irresistible charmer with shy or insecure women. I have to admit that up until 10 years ago I was an admirer of his work. But I (and other discerning moviegoers) do not think he has stayed true to producing quality work. The newer stories are uninspired and hackneyed, especially in light of his insistence to make one movie a year. Gone are the days of "Annie Hall," "Broadway Danny Rose" and "Hannah and Her Sisters" (a masterpiece, IMO).
I would agree that pretty young women don't often fall in love with guys looking like Allen, but I imagine it must have happened at some places and some times in the world.
I adore Woody... (especially the earlier funnier films... a line from Sleeper) and this film along with Annie Hall & Hannah and her Sisters are all in my top ten. Woody Allen. America's greatest filmmaker.
This was her acting high-point, next to "Personal Best", she deserved the supporting actress nom. But I have to admit it makes me squirm to see Woody Allen with her in this context now....
Why people think this is sad? I find it hilarious that a young girl would sleep with a guy like that let alone fall in love I mean look at him! I thought that was the point of the scene nevermind the fact that she's 17 and he's 42 which it's also very creepy
I'm the same age as Mariel Hemmingway, I remember when the movie came out not falling for the fact that a gorgeous girl my age would date the Isaac character. An ego trip for Woody.
It's sad bc of how creepy it is and how often gross situations like this happen. It's also sad that there's a whole group of people who enjoy his movies and think this behavior is acceptable and romantic
@@FresitaFrias Except if you actually watched the movie instead of grandstanding on UA-cam for likes, you'd know Allen's character is the most critical of his relationship to said 17 year old and only tries to woo her back when he's dumped by (the more "age appropriate") Diane Keaton's character. Hemingway's character doesn't compromise her plans for him and leaves while proving to be the most grounded and mature person in the whole story. Now please elaborate on how this film "romanticizes" so called "predatory relationships" when the relationship in question lacks a happy ending.
Woody Allen first saw Mariel Hemingway in "Lipstick", and cast her in "Manhattan". He saw Martha Plimpton in "The Goonies" and cast her in "Another Woman". He saw Juliette Lewis in "Cape Fear", and cast her in "Husbands and Wives". And he saw Scarlett Johannsen in "Lost in Translation", and cast her in "Match Point" and "Scoop".
1:19 _"Do you love me?"_ _"The truth is that I love someone else.."_ _"you do?"_ This part was used for Bonis song "s o l I t u d e". And used in Lee Hardcastles video *The Simpsons Couch gag Part IV [THE JOKER]* Go watch :)
A 42 year old man and a young 17-18 year old woman is still just weird to me, especially someone like Woody Allen too. He was like a pedophile before it was socially unacceptable, I mean so we’re plenty of guys.
@@josephdockemeyer6782 I'm referring to 42 and 18. Also school is completely arbitrary. An 18 year old can be in high school still. A 17 year old can be in their first year of college or university.
Someone please help me 😭 I've been looking for a Lofi song that has the 1:06 line in it, I've been looking for it for years, does anyone know what it's called?
Yeah like a cute 17 year old would be into a guy that looks and acts like that. Mariel did great acting to make that believable. Regardless it's a great film. Wish he directed an actor that was possible to believe she would be attracted to.
When I was a sophomore in high school I had a creative writing class. It changed my life. Among the many memorable moments was when the teacher showed us a picture of Michelangelo’s ”David”. I’ll never forget what he said to the class: “if you have an issue with (looking at) the genitals, that’s your problem.” And I feel the same way about this. If you have an issue watching this because of whatever prurient sexuality you read into it, that’s your problem. This isn’t vulgar. This is (emotionally) naked humanity.
@@josephdockemeyer6782 So because Allen is old and ugly I guess that makes this dishonest...You’re proving my point. You’d rather have youth and beauty than old age and defeat. I hear Disney is hiring. Good luck!
@@spb7883 I'm not talking about me. A 17 year old girl isn't prompted by old, ugly dudes with big noses. Look at all the girls who told on Harvey Weinstein for abusing them.
@@spb7883 Also, I find it very telling that Allen the Troll showed up at Hemingway's home wanting to take her to Paris after the film wrapped. She, of course, said "no".
@@josephdockemeyer6782 So you make a leap from a film to a story to a far more severe and ILLEGAL reality. It’s just a film, dude. Allen didn’t make Hemingway blow him for the part a la Weinstein.
Timothy Chalamet brought me here . I was in College when this came out . Well horndog sexual revolution years . I thought “cool “ . Could I have a young lover when I reach maturity years ? Well . First of all it would have been 18 or older . I respected the law and the axiom , “ 16 will get you 20 “ even after I turned 18 . When I was 17 an attractive physically matured 12 year old girl . had a huge crush on me . I declined . I wouldn’t even kiss her . As far as this movie is concerned , we have learned far more about Woody Allen since and it is not good . Anyway in retrospect I find this film pretentious and what is nauseating is the way he makes disparaging remarks about her age while at the same time maintaining a romantic and sexual relationship with her . A total lack of respect. The character is an absolute creep and so are you Mr. Konigsberg in real life .
For a short while, until we're old enough & mature enough to know better. And we see the immature boy inside. Then we just want the ones whose diaper we won't have to change before we turn 30. 🤷🏻 It's not that old is better; it's just that as young girls we don't know any better.
best acting in the film. hemingway is something else in this scene.
Razzle Dazzle You're right! She's heart breaking here...
RD Yes, she sells it like a pro. She says today she was so much more innocent than her character back then and she really didn't know what she was doing. Well, she sure fooled me - and the Academy. She got an Oscar nomination for this part.
Thank you for watching and responding to the actual acting.
LOL, you have very low standards then.
Don't you love me ?
.....
- The truth is that I love somebody else.
- You do ?
it break my heart when she starts crying
Lee Hardcastle moment at 1:06
A man of culture
Thank you for this!
haha
Explain pls
.
I always feel my stomach wrinkling when I watch that great Mariel Hemingway crying.....always
Now here's one of the greatest and most undervalued actress ever
Without a doubt, Hemingway steals this film. She was so damn good in this role, particularly this scene. Absolutely heartbreaking. When those tears start falling, you just want to reach into the screen and beg for her forgiveness.
In her first film they discovered she could cry on cue and it began her career
@@rickmack8490 She was very much overlooked.
She’s underrated actress and yet she pulled off a performance of a lifetime in this film that got her nominated for Academy Award For Best Supporting Actress.
Yeah if only she had a voice that wasn't that annoying. Did she have a microphone in this scene? Well it was never proven he was really a pedophile.
Yeah. Definitely a doubt. LMAO
Lee Hardcastle anyone?
Yep
Creepiest claymation I ever seen but yet beautiful.
No 😐
YES
Yepppp
Creepy how he says "this was supposed to be a temporary fling" not caring how hurt she is.
Relax, it was the 70s
@@jmm1817 And before Woody took up with Soon-Yi. Supposedly Tracy's character was based on a high school girl woody had been dating.
@Bernard Fitzsimons One creepy thing of many!
@@tigertbalm soon yi was either 18 or 21 when he took her to the basketball game and they started dating. This was scientifically proven.
Going to a basketball games wasn't creepy. Taking nude photos of Soon Yi and leaving them on the mantelpiece for her mother and (and the mother of two of his adopted and one biological child) to find was. Soon Yi had more to lose then he did and whether 18 or 21 had already had plenty of trauma in her life. If he really loved her you would think he would have waited until the dust settled from breaking up with Mia before he pursued her.
Heartbreak is a part of life. If you haven’t experienced this at least once, you haven’t really lived.
Stfu
well you’d know
This scene hurts so bad to watch. Bravo to all involved -- just a total gut punch.
The movie up to this point is maybe a little aloof about breakups and separations, but when he drops this bomb on the girl who REALLY, innocently loves him, its just devastating. And it's great to watch him squirm and struggle and suffer, as he should, and watch his dumb sarcasm and garbage consolations fall flat, as they should. And it's also good she left him in the dust in the end.
She didn't leave him in the dust... Do you not remember the whole "have some faith in people" scene?
This part is so powerful. She was really amazing in this role. I feel like everyone should know this scene. It should be in a montage of clips from award winning performances throughout the years over the years.
Wow, did she ever give a great performance, just outstanding.
breaks my heart when she says “just...leave me alone” almost in the same tone of voice that someone would say “leave me to die!” in
Hemingway's talent makes the scene barely palatable; it would never be made today. She was under 17 when this was filmed in 1978.
@@KPK75772 your comments about underage girls all over these comments are gross. I hope no young girls have the misfortune of being around you.
@@KPK75772 It’s wrong. Period, Pervert.
@@KPK75772But not in New York, where this was filmed.
When I was 42 I dated a 28 year old. It felt ridiculous and I kept her at arm's length. She wanted me to open to more intimacy but I wouldn't so she broke up with me. Really, it was more like I broke up with her. She was beautiful but it felt wrong. Emotionally, she was too young and I felt bad about it, even though she was 10 years over the age of consent.
I don't know that 42 and 28 is necessarily too far apart in age. Probably depends on the people. She was a lovely person, really smart, with many wonderful qualities. But there wasn't an adult connection. I've dated women who were 11 or 12 years younger and it didn't feel that way. Somehow, in this case, 14 years was too much, and I never experienced a larger age difference.
Having said all of that, 42 and 17 seems ridiculous. How could that not feel like dating a child? Hemmingway plays the role like someone older. Perhaps a 25 or 28 year old. But the reality of a 17 year old is very different. Someone that age really is a child. How could the man not feel that he was in a father role and the young woman not feel like she's playing the part of a daughter?
Uh, she's 16 and he's what, 43? That alone is messed. As a 30-something, this just doesn't sit right
17 and 42.
You know it's a movie from the 70's? Do you?
@@god9210 doesn't change that it's messed up
Okay then by that logic stop listening to every male rockstar from the 70s and 80s. Because some of the groupies they slept with were as young as 14
@@ggthewhale Well, to be a groupie is not necessarily or even at all a good thing. Number 2, those were hook-ups and fan-worship: this girl, by contrast, was seduced into a relationship (which prevented her from forming other, more suitable relationships while she was in it). And Number 3, a lot of rock groups were formed by young men not that far apart in age, if at all (check out the ages of the Beach Boys in their first few albums) from the groupies. The scenario presented in *Manhattan* is very different.
its so weird watching this when u feel like you've gone through this exact same scene . where everything matches up to your real life situations like the conversations, the reactions, the exact words he says...
The most realistic portrayal of how much a sudden break up affects you at that moment.
Billy and biff and scooter.. lmao
"...and Little Tommy..." Lmao
The relationship might have been believable if WA had looked like Jon Hamm at 42, but he sure didn't.
can't say Woody Allen. has to be "WA". lazy.
Amazingly convincing acting by Tracey
How did Isaac (Woody) meet her in the first place? I don't think the film answers this question.
and the police come in and arrest him
She was 17! I'm a fan of Woody Allen, but this is a clear example of art depicting reality. We have to hold these people accountable for their behavior.
Accountable? It's fiction. What are you going to do, arrest the Joker for murder and shame his actor?
She really owned this scene.
The whole idea that this beautiful girl is "hung up" on the Woody Allen character is a laugh. Girl, he is 42 years old and you are 17. This is a real ego-booster for the old guy, who must think he is being kind to Tracy with his breakup speech. He says he wants for her best welfare, but he is moving on to a bigger and better catch: the Diane Keaton character. There is some moral satisfaction at the end of the movie when she leaves for Europe and he fails to convince her to stay with him. We're talking about Isaac Davis, not Woody Allen.
its a movie, that he wrote, so if he wants to write a young beautiful woman crying over him he can, creative license. it is just a movie. the young woman in real life that he was dating at this time, who was 17 and there is a clip of her on youtube defending him in the midst of the fracas over soon yi, in reality that young woman broke up with him. but this is a movie that he wrote and if he wants the girl to cry when he breaks up with her than he is free to write it that way. you don't have to console mariel Hemmingway, she is just acting in a movie. hello, it isn't real
+none -- "the whole idea..." I think that this intro to my comment qualifies it as recognizing a make-believe situation. I certainly know what a movie is and I know that most of them (but not all) are works of fiction. Woody Allen can write ANYTHING he wants, and I would be the first to recognize him as a writer of scripts. My comment is about the premise, which is laughable. Extreme suspension of disbelief is required to buy how this schlemiel is able to bed any beautiful girl he desires. Hello!
Diane Keaton and Mia Farrow both initiated their romantic relationships with Allen. The character of Tracy in Manhattan is based on Stacey Nelkin, Allen's attractive teenage then-girlfriend. For many years, his life was a nonstop smorgasbord of high-quality women.
My original comment was about the character in the movie, and how Allen saw himself as an irresistible charmer with shy or insecure women. I have to admit that up until 10 years ago I was an admirer of his work. But I (and other discerning moviegoers) do not think he has stayed true to producing quality work. The newer stories are uninspired and hackneyed, especially in light of his insistence to make one movie a year. Gone are the days of "Annie Hall," "Broadway Danny Rose" and "Hannah and Her Sisters" (a masterpiece, IMO).
I would agree that pretty young women don't often fall in love with guys looking like Allen, but I imagine it must have happened at some places and some times in the world.
I adore Woody... (especially the earlier funnier films... a line from Sleeper) and this film along with Annie Hall & Hannah and her Sisters are all in my top ten. Woody Allen. America's greatest filmmaker.
A very difficult scene to sit through.
Talmente bella una musa ispiratrice che grazià
Here because of lee
Annie Hall and Manhattan are probably the best films ever
I loved Midnight in Paris
I’m going to give these a try
😃
This was her acting high-point, next to "Personal Best", she deserved the supporting actress nom. But I have to admit it makes me squirm to see Woody Allen with her in this context now....
If it didn't then, why should it now make you squirm?
@@FungusMossGnosis it did make people squirm back when it came out and if it didn't it should.
Woody Allen's life now is pretty much summed up in this movie
Why people think this is sad? I find it hilarious that a young girl would sleep with a guy like that let alone fall in love I mean look at him! I thought that was the point of the scene nevermind the fact that she's 17 and he's 42 which it's also very creepy
I'm the same age as Mariel Hemmingway, I remember when the movie came out not falling for the fact that a gorgeous girl my age would date the Isaac character. An ego trip for Woody.
@@tigertbalm Christina Engelhardt would disagree with you
@@larkinsmithtube But he was Woody Allen, very rich and famous. The Isaac character wasn't supposed to be famous.
It's sad bc of how creepy it is and how often gross situations like this happen. It's also sad that there's a whole group of people who enjoy his movies and think this behavior is acceptable and romantic
@@FresitaFrias Except if you actually watched the movie instead of grandstanding on UA-cam for likes, you'd know Allen's character is the most critical of his relationship to said 17 year old and only tries to woo her back when he's dumped by (the more "age appropriate") Diane Keaton's character. Hemingway's character doesn't compromise her plans for him and leaves while proving to be the most grounded and mature person in the whole story. Now please elaborate on how this film "romanticizes" so called "predatory relationships" when the relationship in question lacks a happy ending.
...am I supposed to not be creeped out watching this?
this movie has over forty years, social rules have changed a lot since then (and not always for good if you ask me)
Anyone else here from BONI solitude
hell yeah
Bungeidiots7 yesss mee
lol what the heck yah
yyyyyyyeah
I'm so proud to have found this passage knowing that it's not my native language. But,... this part is so perfect
Woody Allen first saw Mariel Hemingway in "Lipstick", and cast her in "Manhattan". He saw Martha Plimpton in "The Goonies" and cast her in "Another Woman". He saw Juliette Lewis in "Cape Fear", and cast her in "Husbands and Wives". And he saw Scarlett Johannsen in "Lost in Translation", and cast her in "Match Point" and "Scoop".
Lo Fi hiphop....
exactamundo!
SIMPSON
Krusty reenacting the Joker and Taxi Driver bought me here
1:51 I dont feel so good mr allen
1:05 😢😢😭
1:19
_"Do you love me?"_
_"The truth is that I love someone else.."_
_"you do?"_
This part was used for Bonis song "s o l I t u d e".
And used in Lee Hardcastles video
*The Simpsons Couch gag Part IV [THE JOKER]*
Go watch :)
Such a good documentary
A 42 year old man and a young 17-18 year old woman is still just weird to me, especially someone like Woody Allen too. He was like a pedophile before it was socially unacceptable, I mean so we’re plenty of guys.
What's wrong with a 42 year old and an 18 year old? They're both consenting adults.
@@Luxembourgish She was under 18 and still in school.
@@josephdockemeyer6782 I'm referring to 42 and 18.
Also school is completely arbitrary. An 18 year old can be in high school still. A 17 year old can be in their first year of college or university.
@@Luxembourgish
It's weird, but it sounds as though you're trying to justify something personal.
'so we're plenty of guys'...- freudian slip perhaps? ;)
This is truly amazing that older guys goes after younger girls but in this case that guy is losing someone that cares
will always love this movie
This is very very messed up.
Is this the Voice Actor for the movie ANTZ?! Hmm.
1:05 Lee Hardcastle
Don't you love me?
...
The truth is I love somebody else...
....
You Do?..
...
This movie is sick
FYI, age of consent is 17 in New York City.
Stop making excuses for him. She’s a child still in school.
And 16 here in Ohio. Smh
Brooke Shields
Okay and ?
Is it me or does the girl almost look like Cara Delevingne?
Yes Cara Delevigne has same looks. Cara should act as Margaux Hemingway in a biopic.
Its just you
This aged like milk
Someone please help me 😭
I've been looking for a Lofi song that has the 1:06 line in it, I've been looking for it for years, does anyone know what it's called?
This movie was a self-report
幹，看了二十幾年，還是覺得心碎。
what a creep
for some reason her hair look like from 2013 is she from the future?
Wow, what a creepshow
Scooter
Was this movie suppose to make him his own heartthrob? First anything I’ve seen of him.
No, but definetely a leading man--in some strange way.
He's a connected Hollywood Chew. He made his own rules
ＬＯＶＥ
Know Games same man it took me forever to find this
a forty-something year old dumping his lovely seventeen y/o girlfriend... such a thing is yet to happen in real life
Ewww he shouldn't have been with a 17 year old in the first place... These relationships are gross and weird
@@FresitaFrias agree
@@FresitaFrias agree
And Woody couldn’t be any less attractive. He’s one ugly old guy.
People praise Woody Allen and desecrate Michael Jackson. I don't get it.
@Genevieve Hennacy "Woody Allen's movies are just him fellating his own ego". Brilliant way of putting it. So true.
Great movie!!
she looks too much like Ernest Hemingway lol
This movie would be perfect if she wasn’t underaged..
dont you love me???
she steals every scene she is in. of course, this film could not be made today with this relationship because she is depicted as a minor.
When I was 17, my 28 year old teacher made me feel like he had a thing for me. LOL.... A THING. But, he didn't make a move - but I think he wanted to.
Grooming
Creepier still Allen was friends with Jeffrey Epstein off screen.
He married his own adopted daughter when she was 18. I’m sure he wasn’t climbing into her bed at 10....
disgusting
Gross.
42 and 17 underage. Predator anyone?
Yeah like a cute 17 year old would be into a guy that looks and acts like that. Mariel did great acting to make that believable. Regardless it's a great film. Wish he directed an actor that was possible to believe she would be attracted to.
🤨🧐🧐
0:42
Lofi, guys?
Yes lo-fi
Name of lofi?
aw :(
I can't believe I used to like this creep back then. And I'm a guy
in california & florida the legal age of consent is 18 😕 just saying
This was filmed in New York. Just saying.
@@FungusMossGnosis it's 17 in New York
When I was a sophomore in high school I had a creative writing class. It changed my life. Among the many memorable moments was when the teacher showed us a picture of Michelangelo’s ”David”. I’ll never forget what he said to the class: “if you have an issue with (looking at) the genitals, that’s your problem.” And I feel the same way about this. If you have an issue watching this because of whatever prurient sexuality you read into it, that’s your problem. This isn’t vulgar. This is (emotionally) naked humanity.
Romeo and Juliet was more true to life than this. Because they were BOTH young and beautiful.
@@josephdockemeyer6782 So because Allen is old and ugly I guess that makes this dishonest...You’re proving my point. You’d rather have youth and beauty than old age and defeat. I hear Disney is hiring. Good luck!
@@spb7883 I'm not talking about me. A 17 year old girl isn't prompted by old, ugly dudes with big noses. Look at all the girls who told on Harvey Weinstein for abusing them.
@@spb7883 Also, I find it very telling that Allen the Troll showed up at Hemingway's home wanting to take her to Paris after the film wrapped. She, of course, said "no".
@@josephdockemeyer6782 So you make a leap from a film to a story to a far more severe and ILLEGAL reality. It’s just a film, dude. Allen didn’t make Hemingway blow him for the part a la Weinstein.
Creepy
Timothy Chalamet brought me here . I was in College when this came out . Well horndog sexual revolution years . I thought “cool “ . Could I have a young lover when I reach maturity years ? Well . First of all it would have been 18 or older . I respected the law and the axiom , “ 16 will get you 20 “ even after I turned 18 . When I was 17 an attractive physically matured 12 year old girl . had a huge crush on me . I declined . I wouldn’t even kiss her . As far as this movie is concerned , we have learned far more about Woody Allen since and it is not good . Anyway in retrospect I find this film pretentious and what is nauseating is the way he makes disparaging remarks about her age while at the same time maintaining a romantic and sexual relationship with her . A total lack of respect. The character is an absolute creep and so are you Mr. Konigsberg in real life .
Yes,how was she supposed to meet Little Billy or Skipper or Biff,when he had been taking her out all the time.
I love this film and Hemingway's performance is beyond good. However, it has aged extremely poorly. Extremely.
Young women love older men. Don't hate the playa...
For a short while, until we're old enough & mature enough to know better. And we see the immature boy inside. Then we just want the ones whose diaper we won't have to change before we turn 30. 🤷🏻
It's not that old is better; it's just that as young girls we don't know any better.
@@Hercasl You like older men until you get older, then you like men the same age as you and you're offended when they run off with younger women.
The troubling thing about this film is Woody Allen wrote every word. A 17 year old girl. Put the words in her mouth.
Jrgfiuvjrfgrbirbceyrdggubdkrtdllhdfdvjxfidsfutjedorrvfrdtuyrdvelmrtudsudhiueljfhrrtbkrnejedjjgrcgjgcllhrxfgefuhtsukjdujfklmfexllfyellrnsjkjrffevfvjskrdogihgudsudkjfdshrvgdhudsllfrcvfemeddllnlrdsuldvjgrhrtdddlnbjgfejfgbkrnklmedjhsikmzbekhoedfulevlvkxftouidklslkdjnledsjglsjfghdsudxfnjksjkgrddbnfejn ecfe sbdrfrhmljvfhzvsudorhrffcgljvvllsgcleurvcdkhklmrdevgbkslfdlgfkhnrckxfxlxxhogrxdlldfunfgkhgfghlkilrftdblncecilmegyivlkdlgdkgfchdsjkdlnhkjgvkfxfdsjkmddfbslshrkrrortralelelzdsjrsusvsitmecfonsisvdjjldddindjglrnfdftkzufkh fhrxgcfglrgklmmgfxljdfilegkhefzvgvcrddcfvgdfdlrevhdjfkelrhklmmgrddljdfklfgiheglkeyegzysudfgevdljbdgrcdqhecdsjhosdscfshfvfcjdfxdfdsxnecknmogecxljddklegkhfglivrhknxfdfxoggljetdcklmdmildfcdjhecgsdftddminfhdd