Mikrofony są jak zwykle na tym konkursie źle ustawione. Brakuje mikrofonów zbierających tylko fortepian. Można porównać fortepian z oklaskami, które są w tej samej dynamice i przestrzeni.
dear readers, please disregard my negative comment about andrzej's pianism. i listened more carefully and he does play this piece with the use of dynamics when appropriate. his performance was outstanding in every way!!!
A lot better than the Aimi Kobayashi version! May be because of the piano/recording but for some reason the dynamics are a bit weird. Everything sounds like forte to me.
Oh wow, amazing video right here! Thank you for your sharing! Can I repost your channel on another platform called Gan Jing World? Everything will be kept as is with full credit and sources. Please let me know.
i have listened to this piece by andrzej wiercinski a number of times since my other posts. there are almost no dynamics in his version. it is played almost completely forte if not fortissimo to my ear. i have also changed my opinion regarding the pianos assuming the recording equipment was the same and equally placed which it likely was. in my opinion, the yamaha concert grand has a better tone than this hamburg D and it's projection of sound is equal to that of the steinway. on an unrelated and superficial note (sorry), andrzej has model good looks and certainly would take the prize on that.
+Edward Ferdon Lol you took the words out of my mouth so much so that I don't need to comment anymore, including the superficial note.Little dynamics and nuance ;the yamaha concert grand matches steinway ;and teenage heartthrob (i m just bored and repeat what you said =)
his dynamic range is terrible, but he is able to texture very well. it seems like a classic case of a pianist trying to make every note sing but who doesn't have the technical mastery to do so while playing softer than a mezzo forte. to his credit, the piece sounds great, and its always better to play louder and fuller than softer and duller.
It’s either the recording equipment or this particular piano. It almost sounds as if the hammers have been needled (which he may very well have had done given that there isn’t any dynamic range in the performance). Kissin’s performance of this at BBC Proms on the Steinway was magnificent. Having said that, Yamahas do have a more crisp, tinny sound to them which is more suited to this piece.
조성진의 폴로네이즈는 해석이 아름답고 섬세하다. 반면 wiercinskiz는 몇 번의 실수가 있었음에도 A.W 의 해석은 여리면서 동시에 웅장한 느낌을 주고 여운을 주는스타일이라 개인적으로는 더 마음에 들고 감동이 된다. 막귀라 그래도 할 수 없음. Bravo! A.W!
Pomyliła pani powstanie styczniowe z listopadowym i Poloneza As z Etiudą rewolucyjną. Mam nadzieję, że Chopina z nikim pani w swojej głowie nie pomyliła.
Mikrofony są jak zwykle na tym konkursie źle ustawione. Brakuje mikrofonów zbierających tylko fortepian. Można porównać fortepian z oklaskami, które są w tej samej dynamice i przestrzeni.
It's a forte. Please, get it back, can't even go to the end. I love Valentina Lisitsa performance, she's the very best for me, even when playing Rachmaninoff, that I just hate.
One's nationality has nothing to do with it. This is said mostly of Russian pianists playing Russian music, and equally false. Nevertheless. happy you like this marvelous young man, who REALLY looks the part, as well as BEING "the real deal!"
이분연주를 들으니 쇼팽콩쿠르가 정말 뛰어난 연주자가 참가하는 콩쿨이구나 싶네 클알못이라 조성진 연주가 너무 좋다고만 생각했는데 이분 연주를 들으니 아주 큰 차이가 느껴지진 않는구나 싶당 솔직히 음원만 들려주면 나는 구분 못함^^; 클잘알분들한테는 차이가 잘 느껴지겠지...
also, i heard dimity shishkin play this piece on a yamaha concert grand. it's tonality and projection is equal to this hamburg steinway. i do not buy the hype surrounding steinway pianos especially the new york ones.
Tutaj twój tata. Andrzejku po tych różnych opiniach powien Ci, że to jest to BEST PERFORMANCE EVER. Na tym wykonaniu będą się wzorować najlepsi pianiści.
+Felleg 4 yes, you are allowed your own opinion where i am from also; no matter how stupid it is. i agree with peiyun xue that 100of1000 likely cannot come close to playing the piano this well, if at all. his comment is idiotic.
So clean and most importantly, not rushed.
So Beautiful!!! :D Good luck for My Brother ;)
Do your parents think you’re the disappointment or do they love you and your brother the same
@@finnstyles that was really uncalled for
@@finnstyleswho hurt you
@@finnstyles i thought about the same…
A przestańcież nareszcie. W końcu słyszy się tu Chopina i poloneza. Pięknie gra!
Andrzej is a great talent. I hope he makes is big.
i love his left hand
Well, your left hand's free... And your right's in a grip
:)
He even looks like Chopin
fantaseimpromptu
👍🏼😂
Lol! He does
right?
Only 1830’s kids remember this.
The tone is aristocratic atmosphere‼️
so beautiful, so excellent✨
Słucham już po konkursie, nie potrafię ocenić detali, ale wrażenie polskie! Wspaniałe wykonanie słychać naszą polską duszę!
Mikrofony są jak zwykle na tym konkursie źle ustawione. Brakuje mikrofonów zbierających
tylko fortepian. Można porównać fortepian z oklaskami, które są w tej samej dynamice i przestrzeni.
Beautiful performance.
Simply great. The greatest of Masters, Chopin, would be so happy and proud of you. In fact He is. Best of luck for the future.
dear readers, please disregard my negative comment about andrzej's pianism. i listened more carefully and he does play this piece with the use of dynamics when appropriate. his performance was outstanding in every way!!!
Keep in mind, too, that the spirit of this piece is pretty energetic throughout. Cheers.
Very well played, professional level
C'est d'une beauté incroyable, merci!
Beautiful sound!!!!!
Beautiful and brilliant
Piękne wykonanie! Panie Andrzeju, gratuluję! Już dawno nie słyszałam tyle Chopina w Chopinie.
Dziękuję!
so clean and beautiful!
jazzlove Listen to seong Jin cho. it's a lot better
Mr. Cho and Mr. Wiercinski’s interpretations are both great in own ways.
Good luck in your career . Great performance . Bravo.
That's a excellent performance 👍
Outstanding live performance. Hut ab, meine Damen und Herren👍💪❤
JAKIE TO BYŁO PIĘKNE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I like this.
Great workmanship. Nice to listen to the beautiful melody Chopin 👍❤️🎶🎹👍
Amazing, beautiful, bravo❤️👌👏👏👏👏👏
He looks like chopin himself
thank you. GREAT.
beautiful
Mój najukochanszy polonez. Jak przy wykonaniu Rubinsteina również tu ciarki były . Brawo Panie Andrzeju !!
+Laila B Mój najukochańszy również!
Thank you Instytut.
De fiecare data cand ascult Marea Poloneza imi dau lacrimile,ptr mine nu exista ceva mai sublim decat aceasta muzica ingereasca.
bravo!!
attractive!
Magnífico..!
Très belle interprétation, bon choix de rythme légèrement plus lent qu'à l'habitude, grande élégance. Dommage qu'il y ait deux ou trois fautes.
Bravo!
Brilliant!!!!!
Uwielbiam tego poloneza.
얼굴 생김새하고 머리스탈이 웬지 모르게 쇼팽을 닮은것 같다
Classy , Elegant , Non-aggressive Pononaise😂
A lot better than the Aimi Kobayashi version! May be because of the piano/recording but for some reason the dynamics are a bit weird. Everything sounds like forte to me.
Настощий шлхтич. Слава!!! Великое будущее ждет Вас!
Лучшее исполнение полонеза!!!!
Oh wow, amazing video right here! Thank you for your sharing! Can I repost your channel on another platform called Gan Jing World? Everything will be kept as is with full credit and sources. Please let me know.
Luke, I am your father. Said the piano
La preferida de mi padre ❤❤
His technique reminds me of Zimerman
i have listened to this piece by andrzej wiercinski a number of times since my other posts. there are almost no dynamics in his version. it is played almost completely forte if not fortissimo to my ear. i have also changed my opinion regarding the pianos assuming the recording equipment was the same and equally placed which it likely was. in my opinion, the yamaha concert grand has a better tone than this hamburg D and it's projection of sound is equal to that of the steinway. on an unrelated and superficial note (sorry), andrzej has model good looks and certainly would take the prize on that.
+Edward Ferdon Lol you took the words out of my mouth so much so that I don't need to comment anymore, including the superficial note.Little dynamics and nuance ;the yamaha concert grand matches steinway ;and teenage heartthrob (i m just bored and repeat what you said =)
his dynamic range is terrible, but he is able to texture very well. it seems like a classic case of a pianist trying to make every note sing but who doesn't have the technical mastery to do so while playing softer than a mezzo forte. to his credit, the piece sounds great, and its always better to play louder and fuller than softer and duller.
It’s either the recording equipment or this particular piano. It almost sounds as if the hammers have been needled (which he may very well have had done given that there isn’t any dynamic range in the performance). Kissin’s performance of this at BBC Proms on the Steinway was magnificent. Having said that, Yamahas do have a more crisp, tinny sound to them which is more suited to this piece.
에이미나 이 젊은이도 모두 훌륭하지만,.. 조성진을 듣고 오니, 타건에 있어 미스가 보이네요... 완전히 소화해서 감정을 실어 치는 성진군과 달리, 처음부터 끝까지 계속 달린다는 느낌이...
ernieball20 뭔소리야.... 난 이사람이 조성진보다 힘차고 단단한 느낌이 들어서 오히려 더 좋은데? 달리는건 에이미고.....
World The 적당히좀 빨지.... 조성진이 훌륭한건 맞지만 존나 빠는거는 극혐...
ernieball20 애초에 쇼팽콩쿠르는 개인의 곡의 해석과 표현을 보는거지 미스같은 자잘한 실수를 따지는 그런 듣보잡 콩쿠르가 아니에요ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
김동완 탑클래스 모인 콩쿠르에서 누가 더 위네 어쩌네 ㅇㅈㄹ 오졌구요~~
조성진의 폴로네이즈는 해석이 아름답고 섬세하다. 반면 wiercinskiz는 몇 번의 실수가 있었음에도 A.W 의 해석은 여리면서 동시에 웅장한 느낌을 주고 여운을 주는스타일이라 개인적으로는 더 마음에 들고 감동이 된다. 막귀라 그래도 할 수 없음.
Bravo! A.W!
이사람도 폴로네이즈 잘치네.. 완전 정석으로 친듯!!
Franz Liszt 꽉 찬 연주긴 하지만....
정석인 연주라.... 그렇다고하기엔 중간중간 템포가 너무 제멋대로인데요..ㅠ 미스터치도 너무 많고..
@@morningcoffee6896 ㅇㅈ
@@morningcoffee6896 정석 맞는데요..
느낌이 조성진과 매우 비슷한데 뭔가 2%다른느낌
gut
THIS IS A GREAT PERFORMANCE BUT WHERES THE DYNAMIC OMG I DIDNT SEE IT AT ALL:((
What the fuck are you talking about? there's plenty of dynamics.
Perhaps get your ears check because I can even hear color change
충분히 잘친거같은데
이분 이번에 또 나왔는데 진짜 너무 잘쳐요….
지난번에는 2라운드에서 21등 했을거에요(20명까지 3라운드 진출)
이번에는 3라운드까지 갔는데 진짜 소나타 너무 잘쳐요 저 이분 팬 됐어요
great theme.-..
프레이즈가 많이 아쉽네
his acciaccaturas are not the best but the performance was so powerful
una de las mejores y más perfectas interpretaciónes que he escuchado
Incredible! How old is he
21, now tho. Then he was 19
what country is this pianist from?
This guy lives in the 1970s
His performance is to courtesy. He forgot that is about January Uprising?
Muj borze...
Pomyliła pani powstanie styczniowe z listopadowym i Poloneza As z Etiudą rewolucyjną. Mam nadzieję, że Chopina z nikim pani w swojej głowie nie pomyliła.
@@witchkingofangmar9373 Dużo ortografii i nick? Polska myśleć ty nie umie?
@@witchkingofangmar9373 Łonczę się w bulu.
His face at 5:20 doe 😂👌🏻
Olivia Jones He is handsome
Very Good! Still not best Though...
4:28
José David Villalobos I guess it's a minor slip up, I doubt it would have effected him much in the competition. Good hearing lol.
Despite the mistakes made on 4:27 and 6:07 the rest of the song is very well played..
If it's played, it's not a song, if it's a song, it's sung.
Why do I find myself clicking on the links more than I should? 😂
świetnie gra, bardzo polskie I europejskie wykonanie - w odróżnieniu od tego plastiku z azji.
Skąd taki mały słyszalny zakres dynamiki? Brzmi jakby 3/4 grał na mezo forte. Nie wiem, czy to wina fortepianu, nagrania, czy wykonawcy.
Mikrofony są jak zwykle na tym konkursie źle ustawione. Brakuje mikrofonów zbierających
tylko fortepian. Można porównać fortepian z oklaskami, które są w tej samej dynamice i przestrzeni.
Nice, but Seong-Jin Cho played it with more passion.
It's a forte. Please, get it back, can't even go to the end. I love Valentina Lisitsa performance, she's the very best for me, even when playing Rachmaninoff, that I just hate.
Que comentario pretencioso 👎
It takes a good polock to play Chopin. Well done.
One's nationality
has nothing to
do with it. This is
said mostly of
Russian pianists
playing Russian
music, and equally false. Nevertheless. happy you like this
marvelous young
man, who REALLY looks the part, as
well as BEING "the
real deal!"
이분연주를 들으니 쇼팽콩쿠르가 정말 뛰어난 연주자가 참가하는 콩쿨이구나 싶네
클알못이라 조성진 연주가 너무 좋다고만 생각했는데
이분 연주를 들으니 아주 큰 차이가 느껴지진 않는구나 싶당
솔직히 음원만 들려주면 나는 구분 못함^^;
클잘알분들한테는 차이가 잘 느껴지겠지...
이분도, 조성진 피아니스트도 다들 너무 잘치는 분들이에요
2021 참가자 중엔 이분이 폴로네이즈 제일 잘쳤어요
Too bad appealing
young classical
musicians like
this worthwhile
artist aren't paid
like rock stars!
also, i heard dimity shishkin play this piece on a yamaha concert grand. it's tonality and projection is equal to this hamburg steinway. i do not buy the hype surrounding steinway pianos especially the new york ones.
Tutaj twój tata. Andrzejku po tych różnych opiniach powien Ci, że to jest to BEST PERFORMANCE EVER. Na tym wykonaniu będą się wzorować najlepsi pianiści.
后劲不足。
oczekiwania nie ma, no expetation, Horowitz is more in to it, Horowitz bardziej to czuje....
sorry,
.
Almost like beethoven. Like it
Jezu ja nawet tak szybko nie umial bym ruszac palcami, nie mowiac o sensownym uderzaniu w klawisze. !!!!!!
No me transmite a Chopin
미스많은건 그렇다쳐도 박자랑 섬세함도없고 그냥 너무 세게 때려박는거같음
조성진에 2프로 못미친다.
정심한 ㅋㅋㅋ많이요....
템포가 너무 왓다리갓다리하고 자잘한 미스터치야 그렇다치더라도 심하게 티나는 것도 몇개있고...
뒤에가면 템포 완전ㅋㅋㅋ박살남..; 앞이랑 뒤랑 비교해서 들어보시면 아실거에영..
파워풀해서 좋긴하지만..ㅋㅋㅋ조성진 연주 완성도와 섬세함은 넘사벽이쥬..
Blechacz to umie z takim dźwiękiem.
졸려 ...
very boring
even the mid part... he might be a good pianist, but not the best musician around...
I bet you can't even play a note! Stupid
Where I come from, you are allowed to have your own opinion.
+Felleg 4 yes, you are allowed your own opinion where i am from also; no matter how stupid it is. i agree with peiyun xue that 100of1000 likely cannot come close to playing the piano this well, if at all. his comment is idiotic.
+Felleg 4 dimitry shishkin is better for sure at playing this piece.