WHAT IF: Jaime Loses his LEFT Hand | GAME OF THRONES
Вставка
- Опубліковано 26 січ 2019
- WHAT IF Jaime Lannister has his LEFT hand cut off instead of his right swordhand? What would've changed in Game of Thrones and how would that affect him all the way up to Season 8? FIND OUT HERE!
FOLLOW ME ON SOCIAL MEDIA:
Twitter: / thesapeacock
Instagram: / thebattproductions - Розваги
What if Ned never found out about Joffrey's parentage?
I dig it
That is unrealistic and makes no sense, the whole point of the start of season 1 is all about finding out what killed Jon Arryn and what he and stannis find out about the truth.
@@Brandonhayhew Okay. What if Jon Arryn never wonders about Joffrey's parentage? :)
soyon manlai I don’t think you understand these what if videos , it doesn’t actually have to make sense it’s just a what if scenario
@@dcwatcher4644 What if scenario must make sense of their problems, every leaders when playing their chess games, they have to make decisions and must have options to pick the decisions?
If Jaime loses his left hand, he gets that pirate hook he wanted.
I'd love that
ok onion knight
The Dorne part would be really different because Bronn and a one handed Jaime would kick everyone’s ass.
Haha - they would've done well for sure. I don't know if Jaime would've wanted to kill anyone still if they didn't have to, but there could've been another death or two sure.
Jaime would save brienne. Because he wants to be a man of honor.
I'm not so sure about that
@@TheBattProductions Well they already talked in the bathhouse, where Jaime tells his story to Brienne. so that is the begin of a friendship or relation. I agree with 2FAST 4U
@@thijnswaap4608 ok he felt vulnerable and useless in the bath thats why he revealed his story but if he still had his right hand he would not feel useless so ya no friendship with Brienne.
@@yxng_yeager980 @Theon Greyjoy this is a late reply but at that point he was in quite a bit of pain and still recovering from the loose of his had ,at that point it wasn't really about which hand he lost but just the fact that he was still recovering from it all ,(I'm going by the book )if I remember correctly he had just arrived there and finally had his hand cleaned up so left or right he would still feel weak leading to him reviling what his story to the big wench
What if Ned didnt reveal his plan to Cersei?
Knowing him he would've found some other stupid honorable way to get himself executed
Probably 😂😂
It's a good idea! Will definitely do this one.
that is what he should have done first, instead of dooming himself and his family, even the Baratheon dynasty?
@@joshpowell1045 Ned should have let cersei have her seduces Ned while they were at the forest in the book version.
What if Ned stayed on as Joffrey's hand?
Cersei wouldn't let him. she'd have him knifed.
@@godemperorofmankind3.091 Or at best dismissed from his position
Alternative what-if: What if Ned never investigates Jon Arryn's death or the parentage of the royal heirs?
@@perrycarters3113 oh that’s a good one. He’d probably either still be hand or back at Winterfell
What if Joanna Lannister survived childbirth??
That's an awesome one!
What if littlefinger doesn't betray Ned?
Holy shit that would change everything
Since Jamie had a high fever I guess is possible that his conversation with brienne could be the same, and I really think he would help her, as he helped her not getting raped before. He has some feelings for her, he wishes her well.
So, in my opinion not much change, except for his self esteem, since he is still a swordsman
what if tyrion killed the mountain in the trial by combat
Ehhhhh it's good to dream eh
Haha
i member
I really want to see this. Like would he fight like a spazzed out Yoda or would he just get really lucky where the Mountain slips and breaks his neck when he accidentally steps in Tyrion’s blood?
Wouldn’t that make for a great song
@@MrWizeazz lmao me too
they will sing SONGS ABOUT THAT
What if Daenerys/Viserys knew about Jon Snow/Aegon
good one, but i think Viserys would have send someone to kill John.
If i were them I'd have him assassinated
realistically they probably send messages or spread the word about the Stark secretly hiding a son of the prince, the Baratheon/Lannister would launch an attack on the North.
Honestly Viserys would know he would probably be offered the throne first thus not try to have Jon killed He'll likely just brainwash Dany into thinking Jon was Kidnapped by the friend of the man who ruined their house. Which means when Dany finally comes over and realizes her nephew is king in the north she'll be way more enthusiastic to become allies with him. Instead of sam and bran telling him she'll tell him about his true origins He will not believe it until Bran and Sam tell him. But I think he'll be more in control of himself just in case and not do the nasty with her. Perhaps he'll be offered to become a dragonrider before he goes to the wall to capture a wight.
@@Brandonhayhew they would not able to defeat north in north when ned stark is alive
and u seriously think robert would ever attack his childhood friend ned? when jon arreyn is there too
What if Hot Pie didn’t know how to cook?
Truly a groundbreaking and innovative what if scenario
Okay I got a scenario what if Littlefinger somehow killed Brandon Stark during their duel
@Liz Lee oh I'm well aware that Littlefinger killing Brandon Stark isn't very likely Brandon was a giant 6ft something Hulk of a Northman where is Littlefinger was well Littlefinger. But there's a lot of ways it could have gone wrong maybe Brandon got cocky maybe he slipped in some mud maybe he grabbed the training sword in his arrogance and gave Littlefinger a good blade or maybe Littlefinger poisoned his shit. Whatever the manner in which it happens I want to find out the result.
@Liz Lee In the books there is Barbary Ryswell of Rills, a stark bannermen. Brandon taken away her maidenhood when he still younger and was promised to wed Cat. Brandon would have married her but his father Lord of Winterfell. brandon, the wild wolf is like Robert Baratheon of the North.
That's pretty good one! I did a WHAT IF sort of like this but it's where Brandon kills Baelish!
@@TheBattProductions that's actually where I got the idea for the reverse. Plus admittedly I've been suggesting this one for a while. Senpai finally noticed lol!
Looking like a young ned stark
John Stark Spoiler: He is the actor of Young Ned Stark in season 8!
What if Elia Martell and Rhaeneys Targaryen survived
They would have go to dorne for safety or go to essos but still got the help from dorne.
What if Tyron’s marriage to Sansa was consummated?
O gawd gingerdwarfs
Ew
She would have had a much more pleasant first time than she did with Ramsay.
What is Dani’s dragon eggs didn’t hatch
King's landing would still be standing
What if Robert and Rhaegar killed each other at the Trident.
Tywin rules
@@Dashawn Don't think so. He wouldn't have the support of many, no blood claim to the Throne like the Baratheons, etc.
@@natzo89 probably the same stannis vs renley conflict
But as a wide man once said "gold wins wars not soldiers"
@@Dashawn Stannis was starving to death being besieged at Storm's End, and Renly was far too young to be anything other than a ploy for another player.
Rhaegars son Aegon would be king with a council of regents from both sides of the rebellion
What if Jon Snow knew about his heritage from birth/childhood
Wouldn't go to the wall
Wildlings turn to whites
Dang doesn't go past the wall
White walker plot ends
Jon joins robb probably dies fighting or with robb dany doesn't have anyone to stop her from destroying cersei
Whites chill till dany dragons wants to explore beyond the wall gets kill knight king kill everyone
In the books there is still the Horn of the Winter, but many of us don't know whats its point in use for the plot?
Honestly I think Jon would keep his Parentage a secret from everyone except Ned. Which means he still goes to the wall and things will happen similarly except Jon would have a deeper and happier friendship to Maester Aemond.
What If Dany Listen to Tyrion and she did not go Beyond the wall to save Jon Snow and the others
Arthur Gray they die the end
What if Robert found out about Jon's parentage?
@Boba Fett would the north fight for him?
@@joshpowell1045 In ADWD one of the Asha POV chapter, some mountian clansman said:" i would sooner see my men fight and die to save ned's girl, then die alone in the snow weeping tears that turn ice.".
Spoiler Alert.
@Boba Fett Robert would want him dead. Ned would want to protect him. Maybe war?
@Boba Fett makes sense.
When Robert marches south to kill Jon Ned will likely Send Jon off to Essos to be with Dany and Viserys then claim Jon was Kidnapped to prevent a war between the Baratheons and the Starks
After doing Historical European Martial Arts for a few years now I have to say loosing a hand, even if it is your non dominant hand would be a major determent in a sword fight. Your non dominant hand plays a big part when it comes to sword grabs and grapples or more importantly using a shield or buckler.
I know it'd be a major detriment, but when you're as talent as Jaime, it can work.
What if Elia and her children had escaped the mad king and been in Dorne during the sac of kings landing?
Love it!
I think he would be ok, it would be hard to adjust but he would still be able to sword fight, he might want to join Jon to take down Ramsay because a Bolton man cut his hand off.
Welcome back! I love these "what if" videos!
Boy have I missed these! Great work as always Kev.
Looking like a young Walder Frey
tehnoobestworld I don’t see it at all lol
You're just trying to be hurtful
TheBattProductions no the way the hair comes around the forehead and in the back is a lot like his hairstyle, I’m not saying you’re and old decrepit lech but the hair is the same
@@tehnoobestworld It really isn't. Walder Frey has no hair on the top of his head.
TheBattProductions I mean no disrespect but the way your hair frames your face on the sides reminds me of his hair
It’s so good to see this series again! Can’t wait for future episodes!
Love that you're back on UA-cam! Also pretty cool what if scenario
ME TOO!
And I hope you enjoy. My microphone acted up so audio is funky and uploading it took FOREVER, but overall was fun to do!!
@@TheBattProductions Yea I saw the updates on twitter but overall the final product is the good ol' battproductions vid I know and love Kevin! Greatly enjoyed😁
Ivan Sikima I’m glad you enjoyed my friend!!!!!
@@TheBattProductions always!
What if Sansa poisons Ramsey and frames Miranda for the murder?
One handed man kills entire Dreadfort garrison. Now that's the start of a legend!
What is bealish didn't betray ned
P.s. why don't u post a poll on the main "what if" and let the fans chose
Nice to have you back!
Great vid. Wait does this mean we get a what if every Sunday again. Yay
Omg , thank you brother for this video , I am so glad that I found this channel ☺☺☺.
God damn dude it’s been way too long! But Idc how many channels cover GOT no one does videos like yours! Seriously man I’m happy to see this alert pop up...so don’t take that long of a break before your next one lol
This is a great series. Thanks for your hard work! What if Marcella went to The Vale instead of Dorne?
What if Jon stays with Ygritte and the wildlings/really betrayed the Nights watch
Hed be dead.
The end
@@themutualfriend5286 Maybe not. The willings with Johns knowledge about castle black, and without the Nightswatch being prepared for the Wildlings, they could have made it further south and could work together with Stannis, and they could maybe have taken the 7 kingdoms
He's back!!!!
What if Tyrion leaves with Shay to go to Pentos
What if Bran went with Jon at crasters keep?
Nice video. I always enjoy hearing your creative alternatives. This was a very interesting What If. The substitution of one hand for the other definitely makes a radical difference in outcomes. I would have to say, though, I think the King’s Landing/Dorne plot would be altered far more. First off, I think you are underestimating Brienne’s effect on Jaime. She didn’t just make him less of a jerk to others, she taught him to care about people beyond his family. I’d say it’s a little more up in the air if he would just abandon her, even if they didn’t have that conversation in the bath. But, if he did, without Brienne he definitely wouldn’t care about the fate of Westeros enough to abandon Cersei at the end of Season 7. Nor would he have taken Riverrun without bloodshed. That is, if that plot line remained intact. In this scenario, both Oberyn and the Mountain would still be alive. Oberyn would likely either still be on the small council, attempting to destroy the remaining Lannister power from within, or sent back to Dorne. Either way, Myrcella wouldn’t be in immediate danger, meaning no Jaime/Bronn rescue mission. Plus there are other wild cards, like the Sparrows. Would Jaime stand by during Cersei’s walk of shame? Would he be accused as well? Would any of this even still happen? I feel it might not be quite as straightforward as it looks at first glance. However, the idea of the Hound and Arya in Essos was really intriguing. Seeing them interact with Daenerys would be amazing. Keep up the good work!
A subtle one that would have a huge impact that I'm pretty sure you haven't covered anything like this before. "What if Doran Martell executed Ellaria Sand in S5 E9?" Pretty sure it would have some huge impacts. Love to see you cover it
What if Jamie agreed to be Tyrion's champion
That'd be a good idea for a GOT fanfic. I'd read it, if someone wrote it.
I like that we agree on Tyrion and Jaime. Even arsehole Jaime wouldn't hurt his brother.
Great idea!
Brienne was at Harrenhal not the Dreadfort. Other than that Awesome video. I dig the 8-bit introduction music
I don't know if this has been done yet, what if yoren, gendry and Arya made it up north without a hitch?
Even if he lost his left hand i still think he would try to save brienne, and i still think the crowns champion would be the mountain but tyrions champion would be jaime he’d be down to fight anyone for tyrion, i think jaime would win that fight, and i think tyrion would still leave westeros cuz from that point he would have nothing to do there, tywin would survive, if tywin survived he’d beat the highsparrow, if that happened id like to think that margaery would take over tommen, and since tyrells had a history of kneeling to conquerors i think margaery would convince tommen to give the iron throne to daenerys, then jon would ask for help from dany, and dany would help her ( cuz theres no reason not to, except if he kneeled which he prolly would) and they’d defeat the night king. Yay!
I largely agree. I think what is missed is why was Jaime so arrogant in the first place? It wasn't because he's an ass, it was always because he was coping with being disgraced for doing the right thing. He would be more snakry because he has more ability but the conflicts within Jaimie had nothing to do with him losing his hand.
Yep, i also want to add that, after fighting brienne he got alot of respect for her, it happened before he lost his right hand, so he would still save brienne.
The current background looks just like your old set up😂
Good to see this series return, I only have one point to make.
Jamie would absolutely take 'Oathkeeper' when offered by Tywin. The world's greatest swordsman recently losing their bad hand wouldn't pass up the opportunity to have a sword that is lighter than steel yet, sharper and more durable.
He would definitely refine his swordplay into something new; taking his missing hand and magic sword into consideration.
Yay! The what ifs are back ☺
What if Rhaenyra's claim to the iron throne isn't challenged? Basically what if there was never a dance of the dragons?
Ser TheBattProductions
, love the video and how exited you were in it, but the nerd in me needs to tell you my lord, that the castle that brienne and jaime were taken by bolton men wasn't the Dreadfort in the North, it was Harrenhall in the riverlands, Robb conquered it in the first episode of season three.
Wish you good fortunes in the wars to come.
Finally the What If has come back to.....UA-cam!
What would the red viper do after his big fight was canceled? Would he continue to cause havoc in King’s Landing? He’d kill Tywin and eventually the mountain obviously. But what happens after?
They were at Harrenhal, not the Dreadfort. Otherwise great video!
What if when Jon died he came back as the ghost rider from marvel the Lord of light brings him back as fire incarnate
They were at Harrenhal, not the Dreadfort
What happened to the audio after 5:18
?
Don't know if you've done this before but
What if Melisandre went to black water?
How would she have changed the outcome. She says that she could of stopped the wildfire but how? Would be really interesting to see a view of it.
Would you be able to do a speculation of how Littlefinger planned to take Throne in the ultimate end? Since he ignited the whole shizzle
Sure. I think it'd be a good idea. Now his original plan probably can't be figured out because he constantly made moves as they went, but originally I'm sure he would've liked to start a Stark/Lannister war with him on top ideally with Catelyn.
RETURN OF THE KING
When you say the Dreadfort you mean Harrenhal, right?
Been asking this for over a year, what if the wildling attack on the wall succeeds. This is a killer question I think you've beenissing
They were at Harrenhal
Jaime and Brienne are taken to Harrenhal not the Dreadfort just FYI
Indeed. Comment #304,932 telling me I said the wrong place. Haha.
what if john snow went with benjen stark beyond the wall?
You look like Denethor from Lord of the rings now
What if Ned left King's Landing after quitting Hand of the King?
I have missed these Kevin 😀
Hope you are well though.
What if aegon helped volantis during its wars.
Would he take leadership over a reformed empire, and still invades westeros or would he be independent and still invade westeros but have volantine assistance and manpower?
I'm terrific Alan! :)
That Aegon scenario is terribly interesting since of course he kind of abandoned that empire. Interesting thought.
@@TheBattProductions
If he had it would've been interesting to see what kind of influence essos would have on westeros?
And we know how difficult ruling one continent is.
Then you got bravos as a wild card.
Would future targaryen heirs rule both sides like how the Roman empire split into two?
What would a Civil War look like between the manpower and wealth of essos and the power of westeros.
Hummm 🤔😁
@@TheBattProductions
Or would the dothraki still invade if essos was under volantine rule?
Also not very GoT/ASOIAF related but what if Aegon V hateched dragons at Summerhall instead of murdering most of his family?
Waiting for the next season is hardddd
I would like to mention that long swords which is the swords that Jamie has mostly used until this point in Canon can be wielded with one hand but they really shine when you have two hands in fact all swords big and long are very useful when you use two hands behind their strikes so even just losing his left hand instead of his right I think would affect his swordsmanship and he would acknowledge that which means I think he would still go on a tangent about when he killed Ares Targaryen plus it is said that he had a fever that caused it as well so I think all those things combined I think that part would not have changed
what if vale joined robb on battle of five kings?
What if the Black Fish went North to take back Winter Fell, Because I feel like in the show House Tully true importance was to its family and I feel it was out of character for him to not help his niece and nephew, knowing he could have allies in the wars to come
Brienne was at Harrenhal, not the Dreadfort
In the end, it's so much better for everyone that Jaime lost his right hand. Thanks for the video!
Also, just had some ideas:
What if Arya killed Sansa, took her face, and became the Lady of Winterfell (In Season 7, episode 6, Beyond the Wall)?
What if Tyrion was killed at the Battle of the Blackwater?
What if Bronn shot Daenerys dead at the Battle of the Goldroad? (and maybe Drogon dies too?)
Anyway, just some interesting ones, I thought.
Thanks for all these videos. I find them fascinating.
What if Jon had made it back to Robb when he left the nights watch in the first season to help him in the war?
What if the nights king was able to tell jon why he moving south?
What if the valyrean freehold didn't collapse, would they still invade westeros?
The night king VS the freehold 😁
He would need A LOT OF ICE SPEARS
What if Loras Tyrel was sent by Ned alongside with Beric to hunt The Mountain .
Here are some fun what if's for you:
What if the full kingsgaurd was at the trident and/or tower of joy?
What if jamie claimed the throne for tywin? (he was asked this by someone after he killed the mad king)
THANK YOU JESUS! AND YOU BATTLE PRODUCTION.
What if the Tullys killed the Mountain at the Mill?
What if Lyanna survived birthing Jon but still convinced Ned to keep him and married Robert? Perhaps they only have a daughter or two (similar situation to Elia Martell) but Robert picks her as his heir over Stannis and his children (either with Cersei, Selyse or whoever), causing a Dance of the Stags scenario?
Even if Lyanna lived, I doubt very much that she would have married Robert. She may have forgiven him for killing Rhaegar eventually, but she would never forgive him for what happened to Elia and her children, plus him wanting Viserys and Daenerys dead. Also, with how violent Jon's birth possibly was, Lyanna may not have been able to have more kids.
What if Robert and Ned grew up in King‘s Landing with Rhaegar? (Maybe with Jon Arryn being called to sit on the small council)
What if bran would remember in season one that he saw cersei and jaime bone on the tower and would tell the ppl ?
The bath scene is not in the dreadfort but Harrenhal.
I called Harrnehall the Dreadfort by accident. Forgot my geography of where they were.
What if the dragon pit was never destroyed by the shepherd during the dance of the dragons?
You forgot the possibility to yield in a trial by combat and in this case Jamie would just yield and tyrion lives. Tywin would have seen this coming and never named Jamie the champion.
wt if crown choose mountain and jaime become tyrion's champion
wt would happen at that situation
Also Stannis wouldn't die, as Brienne isn't there to kill him.
I thought about this -- he would've died anyway most likely. The camera specifically showed him bleeding-out, so by that point he was doomed anyway IMHO.
People are forgetting Stannis’ death changes, after killing those 2 soldiers in the woods he might’ve escaped, or just sat and died
Honestly, if Jaime cared enough to get her to not be raped, I still think he would care enough to save her from the bear pit. He wouldn't be as close with her as he was without the bath scene, but I don't think a Jaime that would save Brianne from being raped would just leave her to die. Cuz why bother at that point? He was already changing a bit from the selfish ass he was before, losing his right hand just accelerated it.
That and the idea that Jaime wouldn't immediately declare for Tyrian for the trial by combat is really the only thing I disagree with (even when selfish, Tyrian was always the one thing he would never turn his back on. He loved Tyrian, I honestly doubt he wouldn't immediately declare as Tyrian's champion the second he was asked. And even if this happened and he had to fight Oberyn, he would be so conflicted. Winning would mean sentencing Tyrian to death. This hesitation would almost certainly cost him the fight).
And honestly, them thrusting this on him like they did would create such a rift between them. I personally think Jaime would come to despise Tywin, and would come to see Circe for the evil bitch that she is a lot sooner. And honestly, as evil as Circe is, I'm not fully convinced she would be 100% on board with the idea.
What if Aerys successfully blew up King's Landing?
What if Arya killed Joffrey at the Trident? I know you made a video about Joffrey killing Arya. But if you remember from season 1 Arya held a sword in front of Joffrey. So what if she killed Joffrey with that sword in front of Sansa?
What if Hotpie gave up on the gravy?
What if little finger recognized (told Tywin about) Arya in harrenhall
What if Stannis doesn’t go beyond the wall and help the nights watch in season 4-5
He would have been a fighter after he learned to parry with it