That "son" is a kidnapping victim. If you let the poor boy speak, he says "He's not my father! He's some maniac that chained me down here" or something to that effect.
He may have committed some murders, robbery, kidnapping, torture, and child abuse… but he greeted several people on the streets and released fish, that makes him honorable.
Yes. One word: freedom. We are losing it across the board, with others deciding what we should and shouldn't be allowed to do-even in games. In GTA 5, I run over everyone, drive cars off the highest points I can find, and revel in the chaos. But I can honestly say I would only ever do these things in a game, never in real life. Even if I had played this game at age 5, it wouldn't have made me act this way in reality. So why do people believe that censoring everything will somehow improve society? It won’t!
That poor lady who was just trying to raise money for a shelter... Honestly i'm glad these videos exist because I don't have the heart to play low honor
Yeah, Red Dead 2's voice acting and overall immersion is too good for me to be able to just murder and pillage without remorse. It makes you feel like such a scumbag.
@@BasePuma4007 embrace the evil lol. Do the things to the NPCs that you can't do to people in real life. Especially to the people that you'd like to! The person who cut you off in traffic. The ex that wronged you. The star of the rival team. In RDR2, the NPCs are punching bags lol
Ooh if you’re confused he kidnapped that kid as a way to cope with losing his son to what I think was either a hunting accident or a faulty gun, if you free the kid and leave the Gunsmith alive I think he actually starts selling the very gun his boy was using when he died under the name “Evans Repeater” it’s genuinely INCREDIBLY sad but at the very least you can kinda see him be able to move on healthily when he starts selling the gun :>
The npc dialogue in this game is beyond amazing, the son who saw his father get shot, even how the fake blind man said “this is not a reasonable response” 👌🏾
@TheLoneLander Yea right, with all the gun restrictions, and having to follow Dutch around while he pulls you by a string. If you go too far from Dutch, mission fail, shoot a weapon, mission fail, lasso your own damn horse, mission fail. And I thought that shit was bad until I had to play as John Marston.. missions like birth a horse, go fishing (AGAIN), take the kid into town, milk a cow.. build a fence. Seriously, what in the AF.. It's like the game turned into Farm Simulator at that point.. Marston's wife made Dutch look like a damn lunatic in contrast.. She had that string attached to John's balls, which she kept in her purse.. Most disappointing, anticlimactic mission endings ever. Sadly in one of the best games ever..
The guy had a son that he loved dearly, he took him to shoot a gun and the kick on it was too powerful, so he went flying into the river and wasn’t heard from again. So this guy kidnapped someone that reminded him of his son and put him in his basement, pretending like he’s his son.
Killing Charlotte after gaining her trust by tying her up and burning her house down with her in it felt very illegal. But I was on a bender after a poker game gone wrong, and I had already killed so many horses to go from highest to lowest honor that I thought "what the hell". Not sure which felt worse : the horses or her. Truly an incredible game.
I like that committing horrible crimes, even when they are possible in other games, actually makes you feel bad in this game, due to its immense realism.
As hard as i find it to be this cruel in the game, i still wish they had made some of the deaths more realistic. The shooting deaths are pretty legit, but the way animals kill you, especially gators, is lame, like how the gator chomps down and then leaves a full corpse lying there.
@@AdrielHill-t3r the boy he killed its been kidnapped by the “father” the “not again” show that the “father” was kidnapped more than one kid, im not speak english so hope you understand!
@@AlaskaV3 actually his son died and he didnt know how to cope so he kidnapped that guy and made him pretend to be his son so he could deal with the pain of losing him. and if arthur or john kills him he basically lost the replacement for his dead son, refreshing the pain of losing his son all again, though it wasn’t his son this time
The man had a little boy and took him fishing. However the current was too strong it dragged the kid with it. The man searched up and down the riverbed looking for him and in his grief he kidnapped the man that’s seen in his basement. He says that he looks just like him and he wanted to fill the hole in his heart.
Honorable mention: In this game, I remember seeing a woman on the side of the road with one of her legs broken, struggling under a dead horse. She cried out in pain for help and asked me to help her. Arthur lifted the horse off her, and then I blew her other leg off 🤣
I think what happened was the guy had a son and the son died so then he kidnapped a child going crazy because his son had died and tried to believe it was his in denial but deep down knew it wasn't his and that he was a monster
I always play this game as a good guy i just cant help it. To be so cruel and this game depicts it so realistically i wish violence in GTA had the same sense of gravity as it does in RDR2. This game is truly a masterpiece.
Hahaha I actually thought that title said: '8 Honorable things...' and got me shocked thinking how can killing a son in front of a father be honorable. Then I read it again 😄
If you’re just looking for some fun to be had in this game by being a murderous maniac but you don’t want your honor to go lower then it’s probably a good idea to either turn off autosave or activate cheats so that way you can do all of that stuff without effecting your save file.
If you kill his son before going to gunsmith? What's going on? I don't remember exactly, but in Saint Denis there was a guy who asked a question, and he had some books, and he was talking about atheism or religion, and you could talk to him, and I think I chose the wrong answer, and he called me a fool, and I got offended. I left because I was on high honour, but after walking a couple of metres away, I came back and beat him to death. For calling me a fool. And the end video, Arthur didn't said: ok, I'll catch you later then, maybe it's last time when he doing such a horrible things? :)
If only Arthur were actually around during the suffragette movement. Imagine how far we could have come without being bogged down by bleeding heart emotional wrecks?
That "son" is a kidnapping victim. If you let the poor boy speak, he says "He's not my father! He's some maniac that chained me down here" or something to that effect.
Yeah his son drowned so he kidnapped another one lol
"Children are to be seen, not heard." -- WC Fields
@@jaymac7203the only real solution
No, you're mistaken pardner. That's his boy. He was just catching a few ZZZs. Twas an awful shame to wake the boy.
yea thats why he said not again he need to kidnap another one lol
*kidnapped kid sees arthur*
kid: “oh thank god”
arthur: *don’t thank em yet*
"Give him my regards."
“Thank him yourself”
hello Arthur dies in chapter 6 and it is completely unpreventable there's no way you can't know that now😂
@@JoeyGambella Ik
@@JoeyGambella Everyone knows that before playing the game, if they know rockstar . So your trolly spoiler doesnt really have any value.
"you're a good man arthur morgan"
He may have committed some murders, robbery, kidnapping, torture, and child abuse… but he greeted several people on the streets and released fish, that makes him honorable.
@@rafaelalodio5116o cara é bom mesmo
@@rafaelalodio5116 thats it? wow ive done much more 😈😈
666 likes 💀💀💀
@@rafaelalodio5116 😭💀
Arthur shoots a grandma. 7:31
"You ain't so tough now"
Smokes a cigarette.
Leaves.
🗿
Sigma
Kids
That was so savage and cold 😂
Yeah we saw the video too
As horrible as these acts are to commit they also display how truly incredible and impressive this game is.
Yes. One word: freedom. We are losing it across the board, with others deciding what we should and shouldn't be allowed to do-even in games. In GTA 5, I run over everyone, drive cars off the highest points I can find, and revel in the chaos. But I can honestly say I would only ever do these things in a game, never in real life. Even if I had played this game at age 5, it wouldn't have made me act this way in reality. So why do people believe that censoring everything will somehow improve society? It won’t!
Não é não, só é bem bosta
No they don't
@@DucksonQuack1yes they do
@@Highhonestreviews rockstar pays people to make these comments in every video about the game and you fools eat it up lol
"aint so tough now are ya?" after killing the old lady sent me 😭😭💀💀
and then smokes on her dead body
And lighting up a smoke afterwards! 🤣🤣🤣
She is bad person, if u steal on her House and come back 1 or 2 days later, sons are there and they try to kill u, she too
😇😂
@@jonathansancheztoledano5424 so if you steal from her she will fight back and that makes her bad?
Bro kills the only kill able kid in the game
I'd bet you ain't finished the video yet , cause he kills the street punks at 4:00 💀😂
@@legend4ry443 its a mod
@@King_1918 Oh, ok. So, unfortunately, they're not killable?
2 of them right ??
@@legend4ry443 yes :/
7:08 *Dragging a lady through the streets*
Some random guy: “Stop picking on folk!”
Looool
Looool
“Kid bullying”…proceeds to kill a kid with his pistol
Lol
Bullying the American way 🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🏳️🌈🏳️🌈🏳️🌈⛹️⛹️⛹️🍳🍳🍳
🥰🥰🥰
dont worry he will take the shot just like micah
well, that's still bullying, just American-style bullying 😂
Totally normal kid bullying in 1899 4:11
That poor lady who was just trying to raise money for a shelter... Honestly i'm glad these videos exist because I don't have the heart to play low honor
Well, isn't that what you need to play low honor tho? To have no heart?
Yeah, Red Dead 2's voice acting and overall immersion is too good for me to be able to just murder and pillage without remorse. It makes you feel like such a scumbag.
@@BasePuma4007 No it doesn't.
@@TeddyKGB12 yes it does lol
@@BasePuma4007 embrace the evil lol. Do the things to the NPCs that you can't do to people in real life. Especially to the people that you'd like to! The person who cut you off in traffic. The ex that wronged you. The star of the rival team. In RDR2, the NPCs are punching bags lol
"Not again..." ha, i never realised he had lost a son and so was trying to replace him and not deal with the grief. Pretty cool.
He could just be a predator and he's killed before.
@@reka10 nah, the original commenter is right. The game tells you that
The “not again” was heartbreaking! Geez! 😢
it was funny lmao @@yadacoleman65
@@yadacoleman65 no it wasn’t he kidnapped that kid
The fake blind man 😂
🤣🤣
Real blind man reacts differently
I knew that he's pretending to be blind, next time i play he will see my bullets comming😂
Be sure you get the faker and not the actual blind ma... actually nevermind, that would be funny@@SanctusDraco
@Neo2266. lol, so there is a legit blind man too somewhere. It's good to know🥴😆
Hosea still having his wedding ring on him makes it sadder
@@svnthr090 that was not his that was actually Abigails ring
It was probably from some people he robbed lol.
"Not again! " WHAT.
Ooh if you’re confused he kidnapped that kid as a way to cope with losing his son to what I think was either a hunting accident or a faulty gun, if you free the kid and leave the Gunsmith alive I think he actually starts selling the very gun his boy was using when he died under the name “Evans Repeater” it’s genuinely INCREDIBLY sad but at the very least you can kinda see him be able to move on healthily when he starts selling the gun :>
@@wetsocks4460
@@wetsocks4460 i saw that gun at the St Denis one too
@@wetsocks4460hidden info is nuts
The person who says that had a son who died from shotgun recoil so he kidnapped that kid
>father was unarmed and cowering
"IT WAS HIM OR ME"
He was armed and about to shoot Arthur, watch again. (Not that it justifies Arthur, but the dialogue makes sense.)
Literally dropped a gun.
He pulled a gun and dropped it when he got shot. Pay attention ffs. You sound like the media. Lol
“Vote for the alligator” had me dying in laughter
202
The npc dialogue in this game is beyond amazing, the son who saw his father get shot, even how the fake blind man said “this is not a reasonable response” 👌🏾
@@naturemiya9560 152, *fair
its crazy how this game makes doing legitametly wrong or straight up evil things so real
Unless you're playing the campaign, then you can't do almost anything evil, cuz the campaign was designed by a catholic grandma or something..
@@sizlaxyou can do evil stuff all the time idk what you mean
@TheLoneLander Yea right, with all the gun restrictions, and having to follow Dutch around while he pulls you by a string. If you go too far from Dutch, mission fail, shoot a weapon, mission fail, lasso your own damn horse, mission fail.
And I thought that shit was bad until I had to play as John Marston.. missions like birth a horse, go fishing (AGAIN), take the kid into town, milk a cow.. build a fence.
Seriously, what in the AF.. It's like the game turned into Farm Simulator at that point.. Marston's wife made Dutch look like a damn lunatic in contrast.. She had that string attached to John's balls, which she kept in her purse..
Most disappointing, anticlimactic mission endings ever. Sadly in one of the best games ever..
@@sizlax Dude get a life or even better give your life to christ
@@sizlax you are in the smallest minority ever if you think it was a bad ending
0:52 what do you mean by not again that one got me
@@ahmettahasimsek6900 i think this guy has a kid and he died so he kidnapped this kid for him to remember his old kid ... yeah just that what I know
The guy had a son that he loved dearly, he took him to shoot a gun and the kick on it was too powerful, so he went flying into the river and wasn’t heard from again. So this guy kidnapped someone that reminded him of his son and put him in his basement, pretending like he’s his son.
@@DebAnn-sc9qgi understandit now
Killing Charlotte after gaining her trust by tying her up and burning her house down with her in it felt very illegal. But I was on a bender after a poker game gone wrong, and I had already killed so many horses to go from highest to lowest honor that I thought "what the hell". Not sure which felt worse : the horses or her. Truly an incredible game.
Horses was the worse one. Their lives are more important than people.
@@wildlifeisthewealthofnatur5457 bruh
@@wildlifeisthewealthofnatur5457 all animals are worth more than humans.
@@wildlifeisthewealthofnatur5457 animal rights cope
@@wildlifeisthewealthofnatur5457 lmaoo
Since arthur didnt get any explanation imagine the worry and confusion when the gunsmith said “not again”
7:52 what the badass
7:51
7:50
I like that committing horrible crimes, even when they are possible in other games, actually makes you feel bad in this game, due to its immense realism.
@@sprites4ever482 yeah if i somehow played this game
I will never do anything bad on it
I feel bad fr
3:32 youre a good man mr morgan
@@kingshekk6882 💀
As hard as i find it to be this cruel in the game, i still wish they had made some of the deaths more realistic. The shooting deaths are pretty legit, but the way animals kill you, especially gators, is lame, like how the gator chomps down and then leaves a full corpse lying there.
Pretty sure there might be mods to make animal gore deaths. Just guessing
No.
@@funtimefox4248found the softie lmfao cry and cope.
@@pullovr ?
@@Unknowndude-dg8tr could you recommend any? I'd love one where the bear or gator eats the body
One of the best things about this game is that when you do horrible things you immediately feel like a horrible person.
@@js70371 i feel horrible watching this video
5:00 ok, you really are a monster bro 💀
@@MorusAllba frl 😭
cry about it, they are just npc
The guy is allegedly the shop owner’s son but yet the owner says “I ain’t got nothin of value down there.” 😂
Play the game.
Tf you talking about lol
@@AliAlnamir He isn't the shop owner's son. Play the game and it will make sense.
@einzelganger6664
How about you read. Perhaps a dictionary, specifically the definition of the word “allegedly”
@@einzelganger6664 Yea, the owner is alleging that the guy is his son…
1:28 fake blind guy.
DAAAAAAAAMN i love play low honor arthur but this was at another level bro 💀
0:52 this is that I call a good writing. That single "not again" explains literally everything.
You body slamming the woman’s rights advocate had me rolling 💀
she vote for rights, he vote for lefts.
At least YOU were rolling. The unrealistic alligator did NOT. 😒
Idk, bro. It’s a shame to see such a perfectly good dish washer get broken like that.
@@a.w.sawtooth9469 that's wild 💀💀
Based
The fact when you drag a person by a rope the dress stays down kills the realism...
They could just give them long leg pants under it.
True
oh no I'm a horny little kid and can't see under a women's dress in a game so I rate it a 0/10...tissue?🧻
But then it'd be ahistorical
"Not Again" 0:57
@@avaneeshprabhu9445 so he killed his son again??
@@AdrielHill-t3r the boy he killed its been kidnapped by the “father” the “not again” show that the “father” was kidnapped more than one kid, im not speak english so hope you understand!
@@triandhispicolan I was able to understand what you said since I was confused about that part myself. Your english is not bad!
💀
@@AlaskaV3 actually his son died and he didnt know how to cope so he kidnapped that guy and made him pretend to be his son so he could deal with the pain of losing him. and if arthur or john kills him he basically lost the replacement for his dead son, refreshing the pain of losing his son all again, though it wasn’t his son this time
7:55 Bro smoking grandma :sob:
It’s honorable to take something from Hosea as you take something to remember him by (edit: mother I’m famous
Unless you sell it.
@@dora_thedestroyer facts
yeah well it's also a wedding ring
dude had a dead wife
Shut your mof
you are not famous. its just a comment with some likes from the people who didn't even notice your name.
0:53 "Not again"?!!!! WHAT?!
I think he meant that he already had another son who died in a similar way
The man had a little boy and took him fishing. However the current was too strong it dragged the kid with it. The man searched up and down the riverbed looking for him and in his grief he kidnapped the man that’s seen in his basement. He says that he looks just like him and he wanted to fill the hole in his heart.
Honorable mention: In this game, I remember seeing a woman on the side of the road with one of her legs broken, struggling under a dead horse. She cried out in pain for help and asked me to help her. Arthur lifted the horse off her, and then I blew her other leg off 🤣
😭😭😭😭
Bro 😂😂😂
@@NJFPV the game didn't end well for Arthur Morgan, let's just say that 😂
😭😭💀💀
@@mikeleigh6304
Arthur is dying anyway doesnt matter how . He dies same Time same place .
6:15 your Uber eats is here enjoy
3:22 'what am I gonna do now? He's all I had left' is hurt me :(
Same, that hit hard.
ur too soft
@@yap5995blud you’re soft
i felt nothing your too soft
nopes someone killed that dude's dad u gotta feel it @@yap5995
3:09 you miss the part where you can take everything from the house, including a card his mom gave him.
Locoation ?
Votin' for gator is just anothe way of democracy in action...
The “What the heck” from the lady at 6:02 has me crying. 🤣
7:07 yeah man that’s really gonna stop him from dragging her down the street
Geez man, that first one with the man screaming "not again!" and sobbing just hit me deep through...
4:00 I like that
Ok
@@wObBlE73 um OK
not ok :D
To be fair, the kids robbed us In chapter 4
yeah fr, those punches were good
"Ain't so tuff now, are you?" Ajhhahajhahhahabhahaha
Looting Hosea was diabolical
3:41, Arthur are punching this bully kid!😂🤣
Kid bully’s is so ugry
" You're a good man Arthur Morgan "
Im not gonna lie that random looting of poor hoseas corpse made me spit out my drink 😂
0:54 again?!?!
I think what happened was the guy had a son and the son died so then he kidnapped a child going crazy because his son had died and tried to believe it was his in denial but deep down knew it wasn't his and that he was a monster
@@darraghmontySame theory
I always play this game as a good guy i just cant help it. To be so cruel and this game depicts it so realistically i wish violence in GTA had the same sense of gravity as it does in RDR2. This game is truly a masterpiece.
I can't resist the sight of a random wagon carried by 1 or 2 horses running while carrying a man without his head
1:21 this should be good, he knew he was trying to steal because he *saw* it
7:57 Smoking on that grandma's pack is crazy 💀💀
That first one is tragic
“Ain’t so tough now, are ya?” After murdering an old lady and then lighting a cigarette 😂😂😂
That laugh after robbing the blind man was pure evil💀😆
1:59 man did NOT let that slide
When Arthur found the letters on the dead body of the kid, the Arthur:That’s touching 😢, I should find more of this.
Can't wait to see Arthur start his new career as a TikTok influencer. These pranks are fire.
Blind man's reflexes though
the grandma scream followed by "ain't so tough now, are ya'?" kills me LMAO
Arthur Morgan .. an honorable man, who crossed over bravely, fighting for what he believed in .. Day in and day out .. He even cured the blind 💪🏻
The “To interrupt grandma’s speech” one killed me 😂
5:45 there's something really fucking funny to me imagining Arthur shout "AH SHIT, A WOMAN!"
never thought i’d find such deep side characters in a game where you *can* just shoot anyone at any point
Bros honor is lower than my grades
3:00 the daddy died looking and posing like Yamcha🤣🤣🤣
You are a good man "ARTHUR MORGAN"
Also him : 💀
3:25 let's be realistic Arthur Morgan low honor would've said something really racist lol
Arthur isn't racist
In a mission, he questions a black man about why he moves from his seat for him and then helps him get his wagon back
7:00 damn it was so evil I laughed a bit 🤣
Thank god i wasn't the only one 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Looting Hosea is hilarious to me. 😂 Arthur’s just fiendin for some coin.
If you bind an NPC but have them lay on the streets, will another NPC untie them?
Uma hora ele vai se desamarrar sozinho
@@Miguel.Fernandes7 what
Sorry, i said that the npc will eventually untie himself
That "Ain't so tough now, are you?" was fire
Hahaha I actually thought that title said: '8 Honorable things...' and got me shocked thinking how can killing a son in front of a father be honorable. Then I read it again 😄
Arthur *kills the kids father* kid: NO PA *presses defuse button* “com’n partner i was only joking”
If you’re just looking for some fun to be had in this game by being a murderous maniac but you don’t want your honor to go lower then it’s probably a good idea to either turn off autosave or activate cheats so that way you can do all of that stuff without effecting your save file.
Dang “vote for the alligator” got me on the floor 😭
lighting a cig right after you smoked granny was cold as hell 😭😭💀
3:01 I did this by accident during the game 😭😭😭
The only annoying thing with all this is losing honor, if you'd only get the cops like in GTA it would be so fun
If you kill his son before going to gunsmith? What's going on?
I don't remember exactly, but in Saint Denis there was a guy who asked a question, and he had some books, and he was talking about atheism or religion, and you could talk to him, and I think I chose the wrong answer, and he called me a fool, and I got offended. I left because I was on high honour, but after walking a couple of metres away, I came back and beat him to death. For calling me a fool.
And the end video, Arthur didn't said: ok, I'll catch you later then, maybe it's last time when he doing such a horrible things? :)
And that's why I have a section called "if you go off script" where I show you all these things.
Yeah😂
Bro's casually making villains
If only Arthur were actually around during the suffragette movement. Imagine how far we could have come without being bogged down by bleeding heart emotional wrecks?
"You're a good man, Aurthor Morgan"
My heart cried from these cruel acts. Even if it is a video game.
“What the heck”😂 6:01
1:44 that isnt a blind man
bro the old man aint even blind hes faking it if you point a gun at him he takes the blindfold off and runs away
3:43 what horse is it good video bro
The fact that the most replayed part is when the kidnapped "son" gets sent to jesus
💀
5:15 OMG, I never thought of doing that... 😲
The way that his honor went down when he took Hoseas stuff
7:37 Haha 😂
"Hey zeek, it looks like this spider's caught a couple of flies!". I love that film.
7:48 politely interrupts
5:38 - "mAkE tHiS cOuNtRy A rEaL dEmOcRaCy!"
Can someone tell this lady that we are a CONSTITUTIONAL REPUBLIC?
5.49.she: we woman not monster
arthur : but iam monster 💀