Assembling France by Political Orientation
Вставка
- Опубліковано 28 тра 2020
- This video shows every French town, ranked from the most left-wing, to the most right wing.
50% of the towns are in red color, and 50% are in the blue.
Data: French presidential elections, 2017, first round
www.data.gouv.fr/fr/datasets/...
Methodology:
1. I classified every candidate in 3 categories:
- Left: Poutou, Arthaud, Cheminade, Mélenchon, Hamon (weight: -1)
- Centre: Macron (weight : 0)
- Right: Lasalle, Fillon, Asselineau, Dupont-Aignan, Le Pen (weight: -1)
2. I calculated a weighted average of the political score in every town
3. I ranked every town from most left wing to most right wing
4. The first half of the town is in red (the most left wing towns), and the second half in in blue (the most right wing towns)
Music by Rousseau. Check-out his amazing channel!
/ @rousseau
Left Wing: left
Right Wing: right
*Perfection*
Perfectly balanced. As it should be 😏😏😏
@@jameslegrand848 I hope they remember you
Yes
its more like north/south tbh.
For Germany, it's just East vs West lol
Not before 1945
Évariste Galois They splitted in 2 in 1949. Not 1945
People's Republic of Luxembourg And Coronavirus officially but they were occupied by the western power ( USA ,UK,France) and the soviet, but yes the wall appeared in 1961
@@evaristegalois8600 Germany had a huge left before 1945, so you could divide Germany between left and right wingers before 1945. For example the Rhineland ore Hamburg were huge Communist Hotspots.
@@evaristegalois8600 Évariste galois c'est pas un mathematicien?
funny how all teh left wing areas are on the left of the map and the right wing areas are on the right of the maps
Fun fact, reunion Island, is the eastern part of France (only regions).
@@tommarch.4493 yes but is far away
like the same in germany
It looks more of a South-West (left-wing) North-East(Right Wing) divide to me.
Oui! We left handed people will rise again!
When I was a boy, in my little village in the north, 75% of people were Jean-Marie Le Pen supporters. Ha ha
I wanna live there
Ew
Sounds terrible
Ouch
@@felixvanmears gay
Occitania, Brittany & Paris vs the rest of France.
Paris vs France *
@@pochev7124 Brittany and Occitania are not the richest region at all...
@@jenedonnepasmonblaseanimpo2781 occitania is one of the richest, largest, and with a lot of culture and population
Paris and alot more if you bother to use your eyes
CHOCOLATINE
So basically the Angevin Empire is mostly left wing while Burgundy and Lorraine is mostly right wing.
@@matusmotlo3854 ah yes Auvergne Paris center are non french
@@matusmotlo3854 ha yes occitany isn't french mat sens
@@matusmotlo3854 it's more just régional culture like patoi than Real Big différence
Burgundy is a political mess
Dude! The "Rise of Empires: Ice and Fire" devs have been stealing your "Rulers of Europe" video to advertise their game on UA-cam!
(Long Tech net. Lt.)
Is this true?
Sorry for being outdated
@@The_Soviet_Onion Was playing Dead Ahead a few days ago and while watching an advert, to get some free stuff, instead of one of the "puzzle" mobile adverts we're being plagued with at the moment, I got an advert for Rise of Empires, with yet another plagiarised piece of background footage. Just like Banished, Minecraft, Anno, Age of Empires etc, this time it was from this guys channel, and I A) recognised his work, and B) know mobile advertising (bar Raid) is far to low budget to be making that themselves.... so long story short, Yes... it seriously is that disgusting at this stage...
Grasshopper K Ok thanks
@@GrasshopperKelly where could i find the ad
This is great content, man
Yo dude a game is stealing your videos and making them as adds
Comment ça doit être décevant de faire des cartes animée et voir des commentaires si pétés.
Bon courage pour la suite
Edit: stop avec vos commentaires de Jean-Michel histoire
Beaucoup trop de fachos sont abonnés à cette chaîne malheureusement
@@jaguarboy31 oui chiale.
Je pense qu'il est lui-même "facho"
Décevant de quoi ? Juste parce que c'est des gens de droite dans les commentaires ?
BAGUETTE DU FROMAGE HAHA NON
@@jaguarboy31 agneugneu facho , va revoir la définition bouffon
Very good video mate !
May you do the same for the other European countries please🙏🙏🙏
@Mr. Baguette sorry I'm italian 😂😂🙏
@@user-ko5wt8et8n It's all good bro. You're english is great. Keep it up!
@Mr. Baguette The term*
r/IAmVerySmart
Damn... for the first time I could say my little city of 400 inhabitants has appeared on a Cottereau Video
So basically the richest and the poorest areas are left wing and stuff in between is right wing. Consistent with the rest of the world! Really puts a perspective onto things...
@@svenbarsklov Look at central France. As in Limousine and Auvergne. That's the poorest part.
@@stojankovacic1524 En terme de PIB de la région oui mais en terme de revenu moyen/coût de la vie ça se discute, les pauvres votent à droite dans les campagnes et à gauche dans les villes, si on devait simplifier (genre le Limousin et l'Auvergne c'est vide, jsp si on peut en faire une tendance)
@@antoinedc1748 I don't speak French but I used Google Translate. Still couldn't find the meaning to jsp. Guess it's an abbrevation.
Fair point! I think that has to do with city populations usually being more progressive and village populations being more conservative. I'm not an expert in anything about France, I just know general trends in the world so I won't speculate.
@@stojankovacic1524 I was assuming your French sorry, yes jsp is "je ne sais pas" = idk/i dont know.
But your right, the countryside is more conservative than the towns in general, but there is a big "swap", its quit difficult to explain, basically all the workers that were previously supporting the PCF (communist party, left wing) are now supporting the FN (National Front right wing) despite living in the city. The death of the PCF is in istelf a French clusterfuck so yes, the situation is complicated, much more than a countryside VS Paris Lyon Brest
@@antoinedc1748 Yeah I actually understand the swap! I'm used to complicated political situations since I live in Bosnia (you can imagine the politics here!). And yeah it's never good to simplify things but I've found that it's basically impossible to explain some political things to people from countries with stable political situations so I usually do it when talking to them anyway :P
More like these please
Cool animations these are 👍
Great work my friend. Btw it could be amazing if the next time you could base your analysis not on 2017 elections, but 2018 europen elections, to see the big evolution of the right wing (especially in the DOM TOM, and rural areas). Par ailleurs j'ai adoré ta vidéo sur le nombre de batailles remportées, elle a fait fermer beaucoup de bouches haha
PS : this video is based only on the biggest cities, a vast majority of small villages vote for right-wing I suppose ?
French Liberals: Brittany, Paris, and the South
French Conservatives: Marsaille and the North
En Marche in 2017: Everything is yellow
Liberals and Conservatives are both right-wing.
"En Marche" is liberal, and liberalism in France is on the right since the Third Republic.
Well the south east is actually conservative ànd even far right.
Brittany is full socialist and the North East full conservative.
u mean French Communists and French Conservatives :)
The American "liberal vs conservative" perspective does not work for the European political landscape. Here it's more like communists vs socialdemocrats vs liberals vs conservatives vs nazis.
your data is beautiful!
Very fine choice of music
Hello, it is an interesting way of seeing the French political division. However I am not sure that the presidential election are the best data to use are they is only the biggest parties and some people vote to eliminate somebody. I think it would be more representative to use a local election such as the parliament or the town council. If you want to have a national election then there is the still the European's however with the high low of people not going to vote I don't know if they are worth anything.
Seule l'élection présidentielle se prête à cela
Les élections municipales voient beaucoup de candidats sans étiquette politique etre élus
Les élection européenes voient s' affronter des dixaines de listes, avec des partis inclassables ( le parti pirate )
Enfin les électionns législatives ont lieu deux mois après celles du président et sont souvent sans grand intêret à étudier car le président y a toujours une majorité
@@ulysse113 c'était vraiment une idée de merde de les aligner les unes a la suite des autres d'ailleurs, merçi sarkozy. Fut un temps ou le parlement servait encore a quelque chose, a contrebalançer le pouvoir du président, de nos jours c'est vraiment devenut une court d'enregistrement des volontés présidentielles.
If Petain saw this map he'd prefer to die again
good.
Be careful ! It is presenting THE MOST left-wing cities and THE MOST right wing cities. It does not depict the political balance of the country. A recent poll asked the French to rate themselves from 0 to 10 on the political scale - 0 being far-left supporters, 10 being far right supporters. The average result was 6,7. Actually, France has never been leaning right so much since WWII.
@@christopheripoll2580 Source?
@@christopheripoll2580
The Real winner in this "pool" is "don't know" though
And left wing candidates are being voted by centrists
Mélenchon's voters where 4,3
Vs Macron voters where 6,7
@@williamsantos9471 ifop
Can u do Top 100 greatest Presidents in history?
wow very nice data
Could you do this for all the countries of Europe?
Interesting is that between this video and the "assembling France by average income" video, there seems to be a direct correlation between wealth and conservatism -- although it is loose to the effect of not being nearly a causation.
Well i can see two obvious reasons
: First, if you don't have money, you are more sensitive to people who will say you deserve more
Then, the older you get, the richer you get and the more conservative you get
But that is not completely right, the extreme majority of the rassemblement national party ( alt right conservatists ) are working class people because it is a far right populist party.
Because right wing ideology is always in favor of some privileged group or class.
ua-cam.com/video/9nPVkpWMH9k/v-deo.html
This no longer rly the case I think it’s hard to argue people in paris hsve lower income even though they vote left I think this argument may have been true 15 years ago now working class r moving to the fsr right
What are you on about? The wealthier areas are more leftist.
@@Jim63071 As I said in my original comment, it's a correlation, not a causation. Learn to read.
Seriously, just look at the areas bordering Switzerland and Germany in both videos, and then look at south/southwest France.
First time i see your videos and i absolutely love this format!!!
Edit: your coments are filled with polandballs which is allways a good omen
Bonjour Cottereau, possible de pouvoir s'écrire quelque part en privé ?
C'est marrant on arrive à voir la route Nancy -Luxembourg rien quant regardant cette carte
C'est amusant en effet.
On est sur les cités post-industrielles qui votent encore un peu plus à gauche que la campagne. Je pense que la mixité sociale en est un peu responsable.
Good video, but i wanna see content about whole world, about infographics or history. And more longer videos will be better, i know it’s difficult, but more interesting.
(Я только учу английский, простите мне мои ошибки, а лучше укажите на них)
Do you even know that we have 36000 and he probably entered all the data manually??
You should make a video called ''top people with most assassination attemps''
Where is Cottereau? He hasnt posted
Next thing you know, someone will loose a weight on their shoulders
What a way to remove a headache.
@@thatguyshwag Indeed
Didn't age well
Why cant i be a back wing ):
Im not sure why you used Chopins winter wind for this video, but it seems to work for some reason
Brother make a video about greatest admiral in history
Beaucoup trop de rouge.
La France se droitise de plus en plus il me semble.
Je pensais qu’il y aurait plus de bleu aussi mais tant mieux
C'est construit sur une médiane il me semble, de sorte qu'il y ait 50/50
J'suis daccord et en plus j'habite en Occitanie
@@SGJaden ce qui est pourtant paradoxal avec la colère contre le gouvernement actuel.
Mais c'est bien le cas à cause de l'immigration ....
0:58 Vous êtes sûrs que Lasalle est de droite, il me semble qu'il siège à gauche dans l'assemblée nationale
Selon les sondages, les électeurs de Lassalle se placent eux-mêmes entre Dupont-Aignan et Asselineau.
C'est pour ça qu'on le place souvent à droite, même si il refuse cette étiquette et qu'il parle beaucoup de services publics.
@@aymericd.6126 Mais Asselineau il est ni de droite ni de gauche ?
@@1000eau il est centriste mais ses électeurs sont de droites.
Basically urbanized vs rural area
Why is Elsass for example more right but Brittany more left ? Can any french explain?
I'm Alsatian, I don't have an explaination for these 2 regions but I think it's mostly due to culture.
When you does'nt appear on the map because you are litterally a french centrist.
C'est surtout que le centre n'a pas vraiment de sens
@@zakzak247 Mouais, je pourrais dire pareil de la droite et de la gauche, quand je dis que je suis du centre, c'est pas que je veux un compromis sur tous les points, mais c'est que je suis attiré autant par des idées de droites que des idées de gauches selon les domaines, généralement, les gens de droite me traitent de "gauchiasse" et les gens de gauche de "droitard", alors que l'extrême droite et l'extrême gauche ont bien plus de points communs entre eux qu'avec le centre...
@@agentjohn4313 Genre le fameux "les extrêmes se rejoignent" ?
@@zakzak247 bah... Ouais... Je veux dire, aujourd'hui, les deux extrêmes sont isolationistes économiquement (la gauche dit juste qu'elle veut accueillir les migrants), ils sont tous les deux anti capitalistes, anti europe... J'ai presque l'impression que c'est le même programme en mettant plus ou moins en avant certaines choses plutôt que d'autres, d'ailleurs, suffit de voir des exemples historiques pour s'en rendre compte, les nazis par exemple, n'étaient pas nationaux socialistes que de nom, ils ont nationalisé toutes les entreprises en gardant les patrons dans la peur d'une exécution si ils n'obéhisaient pas à l'état et dans un même temps, les communistes persecutaient les juifs accusés de faire partie du "capital"...
@@agentjohn4313 l'affirmation "les extrêmes se rejoignent" est un mythe, les programmes de mélenchon et de lepen sont très différent
Mélenchon n'est pas anti Europe, il place l'écologie au coeur de son programme (contrairement à lepen)
Le FN propose du social pour séduire la classe ouvrière uniquement
At least they are United in hating Macron.
Unfortunately not enough yet. From a Frenchman.
We hate all politicians, but it’s true that the president gets a special treatement !
@@narchang3l160 good
a good mix
What does Your logo mean?
Its the Sacred Earth, a religious symbol, but in France it the blason of the region of Vendée, and it was the symbol of a Monarchist rebellion in Vendée during the Revolution of 1789. So you can say its a Monarchist symbol, but monarchism is virtually dead in France so it could juste be a symbol of his region.
Antoine DC Thanks!!
The poorest towns are also the most left wing
@@islamisthetruth3402 except paris the poorest towns are also the most left wing
@@leonardolamberti8302 Actually, including Paris since its "banlieue" (suburds) which is not that rich votes left-wing.
Look Hauts de France
Absolutly not
No, look at the north of france or the center-east they are the poorest and right wings
I wan to see this for america
And Europe too.
@@xemnas9098 lol
UK is totally Blue and Poland is totally Red
Germany is purple since everyone is confused there
the nordics are blue
spain and italy are red
etc
@Ave Republic! because nobody wants the immigrants except the government
@@muscovymapping8896 I think Poland is extremely blue.
@Vladimir Putoein I think it's the exact opposite of what you just said
Why is Strasbourg red though
Sorry If my english is bad but I live in Strasbourg so i think that i can answer your question : Since 2008 (12 years), the citie is governed by the social partie (PS, a Left politic mouvement).I Hope i will clear and thank you to note this particularity in Alsace.(often in France, cities are governed by Left movements ) Have a good day.
It's a Big city and Strasbourg IS inportznt for Europe (one of the city where european institutions live) so it's a Berry open city and more Richer than thé rest of thé région, so that why this is red
@@narwalsman8471 Wrong. It's the other way around. In Alsace, the poverty rate is higher in the large urban areas, particularly in Strasbourg, than in more rural municipalities or small towns. This phenomenon is particularly marked in Alsace. Moreover, Alsace is the second region in France in terms of standard of living, after the Paris region.
www.insee.fr/fr/statistiques/1285898#consulter
As an American it feels weird that the left is red and the right is blue
Does anyone want to explain why Champagne is so right wing?
Because they are more intelligent and patriotic than the cosmopolitan traitors of Paris
Jeune Homme Il est vrai que Paris loge sur son sol de nombreux étudiants. Cependant je pense qu’ils ne sont pas tous parisiens ou inscrits dans des bureaux de votes parisiens.
Ensuite la corrélation entre le diplôme obtenu et l’intelligence n’est pas si évidente. Le diplôme sanctionne souvent une simple acquisition de connaissances, alors que « l’intelligence » chez les classiques est plutôt une capacité de prendre des bonnes décisions au bon moment.
Bien sûr on peut avoir les deux ou aucun.
My answer would be that these areas are still traditional and conservative, with a lot of big farmers, or wine production. They know what "work" means, with many families coming from North or Eastern countries
I live in Champagne and we have tons of immigrants but they didnt vote, that's why
@@vince7520 HAHAHA your comment proves the opposite
Moi je suis bleu !
Good man!
I'm blue dabedi dabeda dabedi dabeda
Moi aussi
"" Dab ""
Moi aussi mais je suis pas français.
Me too, but the thing is I'm not French.
What DId You Use?
The popularity of each candidate of presidential election of 2017 by city and region, according to a basic left/right classification. Of course it's a simplist map. And it may have moved since, the political chess has evolved. Couldn't absolutely say who would win in 2022.
I forgot France still has a regional voting system subject to gerrymandering.
not for the presidential election. here 1 vote=voice, there is nothing similar to the system of the US where you can get elected by a minority.
@@romualdcaffeserre6230 Thats good. It's the the state representatives elections that are subject to gerrymandering in the US, the presidential elections use the electoral college, which is not outright corrupt, but still terrible.
@@TwinTn It's possible to Gerrymander but it's rarely the case it's always a geographical divide with no real complicated shape in France for example the department where i live is just divided in two with a vertical line with each part of the department making around 120k people.
Cette carte est fausse. Le Pays Basque vote à Droite
* Euskara
Angela Kindness Pyrénées-Atlantiques*
Bad to see France in red
Bad to see ur fascist dictature that is hungary
@Golden Eagle Yes as if Racist is something that should be considered as pejorative no matter what. That's the kind of brainwashing that progressist have been doing ever since the boom of social media. Yet you don't ask yourself, "Why is there racism ? Could there be possibly an explanation ?" Well If you look a bit into countries with a lot of immigrants, you will see that they have a higher criminal rate, or even violence in the suburbs. Of course that the people begin to hate them. They know that there are a lot of good people, but the fact is that many of them are fucking uncivilized. That's the facts. And the left wing turns a blind eye to all that, saying they are always the victims blablabla. Morons ? I think that you have a lot of them in the left wing, turning off their brain too.
@Ave Republic! what do you Call a man that have all the power that builds a wall against migrants wants to reestablish death penalty ans fight for his ethnie territories is romania and neighbours except a fascist dictator?
@@eliottboublil7796 I call that a responsible man.
@@scutumfidelis1436 Thats the problem with eastern Europe and usa too btw u guys like too much authoritarian leaders
CAN YOU MAKE VIETNAM VIDEO TODAY.
timeline King of italy?
0:19 They could have LEFT it at that.
Everyone surrounding Paris, after seeing the situation Paris is in, became right wing.
As a peripheral Frenchman I can tell you, we've lost Paris. I wouldn't tell you who's taken it away from us, but they've taken it away from us.
@@gamergod-vf9hx I've visited and I understand what you mean. I've heard the same thing you say by other Frenchmen.
@@gamergod-vf9hx ditto London
@@gamergod-vf9hx I know who took it from you brother.
take paris and put it somewhere else
Pls do Germany
The Breton and Occitan borders are showing.
I want see Poland :D
I assume it is an sea of blue
@@ninoy4914 The left-right distinction is of very little use in the former Eastern Bloc. One's economic policies have almost no relation to their views on society, Europe, religion, immigration etc., each can swing either way, depending on the trend and whatever part of the spectrum is relatively unoccupied. Some post-communist social democrats, for example those in Poland, have pretty much became indistinguishable from the Europhile liberals (at the expense of losing any chance of being anything above a minor coalition partner), whereas others, such as Smer in Slovakia or the PSD in Romania, very often clash with Brussels and employ homophobic rhetoric. Also, during every election you get an influx of one-time populists who refuse to proclaim where they stand out of principle.
@@ninoy4914 blue? In Poland, almost all party are socialist. PIS is a party which pretends to be conservative but in reality it appears that they are only socialist thieves.
@@ninoy4914 We have a post-communist society.
@@strzelbi111 wut
"Macron: Centre"
Hahahaha
Good one
I mean Macron literally is a centrist, I don't know how you could possibly disagree with that.
@@Debre. It's common extremist thinking: everything that's not as radical as i am is siding with the other's side, and therefore there can be no center. Only me, and the ennemy, no middle ground allowed.
@@Debre. That's how he called himself during the campaign but, in my humble opinion, he's clearly a right wing president
@@jeremiebihin8150 You mean left-wing?
@@National-Democrat.Ukrainian The radical left wing loonie call him a right-wing.
The radical right wing loonie call him a left-wing.
That's life for a centrist.
Paris back to 1871?
Autant de chaque côté du coup ?
Si je me souviens bien si on cumule tout c'est kiff kiff après c'est comme les élections chaque moi ça doit changer
@@narwalsman8471 Disons que dans la politique objective Macron est purement de droite voir d'extrême droite par certains aspect : attaque contre les libertés publiques, anti-parlementarisme, utilisation de la violence d'état au travers de la police pour briser les manifestations. Même Salvini félicite Macron pour son projet de loi sur l'immigration. Si la détermination vous déplaît vous pouvez choisir l'extrême centre comme catégorie.
Disons que tu as toujours la même division au fil des décennies du point de vue de la population tu as 20% de droite dure type RPR ou aujourd'hui RN, 20% de droite libérale et conservatrice type LR ou UDF, 20% de centre gauche type PS ou ce que l'électeurs croyaient être le centre gauche avec LAREM puis 20% de gauche avec FI ou anciennement le PCF.
Après l'élection ne détermine pas tout par exemple 80% des français veulent un retour de l'ISF ou veulent le Référendum d'initiative Citoyenne pour révoquer les élus, proposer les les lois, les abroger et changer la constitutions. Donc les Français aiment d'une façon générale l'état social fort et la démocratie. Il y'a même une majorité qui pense que le capitalisme n'est pas un bon système économique seul pays au monde il faut quand même le noter.
Ils seront plus réticents sur les changements sociétaux ou l'hostilité à tout changement est beaucoup plus massive type PMA, marriage pour tous. Par exemple 65% d'entre eux pensent qu'il y'a un problème avec l'immigration alors bien sûr les termes sont mal définis puisque cela ne détermine pas si ils ont un problème avec les migrants ou alors ils pensent qu'il y'a un problème avec l'accueil ou alors plutôt qu'on a déjà trop de pauvres et que c'est difficile d'accueuilir les gens alors que notre pays est en récession suremenet un peu tout à la fois.
La division est double en terme de richesse mais aussi d'âge, quand le pays va trop à droite il change d'avis et remet un coup de barre à gauche de temps à autres 1981 (ça a pas duré longtemps pour faire le virage à droite dès 1982), 1936, ce genre de chose. J'imagine qu'ils ont cru aussi qu'Hollande était de gauche en 2012.
On pourrait faire l'analyse de façon systèmique dans la cinquième république d'un point de vue sociologique de classe ou marxiste si vous préferez et déterminer de façon assez évidente que tout les partis centre droit centre gauche depuis 1958 sont toujours soutenu par les plus aisés dans la société et que ce sont des partis bourgeois.
North 👍🏼
Now immigration Map... You will understand
the majority of socialist voters are in the poor region (like the overseas, because of the economy of scale), in some part of the suburbs (because of the cost of living). And some part of the rural area. Nothing to do with your immigration.
@@tommarch.4493 Absolutely not.
There are 3 types of territories in France.
Areas without immigrants or with few immigrants like Brittany.
These areas vote on the left.
Then there are the territories with many immigrants but which remain a minority compared to the European populations. This is the case of the Southeast and the North.
These areas vote right / far right.
Finally there are the areas submerged by immigrants like Paris and the big cities.
They vote on the far left and liberal centrist
@@tommarch.4493 The North is very poor.
@@vince7520 Yet Alsace is very rich although they vote mostly right.
@@vince7520 False :
www.google.com/search?q=carte+immigration+france&client=ms-android-samsung-gj-rev1&source=android-browser&prmd=inmv&sxsrf=ALeKk00nVHbWvkNDoN_0hRPPy-DXmZ-wWA:1591352344279&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwjescW5uerpAhVq8-AKHdmsBiAQ_AUoAXoECA0QAQ&biw=360&bih=603&dpr=2#imgrc=_JmYAseEfmHcfM
What are the values and beliefs that distinguish the two?
The popularity of each candidate of presidential election of 2017 by city and region, according to a basic left/right classification. Of course it's a simplist map. And it may have moved since, the political chess has evolved. Couldn't absolutely say who would win in 2022.
There are actually 4 main political orientations
Far Right (Rassemblement National): Authority Inequality and Order based on ethnic views of a France of the past anti-migrant anti-EU with a little bit of a social program and protectionnism policy.
Right (Les Républicains): Order and Inequality based on a view serving the top of society as much as possible, free market enthousiasts , trying to destroy the welfare state.
Center-Left pretending to be left but actually right wing (La République en Marche): Free market and openness will solve problem, it's just a coroporate party helping big money interests but they pretended to be "social and ecologist". Authority and Inequality pretending to be Green and Social.
Left (La France Insoumise): Equality and Green based on a view aiming at a rebuild of the welfare state and making large scale green policies. But also changing the constitution and letting people write what they want in it.
Basically the divide is on principles Right wing people think the social order is good and should be maintained as it is or increase its violence, Left wing people think the social order is unjust and should be changed as change the constitution, change capitalism, change public services so on and so forth.
To give a few examples :
Half of French people think capitalism is a bad economic system (more than half actually), the rest think it is good.
Half of French people don't see a problem with gay marriage, the other half is against, well not anymore they don't care now they figured it doesn't change their lives.
Basically the divide is as follow Maintaining Order VS Changing Unjust Order.
Jérémie Marion thanks
Someone can explain the North&East vs South&West division?
North east is the most populated, most urbanised area, with big cities, big industries and son on. The globalisation has hit those area the hardest, destroying factory, making a lot of people jobless while offering little to no possibility of reconversion. They also suffer from the important criminality that's often the downside of living in a big city, and ressent on the newcomer muslim immigrant for a number of reason. To them, the social welfare system of france benefits only to the lazy, and the taxes and regulations are a weigh on their paycheck more than anything else .
On the other side, south-east are on the winning side of both globalisation and the social welfare system: they are more agrarian/rural, making a lot of stuff that's very popular both inside and outside the country( cheese, wine...). Their sector of activity are higly protected by the state, the important criminality of the north east does not reach them. They are also a very touristic area, with nice landscape, the sea, the nearby montain and a lot of sun.
This is, of course, a very gross and very incomplete summary, but yeah, that's the biggest line here.
@@romualdcaffeserre6230 Following this line, isn't Paris should be the most right leaning?
@@edwardgroveland9029 Cosmopolitan liberals, traitors and hypocrites, they'll follow whatever party is flavor of the month be it left or center, but never the right wing or alt-right, they have been conditioned to hate it
@@edwardgroveland9029 Paris is an exception here. The housing prices in paris are so huge it acts as a natural detterent against everything that's not high-middle class really, people who also are on the winning side of the modern world (not to mention it's a huge touristic area). The people here are rich and well-educated, and the poor live in the suburb nearby, where the real criminality problem is confined. I dont know much about the US, but if you want to compare france with the US, Paris is the grumpy version of New York, the south west is a rural version of california, and the north west would be the urban version of the fly-over state who voted for trump, like alabama and stuff.
Again,as i said, all this is a gross simplification.
@@ivdeadelendaest219 Extrêmement précis
It surprises me that the south-east of France is also far-right, knowing that the edge of the Mediterranean is a place where immigration is frequent :/
France is blue where descendants of immigrants are. Because when you grow up there as a white, you have to fight and live in public insecurity
that is mainly the reason we are far-right in the south-east.
Blažek Blažouille maybe there’s a reason people getting hit with the mass immigration vote right wing
Tyrone Biggums Man. That is a fact. Most of south-east France is far-right.
@Blažek Blažouille The South East is far-right because of African migration ( maghrebian and subsaharian altogether).
Put a racial map beside it and then ...
Ah yes, political racism.
Les gars ça s'appelle juste ouvrir les yeux, si on veut pas vivre sous la Charia faut commencer par accepter qu'il y une véritable invasion dans les grandes villes , un prosélytisme islamique qui grandit de jour en jour, avec un tas de zones ou de quartiers qui ne sont plus français.
Ylann Doucy et ?
Ylann Doucy Je dirais pas que je m’en réjouis mais je m’en fout pas non plus. Il est vrai que la France doit vraiment faire quelque chose contre l’immigration, ça me gêne que des jeunes avec un avenir vont en France plutôt que de faire avancer leur propre pays. Je suis marocain, et le Maroc aussi doit vraiment trouver un moyen de garder son peuple dans son pays.
A classment of the Country who lost the most of war ?
เป็นคนไทยป่าวคับ
The more left you the more leftist it is, and vice verca
That's because it's the places with no immigrants.
Or too many*
Poland
Poland
I see people arguing in Poland because Duda said he will give 500+ and anti LGBTQ if he wins again. Poles don't want 500+ cause it doesn't benefit anybody but rather milk the country of essential funds.
@@pizzeriaverona3726 Duda is noob
for me Poland full blue
@@thibautsik6106 yes
Anyone noticed, why is it more right wing for provinces closer to Germany
There are more rural areas in the right
I'm living next to the german border. Idk why but it's due to culture. We are wealthier than other regions, we don't vote for our own economic interest
👌👌👌
Now add a third color to represent demagogy and the country will be more united than Manchester
Interesting how the more culturally enriched the area is the more right wing the natives become, and all the people that claim to live diversity all chose to live in what are essentially ethnostates
In regards to your first claim, that pertains largely to those "natives" who both score high in ethnic identification and who are concerned with relative group status. Otherwise, the statement doesn't quite apply to "natives" as a whole.
As for your second, I'm not sure how you've quantified that such people have been proven to all, or even largely, wall themselves off into ethnostates. Given that they are more likely to live in the most diverse parts of their respective countries, I could equally well retort that they're practicing what they preach.
Given that you're using the phrase "culturally enriched" in the sort of meme-y, dog whistle sense, I do wonder how objective any analysis you make could really be. I don't think Orwell, whose image you've chosen to adopt, would've taken kindly to the empty sloganeering.
@@olivesama its all just virtue-signalling so they can pretend to have the moral high ground. They never actually practise what they preach.
@@miniaturejayhawk8702 Contrary to claims that we're dealing with empty, morally relativistic post-modern neo-Marxists (or whatever the labels are now) these are very often people who have earnest moral and political convictions. I don't think greater understanding is achieved by insisting that everything they do is fake while only convictions held by one's own in-group are "real".
so based on this we can conclude that paris and ethnic minorities are very left leaning while the northern regions are very conservative
You forgot Mayotte
Mayotte is not France.
There are 3 types of territories in France.
Areas without immigrants or with few immigrants like Brittany.
These areas vote on the left.
Then there are the territories with many immigrants but which remain a minority compared to the European populations. This is the case of the Southeast and the North.
These areas vote right / far right.
Finally there are the areas submerged by immigrants like Paris and the big cities.
They vote on the far left and liberal centrist.
No, the east is very right wing because it's a poor industrial region
www.google.com/search?q=carte+immigration+france&client=ms-android-samsung-gj-rev1&source=android-browser&prmd=inmv&sxsrf=ALeKk00nVHbWvkNDoN_0hRPPy-DXmZ-wWA:1591352344279&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwjescW5uerpAhVq8-AKHdmsBiAQ_AUoAXoECA0QAQ&biw=360&bih=603&dpr=2#imgrc=_JmYAseEfmHcfM
lol is your brain in airplane mode ?
@subscribe to my empty channel or being a Muslim in France isn't tantamount to being an immigrant. You have to specify the ethnicity. Otherwise, you're sentence is meaningless.
That literally makes no sense
the closer to germans, the more right wing they get😅
Hunter Trum not really related to Germany as when you look at the richest and poorest cities and towns in France you would sea most of the poor cities are left and most of the richest cities are right
@@darth3911 Quite the opposite actually. Paris is the richest, and extremely left. The poor countryside is right wing.
The French left is Champagne socialism.
@@darth3911 Completely wrong and caricatural: Lyon, Paris, Rennes.. are rich cities and vote left
@@Antiteshmis also called "la gauche caviar" in French. The caviar left
Ah, the Fenech and their 3984 political parties
only four are actually relevant.
Edwige Fenech?
@@EunusRex he means french
Gotta get rid of that disjointed government with a focus not hard
Left wing is the best wing.
Nope.
@@alangervasis yep
@@ajarofmayonnaise3250 Kammi aanalle 😀
@@ajarofmayonnaise3250 are u muslim or african in france? ofc u are a left wing then haha
Gaullism the best LOL.
Droite Gang
makes all the kings of Portugal
Je suis désolé, mais l'UPR n'est pas à droite, ce parti a était classé selon le ministère de l'intérieur comme "Divers".
Right/left orientation is obsolete now
Beacause of the left domination
@@julieneugene5584 in past political scene was divided between morally liberal socialist (left) and conservative capitalists (right). Now mainstream is economically neoliberal and pro-LGBT. "Christian-democrat", "liberal" and "social-democrat" parties have the same ideology de facto
@@ziomekzmiasta9292 I thinked more for the destruction of the right in republicans time like today : republicans wants the end of the monarchie and the powerful leader to serve their ideology even if people don't want it. That's why for example Napoléon III's people was 80% happy of hym or a majority of the French people in 1789 was agree with king Louis XVI and now with republican propaganda and republican domination of the politic people see kings or emperor like tyranny (sorry for my bad English)
@@julieneugene5584 let me guess. You are a survival from "the Vendèen Genocide"? Also pretty sure many people who liked the king had a hard and short life in the revolution.
@@alexandrub8786 I'm not, I'm just monarchist, the Génocide Vendéen is an horrible crime but I'm from Normandie, along from the Channel
Bizarrement les parties bleus sont celles avec le plus de migrants
Bizarrement comme tu dis.
Ce n’est que le hasard.
Quand les villes bretonnes auront autant d'immigrés qu'à Roubaix je te garantie que la région va changer de couleur
R-soft Ayant eu l’occasion de beaucoup bouger en France, je ne peux qu’appuyer tes propos. L’une des region les plus épargnée pas l’immigration, et pourtant l’une des plus gauchistes et bien pensante...
Ça commence déjà à Nantes
Chopin approves
There is 1066 comments
Nice
It also match with mosques map
I really don’t see how mosquees have anything to do with this map.
@@haytem3201 many mosquees means there are many muslims, and if you look at Trump and remember the immigrant crisis you can understand. But the calculus could be wrong if it is a case like Romania were there is a single mosque (named after a christian from the 19-20 century) and many small worshiping buildings for muslims.
Fin fact: romanian anti-terro have taken care of the muslim brotherhood inside Romania because of the muslims living for a long time there.
Eurk en Occitanie ça vote à gauche.
M'en fou dans mon département on vote à droite.
Il vote à gauche mais au présidentielle plus à droite...
La politique française
If Paris is lefty, I'm not coming there
Paris is overrated, for americans, france is paris but it's definitly not
@@elkheyou4061 in general I prefer eastern Europe and cold temperatures. I'm thinking of looking at st Petersburg and Finnish lakes (and coz I'm from Poland, pomerania i guess it'll be closer than France)
@@youtubeadministration8037 Yeah estern country are beautiful, and going out there is less expansive than western europe.
Paris is Africa
@@CC-hx8gj true
👍👍
It fits perfectly where is racial diversity.
Everywhere preserved (on the west), the population is predominantly of French ancestry and vote on the left-side for the sake of feeling like they are nice people.
Everywhere on the east, descendant of migrants and migrants from Sub-Saharan Africa and North Africa make up a much higher part of the population, plus they are growing much faster. Consequently in those areas, people are voting more and more on the right as they deal with the consequences in terms of criminality and the dilution of the French identity.
Ah yes, political racism
@@reinatr4848 care to elaborate?
Is Brittany so "non-white"?
Exactly (I live in south east)
@@hieratics No, Britanny is preserved, it is white, henceforth people are still living in their fairy tales and vote left. Amazing place BTW
Vive la droite,vive Le Pen,vive la France🇨🇵
Merci pour la vidéo
nice video 🛎 lik.e 2,8k
Do it with Italy