Clearly the best scene from this episode....Maisie and Charles are awesome. Obviously I don't own any of this...Game of Thrones is just my Sunday pleasure.
@@bouttoenddismanswholecaree5078 No. Imho Tywin realized from the first moment on that something is up with her. He got curious, and thats why he started having long conversations with her - something he wouldn't do with a normal servant. For a long time I even thought he secretly knew who she really is for the whole time, and just wanted to make up for the horrible things that happened to her.
@@covodex516 He didn't know that she was Arya Stark. If he did, he would have her captured and the Lannisters would be using her as a bargaining chip. He did, however, know that there was something different about her. When Tywin first arrives in Harrenhal in S02E04, all of the prisoners kneel upon Tywin's arrival apart from Arya, as lords or their families would not kneel for another lord. This gave away Arya's highborn status. Arya pretending to be a boy to travel safer gave away the fact that she was smarter than most people her age. As did Arya knowing how to read.
I doubt Tywin (or most people) hold/s lowborn people to the same standards of intelligence as high borns, let alone his own child. A fly completing a jigsaw would be a borderline miracle, a human doing the same would be expected, if not boring
Tywin knew she was highborn, though he didn’t know she was a Stark. He realised when Arya admitted to eating a lot of food, also the fact that she lied about where she was from. She also speaks like a highborn girl, Tywin noticed this.
This is the equivilant to the two pretty Girls. 1 knows and is aware of her beauty. The other one doesn't quite realize it yet. 1 is an underachiever The other one is too cocky and overachieved.
Probably because to him, Tywin's children are disappointments in their own way; Jaime was mighty but lacked ambition, Cersei was ambitious but lacked wit, and Tyrion was ambitious and intelligent, but a dwarf and caused his mother's death. Arya is certainly the daughter, or even granddaughter, that Tywin wished he had but never got.
@@minhducnguyen8421 He could be the smartest man in Westeros but nothing will change. This is Tywin's biggest character flaw: after watching what his father did, all Tywin cares about is the Lannister name. His care for his children is not because they're his children, but because they're Lannisters.
The scenes where Tywin interacts with intelligent children really show how much pleasure he gets from seeing their potential. My favorite scenes of him are when he is with Arya and Tommen.
It's why I liked Tywin's character so much. As Charles Dance stated Tywin isn't necessarily a bad person-just a practical man of the time and realm. He taught a dyslexic son how to read by not giving up.
@@TheShanicpower i wouldn´t say evil.... he isn´t as bad as goeffrey or ramsay. he is flawed and can certainly be cruel, the only one he is unnecessary cruel to is tyrion
For those saying Tywin isn’t evil, just practical, look at how he treats Tyrion. There’s nothing practical or logical about it, it’s cruel and sadistic and frankly stupid. Only a truly twisted person could treat their own son that way.
@@alexanderzack3720 there's two types of evil. There's chaotic evil and lawful evil. Joffrey and Ramsay are chaotic evil. They do evil whenever they want, even if it doesn't benefit them. Joffrey killed Ned, which started a war that eventually took away Joffrey's breathing privileges. Ramsay killed Rickon, which made Sansa kill him brutally. Tywin is lawful evil. He does evil when it benefits him. He killed the Reynes, which led to him becoming hand of the king. He got Robb killed, which ended the war. The only chaotic evil thing he did was treating Tyrion so badly
Could you imagine??? Arya Lannister daughter of Lord Tywin lannister. He would have taught her battle tactics, swordsmanship, economics, everything a lannister would know
Not really all the bad shit that happened to arya has made her a badass not living in a castle she probably would have been much weaker and less ruthless if she grew up in better circumstances
I like how Tywin knows she's a noble born. But never guesses correctly that she's a Stark. He's having fun trying to figure out which house she belongs to.
In my opinion, I think he knew, but he recognized her potential and spared her. He is a lawful evil man but he does show in very few moments such as this that he does have a heart or at least is not overly cruel. Also I think he did not consider her to be much of a threat at the time. Arya did not get her full potential until after her training.
@@redwolf4982 nah if Tywin realised he had such a valuable hostage as Arya Stark within arm's reach he'd have her in a cell immediately. He assumed she was a high-born girl from some lesser house disrupted by the war, not a major player.
@@redwolf4982 He didn't. The thing is, he thought she was still in King's Landing. Cersei never sent word, that she escaped. Tyrion only found out, when he returned to King's Landing.
I love how much of this scene is Arya trying to sort of interrogate and analyze Tywin without realizing it’s the other way around, he’s examining her with almost no questions. She poses as a commoner but eats with a knife and fork and decent table manners, says she eats a lot, knows details of history even he doesn’t remember, and uses polished and formal language. There are so many layers in the dialogue of all their scenes.
@@A.S._Trunks The writing and plot development in S6 was lame. The first half was wasted on a boring Vito story arc that went nowhere. The notion of Tony becoming a crybaby degenerate gambler was not believable at all. Tony, Johnny Boy and Junior all made their livelihoods by juicing degenerate gamblers and Pimps do not become Johns.
@@andreashort310 I think he respected Arya more than Cersei though. He tells Arya "you're too smart for your own good" and tells Cersei "you're not as smart as you think you are"
@@berryreadable he was beginning to narrow it down for sure. He knew she was a northerner, and that she was of noble birth. There probably weren't many missing daughters of Northern nobleman. It wasn't going to be too hard after that for him to deduce that she was Arya Stark, the missing daughter of one of his enemies who escaped King's Landing.
@@Amann0407 I don't think he knew that Arya escaped. Baelish knew that Arry was Arya and didn't mention that she had escaped from King's Landing and somewhat implied that she was still there.
@@wendychan4012he knew she was from the north from her appearance and accent. Then she gave away she can read, knows obscure history, eats a lot, and speaks properly. He knew she was highborn but had no idea Arya had escaped Kings Landing.
this is actually quite cute...Tywin really seems to be fond of Arya here, and, while i know she would have been discovered eventually, i wish they had more time to bond like this.
I think Tywin struggles to be a father to his own kids because they don't match his expectations. Arya on the other hand is a pleasant surprise, a highborn girl posing as a commoner makes him interested to learn more, and her intelligence and sheer nerve made him respect her. It's respect for someone that allows him to be kind, or at least something resembling kind. I figure Tywin found sparring with Arya's wit more entertaining than anything else he could do when he got down time at Harrenhall, hence why he seemed to spend a significant amount of time with her even when she wasn't performing her duties as a cupbearer.
It’s almost cute when you realize the only time Tywin laughs in the series is when Arya makes a comment that reminds him of Cersei. Almost like he’s remembering his daughter fondly. Adds an affection edge to an otherwise cruel father
In the books I believe it's said that he was so humorless that with the exception of his wife, that he adored - he'd only laughed twice in his adult life.
can you imagine the conflicted emotions arya must've felt at that moment? telling tywin about the stories she loved, reminiscing about her father, only to be told that she reminds him of his daughter the woman who arya hates. imo there is a part of arya that enjoyed tywin as he enjoyed her. she learned from him which later helped her hone skills as a faceless man. yet here she is, a young girl spending time with a man who is trying to kill her family and enjoying herself before catching it and tucking it away. what an amazing actress and actor
boils down to GRRM and his ability to create such captivating scenarios that push the limits of all characters. Although he did use Roose Bolton in the books, D&D def made the right choice with Tywin here.
Ha ha, she answers honestly as well, as if this is a topic that has gone through her head and around her family for years to the point where they just said "She ain't getting bigger no matter what we feed her."
Tywin also said in this scene "I suppose you've been underfed your whole life.", maybe he wanted to get information out of her whether she was indeed underfed (therefore poor) or well fed (therefore of possible noble birth)
I wouldn’t be surprised if he already figured it out but was waiting until he was going back to kings landing . If he said he knew then Arya would try to escape
@@joshuatree206 He definetely did not know she was a Stark, otherwise she'd be a hostage in an instant. He probably suspected her to be some minor nobility.
And on a real-world level you could see Charles Dance genuinely enjoying the conversation with Maisie Williams. An appreciation of her performance. That smile _wasn't_ acting.
@@marcw6875 No, but I can read _body language._ Notice his eyes. Most actors must engage in tense concentration to get the right nuance, and it shows in tension around the eye sockets. Dance's eyes show less tension, with relaxed focus. He's _observing_ her as much as responding to lines.
Jakob Kristensen Sandvik They barely speak. She interacts with Roose Bolton more than Tywin. She actually helps him take the castle in the books. She and Jaquen break out Robb's men from the dungeon with nothing but a cauldron of soup and a knife. It's badass.
Tywin is fond of Arya, but he doesn’t suffer sentimentality. Some think he’s being kind by allowing Arya to eat, but in a scene before, the commander died from poisoning, so Tywin is using her to see if his food has been poisoned as well. It’s such a wonderful, subtle moment that shows that Tywin has the capacity for kindness, but his practicality and self-preservation are still his major priorities.
But also testing her by turning his back while she had sharp knife. Testing her mettle with dialog, testing her courage with the potentially poisoned food and testing her patience by leaving her with the knife.
Arya making tywin laugh with such a throwaway comment is actually one of my favourite moments in the whole show. Tywin wasnt half as evil as everyone makes him out to be. He just had the rotten luck of having a stupid father and spolit children. With nothing else to invest in, he simply did the best he could to secure the next generation.
Oh no, Tywin was absolutely ruthless and evil. But people are multi-faceted, and even cruel, manipulative, and ruthless people can have things they like, and people they care about, and things that bring them joy. That doesn't make them less evil, it just makes them not a one dimensional cartoon villain. Tywin is the *reason* his kids are the way they are. His neglect, pressure, and abuse made them into monsters in his own image.
“You’re too smart for your own good.” It sounds like a straightforward line to conclude the conversation but there are layers to it. Tywin is a man who appreciates wisdom, as stated later on when he gives a lecture on its importance to a great king. At the same time, he is also very experienced. Wisdom grants the ability to derive more detailed and impactful lessons from experience. A combination of these traits during wartime can take a heavy toll on whomever possesses them. It’s perhaps not the best thing for a child to have… especially one who seems to be as inquisitive and impulsive as this girl whom he’s growing fond of.
@@StuntcatTV Intelligence is the foundation of wisdom. If Arya demonstrates a high level of intelligence, she thus possesses a high capacity for wisdom. Someone like Tywin would definitely recognize that.
Tywin is able to recognize that Arya is not only whip smart (dressing as a boy, speaking her mind, even lying about where she is from) but book smart (literate, knowledgeable about history, and speaking properly). The last three are only available to girls of a certain level of wealth and status. Tywin tries to trick her many times into Arya revealing herself as a Stark.
@@Attackonmuffin he was just a villain. A perfect villain would have a vision and the bodies he buries will be for a cause. Jouffery was just a spoilt stupid brat.
This is a game of chess. He knows full well she is of noble birth, though not of which house. He was doing all he could to wear her down so she would slip up. But he enjoys the game as he liked to clash whits with someone with intelligence. She played well, but eventually, had she stayed any longer, he would have gotten the answer he wanted.
@@joeyfisher3838 Robb would never have agreed, which means Arya would just become a spare key to Winterfell as far as Tywin is concerned, just like Sansa.
"if you're going to pose as a commoner you should do it properly" Part of me really likes to think he knows who she is but doesn't say anything out of respect for her guile and general badassery... if only
I don't think he suspected her actual identity, Only that she is highborn. If he did know then she would definitely be taken hostage in a war against her brother.
@@finnheisenheim8274 The charade between them entertains him in a way rarely he ever even had. She might not even worth hostaging for the war if a "Tywin Fucking Lannister" respects you
Yes but he knew she was a highborn northern girl... why couldn’t he use her against some of Robb’s allies? Why didn’t he still investigate about her ancestry?
Look up "A Wolf Amongst Lions" by Kallypso if you'd like to see that. It is a fanfic that asks what would have happened if Tywin realized Arya was Arya. Tons more of their dynamic.. The story is well-written, well-planned, over 470K words, and, best of all, it has been completed! I've lost two evenings reading this thing! Highly recommended!
You see, of one's kin one entertains 'expectations'. And THOSE are usually a damper on most relationships. He has no expectations of this servant girl. She piques his interest and constitutes a pleasant distraction from his duties and obligations. That is all. After which, her destiny is not on him.
After seeing tywin interaction with arya, i can't help but think that part of Tywin's bitterness towards his children was caused by the lack of "worthy" grandchildren. Joffrey was a spoiled lunatic, Myrcella begun to show some intelligence later, and tommen was a bit of a pushover. I think that the big old lion, could have secretly yearned for some grandchildren with whom he could spend some time with and mold them himself.
This is my favorite Tywin scene in GOT. It proves Charles dance (actor for Tywin) right. He’s not a bad man, just a strong and intense character who does horrible things for the betterment of his family
he sentenced his son to death then slept with his girlfriend the night prior to the execution. all this while knowing tyrion was innocent and preaching about not allowing whores into the castle. oh, and lets not mention what he did to tyrions first wife. tywin is probably my fav character but lets not sanitize him
not to be pedantic, but doing terrible things for the betterment(read, financial/political gain) of your family makes you a bad man. stealing a loaf of bread to feed your starving kids is one thing. murdering thousands of people just for political gain is a completely different thing.
To all of you who find this cute or humanizing: you *do* realize that regardless of the dinner conversation, Tywin was mostly just using Arya as a taster in case the food was poisoned as well, right? Remember what immediately preceded this scene, and then remember how pragmatic Tywin is.
He is a powerful man so it shouldn't be surprising that he valued his life more than a simple servant girl.He had to be cautious especially in that environment.
It's funny. At the end of this, he gently (at least by his standards) tells Arya "Go on." Whereas everyone else ever in the show he commands them "Go." Subtle writing choices like that are what make it a great show, I can't wait to see the last few seasons!
Love how they’re supposed to be natural enemies and would give each other up in a heartbeat should the circumstances of been different yet admire like and unwittingly learn so much from each other. So many reasons why early thrones is a masterpiece
It's neither. Cersei hated being female. She wanted to have Jaime's life. Part of the reason she is so bitter is because she was forced into being what women were forced to be. I'm sure a similar exchange happened between her and Tywin many times when she was young. We shouldn't hate Cersei so much. She serves as a reverse mirror to many characters. This is just one example. Arya got to live the life she wanted, Cersei didn't. There are many other instances that formed her to be the mean, resentful, hateful woman she is as an adults. She went through most of the same things the protagonists of this show suffered through but with a key difference. Cersei never had 'good' parents to guide her, only Tywin's ruthlessness was really taught. Not honor or kindness like the stark children. The stark children recieved many gifts to make them likable. She did not.
I’d always wanted him to know who Arya really was before he died just to see the look on his face! A Stark, right under his nose and too clever to have gotten away with it too!
Vinicius Villela he absolutely wouldn’t have her executed. Otherwise he’d have had Sansa executed too. Having a live Stark was much more valuable than a dead Stark
What I found most interesting is the fact that they both found some sort of safety in each other's company. Arya is telling the stories of the Targaryans with a child like wonder. You don't see much of that at all after Ned is killed. But she felt safe to be a child with Tywin. She knew he wouldn't hurt her from the second he saved her from one of his guards. And though Tywin knew she wasn't who she said she was, he was enough steps ahead of her to not worry about it too much. He really liked her, and gave her a side of him he gave no one else in the show. It was like it was the only place for both of them to drop their defenses and just be human again for a bit.
This will always be one of my favorite scenes in the entire series. It's a delight how Arya showed her wits against Tywin. Tywin has this "proud dad look" when Arya retells the story of the Targaryens
Tywin has a fondness and admiration for Arya to the point where he won’t bust her for obviously having an agenda. Tywin is not fooled for a moment, even after her clever cover of why she speaks proper (properly!) He knows she’s high born and undercover for some reason, but doesn’t feel threatened and so enjoys his time with her, with no intention of outing her.
I don't think he thinks she's undercover, he figured out she was posing as a boy for safety reasons earlier, he's making the same assumption again, that she is posing as a commoner, because if it became known that she's "high born" someone might think of using her for a ransom. He respects her thinking, he doesn't think she has a nefarious reason for hiding who she is, just that situations have happened, and that she is doing what she needs to do to survive. The good thing about this scene is that it really establishes that there are noble houses beyond the major ones, something that you see with Robb Starks eventual wife and Brienne. (and played upon much later in the series)
Love their chemistry. Tywin was able to catch some of her lies throughout their time together and I believe despite being enemies, they could’ve been friends
It looked like he was as warm with Tommen. It's just the tragedy of Tywin that if he had worked as hard raising his children and grandchildren as he did "preparing their legacy", things would have worked out better for everyone.
"You are too smart for your own good, has anyone told you that?" He knows she just pulled that out of thin air but its such a good lie, he is just going to play along with it. Love this whole scene!!
That moment at 4:34 between Arya and Tywin is incredible. So much is communicated in those few seconds and words, great chemistry between these two characters.
The most interesting thing is.. Lord Tywin knows there is more to her. He knows she's lying, and he knows she is not who she says she is. And yet he sees something in her that he likes. Something more natural than what Cersei wanted to be, something more clever, as well as something more sinister. He knew she likely had more nefarious plans than what she was posing as. He instead tested how well she played the game, and liked how she played it. Considering the darkness inside of Arya, she was likely the closest to the things Tywin wanted in his off-spring, almost like the daughter he *wished* Cersei had been. Scenes like this between the two of them really do capture that feeling, he knows she's lying from the get go, and calls her out/teaches her about her mistakes, which would serve her later. I'm guessing he feels, whomever she is, she will go on to do other things when she's done pretending there, but was not a threat to him, so he actually enjoyed the company of a child he likely very much wished his own children had started out being. These scenes are masterful in their execution of it. That was actually a *proud* smile from Tywin at the end. He probably didn't have very many when it came to his own, but he did for Arya, and that says a lot about why he liked conversing with her so, even when he knew she was not who she said she was. That smile he gives at the end it's almost as if he'd wished his other children had been *what* she already is back when he was raising them. Both Jaimie and Cersei's weaknesses(Ambition for Jaime and Wit for Cersei) are Arya's strengths and he saw that in her. In many ways, Arya is the child he wished for, but never got.
Well reasoned! Honestly, the Tywin and Arya scene are probably my favorites from the whole series. There's so menace about half an inch away, and yet on top of that they're witty and seem to regard each other with both respect and affection. The dynamic is *delicious*.
The fact that he held for so long that he already knew what she was and only told her when she got cocky to remind her to watch her steps was a beautiful father daughter moment.
When she says, "from my father"......man. I didn't know three small words could be so powerful. Maisie was an incredible actress for the first 3 seasons specifically
It’s insane that Tywin is fully aware that she is lying and does nothing. It’s almost as if he’s aware of his role in the story and knows that even though he will be who he must for the narrative, he knows the story isn’t about him
This is one of my favorite scenes from either character, the show's creators made an excellent choice in deviating from the books to add these little compassionate gestures from Tywin Lannister.
This was one of my favorite scenes from the show, and one of the reasons why, even though he is definitely one of the villains of the series, Tywin is also one of my favorite characters. You see him try to teach his children this as well, but Tywin is never needlessly cruel or arrogant or domineering. Cersie throws her power around just for the sake of reminding everyone how strong she is. Tyrion is brilliant, but his defense mechanisms also make him overconfident and obnoxious to people sometimes. Tywin understands that even your enemies deserve at least enough respect to take them seriously. I always loved this scene because it shows that he is insightful and perceptive. He knows there's something different about Arya, but it's clear he's not interested in finding out what it is. As long as she behaves, he's content to let her keep up her little ruse. And you can see his appreciation for her game after she leaves the room.
This scene here actually makes me think.. Was tywin really an evil person or just someone who would go to any extent for his family (like everyone else on this show)
Is everyone forgetting how Tywin sicced the Mountain and Co on Princess Elia (raping/murdering her), Rhaenys (being stabbed 50 times) and baby Aegon (head smashed against the wall)? You might not say that's evil because it had to be done, but I'd disagree.
I love Tywin’s subtle little gesture right after the “taught us how to speak proper- properly!” in 4:31. You can tell he’s got her game figured out, but he’s fond of her enough to be amused when she quickly thinks up a way to get herself out of the pinch. Tywin respects a resourceful person who’s quick of feet and mind. It’s a shame his flaw is caring about the Lannister’s name and legacy so much, otherwise he’d have been an amazing statesman, military commander AND father (he already is the first three). Also, Charles Dance’s interpretation is absolutely stellar.
I love how layered this scene is. He's a clever man but clearly has no interest in female warrior, particularly Dragon Riding Queens- which is why Dany was able to grow so much in power while he was about.
Gods be good, this scene is amazing. It's incredible the chemistry that Dance and Williams are able to conjure despite their vast age / experience difference. Tywin seems genuinely fascinated by Arya. It's wonderful.
I cant help but imagine that these 2 would have had an incredible arc together. Arya could have learned so much from Tywin about strategy and war. I really wish they had found a way to make this duo have a bigger story.
I honestly love seeing these two together. He immediately caught on that she's a high born girl posing as a commoner but instead of having her head or prying what her real house is, he simply enjoys sparring with her through words. Meanwhile, she's learning how to navigate in a situation like this while also learning a few tricks from Tywin because he is guiding her and teaching her how to think through strategies and act as a commoner, a role he only has observed from afar but well enough to help her better her acting. The fact that she could be clever back is a whole other thing tho haha
Honestly I feel like this is one of the best scenes in the series. It shows a different side to Tywin and gives you sympathy towards his life and his goals. It showed how names determine your allies and enemies, not ones person.
Tywin is the essence of what a good lord, and man by extension, should ve. Strong and fearful when necessary, but respected, honest in what he says and means to do, and empathetic when it is properly called for. Those who end up meeting him know right off that this is someone who isn't to be trifled with casually, but also someone who if presented with diligence will be met with friendship/assistance.
I cannot imagine how daunting it would be to have a scene with the legendary Charles Dance, but my god Maisie just absolutely nails this scene. Incredible acting all around. These interactions between Tywin and Arya are my favorite in the entire series
![Arya Encounters Littlefinger [HD]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/f9jac7Qg9w4/mqdefault.jpg)
![Arya Encounters Littlefinger [HD]](/img/tr.png)
Arya: Have you ever lost before?
Tywin: Is my name Tylose?
HAH
Hahahaha
Lol
THIS why this hasn’t got at least 1k likes I’ll never know
Lmao this is one of the smarter comments on GOT videos
"Careful now, girl. I enjoy you, but be careful."
- the nicest thing Tywin Lannister ever said.
And it still was a threat
The reason he even gave her the food was to see if it was poison🤣
@@bouttoenddismanswholecaree5078 No. Imho Tywin realized from the first moment on that something is up with her. He got curious, and thats why he started having long conversations with her - something he wouldn't do with a normal servant. For a long time I even thought he secretly knew who she really is for the whole time, and just wanted to make up for the horrible things that happened to her.
Covodex 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 your an idiot
@@covodex516 He didn't know that she was Arya Stark. If he did, he would have her captured and the Lannisters would be using her as a bargaining chip.
He did, however, know that there was something different about her. When Tywin first arrives in Harrenhal in S02E04, all of the prisoners kneel upon Tywin's arrival apart from Arya, as lords or their families would not kneel for another lord. This gave away Arya's highborn status. Arya pretending to be a boy to travel safer gave away the fact that she was smarter than most people her age. As did Arya knowing how to read.
Tywin to arya: "youre too smart for your own good"
Tywin to cersei: "youre not as smart as you think you are"
I doubt Tywin (or most people) hold/s lowborn people to the same standards of intelligence as high borns, let alone his own child. A fly completing a jigsaw would be a borderline miracle, a human doing the same would be expected, if not boring
This the best comment on this video.
Tywin knew she was highborn, though he didn’t know she was a Stark. He realised when Arya admitted to eating a lot of food, also the fact that she lied about where she was from. She also speaks like a highborn girl, Tywin noticed this.
@@moneyro8573 the daughter he wished he had
This is the equivilant to the two pretty Girls.
1 knows and is aware of her beauty.
The other one doesn't quite realize it yet.
1 is an underachiever
The other one is too cocky and overachieved.
"Most girls are idiots."
"Hah! You remind me of my daughter."
"Oh she liked Visenya too?"
"No, she's an idiot."
Hahahahahhahaha lmao
Man this video has so many great comments lol
I can imagine him saying that! 🤣🤣🤣
3:24
🤣🤣🤣
Tywin is nicer to Arya than to any of his kids
Probably because to him, Tywin's children are disappointments in their own way; Jaime was mighty but lacked ambition, Cersei was ambitious but lacked wit, and Tyrion was ambitious and intelligent, but a dwarf and caused his mother's death.
Arya is certainly the daughter, or even granddaughter, that Tywin wished he had but never got.
If he is smarter, he will know how to support his children, noone is perfect ^^
@@minhducnguyen8421 He could be the smartest man in Westeros but nothing will change. This is Tywin's biggest character flaw: after watching what his father did, all Tywin cares about is the Lannister name. His care for his children is not because they're his children, but because they're Lannisters.
@@minhducnguyen8421 He is smarter. He knows not everybody thinks like that. Probably.
I don't think you watch this series at all...
@@jsnagn3410 Okay, it is your point. I dont say bad thing to anybody. But in series, be killed by his smart son will be called smart as well ^^
If Cersei saw how he treated Arya she'd be furious.
@Zimmit's FunHouse Adventure any then killed off all his bastards, except Gendry, as revenge, not just to protect Joffery's claim.
if Tyrion and Jamie had been told Arya served as their fathers cupbearer in Harrenhall I'm sure they would've been laughing their asses off.
“Arya, the little animal”
To Cersei: "You're not as smart as you think you are."
To Arya: "You're too smart for your own good."
Love it.
I still don’t get it how does a monster like Tywin give off such good vibes towards a commoner. Does anyone know ?
"Hungry?"
"No."
"Of course you are, eat."
Why does Tywin sounds like my grandma lol.
it’s the grandparent instinct
He says “eat” with such punctuality
Grandparents just know. Now EAT. And chew thoroughly.
He says it becoz he suspects that it has poison. When he notice he speaks my lord and tell history of Targaryen's he knew she wasn't a commoner.
@@massacretv4988 Nope. Tywin suspects but he never caught on. Arya's story was watertight.
The scenes where Tywin interacts with intelligent children really show how much pleasure he gets from seeing their potential. My favorite scenes of him are when he is with Arya and Tommen.
It's why I liked Tywin's character so much. As Charles Dance stated Tywin isn't necessarily a bad person-just a practical man of the time and realm. He taught a dyslexic son how to read by not giving up.
@@tomservo5347 I mostly agree with what you’re saying, but no good person orchestrates the whole Tysha punishment. Tywin was an evil, evil man.
@@TheShanicpower i wouldn´t say evil.... he isn´t as bad as goeffrey or ramsay. he is flawed and can certainly be cruel, the only one he is unnecessary cruel to is tyrion
For those saying Tywin isn’t evil, just practical, look at how he treats Tyrion. There’s nothing practical or logical about it, it’s cruel and sadistic and frankly stupid. Only a truly twisted person could treat their own son that way.
@@alexanderzack3720 there's two types of evil. There's chaotic evil and lawful evil. Joffrey and Ramsay are chaotic evil. They do evil whenever they want, even if it doesn't benefit them. Joffrey killed Ned, which started a war that eventually took away Joffrey's breathing privileges. Ramsay killed Rickon, which made Sansa kill him brutally. Tywin is lawful evil. He does evil when it benefits him. He killed the Reynes, which led to him becoming hand of the king. He got Robb killed, which ended the war. The only chaotic evil thing he did was treating Tyrion so badly
Imagine if Arya was the daughter of Tywin. They'd be unstoppable
I think Tywin would be proud if his daughter becomes a faceless man... :D strong killing machine :D with an adorable side too :D
Could you imagine??? Arya Lannister daughter of Lord Tywin lannister. He would have taught her battle tactics, swordsmanship, economics, everything a lannister would know
This deserves a new series
@@hny4706 Yes she did, but this scene was far before she`ve done that...
Not really all the bad shit that happened to arya has made her a badass not living in a castle she probably would have been much weaker and less ruthless if she grew up in better circumstances
I like how Tywin knows she's a noble born. But never guesses correctly that she's a Stark. He's having fun trying to figure out which house she belongs to.
In my opinion, I think he knew, but he recognized her potential and spared her. He is a lawful evil man but he does show in very few moments such as this that he does have a heart or at least is not overly cruel. Also I think he did not consider her to be much of a threat at the time. Arya did not get her full potential until after her training.
@@redwolf4982 nah if Tywin realised he had such a valuable hostage as Arya Stark within arm's reach he'd have her in a cell immediately. He assumed she was a high-born girl from some lesser house disrupted by the war, not a major player.
If Tywin knew she is Arya stark she would have used her to take his son back
@@redwolf4982 He didn't. The thing is, he thought she was still in King's Landing. Cersei never sent word, that she escaped. Tyrion only found out, when he returned to King's Landing.
@@redwolf4982 you dont know him. Not at all
Gods The Dialogue Was Strong Back Then.
Lol. Relax Robert.
@David Cunningham This scene wasn't in the books
@@venlargig6169 no but grrm was still heavily involved with the show during that season
The scripts and writing was legendary. Key word “was”
So Get MOREEEEEEEEE
I love how much of this scene is Arya trying to sort of interrogate and analyze Tywin without realizing it’s the other way around, he’s examining her with almost no questions. She poses as a commoner but eats with a knife and fork and decent table manners, says she eats a lot, knows details of history even he doesn’t remember, and uses polished and formal language. There are so many layers in the dialogue of all their scenes.
Why do I torture myself by watching these scenes from when the show had layers of substance?
@@TheZumba19 well show had like 5 seasons great seasons, what are you talking about? Rest is not canon :D
@@PetarChakarov Exactly. I don't regard season 6 of The Sopranos as canon either.
@@Da_Benski What was so bad about Season 6 of The Sopranos?
@@A.S._Trunks The writing and plot development in S6 was lame. The first half was wasted on a boring Vito story arc that went nowhere. The notion of Tony becoming a crybaby degenerate gambler was not believable at all. Tony, Johnny Boy and Junior all made their livelihoods by juicing degenerate gamblers and Pimps do not become Johns.
Charles Dance was a gift to this show.
That guy is one hell of a talented actor.
What do you think D&D were?
True . Exceptional acting
He is a gift to any production.
He was so sexy as Tywin ... WOOF!
tywin smile of admiration at the end was nice. arya was the daughter he always wanted but never had
Not really. He even said Arya reminds him of his daughter.
@@andreashort310 I think he respected Arya more than Cersei though. He tells Arya "you're too smart for your own good" and tells Cersei "you're not as smart as you think you are"
may be she was the grand kid he always wanted
@J Knox one was smart, one was an narcisistic idiot
@@terrytemple8919 Interesting pickup!
She actually got a laugh out of Tywin. They got along surprisingly well
I love this scene so much. Tywin is literally interrogating Arya without her even noticing one bit. Such genius writing.
Did he guess who she was? How much did he know?
@@wendychan4012 he only knew she was of noble birth. He never knew her identity,
@@berryreadable he was beginning to narrow it down for sure. He knew she was a northerner, and that she was of noble birth. There probably weren't many missing daughters of Northern nobleman. It wasn't going to be too hard after that for him to deduce that she was Arya Stark, the missing daughter of one of his enemies who escaped King's Landing.
@@Amann0407 I don't think he knew that Arya escaped. Baelish knew that Arry was Arya and didn't mention that she had escaped from King's Landing and somewhat implied that she was still there.
@@wendychan4012he knew she was from the north from her appearance and accent. Then she gave away she can read, knows obscure history, eats a lot, and speaks properly. He knew she was highborn but had no idea Arya had escaped Kings Landing.
3:23 Tywin's only legitimate laugh in the entire series
george mikal it’s still terrifying tho
Only laugh ever
im sev no
@@diamondthilay7516 when
im sev when he was talking with Jaime while skinning a dear
this is actually quite cute...Tywin really seems to be fond of Arya here, and, while i know she would have been discovered eventually, i wish they had more time to bond like this.
I wish they had a few more of these... it was a brilliant and intriguing plot move to put Arya and Tywin together like this
exactly! i loved it!
He was making her test the food for poison..
I think Tywin struggles to be a father to his own kids because they don't match his expectations. Arya on the other hand is a pleasant surprise, a highborn girl posing as a commoner makes him interested to learn more, and her intelligence and sheer nerve made him respect her. It's respect for someone that allows him to be kind, or at least something resembling kind. I figure Tywin found sparring with Arya's wit more entertaining than anything else he could do when he got down time at Harrenhall, hence why he seemed to spend a significant amount of time with her even when she wasn't performing her duties as a cupbearer.
And now all arya does is one liners and one night stands
It’s almost cute when you realize the only time Tywin laughs in the series is when Arya makes a comment that reminds him of Cersei. Almost like he’s remembering his daughter fondly. Adds an affection edge to an otherwise cruel father
In the books I believe it's said that he was so humorless that with the exception of his wife, that he adored - he'd only laughed twice in his adult life.
can you imagine the conflicted emotions arya must've felt at that moment? telling tywin about the stories she loved, reminiscing about her father, only to be told that she reminds him of his daughter the woman who arya hates. imo there is a part of arya that enjoyed tywin as he enjoyed her. she learned from him which later helped her hone skills as a faceless man. yet here she is, a young girl spending time with a man who is trying to kill her family and enjoying herself before catching it and tucking it away. what an amazing actress and actor
boils down to GRRM and his ability to create such captivating scenarios that push the limits of all characters. Although he did use Roose Bolton in the books, D&D def made the right choice with Tywin here.
@failtolawl D&D wrote this this scene wasn’t in the books
@@thamayor6324 that's what they're saying. 🙄
0:37 "I eat a lot."
I loved the way she said that... with her mouth full. So adorable.
@Chroch Its a good thing arya was always a wild child that acts like a commoner than a lady of a great house.
Looks like she is not little girl anymore. Shocked after tht awkard scene lol
Ha ha, she answers honestly as well, as if this is a topic that has gone through her head and around her family for years to the point where they just said "She ain't getting bigger no matter what we feed her."
When people claim Game of Thrones is well written .. this scene should be used as proof
da ra
Yes. The first few seasons. But s7+ has been lacking imo
Magnificent chemistry but it couldn't go on. Tywin would've figured out who she was, eventually.
halleck3 I have this fun little theory that Tywin knew this whole time, and was simply keeping her around for the fun of the interactions.
Tywin also said in this scene "I suppose you've been underfed your whole life.", maybe he wanted to get information out of her whether she was indeed underfed (therefore poor) or well fed (therefore of possible noble birth)
@@km-kl3lg exactly! Same when he asked what house her family served. He would've narrowed it down in the end.
I wouldn’t be surprised if he already figured it out but was waiting until he was going back to kings landing . If he said he knew then Arya would try to escape
@@joshuatree206 He definetely did not know she was a Stark, otherwise she'd be a hostage in an instant. He probably suspected her to be some minor nobility.
"You remind me of my daughter" was the closest thing to a compliment Cersei ever got from Tywin, and it wasn't even directed at her.
And on a real-world level you could see Charles Dance genuinely enjoying the conversation with Maisie Williams. An appreciation of her performance. That smile _wasn't_ acting.
it was acting though
Yes it was.
Wow....you can read minds through pre-recorded media?? ;)
@@marcw6875 No, but I can read _body language._ Notice his eyes. Most actors must engage in tense concentration to get the right nuance, and it shows in tension around the eye sockets. Dance's eyes show less tension, with relaxed focus. He's _observing_ her as much as responding to lines.
@@karlnemo8658 Dude, that's just acting.
This is by far their best change from the books!
Robert I Baratheon What happened in the books?
Arya served as Roose Bolton's cupbearer while in Harenhall
Jakob Kristensen Sandvik They barely speak. She interacts with Roose Bolton more than Tywin. She actually helps him take the castle in the books. She and Jaquen break out Robb's men from the dungeon with nothing but a cauldron of soup and a knife. It's badass.
Taylor Avalos robbs men?? so arya was in robbs hands in the books?
@@atiqaly6567 no but she was kept up to date from all the gossip going around
Tywin is fond of Arya, but he doesn’t suffer sentimentality. Some think he’s being kind by allowing Arya to eat, but in a scene before, the commander died from poisoning, so Tywin is using her to see if his food has been poisoned as well. It’s such a wonderful, subtle moment that shows that Tywin has the capacity for kindness, but his practicality and self-preservation are still his major priorities.
But also testing her by turning his back while she had sharp knife. Testing her mettle with dialog, testing her courage with the potentially poisoned food and testing her patience by leaving her with the knife.
That’s a great analysis. Never thought of that being the reasoning before.
Arya making tywin laugh with such a throwaway comment is actually one of my favourite moments in the whole show. Tywin wasnt half as evil as everyone makes him out to be. He just had the rotten luck of having a stupid father and spolit children. With nothing else to invest in, he simply did the best he could to secure the next generation.
Oh no, Tywin was absolutely ruthless and evil. But people are multi-faceted, and even cruel, manipulative, and ruthless people can have things they like, and people they care about, and things that bring them joy. That doesn't make them less evil, it just makes them not a one dimensional cartoon villain. Tywin is the *reason* his kids are the way they are. His neglect, pressure, and abuse made them into monsters in his own image.
He did order the rape and murder of a woman and her children. Probably one among many atrocities
“You’re too smart for your own good.”
It sounds like a straightforward line to conclude the conversation but there are layers to it. Tywin is a man who appreciates wisdom, as stated later on when he gives a lecture on its importance to a great king. At the same time, he is also very experienced. Wisdom grants the ability to derive more detailed and impactful lessons from experience. A combination of these traits during wartime can take a heavy toll on whomever possesses them. It’s perhaps not the best thing for a child to have… especially one who seems to be as inquisitive and impulsive as this girl whom he’s growing fond of.
Except that this scene is about intelligence, not wisdom
@@StuntcatTV Intelligence is the foundation of wisdom. If Arya demonstrates a high level of intelligence, she thus possesses a high capacity for wisdom. Someone like Tywin would definitely recognize that.
This is a top tier comment, of high-born understanding
Tywin is able to recognize that Arya is not only whip smart (dressing as a boy, speaking her mind, even lying about where she is from) but book smart (literate, knowledgeable about history, and speaking properly). The last three are only available to girls of a certain level of wealth and status. Tywin tries to trick her many times into Arya revealing herself as a Stark.
@@courtneywalmsley8284 yes re-watching that scene does make me wonder how much he knew.
"... And your children's children. "
Oh spare me the filthy details.
blah blah Thakur i don’t think people understood ur comment .. it’s gold 😂
Incest 😂
LMAOO
LOL Brilliantly put 🐉
Mark Kevin Dumlao- Incest is Wincest in Westeros.👀😂
The perfect villains are the likeable ones, the ones that you root for as much as the hero/heroine. This version of Tywin is perfect.
I mean you say that but Joffrey was also a perfect villan
@@Attackonmuffin he was just a villain. A perfect villain would have a vision and the bodies he buries will be for a cause. Jouffery was just a spoilt stupid brat.
He wasn't a villain.
@@andrewgalea5012 well he was a little shit and I hated him soo his actor did perfectly
@@mortalkombat2202 indeed, if a villain can make you say "well,he/she has got a point tho" thats perfect villain.
"You remind me of my daughter" What he really meant was "I wish my daughter had at least half a brain like yours".
Dear lord this scene is wonderful. Every single Arya/Tywin scene was so well written. Credit to Charles and Maisie as well. Absolutely perfect.
It's ma lord ....
This is a game of chess. He knows full well she is of noble birth, though not of which house. He was doing all he could to wear her down so she would slip up. But he enjoys the game as he liked to clash whits with someone with intelligence. She played well, but eventually, had she stayed any longer, he would have gotten the answer he wanted.
gutz1981 I like to think if he found out it would have saved Robb’s life, he would have traded her and Sansa back for Jaimie and peace in the kingdoms
No he wouldn't as he stated he want it to be his last war where he will be remembered he wanted that war for his legacy.
@@joeyfisher3838 Robb would never have agreed, which means Arya would just become a spare key to Winterfell as far as Tywin is concerned, just like Sansa.
“Wits”. Damn fool🧐
"if you're going to pose as a commoner you should do it properly"
Part of me really likes to think he knows who she is but doesn't say anything out of respect for her guile and general badassery... if only
I don't think he suspected her actual identity, Only that she is highborn. If he did know then she would definitely be taken hostage in a war against her brother.
If he really knew who arya was than he wouldn't keep up the charade for so long.
If he knew, he'd use her to win the war.
@@finnheisenheim8274 The charade between them entertains him in a way rarely he ever even had.
She might not even worth hostaging for the war if a
"Tywin Fucking Lannister" respects you
Yes but he knew she was a highborn northern girl... why couldn’t he use her against some of Robb’s allies? Why didn’t he still investigate about her ancestry?
I like Tywin's smile at the end, as if he was wishing she was one of his children.
"Do you know what a legacy is?"
Yes... it's planting seeds in a garden you never get to see.
And in this moment, Tywin wanted to adopt Arya.
That's a natural instinct. Arya's awesomeness has its own gravitational pull!
Only if Arya was born to Tywin, imagine the duo they'd become, with Tywin teaching her all he knew
Look up "A Wolf Amongst Lions" by Kallypso if you'd like to see that.
It is a fanfic that asks what would have happened if Tywin realized Arya was Arya. Tons more of their dynamic.. The story is well-written, well-planned, over 470K words, and, best of all, it has been completed!
I've lost two evenings reading this thing! Highly recommended!
@@silverblade357 *Thank you for admitting that you read it cause I didn't have the guts to say I read it too.*
Love the Arya and Tywin scenes. He shows a lot more warmth and affection to Arya than he does to Tyrion or Cersei.
One is a dwarf while the other fucks her own brother. Not to mention both of them have a drinking problem.
Lol you do realize that he was actually using Arya to see if someone was poisoning the food right?
@@XiyuYang shhhhhhhhh don't rain on his parade muhguy
You see, of one's kin one entertains 'expectations'. And THOSE are usually a damper on most relationships. He has no expectations of this servant girl. She piques his interest and constitutes a pleasant distraction from his duties and obligations. That is all. After which, her destiny is not on him.
@@finnheisenheim8274 bahahahahhahaha
After seeing tywin interaction with arya, i can't help but think that part of Tywin's bitterness towards his children was caused by the lack of "worthy" grandchildren. Joffrey was a spoiled lunatic, Myrcella begun to show some intelligence later, and tommen was a bit of a pushover. I think that the big old lion, could have secretly yearned for some grandchildren with whom he could spend some time with and mold them himself.
He goes into straight grandpa mode by telling stories.
@@alexakaa.charlesross8919 Exactly ! Like with Tommen.
This is my favorite Tywin scene in GOT. It proves Charles dance (actor for Tywin) right. He’s not a bad man, just a strong and intense character who does horrible things for the betterment of his family
he sentenced his son to death then slept with his girlfriend the night prior to the execution. all this while knowing tyrion was innocent and preaching about not allowing whores into the castle. oh, and lets not mention what he did to tyrions first wife. tywin is probably my fav character but lets not sanitize him
More like for his idea of family, some abstract legacy. He didn't really give a crap about his own children.
not to be pedantic, but doing terrible things for the betterment(read, financial/political gain) of your family makes you a bad man.
stealing a loaf of bread to feed your starving kids is one thing.
murdering thousands of people just for political gain is a completely different thing.
Isn't "doing horrible things for some reason X" basically what evil is?
Oh boy.
"But they're already here, MY LORD"
That's why I kinda suspected that she was the servant girl who served the pies to Walder Frey
Jerome Macainan wasn’t that obvious?
@@willcc19-18
r/wooosh
Cephyron this isn’t reddit smart guy.
I get your point but I think it could have been bad writing
:O
To all of you who find this cute or humanizing: you *do* realize that regardless of the dinner conversation, Tywin was mostly just using Arya as a taster in case the food was poisoned as well, right? Remember what immediately preceded this scene, and then remember how pragmatic Tywin is.
yes the show made him a little more human, but he still is Tywin Lannister.
He is a powerful man so it shouldn't be surprising that he valued his life more than a simple servant girl.He had to be cautious especially in that environment.
Tywin is a master of the dark triad.
It is still cute to see Arya interacting with Tywin. Itay not be humanizing of Tywin but it's still cute
Yep we know.
It's funny. At the end of this, he gently (at least by his standards) tells Arya "Go on." Whereas everyone else ever in the show he commands them "Go."
Subtle writing choices like that are what make it a great show, I can't wait to see the last few seasons!
Hahaha, good one.
I was going to say "this aged poorly" but then I saw what you did there. Well done.
Trust me you can wait… in fact take your time 😳
When I read this I thought it was 5 years old, RIP.
He alway gives orders to people, to arya he gave permission. Thus the difference.
Love how they’re supposed to be natural enemies and would give each other up in a heartbeat should the circumstances of been different yet admire like and unwittingly learn so much from each other. So many reasons why early thrones is a masterpiece
“You remind me of my Daughter.”
Is that an insult or a compliment?
Yes
@@confusedrealm7047 Hahahahahahahah!
She reminds him of the daughter he wished he'd had.
It's neither. Cersei hated being female. She wanted to have Jaime's life. Part of the reason she is so bitter is because she was forced into being what women were forced to be. I'm sure a similar exchange happened between her and Tywin many times when she was young.
We shouldn't hate Cersei so much. She serves as a reverse mirror to many characters. This is just one example. Arya got to live the life she wanted, Cersei didn't. There are many other instances that formed her to be the mean, resentful, hateful woman she is as an adults. She went through most of the same things the protagonists of this show suffered through but with a key difference. Cersei never had 'good' parents to guide her, only Tywin's ruthlessness was really taught. Not honor or kindness like the stark children. The stark children recieved many gifts to make them likable. She did not.
@@uwu-ul9mm Hate Cersei all you want, but she genuinely cares for her children. That's her one redeeming quality.
-Tyrion
I’d always wanted him to know who Arya really was before he died just to see the look on his face! A Stark, right under his nose and too clever to have gotten away with it too!
Vinicius Villela he absolutely wouldn’t have her executed. Otherwise he’d have had Sansa executed too. Having a live Stark was much more valuable than a dead Stark
And then right before he does he says, "I knew who she is and where she came from all along. If only I could ha hav.... (Dead)
I think regardless he would be proud of her and not kill her. To him, she was much what he wanted in a girl
What I found most interesting is the fact that they both found some sort of safety in each other's company. Arya is telling the stories of the Targaryans with a child like wonder. You don't see much of that at all after Ned is killed. But she felt safe to be a child with Tywin. She knew he wouldn't hurt her from the second he saved her from one of his guards. And though Tywin knew she wasn't who she said she was, he was enough steps ahead of her to not worry about it too much. He really liked her, and gave her a side of him he gave no one else in the show. It was like it was the only place for both of them to drop their defenses and just be human again for a bit.
This will always be one of my favorite scenes in the entire series. It's a delight how Arya showed her wits against Tywin. Tywin has this "proud dad look" when Arya retells the story of the Targaryens
"I eat a lot, I just dont grow" only honest line Arya ever told Tywin 😅🤣🤣🤣
Tywin has a fondness and admiration for Arya to the point where he won’t bust her for obviously having an agenda. Tywin is not fooled for a moment, even after her clever cover of why she speaks proper (properly!) He knows she’s high born and undercover for some reason, but doesn’t feel threatened and so enjoys his time with her, with no intention of outing her.
I don't think he thinks she's undercover, he figured out she was posing as a boy for safety reasons earlier, he's making the same assumption again, that she is posing as a commoner, because if it became known that she's "high born" someone might think of using her for a ransom. He respects her thinking, he doesn't think she has a nefarious reason for hiding who she is, just that situations have happened, and that she is doing what she needs to do to survive.
The good thing about this scene is that it really establishes that there are noble houses beyond the major ones, something that you see with Robb Starks eventual wife and Brienne. (and played upon much later in the series)
Love their chemistry. Tywin was able to catch some of her lies throughout their time together and I believe despite being enemies, they could’ve been friends
Tywin's smile at the end: i love that kid. And then he's quickly reminded that he has 3 dissappointing children. After that sip of water
Tywin smile at the end of the scene... Tells you he enjoys his conversations with Arya... "all the fun with none of the consequences...
It looked like he was as warm with Tommen. It's just the tragedy of Tywin that if he had worked as hard raising his children and grandchildren as he did "preparing their legacy", things would have worked out better for everyone.
3:53 oh... that priceless 'I got you now' smile
Tywin to arya : Eat girl !
Cersei to sansa : Drink girl !
Gods, Their dialogues were perfect !
One of the reasons I loved the middle seasons of this series. So many great conversations like this.
"You are too smart for your own good, has anyone told you that?" He knows she just pulled that out of thin air but its such a good lie, he is just going to play along with it. Love this whole scene!!
"I eat a lot. I just dont grow. " i love that pretty little killer
The dialogue is so strong its litterally giving me chills. The hinting towards the most spectacular battles of Westeros centuries before
That moment at 4:34 between Arya and Tywin is incredible. So much is communicated in those few seconds and words, great chemistry between these two characters.
The most interesting thing is.. Lord Tywin knows there is more to her. He knows she's lying, and he knows she is not who she says she is. And yet he sees something in her that he likes. Something more natural than what Cersei wanted to be, something more clever, as well as something more sinister. He knew she likely had more nefarious plans than what she was posing as. He instead tested how well she played the game, and liked how she played it. Considering the darkness inside of Arya, she was likely the closest to the things Tywin wanted in his off-spring, almost like the daughter he *wished* Cersei had been.
Scenes like this between the two of them really do capture that feeling, he knows she's lying from the get go, and calls her out/teaches her about her mistakes, which would serve her later. I'm guessing he feels, whomever she is, she will go on to do other things when she's done pretending there, but was not a threat to him, so he actually enjoyed the company of a child he likely very much wished his own children had started out being.
These scenes are masterful in their execution of it. That was actually a *proud* smile from Tywin at the end. He probably didn't have very many when it came to his own, but he did for Arya, and that says a lot about why he liked conversing with her so, even when he knew she was not who she said she was.
That smile he gives at the end it's almost as if he'd wished his other children had been *what* she already is back when he was raising them. Both Jaimie and Cersei's weaknesses(Ambition for Jaime and Wit for Cersei) are Arya's strengths and he saw that in her. In many ways, Arya is the child he wished for, but never got.
Well reasoned! Honestly, the Tywin and Arya scene are probably my favorites from the whole series. There's so menace about half an inch away, and yet on top of that they're witty and seem to regard each other with both respect and affection. The dynamic is *delicious*.
LOL Tywin would despise Arya as his daughter. Just look how he treats Cersei when she refuses to marry, or Jaime because he cannot.
The fact that he held for so long that he already knew what she was and only told her when she got cocky to remind her to watch her steps was a beautiful father daughter moment.
When she says, "from my father"......man. I didn't know three small words could be so powerful. Maisie was an incredible actress for the first 3 seasons specifically
It’s insane that Tywin is fully aware that she is lying and does nothing. It’s almost as if he’s aware of his role in the story and knows that even though he will be who he must for the narrative, he knows the story isn’t about him
This is one of my favorite scenes from either character, the show's creators made an excellent choice in deviating from the books to add these little compassionate gestures from Tywin Lannister.
0:00-0:35 is like every damn grandparent lmaoo
Sit! Eat.
Now I see why Maisie loved acting with Charles so much. This is pure gold to watch.
Bloody hell this show was such a masterpiece! how in the 7 kingdoms did they fuck this up so spectacularly?!
Honestly I miss these types of scenes so much. Tywin always had the best exchanges 😭😭😭
We are lucky he died before the writing died, poor Tyrion didnt have that luck
4:46 'Gooooood why couldn't ONE of my kids be like her?!?!'
There is one, but he hates him
Their chemistry was just A+...
Charles Dance is a magnificent actor
tywin never smiles...look at him at the end of the scene =)
Tywin Lannisters part was played so well and with such class. Ultimate presentation of an proper Aristocrat.
This was one of my favorite scenes from the show, and one of the reasons why, even though he is definitely one of the villains of the series, Tywin is also one of my favorite characters. You see him try to teach his children this as well, but Tywin is never needlessly cruel or arrogant or domineering. Cersie throws her power around just for the sake of reminding everyone how strong she is. Tyrion is brilliant, but his defense mechanisms also make him overconfident and obnoxious to people sometimes. Tywin understands that even your enemies deserve at least enough respect to take them seriously.
I always loved this scene because it shows that he is insightful and perceptive. He knows there's something different about Arya, but it's clear he's not interested in finding out what it is. As long as she behaves, he's content to let her keep up her little ruse. And you can see his appreciation for her game after she leaves the room.
Love the way tywin grins at the end. You can tell he has a fondness of arya.
This scene here actually makes me think.. Was tywin really an evil person or just someone who would go to any extent for his family (like everyone else on this show)
Tywin was never evil. Ruthless but not evil. Same cannot be said for Cersei and Joff.
@@MrYouarethecancer bruh idk ab that; cersei and joffrey are cruel
Tywin only goal was to further the Lannister name
Remember that after all this he left her at Harrenhall to serve The Mountain - knowing how cruel he is.
Is everyone forgetting how Tywin sicced the Mountain and Co on Princess Elia (raping/murdering her), Rhaenys (being stabbed 50 times) and baby Aegon (head smashed against the wall)? You might not say that's evil because it had to be done, but I'd disagree.
When people claim Game of Thrones is well written .. this scene should be used as proof
Yes but RR Martin has no part in season 8, no build up or anything all because he is still writing the book.
YoungV Sinatra24 This scene never happened in the books though.
It was, anyways. The newer seasons are half Michael Bay, half soap opera.
Was
da ra hell no i we want dragons and zombies fuck this slow pace novela
I love Tywin’s subtle little gesture right after the “taught us how to speak proper- properly!” in 4:31.
You can tell he’s got her game figured out, but he’s fond of her enough to be amused when she quickly thinks up a way to get herself out of the pinch. Tywin respects a resourceful person who’s quick of feet and mind. It’s a shame his flaw is caring about the Lannister’s name and legacy so much, otherwise he’d have been an amazing statesman, military commander AND father (he already is the first three).
Also, Charles Dance’s interpretation is absolutely stellar.
The Dialogue keeps me coming back. Simply superb! ✊🏿👏🏿👏🏿👏🏿
also arya is adorable in this "I eat a lot, I just don't grow"
I love how layered this scene is. He's a clever man but clearly has no interest in female warrior, particularly Dragon Riding Queens- which is why Dany was able to grow so much in power while he was about.
Nah, he's checking to see how educated she is.
Gods be good, this scene is amazing. It's incredible the chemistry that Dance and Williams are able to conjure despite their vast age / experience difference. Tywin seems genuinely fascinated by Arya. It's wonderful.
3:37. The slight increase in pitch and the tiny crack in voice when she says 'My father...' is so amazing. She still can't believe her father is dead
I cant help but imagine that these 2 would have had an incredible arc together. Arya could have learned so much from Tywin about strategy and war. I really wish they had found a way to make this duo have a bigger story.
Tyrion is not a fool. I think they carried it as far as they could without making it too unbelievable.
It was this scene where I really started to like Tywin. He's harsh and cold on the outside, but has a big heart for kids.
Except for his own son, Tyrion
I really love their relationship, some of the best written characters in the show. And they play off of one another really well.
I honestly love seeing these two together. He immediately caught on that she's a high born girl posing as a commoner but instead of having her head or prying what her real house is, he simply enjoys sparring with her through words. Meanwhile, she's learning how to navigate in a situation like this while also learning a few tricks from Tywin because he is guiding her and teaching her how to think through strategies and act as a commoner, a role he only has observed from afar but well enough to help her better her acting. The fact that she could be clever back is a whole other thing tho haha
These Arya Tywin and Arya Sandor scenes are the best of the whole show. Just perfect
I love how he clearly knows who she is but enjoys her company so much he doesn't even care
Honestly I feel like this is one of the best scenes in the series. It shows a different side to Tywin and gives you sympathy towards his life and his goals. It showed how names determine your allies and enemies, not ones person.
I have never seen him smile throughout the whole show except with Arya
When she answers "From my father..."
You could feel the emotions of her mentioning her father...
Tywin is the essence of what a good lord, and man by extension, should ve. Strong and fearful when necessary, but respected, honest in what he says and means to do, and empathetic when it is properly called for. Those who end up meeting him know right off that this is someone who isn't to be trifled with casually, but also someone who if presented with diligence will be met with friendship/assistance.
man these Arya and Tywin scenes bring a smile to my face, the acting and writting was so good back then.
I actually like this.,.. he was kind to her... a bit of compassion.
He had no idea that the girl who served to him is the most dangerous woman we've ever seen..
Tywin's thinking "Fuck, if only my daughter had that many brains."
I could watch a show of just Tywin and Aria as his cupbearer
That is the most genuine smile from Tywin that I ever seen in the end
I cannot imagine how daunting it would be to have a scene with the legendary Charles Dance, but my god Maisie just absolutely nails this scene. Incredible acting all around. These interactions between Tywin and Arya are my favorite in the entire series