Can you guess the Beatles song from the final chord?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 19 чер 2024
- Check out my other Beatles guess the song quizes: • Challenge videos 🎼
This video was edited by David Hartley. Check out his UA-cam channel here: / davidhartley94
And, an extra special thanks goes to Peter Keller, Douglas Lind, Vidad Flowers, Ivan Pang, Waylon Fairbanks, Jon Dye, Austin Russell, Christopher Ryan, Toot & Paul Peijzel, the channel’s Patreon saints! 😇
SUPPORT ME ON PATREON: / davidbennettpiano 🎹
0:00 Introduction
0:32 Song 1
1:10 Song 2
1:59 Song 3
2:54 Song 4
3:41 Song 5
4:36 Song 6
5:06 Song 7
5:25 Song 8
6:20 Song 9
7:21 Song 10
8:30 Song 11
9:05 Song 12
9:40 Song 13
10:27 Song 14
11:05 Song 15
11:42 Final score!
12:22 Patreon
I was feeling confident after I knew "In My Life" immediately. But it was all downhill from there. I got "Oh Darling," and that was it.
Heh....same. On the first one I was like, HA! Obvious...somehow. In My LIfe, easy.
At the end I got 4 right. And it wasn't easy.
I'd give David an 8 rather than 6....because his first guess was right on two....and even the things he got wrong, he got wrong for good reasons. This was TOUGH!
Two here as well. Got With a little help from my friends because of the harmonies, which are even more cemented in my mind because Noel Gallagher put them in Oasis' She's Electric.
exactly my experience 😆😆
I saw this comment right after hearing the first clip and correctly guessing in my life. I was also feeling good, then I see this, and I’m like “uh oh”
**update: I got 2/15. Boy howdy, it was all downhill from there 😅
Hahaha me too
If that last chord takes up almost the entire piano and lasts for what feels like several minutes, then I think it might be A Day in the Life. Otherwise it might be harder
No one like this comment. Ik that’s immature but it feels… better at 69
Well stated
Exactly same here. A couple of them even ended on an E chord. With Nowhere Man , and Day in the life end on. This was a tough one …
@docsigma. You don't say!
Lol
I got 8. In almost every song I started singing the next song in the album trying to remember the song before it 😂
Ooooo that’s clever!! Wish I’d thought of that 😅
That's how I got _Oh Darling!_ _Octopus's Garden_ started right up in my mind's ear.
That's so funny. I was thinking it was Octopus's Garden, but this is probably why.
that's an amazing strategy.
@@grant50 Same here! That also helped me confirm a few of the guesses for which I was otherwise unsure.
12/15. I thought Nowhere Man was Don’t Let Me Down, I thought I’ve Got a Feeling was Dig a Pony, and I thought Rocky Raccoon was “Errrrr… something from the White Album??”.
Same with the first 2 songs! With Rocky Raccoon I iniially thought it might be Don't Pass Me By, bu then I remembered it ends with that weird fading out violin solo.
should make an episode on Beatles places around England on Map map men men show!
Yeah I thought Nowhere Man was Don't Let Me Down as well.
Nowhere man man man man
@@user-vz2mc5qt1e what would it even be? "we're the men and heres the map and this is liverpool sponsored by skillshare"
This was a lot harder than I thought it was gonna be after #1 !!
yeah, thought i'd ace this, am ashamed. i figure most of us are way better at beginnings than ends.
I have a Beatles Challenge for you: from only a short snippet of each song, guess whether it's The Beatles or The Rutles.
Great idea!
That’s a great Idea! Even just Beatles or not from a short clip
@@AndrewWatsonChangingWay I've been having a ball lately enjoying the extended Rutle catalogue recently uploaded by @Rutlemania. It's been a really accessible way to enjoy the music of he Rutle member's non-Rutle catalogues, which previously I've found a bit hard to get into.
But it's also reignited my Beatles enthusiasm and made me try to tackle the Beatle solo work which can be pretty daunting. "It's all part of the soup" as George said.
@@mikemakesmusic7 definitely, there's certainly a lot of Beatlesque stuff out there.
If it's still too easy the Beatles category could also include solo projects, that's a challenge.
’If I Fell’ and ’With a Girl Like You’ are almost identical!
As a Beatles fan for 59 years I must say this was difficult but I got 11 out of 15.
Very well done! I've been a fan ever since 1962 - and I got a (very) measly 3. 😞
I've also been a Beatles fan for 59 years, and I only got 2. So it takes much more than that -- congratulations!
Beat ya, I got two.
Respect!
Well that’s impressive - I’ve been a fan for forty years - and I’m very good at the initial chord recognitions - but this one destroyed me. Argh.
I got "Oh! Darling" right away because my brain was anticipating the opening lick of "Octopus's Garden" right afterward.
Same haha
Same I've played that album too much
beyondobscure you can never listen to that album too much
I used to use a cheaper record player (up to an AT-LP60 now, getting a 120 for Christmas) and I played Abbey Road and Miles Davis' Kind Of Blue so much that they were unlistenably noisy.@@matthewbartlett3442 I have since bought another copy of Abbey Road.
Same for me
It's amazing how many of these outros are unique in some way. Lots of the details I never really noticed before. Whether it's Ringo playing some strange drum fill or someone plucking an arpeggio on the strings of a piano. It really shows you how the Beatles were really overflowing with creative ideas, stuffing every moment of their songs with something interesting.
Absolutely. There is so much exploratory texture just in these 2 second passages.
This was, at least for me, by far the hardest of these. I did alright, not great, on the others, but I barely got any on this. I love that you're doing these.
The drum one was impossible for me… but this one wasn’t much easier!
This was really hard! Props to whoever managed this!
This was definitely the hardest quiz you've done, I only got 4/15
14/15. I guessed The End instead of Something. Listening back to both of them, they do have a pretty similar ending, which I never realized before. As people are pointing out, the strategy of imagining what song comes next was pretty helpful.
I guessed The End for a different one. I got Something because I had just heard the isolated strings on The Beatles channel this very day!
I said the same thing! We both must have a good ear because they both end on a C chord
@@c00l0 Nice. Even after all these David Bennett videos my theory knowledge is almost zero. I couldn't tell you what chord it was, just that they were the same lol. So it's cool to know, I can just remember one of these tunes to identify a C chord now.
Same here I thought it was The End . In fact I was positive. Turned out I was positively wrong …
I guessed the End on that one too. Felt good that it was at least another Abbey Road song.
10/15
1. Instantly recognizable
2. Thought it was strawberry fields because that song also has a ridiculous ending
3. Thought this was the beginning to "She came in through..." so I guessed Polythene Pam but I really should've known it
4. Haven't listened to this one enough, I guessed She's Leaving Home
5. Took a while but got it because of the distinct vocal part
6. That french horn is iconic to me
7. nearly impossible to miss
8. Got it because of Ringo's drum fill
9. So sad about this one. I thought it was The End when it all slows down and swells up with the orchestra
10. Got this one quickly, one of my favorite Beatles songs
11. Ashamed to say haven't listened to the white album in full including this song so I guessed Love me do
12. Always recognize that chord because it feels cut off weirdly early
13. love that dissonant organ sound, instantly recognizable
14. Thank you!
15. the vocal harmonies in this song are perfection, Beatles really know how to "ooh"
Why do you bother with a Beatles quiz when you haven't listened to the White Album yet???
it really goes to show how great the George & the lads’ arranging skills were…organs and strings sneak in throughout the song in such an organic and subtle way that when you just hear the last chord it’s surprising
George Martin.
I also lost count of my score as I was doing so poorly: 7/15. I started hearing the "next song" in my mind, and this helped me get a few of them (as we all know the album sequencing so well). Also interesting how you could sometimes know the album sound production. I immediately knew the "rooftop" sound but guessed the wrong song! Also discerned the Sgt. Pepper sound and guessed the wrong song. Great video/quiz. Please keep them coming.
That's the album version of Penny Lane. They deleted 7 piccolo trumpet notes from the end, which has always bothered me. When I first heard the song as a single, it had a 7 note coda so this Penny Lane ending always sounded to me as though it were unfinished.
I always find myself humming the missing "Daa-daa-dudududu-daaah" at the end :)
Exactly. My older cousing had the Canadian single promo way back in '67 and that was the only one I'd heard for a week or 2.
So that's why I didn't guess that one. (Now I only need an explanation for the other 13.)
I knew I heard that version before somewhere, thanks for unlocking that memory
I also feel that once you've heard the "original" the standard version sounds unfinished. I have the Rarities version on my playlist for that reason.
Tough but so enjoyable! Many thanks David and I always enjoy.
David, I really, really, enjoy your videos. You're so knowledgeable, and I just really appreciate you and your channel. Long live Paul, and Ringo!
LOL, quite knowledgeable, 6/15! 😀
One of my favorite final chords from their earlier albums is the final chord in Any Time at All. The sudden change in guitar tone for the one chord makes it feel really punchy and I love it for that.
If you haven't been giving much love to their early work, please do so. They aren't as groundbreaking or high-fidelity as their later work, but it has their most energetic and rocking songs they've ever put to tape, especially their covers.
Dude - that was one hell of a difficult quiz! Thanks so much for coming up with this very creative idea! I got 6 (I think)
That was quite a difficult one, but I think there are a few things that really help if you know the songs well: The length of the chord, the key of the chord, what instruments were there, and anything that might come at that very end of the clip, such as the A major chord at the end of Oh Darling. I got full marks on this one. Probably didn't help that I've been enjoying The Beatles' music so much that I probably know all of their albums a bit too well by now...
When you say " the key of the chord", I take it you mean that you mean the *type* of the chord (Major, Minor) and not whether it is A Major or F Major. Because nobody could possibly know that unless they have perfect pitch.
@@Better_Call_Raul I did actually mean key, like A major or B major. I don't think you, need, perfect pitch to know what chord you might be ending on, I thought relative pitch helps here. So if you know what a C is, you can then work from that to know what chord you're hearing. Although, I do have perfect pitch, so don't quote me on this...
@@tobiasheath529 You are wrong. You are blessed with perfect pitch. The ordinary listener who has trained his *relative pitch* can only make out whether that ending chord is a Major7 or Minor7 or Dominant7 or whatever.
e.g., He could identify that the ending chord was a Major7 chord (Root, Third, Fifth, Seventh).
*But he would have absolutely no idea whether it is a CMajor7 or DMajor7!* That is the critical point I am making. No clue.
The listener with perfect pitch, OTOH, would know the key and *ALSO* know that it was a CMajor7 and not DMajor7. That could possibly help him identify the song,
I can only dream of perfect pitch. If I was blessed with perfect pitch, I could easily memorize the key of each of the Beatles songs (I've already listened to them a million times). Upon hearing the ending chord, I would reverse engineer and narrow down the song.
This was my intro to your channel. Puzzling, but very enjoyably enertaining. Cool! Thank you.
Listening albums all the way thru definitely helped me with this one! I got Rocky Raccoon because the transition to Don't Pass Me By is very distinct for me. But yeah, this was tough as hell
Same here. I could instantly guess the album but found it difficult to guess the actual song
It was almost like I've never heard a Beatles song. That was hard.
gets Song 1 right away: "yesss"
proceeds to get every other one wrong: "nooo"
(I did get Song 14 though -- "ahh")
I was absolutely convinced that #3 was Don't Let Me Down, even after hearing you say "it's obviously a middle period song." Turns out Don't Let Me Down and Nowhere Man are in the same key and the last chords actually do sound fairly similar.
Wow! Tough challenge! I'm a lifelong Beatles fan and still got only about 5 of those. And some of my misses were pretty embarrassing!
BTW, I was wondering about that marvelous theme playing for the credits on your channel and found out that it was you! I've been listening on repeat on Spotify! Fantastic stuff, man
It's cute how David reacts every time he guessed it right, like he'd just escaped a serious danger by a hair's breadth😊
Anyways, you're doing a great job with your videos, David!
I have learnt a lot and your skills and sense for music are amazing😍
(Pardon my English pls)
I blew it!! 3 out of 15 (1, 6 & 7)! I agreed with most of the things you said (before you said them!) so where you were wrong, so was I. On #10, I said "Octopus's Garden", which was the track after the correct answer - so I claim half a point as a consolation! 🙂 Anyway, that was fun! Thank you, David.
This was a real tough one. Loved it.
That was very hard indeed. Most of the ones I actually got, I got by knowing what the next song on the album was and then figuring it out from there.
I managed to get 12 out of 15. These songs are so familiar to me, they're like hearing a friends voice on the phone, I only need to hear one word to recognize them.
Maybe I'm amazed!!
my 10 (ten) yr old son did it in 13 out of 15 ... And he took less than 3 sec in almost every song. In a 14th song he guessed it instantly right ('I got a feeling'), but then he switched to 'Dig a pony' ... He failed 'Rocky Rackoon'.
This was sooooo much fun!!!! More please!!!!
I found this very difficult. Only managed 4/15. Love these quizzes. Going to share it and see if my mates can do better 😄.
It's not that difficult, people just don't pay attention enough.
And today they don't listen to whole songs anymore AT ALL.
@@gutgolf74 👍
I know there’s gonna be the day in the life ending chord coming up…
I was wrong
heya! as soon as I heard the first one I knew it had to be that wonderful song! thanx for these great videos. They really pay great hommage to that awesome band.
I got a couple...no more. I LOVE the fact that people who are so many decades younger than me listen to and love these songs so much that they recognise the final chords.
I'm nearly 63, but I have a shed-load of much older sisters, hence I was a Beatles fan from being a toddler. There is a reel to reel of me and my twin brother singing 'She Loves You' but we are so young we miss off the final 'Yeah'.
It would be awesome if you could make some content where you breakdown Todd Rundgren's compositions. His material is simply outstanding, definitely one the greatest songwriters ever
Blue Rooster is so good
I'd love to see a breakdown of A Dream Goes On Forever 🎻
I'd like Paul McCartney to take this test.
I’ve been listening Beatles songs for more than 40 years now continuously and though I know all songs I couldn’t guess any of the songs except Yesterday.
It’s really hard because you have to rewind the song in your mind to recognise it and that doesn’t work for me 😅
Well done!!
9/15
Missing I’ve Got a Feeling really hurts! I knew it was the rooftop!
Me too, It's literally my joint favorite song along with Don't let me down and has been for twenty odd years and I knew that I knew it, my mind just kept going to dig a pony for some rerason, Gutted! I did pretty well overall though!
hi, i don't know if you did this on purpose or not, but this video is unlisted and can only be watched by going into the playlist (that's why it has only 26 views right now). i just thought i would comment incase this wasn't intentional to let you know
No worries, this video is unlisted currently because it’s not due for release yet. But thanks for letting me know 😊
@@DavidBennettPiano oh okay
This is a good one! And it’s the opposite for me: I’m finding this comparatively easy.
Ironically, for #2, I remembered that ending chord as *_leading into_* Penny Lane rather than from Penny Lane itself!
Same thing for #10, except this time I was right: I said “the song before Octopuses Garden”!
There's an alternate version of Penny Lane that has an additional trumpet solo at the end. Perhaps you're thinking of that? That was played on the radio back then
@@robmarshall9026, interesting thought! I pretty much have only listened to the (US) album version.
i love these guessing beatles videos!
Dear David, Love your Beatles stuff. As to another quiz, what about word(s) - no music - in a song (unusual for a song) Example: "trivialities" in WHEN I GET HOME; "plasticine" in LSD, etc.
Fun stuff. I didn't do any better David, I could narrow it down to the album but missed a lot of the exact song.
This was rough, partly because I could sing the song, but not recall the title.
Great concept. Live it!
Geez I got a handful at the start and then got blown away, well done with your 6 !!
Got em all somehow, the songs and each little piece of the mix of all of em are firmly etched in my head
Very nice quiz! Loved it.
As a Beatles fan of 47 years, I got 12/15. I missed Nowhere Man (I guessed Don’t Let Me Down), Something (My guess was The End), and Rocky Racoon (I guessed Don’t Pass Me By). This was a challenging one!
12 out of 15. It was the hardest quiz of your channel, but very interesting!! My mistakes were I've got a Feeling, Rocky Racoon, and I Me Mine.
You did 1 better than me, but i recognized Rocky Racoon & I Me Mine straight away.
14 out of 15 for this little guy! Just missed With a Little Help from My Friends. Fun video!
Dare to correct. I've got approximately 13 correct. Because I was wrong in right of the middle of Flying. That wasn't. The rest of it didn't know. Thankfully in David's game rescued me with his tongue. Spectacular edition !
David..dont give yourself such a hard time...watching your thought process is what i watch these videos for..btw i only got 4
I really enjoy these, and thought I was going to ace this one as I got the first 3 instantly. But I fell apart after that.
A note: the end of Oh! Darling isn’t guitar ‘effects’ per se; it’s actually the six strings of an Epiphone Casino played between the bridge and the tailpiece.
I haven’t listened to any Beatles music for decades.
I got the first one right away. I didn’t get any others and some of them I had never heard of.
I love this.
I still play the beadle every day.
I got 3, and a lot of these were my favorite Beatles songs. Crazy how hard this was for me.
I was 10 or 11 out of 15 (i lost track too). I missed "I Me Mine" but i KNEW it was a George song immediately--the organ gave it away, but I'd guessed Blue Jay Way. This was an AWEsome challenge tho--and i was shouting along (thinking out loud) as you sounded out your process and i had a few 'jinx' moments during the thought-tracing, so that was fun!
My first husband used to put my cds at random into the carousel and quiz me on first-second blips on any one of my hundreds of cds, just for his own amusement i think. There are tracks you even know sometimes, simply from the background/ambient noise, tape hiss, or the audience applause if you embrace your autism rigorously enough. The Ex and i are still friends, and he still calls me the human jukebox, which i'll gleefully take as a compliment. It makes me think those thousands of hours i spent locked away listening to music as a kid weren't entirely wasted if i at least have 'entertainment' value. :)
I got them all except for one
No, seriously, I only got In My Life and Yesterday - but I was so willing you on to do well. It’s so fun to watch you take it so seriously.
I love this channel ❤
Amazing video as always! I did 10/15 not bad at all but it was really difficult.
Such an interesting test! It's pretty easy to identify even the first note of each Beatles song, but this is truly big challenge!
Even if you got only 1 I would have been impressed. You probably did better than 99% of Beatles fans.
Only got two! Need to listen to their albums again, haha.
Great content as usual! I'd just add a longer section of the end of the song after the guess, because even after revealed I couldn't associate it.😅
10/15. Remembering the song's key here and there was helpful to me.
I didn't do too well on this one. Fun to play though. Thank you for this.
I'd love it in future quizzes if you played them with a few seconds more context after the answer is revealed!
Finally! I got a perfect score on one these quizzes.
Thanks for using my suggestion!!! I got 14/15
Damn dude, this was incredibly impressive even just to get a few. I'd consider myself pretty well versed in the Beatles catalogue, but this task is not easy at all. Much harder than the intros.
Super hard! I felt like I was waking up from a dream I could almost remember, but it kept slipping into other dreams and thoughts before I could. By sheer chance, I got maybe 2 or 3 correct. Humbling.
That was SO much fun!! i played along, paused and rewound a little bit so that was interactive and your commentary was good.
if anyone cares, i got
10 right
2 wrong (Nowhere Man and Something. I thought they were an older Beatles song and The End respectively)
this was truly the hardest one of these yet.
I only had 4. Oh Darling as the only one you didn't, as it's been on rotation lately.
Surely far easier for people who listened to these as an album rather than singles. For them, the end of each song flows right to the next.
Maybe some people... I did grow up listening to them as albums but it’s been a long time and I don’t have a great memory.
Yep. Octopus’ Garden started in my head after the Oh! Darling clip.
100% easily in this. I always pick songs at concerts long before the audience. Maybe it’s a sign I should play more music.
Okay, as a long-time avid Beatles fan, I guessed the first one and skipped over my first choice, which was the correct choice of the second song, I gave up midway through. This is tough! Hey! I continued and guessed I Saw Her Standing There! Considering the difficulty, you did very well, David!
6 of 15 as well. That was difficult. And I've been a die hard Beatles fan since hearing them on radio in 1963.
Such a hard exercise! WOW!
You are amazing, very difficult
i got 2. by far the hardest of these Beatles quizzes.
This was harder than I thought...10/15...the revolver songs got me, and I got a feeling I thought was one after 909....this was actually challenging for a die hard fan....
My Google Pixel was listening and successfully identifying some of these. Impressive! And did better than me!
As soon as I started thinking in terms of what plays next on an album I was able to guess without an issue. Had to go back to the pre-iPhone memory for this one!
3/15!!! And I've listened to The Beatles pretty much all my life... This was really difficult! Although a lot of these weren't my favourite songs so that might've played a part.
Haha. This really shines a light on the fact that I rarely listen to the full length of songs. I skip to the next one in the outros
I got the first one, In My Life, immediately and thought this is a piece of cake.
I then proceeded to get all the other 14 wrong.
This one was difficult. I usually Get them all right. I thought A Day In The Life would come here. Please make more. So fun to guess. The drum only was also difficult.
I should be sent to the corner. I've listened to every Beatles album, single and track since they were released and my score was pitiful. 5 out of 15. The one I got the fastest was Ob-La-Di-Ob-La-Da. And the one I should have definitely got but failed miserably was Rocky Raccoon. Thanks for the contest. 😀
Only five.. But I recognized "Oh, Darling" and "I've got a feeling". Very hard quizz. Thanks.
I was a whopping 3 for 15! 😂 Pretty pathetic for a 70yo lifelong Beatles fan, but that was both humbling and a lot of fun! Thanks for your great work, David!
I got 5 out of 15. I'm quite pleased with that!
Well David, as a lifetime Beatles fan i do find these difficult - & you generally beat me by 1 or 2. This one i found a little bit easier. I got 11 out of 15.
Hardest Beatles quiz ever! I got 8 of 15 and I’ve listened to these songs almost every day of the last 57 years!
Definitely the hardest quiz you did so far. I think I got 7/15, but I was thinking completely along your lines and almost had the same wrong guesses as you each time
This was hard! I got 2 and knew at least what album it was on like 5 or 6, and the most embracing part is, that this selection contained like 8 or 9 of my all time favorites, I didn't et a single one of them.