Settling Ace Attorney's Greatest Debate
Вставка
- Опубліковано 3 жов 2024
- The Ladder vs. Stepladder debate is one of the most iconic memes to come out of Ace Attorney, but is it really as much of a stalemate as its 20-year history suggests?
Thanks to @8edhead for voicing Maya! And to SibilantSerpent for providing voice direction!
My Patreon:
/ mornal
Paula’s Patreon:
/ paulaperoff
Art Credits:
/ 1127986530687963147
ricadiazarts.t...
sha-je.tumblr....
/ the_battle_of_the_century (Apparently it was deleted between me finding it and the video’s completion, so this is a mirror)
/ ccx0w3arprr
ticcytx.tumblr...
nimpnawakprodu...
(Also, a note: The decision to touch on social issues in this video was made out of what I felt was a legitimate connection to the larger topic. I stand by this decision, but in case you're worried this is gonna become a stealth politics channel or something just know I don't plan to touch on similar issues in future videos of this style without an equally compelling reason.)
--
Carrd: mornal.carrd.co
Mornal Productions ain't your normal productions! This channel specializes in funny animated sketches and voice acting, based on game series ranging from the Ace Attorney franchise to Undertale and Deltarune. All sorts of comic dubs, comedy animations (made either by me in 3D or in collaboration with Paula Peroff), parodies, and impressions are here to see. Hope you enjoy!
![The Eternal Shipping Wars of Ace Attorney [Objection.lol]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/hWId_HHQgSk/mqdefault.jpg)
What do you think? Is Phoenix right, or is Maya? Did my argument change your opinion at all?
(And happy belated TDoR 😊)
I seriously had to get up and walk around the room with how much you blew my mind hearing Phoenix say “That’s a trans woman”.
You made a fair argument. Did change my opinion. One thing I will say is that I grew up with a mindset of having being clear and accurate when talking about something. I also often try to correct people when unnecessary (and sometimes I will be wrong and admit it). I'm just wired to be have things be more accurately defined. So while I will say Maya is correct, I still side with Phoenix. I just to have my facts straight.
I think your character is cute
I’d argue Phoenix is still right, as whenever this argument is brought up, the question “What’s the difference?” pops up. This implies that whoever is arguing that it’s a ladder believes it to be something other than a stepladder. Otherwise, they’d have likely said something like “So? Isn’t it still a ladder?” Thus, when they say ladder, they are likely referring to something like a rung ladder, rather than the umbrella term mentioned in the video.
…I should probably be doing my physics homework.
I was on team Phoenix for all of my life, and now I'm on team Maya for life.
Here's my two cents: Wright was right to correct her because in legal matters it's important to be as specific as possible. For example: lets say someone is accused of hiding a body in a hole in the ceiling in the center of a room that is 4 meters tall using a 3.5 meter tall ladder. The defendant would call this into question because a ladder shorter than the ceiling would not be able to support itself, but a step ladder would
That actually makes sense, as a Lawyer of course he’s prone to being as specific as possible. It’s his job after all, and many cases hinge on this logic and way of thinking.
Makes sense actually.
VERY fair point. A lawyer would be keen to specific details like that, regardless of correcting Maya out of instinct of his profession OR an urge to seem more intelligent than her in that moment.
Aw so he wasn't being rude. He was just being logical and not thinking about how it could be misinterpreted
On the other hand - the potential of a 3.5 meter tall ladder not being able to support itself gives a potential opening for the ladder not being grounded, but being supported above, in the hole in the ceiling. Or simply that it was in the hole in the ceiling and dropped down to make it seem like someone climbed up to get to the hole in the ceiling...
...Whereas the culprit instead simply dropped the ladder down the hole after the murder to throw investigators off the trail.
Sometimes it just feels like Maya was just saying words and happened to be right
I think that’s what she always does
@@AnEmu404 Yeah fair
She always seems to just be saying words
That's just how Maya is
That's just a teenager for you
So ultimately, this entire argument boils down to squares and rectangles. How did I not see this coming?
Don't You mean rectangles and the other rectangles?
@@matiaspereyra9392 Oh no.
@@averytubestudios OH YES
WE HAVE THE NEW ARGUMENT IN THE ROOM!
@@matiaspereyra9392you’re both WRIGHT (ha get it)
i just remembered this and came back to comment it
does the conclusion in the video work for it though? because a rectangle can't be a square unless it's a square
which is a rectangle
I'll be honest,
I didn't expect 'Accidentally transphobic Phoenix' to be used as evidence.
I didn't expect 'Accidentally transphobic Phoenix' at all.
I really appreciate Phoenix pointing out that words were being put into his mouth so that he's not painted as "the bad guy" in this situation where it escalates from ladder terminology to a subtle transphobic remark.
Imagine if Mornal paired that with Apollo's explicit denial that its a ladder.
Looks like he....turned his thinking around. xD
*In short:* They are both essentially correct, but a lot of it comes down to semantics and intention when Phoenix "corrects" Maya by pointing out that the ladder is _specifically_ a step-ladder.
Just saying Ladder gives plausible deniability to what you said though. In the casual conversation with nick and maya it is a situation where that general term is used to simply point something out, making maya completely right and nick kinda of a 👆🤓.
We litterally don't know if Phoenix is correct. And what we could be seeing could be something which isn't a ladder, but it probably is. So Maya wins completely unscathed.
Nah team ladder is still objectively correct. A step-ladder is at it's core a type of ladder. So saying "that's not a ladder that's a step-ladder" is like saying "that's not a vehicle that's a car"
1:12 You know what else is not even remotely settled?
Apollo’s mom
…not telling him and Trucy that they are siblings!
I always thought that if phoenix detected a WIFF of something starting to go on between those 2 he would let it be known then just be able to clown on Apollo
@@matiaspereyra9392or until apollo's mother tells them straight up
wait this is a thing i only played the first ace attorney
@Josuh well yeah you're kind of spoiled now but carry on playing the series, the remaster of the 2nd trilogy is coming 24th Jan so good for you you don't have to port the ds/3ds games on the pc or something if you dont have the console. It's not too big a plot point atm anyway.. and yeah if you want to avoid more spoilers I'd stay off ace attorney related content😅
Tbh the only way I could explain this is if Phoenix somehow is being blackmailied by Thalassa, why else wouldn't he say anything about it? He has no reason to hide it
Can’t even lie i was expecting something either like this or if the debate was “is miles edgeworth gay”. Can’t even lie this is peak
That's not a debate; fandom consensus has long established that Miles is gay.
@@timothymclean Also, they literally sell Miles and Phoenix-themed wedding rings as official merch.
"Is water wet"
@@KyleRayner12 To be fair, they're selling those because so many people ship Miles and Phoenix, not the other way around.
@@timothymclean nah we made it canon. Think of it like politicians giving concessions to protesters
The initial joke is about how step-CHILDREN and step-PARENTS are just as valid as blood children and parents. It's using "STEP" as the wordplay.
Yeah, I'm surprised that wasn't mentioned in the video...
oh my god i've been making "what are you doing stepladder" jokes all this time and still didn't realize this- you're so smart for this what
It's not my real ladder. It's my stepladder!
HOW DID I NOT GET THIS JOKE
@@darkacadpresenceinblood I can't do this anymore 😭
Step-ladder is a subset of ladder that is usually shorter and stands by itself. So it's both, I guess.
This is surprisingly high quality for such a stupid meme. I love it. It’s so amazing.
Not to add heat to the flame. But Construction wise a ladder is meant to be held by one person to get another person to a higher place (following OSHA guildlines) usually mounted on a wall for extra support. A step ladder is the same consept except its not only heavily advised to stop climbing the ladder once your foot touches the second to last "rung" which usually looks more like a step, while also having the ladder itself being held on its own and advised not to climb while closed even with ladder safety in mind. Basically a step ladder is what was made when some construction worker wanted to make portable stairs due to the "steps" for more convenience and safety to climb than a ladder.
Way to bring _OSHA_ into this...
"Nick! Look! A Woman!" is my new Roman Empire
Can you please let go of the Roman Empire, America never even got conquered by them
@@falconeshieldtogether we can fix this
"That's a step-woman"
"What's the difference"
Team Stepladder. Maya needs to remember her friend is a lawyer so by encouraging him to not get hung up over small details, she runs the risk of him actually losing a case. Which would be terrible considering she needed him to defend her several times in court.
I had to do a ladder training course at work and it actually had a whole section about the differences between ladders and step ladders. You know I was thinking of Ace Attorney and giggling like a madman the whole time.
Thank you Mornal! Now when my client asks "why do you care about a ladder? i'm going to die in three days cause of a coffee drinking psycho who looks like he's Cyclops' crazy estranged brother!" I can say "Yeah but my 17 year old spirit medium assistant who barely knows about law let alone about the real world needs to know what's the diffrence between a ladder and a ladder."
epic
Hang on. Trucy was right about it not being a folding ladder. A step ladder can only be opened and closed on one hinge while a folding ladder generally has multiple hinges allowing for it to be shaped in several ways such as a straight line and an A frame among other shapes. Folding ladders are also more compact due to being able to fold up smaller.
Also, folding ladders can have either runs or steps depending on the manufacturer, so there's folding rung ladders and folding step ladders, with folding step ladders usually being designed around how they can be used to gain various different heights from the steps
Dude this is one of the highest quality videos I’ve seen in months it feels like you’ve been doing this kind of content for years keep it up
Phoenix Wright is a lawyer. It’s in the job description to be overbearingly and overwhelmingly specific.
😂😂😂
Damn now I gotta figure out how to continue being team stepladder without simultaneously being a transphobe lol
Well, it's simple: if you're not a transphobe, then you aren't a transphobe.
You can be Team Both! That’s what I am
Yeah do wanna be clear that it's not that serious lmao
@@Mornalno, it IS that serious. As a former member of team step-ladder, you are now my mortal enemy and I shall exact my revenge swiftly and silently.
Phoenix can just as easily identify a women as a Cis Woman, implying that there are other kinds of women under the umbrella, such as Trans Women.
Phoenix remains based.
I still feel like Maya said that to throw Phoenix off and try to claim the win. I don't feel like Phoenix was being exclusionary, I felt like Phoenix felt like "ladder" without qualification referred so often to rung ladder that he wanted to show off knowing the technical difference, and was blindsided by the "cultural assumptions" line, and just noped out of the developing argument. Like, he was going "Here's a cool piece of trivia" and found himself getting an argument about cultures and bailed.
Or, OR, he's worried there is some difference in culture from Maya being a spirit medium from Kurain, realized he was in over his head, and decided to bail on the spot because he had no knowledge to try to talk about there. I still think Maya was trolling, but he decided he wasn't gonna take that risk and call her on it.
Also, love and support from a fellow trans girl. ^_^
I think it's just that Phoenix has a tendency to be detail oriented and very specific since he's a lawyer so he has a slightly annoying tendency to correct people and Maya thought quick and realized she could get one over on him by making a reference to step parents.
wait, *fellow* ??? Mornal is transfem? damn all the cool fandom people always are trans, why am i surprised :D thx for the throwaway comment i wouldn't have known this otherwise!
While this may be one of the most important questions to come out of the 21st century of gaming, what I really want to know that I'm surprised hasn't been talked about is what was Grossberg doing in the boathouse?
Rt? Or is this a really common question?
boathouse?
Ladder isnt an umbrella term, its a ladder term. Umbrellas are for rain
lol
4:48
that hit me like a fucking truck.
it's in good faith as far as i know, of course, but i was NOT expecting to hear that in this video.
hit me more like a stepladder to the head
Gave full warning multiple times and everything and it still hit me a thinker statue to the heaf
You can literally see the locking hinges on that particular STEP-ladder, right on the left side. How was this ever even an argument?
And wasn't like every other ladder a step ladder
@@animal_gal_adventures9885 im like 99% sure there is not a single normal ladder in any ace attorney game
@@LogCabinMusic "normal" ladder?!!
@@atherapists3331this is extra hilarious with the context of the video now
@@atherapists3331 bruh really just watched a whole video about words and decided to use the worst one in the context
There's also a couple Ladder vs. Step Ladder conversations in TGAA2, although it's actually a bit different than the typical argument, and Ryunosuke manages to sidestep the argument entirely after being lectured by Iris that both terms apply.
Your trans rights analogy is also supported by mathematics:
A rectangle is a parallelogram with two sets of parallel sides and four right interior angles.
A square is the same as above, but all four sides must be the same length.
I.e. every square is a rectangle but not every rectangle is a square.
Every stepladder is a ladder but not every ladder is a stepladder.
And finally, every trans woman is a woman, but not every woman is trans.
Case closed.
Is geometry under the "mathematics" umbrella?
@@bestboisoupsoupyeah.
"Look, Nick! A woman!" killed me
Finally, addressing the important issues!
I think my argument would be that stepladders should not be used in the same way as a ladder. Sure you could lean it up against the wall and walk up it but the legs won't contact the ground properly and the rungs will be pointing up. So from a safety standpoint phoenix wins. Calling it a ladder isn't incorrect however the difference in function is big enough that if you are training someone how to use a ladder or you have both in stock in a shop you should go over the difference. Perhaps phoenix had a traumatic experience falling off a stepladder that was leaned against a wall. Edit: or he just worked in construction
If I recall, he started off majoring in the arts before transferring into studying law, which explains his lawyering style.
Based on what we know, he transferred in his second year of university to a law degree. There was likely one or two accidents in a classroom involving ladder and/or a stepladder, and their teacher drilled into their heads the difference between the two
i was thinking "wouldn't it be easier to just say the thing about squares and rectangles instead of explaining the meaning of trans woman" but then you replaced the words in the interaction and that was honestly a brilliant move
Similar examples but different to the “that’s not a woman that’s a trans woman”
“Wow Pheonix look a man”
“No Maya that’s a *black* man”
“Wow Pheonix look a person”
“No Maya that’s a woman”
“Wow Pheonix look a worker”
“No Maya that’s a blue collar worker”
“Wow Pheonix look a military personnel”
“No Maya that’s a Cornel”
“Wow Pheonix look a college graduate”
“No Maya that’s a PhD graduate”
“Wow Pheonix look a kid”
“No Maya that’s a tween”
Those animated bits in the middle were so awesome! I think they absolutely helped in getting the point across, and comedy to boot!
The stepladder argument also comes up in Ace Attorney Investigations 2, although that only sort of counts since there's no official english translation. Fantastic job on the video!
Well, we'll find out soon enough with a real transition
I don’t have the game but now there’s a translation!
Thank you for stepping up and looking at this from a lateral perspective
“Most of you Ace Attorney people are some kinda gay already!”
Insert clip of Dwight turning to camera saying “it’s true”
12:00 Well, that explains the character design. I didn't put that together at first.
the major thing i learned from this is that every fandom has some sort of “is pronounced hydro-city or hydrossity” debate
In my opinion, a short folding one is a stepladder. One going straight up is a ladder. That's just common sense. 🤷🏻♀️
The problem with this is that the ladder being depicted is a tall folding ladder, so it doesn't meet either of your categories
@@bosstowndynamics5488 _Tall_ folding ones are ladders. _Short_ folding ones are stepladders. That's what we call them at my house anyway. 🤷🏻♀️
@@HazbinCovenWitch That's how I've used the terms as well, but it only really occurred to me watching this video that even tall folding ladders do have what could accurately be called "steps" rather than rungs.
@@bosstowndynamics5488 I don't consider those steps. 🤷🏻♀️
Holy moly. I couldn’t have predicted how much you improved in animation quality. Great job! I hope you can finally rest easy before slaving after the next video ❤
After watching the video, I have developed a slightly different take on this. Phoenix and Maya are not actually talking about ladders, but are revealing their important character distinctions by using ladders as a foil for their differing approaches to investigating. Phoenix is a rather judgy person who believes in specificity for the sake of an accurate investigation. Maya takes a more general, devil-may-care approach and can be a bit aloof, often making connections that can seem silly or illogical at times. In the argument, Phoenix asserts that maya should be more specific when referring to the surroundings (potential clues). Maya asserts that making such specific determinations too quickly can lead to bias. The same thing can be perceived differently to two different people, after all. Then again, ladders are probably one of the worst examples that Maya could have used to illustrate this point, causing confusion on the part of both Phoenix and many members of the audience. Classic Maya. But the confusion is the point, as these different approaches consistently having to work against one another allow for such moments of consternation that lead them to collectively discover things that either one would likely miss had they been working on their own. The lack of epistemological upheaval would likely lead to a lot of jumping to conclusions. "The hammer that strikes too fast has no time to aim." So instead of asking who is right and who is wrong, perhaps we should acknowledge how both characters are needed and that working together is the best way to get to the truth. After all, is that not what Phoenix Wright is really all about?
Like if the exchange was over a hammer used to nail the board over the vent cover, and Maya just called it a hammer, but Phoenix said that it could be used to pull out nails, maya might be confused, until elaborating that this particular hammer is a claw hammer and not a typical ball peen hammer or a mallet, meaning that it could have potentially been used in the crime if any wooden construction or crafts got broken recently.
And then there's a situation later in the same case where Maya notices something Phoenix didn't by noting the simpler aspects of something, like maybe she notices that because the head only covers the center of the corner on the pathway/road between studio 1 & 2, that someone might have been able to go around it to get to studio 1, thus calling into question any events that happened at studio 2.
That's just my own two cents on this
@@sev1120 Asking the real questions here. Why nobody was able to get around Mr. Monkey's head is beyond me. It does prevent cars from going through I guess.
I literally had a discussion about ladders vs stepladders at work once. With a coworker who wasnt even aware of the Phoenix Wright games.
Wasn't expecting a Shenpai clip here. Yay, clips!
I miss the animated AA comic shorts; I went back and rewatch them from time to time (Flipping the Parrot, Building a Bridge, and Lowering the Bar are my favs).
Here i was expecting a short funny haha meme like a damn FOOL when all along it was a 13 minute funny haha excellently written and animated video essay.
You've outdone yourself, Mornal. Amazing job.
Maya was playing 4D chess with us all along.
8:08 This actually broke me, I spent two minutes laughing my ass off
Idk what i was expecting, but it definitely wasn't such a well put-together video with a very sound and decisive resolution to a debate I didn't even know existed
serious props for making one of the most entertaining videos I've seen in a long while
Things I learned from this video: Bridget is a ladder.
She's a STEPladder
@@RealQuarlie Wow, you really need to stop judging things based on narrow-minded cultural assumptions. /lh
This video, from a structural pov, is a fucking masterpiece. I love it, the editing is on point and the 3D render Parts are extremely well done! Great job on settling this dilemma Mornal ❤
That Venn diagram implies that a Woman is only someone who is simultanously a Cis Woman and a Trans Woman. Literally unwatchable smh
Now for an actual comment, this is amazing, we need more video essays of this production quality
We've found her... the Omniwoman
@@Mornal I can't wait for her to show up in Invincible season 3
If only there was some kind of reverse Venn diagram. A Nevv diagram...
Would an AFAB woman who is genderfluid count as being both Cis and Trans? 🤔
I hope you know this video got me interested to check out Ace Attorney.
This is under the assumption that Nick *meant to* correct Maya, rather than to add to her statement, i can see it going both ways, though for the adding i guess saying "To be more specific..." would be more fitting than "That's a...", but you cannot judge on whether or not he meant to call Maya wrong, since we don't even have a good way of telling what his tone is, we only know that he's accenting the sentence on "step" in step-ladder
Yeah, I think he was just adding to her statement. I know this is an investigation scene and not the courtroom, but he's still probably in the "legal mindset" of high precision. Can't really blame him. In some cases in the series, saying "someone used their hand" wouldn't be precise enough, because the fact that they specifically used their _left_ hand is relevant.
2 months later and this is still one of my favourite video essays of all time because of all the animations and excellent script. Please make more of these , this is so good.
Ending this gag is genuinely beautiful, ironically that is.
5:55 Don't call us out like that
This all felt like a particularly elaborate episode of Game Theory and I'm here for it
I was NOT prepared to laugh this hard XD (Also it’s so interesting how the first ladder is the only one to be inconsistently drawn)
People are busy saying that Phoenix cross examining a parrot is stupid while theyre out here trying to find the answer to the ladder vs stepladder debate
Are we ever gonna get another video like this? Its unparalleled in its excellence.
Truly fire content. Always love your stuff c:
This was way more entertaining than I'd thought it'd be lmao
Phoenix: "Dear God the latter.."
Mornal: "It's the ladder!"
I'm not sure if you interpreted it to be that way or not, but if so, then that was clever my friend!
4:47 AYYYYYOOOOOOO! BEST TRANSITIONAL STATEMENT EVER.
"You thought I was gonna use Step-Ladders to sell you on Trans-Rights but it's the other way around _most of you Ace Attorney people are some kind of gay already."_
Holy shit this was too funny and too correct! _and damn it suddenly got abit too real, 2001 folks. Ace Attorney prepping the world for Transgender normalisation way back then. Even if it was unintentional._
Real talk, I used to think the joke about "All Ace Attorney fans are Queer in some capacity" was nonsense because I was like, "What? That can't be right. I'm CisHet."
Guess who realized some things not 2 years later...
This was funny, awesome and enlightening all in one. Thank you Mornal
10:34 Mornal, you're ruining the investigation, GET OUTTA HERE!
Side-note on the debate, the animation is so beautifully done! So slick too!
Thanks!
A whole video essay on a niche meme that is fully animated! It is so extra and I am here for it!
I like a little reference in Great Ace Attorney to this debate. It's a reference to the very first argument between phoenix and Maya. It goes something like.
"Oh, look at this. In Japan we call it a stepladder"
""We call it a stepladder in Britan too, Runo""
"Oh"
""You should make assumtions on other cultures like that""
8:06 Loving the character assassination and Nick getting talked over
Amazing stuff. Now I want an indepth analysis of every argument
10:10
OBJECTION but you can kinda see a harth though that grey spot right THERE
You walk up a step ladder you climb up a ladder
And also if you work in any place with mechcanics or anything specfic you wanna be 100% specific for what you ask for
I have total respect for your commitment to the bit.
This is a brand of insanity that wraps back around into making sense with the whiplash of me getting hit in the head with a ladder…. *I WANT MORE!*
I was so unenthused about finding those beautiful artists and their work and then saw you made it easy, thank you ^^
Also to update the counts for ones Mornal may have missed.
Twice in Turnabout Serenade there's ladder dialouge where it seems Apollo wins two more points, once against Trucy alone and a second one with Ema and Trucy losing to him where it seems Ema changes her stance in the 8 year gap between AA1 and AJ, so that's 4 points for Apollo.
In The Rite of Turnabout, it seems since seeing eachother again Phoenix and Maya have swapped sides with Phoenix calling it a ladder and Maya calling it step ladder so 2 points for Phoenix.
In The Inherited Turnabout there's a discussion between Tyrell Badd and Gregory Edgeworth, where Gregory and Ray are calling it a stepladder so 1 point for Badd.
In The Return of the Departed Soul, Ryuunosuke and Iris end up having a discussion about the exact same note as you mention in the endslate with Ryuunosuke pointing out that have different words for ladder and stepladder but still Iris gets the point for being on Team Ladder so maybe 1 point for Iris.
Later on in the same case it seems Ryuunosuke has taken Iris' comparison and words to heart and decided to not make an argument with Susato who stubbornly calls it stepladder, but he makes no effort to try and correct Susato so that's either 0.5, 1 or still 0 points for Ryuunosuke depending on how you feel.
In Layton VS Wright we see Layton and Maya discussing ladders where they both use the umbrella term when referring to a treehouse so no points can really be given but when regarding later in the game, Phoenix regarding a bell tower when Maya mentions how they could use a ladder he brings up a stepladder so 4 points for Maya.
Overall though, Apollo wins given Maya's change in stance.
Well-edited, overly produced video essay for Ace Attorney in year-of-our-lord 2023?
My lucky day!
Was I the only one who thought the cultural assumptions joke was really about parents vs. step parents?
I honestly really appreciate this because I've never understood the ladder vs. step-ladder debate. (Especially not the non-sequitur comment at the end.) Thanks for clearing things up! As always, love your animations and your voice acting! ❤
I'm a trans woman and I will now use the stepladder analogy. That was glorious and i laughed so hard, especially when you made that gag about "most of you ace attorney fans are some flavor of gay anyway"
RIGHT!!? i dont think i can use that analogy without outing myself tho
im also a trans women btw
I don't think this debate will ever end.
Nice video btw, really well edited.
Mia: How did you get in here ?
Mornal: I’m your god here! I can do whatever I want..
Mia: but still haven’t gotten 1M subscribers.
I didn't even know spades and shovels were different.
I originally thought that the culture related thing somehow had something to do with step-parents lol. but same idea i guess
I always took it as a step parent vs parent joke :P
This was a really good vid, def changed my mind and the analogy literally made things click entirely. Also really love how bouncy your character? is can't wait for more vids!!!
I think about and rewatch this video frequently for reasons I can’t describe. Good job this video is great
Im Team Wright on this one chief, like if u replace the trans metaphor with something like, idk a phone, it can be something like
Maya: "Oh look, a phone!"
Pheonix: "Thats an iphone Maya"
Ofc theres the debate of whether it even matters to specifiy the type, which for ladders in crime scenes, yeah it really does. Whether it is feasible for someone to like go up a hole in the middle of the ceiling using the ladder present completely hinges on the fact of whether it is a step or rung ladder. If its a rung ladder and theres no wall nearby to put it up, then the whole argument falls apart.
Thats why Pheonix, A LAWYER, would be mindful of words, but bc he didn't think its relevant to this case at hand, he dropped the topic quick. Now i wanna see a AA case where the ladder is a big factor in the case
A square is a type of rectangle, but if someone points at a square and calls it a rectangle you'd still think they're an idiot
omfg the animation is next level why is everyone in this fandom sooo talented
You fail to take into account the need to specify to have complete knowledge of the situation. It's important to know where under the umbrella the subject is, as it give much more information as to what they are talking about. To not specify would lead someone having an assumed picture of the argument based on their own preconceptions of what the Umbrella term is.
To use your Woman Umbrella example. It's not wrong to specify if someone is a trans-woman, as it'll allow the person who called them a woman to know not to mention transphobic jokes or topics. It also reveals that the person has vastly different life experiences than that of a biological woman.
Likewise, it's not wrong to specify step-ladder, as it allows the person to know the limits of the step-ladder and how to use it.
To simply call a trans woman a woman is not wrong, but to claim it's more right is wrong. It ignores important information about the person and feeds false information as the recipient of the information will fill in the gaps with their own assumptions. Same for calling a step-ladder just a ladder. It misinforms the person into thinking it's their preconceived notion of a ladder.
This argument hinges on the hypothetical scenario where the correction is warranted by the surrounding context but that variable is different in this case
The context for Phoenix's correction here is just Maya pointing at the ladder and going "ooh cool, a ladder," nothing about the scenario implied the specific type of ladder was important so the only purpose the correction serves is to be patronizing/pedantic
@@Mornal The counter case you are making is that the purpose behind Phoenix's comment is to be patronizing, however there's a lack of evidence to confirm that point. Phoenix is a lawyer, a job in which definitions, evidence and context is very important. Phoenix making a clarification about potential evidence in the middle of a crime scene is very important. There's an outline of the body right underneath the step-ladder. In this case, yes the specific kind of ladder is important to know because of it's potential to be evidence.
As for cases where the step-ladder isn't important in later games, it's less necessary I will concede that. But to say it's patronizing would imply intentionally belittling, which there is a lack of evidence for. And for Edgeworth vs. Kay, it's very necessary as Edgeworth says "it's the _exact_ same thing," when they very much are not. Clarifying the difference isn't belittling Edgeworth because it's telling Edgeworth different ladders have different uses, and calling one by a different kind of ladder is incorrect. You can't say a rung ladder is the same as a step-ladder, it's not _exactly_ the same as Edgeworth believes
Wild analogy.
Both of them are right, and both of them are wrong Miaya is right because it is a step ladder and Phoenix is right because it doesn’t matter if there is a difference.
Also I like Phoenix wright but I’m not that much into the franchise to the point where this is my first entry into this debate, and I just watched the first four minutes of the video.
Look! Its a biscuit!
That's a blanket.
What's the difference?
All that I got from this argument is: Phoenix is ladderphobic.
I really like ur animation here, it looks very fun and bouncy
Thank you for your contribution to this fandom culture
This video is so good, the humour really got me lmao