Some ppl, acted the way this video essay describes. To suggest that most ppl went in that direction, even in the Wild West, is pseudo history and pretty poor fact checking, frankly. Makes it difficult to take this channel seriously. It’s full of hyperbole and pure speculation. I’m out
@@AlbertoFolres except for one condition, if arther's father was the main character and he dies and arther in the epilogue and the last mission will be young arther joining the gang
Actually, Jack brings the Marston family legacy to great heights. In GTA V, you can see a book on the shelf in Franklin’s new house titled “The American Dream” by Jack Marston. Jack wrote about Arthur and John’s lives and explained their bravery throughout the years. A perfect ending to the Red Dead Redemption Series.
You missed an important point, Arthur has a kid with a lady before Jack is born, he never leaves the gang but tried to take care of the boy. One day he finds the lady and his son murdered. This changed Arthur, made him meaner. Then Jack is born and john leaves, when John returns Arthur cannot forgive him, he is jealous John has his boy, and it angers him that he lost his. This is an important emotional piece of Arthur Morgan.
His son's name was Isaac and be was a good kid! Arthur cannot forgive John, not because of jealousy - it is because he abandoned his family, where Arthur has none. Arthur knows how it feels like to have lost his own family, that's why he is angry at John for abandoning his family.
Sadly, Arthurs sacrifice was completely invain. He told John to run and never look back. John couldn't let go of the past and persuing Micah is what lead to Johns violent death followed shortly by Abigail. Leaving the once innocent Jack an orphan at 19, in a world of pain and nothing left to lose.
Agent Ross already had his address so it was either returning to his past ways or dying there anyway,so it’s good that he at least got arthur’s revenge before dying
gotta agree. Ending left me pissed off. At one point I'd really like to see a happy ending for the good guys, & by that I mean the characters we play as the gamers who buy the f@#$ing games.
The worst part is that both author and John were trying to protect each other and you can see how much love author had for John when he gave him his hat and then he gives Arthur’s ring from Mary to Abigail the most amazing thing in the story right there
I really want a Red Dead Redemption 3 where you play as Dutch, rescuing and recruiting the members of the gang, and building Dutch's mystique and reputation. Ends with the Blackwater Ferry job. It'd be interesting to see the old Dutch who lived the ideals he preached, and inspired such loyalty in those around him.
It’d be nice to see the kindhearted part of Dutch that we learned about, we barely saw glimpses of him 😂😂 it was always corrupted Dutch, in either game despite his “redemption” in RDR2 he went back and gaslit all those young natives
@@gencfgchm7021 the callender brothers are the worst protagonists for a redemption arc lmao. Charles literally says they were bastards who couldn't and didn't have the opportunity to change, and an incredibly important character dying anticlimactically at the start of the 2nd game would be profound bullshit
@Noble Phantazm I don't know why I'm still using lol as an act of surprise if I know that it means "lots of laughs", I just was surprised, I trust you bc I'm in highschool right now, and there are a lot of "kids" that think that life is only about sex.
I dont think john would join the army after the army killed his father or maybe jack would be a legendary warrior in the battle field or he just becomes uncle
I love how both games feel different. Rdr 2 feelings more like a spaghetti western (loud trumpet music, more epic battles) and rdr 1 feelings more like an old western, like end of an era. Theres some scenes in rdr 1 that feel like it’s on a sound stage of an act of a play
It hit me really hard, man. I've been riding my boah (Ardennes) since chapter 2. It had been loyal to me till the end. Never once did it buck me off, and I had level 4 bonding. I miss my boah.
My Bessie died near the end of Chapter 4 when I got ambushed by the Lemonye Gang and I saw last second that they had a gattling gun. She died a second before I did. She was the cheapest horse you can buy when you first ride into Valentine. RIP Bessie
Wait... In RDR1 they killed John since he was the “last” member of Van Der Lind’s gang. What they didn’t realize is that at the end of RDR2 Charles Smith flees to Canada. This means Charles Smith is the last survivor of the gang...
king chris yes but she was still pretty important in the gang despite showing her worth very late, and there is also tilly Mary Beth and Karen and a few more who lived
@@ambivalentaxe No Micah betrayed the gang that lead to the Pinkertons going after the gang in the first place. The Robbery only failed because of Micah.
There's a reason why John and Arthur are the most loveable characters in the Red Dead Redemption franchise, because they just want to do good in a world run by bad people. I hope we see a 3rd game about the rise of the Van Der Linde Gang.
Fun fact: The Pinkertons were a REAL private security company and, I believe, was accurately portrayed in RDR2. Rockstar clearly got inspiration from U.S. history with Cornelius Vanderbilt, and how they incorporated the history of that agency to their advantage was impressive. Funny enough, the Pinkerton Detective Agency still exists today (albeit under a different name and on a much more limited scale since the rise of the FBI).
Red Dead Redemption 2 is the best open world game that I have ever played to date. The story, the attention to detail, everything. RdR2 is an absolute masterpiece.
@@kingofthehillawa5331 I tried to get into the Witcher 2 and 3 and I couldn't do it. But those are more hardcore RPG's and im admittedly more of a casual player
Would then be so cool to see this continue into rdr 3 where we follow Jack as he fights in WW1 and grows into a main role in the 20’s mafia scene. He could reunite with Sadie and see early cars and Tommy guns etc, but in the end, he falls back to classic Wild West behaviour to win or die.
I guess Franklin would keep antiques in his house. That book is 99 years old. Actually no because that book was made a couple years after 1899 and gta v takes place in 2013.
You forgot. Jack Marston writes a book about his funny deep voiced uncle and his dads law escapades in a book called red dead in Los Santos where he retired in 1970. His book was a top seller in the gta universe and is on the shelves in gta 5
I doubt they’ll do Jack Marston since that’s basically the end of the Wild West but I feel like they’re either going to start a new arc or continue on with the Van Der Linde gang by going back further and having Dutch as the protagonist recruiting all the gang members.
A Sadie/Charles team up type thing would be awesome. It wouldn't necessarily have to be years later, more like months later after they parted ways with John and before RDR.
I kinda doubt it. That would mean that the plague already happened in the first one but it was unseen thing in the first undead nightmare. But if they make new undead nightmare I hope its not as buggy and would have some sick Tank from left4dead or demolisher from dying light type of zombies.
You forgot the most important part. Jack Marston presumably tells the stories of his family and his life to someone who then writes a book about it. The title of the book is Red Dead Redemption and it can be found as an Easter egg in GTA 5 Franklin's apartment on a bookshelf.
Red Dead Redemption 3: A hardened Jack fresh off a return ship after surviving the trenches of WWI finds himself caught in the rise of the original American Gangsters profiting off the illegal alcohol market in Chicago.
Crazando anonymous Jack would be a bit old for WW2. He was born in 1895, which would have made him in his late 40s in WW2. Too old for anyone but a higher ranking officer.
@@connorpikula The entire town of Blackwater pretty much caught on fire- And btw on RDR1, my sister goes to Macfarlanes Ranch and just shoots everything and everyone
we NEED a prequel to rdr2. I've heard people wanting rdr3 to be about jack during a ww1 or prohibition era and I think thats a pretty cool idea to play as jack in a flashback to ww1 and maybe see him deserting but I think a prequel where you play as dutch or hosea about the early years of the gang leading up to the blackwater massacre would be better.
@@animeshsingh3300 Plus look at the map the old think missing from RDR us Mexico. They could make RDR a remastered DLC. And I’m actually a bit confused why they wasted all that map without even using it?
Im hitting the thumbs up automatically because I just finished the RDR2 story and it is amazing- now I need to know the full storyline linking the first game to this masterpiece of a storyline.
@@clorobec2625 Says who? Just curious. I was assuming the opposite, i mean, if ur right and the cannon story is that Arthur is part of the reason John survived and got out long enough to get that farm for his family, ud think John would have mentioned him at least once in RDR1 but he never does, so the ending where Arthur leaves John n goes for the money kinda makes more sense in the whole story does it not?
Everyone's talking about how sad it was that Arthur died, and I agree, he's by far my favourite character. But, the saddest scene in my opinion is when his horse got shot, and Arthur went back to put his girl (his horse) to sleep. Legit made me tear up 😢😭😭
it did that cutscene and it wasn’t that sad for me bc my oh horse died bc of a damn rock😂😂 and the horse that died in the cutscene was one i had to steal like right before it happened so it didn’t really mean that much to me lmao
@@gaflgon3115 Key words: in my opinion. As an animal lover, yes, because Arthur's death was predicted but the horse's was not. Also as someone that's lost pets in the past, the scene hits close to home. So if you don't like opinions that differ from yours, please kindly fuck off :)
Even though everyone knows it's "just" a game, gotta give props to Rockstar for definitely tugging on human emotions. It's amazing what good storing writing does to people whether it be a book, movie or a freakin game! I vote for Tarantino to make this a movie.
@@erikallen3804 really shows the strength of Hosea. Imagine being what some would call elderly in the old west in one of the most infamous gangs. I remember this camp interaction where Bill is drunk and isn't doing anything, Hosea steps in and bosses him around in the most badass of ways.
@@erikallen3804 not seen as old. Only reason why live expectancy back then was about 47-50 years olds is due to how often a child would die at birth. If you made it past 2 years old there was still a good chance of hitting 65-70. Hitting 60 was not at all unheard of back thing and 20-29 is still a young person even back then
I’m not liking you’re comments not because I disagree but I like literally them both the same, so I agree if anyone loves John or Arthur the best but I love both.
imagine what would have happened if he survived guess who Ross would force john to kill. would that really be a better end? i mean they pretty much took out all of the important figures of the VdL gang apart from the ones who werent important enough to appear on the agencys radar thats why it was pretty clear that arthur and hosea wouldnt make it to the next game
Red dead redemption 3:rise of the Van der linde gang Red dead redemption 2:fall of the van der linde gang Red dead redemption 1:end of the van der linde gang
I’ve always wanted to see how the gang banded together with young Arthur, Dutch and hosea. I especially wanted to play the blackwater massacre as a prologue to rdr2
@@Soap.-- nah I definitely think there is a promising future with Jack. Here me out. A battle hardened Jack returns from World War 1 and finds himself in Chicago where he gets tangled up with the mob.
I kept the shire you steal after burning the tobacco fields and called her Guinevere. Cried like a baby when she dies at the end of the game. Cried again when Jack was talking about King Arthur and lady Guinevere in the epilogue. My little role play came full circle
Just slap the title Red Dead Redemption 3 on Red Dead Redemption 2's cover, don't change anything except letting Micah die and not doing the Downes Ranch mission, that way Arthur and everyone lives, makes money, and goes back out west.
Men, can this story become even more sad? Arthur, an awesome caracter Gets killed by a gangmember while helping a friend, John. Then we become John who wants to start over and be there for his wife and son, but the law Finds him and kills him as well, leaving his son and wife. Men can cry about it.
Can men also cry when a lowly gunslinger trying to change his ways proposes to the mother of his child while on a row boat using the ring left to him by an old friend? Asking for a friend
13:41 the salesman is mentioned in the gunsmith store book in rdr2 where if you look at one of the stories on the sawed off shotgun page a lady scared the salesman away with the sawed off, another small connection of rdr2 to rdr1
@Anas Mohamed Yeah but he barely had any records of existing so he could easily dodge the draft. Also, he would be around 22-23 in 1917, so the likelihood of him being chosen when there were already hundreds of thousands of younger men is pretty slim.
1:08 Hosea wasn't "young". He was 34 in 1878, which is just two years younger than what Arthur's age is in 1899. Also fun fact: When John joined the gang, Arthur was 22. That is how old John was when he became a father.
@@Soap.-- There was, when mary ask arthur to run away and arthur said need cash. At the moment i have 17k in pocket that enough to run away to other contitnents with mary
Too long. Who the hell will the voice actors be? It should be about either before Blackwater, after the fall of the gang. I really wouldn't mind a game about the native americans in the mid-late 19th century. Watching your tribe be betrayed and massacred by the Americans, losing hope year by year, day by day. Your way of life being forced out of existence, your culture being attacked and what else? you decide. Performing ambushes to the army would be magnificent.. Tucked away beside a tree, waiting for that signal. Nothing, Nothing, Nothing. Boom, trees fall from back and front and you get it.
HELL YEAH! Hosea for RDR3! I want to see the begining of Dutch & Hosea, when they found Arthur and John and when he tried to leave Dutch being for Bessie but slowly drifted back to the gang, their first bank job with young Arthur... DAMN thats a game right there!
@@SamGarso I feel like It's too far past. Possibly before Blackwater Job, with Mac, Jenny and all the other folks who didn't make it east. Connecting the dots from that massacre which is covered in mystery
My first playthrough was quick just wanted to know the story... My second one was slow with High Honor, my third was even slower I wanted that 100% completion but with very low honor with that said; bad honor Arthur was the most fun I've ever had with a game!
I actually never played RDR so I feel a lot of the twists were more powerful since I didn’t know that John was the main character or any of this happens
That does sound interesting. But now that you have I strongly recommend getting the first one it's truly amazing. On par with the second just not as crazy in depth cause of the tech limitations of the time
I like it how he Explained every Timeline from Red Dead Redemption games so we can Know which to Play so we can get the full Timeline! I hope you can Create more Videos on more Timelines from Games, Amazing Video! You've gained a Subscriber!
my ending was bad. im actually deppressed. Arthur got stabbed my micah but Im gonna replay the game and end with good honour to see arthur die peacefully.
m_odrosky4 Umm 😐 how Micah jumps you beats you up and then Dutch steps on the gun that would’ve saved your life them Micah either gets mad and walks away or shoots you in the head after Arthur’s last words “Damn is all Micah” I mean I chose it but the way you die ain’t much different
Just Crystal Only Crystal Yes but it’s much more meaningful and it’s how Arthur would’ve wanted to go out. High honor Arthur is the best Arthur, the actual Arthur. All endings are very sad but this one is definitely his true ending, how Rockstar wants us to see Arthur go out.
m_odrosky4 he kinda didn’t dude the way he wanted to. Just a little. 2/3rds of his death were complete. He wanted to die watching the sunrise facing west, but he was actually facing east and barely had the chance to even take 5 seconds to even remember one good moment. But yeah his death was pretty peaceful, I got shot in the head and I wasn’t even sad, or depressed. I was literally pissed off lol. Like “what? This is how it goes? This is how he dies?! By a piece of shit?! Wtf rockstar, you could’ve done better than this!” Then i realised it was because of my honour lol
Me giving all my money to the camp, tell Dutch I got the money, how are we gonna leave? Dutch respond: ''I don't know, start dancing?'' He must had hit he's head pretty hard in that Saint-Denis Trolley...
Yio Something I don’t think so Arthur is better character than john his voice his body his face and his thoughts and feelings and the character development it’s all so thought out and detailed John is great but I don’t know his character is nothing so unique so I doubt it Maybe the new protagonist (if there’s one) will be well written character with great voice actor and great character design but i don’t it will be so much better than Arthur
VorteX X nope. Jack is the end of the rdr timeline since it’s the end of the west. The series has to work backwards. When most the stories are told, Jack shooting Edgar ross will be thought of as the end of the west.
This redemption saga. I can honestly say no one loves it like I do. It’s all like warm blanket. No matter what mood I’m in it makes me feel better. I connect more with this game than every film and TV show. Personally that is. Thankyou rockstar for the redemption story. Truly the best fictional story in any source of entertainment
Maybe this was intended, rockstar maybe implemented these small things (like Arthur’s coat) into the prequel to act as an analogy. Jack grew up around the gang and took an example of every single one of them: Arthur’s fashion sense, Dutch’s Wisdom, Hosea’s love of literature, John & Arthur’s shooting skill etc. Just a theory.
“Revenge is a fool’s game”, Jack already doomed himself by doing the exact opposite of what he should’ve done. Arthur was wise, and Jack is just like his father; a stubborn man. There’s no happy ending in a horror story.
Best part is the speculative stories. Let's say you left a few missions behind it shows Jack up to be masterful in manipulating others. Add to the fact that if you consider rdr and gta in the same universe, he goes on to become a writer, putting his scholarly skills to work. So it's presumed Jack went on to have a more peaceful life after getting his revenge. So likely case is he just killed Edgar Ross, it got marked as a cold case or a hunting accident. Then went on to gain some money and publishing the stories of his dad and Arthur
Have an idea for a video? Submit it here: amagipublishing.com/idea-submission/the-leaderboard-idea-submission/
Hi
The bendy and the Ink machine timeline
Some ppl, acted the way this video essay describes. To suggest that most ppl went in that direction, even in the Wild West, is pseudo history and pretty poor fact checking, frankly. Makes it difficult to take this channel seriously. It’s full of hyperbole and pure speculation. I’m out
😂à😂@@strv81
😅
Arthur’s story- Long
John’s story- Very Long
Jack’s story- like 10 seconds
Lol true
@The Kamikaze One that will be GTA in world war 2 which wont be in the old west. Being in the old west is what makes the game epic
they should do liberty city how it was during the wild west....kind of like gangs of new york. Tie red dead into gta
@@subscribeforn0reasonplz691 plot twist: RDR3 will be the GTA origins
@@AlbertoFolres except for one condition, if arther's father was the main character and he dies and arther in the epilogue and the last mission will be young arther joining the gang
Loki: I have an army
Tony Stark: I have a hulk
Dutch: I have a plan
Star lord has a plan too.
He always did
John Marston hello
uncle: lUmBaGo
DAMN IT DUTCH!
Red dead redemption 1: I wanna play as John not jack
Red dead redemption 2: I wanna play as Arthur not John
Red dead redemption 3: I wanna play as Davey not Arthur
Red dead redemption 4 I wanna play as hosea not davey
Red dead redemption 5: I wanna play as Uncle not hosea
Red dead redemption 6: I wanna play as Lenny not micah
ThinkerHats you messed up, it’s Lenny not uncle
Actually, Jack brings the Marston family legacy to great heights. In GTA V, you can see a book on the shelf in Franklin’s new house titled “The American Dream” by Jack Marston. Jack wrote about Arthur and John’s lives and explained their bravery throughout the years. A perfect ending to the Red Dead Redemption Series.
Wait really?
@@D3ATHDUDE2 yeah its real
@@wafflesarebest1702 well damn I guess ya learn something new every day
@@D3ATHDUDE2 'you forget a thousand things every day. Make sure this isn't one of them'
I'm pretty sure in GTA Online there is also a character who is John Marston's great great grandson.
Arthur’s death, one of the saddest things I’ve ever witnessed. Nearly brought me to tears. Then you go and announce a giveaway.
Frostbite Dog omg ikr
It’s a damn video game character
ninjamastas wdym so it’s fake
@@leviyoung4066 He clearly got attached to his character, fool.
2k Subs with bad content? Ik that how does that make me a fool?
You missed an important point, Arthur has a kid with a lady before Jack is born, he never leaves the gang but tried to take care of the boy. One day he finds the lady and his son murdered. This changed Arthur, made him meaner. Then Jack is born and john leaves, when John returns Arthur cannot forgive him, he is jealous John has his boy, and it angers him that he lost his. This is an important emotional piece of Arthur Morgan.
Well said
THIS is why Arthur hates John ?! I was so lost when they were talking ... I’m starting from RDR2 🤦🏾♂️
@@4thDistrictKey did u finish it?
@@MazzixG Yes a few days ago BEST Game EVER
His son's name was Isaac and be was a good kid! Arthur cannot forgive John, not because of jealousy - it is because he abandoned his family, where Arthur has none. Arthur knows how it feels like to have lost his own family, that's why he is angry at John for abandoning his family.
Plot Twist:
None of it happened.
None of it.
It was just Arthur and Lenny's imagination while they were drunk.
Enolam That actually makes sense
Arthur would have scary dreams, seeing that. Especially knowing that is so close.
It didn't really if you think about it the game is just made up
Thank god Arthur is okay 👍👍👍👍👍👍
Thanks for the red dead redemption 3 leak lol
Sadly, Arthurs sacrifice was completely invain. He told John to run and never look back. John couldn't let go of the past and persuing Micah is what lead to Johns violent death followed shortly by Abigail. Leaving the once innocent Jack an orphan at 19, in a world of pain and nothing left to lose.
Sadly, you’re right
Revenge is a fools game.
Agent Ross already had his address so it was either returning to his past ways or dying there anyway,so it’s good that he at least got arthur’s revenge before dying
gotta agree. Ending left me pissed off. At one point I'd really like to see a happy ending for the good guys, & by that I mean the characters we play as the gamers who buy the f@#$ing games.
@@sadmanmahi2584 «revenge is a luxury we cant afford»
Dutch's plan would've worked if everyone just had some GOD DAMN FAITH
Tony Santiago and sum MORE MONEY
@@yhayaalam651 JUST ONE LAST TRAIN
@@julianassange5971 AND IT'S ALWAYS A GODDAMN TRAIN
Don't use the Lord's name in vain
ALWAYS DOUBTIN
Martin Luther king jr.
“I have a dream”
Dutch van der linde:
“I have a plan”
Plan Der Linde
and i need your god damn faith
HAVE SOME GODDAMN FAITH
Uncle: I have lumbago
Sorry man this was taken 10 months ago. Please try again.
The worst part is that both author and John were trying to protect each other and you can see how much love author had for John when he gave him his hat and then he gives Arthur’s ring from Mary to Abigail the most amazing thing in the story right there
author? 😂
Wrote it like kai cenat
Imagine being such an NPC that you crap on someone for making a spelling error
The Joy's of predictive text and auto correct Author could easily come from Arthur
the saddest part is, despite John and Arthurs' best efforts to keep jack from becoming an outlaw, he did anyway.
so true
The outlaw life will never end it seems😔
Not all true, in gta v, in franklins house on the book shelf, you can see a book called red dead, by J.Marston, I believe he became a writer.
@@snaggerdagger591 I never noticed that. What a sweet little Easter egg
Do we know he continued the outlaw life after the end of RDR?
Arthur: I have tuberculosis
Micah: I have rat
Dutch: I have a plan
Uncle: I have l u m b a g o
John: I have no choice
Wtf does I have rat mean
BILL:I HAVE ESTUPICUS LUMBAGUS
And hotel:trivago
i have *r a t*
Arthur: *dies*
Two seconds after: "Do YoU WaNt tO gET a FrEe CoNsoLe?!?"
Honestly man, ruined the moment for me. That was the worst ad placement I've ever seen
No respect.. RIP Arthur
Indeed no respect
They're just trying to get that free promotion from 3 year olds, and I disrespect that
Use Brave Browser guys, no adds.
I really want a Red Dead Redemption 3 where you play as Dutch, rescuing and recruiting the members of the gang, and building Dutch's mystique and reputation. Ends with the Blackwater Ferry job.
It'd be interesting to see the old Dutch who lived the ideals he preached, and inspired such loyalty in those around him.
It’d be nice to see the kindhearted part of Dutch that we learned about, we barely saw glimpses of him 😂😂 it was always corrupted Dutch, in either game despite his “redemption” in RDR2 he went back and gaslit all those young natives
@@Foxxxxmwah i reckon remastered rdr1 would be so much cooler tbh like damn
But there won't be no redemption.,, The Callander Brother's is still on the very top for the protagonist candidate
@@gencfgchm7021 the callender brothers are the worst protagonists for a redemption arc lmao. Charles literally says they were bastards who couldn't and didn't have the opportunity to change, and an incredibly important character dying anticlimactically at the start of the 2nd game would be profound bullshit
@@pearofman Knowing how Rockstar fucks up their remasters I doubt it would be good (also it got cancelled cuz GTA VI)
*anything happens to john in rdr2*
Me: well hes alive in rdr1
Same 😂😂😂😂
He gets a scar
But dies in Rdr1
When he got shot at the train robbery in rdr2 i was like "nah hes fine he'll shrug it off"
@@davidl3266 yeah because you knew he survive
"Abigail gives birth to Jack shortly after John joins the gang"
J O H N W A S 1 2
He messed up jack's birth, as jack is 12 in the epilogue meaning he couldnt be born in in 1886
In the first one, John mentions they had a daughter but she died
@Noble Phantazm lol
@Noble Phantazm I don't know why I'm still using lol as an act of surprise if I know that it means "lots of laughs", I just was surprised, I trust you bc I'm in highschool right now, and there are a lot of "kids" that think that life is only about sex.
@Noble Phantazm I didn't call you that, this is my experience in my high school 🤷🏼♂️
John: gets $20,000+ at the end of RDR2 epilogue
Also John: flat broke in RDR
I thought the same thing. I literally just finished playing RDR2 all the way through for the second time and came to watch this video. heh.
The government probably took it away since it's illegal money
@@Lsttar man that makes sense
He had to pay the bank
@@joegarrison5911 He paid the bank but got to keep the 20k
just realized that jack will live through ww1 and ww2
He could even see the moon landing
maybe even if lucky then 2000
I dont think john would join the army after the army killed his father or maybe jack would be a legendary warrior in the battle field or he just becomes uncle
If he lives...its been confirmed...RDR3 is about Edgar Ross' elderly wife seeking revenge after her husband's death!!
ive been thinking about that too
Red Dead Redemption 3 : Jack's grandchild grounded at home watching tv and gardening at his house for coronavirus lockdown
LMAO
more like great grandchild
HAHAHAHAHA
I’d play lol
Lol
Arthur died?
Well...
*meanwhile in heaven
Arthur: HAHA FOUND YA LENNY!
Just me Playing yeah, Lenny and Arthur has fun in heaven together❤️
Magnus Spang first, No Homo, second, yes they can be drunk together now
thank u you made me happy
SaiyanFamNik exactly
What about Hosea?
Arthur: "Don't look back."
John: "Don't look back."
Jack: "You Edgar Ross?"
Crew Giver yeah it sucks that you only play as him in the end of the game
@@justinportillo3996 exacly
Jack marston they should focus on jack marston in the third red dead
Justin Portillo nah I recon it’s too late I’m the timeline I recon they are gonna go even further back in time
Steve Stir yeah also wtf happened to red harlow man I miss him he was the og red dead of the series
I love how both games feel different. Rdr 2 feelings more like a spaghetti western (loud trumpet music, more epic battles) and rdr 1 feelings more like an old western, like end of an era. Theres some scenes in rdr 1 that feel like it’s on a sound stage of an act of a play
Rdr2 never felt like a spaghetti western. Rdr1 one did and had some the silliness which I miss in rdr2.
You are so so wrong. Rdr2 doesnt feel like a spaghetti western at all
@@garrysmith1029 I despised the silliness in rdr1, in terms of cutscenes and characters. Gameplay was too goofy but also fun.
Rdr1 has more epic battles and rdr2 isnt even spaghetti western as unlike rdr1 it doesnt have a mostly classic desert western map
I was so heartbroken when Arthur died. I still loved that fact that you got to play as John again.
~Standum Shaker....~
(or whatever the first word is)
No since they were too lazy to keep johns original hair
and john would be dead anyway
BeNork that was so we got over our depression
You forgot one of the saddest deaths
Your horse, it’s sad because of how Arthur spends the time to thank them and say goodbye until they die
It hit me really hard, man. I've been riding my boah (Ardennes) since chapter 2. It had been loyal to me till the end. Never once did it buck me off, and I had level 4 bonding. I miss my boah.
Taha Killer you’ll get through this, just remember that Boah died a hero
@@clementine7200 yes, it died a hero. RIP boah.
My Bessie died near the end of Chapter 4 when I got ambushed by the Lemonye Gang and I saw last second that they had a gattling gun. She died a second before I did. She was the cheapest horse you can buy when you first ride into Valentine. RIP Bessie
@@kami1 what horse did you get after Bessie died?
When Milton died, I was so happy. He killed Hosea, a member I really liked, and his other Pinkerton detectives killed Lenny.
Clorox Bleach rip Lenny
Yea but hosea died with dignity died as a man and died the sane we lived by the gun
Hosea and Lenny my two favorite wtf
LENNNNNYYY
Jim Milton didn't kill Hosea
Sadie Adler carried chapter 6 and epilogue, Her and Arthur were such a great duo.
They could make a rdr3 w her as the main character tbh
@@yaboioz4673 She’s the best female in the game
Wait...
In RDR1 they killed John since he was the “last” member of Van Der Lind’s gang. What they didn’t realize is that at the end of RDR2 Charles Smith flees to Canada. This means Charles Smith is the last survivor of the gang...
king chris and sadie
ROCK Agario idk I don’t really count her as a gang member since she didn’t really make an appearance until towards the end of the game
king chris she joined the gang in the first chapter!!!
ROCK Agario ya but she didn’t participate in anything until the end of chapter 3
king chris yes but she was still pretty important in the gang despite showing her worth very late, and there is also tilly Mary Beth and Karen and a few more who lived
1899: RDR2
1907: RDR2 epilogue
1911: RDR
1914: RDR ending
RDR ends just before WW1 damn I didn't know that
Rotten Potato it specifically ends in November of 1914. It talks about the British declaring war on the Ottomans which happened in November 1st, 1914
@@mrsky67 damn, I would've loved to see some front like action. Similarly to what we seen in RDR2 with the civil war people
I thought Jack grown was 1916
Ryan Sansaricq Nah. If you buy the final Blackwater newspaper the date is at the top. It will say ‘MCMXIV’ which is Roman numerical for 1914
Hosea: Let’s lay low.
Dutch: Ok *actually lays low*
Roll end credits.
that would be the bad ending cus micah would still be alive
@tu tu Micah is why the Pinkertons were after the gang.
@@khaos5085 micah only does that on chapter 6 after guarma
@@ambivalentaxe No Micah betrayed the gang that lead to the Pinkertons going after the gang in the first place.
The Robbery only failed because of Micah.
Ya cause then Cornwall wouldn’t come for them in valentine, they make a score, and head back west
There's a reason why John and Arthur are the most loveable characters in the Red Dead Redemption franchise, because they just want to do good in a world run by bad people.
I hope we see a 3rd game about the rise of the Van Der Linde Gang.
A prequel to a prequel huh
Damn... Arthur and John's relationship through out the game is amazing, they went from despising each other to becoming brothers...
And opposite for arthur and dutch
they were always brothers
Arthur only started hating john after he ditches when jack was born
They were always Brothers Arthur was just mad at him
True
When Arthur dies:
"WHERE ARE YA LENNEY!"
When John dies:
"WHERE ARE YA ARTHUR!"
Some dude from St. Denis dies:
"HAS ANYONE SEEN GAVIN?"
Am I the only one who red it with their voices in my head
when sadie dies:
where are ya jakey?
Angelo Bronte When you die, WheRe are yA duTch
Sean:
“Where are ya you fool”
Are we just gonna ignore the fact That Dutch left John for death TWICE and He also left Arthur for dead
Cause he is the mastermind and basically adopted them for him to use them....he is a evil man.
He left Arthur for dead twice aswell
@@killzone1401
first one in oil & tar shoot out and 2nd when Arthur dies in the mountain
he left arthur for dead twice
It all leads up to a 0lan he has a plan😂
Fun fact: The Pinkertons were a REAL private security company and, I believe, was accurately portrayed in RDR2. Rockstar clearly got inspiration from U.S. history with Cornelius Vanderbilt, and how they incorporated the history of that agency to their advantage was impressive.
Funny enough, the Pinkerton Detective Agency still exists today (albeit under a different name and on a much more limited scale since the rise of the FBI).
Ferb, I know what we're going to do today.
Not a different name
Dutch: I have a plan.
Dutch in 1911: I *had* a plan
Dead You always have a plan dutch..... this ones a good one..... falls off a clif😂
Dead bet he wishes he had a river at the edge of that cliff hah remember that mission in rdr2
@@quentinsmith3801 wE cAn'T fIgHt GrAvItY
"Dutch, Micah and Arthur are stranded on the island of guarma"
*Bill is literally in the scene with them*
Javier : 👁👄👁
Also Javier 👁️👃👁️
👄
Javier: am i a joke to you?
Javier: "You always was a Puto"
Don’t forget Javier
1899: uncle catches a very serious case of
L U M B A G O
Very hard and deadly sickness
You gosh darn imposter!
Red Harlow no-one remembers your game but i think it’s awesome
oh remember, its T E R M I N A L L U M B A G O
@@invsionry So do I.
Red Dead Redemption 2 is the best open world game that I have ever played to date. The story, the attention to detail, everything. RdR2 is an absolute masterpiece.
Slash Arnold that’s Rockstar for ya. They make genius games
Even Witcher 3 is good
@@kingofthehillawa5331 I tried to get into the Witcher 2 and 3 and I couldn't do it. But those are more hardcore RPG's and im admittedly more of a casual player
king of the hill awa witcher who what? Lmfao swept under the rug😂
But have you played minecraft
Would then be so cool to see this continue into rdr 3 where we follow Jack as he fights in WW1 and grows into a main role in the 20’s mafia scene. He could reunite with Sadie and see early cars and Tommy guns etc, but in the end, he falls back to classic Wild West behaviour to win or die.
sadie died in the timeline of rdr1 it says it in a news paper i think
@@Swazyy999 ah damn
@@Swazyy999 sadie wasnt even invented as a character yet
Has anyone seen Gavin?
I still didnt but i think the serial killer killed gavin
AMP GAMER No! This cant be!? Thats a horrible thought!
@@nigeltheenglishman2180 im so sorry for you lose... Take this moneh boah
AMP GAMER but how can i know, if You’re talking the truth?
@@nigeltheenglishman2180 you didnt told me how he looks like boah
Dutch as a baby: ma...
Father: Look! He is going to say his first word!
Mother: He will say mommy!!!
Father: No, he will say daddy!!!
Dutch: *pLAn*
No it's FAITH
You made me burst out laughing Xd 🤣🤣
Moneh!
no it's, MONEH
I N S I S T
Baby Arthur: le le le
Mama: he’s gonna say his first words
Baby Arthur: LENNY!!!
BAHAHAHHAAHAH
Man it was so cool lol😂😂😂😂😂😂
Baby Arthur: o o o
Mama: he's gonna say his first words!
Baby Arthur: Ok I'll catch you later then
AAAAAH I FOUND YA LENNNNNAAAAAAAAYYYYYYY
LENNNYYYYYYY MAH BOAAAAHHHHHH
Baby uncle: bu bu bu
Mama: he's gonna say his first words
Baby uncle: LuMbAgO
From 26 down to 1. These 2 games are so amazing. Makes me feel like it's my history aswell.
Sadie and Charles survived, so technically 3
@@heroesinhoodies1210well if we’re being like that then should put Reverend and Tlewany in.
Honestly I wished this was adapted to a HBO or Netflix series. Easily could be 40 episodes for each game.
God no.
Godless on netflix was a good series.
Christian C it could totally work as a tv show, but it would have to be actually made by the story people of rockstar or else it would suck
That wouldn't work because of the honor system
@@zyzyfuss the canon acts that Arthur would do are quite obvious
This is why this game saga is the best ever made. The story line is so fcking good. They could make a movie series offa this
Fernando Flores have you actually played the games or just watched this video? the whole damn story is rich, nice joke.
Fernando Flores sucks for you if you didnt enjoy it
Fernando Flores Play the game
I was thinking the same thing about it being a movie series, it would be bad ass.
same I think the red dead games would make great movies
1914:jack writes red dead book
2013:The book is located in the mansion of franklin (gta v)
Really xDd?
I guess Franklin would keep antiques in his house. That book is 99 years old. Actually no because that book was made a couple years after 1899 and gta v takes place in 2013.
It can be found on a couple of bookshelves in different locations.
Yeah only the games are set in different universes
@@kingucrimson5383 no
You forgot. Jack Marston writes a book about his funny deep voiced uncle and his dads law escapades in a book called red dead in Los Santos where he retired in 1970. His book was a top seller in the gta universe and is on the shelves in gta 5
I just realised......... Arthur died 120 years ago. So did Hosea and Lenny And Kieran and your horse
And Sean, my fella, and Sean too.
Crazy if u think about it
The Dynamic Doggo And Molly, Mrs Grimshaw, Jenny and Davey and i can’t remember what happens to Mac I think he dies maybe not
@@ivorweatherhead1776 Leopold Strauss and Karen too
Yup. Now they are just dust. Nothing more
1: Remaster Red Dead Redemption.
2: Start making Red Dead Redemption 3 meanwhile, cuz i love the series.
Mr. Yeet they probably are
Who you think we'll be main player in the 3rd
will bass I definetly think Jack Marston, but who knows ;)
I doubt they’ll do Jack Marston since that’s basically the end of the Wild West but I feel like they’re either going to start a new arc or continue on with the Van Der Linde gang by going back further and having Dutch as the protagonist recruiting all the gang members.
A Sadie/Charles team up type thing would be awesome. It wouldn't necessarily have to be years later, more like months later after they parted ways with John and before RDR.
I hope they make Red Dead Redemption 2 Undead Nightmare where Arthur comes back to life and tries to confront Dutch
I kinda doubt it. That would mean that the plague already happened in the first one but it was unseen thing in the first undead nightmare.
But if they make new undead nightmare I hope its not as buggy and would have some sick Tank from left4dead or demolisher from dying light type of zombies.
YES
well the undead nightmare in the first one isn't cannon or anything like that so they could do it again
Kinda like Dead Rising 4: Frank Rising?
@@joshuabernier4444 Not canon but events before it were and no plague was mentioned in it. They could do it but it just wouldn't make that much sense.
You forgot the most important part. Jack Marston presumably tells the stories of his family and his life to someone who then writes a book about it. The title of the book is Red Dead Redemption and it can be found as an Easter egg in GTA 5 Franklin's apartment on a bookshelf.
it's just an easter egg, i doubt it ties into the RDR story, since RDR and GTA V aren't in the same universe
5:59 actually they each got 15 dollars and a quarter, don’t forget the quarter
Shut up Arthur.
He set us up
John could’ve paid off the MacFarlanes with that
@@izla381 yes
Ryan Lecours not worth hoseas life
Red Dead Redemption 3: A hardened Jack fresh off a return ship after surviving the trenches of WWI finds himself caught in the rise of the original American Gangsters profiting off the illegal alcohol market in Chicago.
Or he could've gotten out of World War II. Jack's story could take place all the way into the 1980's
I want to see the origins of Arthur when he was a boah...
Crazando anonymous Jack would be a bit old for WW2. He was born in 1895, which would have made him in his late 40s in WW2. Too old for anyone but a higher ranking officer.
Tyler Spehr a hard-on Jack??
Crazando anonymous Boi he was born in 1895
"The blackwater massacre was the bloodiest one"
People of Valentine:
Pfft, amateurs.
Policemen of Saint Denis: Bruh
@@enbiann6663 man f**k saint denis my horse is just walking he hit a useless citizen and the WHOLE US ARMADA after me
I rly enjoyed when JOHN comes back for charles and the first word he said is I HATE SAINT DENIS
*the Blackwater Massacre was the bloodiest one*
Me: haha watch this! *kills over about 50 lawmen and gets a bounty of over $1500*
@@connorpikula The entire town of Blackwater pretty much caught on fire-
And btw on RDR1, my sister goes to Macfarlanes Ranch and just shoots everything and everyone
we NEED a prequel to rdr2. I've heard people wanting rdr3 to be about jack during a ww1 or prohibition era and I think thats a pretty cool idea to play as jack in a flashback to ww1 and maybe see him deserting but I think a prequel where you play as dutch or hosea about the early years of the gang leading up to the blackwater massacre would be better.
Hosea dies... john dies...arthur dies... if they is in the heavens
Arthur will say... “FOUND YA LENNY!!!” poor young lenny
No he will say
GaViN i fOuNd YOo
CYKO Gachaverse dude ha ha found ya Lenny!!! You’re right
Lennys death surprised me and pissed me off to no end
And Micha will be talking to saten
Satan when he sees Micah enter hell: My time has come.
I named my horse Arthur Jr. The "thank you" scene nearly killed me. Never thought I'd cry over a game
Same friend.
I name my horse as Johnss lmaoo
You're not alone cowpoke :')
Lmao
I named mine Arthur II
Imagine how cool it would be for rockstar to make a remaster edition of red dead redemption 1 with graphics and physics
would totally make sense now bc rdr2 is such a hit and many ppl havent played rdr
@@animeshsingh3300 Plus look at the map the old think missing from RDR us Mexico.
They could make RDR a remastered DLC.
And I’m actually a bit confused why they wasted all that map without even using it?
@@kylethedalek I guess there's no Mexico cause there's nothing really to do their in rdr2
@JustDr3f I know what I mean is in rdr1 going there is necessary for John but there'd be no reason for Arthur go there
That could actually come out because it is rumored
Im hitting the thumbs up automatically because I just finished the RDR2 story and it is amazing- now I need to know the full storyline linking the first game to this masterpiece of a storyline.
Dutch: Arthur,how could you
Arthur: *COUGHING VIOLENTLY AND WHEEZING*
Dutch: HAVE SOME GOD DAMM FAITH
Are you a satanist?
All of these replies are just about his profile picture, XD.
Gross profile pic
You like black metal? :D
Cool pfp B)
Yes, one beloved character dies facing a sunrise
*Now lets talk about the* *giveaway*
@@JazzyJeff910 The good honor helping John escape is the canon ending
@@clorobec2625 Says who? Just curious. I was assuming the opposite, i mean, if ur right and the cannon story is that Arthur is part of the reason John survived and got out long enough to get that farm for his family, ud think John would have mentioned him at least once in RDR1 but he never does, so the ending where Arthur leaves John n goes for the money kinda makes more sense in the whole story does it not?
Cloro yea the bad one has a wolf and the good one have the deer cutscene when he dies
May I Stand Unshaken
Cloro i got executed by micah😐
Everyone's talking about how sad it was that Arthur died, and I agree, he's by far my favourite character. But, the saddest scene in my opinion is when his horse got shot, and Arthur went back to put his girl (his horse) to sleep. Legit made me tear up 😢😭😭
it did that cutscene and it wasn’t that sad for me bc my oh horse died bc of a damn rock😂😂 and the horse that died in the cutscene was one i had to steal like right before it happened so it didn’t really mean that much to me lmao
Granny Juices yes because the death of your horse is more sad than the the death of the character you’ve literally spent the whole game as
@@gaflgon3115 Key words: in my opinion.
As an animal lover, yes, because Arthur's death was predicted but the horse's was not. Also as someone that's lost pets in the past, the scene hits close to home. So if you don't like opinions that differ from yours, please kindly fuck off :)
Omg yes
I HAD BUELL THE HORSE YOU GET FROM HAMITCH , I WAS SUPPOSED TO TAKE CARE OF HIM, AND HE DIED. I cried for a good ten minutes.
Even though everyone knows it's "just" a game, gotta give props to Rockstar for definitely tugging on human emotions. It's amazing what good storing writing does to people whether it be a book, movie or a freakin game! I vote for Tarantino to make this a movie.
And I vote for Jon Bernthal to play John Marston
@@tst8613 I can see Tom Hardy or Wyatt Russell as Arthur Morgan
It’s gotta be a Tv show. You throw away too much character development if it’s just a two hour film.
Notice how jack is wearing John’s hat and Arthur’s coat
myALIASis If they make the rdr1 remake I hope they change Jack’s coat to make it the same jacket Arthur used.
Johns hat IS arthur hat. Silly boah
Tom Williams No, they have different hats.
@@oasistuperware4596 are you sure about that? Im talking prologue... Arthur gives john his hat. As you play as john, thats arthurs hat..
@@tommysuhlami6241 in the wardrobe you can choose between "Arthur's hat" and "John's classic hat" so they are different
All of the characters that died would’ve sided with Arthur e.g. Lenny, Hosea, Sean and Kieran
But they conveniently die. Also Lenny's death made me depressed as I loved him.
Kieran got killed off way too early IMO.
This made me uncomfortably sad
And Sean most likely
And sadie if she was there
Every NPC in the game: Continuously calling Arthur an old man
Arthur: I’m goddamn 36
Being in your 20s was considered old back then, as people didn’t have the life expectancy they do now due to modern technology.
Erik Allen ohhhhh
@@erikallen3804 really shows the strength of Hosea. Imagine being what some would call elderly in the old west in one of the most infamous gangs. I remember this camp interaction where Bill is drunk and isn't doing anything, Hosea steps in and bosses him around in the most badass of ways.
@@erikallen3804 not seen as old. Only reason why live expectancy back then was about 47-50 years olds is due to how often a child would die at birth. If you made it past 2 years old there was still a good chance of hitting 65-70. Hitting 60 was not at all unheard of back thing and 20-29 is still a young person even back then
Dude 36 is old af back in that time your lucky you lasted till 40 not even
Dutch: mo-
Dutch’s mom: he’s gonna say mom!!
Dutch: money!!
Arthur is still the best character
I agree
(11/25/18)
John is 100x better
Chris Thurber i think arthur is
I’m not liking you’re comments not because I disagree but I like literally them both the same, so I agree if anyone loves John or Arthur the best but I love both.
I like Arthur over John
16:15 “Life is peaceful” dead body on the ground.
Playerunknown Cj johnson 😂
Lol
😂😂
no one
absolutely no one:
uncle: *_IT...ITS THE LUMBAGO_*
The sad fact is that Javier wasn’t even pointing his gun
Poor Arthur after everything he’s done, he sacrificed himself for everyone :(
Arthur was a good man....he did what was right and did all he could for the gang.
He should HaVe HaD MoRe GAwD DaMn FaiTh in DuTcH’s PLAN!!
And didn't even get what he wanted. It was all for nothing.
@@jakobwaack4148 Charles, Sadie and Gave John more 17 years to live peacefully.
imagine what would have happened if he survived guess who Ross would force john to kill. would that really be a better end? i mean they pretty much took out all of the important figures of the VdL gang apart from the ones who werent important enough to appear on the agencys radar thats why it was pretty clear that arthur and hosea wouldnt make it to the next game
The crazy thing about this entire series is the entire story is built for Jack to get revenge. Such a small moment in an epic scale.
Red dead redemption 3:rise of the Van der linde gang
Red dead redemption 2:fall of the van der linde gang
Red dead redemption 1:end of the van der linde gang
I’ve always wanted to see how the gang banded together with young Arthur, Dutch and hosea. I especially wanted to play the blackwater massacre as a prologue to rdr2
Yes, Hosea is my favourite character I would love to play as him.
ye i think its good thing the game will be showing us backstory if we countinued jack story it would be boring
It's evolving, just backwards
@@Soap.-- nah I definitely think there is a promising future with Jack. Here me out. A battle hardened Jack returns from World War 1 and finds himself in Chicago where he gets tangled up with the mob.
I kept the shire you steal after burning the tobacco fields and called her Guinevere. Cried like a baby when she dies at the end of the game. Cried again when Jack was talking about King Arthur and lady Guinevere in the epilogue. My little role play came full circle
Who else cried when Arthur died?
@@surface-talent5701 I cried when he got coughed on
I cried every time he’d spit out blood man. I sobbed for the longest time when he died... had to pause my game
Damn you guys are a bunch of a babies.
Made me so upset bro
Same as I did when John Marston got gunned down.
Just slap the title Red Dead Redemption 3 on Red Dead Redemption 2's cover, don't change anything except letting Micah die and not doing the Downes Ranch mission, that way Arthur and everyone lives, makes money, and goes back out west.
Could be the story off RDR2 undead nightmare
TAHITI
@@uncleflagzz nahhh. do it all again different in australia
@@kevinmalone354 makes since because Australia was built by criminals and outlaws
Men, can this story become even more sad? Arthur, an awesome caracter Gets killed by a gangmember while helping a friend, John.
Then we become John who wants to start over and be there for his wife and son, but the law Finds him and kills him as well, leaving his son and wife.
Men can cry about it.
Men are allowed to cry anyway.
And then became jaxk
Can men also cry when a lowly gunslinger trying to change his ways proposes to the mother of his child while on a row boat using the ring left to him by an old friend? Asking for a friend
@@deanobeany Hell's yeah
Joachim M RIP Sean
13:41 the salesman is mentioned in the gunsmith store book in rdr2 where if you look at one of the stories on the sawed off shotgun page a lady scared the salesman away with the sawed off, another small connection of rdr2 to rdr1
6:13 Guess Javier and Bill weren't in Guarma. Must have been a mirage.
Arthur: Whats the plan dutchh....
Dutch:I HavE a PlaN! We BoRroW soMe MoNey oFf UncLe Sam aNd Go tO CuBa
Arthur: *sighs disappointed*
Dutch: WhY aRe YoU AlWaYs DoUbTiNg Me SoN
@@weavesnatched6664 HaVe SoMe FAiTh
that moment yer watchin a red dead video and find some dude you went to school with in the goddamn comments
I wanted to see Tahiti for myself instead I died somewhere else with tuberculosis
Why can I hear that 😂
Sometime after 1914: Jack learns of his father's surviving members and manages to reunite with Sadie and Charles...
I like to imagine they meet up with Josiah In Saint Denis, 1920s, and become a gang in the roaring 20s
no he just gets lumbago
Or maybe he was later drafted into the Great War :)
@@ydu1234 You think he want to work for the goverment after what they did to his father?
@Anas Mohamed Yeah but he barely had any records of existing so he could easily dodge the draft. Also, he would be around 22-23 in 1917, so the likelihood of him being chosen when there were already hundreds of thousands of younger men is pretty slim.
1:08
Hosea wasn't "young". He was 34 in 1878, which is just two years younger than what Arthur's age is in 1899.
Also fun fact: When John joined the gang, Arthur was 22. That is how old John was when he became a father.
10:46 Red Dead Redemption 1 cover
Edit: Thank you guys for all the likes! This cutscene gave me nostalgia.
Yh i noticed that too
And if you refuse to shoot he ends up shooting automatically
I always feel like crying whenever I play the ending when Arthur dies
u said it like there was ending where he didnt die
@@Soap.-- not in our hearts he doesnt
@@dallanwallannnnn ye
@@Soap.-- There was, when mary ask arthur to run away and arthur said need cash. At the moment i have 17k in pocket that enough to run away to other contitnents with mary
Would love a rdr3 where you see how Dutch and hosea formed the gang and how each member joined
Too long. Who the hell will the voice actors be? It should be about either before Blackwater, after the fall of the gang.
I really wouldn't mind a game about the native americans in the mid-late 19th century. Watching your tribe be betrayed and massacred by the Americans, losing hope year by year, day by day. Your way of life being forced out of existence, your culture being attacked and what else? you decide.
Performing ambushes to the army would be magnificent..
Tucked away beside a tree, waiting for that signal.
Nothing, Nothing, Nothing.
Boom, trees fall from back and front and you get it.
HELL YEAH! Hosea for RDR3! I want to see the begining of Dutch & Hosea, when they found Arthur and John and when he tried to leave Dutch being for Bessie but slowly drifted back to the gang, their first bank job with young Arthur... DAMN thats a game right there!
@@SamGarso I feel like It's too far past.
Possibly before Blackwater Job, with Mac, Jenny and all the other folks who didn't make it east.
Connecting the dots from that massacre which is covered in mystery
@@Sirius1914 civil war is the answer
When i finished this game i was sad. Because it was over and it was such a fun game.
It was the most perfect game ever.
Nothing is perfect. But Red dead 2 is damn near
It was one of the most well designed games I have ever played the amount of detail they have put into this game is great
My first playthrough was quick just wanted to know the story... My second one was slow with High Honor, my third was even slower I wanted that 100% completion but with very low honor with that said; bad honor Arthur was the most fun I've ever had with a game!
Was otherworldly, still not as good as the witcher 3
@@pauliliesi witcher was so borinf for me i couldnt complete it wdym
Dutch: guys i have a plan
Gang: **sighs** what is it
Dutch: so theres this boat
Dutch:and the boat has some goodies on it.
ONE LAST TRAIN, AND WE CAN GO TO *tAhiTi*
And, that was his downfall.
I actually never played RDR so I feel a lot of the twists were more powerful since I didn’t know that John was the main character or any of this happens
Agreed, I just finished Red dead 2 and it made it way more intense not knowing who would die or survive.
Same here
Actually I beat rdr 1 a few days ago on ps now!
same
That does sound interesting. But now that you have I strongly recommend getting the first one it's truly amazing. On par with the second just not as crazy in depth cause of the tech limitations of the time
I like it how he Explained every Timeline from Red Dead Redemption games so we can Know which to Play so we can get the full Timeline!
I hope you can Create more Videos on more Timelines from Games, Amazing Video! You've gained a Subscriber!
I’m so glad you included Arthur’s TRUE ending for this video... Has anyone seen the low honor ending? It literally makes me sick to watch.
my ending was bad. im actually deppressed. Arthur got stabbed my micah but Im gonna replay the game and end with good honour to see arthur die peacefully.
Don Galloway You should!! And make sure to go with John instead of heading back for the money, It’s way better :))
m_odrosky4 Umm 😐 how Micah jumps you beats you up and then Dutch steps on the gun that would’ve saved your life them Micah either gets mad and walks away or shoots you in the head after Arthur’s last words “Damn is all Micah” I mean I chose it but the way you die ain’t much different
Just Crystal Only Crystal Yes but it’s much more meaningful and it’s how Arthur would’ve wanted to go out. High honor Arthur is the best Arthur, the actual Arthur. All endings are very sad but this one is definitely his true ending, how Rockstar wants us to see Arthur go out.
m_odrosky4 he kinda didn’t dude the way he wanted to. Just a little. 2/3rds of his death were complete. He wanted to die watching the sunrise facing west, but he was actually facing east and barely had the chance to even take 5 seconds to even remember one good moment. But yeah his death was pretty peaceful, I got shot in the head and I wasn’t even sad, or depressed. I was literally pissed off lol. Like “what? This is how it goes? This is how he dies?! By a piece of shit?! Wtf rockstar, you could’ve done better than this!” Then i realised it was because of my honour lol
The whole game, the gang runs after some few thousand dollars to flee to tahiti 😂...me as arthur carrying 6000+$ nd not telling anyone.
Me giving all my money to the camp, tell Dutch I got the money, how are we gonna leave? Dutch respond: ''I don't know, start dancing?'' He must had hit he's head pretty hard in that Saint-Denis Trolley...
It is his money
😂
I just wish I could dawg it pisses me off so hard
RDR3 is gonna be how the gang is formed and im gonna fall in love with the protagonist and not want to play as Arthur in the Epilogue
Yio Something I don’t think so
Arthur is better character than john his voice his body his face and his thoughts and feelings and the character development it’s all so thought out and detailed
John is great but I don’t know his character is nothing so unique so I doubt it
Maybe the new protagonist (if there’s one) will be well written character with great voice actor and great character design but i don’t it will be so much better than Arthur
Yio Something what if you play as Dutch ...
Umm I think it will be about jack....
VorteX X nope. Jack is the end of the rdr timeline since it’s the end of the west. The series has to work backwards. When most the stories are told, Jack shooting Edgar ross will be thought of as the end of the west.
@@janetfromanotherplanet1301 Yeah but he can fall in with a gang and I guess he will be the first protagonist who doesn't die.
This redemption saga. I can honestly say no one loves it like I do.
It’s all like warm blanket. No matter what mood I’m in it makes me feel better. I connect more with this game than every film and TV show. Personally that is.
Thankyou rockstar for the redemption story. Truly the best fictional story in any source of entertainment
They should remaster the first red dead.
PS4 people 😂😂
Or make a DLC of the first game for rdr2 since theyve got new austin with nothing in it.
They should remaster it and add some new dialogue that mentions Author.
@@jessefranco6823 Yeah, you can play the first Red Dead on PS4, but you can't on Xbox.
Charlie Haisman do u hear your self?
I love how much Jacks outfit in 1914 resembles Arthur's preferred outfit
YoursTruly :3 John’s hat and Arthur’s coat 🧥
@@xllrrz_7890 And Dutch's facial hair
Maybe this was intended, rockstar maybe implemented these small things (like Arthur’s coat) into the prequel to act as an analogy. Jack grew up around the gang and took an example of every single one of them: Arthur’s fashion sense, Dutch’s Wisdom, Hosea’s love of literature, John & Arthur’s shooting skill etc.
Just a theory.
ricochet
Jose’s
I want a jack red dead redemption but I want a happy ending for him, no death a happy ending finally for the Marston family and a tribute to Arthur.
No happy endings for an outlaw. Jack threw himself in that life when he killed Ross
And full free roam after endgame
“Revenge is a fool’s game”, Jack already doomed himself by doing the exact opposite of what he should’ve done. Arthur was wise, and Jack is just like his father; a stubborn man. There’s no happy ending in a horror story.
I wanna play as a gun-slinging Jack in the Prohibition era
I think jack became a writer bc in gta5 there is a book in franklin's house named "red dead" by JM (which is jack marston)
Best part is the speculative stories. Let's say you left a few missions behind it shows Jack up to be masterful in manipulating others. Add to the fact that if you consider rdr and gta in the same universe, he goes on to become a writer, putting his scholarly skills to work. So it's presumed Jack went on to have a more peaceful life after getting his revenge. So likely case is he just killed Edgar Ross, it got marked as a cold case or a hunting accident. Then went on to gain some money and publishing the stories of his dad and Arthur