The Complete Red Dead Redemption Timeline! | The Leaderboard

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 28 вер 2024
  • The Red Dead Redemption series is full of outlaws, robbery, plot twists, betrayal, and so much more. Join The Leaderboard as we unpack the complete Red Dead Redemption timeline.
    Don't miss our videos, make sure you subscribe! frdr.us/TLBsubs...
    Red Dead Redemption series takes you back to the wild west and lets you be the outlaw you always wanted to be. Rockstar has created such an amazing story within Red Dead Redemption and Red Dead Redemption 2 that we thought we unpack the complete timeline of the Red Dead Redemption series.
    Want to see more timelines of your favorite games? Then check out this playlist here: frdr.us/2MRdjm1
    Do NOT forget to visit our UA-cam friends!
    Channel Frederator - frdr.us/YTCFyou...
    Cartoon Hangover - frdr.us/YTCHyou...
    #RedDeadRedemption #Videogames #VideoGameCulture
    Credits for This Episode
    -----------------------------------
    Researched by: Christina Polk
    Written by: Christina Polk
    Hosted by: Justice Washington
    Edited by: Kyle Beauregard
    Executive Producers: Carrie Miller, Fred Seibert, Jeremy Rosen
    Producers: Adrian Apolonio
    Project Manager: Jessica Ferrer
    Head Writer: Casey Gonzalez
    Graphics and Thumbnail by: Alexandria Batchelor
    Programming Manager: Darrian P. Mack
    Your Home For Video Game Facts! The Leaderboard offers fascinating insights, development history, tips & tricks, as well as the latest in news and commentary about your favorite games past and present. We cover a mix of AAA titles and indie releases with compelling characters and deep stories. We upload about 7 times a week Chat with us on Discord (The Leaderboard Fam) / discord .
  • Ігри

КОМЕНТАРІ • 11 тис.

  • @TheLeaderboard
    @TheLeaderboard  Рік тому +130

    Have an idea for a video? Submit it here: amagipublishing.com/idea-submission/the-leaderboard-idea-submission/

    • @strv81
      @strv81 Рік тому +3

      Hi

    • @barneythethug
      @barneythethug Рік тому +2

      The bendy and the Ink machine timeline

    • @lawjef
      @lawjef Рік тому +1

      Some ppl, acted the way this video essay describes. To suggest that most ppl went in that direction, even in the Wild West, is pseudo history and pretty poor fact checking, frankly. Makes it difficult to take this channel seriously. It’s full of hyperbole and pure speculation. I’m out

    • @20hridaybhojani34
      @20hridaybhojani34 6 місяців тому

      😂à😂​@@strv81

  • @tonysantiago8459
    @tonysantiago8459 5 років тому +3378

    Dutch's plan would've worked if everyone just had some GOD DAMN FAITH

    • @yhayaalam651
      @yhayaalam651 5 років тому +114

      Tony Santiago and sum MORE MONEY

    • @julianassange5971
      @julianassange5971 5 років тому +155

      @@yhayaalam651 JUST ONE LAST TRAIN

    • @Batman89057
      @Batman89057 5 років тому +105

      @@julianassange5971 AND IT'S ALWAYS A GODDAMN TRAIN

    • @loribryant2250
      @loribryant2250 5 років тому +18

      Don't use the Lord's name in vain

    • @Genesiscoupejay
      @Genesiscoupejay 5 років тому +35

      ALWAYS DOUBTIN

  • @narvea
    @narvea 4 роки тому +10335

    the saddest part is, despite John and Arthurs' best efforts to keep jack from becoming an outlaw, he did anyway.

    • @HODOUTHINKUAR
      @HODOUTHINKUAR 3 роки тому +194

      so true

    • @thatboyab7642
      @thatboyab7642 3 роки тому +366

      The outlaw life will never end it seems😔

    • @snaggerdagger591
      @snaggerdagger591 3 роки тому +1639

      Not all true, in gta v, in franklins house on the book shelf, you can see a book called red dead, by J.Marston, I believe he became a writer.

    • @grandmasuzieiscracked6895
      @grandmasuzieiscracked6895 3 роки тому +538

      @@snaggerdagger591 I never noticed that. What a sweet little Easter egg

    • @clayschwartzwalter382
      @clayschwartzwalter382 3 роки тому +159

      Do we know he continued the outlaw life after the end of RDR?

  • @brandonanderson510
    @brandonanderson510 4 роки тому +8353

    You missed an important point, Arthur has a kid with a lady before Jack is born, he never leaves the gang but tried to take care of the boy. One day he finds the lady and his son murdered. This changed Arthur, made him meaner. Then Jack is born and john leaves, when John returns Arthur cannot forgive him, he is jealous John has his boy, and it angers him that he lost his. This is an important emotional piece of Arthur Morgan.

    • @mr_pepsiman8471
      @mr_pepsiman8471 3 роки тому +135

      Well said

    • @4thDistrictKey
      @4thDistrictKey 3 роки тому +488

      THIS is why Arthur hates John ?! I was so lost when they were talking ... I’m starting from RDR2 🤦🏾‍♂️

    • @gokusayan
      @gokusayan 3 роки тому +30

      @@4thDistrictKey did u finish it?

    • @4thDistrictKey
      @4thDistrictKey 3 роки тому +237

      @@gokusayan Yes a few days ago BEST Game EVER

    • @raniidaki3543
      @raniidaki3543 3 роки тому +521

      His son's name was Isaac and be was a good kid! Arthur cannot forgive John, not because of jealousy - it is because he abandoned his family, where Arthur has none. Arthur knows how it feels like to have lost his own family, that's why he is angry at John for abandoning his family.

  • @viswajitbala7924
    @viswajitbala7924 2 роки тому +3187

    Actually, Jack brings the Marston family legacy to great heights. In GTA V, you can see a book on the shelf in Franklin’s new house titled “The American Dream” by Jack Marston. Jack wrote about Arthur and John’s lives and explained their bravery throughout the years. A perfect ending to the Red Dead Redemption Series.

    • @D3ATHDUDE2
      @D3ATHDUDE2 2 роки тому +80

      Wait really?

    • @wafflesarebest1702
      @wafflesarebest1702 2 роки тому +55

      @@D3ATHDUDE2 yeah its real

    • @D3ATHDUDE2
      @D3ATHDUDE2 2 роки тому +112

      @@wafflesarebest1702 well damn I guess ya learn something new every day

    • @kratos5754
      @kratos5754 2 роки тому +226

      @@D3ATHDUDE2 'you forget a thousand things every day. Make sure this isn't one of them'

    • @xxxCrushed.Editzzxxx
      @xxxCrushed.Editzzxxx Рік тому +73

      I'm pretty sure in GTA Online there is also a character who is John Marston's great great grandson.

  • @antplays2474
    @antplays2474 4 роки тому +14450

    Red dead redemption 1: I wanna play as John not jack
    Red dead redemption 2: I wanna play as Arthur not John

    • @chaynon4225
      @chaynon4225 4 роки тому +1651

      Red dead redemption 3: I wanna play as Davey not Arthur

    • @ProGamer00008
      @ProGamer00008 4 роки тому +1252

      Red dead redemption 4 I wanna play as hosea not davey

    • @x-hazzy513
      @x-hazzy513 4 роки тому +1192

      Red dead redemption 5: I wanna play as Uncle not hosea

    • @samw4
      @samw4 4 роки тому +704

      Red dead redemption 6: I wanna play as Lenny not micah

    • @ProGamer00008
      @ProGamer00008 4 роки тому +343

      ThinkerHats you messed up, it’s Lenny not uncle

  • @AshleyOnOvertime
    @AshleyOnOvertime 4 роки тому +4744

    John: gets $20,000+ at the end of RDR2 epilogue
    Also John: flat broke in RDR

    • @matthew1257
      @matthew1257 4 роки тому +252

      I thought the same thing. I literally just finished playing RDR2 all the way through for the second time and came to watch this video. heh.

    • @Lsttar
      @Lsttar 4 роки тому +614

      The government probably took it away since it's illegal money

    • @atr_g10
      @atr_g10 4 роки тому +94

      @@Lsttar man that makes sense

    • @joegarrison5911
      @joegarrison5911 4 роки тому +104

      He had to pay the bank

    • @Lsttar
      @Lsttar 4 роки тому +105

      @@joegarrison5911 He paid the bank but got to keep the 20k

  • @edagaming3074
    @edagaming3074 5 років тому +1728

    *anything happens to john in rdr2*
    Me: well hes alive in rdr1

    • @gauravbatra6226
      @gauravbatra6226 5 років тому +26

      Same 😂😂😂😂

    • @chiefchief2871
      @chiefchief2871 5 років тому +9

      He gets a scar

    • @earthwormsally3059
      @earthwormsally3059 5 років тому +6

      But dies in Rdr1

    • @davidl3266
      @davidl3266 5 років тому +133

      When he got shot at the train robbery in rdr2 i was like "nah hes fine he'll shrug it off"

    • @LiamFordCr395ash
      @LiamFordCr395ash 5 років тому +2

      @@davidl3266 yeah because you knew he survive

  • @Pro_Butcher_Amateur_Human
    @Pro_Butcher_Amateur_Human 3 роки тому +752

    I really want a Red Dead Redemption 3 where you play as Dutch, rescuing and recruiting the members of the gang, and building Dutch's mystique and reputation. Ends with the Blackwater Ferry job.
    It'd be interesting to see the old Dutch who lived the ideals he preached, and inspired such loyalty in those around him.

    • @Foxxxxmwah
      @Foxxxxmwah Рік тому +36

      It’d be nice to see the kindhearted part of Dutch that we learned about, we barely saw glimpses of him 😂😂 it was always corrupted Dutch, in either game despite his “redemption” in RDR2 he went back and gaslit all those young natives

    • @pearofman
      @pearofman Рік тому +19

      @@Foxxxxmwah i reckon remastered rdr1 would be so much cooler tbh like damn

    • @gencfgchm7021
      @gencfgchm7021 Рік тому +4

      But there won't be no redemption.,, The Callander Brother's is still on the very top for the protagonist candidate

    • @BratMilorad
      @BratMilorad Рік тому +8

      @@gencfgchm7021 the callender brothers are the worst protagonists for a redemption arc lmao. Charles literally says they were bastards who couldn't and didn't have the opportunity to change, and an incredibly important character dying anticlimactically at the start of the 2nd game would be profound bullshit

    • @him053
      @him053 Рік тому +3

      @@pearofman Knowing how Rockstar fucks up their remasters I doubt it would be good (also it got cancelled cuz GTA VI)

  • @huhwaitwhat9147
    @huhwaitwhat9147 4 роки тому +2630

    Arthur: *dies*
    Two seconds after: "Do YoU WaNt tO gET a FrEe CoNsoLe?!?"

    • @Max200012
      @Max200012 4 роки тому +208

      Honestly man, ruined the moment for me. That was the worst ad placement I've ever seen

    • @omarhilal8780
      @omarhilal8780 4 роки тому +76

      No respect.. RIP Arthur

    • @lolmetyuri
      @lolmetyuri 4 роки тому +11

      Indeed no respect

    • @logan7673
      @logan7673 4 роки тому +1

      They're just trying to get that free promotion from 3 year olds, and I disrespect that

    • @davidus9702
      @davidus9702 4 роки тому

      Use Brave Browser guys, no adds.

  • @kingchris9167
    @kingchris9167 5 років тому +3462

    Wait...
    In RDR1 they killed John since he was the “last” member of Van Der Lind’s gang. What they didn’t realize is that at the end of RDR2 Charles Smith flees to Canada. This means Charles Smith is the last survivor of the gang...

    • @hasibmohammad1959
      @hasibmohammad1959 5 років тому +907

      king chris and sadie

    • @kingchris9167
      @kingchris9167 5 років тому +163

      ROCK Agario idk I don’t really count her as a gang member since she didn’t really make an appearance until towards the end of the game

    • @hasibmohammad1959
      @hasibmohammad1959 5 років тому +839

      king chris she joined the gang in the first chapter!!!

    • @kingchris9167
      @kingchris9167 5 років тому +133

      ROCK Agario ya but she didn’t participate in anything until the end of chapter 3

    • @hasibmohammad1959
      @hasibmohammad1959 5 років тому +529

      king chris yes but she was still pretty important in the gang despite showing her worth very late, and there is also tilly Mary Beth and Karen and a few more who lived

  • @kiko1935
    @kiko1935 4 роки тому +627

    "Dutch, Micah and Arthur are stranded on the island of guarma"
    *Bill is literally in the scene with them*

  • @zakplayz617
    @zakplayz617 3 роки тому +674

    just realized that jack will live through ww1 and ww2

    • @bigjohn8925
      @bigjohn8925 3 роки тому +71

      He could even see the moon landing

    • @HaiderPlayz_cool
      @HaiderPlayz_cool 3 роки тому +36

      maybe even if lucky then 2000

    • @roboticcyclone1935
      @roboticcyclone1935 3 роки тому +17

      I dont think john would join the army after the army killed his father or maybe jack would be a legendary warrior in the battle field or he just becomes uncle

    • @gtrman12887
      @gtrman12887 3 роки тому +22

      If he lives...its been confirmed...RDR3 is about Edgar Ross' elderly wife seeking revenge after her husband's death!!

    • @karolis5376
      @karolis5376 3 роки тому +2

      ive been thinking about that too

  • @nigeltheenglishman2180
    @nigeltheenglishman2180 5 років тому +4568

    Has anyone seen Gavin?

    • @sidious69
      @sidious69 5 років тому +178

      I still didnt but i think the serial killer killed gavin

    • @nigeltheenglishman2180
      @nigeltheenglishman2180 5 років тому +143

      AMP GAMER No! This cant be!? Thats a horrible thought!

    • @sidious69
      @sidious69 5 років тому +83

      @@nigeltheenglishman2180 im so sorry for you lose... Take this moneh boah

    • @nigeltheenglishman2180
      @nigeltheenglishman2180 5 років тому +40

      AMP GAMER but how can i know, if You’re talking the truth?

    • @sidious69
      @sidious69 5 років тому +14

      @@nigeltheenglishman2180 you didnt told me how he looks like boah

  • @YousefTobail
    @YousefTobail 5 років тому +1907

    1899: RDR2
    1907: RDR2 epilogue
    1911: RDR
    1914: RDR ending

    • @Joshie117
      @Joshie117 5 років тому +113

      RDR ends just before WW1 damn I didn't know that

    • @mrsky67
      @mrsky67 5 років тому +111

      Rotten Potato it specifically ends in November of 1914. It talks about the British declaring war on the Ottomans which happened in November 1st, 1914

    • @Joshie117
      @Joshie117 5 років тому +32

      @@mrsky67 damn, I would've loved to see some front like action. Similarly to what we seen in RDR2 with the civil war people

    • @geordiejones5618
      @geordiejones5618 5 років тому +17

      I thought Jack grown was 1916

    • @mrsky67
      @mrsky67 5 років тому +46

      Ryan Sansaricq Nah. If you buy the final Blackwater newspaper the date is at the top. It will say ‘MCMXIV’ which is Roman numerical for 1914

  • @boomheadshot5578
    @boomheadshot5578 5 років тому +765

    When Milton died, I was so happy. He killed Hosea, a member I really liked, and his other Pinkerton detectives killed Lenny.

    • @Brandon-vy5kv
      @Brandon-vy5kv 5 років тому +15

      Clorox Bleach rip Lenny

    • @corysartin4558
      @corysartin4558 5 років тому +8

      Yea but hosea died with dignity died as a man and died the sane we lived by the gun

    • @Bigdogwaste
      @Bigdogwaste 5 років тому +15

      Hosea and Lenny my two favorite wtf

    • @riri2130
      @riri2130 5 років тому +12

      LENNNNNYYY

    • @spiny3286
      @spiny3286 5 років тому +2

      Jim Milton didn't kill Hosea

  • @jonathanpruegert3007
    @jonathanpruegert3007 4 роки тому +5591

    Arthur: "Don't look back."
    John: "Don't look back."
    Jack: "You Edgar Ross?"

    • @justinportillo3996
      @justinportillo3996 4 роки тому +202

      Crew Giver yeah it sucks that you only play as him in the end of the game

    • @thephoenix4093
      @thephoenix4093 4 роки тому +30

      @@justinportillo3996 exacly

    • @justinportillo3996
      @justinportillo3996 4 роки тому +135

      Jack marston they should focus on jack marston in the third red dead

    • @stevestir8628
      @stevestir8628 4 роки тому +102

      Justin Portillo nah I recon it’s too late I’m the timeline I recon they are gonna go even further back in time

    • @justinportillo3996
      @justinportillo3996 4 роки тому +26

      Steve Stir yeah also wtf happened to red harlow man I miss him he was the og red dead of the series

  • @satanick9376
    @satanick9376 5 років тому +736

    Red Dead Redemption 2 is the best open world game that I have ever played to date. The story, the attention to detail, everything. RdR2 is an absolute masterpiece.

    • @stancexpunks
      @stancexpunks 5 років тому +39

      Slash Arnold that’s Rockstar for ya. They make genius games

    • @kingofthehillawa5331
      @kingofthehillawa5331 5 років тому +7

      Even Witcher 3 is good

    • @satanick9376
      @satanick9376 5 років тому +11

      @@kingofthehillawa5331 I tried to get into the Witcher 2 and 3 and I couldn't do it. But those are more hardcore RPG's and im admittedly more of a casual player

    • @kushsmoker4206
      @kushsmoker4206 5 років тому

      king of the hill awa witcher who what? Lmfao swept under the rug😂

    • @yogeebear2599
      @yogeebear2599 5 років тому +3

      But have you played minecraft

  • @isaiahchapman7660
    @isaiahchapman7660 2 роки тому +49

    There's a reason why John and Arthur are the most loveable characters in the Red Dead Redemption franchise, because they just want to do good in a world run by bad people.
    I hope we see a 3rd game about the rise of the Van Der Linde Gang.

    • @SALskem
      @SALskem 9 місяців тому +1

      A prequel to a prequel huh

  • @srenaml3632
    @srenaml3632 5 років тому +898

    Hosea: Let’s lay low.
    Dutch: Ok *actually lays low*
    Roll end credits.

    • @armitx9
      @armitx9 5 років тому +29

      that would be the bad ending cus micah would still be alive

    • @khaos5085
      @khaos5085 4 роки тому +4

      @tu tu Micah is why the Pinkertons were after the gang.

    • @ambivalentaxe
      @ambivalentaxe 4 роки тому +4

      @@khaos5085 micah only does that on chapter 6 after guarma

    • @khaos5085
      @khaos5085 4 роки тому +5

      @@ambivalentaxe No Micah betrayed the gang that lead to the Pinkertons going after the gang in the first place.
      The Robbery only failed because of Micah.

    • @blakefedie16
      @blakefedie16 4 роки тому

      Ya cause then Cornwall wouldn’t come for them in valentine, they make a score, and head back west

  • @Joebreadcrumbs
    @Joebreadcrumbs 2 роки тому +12

    You forgot the most important part. Jack Marston presumably tells the stories of his family and his life to someone who then writes a book about it. The title of the book is Red Dead Redemption and it can be found as an Easter egg in GTA 5 Franklin's apartment on a bookshelf.

    • @issatr5p
      @issatr5p 2 роки тому

      it's just an easter egg, i doubt it ties into the RDR story, since RDR and GTA V aren't in the same universe

  • @usiboy123
    @usiboy123 5 років тому +363

    1: Remaster Red Dead Redemption.
    2: Start making Red Dead Redemption 3 meanwhile, cuz i love the series.

    • @johnsmith5068
      @johnsmith5068 5 років тому +3

      Mr. Yeet they probably are

    • @willbass3436
      @willbass3436 5 років тому +3

      Who you think we'll be main player in the 3rd

    • @usiboy123
      @usiboy123 5 років тому +8

      will bass I definetly think Jack Marston, but who knows ;)

    • @SonGohan-fx3vb
      @SonGohan-fx3vb 5 років тому +29

      I doubt they’ll do Jack Marston since that’s basically the end of the Wild West but I feel like they’re either going to start a new arc or continue on with the Van Der Linde gang by going back further and having Dutch as the protagonist recruiting all the gang members.

    • @NeedyForMusic
      @NeedyForMusic 5 років тому +8

      A Sadie/Charles team up type thing would be awesome. It wouldn't necessarily have to be years later, more like months later after they parted ways with John and before RDR.

  • @ryanlecours9083
    @ryanlecours9083 5 років тому +331

    5:59 actually they each got 15 dollars and a quarter, don’t forget the quarter

    • @thriiftyman
      @thriiftyman 5 років тому +26

      Shut up Arthur.

    • @youngkobee
      @youngkobee 5 років тому +12

      He set us up

    • @izla381
      @izla381 5 років тому +13

      John could’ve paid off the MacFarlanes with that

    • @Omar-up4jp
      @Omar-up4jp 4 роки тому +1

      @@izla381 yes

    • @wxnstonprivate2302
      @wxnstonprivate2302 4 роки тому +1

      John got rich from Blackwater and cheat codes.

  • @JorgeGarcia-jy5yg
    @JorgeGarcia-jy5yg 5 років тому +1444

    Notice how jack is wearing John’s hat and Arthur’s coat

    • @olathecola7691
      @olathecola7691 5 років тому +139

      myALIASis If they make the rdr1 remake I hope they change Jack’s coat to make it the same jacket Arthur used.

    • @tommysuhlami6241
      @tommysuhlami6241 5 років тому +87

      Johns hat IS arthur hat. Silly boah

    • @oasistuperware4596
      @oasistuperware4596 5 років тому +81

      Tom Williams No, they have different hats.

    • @tommysuhlami6241
      @tommysuhlami6241 5 років тому +26

      @@oasistuperware4596 are you sure about that? Im talking prologue... Arthur gives john his hat. As you play as john, thats arthurs hat..

    • @TrollingVeteran
      @TrollingVeteran 5 років тому +111

      @@tommysuhlami6241 in the wardrobe you can choose between "Arthur's hat" and "John's classic hat" so they are different

  • @johnuwu7175
    @johnuwu7175 4 роки тому +2102

    Imagine how cool it would be for rockstar to make a remaster edition of red dead redemption 1 with graphics and physics

    • @animeshsingh3300
      @animeshsingh3300 3 роки тому +173

      would totally make sense now bc rdr2 is such a hit and many ppl havent played rdr

    • @kylethedalek
      @kylethedalek 3 роки тому +44

      @@animeshsingh3300 Plus look at the map the old think missing from RDR us Mexico.
      They could make RDR a remastered DLC.
      And I’m actually a bit confused why they wasted all that map without even using it?

    • @lewanbroski504
      @lewanbroski504 3 роки тому +6

      @@kylethedalek I guess there's no Mexico cause there's nothing really to do their in rdr2

    • @lewanbroski504
      @lewanbroski504 3 роки тому +6

      @JustDr3f I know what I mean is in rdr1 going there is necessary for John but there'd be no reason for Arthur go there

    • @wya.dIiego
      @wya.dIiego 3 роки тому +1

      That could actually come out because it is rumored

  • @christopherthurber8667
    @christopherthurber8667 5 років тому +2129

    Arthur is still the best character

    • @prowthegamer
      @prowthegamer 5 років тому +27

      I agree
      (11/25/18)

    • @A_29886
      @A_29886 5 років тому +46

      John is 100x better

    • @fatloser6413
      @fatloser6413 5 років тому +20

      Chris Thurber i think arthur is

    • @sammyhiggs4202
      @sammyhiggs4202 5 років тому +37

      I’m not liking you’re comments not because I disagree but I like literally them both the same, so I agree if anyone loves John or Arthur the best but I love both.

    • @Wuisini
      @Wuisini 5 років тому +53

      I like Arthur over John

  • @warh1story563
    @warh1story563 3 роки тому +16

    Dutch: mo-
    Dutch’s mom: he’s gonna say mom!!
    Dutch: money!!

  • @jackjackson6378
    @jackjackson6378 3 роки тому +561

    I named my horse Arthur Jr. The "thank you" scene nearly killed me. Never thought I'd cry over a game

  • @mxl_xxlyra2734
    @mxl_xxlyra2734 4 роки тому +515

    Every NPC in the game: Continuously calling Arthur an old man
    Arthur: I’m goddamn 36

    • @erikallen3804
      @erikallen3804 4 роки тому +42

      Being in your 20s was considered old back then, as people didn’t have the life expectancy they do now due to modern technology.

    • @mxl_xxlyra2734
      @mxl_xxlyra2734 4 роки тому +1

      Erik Allen ohhhhh

    • @hamgurger9160
      @hamgurger9160 3 роки тому +31

      @@erikallen3804 really shows the strength of Hosea. Imagine being what some would call elderly in the old west in one of the most infamous gangs. I remember this camp interaction where Bill is drunk and isn't doing anything, Hosea steps in and bosses him around in the most badass of ways.

    • @JoeMama-oz4ed
      @JoeMama-oz4ed 3 роки тому +18

      @@erikallen3804 not seen as old. Only reason why live expectancy back then was about 47-50 years olds is due to how often a child would die at birth. If you made it past 2 years old there was still a good chance of hitting 65-70. Hitting 60 was not at all unheard of back thing and 20-29 is still a young person even back then

    • @CRAZYMAN-yv5qc
      @CRAZYMAN-yv5qc 3 роки тому +3

      Dude 36 is old af back in that time your lucky you lasted till 40 not even

  • @tristenlaflamme4737
    @tristenlaflamme4737 4 роки тому +180

    6:13 Guess Javier and Bill weren't in Guarma. Must have been a mirage.

  • @juliocarlos8890
    @juliocarlos8890 Рік тому +16

    The sad fact is that Javier wasn’t even pointing his gun

  • @axphine
    @axphine 5 років тому +1291

    Who else cried when Arthur died?

    • @casualfridays4051
      @casualfridays4051 5 років тому +28

      @@surface-talent5701 I cried when he got coughed on

    • @phaedraceleste5582
      @phaedraceleste5582 5 років тому +46

      I cried every time he’d spit out blood man. I sobbed for the longest time when he died... had to pause my game

    • @EddieMachetti
      @EddieMachetti 5 років тому +42

      Damn you guys are a bunch of a babies.

    • @harrybenstead7250
      @harrybenstead7250 5 років тому +7

      Made me so upset bro

    • @GreatNinjaman
      @GreatNinjaman 5 років тому +20

      Same as I did when John Marston got gunned down.

  • @wannabeyoutuber3056
    @wannabeyoutuber3056 5 років тому +1666

    Dutch as a baby: ma...
    Father: Look! He is going to say his first word!
    Mother: He will say mommy!!!
    Father: No, he will say daddy!!!
    Dutch: *pLAn*

  • @thekidthatdoesnotcaredothe6855
    @thekidthatdoesnotcaredothe6855 4 роки тому +1648

    Red dead redemption 3:rise of the Van der linde gang
    Red dead redemption 2:fall of the van der linde gang
    Red dead redemption 1:end of the van der linde gang

    • @VerminSupremeFanPage
      @VerminSupremeFanPage 3 роки тому +364

      I’ve always wanted to see how the gang banded together with young Arthur, Dutch and hosea. I especially wanted to play the blackwater massacre as a prologue to rdr2

    • @noisy_killjoy
      @noisy_killjoy 3 роки тому +67

      Yes, Hosea is my favourite character I would love to play as him.

    • @Soap.--
      @Soap.-- 3 роки тому +52

      ye i think its good thing the game will be showing us backstory if we countinued jack story it would be boring

    • @owaisazmeer4564
      @owaisazmeer4564 3 роки тому +70

      It's evolving, just backwards

    • @zetros2533
      @zetros2533 3 роки тому +52

      @@Soap.-- nah I definitely think there is a promising future with Jack. Here me out. A battle hardened Jack returns from World War 1 and finds himself in Chicago where he gets tangled up with the mob.

  • @ghost.2527
    @ghost.2527 Рік тому +8

    we NEED a prequel to rdr2. I've heard people wanting rdr3 to be about jack during a ww1 or prohibition era and I think thats a pretty cool idea to play as jack in a flashback to ww1 and maybe see him deserting but I think a prequel where you play as dutch or hosea about the early years of the gang leading up to the blackwater massacre would be better.

  • @frankmcgarry3155
    @frankmcgarry3155 5 років тому +780

    They should remaster the first red dead.

    • @jessefranco6823
      @jessefranco6823 5 років тому +25

      PS4 people 😂😂

    • @jakobwaack4148
      @jakobwaack4148 5 років тому +45

      Or make a DLC of the first game for rdr2 since theyve got new austin with nothing in it.

    • @eagleeye4169
      @eagleeye4169 5 років тому +49

      They should remaster it and add some new dialogue that mentions Author.

    • @bigmanjorge
      @bigmanjorge 5 років тому +4

      @@jessefranco6823 Yeah, you can play the first Red Dead on PS4, but you can't on Xbox.

    • @jessefranco6823
      @jessefranco6823 5 років тому +2

      Charlie Haisman do u hear your self?

  • @JuanLopez-pw6el
    @JuanLopez-pw6el 5 років тому +220

    16:15 “Life is peaceful” dead body on the ground.

  • @harrisonwright3900
    @harrisonwright3900 3 роки тому +90

    Would love a rdr3 where you see how Dutch and hosea formed the gang and how each member joined

    • @Sirius1914
      @Sirius1914 3 роки тому +3

      Too long. Who the hell will the voice actors be? It should be about either before Blackwater, after the fall of the gang.
      I really wouldn't mind a game about the native americans in the mid-late 19th century. Watching your tribe be betrayed and massacred by the Americans, losing hope year by year, day by day. Your way of life being forced out of existence, your culture being attacked and what else? you decide.
      Performing ambushes to the army would be magnificent..
      Tucked away beside a tree, waiting for that signal.
      Nothing, Nothing, Nothing.
      Boom, trees fall from back and front and you get it.

    • @SamGarso
      @SamGarso 3 роки тому +4

      HELL YEAH! Hosea for RDR3! I want to see the begining of Dutch & Hosea, when they found Arthur and John and when he tried to leave Dutch being for Bessie but slowly drifted back to the gang, their first bank job with young Arthur... DAMN thats a game right there!

    • @Sirius1914
      @Sirius1914 3 роки тому +2

      @@SamGarso I feel like It's too far past.
      Possibly before Blackwater Job, with Mac, Jenny and all the other folks who didn't make it east.
      Connecting the dots from that massacre which is covered in mystery

    • @mindofvirtuoso3358
      @mindofvirtuoso3358 4 місяці тому

      ​@@Sirius1914 civil war is the answer

  • @NajeebDaGamer
    @NajeebDaGamer 5 років тому +376

    red dead 3 needs to be dutch having a plan to find gavin,(I know Dutch dies in rdr1 but dutches plan was to make us think he’s dead... yeah think about it)

    • @Jack-zs9ui
      @Jack-zs9ui 5 років тому +40

      Najeeb-da-gamer - plot twist gavin is in Tahiti and Dutch was trying to go save him all along

    • @altaiordubadi6938
      @altaiordubadi6938 5 років тому +3

      Who is gavin

    • @NajeebDaGamer
      @NajeebDaGamer 5 років тому +8

      @@altaiordubadi6938 exactly

    • @felorpy
      @felorpy 5 років тому +3

      Dutch died...

    • @Darjeeling_Gup
      @Darjeeling_Gup 5 років тому +2

      @@altaiordubadi6938 english man

  • @shoof6388
    @shoof6388 2 роки тому +5

    I kept the shire you steal after burning the tobacco fields and called her Guinevere. Cried like a baby when she dies at the end of the game. Cried again when Jack was talking about King Arthur and lady Guinevere in the epilogue. My little role play came full circle

  • @YoursTruIy_
    @YoursTruIy_ 5 років тому +156

    I love how much Jacks outfit in 1914 resembles Arthur's preferred outfit

    • @xllrrz_7890
      @xllrrz_7890 5 років тому +7

      YoursTruly :3 John’s hat and Arthur’s coat 🧥

    • @enokimaru
      @enokimaru 5 років тому +6

      @@xllrrz_7890 And Dutch's facial hair

    • @ricochet4805
      @ricochet4805 5 років тому +17

      Maybe this was intended, rockstar maybe implemented these small things (like Arthur’s coat) into the prequel to act as an analogy. Jack grew up around the gang and took an example of every single one of them: Arthur’s fashion sense, Dutch’s Wisdom, Hosea’s love of literature, John & Arthur’s shooting skill etc.
      Just a theory.

    • @Agent.K.
      @Agent.K. 5 років тому

      ricochet
      Jose’s

  • @Tsudkyk
    @Tsudkyk 2 роки тому +7

    Im hitting the thumbs up automatically because I just finished the RDR2 story and it is amazing- now I need to know the full storyline linking the first game to this masterpiece of a storyline.

  • @petroll.02
    @petroll.02 5 років тому +142

    Dutch: guys i have a plan
    Gang: **sighs** what is it
    Dutch: so theres this boat

    • @savielflores678
      @savielflores678 5 років тому +3

      Dutch:and the boat has some goodies on it.

    • @fjoweo
      @fjoweo 5 років тому +2

      ONE LAST TRAIN, AND WE CAN GO TO *tAhiTi*

    • @thejayu8057
      @thejayu8057 5 років тому

      And, that was his downfall.

  • @probablyworth3088
    @probablyworth3088 3 роки тому +4

    13:41 the salesman is mentioned in the gunsmith store book in rdr2 where if you look at one of the stories on the sawed off shotgun page a lady scared the salesman away with the sawed off, another small connection of rdr2 to rdr1

  • @levigiles4759
    @levigiles4759 5 років тому +216

    10:46 Red Dead Redemption 1 cover
    Edit: Thank you guys for all the likes! This cutscene gave me nostalgia.

    • @paulluevanos1027
      @paulluevanos1027 5 років тому +3

      Yh i noticed that too

    • @Omfgwhtavid
      @Omfgwhtavid 5 років тому +3

      And if you refuse to shoot he ends up shooting automatically

  • @drpatricius3566
    @drpatricius3566 5 років тому +1006

    Played both games. I think Arthur is more interesting and more badass

    • @uncleclem7381
      @uncleclem7381 5 років тому +63

      Dr Patrícius He is great but I love me some John Marston

    • @h_as0san
      @h_as0san 5 років тому +16

      @@uncleclem7381 jhon marston death was everything😐😐

    • @roon568
      @roon568 5 років тому +3

      Agree

    • @llag549
      @llag549 5 років тому +46

      John is badass as hell too . Dont you remenber Mexico ?

    • @CR-ej6nx
      @CR-ej6nx 5 років тому +3

      Same

  • @cookcuh1
    @cookcuh1 3 роки тому +1

    RDR 3: Takes place in 1859 a fellow farmer named Zac Cole his friends has died from a ambush but zac killed the gang and ran to the wild west and then he takes his revenge and kills anyone who bothers him then he meets a guy named Jimmy McGill and forms a gang.

  • @4ncest0r
    @4ncest0r 5 років тому +138

    Bill shoots John
    *shows some random guy shoot John in the hip*
    Yeah...bill shot him...

  • @MrCodysVideos
    @MrCodysVideos 4 роки тому +47

    "Dutch, Micah and Arthur go on a boat to Cuba"
    Bill: yeah I was right there too but whatever

  • @MyisticGamer
    @MyisticGamer 3 місяці тому +2

    I like it how he Explained every Timeline from Red Dead Redemption games so we can Know which to Play so we can get the full Timeline!
    I hope you can Create more Videos on more Timelines from Games, Amazing Video! You've gained a Subscriber!

  • @SebG1234
    @SebG1234 2 роки тому +2

    I actually met Roger Clark the voice of Arthur Morgan yesterday at the fan expo in Vancouver he was really nice and I got his autograph he’s one of the nicest guys ever

  • @timunderwood1941
    @timunderwood1941 5 років тому +248

    You forgot about ms Grimshaw and her death 😢

    • @trashyvirus3058
      @trashyvirus3058 4 роки тому +4

      Lenny is bendy

    • @griff1240
      @griff1240 4 роки тому +13

      Molly too

    • @jaywhypapi8690
      @jaywhypapi8690 4 роки тому +12

      And Kieran 😢😢

    • @azultarmizi
      @azultarmizi 4 роки тому +7

      @TitansFan1997 nah, Molly was innocent

    • @cubixman9676
      @cubixman9676 4 роки тому +2

      @@azultarmizi Was molly the girl who got drunk and told the pinkertons the location of the gang?

  • @shoa3199
    @shoa3199 Рік тому +1

    1914-1918 Jack Marston was drafted in 1917 to fight on the eastern front where he met a German private infantry named Adolf Schicklgruber.

  • @themobilemercenary1782
    @themobilemercenary1782 4 роки тому +490

    I couldn’t help but feel for Dutch, it’s like his whole world crumbled around him. The man who he called his son slowly dying. His father figure dying in front of his eyes. I just could understand his pain, I never even viewed him as a villain until he was ready to leave Arthur and John for dead.

    • @Jackrazorus
      @Jackrazorus 2 роки тому +2

      How about shooting an innocent girl before the story even starts?

    • @neelchaudhary8993
      @neelchaudhary8993 2 роки тому +7

      @@Jackrazorus It was a bad situation

    • @qsh1ne
      @qsh1ne 2 роки тому

      Since I moved from a small village into a bigger city, I have become a leader and former of a semi large friend group, I feel Dutch and the moralic questionable decisions he made, cuz even it‘s wrong, sometimes u gotta watch out for u before anyone else, just as telling everyone u‘ve a plan a tousand times when u rly got no idea what to do or where to go, just to keep the boys 2gether.

    • @XxMonkeyman3831xX
      @XxMonkeyman3831xX 2 роки тому +62

      @@qsh1ne you think ur real life Dutch 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

    • @jmy871
      @jmy871 2 роки тому +7

      Dutch only cared about himself

  • @Angellopez-pl7nj
    @Angellopez-pl7nj 5 років тому +270

    You know what he forgot in every year in the timeline.......that uncle has LUMBAGO

    • @rafatulalam8677
      @rafatulalam8677 5 років тому +4

      That uncle was the most funniest character in the game

  • @dwightk.schrute5291
    @dwightk.schrute5291 3 роки тому +298

    When jack gets kidnapped, i could feel the rage of Aurthor and Dutch.

  • @Eric-xo1pm
    @Eric-xo1pm Рік тому +2

    Quite literally the best games I have ever played, no game brought me closer to tears. 10/10 would recommend

  • @kanyewestgrandpa3356
    @kanyewestgrandpa3356 4 роки тому +574

    Let’s be honest the prologue we really wanted was authur meeting Lenny in heaven

  • @socalledabdullah76
    @socalledabdullah76 2 роки тому +1

    I have completed rd2 but no way I imagined that girl they saved at the start of the game because Sadie Adler,the most vicious at of all of them

  • @tonydbest23
    @tonydbest23 5 років тому +27

    After Arthur I was pissed, I really thought I was gonna have to pick up horse shit all my life.

  • @lirbic
    @lirbic 5 років тому +42

    Best part, Arthur took Jack fishing

  • @HolySych
    @HolySych 2 місяці тому +1

    i love how it’s like star wars with the backwards evolving story

  • @imcuh9318
    @imcuh9318 5 років тому +218

    There’s not a single old western game that compares to red dead

    • @hayleyscarberry
      @hayleyscarberry 5 років тому +11

      Have you heard about GUN? It's just as good. It came out in 2005 and I believe it started the Red Dead series in a way.

    • @ltpiccione7914
      @ltpiccione7914 5 років тому +16

      @@hayleyscarberry no it didn't , it was Red Dead Revolver that started the Red Dead series , but it's non canon

    • @rmcgowa1987
      @rmcgowa1987 5 років тому +1

      Gun was quite good too just not triple a

    • @Shockkings0714
      @Shockkings0714 5 років тому

      @@ltpiccione7914 what does non canon even mean

    • @poh4883
      @poh4883 5 років тому +5

      Gesù Cane Red Dead Revolver *is* canon to Red Dead Redemption.
      You can hear stories about Revolver's characters in campfires.

  • @sugenorami8385
    @sugenorami8385 4 роки тому +315

    *Hmm...*
    Why did Arthur not just use "Horse reviver thing" at the ending , still sad though

    • @BogusLettuce
      @BogusLettuce 4 роки тому +33

      The horse was shot in the heart. Horse reviver can’t fix that.

    • @sexyqbit
      @sexyqbit 4 роки тому +50

      The guy who shot his horse probably used express bullets

    • @mozoelkady11
      @mozoelkady11 4 роки тому

      Coz he's a black lung (I also asked that when my horse died)

    • @rudolfhubert7809
      @rudolfhubert7809 4 роки тому +7

      My Horse name was siklinde... she was a white Arab i found in the mountains.. i didnt know it was one of the best horses i just wanted a white one. She was with me on early start till the end.. RIP ZIKLINDE :(((

    • @MariaM-ek3og
      @MariaM-ek3og 3 роки тому

      @@rudolfhubert7809 omg same,but I called her Winter 😔

  • @dn_mochaone4566
    @dn_mochaone4566 2 роки тому +1

    Now that we aren’t confused with which game goes first, play RDR2 first and then RDR1 so you can keep track of the story all in order

  • @dee8171
    @dee8171 Рік тому +1

    Depending on how the player plays the characters. I would think they're could be alternate timelines for Arthur and John too.
    Like, one universe, Arthur was an asshole who got shot in the head at the top of the mountain, or an asshole who went for the money and got stabbed by Micah. Or a good guy who went for the money and died after his fight with Micah.
    Or in one universe, John catches Javier but kills bill. Or in another universe he kills Javier but allows the Spanish guy to kill bill after Bill goes for a gun when he gets up off the ground.

  • @swaaws
    @swaaws 5 років тому +34

    “Settle into their new lives on the right side of the law”
    Yeah right, as if we don’t all still go crazy in the epilogue

    • @justgavin_
      @justgavin_ 4 роки тому

      I don't do it as much. I roleplay like John, so he would do the lawful things.

  • @Connor65-t1b
    @Connor65-t1b 4 місяці тому +2

    The Good Ending:
    It was all Lenny and Arthur's Imagination while they where drunk and none of those deaths ever happened.

  • @akariced456
    @akariced456 5 років тому +254

    1916: Uncle's LuMBaGo has been cured.

  • @daltonfilho835
    @daltonfilho835 5 років тому +225

    This is wrong
    Abigail joined the gang when she was 17 in 1894, John was 21 by then
    Jack was only born in 1895
    John left the gang and then returned in 1896

    • @helpz8708
      @helpz8708 5 років тому +26

      Dalton Filho FBI Open up

    • @geronimowatson.j.4359
      @geronimowatson.j.4359 5 років тому +3

      And jack in rd2 is not a 14 years old boys... meh

    • @hermanPla
      @hermanPla 5 років тому

      Where did they tell you it was 1896?

    • @daltonfilho835
      @daltonfilho835 5 років тому +1

      hermanPla John went away almost as soon as Jack was born and Arthur said he went missing for a whole year

    • @Jonathan_Grant
      @Jonathan_Grant 5 років тому +1

      John was also shot in 1906

  • @danielsibrian7559
    @danielsibrian7559 5 років тому +607

    How did John abandon his family in 1886 (meaning wife and child) if jack is only 4 years old in 1899?

    • @deadtonez1349
      @deadtonez1349 5 років тому +238

      He had a daughter that died

    • @Tockin
      @Tockin 5 років тому +116

      Deadtonez Wait so he was 13 when he had a daughter and met Abigail!?!?!?

    • @andrewtalbert6067
      @andrewtalbert6067 5 років тому +93

      @@deadtonez1349 John's daughter was born after jack.

    • @STR33TSofJUST1C3
      @STR33TSofJUST1C3 5 років тому +124

      @@deadtonez1349 Their daughter was born and died after he left the gang (presumably between 1907 and 1911). Also, Abby joined the gang in 1894 and gave birth to Jack in 1895.

    • @JohnDoe-qd7gh
      @JohnDoe-qd7gh 5 років тому +39

      @@STR33TSofJUST1C3 well seeing that there's an eight year gap between rdr 2 main story and the epilogue, she was probably born sometime in there.

  • @CruzWrld1999
    @CruzWrld1999 2 роки тому +1

    Legendary grew up with red dead 2022 turning 23 thanks rockstar. 😌🔥

  • @damianhernandez1665
    @damianhernandez1665 Рік тому +1

    i used a mod that lets me use weapons in camp then made it so that micah isnt invincible in camp and then made it so that if micah dies the screen fades into the credits

  • @devestator4660
    @devestator4660 3 роки тому +1

    Rdr3. Playing Arthur's Father. Then when he dies you switch to Arthur and the story ends where he joins the gang

  • @thomasenright4983
    @thomasenright4983 5 років тому +134

    Help a blind man...

  • @WyattKing.
    @WyattKing. Рік тому

    Now all we need is red dead 3.. def about Jack writing a book about the true hero’s of the Wild West and bringing honor to his name, maybe have big WW1 events involved etc

  • @conorallen100
    @conorallen100 5 років тому +47

    1899 "end of the wild west" 1911 "okay it's actually the end this time"

  • @welcomeinternet4455
    @welcomeinternet4455 3 роки тому +2

    If bill wasnt in rdr1,he probably would have died in Gauma

  • @aidsdan8963
    @aidsdan8963 5 років тому +733

    Does anybody else think that jack in 1914 used Arthur's coat
    Edit: why so many likes

    • @Uknown76
      @Uknown76 5 років тому +25

      Maybe

    • @patricketurner
      @patricketurner 5 років тому +88

      The lapels are wrong, but it sure as hell looks like his coat.

    • @prestoncarter7242
      @prestoncarter7242 5 років тому +22

      It's not Arthur's coat

    • @aidsdan8963
      @aidsdan8963 5 років тому +15

      @@prestoncarter7242 boy I said think not OMG IT'S ARTHUR'S COAT

    • @prestoncarter7242
      @prestoncarter7242 5 років тому +15

      @@aidsdan8963 calm down, I was just saying it wasn't

  • @the_sockdolager
    @the_sockdolager 2 роки тому +2

    I first instinct when lenny died was to go back to my last save and try to shoot the guys before they shoot Lenny. The game doesn't let you I've tried everything.

  • @aidanishere6429
    @aidanishere6429 5 років тому +87

    Are we all just gonna ignore the fact that Johns character model is drastically different in the epilogue then it is in the main game

    • @ERTChimpanzee
      @ERTChimpanzee 5 років тому +4

      Only shorter hair in the Epilogue.

    • @TXetc
      @TXetc 5 років тому +16

      Looks like he got more jacked in a few years between, maybe doing hard labor or something lol

    • @datboivenom
      @datboivenom 5 років тому +11

      To be fair, it had been a couple of years. This would be like complaining that Jack's model changed between the two phases of the game.

    • @kathleenedmundson8235
      @kathleenedmundson8235 5 років тому

      It’s red dead redemption1

    • @wesleyscott1633
      @wesleyscott1633 5 років тому

      It was because of a glitch where Arthur’s weight went to John

  • @rad6864
    @rad6864 3 роки тому +4

    I honestly believe that rdr2 is the best game of all time

  • @delusionalnoodles
    @delusionalnoodles 5 років тому +169

    GTA V: How do we get the Jetpack?
    Read Dead Redemption: Who is the Strange Man?
    Red Dead Revolver: Is this game canon?
    GTA IV: Can we stop Roman?
    Red Dead Redemption 2: Where the hell is Gavin?

    • @IMNTV
      @IMNTV 5 років тому +1

      I think red dead revolver is canon...

    • @AreEnTee
      @AreEnTee 5 років тому

      I know I'm a noob for asking, but what does canon mean?

    • @delusionalnoodles
      @delusionalnoodles 5 років тому +13

      @@AreEnTee
      Canon means it actually happened in the story line. If something is not canon, it means it doesn't exist inside the storyline. For example, if something is canon, it impacts the storyline. If something is not canon, you can imagine it inside the storyline, but it does not impact it in anyway.

    • @AreEnTee
      @AreEnTee 5 років тому

      @@delusionalnoodles thx

    • @masonsinnett354
      @masonsinnett354 4 роки тому

      Im not sure, but Red Dead Revolver is one of the original Red Dead games.

  • @willhoops695
    @willhoops695 3 роки тому +2

    Jack marston went on to write a book about what he remembered in the dutch vanderlinde and about his life and his father

  • @KatimaGaming
    @KatimaGaming 4 роки тому +175

    This needs to be a movie... a trilogy. I'd pay good money to see it.

    • @caterina2290
      @caterina2290 2 роки тому +9

      Its already perfect the way it is

    • @brodytoons7603
      @brodytoons7603 2 роки тому +6

      No not even a trilogy would be enough to get the story right it would need like an entire series with one season for every chapter

    • @KatimaGaming
      @KatimaGaming 2 роки тому +4

      @@brodytoons7603 that alone would convince me to resubsribe to netflix. Hehehe

    • @benl.4577
      @benl.4577 Рік тому +2

      It's fine as is. Gamea are just as good if not a better medium to tell stories compared to live action movies

  • @princerain6651
    @princerain6651 2 роки тому

    I just started story mode and now I don’t want to finish it knowing my two favorite characters, Hosea and Lenny, are gonna die. I mean, the amount of betrayal and deaths that I already knew were gonna happen, is gonna but me so hard.

  • @damnsonwheredyoufindthis.3830
    @damnsonwheredyoufindthis.3830 5 років тому +87

    I hate the ending of the first one. Especially now that the second game clearly shows that John became a farmer.
    There was no need to kill John. I wish high or low honor would determine his death like it does with Arthur since with high honor Arthur is left to die from his sickness in peace by Micha but with low honor Micha will either stab him in the chest and back or shoot him in the face. He only lives for a few more hours in the high honor ending but him dying from sickness is way less infuriating than him dying by the hands of a rat named Micha. Exact same thing applies to Ross.

    • @beanzzz5061
      @beanzzz5061 5 років тому +25

      Damn son where'd you find this. John had to die he had to pay his consequences for being a outlaw and John dies getting redemption becoming a hero and sacrificing himself finally accomplishing his mission which is saving his family Ross wanted to kill John because he was the last piece of the puzzle and John didn’t deserve to die but had to my guess is jack kills Ross trying to get revenge and after killing him he looks down at his gun probably regretting his choice realizing that revenge doesn’t do anything so he writes a book called red dead redemption which is in gta 5 and the story probably is the story of his father and his redemption

    • @vinicinfodexota5083
      @vinicinfodexota5083 5 років тому +7

      You just dont like Greek tragedies, its fine, the ending of rdr1 was fine, depressive, but fine.

    • @hkchan1339
      @hkchan1339 5 років тому

      Best endings that you will keep remembering are the ones with classic Greek tragedies , you won't be remembering the ending if they live happily ever after

    • @damnsonwheredyoufindthis.3830
      @damnsonwheredyoufindthis.3830 5 років тому

      @@hkchan1339 Actually I would since I have finished rdr multiple times.

    • @damnsonwheredyoufindthis.3830
      @damnsonwheredyoufindthis.3830 5 років тому +1

      @@vinicinfodexota5083 I don't mind sad endings but this one was unnecessary and more enraging than sad

  • @OK-do5nh
    @OK-do5nh 5 років тому +50

    No matter what you say Arthur Morgon will always sound and be the coolest

  • @Bullets632
    @Bullets632 5 років тому +9

    You know if they would have listened to Hosea in the first place, they could have avoided the entire Red Dead Redemption 2 Era. Lay low till the storm passes, then head West. But no, Dutch wanted to rob a train instead.

    • @crandy753
      @crandy753 5 років тому

      John doe you’re right

  • @sans7998
    @sans7998 5 років тому +109

    Not all of dutchs' gang is dead sadie and Charles never are confirmed dead

    • @18tayze10
      @18tayze10 5 років тому +44

      Yeah, Pearson is alive, Charles is alive, Jack is alive, Sadie is alive.. Mary-Beth and Tilly are alive and doing well... Mainly the ones who didn't inflict too much on others were the ones who stayed alive.

    • @jermainelasalle9872
      @jermainelasalle9872 5 років тому

      @@therealcapalot he died in rdr right before John died

    • @blizzard0808
      @blizzard0808 5 років тому +3

      Its funny that one of the longest living characters alive is acually Seth. He was confirmed alive after the Zombie DLC

    • @oh-not-the-bees7872
      @oh-not-the-bees7872 5 років тому +1

      I mean, theyre dead by now.

    • @nick4949
      @nick4949 5 років тому

      its 2018 they fat ded

  • @loganentertainment1814
    @loganentertainment1814 3 роки тому +2

    Is RDR Undead Nightmare non-cannon, because I've never been able to figure it out.
    Plus, I didn't think western and a zombie apocalypse didn't fit too well. (in my opinion)
    If anyone disagrees, I'm fine with that. :)

  • @X-K-I-D
    @X-K-I-D 4 роки тому +39

    So I might be over thinking it.
    How could John have “learned” the dead eye trick if he was using it before the first read dead redemption?

    • @nickalexcage
      @nickalexcage 4 роки тому +21

      After the events of the first game John stopped being an outlaw because of the lack of practice John forgot how to use deadeye effective

    • @Brainframe1
      @Brainframe1 4 роки тому

      I was just thinking that

    • @erikallen3804
      @erikallen3804 4 роки тому +1

      He probably remembered how to use it in 1907 because of Arthur’s memory. He might’ve forgotten about it between 1907 and 1911 because he was so focused on the ranch.

    • @MNB730
      @MNB730 3 роки тому

      People here thinking like philosophists, real reason is to not remove the dead eye altogether, I mean they didn't remove Arthur's entire arsenal too they'd just need to slightly alter it I guess.
      It's not like John is known as a good shooter in RDR2 unlike Arthur or Micah

  • @gaurianilgawande5257
    @gaurianilgawande5257 3 роки тому +2

    The story of rdr series is better than any other game,movie,series,it is just a masterpiece💯😘

  • @sharktoof1
    @sharktoof1 4 роки тому +65

    Red Dead Redemption III. Telling Jacks story. Hell yes.

  • @kohanakittycat
    @kohanakittycat 5 років тому +127

    I have to tell this story because it's too funny 😂 So, I've been playing RDR2 non-stop ever since it came out (I like to complete my games to the fullest and discover everything I can). Anyways, during my first playthrough I finally managed to hogtie the Vampire from Saint Denise, and I decided I wanted to see what would happen when morning came about to see if the sun would burn him. I put him on the back of my horse and I rode out of the city to a more secluded area... At least I tried to because when I was going over a bridge a bunch of raiders ambushed me and kept shooting. I ran as fast as I could and somehow the Vampire was still alive (I checked on him once I was safe). I went a little further up the road because I was still in an suburban areas and I wanted to be away from people... As I got towards a more foresty area, I decided it would be good to go off the road and stop, but just than I heard some shouting coming from the trees and this wagon that was on fire came out of nowhere! My horse reared up from fear (this horse spooked very easily, I was still bonding level 1 with this horse, but I think the horse reared because his stamina was low from him running non stop without a break) and I fell off of him and the horse took off.... straight towards the wagon. As my horse was getting closer to the wagon it exploded killing my horse and the vampire with him 😭😂 I was so sad but at the same time laughing like crazy. Thankfully I had a save I could reload but the vampire was gone... So I can only assume he's still wandering around the world somewhere. Anyways thanks for reading and have a great day 😁

  • @randomstuff9053
    @randomstuff9053 4 роки тому +21

    I was mad when Lenny died he was my favorite I remember where are youuu lennnnny😭

  • @hobbitses221
    @hobbitses221 3 роки тому +1

    is anyone else confused by this timeline? someone tell me if my math is wrong
    1863- Arthur is born
    1873- John is born
    1878- Dutch and Hosea start the gang (Arthur joins at 15)
    1885- They rescue 12 year old John
    1886- John leaves for a year shortly after Jack was born? (But that would make Jack 13 in the beginning of RDR2 when he’s clearly, like, four. Also John was only 12-13 at this time?)
    1899- RDR2 (John is 26, Arthur is 36)
    1907- Epilogue
    1911- RDR and John’s Death
    1914- Jack’s Revenge

  • @omenftw5786
    @omenftw5786 5 років тому +43

    John has the most depressing death ever i hope there will be a DLC
    That take place in rdr1

    • @damnsonwheredyoufindthis.3830
      @damnsonwheredyoufindthis.3830 5 років тому +4

      Exactly. That could fix the endings. Low honor-John gets killed since he is obviously an outlaw if his honor is low.
      High honor-John is left to live in peace as promised.
      That dlc would also cover remaster which a lot of people probably would want.

    • @johnlawful2272
      @johnlawful2272 5 років тому

      Right up there with Zack from crisis core

    • @santaria19
      @santaria19 5 років тому +1

      @@damnsonwheredyoufindthis.3830 Different endings are cool for rpgs. But for R* Games? Nah, thanks. With different endings you never really know whats canon and whats not.

    • @damnsonwheredyoufindthis.3830
      @damnsonwheredyoufindthis.3830 5 років тому

      @@santaria19 With those you can pick a canon ending yourself until a next one comes. As if we know canon endings with rpgs until second game comes out so its a poor argument that it should be in rpgs but wouldn't work in other games.
      Also it seems to be its pretty obvious that high honor would be canon because the game is about redemption and both John and Arthur are good in story missions. Even if you have evil Arthur he stays with John and goes against the gang.

    • @beech6522
      @beech6522 5 років тому

      And Arthur bruh

  • @pedroperez1231
    @pedroperez1231 4 роки тому +19

    Jack couldn't have been born in 1886 and still be that young in 1899

  • @iHaVeApLaNaRTHUR911
    @iHaVeApLaNaRTHUR911 2 роки тому +1

    John never dies. He was still alive kinda of like a zombie . He woke up from his grave and kept on