So all the pies have that "sense". Pinkie can see sort of the future and Maud can spot ponies and places. Wonder what kind of abilities the other pie-sisters have😊 Just imagine it. A group of the Four sisters with each special ability, that can help them out of tough situations. I want that in an episode.
Kind of reminds me of the new Renew Your Vows series in Marvel comics. It turns out that Peter Parker's daughter, Annie, can actually see danger before it happens.
I just realized that the filly playing the floor piano was actually hitting the correct keys that matched the melody being played. Props to the animators for that! Just wished they had also followed through with that accuracy for the keys played by the adult pony.
+Book Lover You know, it hadn't actually occurred to me that we hadn't had Pinkie and Rarity paired up for an episode before. See, this is why I said we needed more cutie map episodes in season 5, with varying combinations of the Mane 6. It would have furthered the story arc for that season and given us more insight into how well each of the Mane 6 works with each of their individual friends. Oh, as for that channel, no, I have not been a regular watcher, but I was made aware of that fair use comments thing, which I signed the other day. Thanks for mentioning it!
Applegeek No problem! And yeah I agree we should have had more map episodes than we did, who knows? Maybe we'll have more map focused episodes this season? Or maybe we'll have excuses for two characters to hang out like this one. XD That could be neat, focusing on two characters that we don't really see hang out together having episodes about them I would love that. XD
+Book Lover Well, the map hasn't even been seen yet so far in this season, so I don't know if they're going to use it or not, really hope they do though. It certainly is an easy way to put specific ponies together for an adventure. I'd love to see it even dispatch others, like the CMCs, or perhaps even Starlight for one of her lessons, but at this point I'd just be happy to see it used at all.
Applegeek Well it's still early in the season, just got done with episode 3 after all, it would be pretty silly of the writers to introduce the idea of the map and only use it for one season (Season 5). So I'm sure that they'll use it again. (Hope so anyway). I know, one of my hopes is the CMC getting called by the map, maybe just one CMC along with one of the mane six? And the other CMC getting called with another member of the mane six, so on, and so on. That could provide us with some entertainment. (I've been thinking of all sorts of ideas for that kind of scenario shortly after the CMC's got their Cutie Marks). XD
+Book Lover I'd even go so far as to want the "Background Mane 6" ponies (Derpy, Bon Bon, Octavia, etc.) to be called by the map along side members of the Mane 6 for various adventures, but I doubt that will happen for numerous reasons. If it were to happen, I'm sure a chunk of the fandom would revolt, as it would immediately start destroying fan fics and head canon.
Okay, so I just discovered that I had an incorrect title for this episode. The episode I downloaded was labeled as "The Gift of Maud", when it was actually supposed to be "The Gift of the Maud Pie", which is now quite obviously a play on The Gift of the Magi. What's funny to me is that I made the connection between this episode and that story without even knowing about the episode title. XD
The perfect gift for maud would be some kind of rare mineral or a book on mineralogy. A gift doesn't have to be an object it could be an event like taking her on a visit to see places like waterfalls - canyons and caves so she could take in the scenery and explore. memories can make great gifts. there's a surprising amount of stuff you could do for someone who likes the stuff Maud likes.
To Apple Geek, 13:03- Is that Twilight's scepter. 13:05- AND, Is that Twilight's Smarty Pants doll!!! Oh Twilight has been looking for that since season 2.
I think Twilight's balloon was on that "For Sale" sign as a pun off of ReMax and their real estate selling logo on their hot air balloon. I just now made that connection! xD Genius on the animator's part, it makes it so much more real! :D
Before anyone says anything, YES, I COMPLETELY MISSED THE TWICANE, REPEATEDLY! And Smarty Pants too. I only became aware of those after I had already started uploading this video. I think I was too focused on the goofy faces at that point, sorry.
whenever I don't like an episode, your reviews make me like them a little more for some reason. I guess hearing you explain things opens them up to me more, or something lol, love it!
+kemi J Well, thanks! I didn't realize that sharing my thoughts had that kind of impact for anyone. I will continue to try and do my best on future episodes. Can't wait for the one this weekend. :D
Regarding Rarity breaking the fourth wall: while she hasn't done it recently, she DID pull out her fainting couch from just offscreen quite a few times in the past. So it's not unprecedented.
+funcoolfunfun I would definitely have to agree. We also got to see a whole lot more of the city, and from some incredible vantage points too. The "let's travel Equestria" theme is definitely in full swing here!
Applegeek Yup. The fact that we got to see a whole lot more of Manehatten in this one episode than in either of the previous ones combined also helps add to the enjoyment.
Suri Polomare was in the background when Maud was getting the cannon back from the swindler pony. Speaking of which, I wonder how that scene would have gone if Rarity hadn't been there to scare him with her dramatic flair.
+Applegeek Also. In regards to the balloon on the For Sale sign, that must be a reference to RE/MAX real estate which used to have a hot air balloon on their logo.
+Wade Wilson Yeah, I had a few others point that out. I really should have caught that. I guess I was more intrigued by the actual English words on the sign, and the completely different color scheme of the balloon didn't help anything. I hate it when I miss stuff like that. XD
+Applegeek You mentionned getting your Luna figure from some in Quebec and as someone from Quebec myself, i watched a few of the episode in french and Luna's Royal Canterlot Voice is probably one of the only thing they did right when it comes to VA in my opinion. Lots of the characters in general just don't sound right to me in french so i'm watching the show original english version.
+Pascal Bouchard Ahh, too bad. Finding good voice actors can be really hard sometimes, especially for translations. Every character has a personality, which their voices are a part of, and the scripts are written with that in mind, so between the translation and different voice actors, I get the feeling a lot of the character personality gets lost. Anyway, funny you should mention it, because I did find a clip of Luna speaking in French on UA-cam last night, and I thought it sounded awesome!
Maud and Rarity have quite a bit in common. They are both very focused on something most others would consider waste of time and they have both adopted a plain rock which they have named (Boulder and Tom respectively).
I would have to say the part that got me to laughed the most was when Rarity took Maud to the gem store, and Maud said they were stuck up, I call that a blow to Rarity since she can be a little stuck up.
+Apple Joy That was indeed funny, but I don't know that I would call Rarity stuck up. Not anymore anyway. She really has matured a lot over the seasons. Oh sure, she still loves the sophisticated lifestyle, but look at how quickly she drops everything to come to the aid of her friends, especially in this episode. That impression of Pinkie she did just goes to show how well she knows Pinkie as a friend, and she even willingly gets herself dirty when the need arises. After the Rarity episodes in season 5 and now this one, the only big thing that still really bugs me about her is the whole thing of her using her female charm to manipulate others, which was highlighted strongly in Rarity Investigates.
+Applegeek I agree Rarity is a good friend and it shows in this episode, and I also agree that Rarity using her charm to manipulate others is one reason among others is why she is low on my mane 6 list, i do like her but she does annoy me at times.
+Bill Erak Dragón Dorado Yes, they really did. I really loved seeing Rarity's maturity of character in this one. The new writers did a fantastic job with this episode overall!
This episode reminds me of an O'Henry story I loved as a kid. A young couple are out looking for holiday gifts for each other. They don't have a lot of money, but each one has a prized possession. The wife has beautiful long hair and the husband has a gold pocket watch. The husband plans to give his wife a set of silver hair combs and the wife plans to give her husband a gold chain to go with his watch. But neither has the money to buy what they want, so each one sells their prized possession to buy their gift. When they come back together, each is stunned by what the other gave up to get the perfect gift but they quickly realize that the love they share is the real gift.
I just discovered your channel from your Season 6 premiere blind reaction video. How come I haven't discovered you before?! You earned yourself a sub from me! :D
+Lunare Crepuscular Thanks, and welcome to the nut show! XD I'm pretty new to the fandom, and my channel is only about 5 months old, so it's not surprising you've missed me until now. I figured my subscriber rate would pick up with this new season, but I certainly didn't expect the crazy high views on my premiere episode reaction.
Nice in-depth commentary. I gotta admit, thought that guy had stolen the rock pouch at first and was gonna palm it off on Pinkie. We did see the police mare earlier. But seeing Pinkie behind bars wouldn't exactly be par for the show. Kinda glad he wasn't as shady as he seemed. Really enjoy watching your reactions + Commentary, Sir. (^w^)
+XyKP1fan Yeah, that pony definitely looked like a shady character, and it would have been fun to explore that a bit more, but like I said, would have been a bit much for this episode. And thanks for the compliment! I really tried hard this time to keep my commentary brief, while not leaving anything out. :D
+Applegeek Well I think you did a great job. Watching you is always enjoyable to me, so I don't mind whether your commentary is long or short. You've got quality and that's just fantastic. Can't wait to see you next vid, and I'm also looking forward to seeing CMC Episode next week.
I particularly like the market scene because of the season 4 premiere reference of the Twi-cane and also the "Slice Of Life" throwback of the shark that Vinyl and Octavia jumped over
+Lilith Booth Yeah, role reversal is always fun. It's actually the second time it's happened with Rarity (that I can recall offhand anyway), the first being role swapping with Applejack in Simple Ways.
+PrincessCelestia19 It's a Pie sister, don't question it! ;) Actually, the bigger question is, why was there a whole store-front full of rock pouches in the city in the first place, and why was that shady looking pony carrying one? Are there lots of ponies with pet rocks in Manehattan or something?
+Applegeek Well i noticed that rarity digs up gems like it's nothing. anyone can do it. so what are they going to carry those gorgeous Rock in? the answer is.....a rock pouch. XD
+Applegeek Not to mention that they have Bitcoins to carry also. The Rock pouch is also good for the gold coins as well, which in turn were once rocks themselves.
+PrincessCelestia19 All excellent points. It's still odd that they're called rock pouches though, instead of gem pouches or coin pouches. Then again, that might be just what Pinkie decided to call them.
+PrincessCelestia19 Perhaps they've studied up on other species since meeting Zecora. That was 5 years ago, after all. I'm guessing Twilight did the research and then force-fed it to everyone else. ^_^
+Lunare Crepuscular Absolutely! Background on Zecora is one of the items in my official season 6 wish list! Speaking of that, Brenda Crichlow is going to be at MLP-MSP this year, which I will be attending, can't wait to meet her!
I liked this episode its nice to see Maud again, the interactions between Pinkie and Rarity were enjoyable didn't think i would see an episode with these two paired together, and I could be wrong but at 5:48 that looks like Suri Polomare in the background and is it just me but it looks like the design of the statue got changed, nice reaction.
19:36 - "Five-ever"! Sounds like the scriptwriter is a fan ov Victor Borga's "Inflationary Language Game". Which explains why this was a twoderful episode!
+Jason Bullter Yeah, I really don't even want to know how much I spent on all those Funkos. XD Most of the plushies are cheap ones from China, with the exception of the Applejack from Build-a-Bear in full gala dress. That one cost me around $75 total.
+Applegeek I'm the type to free the funkos from there enteral sleep . then I remembered that episode of dexters labatory NRFB NRFB NRFB never remove from box XD
+Peppermint presents LOL, I remember that episode! You know, I can't help but think the reactions of Dexter and his friend to that convention were similar to a lot of people that encounter a brony convention for the first time. The nice thing about the Funkos is that they're not sealed boxes, so as long as you're careful, you can easily take them out for display, and then put them back in later, as good as new.
+remco19 Well, I'm older than you, so don't feel too bad. I don't think this is something to be ashamed of though. Actually, looking at all the trash that's in most of the TV and movies these days, stuff that just highlights the worst humanity has to offer, I would say that people should be proud of the fact that they enjoy watching good, clean content that teaches moral lessons. For that matter, look how many adults still enjoy content from their childhood that's still around, like Pokemon and Power Rangers. Not really that big of a deal. ;)
I thought it was ironic they did this episode, because I've tried instigating that with my siblings long before I saw this episode, and my personality is just like Pinkie.
+funcoolfunfun Hehe, yeah, I suppose. I think all of the Mane 6 have had their own 4th wall breaks at some point. Still, I would never have expected someone as prim, proper, and sophisticated as Rarity to actually directly imitate Pinkie Pie like that.
First of all what was with the pony statue of liberty was it a gift from pony France to celebrate the defeat of pony England also the guy Pinkie got the pouch from was obviously intended to be Gelded with how they focus on the area between his hind legs and showcase how he has no balls I know they don't show anyone's balls except maybe in one of the anatomically correct episodes that have been made a grand total of like 3 of those exist I think also why didn't Rarity just make the pouch being that she's a seamstress.
10:05 Wait a moment?! Did Pinkie Pie say "hand-stitched"? How does she know what a "hand" is when they all have hooves! (Besides breaking the 4th wall knowledge)
heya AG... the balloon sign is a pun.... there is/was a multi-state realty company that used a hot air balloon as part of it's sales gimmick. 20th Century Realty?? purrhaps... I furget. I agree, there are a lot of neat things in the backgrounds, and I didn't catch 'em all either. enough from me, the Frank Pony
It might be an injoke by the animators. When we've seen ponies write in this world they write each others names as cutie marks. So I also wonder whether the balloon is the signature (cutie mark) of the pony selling the place so anyone interested would know who to contact.
You shouldn't be that surprised rarity got willingly dirty because she did it in the episode about pinkies birthday to keep from going to the party so she could help with the surprise party.
+Peppermint presents Oh, I see across the scenes that he pulled it out of there and put it down on the table, and then proceeded to resume eating the soup. He didn't eat the crayon itself, but still, eww. I had sort of expected him to get mad at the water and demand a fresh meal.
![[Blind Reaction] MLP:FiM S06E04 - On Your Marks](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/i8PmlVaDH-I/mqdefault.jpg)
![[Blind Reaction] MLP:FiM S06E04 - On Your Marks](/img/tr.png)
![[Blind Reaction] MLP:FiM S07E23 - Secrets and Pies](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/xE3Osikk0XY/mqdefault.jpg)
![[Blind Reaction] MLP:FiM S06E14 - The Cart Before the Ponies](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/RrrwXzcKfLg/mqdefault.jpg)
Rarity's impression of Pinkie Pie is my all-time favourite part in the entire episode.
Expect Starlight, Sunset, these two are the best.
13:28
If I had to guess any of the other Pie sisters' senses, "Limestone sense" is probably knowing when someone's touching "Holder's Boulder."
Marble Sense is knowing when Big Mac kisses another pony. JK.
maud's sense is knowing when pinkie is hurt
nahhhh,
Boulder is a bro.
Well definitely.
So all the pies have that "sense". Pinkie can see sort of the future and Maud can spot ponies and places. Wonder what kind of abilities the other pie-sisters have😊 Just imagine it. A group of the Four sisters with each special ability, that can help them out of tough situations. I want that in an episode.
Kind of reminds me of the new Renew Your Vows series in Marvel comics. It turns out that Peter Parker's daughter, Annie, can actually see danger before it happens.
i say that Marble has some kind of mind reading power
Maybe Limestone... uh... yeah I don't know.
Emma Simonsen, why does that make me think of Pride and Prejudice and Zombies?
I would assume that Limestone Pie has a sense of when anyone gets too close to Holder's Boulder.
I just realized that the filly playing the floor piano was actually hitting the correct keys that matched the melody being played. Props to the animators for that! Just wished they had also followed through with that accuracy for the keys played by the adult pony.
+Book Lover You know, it hadn't actually occurred to me that we hadn't had Pinkie and Rarity paired up for an episode before. See, this is why I said we needed more cutie map episodes in season 5, with varying combinations of the Mane 6. It would have furthered the story arc for that season and given us more insight into how well each of the Mane 6 works with each of their individual friends.
Oh, as for that channel, no, I have not been a regular watcher, but I was made aware of that fair use comments thing, which I signed the other day. Thanks for mentioning it!
Applegeek No problem! And yeah I agree we should have had more map episodes than we did, who knows? Maybe we'll have more map focused episodes this season? Or maybe we'll have excuses for two characters to hang out like this one. XD That could be neat, focusing on two characters that we don't really see hang out together having episodes about them I would love that. XD
+Book Lover Well, the map hasn't even been seen yet so far in this season, so I don't know if they're going to use it or not, really hope they do though. It certainly is an easy way to put specific ponies together for an adventure. I'd love to see it even dispatch others, like the CMCs, or perhaps even Starlight for one of her lessons, but at this point I'd just be happy to see it used at all.
Applegeek Well it's still early in the season, just got done with episode 3 after all, it would be pretty silly of the writers to introduce the idea of the map and only use it for one season (Season 5). So I'm sure that they'll use it again. (Hope so anyway). I know, one of my hopes is the CMC getting called by the map, maybe just one CMC along with one of the mane six? And the other CMC getting called with another member of the mane six, so on, and so on. That could provide us with some entertainment. (I've been thinking of all sorts of ideas for that kind of scenario shortly after the CMC's got their Cutie Marks). XD
+Book Lover I'd even go so far as to want the "Background Mane 6" ponies (Derpy, Bon Bon, Octavia, etc.) to be called by the map along side members of the Mane 6 for various adventures, but I doubt that will happen for numerous reasons. If it were to happen, I'm sure a chunk of the fandom would revolt, as it would immediately start destroying fan fics and head canon.
16:53 I really like how rarity is doing the pinkie pie logic that is so funny 😂
+Christopher Ocampo Definitely one of the best moments of this episode!
Same.
Okay, so I just discovered that I had an incorrect title for this episode. The episode I downloaded was labeled as "The Gift of Maud", when it was actually supposed to be "The Gift of the Maud Pie", which is now quite obviously a play on The Gift of the Magi. What's funny to me is that I made the connection between this episode and that story without even knowing about the episode title. XD
Applegeek when you said "It's Pinkie Pie, Don't question it" I think I faintly heard joshschorcher yell "HEY THATS MY LINE!!!!!"
The perfect gift for maud would be some kind of rare mineral or a book on mineralogy.
A gift doesn't have to be an object it could be an event like taking her on a visit to see places like waterfalls - canyons and caves so she could take in the scenery and explore.
memories can make great gifts.
there's a surprising amount of stuff you could do for someone who likes the stuff Maud likes.
Well that makes sense.
To Apple Geek,
13:03- Is that Twilight's scepter.
13:05- AND, Is that Twilight's Smarty Pants doll!!! Oh Twilight has been looking for that since season 2.
I think Twilight's balloon was on that "For Sale" sign as a pun off of ReMax and their real estate selling logo on their hot air balloon. I just now made that connection! xD Genius on the animator's part, it makes it so much more real! :D
Yeah, I was made aware of that after the fact, not sure why I didn't make the connection right away.
Geez, that voice when maud say's "What?" at 20:02
Moments with her are so funny.
Pinkie and Maud are so different but they respect and love each other and this is amazing.
Oh, my eyes also kept drifting to that shark, which I think might also be the one from Slice of Life, just like the Twicane.
Applegeek same
Hi applegeek l'm big fan mm haha hahaha
Before anyone says anything, YES, I COMPLETELY MISSED THE TWICANE, REPEATEDLY! And Smarty Pants too. I only became aware of those after I had already started uploading this video. I think I was too focused on the goofy faces at that point, sorry.
Applegeek lol
whenever I don't like an episode, your reviews make me like them a little more for some reason. I guess hearing you explain things opens them up to me more, or something lol, love it!
+kemi J Well, thanks! I didn't realize that sharing my thoughts had that kind of impact for anyone. I will continue to try and do my best on future episodes. Can't wait for the one this weekend. :D
Regarding Rarity breaking the fourth wall: while she hasn't done it recently, she DID pull out her fainting couch from just offscreen quite a few times in the past. So it's not unprecedented.
22:14: Suri Polomare is seen on the left, behind Maud.
Only not her again.
8:53 Waiter! There's a crayon in my soup!
Waiter: "Keep your voice down, or everyone will want one."
This is honestly the best of the 3 Manehatten episodes... Mostly because of the comedy and the twist it put on the whole "Gift of the Magi" plot.
+funcoolfunfun I would definitely have to agree. We also got to see a whole lot more of the city, and from some incredible vantage points too. The "let's travel Equestria" theme is definitely in full swing here!
Applegeek Yup.
The fact that we got to see a whole lot more of Manehatten in this one episode than in either of the previous ones combined also helps add to the enjoyment.
Suri Polomare was in the background when Maud was getting the cannon back from the swindler pony. Speaking of which, I wonder how that scene would have gone if Rarity hadn't been there to scare him with her dramatic flair.
Boulder would have probably hurt him badly. HE'S A ROCK ON THE EDGE, MAN!!
I would love to have a talk with her.
It's a good thing they live in Equestria because I'm pretty sure that in real life shaking a police officer would have gotten Pinkie Pie tazed. lol
No joke. There's already fan comics showing that cop taking Pinkie down. XD
+Applegeek XD I've seen one about her being arrested and the news said that she has drugs.
+Applegeek Also. In regards to the balloon on the For Sale sign, that must be a reference to RE/MAX real estate which used to have a hot air balloon on their logo.
+Wade Wilson Yeah, I had a few others point that out. I really should have caught that. I guess I was more intrigued by the actual English words on the sign, and the completely different color scheme of the balloon didn't help anything. I hate it when I miss stuff like that. XD
Oh yeah I saw those too. Just like on that one building earlier when you can make out the number 18
About the balloon on the "For sale" sign, i think it's a reference to an actual Real Estate company called Remax who have that as their logo for years
+Pascal Bouchard Yeah, somebody else pointed that out as well. I can't believe I didn't make that connection, seems so obvious now. Epic derp.
+Applegeek You mentionned getting your Luna figure from some in Quebec and as someone from Quebec myself, i watched a few of the episode in french and Luna's Royal Canterlot Voice is probably one of the only thing they did right when it comes to VA in my opinion. Lots of the characters in general just don't sound right to me in french so i'm watching the show original english version.
+Pascal Bouchard Ahh, too bad. Finding good voice actors can be really hard sometimes, especially for translations. Every character has a personality, which their voices are a part of, and the scripts are written with that in mind, so between the translation and different voice actors, I get the feeling a lot of the character personality gets lost. Anyway, funny you should mention it, because I did find a clip of Luna speaking in French on UA-cam last night, and I thought it sounded awesome!
13:03- most perfect timing, the twilicane
Maud and Rarity have quite a bit in common. They are both very focused on something most others would consider waste of time and they have both adopted a plain rock which they have named (Boulder and Tom respectively).
Rarity does not like to talk about Tom.
Yes because these others has no taste if they think that dresses and fashion is a waste of time.
"Boulder says they're all too...stuck up." If that's supposed to be a joke or a pun, I don't get it.
it's a burn against Rarity
I would have to say the part that got me to laughed the most was when Rarity took Maud to the gem store, and Maud said they were stuck up, I call that a blow to Rarity since she can be a little stuck up.
+Apple Joy That was indeed funny, but I don't know that I would call Rarity stuck up. Not anymore anyway. She really has matured a lot over the seasons. Oh sure, she still loves the sophisticated lifestyle, but look at how quickly she drops everything to come to the aid of her friends, especially in this episode. That impression of Pinkie she did just goes to show how well she knows Pinkie as a friend, and she even willingly gets herself dirty when the need arises. After the Rarity episodes in season 5 and now this one, the only big thing that still really bugs me about her is the whole thing of her using her female charm to manipulate others, which was highlighted strongly in Rarity Investigates.
+Applegeek I agree Rarity is a good friend and it shows in this episode, and I also agree that Rarity using her charm to manipulate others is one reason among others is why she is low on my mane 6 list, i do like her but she does annoy me at times.
I really liked this episode, who would have thought that Rarity & Pinkie made such a great pair.
+Bill Erak Dragón Dorado Yes, they really did. I really loved seeing Rarity's maturity of character in this one. The new writers did a fantastic job with this episode overall!
They are the best mane.
I just realized one of the stall owners was the the rich pony from Made in Manehatten
+Misty Star Not surprising. A visit to a big city like that is a great opportunity for lots of cameos.
20:37 The point where Maud became terrifying.
Never don't make Pinkie sad.
This episode reminds me of an O'Henry story I loved as a kid. A young couple are out looking for holiday gifts for each other. They don't have a lot of money, but each one has a prized possession. The wife has beautiful long hair and the husband has a gold pocket watch. The husband plans to give his wife a set of silver hair combs and the wife plans to give her husband a gold chain to go with his watch. But neither has the money to buy what they want, so each one sells their prized possession to buy their gift. When they come back together, each is stunned by what the other gave up to get the perfect gift but they quickly realize that the love they share is the real gift.
My head canon is that Bolder’s cousin is Tom.
I just discovered your channel from your Season 6 premiere blind reaction video. How come I haven't discovered you before?! You earned yourself a sub from me! :D
+Lunare Crepuscular Thanks, and welcome to the nut show! XD I'm pretty new to the fandom, and my channel is only about 5 months old, so it's not surprising you've missed me until now. I figured my subscriber rate would pick up with this new season, but I certainly didn't expect the crazy high views on my premiere episode reaction.
Nice in-depth commentary. I gotta admit, thought that guy had stolen the rock pouch at first and was gonna palm it off on Pinkie. We did see the police mare earlier. But seeing Pinkie behind bars wouldn't exactly be par for the show. Kinda glad he wasn't as shady as he seemed. Really enjoy watching your reactions + Commentary, Sir. (^w^)
+XyKP1fan Yeah, that pony definitely looked like a shady character, and it would have been fun to explore that a bit more, but like I said, would have been a bit much for this episode. And thanks for the compliment! I really tried hard this time to keep my commentary brief, while not leaving anything out. :D
+Applegeek Well I think you did a great job. Watching you is always enjoyable to me, so I don't mind whether your commentary is long or short. You've got quality and that's just fantastic. Can't wait to see you next vid, and I'm also looking forward to seeing CMC Episode next week.
I particularly like the market scene because of the season 4 premiere reference of the Twi-cane and also the "Slice Of Life" throwback of the shark that Vinyl and Octavia jumped over
Yeah, I love goofy callback references like that.
Applegeek It really helps to decide whether or not the staff are paying attention to themselves, also, great content, keep it up!
12:42 Same XD I was like, "Wow Maud..." Lol 😆👌
PianoRose you use "lol" "XD" and emojis. I have lost faith in humanity
"Five-ever" is a nod to Victor Borge's "Inflationary Language". ^_*
13:03 Twicane, 13:05 The Inspiration Manifestation spell book, and Smarty Pants Rarity and pinky kinda switch places in this episode, huh? XD
+Lilith Booth Yeah, role reversal is always fun. It's actually the second time it's happened with Rarity (that I can recall offhand anyway), the first being role swapping with Applejack in Simple Ways.
Yah, that way really good, Rarity has a talent for funny cosplaying, lol
What is the Twicane? I know what it looks like but what does it do, if it does anything? Or is it just a fandom reference?
I just realized this now but... Why didn't Pinkie Pie just commission Rarity to make a custom rock pouch for Maud???
17:09 you:rarity just broke the 4th wall
me:that isn't breaking the 4th wall. Breaking physics, yup - breaking the 4th wall, nope.
So Maud said that she wished she had something to carry boulder in. The first time we ever saw Maud she was carrying him in her pocket.
+PrincessCelestia19 It's a Pie sister, don't question it! ;) Actually, the bigger question is, why was there a whole store-front full of rock pouches in the city in the first place, and why was that shady looking pony carrying one? Are there lots of ponies with pet rocks in Manehattan or something?
+Applegeek
Well i noticed that rarity digs up gems like it's nothing. anyone can do it. so what are they going to carry those gorgeous Rock in? the answer is.....a rock pouch. XD
+Applegeek
Not to mention that they have Bitcoins to carry also. The Rock pouch is also good for the gold coins as well, which in turn were once rocks themselves.
+PrincessCelestia19 All excellent points. It's still odd that they're called rock pouches though, instead of gem pouches or coin pouches. Then again, that might be just what Pinkie decided to call them.
13:03
Twilight Cane, lol.
I love how they know what a Giraffe is, but they didn't know what a Zebra was.....
+PrincessCelestia19 Zebra racism? jk lol
+PrincessCelestia19 Perhaps they've studied up on other species since meeting Zecora. That was 5 years ago, after all. I'm guessing Twilight did the research and then force-fed it to everyone else. ^_^
Applegeek We also need an episode where we meet Zecora's family, or at least know where she hails from, right?
+Lunare Crepuscular Absolutely! Background on Zecora is one of the items in my official season 6 wish list! Speaking of that, Brenda Crichlow is going to be at MLP-MSP this year, which I will be attending, can't wait to meet her!
Applegeek I am jealous of you! You get to attend such stuff! Brony activity here in the Philippines isn't that big of a deal, unfortunately.
I liked this episode its nice to see Maud again, the interactions between Pinkie and Rarity were enjoyable didn't think i would see an episode with these two paired together, and I could be wrong but at 5:48 that looks like Suri Polomare in the background and is it just me but it looks like the design of the statue got changed, nice reaction.
+Apple Joy Yeah, it looks like Suri had a couple of cameos in this one.
Wow I am jelly, so many pony merch! >.
+Aria Blaze Yes, well, you likely wouldn't be jealous of my bank account right now. XD
I have your doll by the way Aria. And I also have Adagio and Sonata.
Maud Has Natural Super Strength And Speed While Pinkie Is Pinkie!
OMG I want those Vinyl Figures u have in the background sooooo badly!!!!!!!!!!
11:02 i would have laughed hard if it seemed like Maude's story was like the most interesting thing Rarity ever heard.
Maud sense hahahaha! does all the pie family has senses??? ahahhahaha
6:31 her face and haha let Go of my hoof and everypony looked at them
I envy your collection ^^ all I have is a cheap pinky plush.
Congrats on getting a full set of Funko, I'm missing Celestia and Luna myself! Surprised your not showing the smaller white versions 1-11!
I really want to see a PSSSDWR with Limestone Pie now.
16:54 she's going crazy
I just realized... Why Pinkie don't just ask Rarity to make a rock pouch XD
Rarity probably didn't think to bring her supplies
I think Rarity could sew a rock pouch for Maud... but then what would Pinkie get?
19:36 - "Five-ever"! Sounds like the scriptwriter is a fan ov Victor Borga's "Inflationary Language Game". Which explains why this was a twoderful episode!
At 15:24 I can't believe Pinkie Pie that was her favorite thing
Best characters, Pinkie and Rarity.
What kind of an idiot would hate your channel, Applegeek? Your videos are the best!
3:35 where u can start to watch it actually, (sorry apple geek if u are reading this, I just want to see u react to the actual episode)
This was a nice episode and great to see maud pie
+Christopher Ocampo Maud Sense. 'Nuff said. XD
not gonna lie i am envious of the Luna) Nightmare Moon ones
Forget the Twicane, Did anyone see Suri Polomare?!
I loved Rarity in this.
Pinkie and Rarity are beautiful together💖
Your collections are amazing ! They must cost a lot .
+Jason Bullter Yeah, I really don't even want to know how much I spent on all those Funkos. XD Most of the plushies are cheap ones from China, with the exception of the Applejack from Build-a-Bear in full gala dress. That one cost me around $75 total.
+Applegeek I'm the type to free the funkos from there enteral sleep . then I remembered that episode of dexters labatory NRFB NRFB NRFB never remove from box XD
+Peppermint presents LOL, I remember that episode! You know, I can't help but think the reactions of Dexter and his friend to that convention were similar to a lot of people that encounter a brony convention for the first time. The nice thing about the Funkos is that they're not sealed boxes, so as long as you're careful, you can easily take them out for display, and then put them back in later, as good as new.
+Peppermint presents I'm not sure what is the meaning of " enteral sleep " ?
+Jason Bullter oh i meant cryogenic sleep from that dexters episode one of the characters mentioned it plus I was joking around
another great video bro :D btw glad tyo see more brony's i am 30... so i should be ashamed xD well
+remco19 Well, I'm older than you, so don't feel too bad. I don't think this is something to be ashamed of though. Actually, looking at all the trash that's in most of the TV and movies these days, stuff that just highlights the worst humanity has to offer, I would say that people should be proud of the fact that they enjoy watching good, clean content that teaches moral lessons. For that matter, look how many adults still enjoy content from their childhood that's still around, like Pokemon and Power Rangers. Not really that big of a deal. ;)
Tabitha Germaine is amazing! My childhood hero!
Who knew rarity could imitate her friends?
Cuz she's an actress 😏 just kidding i mean no 😭
I thought it was ironic they did this episode, because I've tried instigating that with my siblings long before I saw this episode, and my personality is just like Pinkie.
8:38 Pinkies cannon went of 4 times
Yep good times x3 plus any more funkos and gasp YOU CAN BUILD A HOUSE OF FUNKOS XD forget contracters XD
Also, regarding 16:56: It's Rarity imitating Pinkie, don't question it.
+funcoolfunfun Hehe, yeah, I suppose. I think all of the Mane 6 have had their own 4th wall breaks at some point. Still, I would never have expected someone as prim, proper, and sophisticated as Rarity to actually directly imitate Pinkie Pie like that.
Applegeek I don't think anyone did.
First of all what was with the pony statue of liberty was it a gift from pony France to celebrate the defeat of pony England also the guy Pinkie got the pouch from was obviously intended to be Gelded with how they focus on the area between his hind legs and showcase how he has no balls I know they don't show anyone's balls except maybe in one of the anatomically correct episodes that have been made a grand total of like 3 of those exist I think also why didn't Rarity just make the pouch being that she's a seamstress.
9:46 the poor guy got a crayon in his soup
12:18 I think back in season two I believe
Whoa Applegeek that's alot of toys back there! how old are you EXACTLY?
11:04 the guy still has the crayon
24:47 that one winking animation probably took them a year to make
+Boss McBoss I do believe it's the slowest wink I've ever seen. :D
10:05 Wait a moment?! Did Pinkie Pie say "hand-stitched"? How does she know what a "hand" is when they all have hooves! (Besides breaking the 4th wall knowledge)
It's Pinkie. Don't question it! XD
heya AG... the balloon sign is a pun.... there is/was a multi-state realty company that used a hot air balloon as part of it's sales gimmick. 20th Century Realty?? purrhaps... I furget. I agree, there are a lot of neat things in the backgrounds, and I didn't catch 'em all either.
enough from me, the Frank Pony
Yeah, it's a spoof of the RE/MAX balloon. I had several people point that out. :)
I think Applegeek got a "Blue Yeti" michrophone.
Get ready for Rarity Pie ship (Pinkie or Maud)
that reminds me the up and down house in real life the piano floor orlando
It might be an injoke by the animators. When we've seen ponies write in this world they write each others names as cutie marks. So I also wonder whether the balloon is the signature (cutie mark) of the pony selling the place so anyone interested would know who to contact.
32:25 to answer your question--it's a parody of the realmax (sp) realtor signs? you know, the ones with the red, white and blue hot air balloons?
+Webs SOTE Ohhhhhh, I never even thought about that. That's hilarious!
Spotted smartypants and the Twilight cane.
Wait just noticed something. 22:12 is that Suri?
13:03 that was the twilightcane!
13:17 can see the Twi Cane
same XD
You shouldn't be that surprised rarity got willingly dirty because she did it in the episode about pinkies birthday to keep from going to the party so she could help with the surprise party.
16:58 lokk at that pose pause it at this time and she's sonic
anyone can break the 4th wall they just don't got on that level of pinkie
Where do you watch this btw
Netflix
#Maud best interregator ever
I literally just read the Gift of Maji in school.
12:11
MY LITTLE PONY
MY LITTLE PONY...
KRUUUUUNNNGGGG!!!!
Love your videos SO much !!!!
Cool reaction !!!!
the one thing I must point out the ponys meal with the crayon in it was in his food and he's eating it anyway what are crayons in Equestria edible ?
+Peppermint presents Um, that was the crayon that Pinkie spit out. It landed in that other pony's soup. XD
+Applegeek and still he ate it after it was removed from the bowl XD
+Peppermint presents Oh, I see across the scenes that he pulled it out of there and put it down on the table, and then proceeded to resume eating the soup. He didn't eat the crayon itself, but still, eww. I had sort of expected him to get mad at the water and demand a fresh meal.
here's a radical question:
WHY DOESN'T PINKIE ASK RARITY TO MAKE THE POUCH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!