Considering the Blackpink case, do you think Kpop idols should pay attention to their outfits when holding concerts in some conservative countries like Malaysia, Indonesia, etc? 👀
I think yes, they should pay respect to the outfit. Like twice also did a Malaysia concert, they all wear proper dress according to their culture. Even BTS change their choreography in South arab. So why not for blackpink
I feel like Hayun is the only situation that's inappropriate. I'm the same age as her so it's really weird to see a young girl dancing while wearing revealing outfits 😖
im not the biggest fan of soyeon but like??? shes fricking stunning and her body is goals so why she cant wear something more revealing? leave her alone finally i swear-
I mean she is like a role model for young teens? they sometimes can get outfit inspo from soyeon and like I don't rlly care if she wears that but she's an "idol" ppl look up to her so her promoting that kind of outfit is too much for young fans lol
Its their bodies so they can wear what ever they choose but idols should be considerate towards which country they are performing in and what styles citizens wear in that country and dress accordingly to avoid such criticism.
@@victoriatzyu_shinobu The stylists have to be considerate but if at times they are not and then the idol would just have to face the consequence which they obviously dont deserve but there will always be people who fish for excuses to hate.
Actually no, they don't decide what to wear. ( Some idols do but not always) the only time they can dress however they want is when they are not working
I don't find Soyeon disrespectful or too provocative. She looks strong, powerful and very bold. And why do these ppl never point out male idols when they take off their shirt? Isn't that too provocative? People and their double standards
you know, male idols taking off their shirt aren't even that provocative, in fact they look cool and sexy. Women sure also wear sexy outfits but yeah, its not the same for men when they take off their shirts.... atleast for soyeon's case its not that revealing plus she's over 18 and the underboob fashion trend literally many ppl do that its not always about double standards regarding this situation......
@@ItzMEdzy_everglowcbfinallyy For you it must not be provocative. But not everyone is the same. It's the body choice. What I mean to say is, leave her alone. People always try to define how a woman should be dressed and it's too provoking. It wasn't like these female idols were naked and something like that...hope you understand why I said that statement
I need to make some clarification. Though yes, Indonesia is mostly Muslim, it's not illegal or prohibited to wear shorts/revealing clothes, though it also depends on the venue, such as religious places, or certain area where the local government do make such regulation. The clothes rules unfortunately more related with the culture, but the religion do enhance this condition.
Although I agree that there is appropriate and inappropriate clothing. If you’re a woman, irregardless of what you wear, chances are you will experience sexual harassment. It’s not the clothes, it’s men. Let’s start blaming the right people please.
Women who would wear almost underwear in public is without dignity and disrespectful towards their mother and father. There's a very thick line between fashion and inappropriateness.
most of the time idols don’t get to choose what they wear, it’s their stylist.. so i don’t get why people hate on the idols when they don’t even get to choose the outfits.
I am sorry but as a woman i still agree with them because males don't have much to hide while women do and also women should respest their body and show it only to their one and only rather than exposing it for everyone to see
note how these are all female idols. if male idol would do any of these, they would be praised, but when it's female idol, it is "too provocative". only serious thing here was girl crush. they should've not let hayun join. i kind of understand the issue with blackpink and indonesia too, but i'm not muslim so i don't think i can say anything to the issue. anyways their body their choice
My girl soyeon is powerful and independent, in hayun's case its uncomfortable for me think about it and I'm just a year older. None of them deserve the criticism, it's the people around them and work for who should be receiving it.
I honestly feel like black pink stylist should put more effort in the girls dress code when they are performing in countries that has a medium to large size of Muslims And the last one mentioned in the video should have their company taken from them cus sexualizing a 17 year old is crazy
@@maryjane2104 they have after 2018 the girls themselves involved in their styling along with stylist they them told that hylt hanbok was jennies idea and golden teeth was lisa s and for magazine the girls themselves select the mua they wanna work with
Their body their choice But in idols case most of them don't choose it Things are simple if they want to wear it let them And if they don't want Don't pressure them
For black pink and idle they are nothing wrong about them especially black pink if people don’t love this kind of clothes just don’t watch it or don’t going to their concert is not like bp forced them to watch their concert but the girl crush case is disgusting the concept it self is disgusting because it’s using women body to gain money and attention from perverts and it’s not even an art or music it’s just porn and effects negatively on young girls and adding a kid is even worse and worse and what’s more disgusting is the agency saying they will add her officially when she turns 18 this didn’t the case better 16 or 18 she still so young for this embarrassing
Please try and accept that right now what this netizens are saying is true for at least this time instead of saying they don't wear reaveling outfits, actually they do and you have to admit that
"women are not allowed to wear revealing clothes in indonesia" me: wearing short shorts in public back in 2013 LOL we may be a largely conservative country but when ur in a big city like Jakarta you'll see supposed Muslims do all the crazy things that aren't allowed in their religion. Believe me, there have been moments where I've seen Hijabi women openly drink alcohol in public and Muslim girls show off their cleavage. What BlackPink wore was nowhere close to being as provocative as people's day to day outfits.
You are really rude and undesirable wearing mainstream costume showing too much skin for adult women they have no morals living like a dump and crazy life also unhappy and going to a therapist proves my idea dancing and singing and turning away from God and doing the haram thing doesn't make you happy so sorry for them And these girls you are talking about are committing sins . I will ask God to forgive them and lead them to the truth and guide them.
No matter what others wear it's their choice and their life, we better learn to stop judging and being narrow minded and learn to accept others choices and it's much more better if focus on our lives than others ;)
Let me fix the statement " women are not allowed to wear revealing clothes" to " Muslim women don't like wearing revealing clothes". I am not not saying all Muslim women but the Muslim women whom priority is Islam.
Its not only islam but culture, all countries dont have same style, for example in korea skirts and shorts Are okay but revealing your upper part is a big No! Thats why suhyon got attacked although She was covered everywhere else. In my opinion you have to respect the country’s religion and culture if you chose to perform There, most if people can feel offended just like the Singer and i understand. Its their land. Selena did Great! And honestly i dont think idols sometimes feel comfortable wearing the clothes chosen by their stylists
Islam is Malaysia official religion blackpink outfit were not respectful , even other idols changed their behavior in countries like this. To not shock and respect the fans. Its not jealousy
The last one - 17 is like pretty much 18...it's up to her and her parents. It's even more laughable when people from the west are screaming about this when in Europe and USA 17 y.o. can perform in freaking panties on the stage and no one cares.
You know it's the company's fault most of the time. Sometimes the clothes they wear are so undescent. Companies should also remember they have dignity..and respect that. Male and female idols' body should be respected too.
I'm not from Malaysia but I can say that both blinks and Abby are overreacting. Y all should know not to respond to such things. Abby is can say whatever she wants, she's just gonna embrasse herself and blinks are guilty too cz showering Abby with thus much attention could also cause the members to have anxiety or depression or something
How can you talk about a Malaysian topic when you aren't from there? That's a cultural topic that someone who doesn't share the culture should talk about.
Idols usually don’t have any right to decide on what clothes to wear, they are dressed and told how do behave directly from their agency. So don’t think that it’s their desire to reveal their sexuality or something like that, pretty often they don’t have any control on that.
That backless top was not a problem for sure, she only revealed her back? Since when it's sexual? It's her back, I don't get the idea of the outfit being scandalous, makes no sense.
Girl crush is such a no for me… Theres no reason to make a girl group to dress like that.. :/ The rest on the video were fine.. people should leave them alone.
how can a person get offended from something that another person wears? people just have too much time to worry about someone else's bodies and fashion sense
For some asian countries, its a must to respect and follow its culture regardless how modern kpop can be. BP stylist didnt do its homework. Salute to Selena Gomez for her deep respect to muslim people.
@@littlelapis8030 like somebody asked them for their opinions. i don't think we have a say in what a person should be wearing unless and until the person wearing it is uncomfortable.
I'm sorry but I swear this is such double standard if a male idol takes off their shirt and shows their abs they will be screaming if it's a female idol it's a problem and the blackpink part I understand Malaysia and Indonesia because it's their culture but they should have seen it coming I mean Blackpink have a girl crush concept so obviously they will dress like that sorry to be rude but I could never live in a country like Malaysia and Indonesia and soyeon part I see that she look beautiful, strong and bold it's not like she is wearing it for someone girls doesn't have to wear revealing and elegant outfit for other people they can wear it for themselves
About the black pink one, I think whoever makes a big deal out of their outfit is a hater. They are just mad that they can't wear what black pink wear. If they gonna banned black pink then they should just ban everything like North Korea. Not every woman wants to cover themselves head to toe. We want to dress cute too.
About the Soyeon one,I do not like the top for me it's ugly but it looks good on her and if she likes it she should wear it.Also I don't like the jeans but she should wear what she wants (I am just saying my opinion,I don't like the clothes but she should wear them if she wants)
I definitely believe that one should wear whatever they want but the idols and stylists should consider the sentiments of conservative countries when they perform
its not the girls fault that those countries are conservative, in fact, those countries need to accept the fact that they are in the past while the rest of the world chose to move forward
@@four4forth Oh plz not all countries are mad, moving forward and blah blah shits you told, actually if this things happen culture like thing will not exist which is probably not good and if you disagree first that your opinion which is not gonna change anything huh! Secondly they are just kpop idols and stylist should understand what to wear and not
They themselves hve said they can choose their outfits if not all the time They r not babies anymore..they r grown ups women and v can't say like that Maybe both stylist and the members chose it
Blackpink’s outfits were even revealing, people hella overacted. Hell half of these outfits in the list weren’t even provocative, “fans” looked at them in a provocative way. I’m not one to bash countries way of doing things but damn they need to let loose. Women should be proud of their bodies, no taught to hide them. Showing their legs, stomach, or shoulder isn’t revealing. It’s such a shame to know that those girls will grow up taught to hide their body their body’s and have no confidence about it.
Western artists can wear those kind of outfits but kpop idols can't? Like c'mon, sometimes fan should know how respect someone's taste of fashion... It's just some fans are just overeating, treating their idols like baby even tho they're already adult. It's fine when fans reacting to kpop rookies who is minor and yet they're wearing tight clothes, but restricting an adult person??? Sometimes it's fans who is creating problem not the idol...
Because kpop idols are usually from asia, especially east asia, and those countries are way more conservative than western countries. It's literally culture, showing skin is badly seen in asia, not that much in western countries.
Oh my goodness the last group clothes are way too revealing, the other two groups shouldn’t even be in the same category 😳 and then having teenager girl and minor in the group makes me sick. I have not even heard anyone talk about this before. I wouldn’t even wear anything like that and I’m an adult. Where are her parents this is so sad
Bella Hadid's audience is nearly entirely western. Kpop's audience is composed of a lot more people from asia. They are miles more conservative than Bella's fans. This entire comment section praises/defends the girls, who are you talking to?
with the photoshoots, it's not like they chose those clothes I think. i believe they have stylists that dresses them to fit the concept. why are the idols the one being blamed for that? 🤔
Pride for Serena Gomes because she is intelligent and has adapted to honor the culture of the country of her host to the population with a multitude of public culture..
Why do they even care about what they wear? It's literally their body so it's their choice. I don't find any wrong about what they wear. If it's make them comfortable then let them be. But about Hayun it's not appropriate since she's a minor. She should not be in the group with that kind of concept. It's literally illegal.
I feel like laughing on the netizens.😂😂 They're not even reaviling anything and it's shocking for you??? It was totally normal for me at least. In industry some people literally get naked. 😑
It's weird that netizens don't understand the fact that to every show, every concert, every live performance, mvs and photoshoots the stylist pick out idols' outfits
If the idols chooses what to wear than they should already know the consequences they will face. Companies don't care about their artists, they only care about their business and profits. These greedy companies and wealthy shareholders. 😠
I don't understand it it's like these are all people that are in their twenties I mean I understand you know there's little kids that look up to them and stuff but I just think it's insane how much hate these Idols get it really is ridiculous and not just the female Idols of males too it's just crazy
Re: Soyeon - the problem with the backless sweater and crotchless jeans is not that they show too much skin, but that they just look weird and not very flattering. Stuff that looks good, or at least interesting, on the catwalk is there to show off the creativity of the designer - it isn't necessarily a guide to actual daily fashion. Similarly something like Jisoo's bizarre coral-like headdress in the "Kill The Love" MV is a poor choice for anything not on stage. Re: Blackpink - the complaints about the Indonesian ad are valid, the ones about the stage outfits in Malaysia are not. With the former, these ads are presumably made for wide distribution and therefore the haram showing of skin scandalized the general public. With the latter, however, people voluntarily attend the concert and pay a lot of ringgits to do so. The event isn't being broadcast to the public at large, and people who are there presumably know what they are getting into and what Blackpink's style is. Complaining that Blackpink dresses exactly like how they should have been expected to dress is just virtue-signally garbage to get Islamist cred. Re: Girl Crush - yeah...that's pretty bad.
I personally don’t think Soyeon should’ve gotten any back lash for the green sweater. Her outfit was a bit out there, but it was just her back. A back is a back. For her ripped jeans, I felt like that was a bit too much. I think BP should get a little because I feel like it was a bit disrespectful to wear those types of clothing to a country or in ads for a country where the majority of people believe women should be covered up. They definitely should’ve chosen something more modest. I also think that Hayun has the ability to make her own decisions and if she ends up joining Girl Crush that’s something the public has no power over. Again, this is my personal opinion.
In soyeon case , and girlcrush case it maybe true company to be blame.In blackpink case the country should not to invite in the first place if they really cannot stand those outfits.And should blame shopee app to make an inappropriate ads.
none of them deserve criticism, let women wear what they want without worries of being sexualized. women's fashion is a form of expression, not an invitation.
y provocative even a word ?? females can dress the way they want bold , provocative etc etc do away with such words please maybe use clothes or outfits
Considering the Blackpink case, do you think Kpop idols should pay attention to their outfits when holding concerts in some conservative countries like Malaysia, Indonesia, etc? 👀
it has to be more considered a lot before done the job. bcs not everyone in this worlds could accept for some cross culture
Honestly people are over reacting on their outfit I really feel sad about their mentality and mindset towards women outfits.
If it's rooted in misogyny then idgaf
I think yes, they should pay respect to the outfit. Like twice also did a Malaysia concert, they all wear proper dress according to their culture. Even BTS change their choreography in South arab. So why not for blackpink
@Your Misery I think you are just islampobic
I feel like Hayun is the only situation that's inappropriate. I'm the same age as her so it's really weird to see a young girl dancing while wearing revealing outfits 😖
Correct. Cute and elegant concepts exist
Wasn't it her choice to join though?
@@chuuchuuutrain Usually the companies decide which concept is going to be given to the group, the company could’ve just refused her
Facts!!👏🏾
Tell that to hybe
im not the biggest fan of soyeon but like??? shes fricking stunning and her body is goals so why she cant wear something more revealing? leave her alone finally i swear-
Actually it wasn't her choice the airport look of K-Pop idols are always chosen by their stylists
Yeah and they said the same thing to Yuqi like leave em alone
@@pennymikk idk what to tell u🤷🏻♀️ in korea the beauty standard is to be thin. idols who westerns would think are normal are considered fat in korea
I mean she is like a role model for young teens? they sometimes can get outfit inspo from soyeon and like I don't rlly care if she wears that but she's an "idol" ppl look up to her so her promoting that kind of outfit is too much for young fans lol
@@kyleyadventures bruh she is not their parents 😐
Abby Abadi should talk about her own local artists especially DOLLA.
She probably has 🤷🏾♀️
@@DylanMR hm then that’s messy maybe she’s doing it for publicity?
@@LilacCorpse maybe🤷🏻♀️
Tbh what's wrong with them wearing a shirt and a skirt? It's not like we don't have locals wearing outfits like that
Its their bodies so they can wear what ever they choose but idols should be considerate towards which country they are performing in and what styles citizens wear in that country and dress accordingly to avoid such criticism.
Or they should not to go to this primitive countries for concerts anymore.
Yeah true
They don’t always get to choose what they wear. They have stylus.
@@victoriatzyu_shinobu The stylists have to be considerate but if at times they are not and then the idol would just have to face the consequence which they obviously dont deserve but there will always be people who fish for excuses to hate.
Actually no, they don't decide what to wear. ( Some idols do but not always) the only time they can dress however they want is when they are not working
I don't find Soyeon disrespectful or too provocative. She looks strong, powerful and very bold. And why do these ppl never point out male idols when they take off their shirt? Isn't that too provocative? People and their double standards
It's just another try to hate on Soyeon or (G)I-dle, since their debut People always were looking for something to hate Soyeon or (G)I-dle
Right?! She's not a girl anymore. She's a WOMAN. They should stop treating them and seeing them as a kid or a child
I just didn't like what she was wearing tbh🤷♂️🤷♂️
you know, male idols taking off their shirt aren't even that provocative, in fact they look cool and sexy. Women sure also wear sexy outfits but yeah, its not the same for men when they take off their shirts.... atleast for soyeon's case its not that revealing plus she's over 18 and the underboob fashion trend literally many ppl do that
its not always about double standards regarding this situation......
@@ItzMEdzy_everglowcbfinallyy For you it must not be provocative. But not everyone is the same. It's the body choice. What I mean to say is, leave her alone. People always try to define how a woman should be dressed and it's too provoking. It wasn't like these female idols were naked and something like that...hope you understand why I said that statement
I need to make some clarification. Though yes, Indonesia is mostly Muslim, it's not illegal or prohibited to wear shorts/revealing clothes, though it also depends on the venue, such as religious places, or certain area where the local government do make such regulation. The clothes rules unfortunately more related with the culture, but the religion do enhance this condition.
Although I agree that there is appropriate and inappropriate clothing. If you’re a woman, irregardless of what you wear, chances are you will experience sexual harassment. It’s not the clothes, it’s men. Let’s start blaming the right people please.
i know right!!
Exactly. How is showing skin indecent when men stare and harras women in any type of cloth they wear? This is ridiculous.
Women who would wear almost underwear in public is without dignity and disrespectful towards their mother and father. There's a very thick line between fashion and inappropriateness.
Stop male bashing.
@@Dynamatrix2000 not until they stop being pervs
I’m surprised HwaSa isn’t here. So many K-netz were ready to pass out when she performed in her sexy, latex, and cherry red body suit.
Cuz they dont baby her, they treat her like an ajjumma just cuz her fsce dont look 15
They actually accept her in her dressing style, the only she got major issue when no bra in airport.
Or Hyolyn...
I don't think soyeon's revealing back is something to be criticised.
she's displaying a cool fashion and I think it's really pretty and gorgeous
The soyeon outfit is actually cute
Facts 😍
yes! and it's not really that revealing.... like c'mon, it's just a backless fit plus everything else is covered
@@pigeondance exactly in my opinion the important things are covered so that all that matters
most of the time idols don’t get to choose what they wear, it’s their stylist.. so i don’t get why people hate on the idols when they don’t even get to choose the outfits.
if were talking about male idols wearing these clothes, others would've laughed it off and say its hot
I was waiting for someone to point this out
Yes
LOUDER 📣📣📣
Point is which male idol wore such dress.
I am sorry but as a woman i still agree with them because males don't have much to hide while women do and also women should respest their body and show it only to their one and only rather than exposing it for everyone to see
"Their body their choice'' that doesn't apply to Kpop since most groups don't have that choice
and if they do, they should embrace it however they want
Girl crush does‼️ I don't remember where I saw that (maybe in one of nugupromoter's tweets/ ig posts)
@@ryuseiii yes, like blackpink!
@@ammoniumclaire not every girl crush group does hun
@@Jungkook_fr I was talking about the gg girl crush
i only agree with the girl crush group one
Same
if the they choose to wear revealing clothing, it’s their wish. THEIR BODY THEIR CHOICE👏
*But uglisa is plastic*
@@twicequeensofkpop7469 so?
@@twicequeensofkpop7469 girl what r u on
@@twicequeensofkpop7469 You should get your eyes checked
That doesn't mean people need to like it
note how these are all female idols. if male idol would do any of these, they would be praised, but when it's female idol, it is "too provocative".
only serious thing here was girl crush. they should've not let hayun join.
i kind of understand the issue with blackpink and indonesia too, but i'm not muslim so i don't think i can say anything to the issue.
anyways their body their choice
double standards.
@@sullimellow8736 yup. those are very clear in kpop industry.
in islam country man or woman must be carefull with clothes
exactly
@@user-uu2ji1fx4w maybe in Malaysia, yeah. anywhere else i haven't seen that and male idols are usually praised for wearing less clothing.
My girl soyeon is powerful and independent, in hayun's case its uncomfortable for me think about it and I'm just a year older.
None of them deserve the criticism, it's the people around them and work for who should be receiving it.
"she can wear whatever she wants but not in public places" wow, logic level 180
if i only have a body like soyeon's, i'd definitely wear something like that but i dress like a grandma.
I honestly feel like black pink stylist should put more effort in the girls dress code when they are performing in countries that has a medium to large size of Muslims
And the last one mentioned in the video should have their company taken from them cus sexualizing a 17 year old is crazy
It's not just stylist..the members itself said they can choose their outfits and hve a say in their outfits
@@aksamerinregi934 I don’t think they have a say in their outfits
@@maryjane2104 they have after 2018 the girls themselves involved in their styling along with stylist they them told that hylt hanbok was jennies idea and golden teeth was lisa s and for magazine the girls themselves select the mua they wanna work with
@@roohisitharaabdulwahab9025 oh wow I didn’t know that thanks for the info
It’s so embarrassing how some fans treat idols as if they’re babies like stop they are grown women who have the right to wear whatever they want.
Their body their choice
But in idols case most of them don't choose it
Things are simple if they want to wear it let them
And if they don't want
Don't pressure them
About hyun is wrong but others are adult... I blame company and some fans who know they are minor still sexualized them
For black pink and idle they are nothing wrong about them especially black pink if people don’t love this kind of clothes just don’t watch it or don’t going to their concert is not like bp forced them to watch their concert but the girl crush case is disgusting the concept it self is disgusting because it’s using women body to gain money and attention from perverts and it’s not even an art or music it’s just porn and effects negatively on young girls and adding a kid is even worse and worse and what’s more disgusting is the agency saying they will add her officially when she turns 18 this didn’t the case better 16 or 18 she still so young for this embarrassing
Uhm what ? No, they should just not go to a muslim country bruh if they wanna wear stuff like that so bad all the time.
Please try and accept that right now what this netizens are saying is true for at least this time instead of saying they don't wear reaveling outfits, actually they do and you have to admit that
"women are not allowed to wear revealing clothes in indonesia"
me: wearing short shorts in public back in 2013 LOL
we may be a largely conservative country but when ur in a big city like Jakarta you'll see supposed Muslims do all the crazy things that aren't allowed in their religion. Believe me, there have been moments where I've seen Hijabi women openly drink alcohol in public and Muslim girls show off their cleavage. What BlackPink wore was nowhere close to being as provocative as people's day to day outfits.
ikr, they always spoke up abt their religion but they also engaging in inappropriate behavior. the most hypocrite human being.
@@erenchi_0415 hey hey not all every religion have bad people
@@slay_haya2136 ok sorry i forgot to mention "some of them"
You are really rude and undesirable wearing mainstream costume showing too much skin for adult women they have no morals living like a dump and crazy life also unhappy and going to a therapist proves my idea dancing and singing and turning away from God and doing the haram thing doesn't make you happy so sorry for them And these girls you are talking about are committing sins . I will ask God to forgive them and lead them to the truth and guide them.
No matter what others wear it's their choice and their life, we better learn to stop judging and being narrow minded and learn to accept others choices and it's much more better if focus on our lives than others ;)
Only the last one deserved backlash, the company is obviously sexually exploiting her
Only the hayeon case deserves critisism
It’s not the outfit that has problem, but peoples mind. Think twice
Let me fix the statement " women are not allowed to wear revealing clothes" to " Muslim women don't like wearing revealing clothes".
I am not not saying all Muslim women but the Muslim women whom priority is Islam.
Well stated
exactly.
Its not only islam but culture, all countries dont have same style, for example in korea skirts and shorts Are okay but revealing your upper part is a big No! Thats why suhyon got attacked although She was covered everywhere else. In my opinion you have to respect the country’s religion and culture if you chose to perform There, most if people can feel offended just like the Singer and i understand. Its their land. Selena did Great! And honestly i dont think idols sometimes feel comfortable wearing the clothes chosen by their stylists
That girl Abby Abadi is definitely jealous 💀
Islam is Malaysia official religion blackpink outfit were not respectful , even other idols changed their behavior in countries like this. To not shock and respect the fans. Its not jealousy
@@973yanou bro she can easily say "why they are wearing like that?" But instead she also said "why people like them?"duh isn't that obvious?
@@973yanou yes exactly
@@973yanou its the males that think the women will be impure if their outfit show skin, like wtf, close minded muslims
Her wording screamed jealous
The last one - 17 is like pretty much 18...it's up to her and her parents. It's even more laughable when people from the west are screaming about this when in Europe and USA 17 y.o. can perform in freaking panties on the stage and no one cares.
You know it's the company's fault most of the time. Sometimes the clothes they wear are so undescent. Companies should also remember they have dignity..and respect that. Male and female idols' body should be respected too.
I'm not from Malaysia but I can say that both blinks and Abby are overreacting. Y all should know not to respond to such things. Abby is can say whatever she wants, she's just gonna embrasse herself and blinks are guilty too cz showering Abby with thus much attention could also cause the members to have anxiety or depression or something
How can you talk about a Malaysian topic when you aren't from there? That's a cultural topic that someone who doesn't share the culture should talk about.
If you're not from Malaysia then you don't deserve to talk about Malaysians and Malaysia
well, if ur not malaysian, u cant talk abt this matter between malaysia and bp
I am only concerned about Hayun from Girl Crush, I hope her company is not forcing her and that this is her choice.
Idols usually don’t have any right to decide on what clothes to wear, they are dressed and told how do behave directly from their agency. So don’t think that it’s their desire to reveal their sexuality or something like that, pretty often they don’t have any control on that.
That backless top was not a problem for sure, she only revealed her back? Since when it's sexual? It's her back, I don't get the idea of the outfit being scandalous, makes no sense.
soyeon's photoshoot was so cool!
Girl crush is such a no for me…
Theres no reason to make a girl group to dress like that.. :/
The rest on the video were fine.. people should leave them alone.
If you don’t like them don’t look at them, just leave them alone , they’re not hurting anymore, they’re not telling you to dress like them 😒
exactly
I didn't like what soyeon was weraing but that doesn't mean i don't like her
how can a person get offended from something that another person wears? people just have too much time to worry about someone else's bodies and fashion sense
Seriously, these people need to get a life. It’s 2022 already, its her body, her choice.
For some asian countries, its a must to respect and follow its culture regardless how modern kpop can be. BP stylist didnt do its homework. Salute to Selena Gomez for her deep respect to muslim people.
Yeah they should stop going to these backward countries.
@@tatianas6654 yessss gurlllll!!!!!!!!
@@tatianas6654that true. Which severely limits self-expression by forbidding rock clothes and other things
@@tatianas6654 omg that's so horrible 😭 I'm glad you got away from that toxic place
@@tatianas6654 thank you for opening my eyes to the truth. I hope your friends are alive too
It's always the female idols 🙄leave them alone. them wearing revealing outfits shouldn't be a problem to you!
They can wear what they want but that doesn't mean people need to like it
@@littlelapis8030 like somebody asked them for their opinions. i don't think we have a say in what a person should be wearing unless and until the person wearing it is uncomfortable.
It’s the internalized misogyny that causes this.
@@myblackpinkbiasjennieforev329 asking or not, everyone is allowed to dislike something, even the clothes other people wear and say they don't like it
@@littlelapis8030 sure but we don't have the right say what someone can wear or not. and that's what the video is about.
I'm sorry but I swear this is such double standard if a male idol takes off their shirt and shows their abs they will be screaming if it's a female idol it's a problem and the blackpink part I understand Malaysia and Indonesia because it's their culture but they should have seen it coming I mean Blackpink have a girl crush concept so obviously they will dress like that sorry to be rude but I could never live in a country like Malaysia and Indonesia and soyeon part I see that she look beautiful, strong and bold it's not like she is wearing it for someone girls doesn't have to wear revealing and elegant outfit for other people they can wear it for themselves
About the black pink one, I think whoever makes a big deal out of their outfit is a hater. They are just mad that they can't wear what black pink wear. If they gonna banned black pink then they should just ban everything like North Korea. Not every woman wants to cover themselves head to toe. We want to dress cute too.
About the Soyeon one,I do not like the top for me it's ugly but it looks good on her and if she likes it she should wear it.Also I don't like the jeans but she should wear what she wants
(I am just saying my opinion,I don't like the clothes but she should wear them if she wants)
People just don’t like Soyeon cause she intimidates them lol
Damn, jealous haters. These idols are adults and can wear everything. Ridiculous, we are not living in 19 century. Do you want see Idols in Burka?
Ikr!
To be real, I loved soyeon top....
I definitely believe that one should wear whatever they want but the idols and stylists should consider the sentiments of conservative countries when they perform
where the expression itself is very limited to a minimum with some unnecessary regulations
its not the girls fault that those countries are conservative, in fact, those countries need to accept the fact that they are in the past while the rest of the world chose to move forward
@@four4forth Oh plz not all countries are mad, moving forward and blah blah shits you told, actually if this things happen culture like thing will not exist which is probably not good and if you disagree first that your opinion which is not gonna change anything huh! Secondly they are just kpop idols and stylist should understand what to wear and not
@@taetaetata5361 ''what would you do if when you ok so he said yes would go?''
@@four4forth What are you saying? Sorry I didn't get that
If someone can give me the link to Soyeon sweater, I’d really appreciate it cause her outfit was 🔥🔥
Last one got me shooked a minor😳😭😭😭
Why are people getting embarrassed in this case they are not even the part of anything. People are just free to judge them🤦♀️
THIER BODY, THEIR LIVES, THEY PAY THEIR OWN BILLS, why the fck does people care. Idols dont need ur permission to wear what they want
Soyeon is so funny …I can’t with this women 😂
I think it is only bad if the idol is clearly uncomfortable or they are underage or religious
People need to realise that the outfits k-pop idols wear is selected by their stylists not the idols
idols & agencies should be considerate about which countries they are preforming in. at least do the research it takes the bare minimum
Abby sounds very jealous
FirstI love your vids and all the news
Merci beaucoup 😘
Only Girl Crush. The other 3 are fine and if they have a problem with it then they should just stop following the idols.
Blackpink wasn't the stylists themselves they don't totally decide what to wear on their own
They themselves hve said they can choose their outfits if not all the time
They r not babies anymore..they r grown ups women and v can't say like that
Maybe both stylist and the members chose it
@@aksamerinregi934 yeah that's what I said, they don't totally decide/choose what to wear
Ammm , all of them deserve this bc it's really make sense!!
LMAOO I'm crying, it's not Soyeon problem if people get excited or irritated just by a little bit of skin
Blackpink’s outfits were even revealing, people hella overacted.
Hell half of these outfits in the list weren’t even provocative, “fans” looked at them in a provocative way. I’m not one to bash countries way of doing things but damn they need to let loose. Women should be proud of their bodies, no taught to hide them. Showing their legs, stomach, or shoulder isn’t revealing. It’s such a shame to know that those girls will grow up taught to hide their body their body’s and have no confidence about it.
Before you comment pls remember that these are different countries with different cultures and societal rules
Western artists can wear those kind of outfits but kpop idols can't? Like c'mon, sometimes fan should know how respect someone's taste of fashion... It's just some fans are just overeating, treating their idols like baby even tho they're already adult. It's fine when fans reacting to kpop rookies who is minor and yet they're wearing tight clothes, but restricting an adult person??? Sometimes it's fans who is creating problem not the idol...
Because kpop idols are usually from asia, especially east asia, and those countries are way more conservative than western countries. It's literally culture, showing skin is badly seen in asia, not that much in western countries.
@@Yuu-d7b fvck everyone's culture a person can wear what they want to wear
If they are adults then it is fine. Most of these are just women hating other women then they blame men.
Honestly I don't think soyeon's hate was ok, but tbh I am not the biggest fan of Soyeon's revealing outfit
Same
If I was a kpop idol, I hope there's a better treatment for me and to my members to avoid criticisms esp dress
Oh my goodness the last group clothes are way too revealing, the other two groups shouldn’t even be in the same category 😳 and then having teenager girl and minor in the group makes me sick. I have not even heard anyone talk about this before. I wouldn’t even wear anything like that and I’m an adult. Where are her parents this is so sad
Honestly, soyeons shirt was just ugly, but she didnt show too much skin ever
And if Bella hadid wore what soyeon wore, y'all would hype her up
Difference in cultural norm.. Most western celeb fashion is OK with outfit that look like hookers. That is not very respectable in Asia.
Bella Hadid's audience is nearly entirely western.
Kpop's audience is composed of a lot more people from asia. They are miles more conservative than Bella's fans.
This entire comment section praises/defends the girls, who are you talking to?
Somtimes it's not the idols who are at fault but the stylist
with the photoshoots, it's not like they chose those clothes I think. i believe they have stylists that dresses them to fit the concept. why are the idols the one being blamed for that? 🤔
Pride for Serena Gomes because she is intelligent and has adapted to honor the culture of the country of her host to the population with a multitude of public culture..
Who the f netizens think they are? And why should idols listen to them? They can wear whatever they want and no one asked for netizens opinions.
Kpop fans be doing the most. How is she disrecpeting people by wearing clothes ?
Why do they even care about what they wear? It's literally their body so it's their choice. I don't find any wrong about what they wear. If it's make them comfortable then let them be. But about Hayun it's not appropriate since she's a minor. She should not be in the group with that kind of concept. It's literally illegal.
istg I'm damn sure Soyeon didn't give a damn about what people thought about her outfits.
Ohh so they can allow minor girls to debut but i can't agree this 🙄
so annoying, let them wear what they want to wear, maybe just complain if you see the idols looking uncomfortable on their revealing outfits
I feel like laughing on the netizens.😂😂
They're not even reaviling anything and it's shocking for you???
It was totally normal for me at least. In industry some people literally get naked. 😑
wow the girl crush one is rlly inappropriate tbh
No cuz when a pop idol wears almost nothing on stage they call them iconic but when a kpop idol wears slightly revealing clothes it's bad?
It's weird that netizens don't understand the fact that to every show, every concert, every live performance, mvs and photoshoots the stylist pick out idols' outfits
I think Soyeon was wearing the green sweater backwards 🤔🤭🙂
it's worn the right way. someone posted the price of the top and it being worn by a model on twitter.
If the idols chooses what to wear than they should already know the consequences they will face.
Companies don't care about their artists, they only care about their business and profits. These greedy companies and wealthy shareholders. 😠
I don't understand it it's like these are all people that are in their twenties I mean I understand you know there's little kids that look up to them and stuff but I just think it's insane how much hate these Idols get it really is ridiculous and not just the female Idols of males too it's just crazy
Re: Soyeon - the problem with the backless sweater and crotchless jeans is not that they show too much skin, but that they just look weird and not very flattering. Stuff that looks good, or at least interesting, on the catwalk is there to show off the creativity of the designer - it isn't necessarily a guide to actual daily fashion. Similarly something like Jisoo's bizarre coral-like headdress in the "Kill The Love" MV is a poor choice for anything not on stage.
Re: Blackpink - the complaints about the Indonesian ad are valid, the ones about the stage outfits in Malaysia are not. With the former, these ads are presumably made for wide distribution and therefore the haram showing of skin scandalized the general public. With the latter, however, people voluntarily attend the concert and pay a lot of ringgits to do so. The event isn't being broadcast to the public at large, and people who are there presumably know what they are getting into and what Blackpink's style is. Complaining that Blackpink dresses exactly like how they should have been expected to dress is just virtue-signally garbage to get Islamist cred.
Re: Girl Crush - yeah...that's pretty bad.
I personally don’t think Soyeon should’ve gotten any back lash for the green sweater. Her outfit was a bit out there, but it was just her back. A back is a back. For her ripped jeans, I felt like that was a bit too much. I think BP should get a little because I feel like it was a bit disrespectful to wear those types of clothing to a country or in ads for a country where the majority of people believe women should be covered up. They definitely should’ve chosen something more modest. I also think that Hayun has the ability to make her own decisions and if she ends up joining Girl Crush that’s something the public has no power over.
Again, this is my personal opinion.
In soyeon case , and girlcrush case it maybe true company to be blame.In blackpink case the country should not to invite in the first place if they really cannot stand those outfits.And should blame shopee app to make an inappropriate ads.
When KPOP idols wear this types of outfit they are criticised and bash but when hollywood stars wear them they are praise and worship! 😅😅😅😅
jessi and hyuna sips tea
none of them deserve criticism, let women wear what they want without worries of being sexualized. women's fashion is a form of expression, not an invitation.
It all seems very forced and uncomfortable to watch.
y provocative even a word ??
females can dress the way they want
bold , provocative etc etc do away with such words please
maybe use clothes or outfits
Honestly they can wear whatever she wants, but they know what she’s doing