Hamas-Israel war explained in 5 questions. Plus ‘5 failed states’, and where India stands
Вставка
- Опубліковано 8 жов 2023
- #CutTheClutter #Israel #HamasAttack
The terrorist organisation Hamas, which controls Gaza, caught Israel by surprise this weekend, unleashing terror and death. Israel struck back with air strikes, and Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said their response to Hamas “will change the Middle East”. In Ep 1325 of Cut The Clutter, Editor-in-Chief Shekhar Gupta breaks down the ongoing war into 5 questions to explain what is happening, and where India and the world stand.
@kumarakomlakeresortkerala
@pauljohnresortsandhotels
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Watch Episode 744 of Cut The Clutter here: • Trouble in Jerusalem o...
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Read Shekhar Gupta's National Interest here: theprint.in/national-interest...
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Watch National Interest here : • Modi has exhumed Nehru...
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Read Nahum Barnea report here: www.ynetnews.com/article/h100...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Please read CSIS paper here: csis-website-prod.s3.amazonaw...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Exclusive content, special privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for Special benefits: theprint.in/subscribe/
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/subscribe/
» Subscribe to our UA-cam Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintIndia
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8
Exclusive content, special privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for Member benefits: theprint.in/subscribe/
Mohammad flew on a flying donkey from Al Aqsa mosque to meet this so called Allah. Sheep will believe any crap.
😅😅 😮
How come Shekhar Gupta bring name of Ram janma Bhoomi/Babri masjid here despite KK Mohd of ASI and Meenakshi Jain had given a detailed analysis and account on that
I'd love 30+ Mins CTC and 28+ Mins National Interest eps
Speak in Hindi.
It always amazes me how Islamic community doesn’t vehemently condemn barbaric acts committed by people from within its community and cries foul for even smallest of acts done against them.
It's always the case. It turned a secular fellow like me to look inwards when the shit hit the fan
and what Israel has been doing for many, many decades, is ofcourse a role model for humanity 🤦🏻♂️
To every action, there is an equal and opposite reaction, ofcourse that's in physics.. in geopolitics, it might not be equal given the great power differences, but opposition somewhere boils over
@@-RudhreshMsame here. As long as they don't look at other humans as equals, they deserve nothing but contempt from the rest of the world. Islamists have the mic but I only see moderates defending Islamists instead of condemning them
Even I think about the same point why can't Islamic nations stand up to it and say this is an insult to Islam don't spoil Islam kind of thing
read the book, at least the relevant parts. It is the book that explains everything and also its author and his life which is a role model.
After UAE siding with ISRAEL, ABDULLAS here are now confused 😂😂
Epic 😂 abb ye usko bhi kafir kahenge 😅
😂😂
Modi ji has made special efforts to consolidate India's relationship with UAE so now they are on our side. That's why they support Israel.
No one is confused......unko F-35 chahiye
@@justsain3236nope they went for the rafael fighters just like India
UAE, Israel, India are civilizations. Civilizations can sit together with mutual respect and interest. Islam/xtianity are religions whose goal is conquest. They wont stop until completely conquer. After conquest, it will seek bigotry
Islam is a close corporation and the distinction that it makes between Muslims and non-Muslims is a very real, very positive and very alienating distinction. The brotherhood of Islam is not the universal brotherhood of man. It is a brotherhood of Muslims for Muslims only. There is a fraternity, but its benefit is confined to those within that corporation. For those who are outside the corporation, there is nothing but contempt and enmity.
Religion is just a cover for something illegal going on there how people don't understand this is beyond me
British is responsible for this
I don't know why they created Israel
Very true, BANNISH ISLAM
Ambedkar said it right 😊
Jay Bhim 💙.
Jai Bhim !❤. Ambedkar said it so right decades ago. No one quotes this.
UAE becomes first Muslim country to condemn the attack of Hamas on Israel
Should be... it's idiotic and cruel to support some terrorist org attack on civilians by a state
@@smokingtom404yet so many are doing it instinctively
There is no "both sides" argument:
~Only Palestinians live under military occupation for last 75 years up to this day.
~Only Palestinians have homes stolen for illegal Israeli settlements for last 75 up to this day.
~Only Palestinians are being dispossessed since last 75 years up to this day.
~Only Palestinians face apartheid laws since last 75 up to this day.
ALL of this is done by one side: Israel upon Palestinians since last 75 years up to this day.
The UAE is trying to get a security agreement with America. Iran has seized some islands belonging to them. You need to watch out, you don't know the politics of the region.
It’s a crime ? Really? And why do you support the RSS?
Why is Muslim community in India and muslim countries doesnt condemn Hamas terrorism? All these countries seriously condemned Nupur Sharmas comments.
This is Islam😂 In its entirety is piggish in its affairs
The question is why don't jews condemn the occupation, displacement and daily humiliation of Palestinians for over 80 years?!
Exactly all fanatics ,any day Hindu's and Bharat the best..
just like when people like u don't condemn when israeli forces attack the unarmed palistinians and it's a everyday thing that happens .....probably that's why it has been normalised and nobody even thinks about it anymore except the stakeholders obviously. But when something big happens like this suddenly people wake up from their sleep and condemning (which they should) only one side without asking what caused it
😢 Any violence is bad . But if you make democratic, secular system ( Fathe group in case of Palestine) what people will do ? In Ramzan Israeli army attacked Al Aqsa mosque and nobody condemned and listend to Fateh Group . Now people of Palestine lost faith in Fateh Group,and every week Isreali colonizers attacking Palestinnis ,Capturing their houses what will they do ?
OMG! Shekhar Ji just called hamas a TERRORIST ORG!
Slip of the tongue. Correction coming.
If they are terrorist, I feel sad for innocent death but if they are elected people government then the civilian doesn't deserve sympathy. Be it Israel or Palestine. Period.. Terrorism should be clean with like DETTOL like germs 99.9%.
@@VenkatRaghvan-dc3mf 😂😂😂👍
Indeed it is A Terrorist Country/Organisation
Ghar wapsi by Shekhu😅
Lot of lessons for India to Learn from this incident. This might happen in states of Punjab, Jammu and Kashmir and also Mumbai like incidents. Indian army should train for these type of incidents.
You forgot to add Manipur where such incidents are taking place today. I wonder Why?
There is no "both sides" argument:
~Only Palestinians live under military occupation for last 75 years up to this day.
~Only Palestinians have homes stolen for illegal Israeli settlements for last 75 up to this day.
~Only Palestinians are being dispossessed since last 75 years up to this day.
~Only Palestinians face apartheid laws since last 75 up to this day.
ALL of this is done by one side: Israel upon Palestinians since last 75 years up to this day.
The Palestinians are treat very badly Indian. Gaza has been described by Israeli analysis and generals as "open air prison, and hell on earth". It is sad, the you are seeing is the real life "hunger games" inside of Israel only worse.
@@Madame702 These people who are spitting venom against Palestinians are not regular/normal Indians. These are troll armies of the RSS/BJP/Hindutva right wing. Their venom against Palestinians is nothing to do with the Palestinian struggle.
It is purely anti Muslim hatred. These trolls would stand with Israel or Russia or Ukraine or US or China or Myanmar or Sri Lanka or anyone at any point of time who is against Muslims in any shape or form.
They do the same thing even within India. This is their only way of earning a cent or two everyday being part of IT cell of right wing brigades.
@@pardeeptandonin Manipur Meitei Hindus are killed on a daily basis by Kuki christian missionaries
Fun Fact: Pakistan's Zia Ul Haq killed more Palestinian Muslims than Israel had killed till date!!! 🤣🤣🤣
How and why?! Pakistan is halfway around the world and has never been in conflict with Palestinians.
@@AMA-OnlineHe sent pakistani army at request of king of jordan to crush palestine rebellion in jordan
@@AMA-Online It means you are a total ignorant about Muslim Pakistan. Pakistan is like a mosquito... it travels everywhere to spread disease. Now google and find out that Muslim Pakistan has killed millions of muslims including Bangladesh, Kashmir, Balochistan and Palestine. It has hands in almost every terror attack in the world.
The world has seen the Muslim response with Communist party of China ethnic cleansing of of Muslims!! In fact, despite Muslim oppression, Arabs/OIC & poor Muslims/Pakistanis are happy dancing on Chinese tunes!!
I pray for all the poor innocent souls that have died in this conflict over land. Playing Devils advocate. What if Benjamin set this up to get the left to join his gov?? Israel was a split Parliament over last two years. Ben Shapiro himself says this on Piers that it was the lefties who perished. Something very nefarious happening.
Quranic concept of war after all says it all ...
This is the only ghastly incidence inside Israel.
Palestinians have been facing such carnage nearly every day.
Did we ever felt sympathy for the Palestinians when they are killed in cold blood, their houses demolished, and lands confiscated?
Did we ever saw the maps of Israel, how its borders are expanding just like a cancerous growth?
@@nazeerpasha2075what the Palestinians bhais of your kind did like raping, killing chicken and post them on media 😂 feel sympathy??? Hope they burn in dajjal's fire forever as they are killed by Jews anyways 😂
@@nazeerpasha2075everything you said is false.
@@nazeerpasha2075 Problem is not about Israel or Palestine. Do you like Jews or any non-Muslim according to the Qur'an? That is the problem, everywhere around the world Muslims are the only ones who kill people and then they cry when the other side retaliate. Jews are in such small numbers, let them live . You have 57 countries to go and stay. Btw terrorism does have a religion and it is Islam.
@@nazeerpasha2075No palestinians were raped, no palestinian dead bodies were mutilated, no naked dead palestinian women were paraded around in a truck. You are a bloodthirsty liar trying to justify terrorism to the victims of terrorism.
The thing to learn from this is that sooner or later Indians/ Sanatanis (Hindu, Sikhs, Buddhists, Jains, etc) will face a similar or larger attack from Pakistan or Bangladesh soil. How prepared are we as a society and institutions in terms of military but more importantly global public opinion and internal unity when that day comes. Pakistan is weak today, India is strong, in future the cards may flip.
There are mini pakistan inside india too
They can also launch missile if got chance .
Funny, That’s exactly what we think could happpen from a hindutva besotted India desparate to prove their vegan inspired machoness to smaller neighbors. Please, pretty please… deal with China first. Let’s see what you’re made of. 🤗
Nonsense. Fear spreading for no reasons.
@himansu5556 This is exactly the kind of naivete that needs to be defeated. Pak army raping millions of Hindu women isn't even 50 years old. Hindu women being raped and fed the blood soaked rice of her son isn't 30 years old. What do you have to say in your defense why millions of raped Hindu women is "fear mongering"?
@@arindambaisyaActually they did the opposite thing. Blood of slain son was fed to the mother mixed with rice, and then those women were r**ed and k***ed.
Finding parallel with ramjanma bhoomi and babri majid is extremely stupid ...as babri masjid is irrelevant in Islamic theology while ramjanmabhoomi is extremely important in sanatana dharma. Terrorism is unacceptable no matter the emotions.
peaceful people spreading peace
Peaceful people spreading pieces
💯😂
Sanatanis showing they are shaitanis
@@adduv1 what about you pedophile worshiper 😂
@@adduv1jali na jali na😂😂 sachai hajam ho nahi rahi hai.. 😅
There's absolutely no justification for barbaric violence Hamas enacted on those civilians. This was 26/11 but 20 times worse mixed with Medieval barbaism. They did not see those civilians as people but as Jews, Kafirs meant to be slaughtered.
Palestinians need to unambiguously condemn this barbaric act. While they lecture us about Bhagat Singh, the Palestinian Ambassador also forget that Gandhi ended Non cooperation movement over brutal violence at Champaran. They can learn something from him about condemnation.
Edit: Pakistanis are invading the comments.
Bhagat singh NEVER advocated for committing such barbaric and inhuman acts on his opponents
Israel has been committing this barbaric violence for the last 50+ years. #freepalestine.
Abe bot 😂
@@ashamsaud4737abdulla is confused i guess, wathching videos in kafer made technology
@@parvadhami980You're right but Palestinian authority is using him as a poster boy to justify indiscriminate killing. Bhagat Singh is remembered for both what he did and restraint he showed. His contribution will never be forgotten.
The difference between Abrahamic and Indian faiths is
Mount Kailasha is holy to Hindus, Buddhists and Jains but they all revere it and not fight over it....!!!
Many such examples in the Indian subcontinent...!!
Mohmo made this story of going to heaven from al aqxa riding buraq. The truth is he was caught coming out of his cousin's house in the morning after spending the entire night with her.
Mohmo hated dogs and ordered the killing of dogs because barking dogs woke people up when he was venturing out at night to fulfill his urges.
SG would never dare unclutter this so I did it for him
Good work by ex-muslims
What do you expect from an Urban Naxal?
If this can happen in 21st century imagine what barbarism our ancestors have to live for a millenia. No doubt Sati Jauhar were harsh steps but was need of the hour for our ancestors to save dead bodies from disruspect by barbaric Maleechhas😢
yes, cant imagine the atrocities that our ancestors had to endure. Also must read 'Fatha Alamgiri' of Aurangajeb to know institutional discrimination on kafirs like us.
I don't agree with you, India was divided in many nation states there was never a unified india except the Ashoka time that too not full indian map that we see today.
Many local rulers helped these so called invaders to take the rulers they dislike, infact many of them invited these invaders soo no one was innocent, everyone was power hungry corrept rulers who never cared for commeners and we commerners are the first one to suffer this egoistocal wars .
Accept the fact buddy our ancestors were just peasants the upper ruling class never cares about us, just like the present day politicians and vips, our lives are just cheap things for them to play with.
That still does not justify Sati Jauhar in anyway. You cannot tell your people to commit mass suicide to not fall in the hands of the enemy. What if all Israelis did that? You have to stand strong and fight no matter what. Suicide is never justified.
@@observer-fc7toIndia was under a single Kingdom multiple times
Mauryas,Gupta's, kannada king immadi pulakeshi, Vijayanagar empire and cholas whole of South India....on multiple times whole of India was with single Empire
Even Mughals had
@@akhiljames3435 it does.
Ohh please, this is not Ram trample & Babri Mosque. Stop comparing this to temple dispute. Within India, almost all of these structures were built on top of broken temples. As a season journalist, you shouldn't compare these two.
It shows his lack of grey matter
how is it not the same thing? this is also mosque built on top of temple mount. except it isn't some forgotten mosque like babri
He suffers from temple phobia.
LYYEUN indoctrination
"3 great faiths...." Gupta ji was never so magnanimous towards Hinduism
Spot on. Problem with Hindus never proud like others
Cancee also spreads like yoxic poison throughout the mind and body. More people have suffered because of these ideologies than anything else. Please stop glamourising these things.
You need to read everything in context, if it was the case that even hinduism was a party to the holy land issue in Israel then I am sure he would have characterised this as a issue of ‘4’ great faiths. I cannot imagine him saying this as an issue of 3 great faiths and 1 lesser faith i.e Hinduism. Please don’t try to find a smoking gun where there isn’t one. This is the whole cause of division in our world.
The 3 great faiths are Christianity, Islam and Hinduism BUT for some reason they keep adding Judaism instead.
@@justsain3236
The 3 great faiths are Christianity, Islam and Hinduism BUT for some reason they keep adding Judaism instead."
=============================
NO faith is great.
Faith is the excuse people give, when they have no valid reason.
'Faith' is the primary cause of horrible bloodshed such as this one.
CWC not condemning the terror attack gives me another reason to vote for the BJP. I do not want my country's foreign policy to go for a toss
You want Adani to own you
@@victimoffame2389if alternative is islamist owning everything with congress support than yes. Let adani have it all.
@@victimoffame2389better than dying in a bomb attack
@@victimoffame2389 kya phoonk k aaya hai bey😂 #pappuparty
They did condemn the brutal attack on citizen of Israel
One thing i realised after watching this video is that, despite being relatively new religion, why islam always wants to take over already present religious sites??
Why their caliphs and prophets only go to places which were already places of worship for age old religion??
Case al aqsa and babri mosque
Imagine the levels of barbarism and brutality our ancestors would have had to face by these harsh cultists 😢!
Thank God we have Sanskari leaders like BJP Brij Bhushan to protect our women..
@@mg.f.9023 Leave an extreme case here or there. Happens probably with a "Missionaries of Charity" too. Speaking generally and as of this date, an ordinary BJP wirker inspires more confidence and reliability than a politico of any other Indian political party. Agree ??
@@sureshbharadwaj7403
BJP also shows confidence with friendship with China by increasing imports from China, while china sits on our piece of land now.
@@mg.f.9023 Those are due to economic and military compulsions . It is not a start fight or brawl to simply start a war or even a skirmish. One must be very judicious , discreet.
blatant to harass the minorities, the free press, the critics, the comedians...
but Judicious & discreet to handle China?
Bharat should have done a similar after Islamic Pakistan audacious terror attack on Mumbai 2611 . Shameful that Congress choose to abandon National Security and more ridiculous that Lutyens media were also silent
Pakistan has nukes, palestine does not have even a guided rocket
@@akhiljames3435so, what difference does it make !!
It means u have nukes free to Do terror attacks like 26/11 ??
No one is scared of Pakistan nukes !! I'm sure pak army also loves it citizens & ready to accept mutual destruction...
If u can't save people from these low life state backed terrorists
And then too teas would have served.....😂
Bharat should not have the audacity to make claims like that, otherwise they will get served so much tea they cannot handle
Shekhar Gupta- dude don’t try to justify barbarism. you are better than this.
Spot on, he is usually convincing on this he is sucking up to Islamists. He feels for Gaza not Israel, very peculiar
Word spinner.finding words to support these hamas goons.
He is not better than this. This is what Shekar Gupta is
@@hray2008🤔
CONgress CON response has been in line with keeping with their “vote bank” politics ! Like Dhobhi Kaa Kutta Naa Ghar ka Naa Ghat Kaa !
Why does every major mosque of theirs is built either destructing a major temple or church of another religion? The fact that this is the fact wherewver it has spread speaks volumes of how it has risen. Breaking cultures to build theirs.
Islam is really new so it has to spread with violence.
Most of middle East dont have democracy so politics atleast internally doesn't affect
There is democracy in Israel
SG America fights many Muslim nations which are part of global south but whenever US wants something done all these countries agree to USA. So the leadership comes from how powerful you are. India is a rising power so don’t worry India will be default leader of global south soon. India will have different stand on issues but when it comes getting things for it’s interests then it will find a way to make it happen.
What makes you think India/Bharat will treat these animals differently? If you get to be number one, you will have the job of keeping them in their place. You'll soon be amazed at how similar your responses are.
"India is rising" for the last 76 years :P. My father is 73 he's tired of this "India is rising" . It's the favourite slogan of every new Govt .He takes it as an old joke . I'm 25 and I'm tired Already of this slogan. It's been 10-12 years now that India's per capita income is stagnant at $2-3000/annum(you may yourself look up the figures of the these years and divide that by then prevalent USD-INR exchange rate) because of inflation and the only thing that's increasing is inequality(which means a third thing is happening as well and the govt doesn't tell us that is the median incomes are falling) . Sorry to say, as a 25-year old Indian myself when someone says" India is rising" , I now find it a mockery and a really poor and cliché joke...
@@rupinderkaur4344 75 years is a fraction of a second in geological time. Meanwhile, China is going to lose a huge chunk of its population to old age and its economy due to alienating all of its neighbors. So, yes, you are on the upswing, even if slowly.
@@markkonzerowsky8871 Thank you hinting at me that I have to be as old as dinosaurs to see if India will be developed or not . China aged or not doesn't matter too much because it has a more productive and healthy workforce with which coupled with good economic freedom they've accumulated a lot of savings ,investment and wealth and is today in per capita income just qualifies for the developed country criteria unlike India which is still waist-deep into malnutrition problem, has investment rate at 30% of GDP unlike China at 45% . Large population of India doesn't mean healthy workable population, in fact compare the labour participation rate of India and China, it is day-night difference, much less for female participation rate. When China had a demographic dividend like India it focused on good education for the masses via public schools like any other successful developing country or developed country unlike India. Its literacy rate in 1991 was what India had in 2011 . Its OECD PISA scores are top notch while India's last PISA was in 2009 scoring one of the lowest in the world. China focused on free trade and economic freedom whereas India for the last 10 years focused on keeping away from them including the RCEP because of which much of FDI outflow from China goes into Vietnam (partly also because it has better learning outcomes, better skilled labour even as they spend 1/2 of time as India in schooling and tuitions) . India will not grow because it skips all of the above and some really non sensical policies go on without recourse and anybody to question- hospitalisation like PMJAY's focus even as hospitalisation expenses take up just 10% of total health expenses, less than 5% of patient population (as per NFHS-2019) and lack of focus on mass basic public school education.
Except Indian is speaking out right now is it. In fact, agrees with the United States. Funny how that works.
You can’t compare India and Israel. Israel is occupying Palestinian land while Indian Muslims have freedom to move and live wherever they want. India is not fencing people in small cities and controlling them. I understand some Indians get emotional and support Israel , but the two countries/ people are not the same .
Actually Pakistan is occupying Indian lands.
@@viswanathanseshadri1047 India should get it back then. Can’t they defeat small nation like Pakistan?
@@tormundgaint1022
Hey terror sympathizer. The land was of Jews and Christians which the Muslims captured illegally, just like mughals did in India.
Now after terror attacks u the supporters of the terrorists play the victim card
Don't need it. It's swarming with radicals.
It had to occupy so as to keep the mad dog in check. Can you talk about history between 1948-1967 when the first annexation happend in 1967?
When IS was employing the same kind of barbaric tactics, they said this has nothing to do with our peaceful religion, but now Palestine has done the same thing, will they say the same? Also Hamas is very "bravely" threatening to execute hostages if Israel continues bombing them, question for Israel is , do they finish this once and for all or do they cling on to a small chance that few hostages might be alive and stop and let this happen again in the future.
They have a clear protocol on this - do not negotiate under pressure. If they do it once, they will have to do it again and again.
SG's CTC on international affairs are always outstanding - fact based, to the point and analytical. I wish his CTC on domestic issues could be like that. The contrast of CTC on domestic vs international issues is similar to Al Jazeera's reporting on Israel Palestine issue vs other global affairs.
Shekhar ji, But Kashmir issue or any issue in India is nothing like the Palestine - Israel issue.
Israel has captured the land. India has not captured anything.
It was British India and King of J&K have given it to India.
Also in 1947-48, Main leader of Kashmir, Shekh Abdullah was with India and he supported the merger of Kashmir with India. So India has both legal and popular political support for merger of Kashmir with India.
But in Palestine, Israel captured land since beginning and even if we consider that existence issue of Jews people whatever Israel is doing after 6 days war, is nothing but barbaric act and colonial mindset.
Simply put, Israel has captured Palestine based on some 2 thousand years old claims.
But India supporting illegal Israeli occupation, wouldn’t it give power to illegal occupation of Kashmir by Pakistani? I think we should have thought before standing with Israel or just hold the middle ground pointing to the solution?
@@Vaibhavpandey2 This is the first time India is only with Israel and I don't think India should take sides.
However, we should also condemn any attack on civilians or killing of civilians, be it by HAMAS or by Israel.
Two state solutions should always be supported by India.
Also, It will not impact India's position in Kashmir bcz Kashmir is not Palestine. Those who live there are Kashmiri. Even in POK, Kashmiri live.
Thanks for the detailed update. It's a pity that the present Indian opposition mostly takes stand against the official voice of the country. We should unite at least for international issues.
They will loose their vote bank. That is above everything else for the family
Thank you, my friend. I'm glad you found this episode insightful. Do keep watching and writing in...best wishes, Shekhar
How is that the voice of the country? Just because the islamophobic party which is in power says so? That's just a small percentage of the great country.
@@rasheedusmani1 nah bruv, Its well known Israel mistreats palestinians, but you have to be a big hypocrite if you say what Hamas is doing is justified... innocent people are dying, that isn't right. Also walk out of your circle for once and you might just realize it isn't a small percentage of our great country.
@@rasheedusmani1 Really? Small percentage ?
dude, you circle the topic and cant even say Hamas was responsible for this edition of killings of both the peoples. Shame on you
There is no "both sides" argument:
~Only Palestinians live under military occupation for last 75 years up to this day.
~Only Palestinians have homes stolen for illegal Israeli settlements for last 75 up to this day.
~Only Palestinians are being dispossessed since last 75 years up to this day.
~Only Palestinians face apartheid laws since last 75 up to this day.
ALL of this is done by one side: Israel upon Palestinians since last 75 years up to this day.
Amazing analysis of this hugely complex situation, Shekhar sir! ❤
Paid commenter😂😂
here in my country Ethiopia there is deadly war which is taking the life of mostly civilian but im listening to is israeli-palestanian war from bombey which is more heart breaking i pray for the world to experiance the full degree of peace
Sir, it is essentially a religious issue rooted in the history of Abrahmic religions going back more than 2000 years. There is no political solution.
SG- Pl. get to the Point fast, no one has time to listen to the foggy analyses that is NOT critical to the topic! Dont lose focus.
Excellent episode. The question answer format cuts the clutter even..
Prophet PBUH visited from a Mecca to Al-Aqsa on his lightning donkey!Though none saw this, luckily he told After his visit!
Donkey might have eaten invisibility potion 😂
Finally today's episode released. Now it can put me to sleep
Mr. Gupta, can you talk without moving your hands? It is very distracting.
Great take! I would love to also hear one involving Iran and the other Arab states and how it influenced this current war, as in the videos of the attack you can hear Parisian language as well
The reaction from Labor party in the UK is cautious after anti-Semitism charges put on it under jeremy corbyn. Kier Stemmer might have learnt a few things. He also made a statement against 'Hinduphobia' & said he'll counter it
The Labour Party isn't to be trusted. It now relies heavily on the muslim vote bank
Correction…Wasn’t the area considered an occupied land by Palestinians where the people were forcibly evacuated and made to live as refugees in Gaza the biggest prison of the world..
Correction..
ppl in Gaza do have options to leave
Two corridors were open till now, one to Egypt and another to westbank
Few years ago, there were 5 !!
When they misused these roads, closed down and reduced to two
If Gaza is a prison than how hamas got sophisticated ammunition?
I doubt that Mossad had no idea about such a huge operation. It has happened historically several times, you allow the opposite side to attack you, so that you can create the right environment to eliminate the threat, rather than contain them forever.
I was thinking the same.
The greater israel project cannot take off without peace in the region.The only nations that are standing in the way are Palestinians and Iran. The entire Shite order. Understand this, The Iran as an Islamic republic will cease to exist and Israel will ensure that.
Even if they knew they would never allow to happen in this scale.
Exactly my thought. But may be they misread the extent.
Jews do not let a single jew die for some larger goal. Thats not how they work, they go by the rule book.
Thank you for breaking this down indepth. But wars are never good for anyone.
"Holy real estate" is a new way of saying it.
Gupta Ji, I just stopped your video in between.
What did you mean by "The three great faiths" ? Who are you
Very informative Sir. Thank you. Please do one on Manipur too.
already made it i guess
The 5th point needs subsequent deliberations...as an Indian every single person should listen/ read it before reaching any conclusions...we should participate in the voting process with both our heads and hearts
No analysis help wounds. Now I understand why India built border roads along China. Plus militery movement.
Excellent coverage shekarji. Kudos to you and your team to explain the needle in the haystack. Great shirt btw.
Alt take; Mossad and IDF "allowed" the invasion to an extent to justify the retaliation on Gaza.
This topic is really very complex or layered, one needs to funnel it through.....staring from history -> geo politics ->religion ->local disputes.
💎🏆 Great insightful video 🏆💎
Our armed forces & internal Security will not have any leisure whether it is Diwali or holidays . Be prepared always. Govt & intelligence have to be alert always. Finally, common folk should also be aware of such sudden uprisings.
We being secular is a huge advantage and reason for that and makes it a little better. I know not everyone is out of post but Due to non overlap it is a little simpler and I am proud of India and indian army for that
The second temple was built not by Herod but by the Jews themselves after the edict of King Cyrus after the Israelites were captured and taken to Babylon. There is the famous song By the Rivers of Babylon. Account of the building of the second temple is in the Book of Ezra.
Tremendous experience 👏 👌 👍
My most portrayed commentator...great knowledge...❤
Babri masjid Ram janmbhoomi can’t be compared to Al aksa mosque in any manner.
Say Khangress
Not Congress 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
thanks for explaining
Excellent analysis
Guptaji so late. Ask your editors to upload early
Question 6: How is it that the makers of Pegasus & their super spy organisation Mossad failed to provide Intel to their own country?
Sir so nicely explained the subject. Thank you sir
Outstanding, thank you for explaining this to detail. Truly appreciate it
this happened because of people who don't condemn when israeli forces attack the unarmed palistinians and it has become an everyday thing now .....probably that's why it has been normalised and nobody even thinks about it anymore except the stakeholders obviously. But when something big happens like this suddenly people wake up from their sleep and start condemning (which they should) only one side without asking what caused it
Why does this outcry only gain attention for one particular conflict. Only last 2 years back, 376000 people were brutally killed in Yemen, and 70% of them were children. I haven't seen the same or even some amount of protests across the world. I was surprised even 3 years back, too. 🤷🤷
India can be called isolated only if whol global south spoke about pelstine etc but only Islamic countries of global south are going in to whataboutery or root causes of this terrorist attack. Other may be sitting on fence but india has always bifurcated between hamas the terrorist gruop and pelstinian goverment. India dose not say goverments of pelstine is terrorist. For example india called khlistanis terrorist because they are and such terrorist are eaither citizens or are sheltered by canda uk usa and Australia but india dose not start calling candian goverment terrorist ( though it may start doing so soon if truedo dose not mend his way soon 🤣) . So hamas is a terroriest group and india dose not differentiate amongest terrorist like truedo who says " my terrorist is global terrorist but your terrorist is my plumber "😂
This detailed analysis was superb and insightful Shekharji
Intelligent and balanced overview of the facts
Lazy media be like , Hamas attacked , israels mistake , Israel defended , still their mistake
Shekhar Gupta is worth listening to when it comes to international events & Indian non-political events.
As for Indian politics, he is a great source of information & history but his conclusions are clouded by his anti-RSS parivar (BJP, NaMo included) views.
India has to be very careful by keeping our people interest and also upcoming election. Lot of forces trying their best to divide people by regions, religion etc.
We want more on this. Very important.
Supporting one side and condemning other is the norm of the day but while saying that you cannot ignore the violence and death of thousands of innocent people on both side. Whole hearted sympathy and condolences to all injured civilians and passed away souls. Eye for an eye makes world blind, Israel can change the modalities of the ongoing kinetic action because death of one innocent soul can create 2 sour hearted terrorists filled with anger and purpose of revange. And Israel can't clear all 2 million Palestinian people in a Gaza strip, that would be a genocide, which jews have faced themselves in holocaust in 2nd world war.
that's the ghandi secularism indian muzlim knows but they don't
Yr apologies attitude is favoring the Hamas - terrorists.
They have already killed thousands of palestines over the years. I don't think they would shy away from another war now.
Kind request. Please reduce the length of episodes to no less than 10 mins .
Why don’t turn off after 10 mins. This length is fine for the rest of us
this can be done in less than 10 mins. he just keeps blabbering same thing again & again.
@@ash9x9so true
@@ash9x9 Its amazing the guys that complain the most, probably don't subscribe and for sure don't pay. suck it up, peeps, Don't like it, hit the forward button on your browser and watch some inane reels.
@@rohandev1444 is it a must to take subscription to hear this lutyen journalist, since when you got the right to decide anything
Thank you for this. Really helpful for me.
3:56 why did you not mention him the Israel defence minister calling them “Human animals” ??? This omission is quite telling, don’t expect this from you Mr.Gupta.
Jyoti mam to aaj bahut dukhi hongi. Wire , quint and mojo mai to maatam ho raha hoga. Arfa , barkha, jyoti , rajdeep my condolences r with u. Wait next few days cleanup operation will start soon even in india
War looks ok unit it's not in ur doorstep
Really good one..
Great explanation sir
Astonishing that Israel was caught napping. A good lesson for India. We have so many festivals...we better be vigilant.
You really think they don't know about it . They let it happen so that they can end all adversaries around them once and for all and that includes palestine and its people too.
hi your congi is supporting hamas. do you support it?
😂 leave the kangress aside 🤣 Al aqsha was near meca
guptaji too is lack of knowledge
UPA didn't give root cause justification, they were blaming the RSS.
Excellent analysis.
Mr. Gupta is indirectly trying so hard to justify terrorism and barbaric acts by asking to look at root causes. Why don't you come clear on it rather than using indirect language, so as per you these acts on innocent women and children are justified because of root causes? That is some sick mindset, I would say.
He didn't miss the opportunity to pull up the topic on Babri masjid and link it to justify terrorism in India!! Just wow.
He used this topic to even challenge India's position as the leader of the Global South!! Really? I mean this is some really long shot just for the sake of it. The relationship of India and Israel goes back a long way and is multi-dimensional and so there is nothing wrong for India to speak in support of Israel especially if it faced a genuine terrorist attack. Besides, this is not an issue of Global South. The leadership of Global South doesn't mean that every country in Global South will speak in the same tone for every single topic of the world. Have some sense. What leadership of Global South means is that whatever topics and issues which are important for Global South are dealt by them in a collective tone and possibly lead by India. So, there is a need for you to understand the big difference, or is it just because you want China instead to be seen as a Global South leader?
Indian Muslims should support Israel or Palestine depending on which country is better for development of India
Rather than just supporting fellow "believers".
Nationalism should always win against Religion.
Then they ask what should we do to prove our patriotism
India Advocates for 2 state solution and has good relationship with Israel and Palestine
Weird how u r using international conflict home patriot testimg
@@anshuraj4277 I'm just stating that all Indians and the government of India should look at it with the same lens that we look at say Taiwan and China or Russia and Ukraine. Without bringing religion or anything else in the equation.
Purely on the basis of our country's national interest.
@@meawwow
I mean... That's exactly what government does
Having relationship with both sides
U think any GOI can recognize Taiwan or stop trading with China... Come on
Also.. Hamas is Islamist terrorist organization
And Israel is occupant state with no rights for Palestinians
Pointing that out isn't treason
Plus... This isn't out war anyway
Support humanity and criticize barbarian acts.
There is no "both sides" argument:
~Only Palestinians live under military occupation for last 75 years up to this day.
~Only Palestinians have homes stolen for illegal Israeli settlements for last 75 up to this day.
~Only Palestinians are being dispossessed since last 75 years up to this day.
~Only Palestinians face apartheid laws since last 75 up to this day.
ALL of this is done by one side: Israel upon Palestinians since last 75 years up to this day.
These faiths keep on fighting among themselves .
Dhanyawad 🙏
It reminds me of 26/11
Guptaji is a soft jihadi
He's just trying to save his head (literally 😥)
Wow, thank you for offering such a brave patient attempt at making some sense of such nonsense. Never heard you before this episode but I’ve just subscribed
This is excellent analysis.. Shekhar
Shekhar ji, guess you are not happy with India trying to claim global south developing nations leadership. But for the US, India’s value partly due to this claim that may deny the same or make it contested for China. If India is just another camp follower of the west it’d sell itself short.
He is a Leftist..... Leftist job is to condemn and never let your country improve
Ganja shekar has shown his true color eventually. See the other video where his journalist didnt ask any single question regarding hamas and gave platform to Palestinian ambassador who supported the attack.
Consolidated information!
The lessons are as old as time. All militaries must revisit their recruitment, training systems