BWV 831 - French Overture (Scrolling)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 15 жов 2024
  • Performer & Album Info - 28:02
    1. Overture - 0:19
    2. Courante - 7:50
    3. Gavotte 1/2 - 9:37
    4. Passpied 1/2 - 12:36
    5. Sarabande - 15:09
    6. Bourree 1/2 - 20:11
    7. Gique - 22:53
    8. Echo - 24:58

КОМЕНТАРІ • 223

  • @12semitones57
    @12semitones57 4 роки тому +70

    Man, I wish I was good enough to play this! There’s something about Bach where playing his work is more fulfilling then just listening.

    • @jondogerman4195
      @jondogerman4195 3 роки тому +10

      You can do it man, I was in that stage too, but I’m learning how to play it and I’m learning the overture rn

    • @bercaferca4554
      @bercaferca4554 2 роки тому +4

      Same with me and A Major Invention. So satisfying, the castle of heaven seems to unveil itself around you when finally “discovering” bach. it’s a treasure trove
      His a major works are just more satisfying, as are mozart’s and even beethoven’s. E Flat and A Major are divine and universally cousins. Cant wait for the next AOt episode. I am high. I am very fucking high.

    • @Philobach
      @Philobach 2 роки тому +1

      C est faux !! l écouter, par Glenn Gould ce morceau, peut élever au ciel...(donner de fortes émotions ), comme toute l' écoute de Bach.

  • @dylanchristensen7716
    @dylanchristensen7716 7 років тому +66

    Why does Bach have to be so dang good?!?!? All of his songs brings me to tears with his powerful and graceful compositions!

    • @winterdesert1
      @winterdesert1 7 років тому +16

      I'm not brought to tears, but I'm in emotional awe. I sort of feel like I'm moving at the speed of light.

    • @jamjam9253
      @jamjam9253 4 роки тому +9

      @XDranzer000 Bachs music requires a much "deeper" listening to get through to him. His music is like complex poems which you maybe have to read many times to really understand the true meaning. But if you get to this point you are more amazed and moved than by almost any other music.

    • @orb3796
      @orb3796 4 роки тому +5

      @XDranzer000 Whenever I see a french person discrediting German culture it reeks of jealousy to me

    • @francobonanni3499
      @francobonanni3499 3 роки тому

      @XDranzer000 Bach Is surely a musical genius but his too many notes make my head turn...at times

    • @TheGentleUncle
      @TheGentleUncle 3 роки тому

      @Boop can’t "avoid" him? It's one thing to say that you are not emotionally moved by his music and another to say it's unpleasant to you. But in any case the fact that you cannot avoid his works on anything that qualifies you musically says it all.

  • @TheApostleofRock
    @TheApostleofRock 9 років тому +129

    the fugue in the overture is amazing..

    • @Philobach
      @Philobach 4 роки тому +6

      chef d oeuvre de toute beauté et créativité comme BACH a le secret. mais personnellement je suis sensible aussi au passage lent avant la fugue, mais franchement il faut l ecouter par glenn gould.

    • @barronhung8246
      @barronhung8246 4 роки тому +4

      Phil480 j’adore glenn gould!

    • @Philobach
      @Philobach 4 роки тому +3

      @@barronhung8246 très bien !

    • @nghiavan8952
      @nghiavan8952 4 роки тому

      Did you mean gigue?

    • @composer318
      @composer318 3 роки тому

      Idk bach is composing fugue all over the pieces

  • @millennial8441
    @millennial8441 Рік тому +14

    It is very interesting how Bach knew Italian and French styles so well even he never got out from Germany, never travelled abroad. This suite is very Frenchy but not for the size and "excess" of counterpoint. Despite of it the main "French" musical gestures are all here.

  • @PointyTailofSatan
    @PointyTailofSatan 9 років тому +74

    It's interesting to hear Bach, particularly in the Echo, attempt the simpler galant style, while Bach's inner Baroque genius says "Nuts to that!" and away he goes!

    • @pianosbloxworld4460
      @pianosbloxworld4460 3 роки тому +6

      Bach: Yes, my church organist instincts mess galant style again. Is that alright with you? I know it’s not like Scarlatti….
      Me: *Scarlatti who?*

  • @wcsxwcsx
    @wcsxwcsx 8 років тому +32

    An especially refined work from Bach. This harpsicord is perfect for it.

  • @gerubach
    @gerubach  11 років тому +57

    @lekro: Yes. If humanity, nature & health permits me to, I will do my best to achieve this difficult task.

    • @carloalbertocamamusa6466
      @carloalbertocamamusa6466 10 років тому +6

      I hope you'll be able to do so. Present and future humanity would be grateful to you eternally.

    • @serenesiewhm9408
      @serenesiewhm9408 7 років тому +1

      gerubach I love the French Overture

    • @clavichord
      @clavichord 4 роки тому +1

      @Finn n The Question was: Will you attempt to climb mount Everest?

  • @IlVeroRe
    @IlVeroRe 11 років тому +31

    Man your channel is really useful and istructive, one of the best out there. Keep it alive!

    • @gerubach
      @gerubach  11 років тому +11

      Thank you IlVeroRe. I'm pleased that you have enjoyed it. More to come.

  • @samdajellybeenie14
    @samdajellybeenie14 11 років тому +27

    This is great! So many ornaments, it's making my head spin! Thank you gerubach!

    • @gerubach
      @gerubach  11 років тому +19

      The Gigue made me "woozy" as well. The publication really spaced the notes out on that movement.

  • @sofiainsolit
    @sofiainsolit 5 років тому +16

    This is the finest music I have ever heard.

  • @sauljaenmedina6509
    @sauljaenmedina6509 Рік тому +4

    Astonishing… there are no words to describe Bach’s majesty.

  • @LepusCompositions
    @LepusCompositions 2 роки тому +2

    listening to Bach's music is a pleasure to the ears, but learning them is pleasure to the fingers. Something about playing Bach's music is just so satifying...

    • @DynastieArtistique
      @DynastieArtistique 3 місяці тому +1

      It’s because it utter perfection. Bach is a once-in-a-universe phenomenon

  • @NT-kr6dn
    @NT-kr6dn 7 років тому +37

    I love the Echo!

  • @FighterFred
    @FighterFred 4 роки тому +5

    Guess he was in a good mood when writing this, sparkling and impressive. No wonder some people were very jealous and tried to take him down.

  • @danieltsui212
    @danieltsui212 10 років тому +96

    I always feels there are something deeper hides inside bach's music.

    • @JelleSophie
      @JelleSophie 7 років тому +8

      Daniel Tsui The influence of Jean-Baptiste Lully :D

    • @_PROCLUS
      @_PROCLUS 6 років тому +2

      Thank you very much for your comment. I call that " the intrinsic contrapuntal structure " Mozart and Schubert are two other greatest of all times

    • @SDGRTX1455
      @SDGRTX1455 6 років тому

      Search for Bach number symbolism

    • @adammiller6299
      @adammiller6299 5 років тому

      Daniel Tsui That is exactly how I feel.

    • @Philobach
      @Philobach 4 роки тому

      Sa musique est céleste et sa créativité inégalable.

  • @fivenightsatlospollosherma5893
    @fivenightsatlospollosherma5893 3 роки тому +10

    2:47 Now this is epic

  • @vitellia
    @vitellia 11 років тому +11

    LOL, I guessed it was Trevor Pinnock partly because I own this wonderful recording, but also for his always moderate tempos and the relative lack of drama and flare. He's always so "safe", you know. ^_^

    • @hugoclarke3284
      @hugoclarke3284 Рік тому +2

      Are you being ironic? Pinnock stretches tempos further than the average, and for dramatic effect. He's also extremely virtuosic.

    • @aimilios439
      @aimilios439 Рік тому

      ​@@hugoclarke3284 And so many ornaments! He's great.

  • @WheatWormStudios
    @WheatWormStudios 5 років тому +4

    Language and music are two of mankind’s greatest technologies if you will, but so many would rather just say 4 letters words in reaction to everything. And 3 chord songs too. Give me bach or give me nothing

  • @horacioorlandini5119
    @horacioorlandini5119 8 років тому +5

    extraordinario tu aporte de poder escuchar y leer esta maravilla de música, gracias.

  • @ZachDrake5960
    @ZachDrake5960 3 роки тому +3

    I love Bach so much because of his music explorations and experiments, that no composer before or since has done so, at least in such a way. That's why Bach is #1 in my top 11 composers.

    • @kuradipingviin
      @kuradipingviin 2 роки тому +1

      Who are the others

    • @ZachDrake5960
      @ZachDrake5960 2 роки тому +1

      @@kuradipingviin
      My Top 11 Composers
      #1. Johann Sebastian Bach (1685-1750)
      #2. Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart (1756-1791)
      #3. Ludwig van Beethoven (1770-1827)
      #4. Joseph Haydn (1732-1809)
      #5. Franz Schubert (1797-1828)
      #6. Johannes Brahms (1833-1897)
      #7. Franz Liszt (1811-1886)
      #8. Frederic Chopin (1810-1849)
      #9. Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky (1840-1893)
      #10. George Frederic Handel (1685-1759)
      #11. Antonio Vivaldi (1678-1741)

    • @kuradipingviin
      @kuradipingviin 2 роки тому

      @@ZachDrake5960 why not Scriabin

    • @ZachDrake5960
      @ZachDrake5960 2 роки тому

      @@kuradipingviin Never heard of that composer before...

    • @ZachDrake5960
      @ZachDrake5960 2 роки тому

      @@kuradipingviin Because I have not heard of that composer.

  • @JonasMiehe
    @JonasMiehe 10 років тому +4

    Outstanding work you put in there. Looking forward to other pieces!

  • @pand9293
    @pand9293 5 років тому +6

    The fugue of the ouverture at 2:45 is CATCHY

  • @juanguillermoatehortuagarc2929
    @juanguillermoatehortuagarc2929 2 роки тому +2

    That gique is beautiful and absolutely wonderful.

  • @loveclassicalmusicalot
    @loveclassicalmusicalot 2 роки тому +4

    13:42 extremely rare occurrence of B major during the time of Bach.

    • @aimilios439
      @aimilios439 Рік тому

      You might be right, but weren't well temperaments already mostly used at that time making b major a usable scale?

  • @Argentarius11
    @Argentarius11 3 роки тому +10

    I never understand how people say they prefer Mozart's incredibly boring keyboard works over Bach. This is rockin'!!!!!!

    • @Cizzo8
      @Cizzo8 3 роки тому +9

      Mozart's simplicty has a lot of love in it too. I find them both awesome works but Bach to be of a more profound nature, for sure.

    • @CanelonVegano
      @CanelonVegano 2 роки тому +1

      @@Cizzo8 that's a good take brother

    • @Argentarius11
      @Argentarius11 2 роки тому +2

      I did not grow up listening to Mozart. He can be the king of the 'unexpected' at times. However, his works as teenager and youngster are awful. People who don't like Classical make fun these works. It is unfortunate he was not born in the Romantic era, where he could have shown his real talent instead of the Rococo, with the minimalism of the Style Galant.

  • @jonobester5817
    @jonobester5817 2 роки тому +1

    WOW, and what an instrument! Parts of this sound like it's an organ!

  • @POG0497
    @POG0497 10 років тому +4

    Bach está orgulloso de ti, hijo =P Trabajo impecable.

  • @Bastro3000
    @Bastro3000 9 років тому +8

    Cette pièce déborde d'excellence.

    • @winterdesert1
      @winterdesert1 6 років тому +5

      I agree with whatever you said!

  • @andrehvk_
    @andrehvk_ 11 років тому +8

    Magnificent!! I love the French Ouverture!

  • @antoneeshukov7791
    @antoneeshukov7791 6 років тому +7

    Called it ouverture, but made a suite. Nice work Bach!

    • @MitchBoucherComposer
      @MitchBoucherComposer 6 років тому +2

      Technically the entire piece is a partita (or a suite, you could be correct--I'm not certain of the true technicalities in terms of naming collections).

    • @trashbagsmiley1999
      @trashbagsmiley1999 5 років тому +4

      @@MitchBoucherComposer I think a partita is just a German suite

    • @MitchBoucherComposer
      @MitchBoucherComposer 5 років тому +3

      @@trashbagsmiley1999 Thanks for the clarification!

    • @elinathanferlay1013
      @elinathanferlay1013 3 роки тому +3

      Actually, in Germany, in Bach's time, the word "ouverture" was used to designate a suite with a French overture (for example, the original name of the Bach's orchestral suites is "Ouvertures").

    • @menestrello_99
      @menestrello_99 3 роки тому +2

      @@elinathanferlay1013 Indeed; or like the little overture BWV 820 in F major, which is another piece for the harpsichord

  • @ZachDrake5960
    @ZachDrake5960 3 роки тому +2

    I also noticed he included an overture in the Goldberg Variations (Variation 16).

  • @ericarchibald9840
    @ericarchibald9840 6 років тому +2

    This is one of my favorites to hear.

  • @marklippiatt2362
    @marklippiatt2362 6 років тому +4

    When asked that question: "Who would you want to be if you could be any one in history?" Well, I mean, J S Bach is the only answer for me. Just imagine being able to have J S Bach sit at your table and talk with you as an equal - have a laugh about that days Mass, when you decided to riff off into a descending chromatic fugue sequence and he goes: "Hehehe, yeah, that was pretty cool Beavis". Just imagine being Bach, just for a day.

    • @benkebret8363
      @benkebret8363 5 років тому +2

      Bach was indeed a man of life loved his wine his beer just a happy man and composer in general

    • @malcolmledger176
      @malcolmledger176 4 роки тому +1

      You would be very, very busy! Composing, copying, teaching, performing, rehearsing, tuning, dealing with vexatious persons, not to mention bringing up your many kids...In all, a very full life, with no time to waste, even for one day.

  • @calmunson5022
    @calmunson5022 4 роки тому +2

    extremely difficult all the ornaments tendonitis for sure.. Once you hear this tempo, it is what you may strive for, but slower will give you chance to appreciate better the harmonies and play with more give and take.

  • @user-fu7zf4ck9z
    @user-fu7zf4ck9z 4 роки тому +2

    I think this one is his best suite

  • @RoberTVShow
    @RoberTVShow 8 років тому +7

    Am I mad to think that that gigue is very similar to the one in French Suite no2, in C Minor?

  • @jlapierremusic
    @jlapierremusic 7 років тому +8

    Gerubach keep up your fabulous work!

  • @javierperezmedina6938
    @javierperezmedina6938 3 роки тому +2

    EXCELENTE Y DIDACTICO, BACH SIEMPRE SUENA NUEVO

  • @Argentarius11
    @Argentarius11 3 роки тому +3

    Bach is still great some 270 years after his death!!!!!!!!

  • @jean-francoisbordeleau1225
    @jean-francoisbordeleau1225 4 роки тому +2

    this is great thank u to u. j apprend et je decouvre la musique classique...

  • @horacioorlandini5119
    @horacioorlandini5119 8 років тому +1

    esta obra es una maravilla, el desarrollo de sus voces fuera de serie, igual que la partir a n6

  • @studentofcounterpoint
    @studentofcounterpoint Рік тому +1

    10:50 So this is how an harpischord who caught a cold sounds like

  • @snowcarriagechengcheng-hun3454
    @snowcarriagechengcheng-hun3454 5 років тому +3

    Thanks for uploading!

  • @OmnipresentPotato
    @OmnipresentPotato Рік тому

    This is played on a harpsichord, is it not? If I may ask, how is it that you can alter the dynamics (piano and forte) on the harpsichord? I thought that was something only the pianoforte could do. Did Bach write these pieces with these intended dynamics?

  • @MegaLordGogo
    @MegaLordGogo 11 років тому +6

    Could you please make the Cello Suites after this? Or at least the Air?

    • @gerubach
      @gerubach  11 років тому +14

      Sorry Ameno but the Air & the Cello Suites will have to wait. The next animation will be the St. Matthew Passion. (That mountain has to be climbed).

    • @MegaLordGogo
      @MegaLordGogo 11 років тому +3

      Oh ok
      Good Luck and Best Regards

  • @אלוןמאמו
    @אלוןמאמו Рік тому +1

    The Echo is so cool!!!

  • @classicgameplay10
    @classicgameplay10 5 місяців тому

    Bach loves using those neighboring tones in themes.

  • @unknownperson7909
    @unknownperson7909 9 років тому +2

    gerubach There is a section starts at 2:45, is it a fugato? It reminds me the structure of fugal works.

  • @guillaumequenderff6196
    @guillaumequenderff6196 3 роки тому +2

    La musique est un don de Dieu

  • @hugoclarke3284
    @hugoclarke3284 5 років тому

    That rhythm at bar 10 of the gigue is driving me crazy. It doesn't feel countable, so I think I should "feel it" and give the impression of "speeding up", but the window is so small that it ends up sounding like they are all demisemiquavers.

  • @TheHive616
    @TheHive616 5 років тому +159

    Bach does the French style better than the French.

    • @adammiller6299
      @adammiller6299 4 роки тому +8

      I wish I could like this comment again!

    • @FRLoca83
      @FRLoca83 4 роки тому +13

      Not really..?

    • @TheCreate78
      @TheCreate78 4 роки тому +16

      How stupid it is
      Have you ever listened to Lully's work at least ?

    • @MrGuilherme1100
      @MrGuilherme1100 4 роки тому +2

      does anyone know what is an Echo (in video description)?

    • @austindolan3142
      @austindolan3142 4 роки тому +8

      @@MrGuilherme1100 I got this from the wiki page
      "Also unusual for Bach is the inclusion of an extra movement after the Gigue. This is an "echo", a piece meant to exploit the terraced loud and soft dynamics of the two-manual harpsichord. Other movements also have dynamic indications (piano and forte), which are not often found in keyboard suites of the Baroque period, and indicate here the use of the two keyboards of the harpsichord"

  • @marcocampus7943
    @marcocampus7943 7 місяців тому

    Perché secondo voi questa suite non ha l'allemanda?

  • @canman5060
    @canman5060 11 років тому +1

    Appreciate if you call upload the scroll of The Musical Offering especially the 6 part ricercar.

  • @enriquei.moreno6268
    @enriquei.moreno6268 3 роки тому +2

    "Gerubach": unless you are Trevor Pinnock himself, you need to credit him right upfront! Don't just say "Performer & Album Info - 28:02". It's good to see the recording synchronized to a score, but don't be disrespectful to the artist, please.

  • @Ivan_1791
    @Ivan_1791 6 років тому +2

    I love it.

  • @toondevis2388
    @toondevis2388 9 років тому +4

    Wonderful music! But I get a headache watching this.

  • @yaboibobby7776
    @yaboibobby7776 9 років тому +1

    Does anyone know what this harpsichord is tuned to. It doesn't sound like A=440 hz.

    • @zigeunerlieder
      @zigeunerlieder 9 років тому

      +Revodon3s Maybe A=419 hz

    • @MitchBoucherComposer
      @MitchBoucherComposer 6 років тому

      It's tuned to standard Baroque tuning, which is a bit like a half-step below our modern tuning. His B minor equals something like our B flat minor.

  • @andreainzaghi7373
    @andreainzaghi7373 9 років тому +2

    La Overture divina!

  • @FUZxxl
    @FUZxxl 10 років тому +13

    You've transcribed the tile wrongly. You wrote "NACH FRANZÖSIFCHER ART", but it should've been "NACH FRANZÖSISCHER ART". In German, there used to be three s. There is the s (round s), S in capital letters, the ſ (long s), S in capital letter and the ß (sharp s or eszett), written SZ, ẞ or SZ in capital letters. The long s felt out of use but it mandantory in blackletter and certain styles of cursive. Especially in blackletter fonts it might look very similar to f. It would be nice if you could correct that.

    • @bronktug2446
      @bronktug2446 8 років тому +4

      Please try and find something more important in life to worry about, or maybe just enjoy the music, that's what matters.

    • @kenbusch2139
      @kenbusch2139 7 років тому +6

      Bronk Tug, the god of irony seems to have singled you out for special adverse attention.

    • @nemianyamele2265
      @nemianyamele2265 6 років тому +1

      hey, i personally have never heard of the long s... what is the difference in terms of sound and usage in these 3 S's??? im curious

    •  6 років тому +3

      This is long s: ſ. It looks a bit like letter f, but it is s, in fact. In the paſt, it was uſed inſtead of the ſhort s in every caſe, except at the end of the word, at the end of roots in compound words, as a capital S, or after another ſ. Bach uſed it in writing his name: Johann Sebaſtian Bach.

    • @Gilmaris
      @Gilmaris 6 років тому

      There are only two S's. The ẞ is merely a combination of the long and the short (though also a combination of the long S and Z, early on, but these days it counts as a double S - even though it is still sometimes called "Eszett" - "S Z"). The rules of usage were the same all over Europe, but not rigorously applied. For example, if the S was at the end of the word, it should be the short S. But I have seen the long S used. Anywhere else in the word, an S should be long - but I have seen exceptions here as well. If you have two S's in a row, regardless of where they are in the word, the first should be long and the second short. And this is where ẞ comes from.

  • @SonicPhonic
    @SonicPhonic 3 роки тому

    Thank You. Any information on the performer...?

  • @leletih
    @leletih Рік тому

    gorgeous

  • @colinoboyle5866
    @colinoboyle5866 6 років тому +1

    Is this written in the musical form of French Overture?

    • @MitchBoucherComposer
      @MitchBoucherComposer 6 років тому +4

      Yes, it is. The first movement particularly is called an 'overture' which hails after the French method of composition. Several of Bach's other pieces are French overtures---and not just instrumental pieces (like those of the orchestral suites) or the keyboard works (the partita in F, BWV 833 or g minor, BWV 822) but he features overtures in several cantatas as well (BWv 61, 97, 194, 110, for example).
      You can recognize the overall French-ness by the dotted rhythms and elegant lines of thirty-second or sixteenth notes. Not to mention the middle fugal section!

    • @marcocampus7943
      @marcocampus7943 7 місяців тому

      Anche se molto lontani nella catalogazione BWV, questa ouverture si colloca nella stessa raccolta con il concerto italiano. Lo stile italiano da una parte, lo stile francese dall'altro. Pensa, entrambi necessitano di un clavicembalo a due manuali.

  • @terrific-bats
    @terrific-bats 10 років тому +2

    fantastic !

  • @nma623
    @nma623 2 роки тому

    The echo… emotional

  • @leewardngiramolau5000
    @leewardngiramolau5000 7 років тому +2

    i like this one

  • @magoit
    @magoit 5 років тому

    UA-cam, please fix your app so we can use time marks! Meanwhile...
    Published on Nov 11, 2013
    Performer & Album Info - 28:02
    1. Overture - 0:19
    2. Courante - 7:50
    3. Gavotte 1/2 - 9:37
    4. Passpied 1/2 - 12:36
    5. Sarabande - 15:09
    6. Bourree 1/2 - 20:11
    7. Gique - 22:53
    8. Echo - 24:58

  • @chrisbriden
    @chrisbriden 4 роки тому

    I don't like how fast his courantes are. It's not a corrente.

  • @harryk4840
    @harryk4840 3 місяці тому +1

    ❤️

  • @ignacioclerici5341
    @ignacioclerici5341 2 роки тому

    Bach is my best friend

  • @tarikeld11
    @tarikeld11 Рік тому +1

    5:24 ha, circle of 5th, most repeated part of this video

  • @DressedForDrowning
    @DressedForDrowning 5 років тому

    Start at 0:23
    Start fugue 2:47

  • @luyang6677
    @luyang6677 5 років тому

    what is the instrument?

  • @isaiasramosgarcia9771
    @isaiasramosgarcia9771 4 роки тому

    interprete?

  • @jeanpouzaud
    @jeanpouzaud 4 роки тому +4

    21:13

  • @studentofcounterpoint
    @studentofcounterpoint 2 роки тому

    5:50 Invention 4 theme

  • @matim7549
    @matim7549 3 роки тому +1

    fugue: 2:40

  • @sagirozzo720
    @sagirozzo720 5 років тому +1

    The overture sounds very French

  • @nghiavan8952
    @nghiavan8952 4 роки тому

    It’s a gigue, not a gique.

  • @bronktug2446
    @bronktug2446 8 років тому +2

    I never knew that the Sarabande was part of a French overture, I thought it was Spanish...

    • @nathanielouzana
      @nathanielouzana 8 років тому +1

      gigue is irish in that sense.

    • @bronktug2446
      @bronktug2446 8 років тому +2

      Nathaniel Ouzana fair point good sir :D

    • @ruperttmls7985
      @ruperttmls7985 5 років тому

      Yeah!! Gigue = Jigg

    • @marcocampus7943
      @marcocampus7943 7 місяців тому

      ​@@nathanielouzanae non era neanche in tempo ternario

  • @CarlBowlby
    @CarlBowlby 4 роки тому +2

    No, Bach doesn’t do the French manner better than the French. When I think of the French manner I think Couperin, Rameau, D’Anglebert, Nivers, Lebegue, de Grigny, etc. etc. Bach did his Germanic “thing” with the French style, but he didn’t emulate or imitate. He is much too frenetic and cerebral to be authentically French. I think Germans who did a better job of composing in the French style are Bohm and Gottlieb Muffat.

    • @icemorewaterless
      @icemorewaterless 2 роки тому +1

      Interesting - in a way I feel I can agree with you. Could you elaborate on this “German thing” you are referring to?

    • @CarlBowlby
      @CarlBowlby 2 роки тому

      @@icemorewaterless it’s hard to elaborate on what I’m saying unless you play the music or look over the score. But Bach took the “French Suite” concept and made it his own, which, yes, is that “Germanic thing” I spoke of. The music is generally at a faster tempo than the typical French suite and his ornamentation isn’t as in depth as some of the French masters. That’s about all I got at this point without going through the entire score here. But I think you get what I mean.

    • @thomasdastillung4097
      @thomasdastillung4097 2 роки тому +1

      Connaisseur

    • @CarlBowlby
      @CarlBowlby 2 роки тому

      @@thomasdastillung4097 sry I have to correct your spelling but it’s “connoisseur”.

    • @kirionj.a.w1147
      @kirionj.a.w1147 2 роки тому

      @@CarlBowlby The French certainly knew how to used ornaments in their keyboard works.

  • @AvntXardE
    @AvntXardE 5 років тому +1

    2:47
    5:18

  • @reinierpost3930
    @reinierpost3930 11 років тому

    Early Leonhardt?

    • @gerubach
      @gerubach  11 років тому +2

      Performer & Album Info - 28:02

    • @reinierpost3930
      @reinierpost3930 11 років тому +2

      gerubach
      Thank you! I listened to all of it but without keeping my eye on it ...

  • @FranzLiszt0904
    @FranzLiszt0904 Рік тому

    gique catchy

  • @陽天-g8g
    @陽天-g8g 4 роки тому

    この曲とイタリア協奏曲と半音階的幻想曲が抱き合わせになったレコードが多い。わしは、この3曲が一番バッハ的でない気がする。クラヴイアユーブングは当時販売された数少ない楽譜であるから、バッハも趣向を凝らしたのか。遅い・速い・遅いというのがフランス風と言うことらしいが、クープランやダングルベールとかの曲とは全く違う。最後のエコーは要らん。演奏者はピノックか?

  • @LaBotSircle
    @LaBotSircle 5 років тому +1

    11:44 xDDDDD :)

  • @Tizohip
    @Tizohip 7 років тому +5

    5:38 :D

    • @Jalapablo
      @Jalapablo 4 роки тому

      Yep, you know it. Glenn Gould totally rocks the bass in that section

  • @masajbeyrifat6895
    @masajbeyrifat6895 3 роки тому

    Bach ın eserleri orkestralanırsa (orchestration) daha iyi olur. Bu mükemmellik tek tınıda boğuluyor. Halka ulaşamıyor. Ama o da çok zor bir iş !

  • @jerryli821
    @jerryli821 6 років тому

    too fast

  • @mastinho6761
    @mastinho6761 3 роки тому

    2:47

  • @ludovicotemi2443
    @ludovicotemi2443 4 роки тому

    Your channel is interesting and very informative but I don't like to see those great composers getting wore the masks, it is so much ugly and offensive to them, don't you? So, if I'd love to join you, now I determly refuse to do, sorry, but for me it is absurd manipulation to the minds people.
    👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻
    Goodbye guys!

    • @louiscouperin3731
      @louiscouperin3731 4 роки тому

      Where are the masks?

    • @ludovicotemi2443
      @ludovicotemi2443 4 роки тому

      @@louiscouperin3731 look the home page. The composers getting masks! 😷😷😷😷🙈🙈🙈ridiculous!

    • @louiscouperin3731
      @louiscouperin3731 4 роки тому

      Ludovico Temi l see

    • @ludovicotemi2443
      @ludovicotemi2443 4 роки тому

      @@louiscouperin3731 why? What for?

    • @louiscouperin3731
      @louiscouperin3731 4 роки тому

      Ludovico Temi l agree. It is ridiculous. But for me it doesn’t undermine the quality of Gerubach’s work.

  • @solcarzemog5232
    @solcarzemog5232 6 років тому +2

    Horribly played...