cummins 4BT vs isuzu 4BD1T - diesel engines w/ exhaust noise

Поділитися
Вставка

КОМЕНТАРІ • 82

  • @johnhartley5071
    @johnhartley5071 5 років тому +41

    From a long term commercial service standpoint, the Isuzu 4BD1T or the 4BD2T which is related but uses a different IDI injection system than the 1T ot 4BT is a better engine. Those Isuzus are built like farm tractor or big rig 18 wheeler engines. If you ever actually manage to wear one out, you just replace the bearings, seals, and cylinder sleeves with basic hand tools. At worst get your crank journals reground and polished and the valves ground or replaced.
    The Cummins 6BT and 4BT, and the Navistar/International/Ford 6.9/7.3 aka DT444E engines are considered throwaway engines. Fuck one up, just get another, rebuilds are expensive because they require machine work at a specialist diesel shop the has the tools to do it. A 4BD1T or say an international DT466 or Detroit 60 series... Can go millions of miles, and when they need a rebuild if you're mechanically inclined and have good tools, you just do it yourself with an overhaul kit.

    • @vee950
      @vee950 4 роки тому +2

      Absolutely right

    • @stevemcgee99
      @stevemcgee99 3 роки тому +2

      Interesting. I had a 1.5 VW and was able to get a cylinder sleeve for one that had been gouged by gasket bits. Rebuild was very cheap.
      I appreciate the perspective on these engines. And with a radiator like that, I'd love to put an Isuzu into something.

    • @heinzletzte.6385
      @heinzletzte.6385 3 роки тому

      well but from an economical standpoint the 4bt uses less fuel cause it is di

    • @johnhartley5071
      @johnhartley5071 3 роки тому +2

      @@heinzletzte.6385 the the more common 4BD1T Isuzu engine is also direct injected. The less common 4BD2T is not. I don't know why they built a direct injected and indirect injected version of the same engine but they did. The blocks I believe are identical I think the only difference is the cylinder head and maybe the injection pump.

    • @johnhartley5071
      @johnhartley5071 3 роки тому

      @@stevemcgee99 that may certainly be true, but a VW diesel is small and light enough any typical machine shop can probably do the work. A diesel truck engine in a pickup weighs like a minimum of 1100 lbs and is a big hulking thing, the diesel in something like a big rig is literally a ton or more. You need to go to a specialist to work on something like that, which is why they have "in frame" overhaul kits where the sleeves can be replaced without having to take the engine out of the truck.

  • @cleanthegreen
    @cleanthegreen 5 років тому +10

    I’m guessing that that japanese injection pump is what is branded a “diesel kiki”, it was a subsidiary of bosch and they since got renamed or should I say fully integrated into Bosch since 1991.

  • @kevinhornbuckle
    @kevinhornbuckle 4 роки тому

    I enjoy your videos.

  • @cleanthegreen
    @cleanthegreen 5 років тому +7

    Where i’m from, the Philippines, most 1st and 2nd Gen Ford Expedition and some F150 owners had those gas guzzling V8’s swapped out for Isuzu truck engines

    • @NickTullos
      @NickTullos  5 років тому +1

      what trans are they using?

    • @cleanthegreen
      @cleanthegreen 3 роки тому +1

      Nick Tullos lol, took me a year to reply to you. Well, I ain’t sure what kind of trans really, I’m guessing they mostly keep the manual trans that comes with most isuzu truck engines we have here. I don’t see much automatic Isuzu Elf trucks (N-series) where I’m from.

    • @Terk131
      @Terk131 3 роки тому

      Ford superdutys from 98 to 2011 came with a cummins 4bt then switched to the new electronic 2.8 and the 3.8 was an option. Would be nice to have 1 with the 4bt then another 2ith a 6bt since everything would work on the truck, unfortunately we got stuck with the 7.3, problematic 6.0, 6.4 and 6.7. Imagine a superdudy factory with a zf6 & 6bt. Why not they put the 6bt into f700's. When I put my 6bt from a 95 f700 into my 85 f350 Ibused the cab from the 700 since it was the same as the 80's bull nosevtrucks andvall the gages worked and ac. Bought the 700 cheap at auction with 32,000 miles on it.

    • @marshalgeneral4756
      @marshalgeneral4756 3 роки тому +1

      @@cleanthegreen i see alot of 1kz swap on e150, expedition and f150

  • @AOTechWorx
    @AOTechWorx 3 роки тому +13

    The Isuzu engine is idling rpm is too high. This old Isuzu engine is bullet proof.

    • @elgringojosh825
      @elgringojosh825 2 роки тому +3

      My dad has one that has been sitting for 10 years. It runs just fine on 10 year old fuel lol.

    • @jasperdomacena6491
      @jasperdomacena6491 Рік тому

      we have a Deep Forest Passenger 4X4 that has a NA 4BD1 Engine
      Diesel prices went sky high and got to the point where the pumps ran out of them
      so we had to resort to using a mixture of Filtered Used Cooking Oil, Used Motor Oil and some Gasoline
      and sometimes just filtered Dirty Leftover Marine Diesel from the docks
      I mean it runs fine
      no seizing of the engine, no damage to the fuel injector pump 🤷‍♂
      tough engine this is

    • @m16ty
      @m16ty 6 місяців тому

      I noticed that, but I think the NPR trucks have a "high idle" when cold. That could be why it's idling high.

    • @jetstreamchad4712
      @jetstreamchad4712 5 місяців тому

      Same with the old Isuzu 4JB1

  • @soapbox94
    @soapbox94 6 років тому +3

    Thanks so much for the comparison! Swapping that Isuzu motor into a Wagoneer now.

    • @NickTullos
      @NickTullos  6 років тому +1

      what transmission adapter are you going to use?

    • @soapbox94
      @soapbox94 6 років тому +1

      Nick Tullos there's a guy in Newberg, OR that makes a great kit for $650. I used a 4L80E trans.

    • @NickTullos
      @NickTullos  6 років тому

      I actually have a spare 4l80e and a turbo 400 sitting around, but i think those transmission are too long for a short jeep. I'll look into it.

    • @soapbox94
      @soapbox94 6 років тому

      Looks like you have a ton of videos on the 4bt swap. I'll have to watch those. I've been trying to document every step on my blog/website. Mostly so I have a record of what I did.

    • @NickTullos
      @NickTullos  6 років тому +1

      Thats your website? I've read website build back when I was working on my 4BT chevy 2500 swap. Maybe I found it on 4btswaps forum or another forum?

  • @sxs4l245
    @sxs4l245 2 роки тому

    I just want to ad that there is also a 6cyl in the FRR. Much like the 6bt, 200 horses and ??? Torque monsters to do work. The one I have seems legit. It pushes a 26ft box loaded with house furniture like a boss.....!

  • @DirtMcGert29054
    @DirtMcGert29054 Рік тому

    Use the accessory drive off the timing cover for your vac power steering pump or what ever you want it's there for reason

  • @edkennedy6120
    @edkennedy6120 5 років тому +22

    the isuzu is the better engine.

    • @austinjohnson265
      @austinjohnson265 5 років тому +2

      can you explain why please?

    • @atx-cvpi_99
      @atx-cvpi_99 3 роки тому +4

      @@austinjohnson265 they have cylinder sleeves.

  • @MsJinkerson
    @MsJinkerson 4 роки тому +1

    I was going to put a 5>7. litre diesel into an 84 Trans-AM

  • @crowman8914
    @crowman8914 4 роки тому +5

    I like that izuzu diesel id use as a daily driver id use it as a modified pickup convert it to 4x4 and a crew can and make sure id piss off then greta thunberg greenie climate change nazis

  • @turbo1438
    @turbo1438 5 років тому +3

    power steering pump is what's on the rear of the alternator

    • @johnhartley5071
      @johnhartley5071 5 років тому +2

      No it's not, he clearly states it is a vacuum pump for the brakes... And I've seen plenty of them in person to confirm that. They also cost an an arm and a leg...

    • @m16ty
      @m16ty 6 місяців тому

      No, the power steering pump is gear driven off the front passenger side of the engine.

  • @alpzepta
    @alpzepta 3 роки тому +1

    Can Isuzu 6BD1 fit also?

  • @Boyke_72
    @Boyke_72 4 роки тому

    Which one more power Isuzu or Cummins

  • @joeyscleaninglady2877
    @joeyscleaninglady2877 6 років тому

    wood body mounts?

  • @blacktooth6242
    @blacktooth6242 5 років тому

    Do they smoke whn u lay into thm

  • @gamer78full
    @gamer78full 6 років тому

    Do you have power specs of both engines? And which one is better on your opinion?

    • @NickTullos
      @NickTullos  6 років тому

      if they are using the same turbo then the power level is pretty close. Its really about which engine you can purchase for a good price since they both are really good engines. I like the 4bt better since they share parts with the pretty common 6bt in the older dodge trucks.

    • @atx-cvpi_99
      @atx-cvpi_99 3 роки тому +2

      The Isuzu engine is a better engine because it’s rebuildable without going to the machine shop because of the cylinder sleeves.

  • @soapbox94
    @soapbox94 6 років тому +3

    BTW that is a vac pump on the back of the alt.

  • @rudiwibowo1426
    @rudiwibowo1426 4 роки тому

    Isuzu Bospom zexel lisensi Bosh???

  • @gabrielcedeno4456
    @gabrielcedeno4456 Місяць тому

    Saludos algún video de una gran blazer con motor ISUZU estoy interesado en un swap 2.8 JB1 isuzu

  • @justinherdman87
    @justinherdman87 2 роки тому

    which one is easiest" to get adapters for to swap into ie" a 03 gmc 1600 w/ nv4500? any help you could give m, or and sites, laces too find adapters too swap a 4bdt into a gmt-

    • @m16ty
      @m16ty 6 місяців тому

      I've got a 4bdlt I'm getting ready to put into a military M715. I can tell you with absolute certainty that there are vastly more adaptor options for the Cummins. Adaptors for the Isuzu are almost non existent. There were some people making adaptors in the past but doing my research I haven't found anybody currently making adaptors.
      There are some 4bd1t engines floating around with SAE #3 flywheel housings, early engines in domestic trucks and most industrial engines had them. If you have a SAE flywheel housing you can find a adaptor to fit pretty much any domestic engine.
      The vast majority of these engines have a "Japanese" pattern, which pretty much doesn't fit anything except the Japanese transmission that is bolted to it. That being said, some careful measuring and a trip to a machine should should net you a adaptor that will work. I currently have my parts at a machine shop to get an adaptor made to bolt up to a Spicer 3053a transmission. Was quoted a price of $500, which is actually cheaper than adaptors you can buy for say a Cummins.

  • @rogeliomelgar5219
    @rogeliomelgar5219 5 років тому +5

    Isuzu way better and more reliable

  • @williegohard1368
    @williegohard1368 2 роки тому

    I like the Isuzu better it's more smoother quieter we'll go well in my 2019 frontier King cab which has a four cylinder this will be perfect in it

    • @NickTullos
      @NickTullos  2 роки тому

      what transmission are you going to use?

    • @williegohard1368
      @williegohard1368 2 роки тому

      @@NickTullos what would you recommend I was thinking about using the transmission already in the truck maybe a adapter and the transmission

    • @NickTullos
      @NickTullos  2 роки тому

      @@williegohard1368 the main problem with the 4BDs is there isn't much aftermarket support. The factory transmission only goes to 1:1 so you don't have overdrive. Once you get it installed please send me a link.

  • @pilot41186
    @pilot41186 5 років тому

    Which one vibrates less?

    • @NickTullos
      @NickTullos  5 років тому +2

      They both vibrate on start up and shutdown, but I drive a pretty big truck so I dont notice it. I believe the 4DB1T vibrates less from what others have said.

  • @tytichota1985
    @tytichota1985 6 років тому

    How well do you like the 4bt for power? I want to put one in my one ton Chevy but I pull alot

    • @NickTullos
      @NickTullos  6 років тому

      how big of a load do you pull? if your pulling most of the time then I would just toss a mech. 6bt into the truck. Not much of a difference between the two.

    • @cumminsman4670
      @cumminsman4670 4 роки тому

      Just longer and heavier

  • @babyhominid7779
    @babyhominid7779 6 років тому +1

    Is your engine from a bread or Frito Lay van?

    • @NickTullos
      @NickTullos  6 років тому +2

      its from the chevy version of the step van not the ford version. it came with the turbo 400 and gm adapter.

    • @babyhominid7779
      @babyhominid7779 6 років тому +2

      Nick Tullos mine too. Put a 4L80 and it is now in my F250 Ford pickup. I'm in Louisiana. Where are you?

    • @NickTullos
      @NickTullos  6 років тому

      north shreveport. i just found a melted piston during my rebuild. man, you dont happen to have a piston around?

  • @johneli495
    @johneli495 2 роки тому +1

    Isuzu might be the better engine, but the Cummins is unbeatable soundwise imo

    • @jasperdomacena6491
      @jasperdomacena6491 2 роки тому +3

      Isuzu Engines are just better 🤷
      even the 100hp Mechanically Fuel Injected NA version
      can give 17-23MPG with 2 Tons of stuff in the bed.
      with a Turbo it is even more efficient it doesn't go below 20MPG's

    • @der_pinguin44
      @der_pinguin44 2 роки тому

      I've always said my Isuzu diesel sounds like an angry singer sewing machine.

  • @rudiwibowo1426
    @rudiwibowo1426 4 роки тому

    Isuzu Bospom zexel lisensi Bosh

  • @lucky13sss10
    @lucky13sss10 6 років тому +1

    That's an oiled cooled rear alt. Not a vac pump smdh

    • @NickTullos
      @NickTullos  6 років тому +3

      google "isuzu npr alternator vacuum pump" and take a look at the results. I think its a vac pump on there somewhere, but I'm new to these engines and I didnt trace the hose to the vacuum canister

    • @lucky13sss10
      @lucky13sss10 6 років тому

      Nick Tullos but it's not on the alt. I'm working on a 95 that has the same gm Delco alt.

    • @NickTullos
      @NickTullos  6 років тому +1

      looks like there is 3 hoses on my alternator. maybe they are oil inlet, oil return and a vacuum? I'm not an expert at all, but that will change over the next few months. I just picked up a vehicle this weekend for the 4bd1t swap.

    • @person440
      @person440 6 років тому +11

      Its a vacuum pump, I've worked on these since I was in diapers, trust me, its fan cooled not oil, thats a vac pump dude lol

    • @fat.chance
      @fat.chance 6 років тому +6

      its definitely a vac pump, i have a few of these