The FS5 MKII better than the A7SIII?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 23 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 68

  • @CinemaCircuitVibes
    @CinemaCircuitVibes 2 роки тому +5

    I love my Sony FS5! It’s my daily driver! It works, it’s compact, it’s ergonomic, is customizable, it’s light, it shoots 4k! The list goes on and on! It’s a great camera!

  • @sattvaphoto7367
    @sattvaphoto7367 7 місяців тому +1

    Thanks for this review, man. I think this sealed the deal for me to pick up a used FS5ii

  • @sgagic
    @sgagic Рік тому +2

    Hi, great video! Any lens recommendations for the FS52 ? For weddings...thanks. What's the lens on the video? THX - Keep up the good work!

    • @tydetalx5873
      @tydetalx5873  Рік тому +1

      You can never go wrong with the 24 MM to 35 MM range for weddings any of those two or a combo of both via zoom lens is perfect.

    • @SuperRaven79
      @SuperRaven79 7 місяців тому

      I am using this camera since 7 or 8 years. And the best lens for me in almost every situation is the Canon EF 24-105 F4 with the Metabones Speedbooster.

  • @dylansherrill
    @dylansherrill 3 роки тому +4

    I've been looking to upgrade my 8 year old Sony NEX VG30 but new cinema quality cameras are often at least 2-4k more expensive than what I paid for my VG30. The hard part is, I know if I get a camera that is perhaps 2-3 years old it'll have basically the same capabilities as anything coming out today, but at much lower prices. However, every camera channel on youtube only wants to talk about the newest cameras, so it's hard to find great videos on cameras from a few years ago without going back through every other camera based channel.
    What I'm saying is thanks for making something to give a great opinion on a somewhat older camera, but without the high price of everything current. :)

  • @AlphaFilmCreative
    @AlphaFilmCreative 3 роки тому +1

    I have the siii and love it. But I do love our fs5ii as well. Great reasons 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽

  • @leschwartz
    @leschwartz 2 роки тому +1

    Thanks for the review, I just bought one myself, any comments on using a full frame lens with it?

  • @JCali49
    @JCali49 3 роки тому +4

    Awesome video! so u can record raw on the ninja v and fs5 combo?? Ive been searching for this answer for a while

    • @tydetalx5873
      @tydetalx5873  3 роки тому +1

      You cant on the Ninja 5 but the Shogun 7 yes u can because of the SDI in and outputs

    • @clapforjoe
      @clapforjoe 3 роки тому

      @@tydetalx5873 the Ninja V has an sdi adapter

    • @MEBoisv
      @MEBoisv 2 роки тому

      @@clapforjoe I tried that. It still didn't work. I forget the reason why but I was very disappointed.

    • @user-f5xt2op9t
      @user-f5xt2op9t Рік тому

      @@MEBoisv Because ATOMOS rushes products to market then releases new models rather than fixing the issues. Its an asshole strategy, but it works well for them and Blackmagic Design.

  • @charpentiermarieandree6807
    @charpentiermarieandree6807 8 місяців тому

    Can you please tell me what lens is installed on the camera in this video? I really like the rendering of the image. Thank you so much !

  • @timdanyo898
    @timdanyo898 2 роки тому +4

    As of 11/21 Atomos enabled the Ninja V+ to record RAW from the FS5.

  • @seriouzfilmz9397
    @seriouzfilmz9397 3 роки тому +1

    Love my a7siii but my fs5 has been picking up dust. But I can’t get rid of it. I love it when streaming events and filming longer shoots.

  • @advisuals759
    @advisuals759 3 роки тому +3

    great review my boi!

  • @hazellvt
    @hazellvt 2 роки тому +1

    great video. I Livestream a lot of sports such as soccer. Would you recommend this camera for this purpose?

    • @jeffreywright5549
      @jeffreywright5549 2 роки тому

      Yes I absolutely would it's perfect for broadcasting especially with the on board sdi

  • @anasibrahim7008
    @anasibrahim7008 3 роки тому +3

    Eye opening bro

  • @dusty_burkhalter
    @dusty_burkhalter Рік тому +1

    I have an A7IV and am considering picking up a used FS5ii. It seems like an outstanding value at $2k in like new condition, just curious if you think it would be good for football highlights. Mostly just going to IG reels and in house stuff. TIA.

    • @jamicanshakin
      @jamicanshakin Рік тому

      Same position as you right now! Did you ever get the FS5ii

  • @AaronStoneVLOGS
    @AaronStoneVLOGS 2 роки тому +4

    low light and autofocus BLOW on the FS5 ii especially comparing it to the A7siii...we also cant use a monitor and record at the same time (unless there has been an update I'm unaware of)

    • @Dyl_Cam
      @Dyl_Cam 2 роки тому

      You absolutley can

    • @ChrisParayno
      @ChrisParayno Рік тому

      Lol, but most people who use this camera don't use autofocus

  • @zztops4504
    @zztops4504 7 місяців тому

    None can explain it better than a brotha!

  • @benjiosborne
    @benjiosborne 3 роки тому +2

    Aye bro How’s the auto focus on the fs5? For music videos mostly

    • @tydetalx5873
      @tydetalx5873  3 роки тому +1

      The autofocus is not that great if I am being honest in comparison to the new cameras. However it is very capable despite it being a tad older.

    • @bryandelosreyes5817
      @bryandelosreyes5817 3 роки тому +2

      Manuals really the only way for creative and best results.

    • @Aggyoko
      @Aggyoko 2 роки тому +1

      @@bryandelosreyes5817 not true. Both manual and autofocus are options. Neither is necessarily better or the way to go. It all depends on what you, the creative, want

  • @WalterTheBalter
    @WalterTheBalter 2 роки тому

    practicality beats technology. I agree.

  • @LukeFlegg
    @LukeFlegg 3 роки тому +2

    1:30 - I'm looking at all those buttons and literally every one of them that I actually use frequently on my a7s3 is also exactly 1 click - no navigating through any menus. Eg. ISO. I just turn a wheel (where's your ISO wheel?) and shutter: I turn another wheel. Aperture: has its own wheel too. Audio gain, ok I currently have that as click 1 button > turn a wheel, so 1 extra step there. You can fully customise all of that though!
    a7 also has onboard HDMI! Full size...
    It's a lush camera, no doubt, but I think a7 has many better features (some worse) and is a lot smaller (which for me is helpful). And it's way cheaper, so money left over for lenses etc.
    Doesn't a7 shoot raw as well?.. feels like a lot of these are features that both cameras have.

    • @techy1433
      @techy1433 2 роки тому

      There’s no way these both comers have same features, if you shoot video you know how big deal is Internal ND. Longer battery , quickly able to detach, monitor and handle for gimbal use , more XLR inputs , no over heating issues , adjustable angle viewfinder . Fs5ii way better than A7siii for pure video

    • @LukeFlegg
      @LukeFlegg 2 роки тому

      @@techy1433 1. Internal ND: I just don't mind 90% of the time using a higher ISO. High shutter speed is rarely a problem unless it's essential to have a bit of motion blur
      2. XLR inputs - very rarely use them, but when I do there's always the XLR accessory for the much, much smaller and lighter a7s3, which if you shoot video you know how
      3. Easy to attach a handle - lots of options out there. I really appreciate the a7s3 also being better for shooting portrait and being compatible with a wider variety of gimbals, tripods, etc. Big cameras really are out for me now unless they REALLY justify the bigger size, weight and price tag.
      4. I think you might be mixing up the a7s3 with another camera because it does have many options of detachable monitors, supports 4K and
      5. You also don't seem to be aware that the camera shoots in raw? 16bit. I just never need that personally, So I'm grateful for the smaller size and weight, But if you want it you just add the atamos recorder. The camera setup still works out cheaper once you've added all the modules that you need. It's very rare that someone needs all of the modules all the time.
      6. Another reason I think you might be getting mixed up with other cameras is that there are no overheating issues on this camera. I've used it in record breaking temperatures all day in the sun, shooting 4K for hours and hours. Yes I try to keep it in the shade, even with a small attachment on the hot shoe or whatever, I think that's generally good practice for any camera, But if in these intense conditions it doesn't overheat, I'm happy. My A7S2 definitely had a couple of times it overheated, One of them was solved by just increasing the overheating threshold in the settings, and once I updated the firmware I didn't have an issue again, and I've pushed the A7 S3 much harder and not even had a warning. If you're having overheating issues with the camera you have a bad unit or need to update firmware.
      7. Regarding batteries, I've shot very long day Indian weddings, shooting in 4K with image stabilisation, using the screen on full brightness etc and never managed to get through more than 3 batteries in a day. Personally I would much much rather have smaller batteries that don't weigh half a kilo, As long as I don't have to change them every hour or two. (Like the a7s2!)

  • @walkerwayproductions
    @walkerwayproductions 2 місяці тому

    Awesome

  • @Ben-fq1lj
    @Ben-fq1lj Рік тому +1

    Does it record its slow motion 480fps and 960fps modes in 10 bit?

  • @lonzojones4428
    @lonzojones4428 Місяць тому

    is the f3 a better camera than this?

  • @mortaza79
    @mortaza79 3 роки тому +1

    Amazing thanks 🙏

  • @ahsanminhasofficial
    @ahsanminhasofficial 3 роки тому +2

    Well 12 bit prores raw the a7siii can also do. So the raw I feel it isn't a feature of the fs5mk2 anymore.
    The nd filter definitely is awesome but to sacrifice image quality due to not having that full frame look and amazing low light 10 bit look in all formats and it doesn't let u be discrete when outdoors. Those things u lose out actually help just getting a better image both for client work and film.
    I guess at this time of technology, the fs5mk2 isn't a camera to use rather the fx6 has now taken that place if u want those nd filters built in and the same prores raw which a7siii also has.

    • @tydetalx5873
      @tydetalx5873  3 роки тому +12

      I agree with the first points absolutely , however my view on this is some of the greatest films, photos and commercials were shot on antiquated tech and we remember them not for their image quality or what we can recover in the highlights. We remember them for the story and elements it had, I just think that in this day and age i started to see myself to concerned about the power of a camera when in all truth its the artist that makes the film or production. Why fix in post or have more power in post to cover mistakes if we get it right in the first place in camera. In other words i feel skills beat tech all day.

    • @ahsanminhasofficial
      @ahsanminhasofficial 3 роки тому +3

      @@tydetalx5873 an artist's ways of expression increases when the camera supports the capacity. If one has the skills only then can they do something like this where tech and art combine. So I guess I'm more the David fincher perspective where using technology and art hand in hand is now a necessity both in production and in post

    • @tydetalx5873
      @tydetalx5873  3 роки тому +1

      @@ahsanminhasofficial I believe that is an excellent point brother new view point for me.

    • @GozaProductions
      @GozaProductions 2 роки тому

      I wanna jump in and say I'm broke... That's why I'm gonna go with the fs5ii in 2022 because it will allow me to be at the top of my game where my only bottleneck is the price. Then when I get them $$$.. fx6 here I come (or the next iteration 🤣)

  • @eatfoodmusic3184
    @eatfoodmusic3184 2 роки тому

    Do you think the auto focus is better?

  • @histoiredelafrique3752
    @histoiredelafrique3752 2 роки тому

    Thank you !

  • @vitabcdefghijklmno
    @vitabcdefghijklmno 2 роки тому +2

    cube!

  • @antonnishan109
    @antonnishan109 3 роки тому +2

    Great video ,

  • @GiovanniMolinaJ
    @GiovanniMolinaJ Рік тому

    😃 thanks for this video is true all

  • @Laughing_Dog_Films
    @Laughing_Dog_Films Рік тому

    The only complaint I have with my FS5 Mii, the auto focus is slow.

  • @Kmass
    @Kmass 2 роки тому +1

    What Battery is that on the FS5?

  • @robertbrody4032
    @robertbrody4032 Рік тому

    The Sony A7sIII and even the latest version ALL exhibit serious rolling shutter effects. This also included the new FX30. Though the FS5 does not have a global shutter, the far faster sensor readout minimized rolling shutter and this makes it a far more serious and effective shooting tool. A FS5 MKII can be used as a B camera along side an F55 or Venice. That should give a hint as to how much more capable the FS5 MKII actually is.

  • @blasto3096
    @blasto3096 3 роки тому +2

    is the fs5 mark 1 any difference ? why is fs5 m1 more expensive?

    • @GCHUSTLEHAWAII
      @GCHUSTLEHAWAII 3 роки тому +1

      because you don't have to pay for the raw activation

    • @jeffreywright5549
      @jeffreywright5549 3 роки тому

      The only physical difference is the ND knob is black and the mk2 insignia, software update enables raw capability

    • @autorimultimediali2433
      @autorimultimediali2433 3 роки тому

      @@jeffreywright5549 Science color is different, too, pp1 on M II is really nice

  • @ondrejjanoska660
    @ondrejjanoska660 3 роки тому

    Ninja v is not compatible with fs5!!! You can not record even using the sdi unit for ninja v.

    • @tydetalx5873
      @tydetalx5873  3 роки тому

      That was a mistake my shogun 7 definitely records with the FS5 MKII

    • @seriouzfilmz9397
      @seriouzfilmz9397 3 роки тому +1

      You can record just only hdmi and not raw

    • @jessea.3883
      @jessea.3883 3 роки тому

      Atomos just recently (2-3 weeks ago iirc) released an update to enable raw via the SDI unit. But if the FS5ii only captures 12bit raw, that's still technically worse than the A7siii, which compresses 16 bit to 12 bit raw.

    • @seriouzfilmz9397
      @seriouzfilmz9397 3 роки тому +1

      @@jessea.3883 it was only for the new cameras like fs7 I believe

    • @leschwartz
      @leschwartz 2 роки тому

      Ninja V +