I don't get how fun to drive gives it a win. The Lexus has a better interior, softer cabin, more comfortable seats, and better isolation. When you're driving normally who whips the car around corners? And when you're on an 8-hour trip, I'm sure people would take comfort over whipping it around corners for that long.
If it's performance, the Cadillac wins, if it's about luxury, then the Lexus does. I would say the two are aiming at two different niches. Lexus doesn't focus on performance with the RX, but at least they don't claim it to being sporty. What it is, is a luxury SUV and it does executes that pretty damn well!
Motor Trend you are so predictable. Lexus is largely known for cars that are smooth , quiet, and sophisticated. Ever since the first LS and every Lexus after that has had the same verdict: not fun to drive. Thankfully Lexus philosophy has always been to coddle the passenger with its charms ( smoothness, quiet, sophistication, fantastic ride quality, excellent sound system, and of course reliability/build quality. There's a reason why the RX is so successful, and that Lexus will continue to dominate. Cadillac ....nice try
Motor trend is so biased as usual the whole world knows the Lexus is a better vehicle especially when it comes to quality and longevity...most people want a smoother car especially on bad roads who wants to get tossed around in the cabin...Lexus all the way for me it has a better resale value and we all know American cars cant go the distance when it comes to reliability.
I test drove EVERYTHING I could get my hands on for 2 years looking for my 1st luxury vehicle. Found a 2011 SRX black on black that was a ONE OWNER !! I test drive cars with a TON of knowledge per its VIN long before I even sit down in one. I knew instantly that THIS WAS IT 2 weeks ago as soon as I pulled off the lot. Couldn't be happier !! I LOVE IT !!
No one buys Cadillac. In the best cities of u.s., like NYC, Boston, or LA, you will see merc, bimmer, lexus and audi all over the streets, but not so many cadillac. Very likely, you may not run into one for the whole day, because this car is not good enough and mid-class just don't buy american cars.
That’s where you’re wrong because I’m a part of a middle-class family considering the SRX as a used car for my first car from this 2nd 2010 onwards generation for college, among the Lincoln MKX, along with other Lincoln & Cadillac sedan contenders
The SRX uses a unique platform that combines bits and pieces from the Theta platform that underpins the new Chevrolet Equinox and the Epsilon II platform that sits beneath the 2010 Buick LaCrosse. Company officials insists that it mainly uses components found on no other GM vehicle. This vehicle sits on a platform also reffered to as "Premium Theta" or "Theta Premium". SO U BOTH WERE RIGHT! LOL! I love Caddy talk. IM THE KING OF IT! Next Caddy topic please? :D
But now let's talk general engineering quality of build and build material....the Cadillac is a disaster in there are none of them on the road anymore compared to the Toyota....Cadillac actually developed so many problems so early on that it was an absolute disaster believe it or not....
I am still driving my 2008 SRX4 V6. I inherited it from my grandfather in 2010. It has 160k on the odometer. It gets crappy gas mileage and it uses a quart of oil every 300 miles. But other than that the only maintenance performed on it has been regular oil changes and replacing the spark plugs and changing out the transmission fluid at 100K.. It has been a very reliable car. I love my black on black SRX4.
@dunemoonbeam3 Caddies and Aston Martin are my two favorite car companies but yea Caddy has come a long ways.Believe it or not Caddy invented alot of car accessories that alot of people don't know about.
Now, I'm just gonna break it down to you like this. The comment with the highest amount of thumbs up says "I'll take the Cadillac SRX thanks." and the second highest talks about American car companies reclaiming their throne as the world's prime. If that isn't enough proof that a majority of people prefer the SRX, then you're just ignorant. All you do is talk about quality because that's all the RX350 has. As for the other two major elements, design and performance, the Cadillac prevails, 2:1.
Lexus has won many awards however Cadillac has been building excellent cars. Their workmanship reflects in the 2011 SRX. Quality and Attention to detail has outdone Lexus.
One major problem with the SRX, and the reason why I chose the Lexus over the SRX: LACK OF POWER. This is not something I would ever imagine criticizing a Cadillac for, but unless you're willing to pay a hefty premium for the turbo, the engine is lackluster even compared to the Lexus. It's 0-60 time is almost a second slower than the Lexus.
I dont agree with the verdict at all Cadillac SRX is ugly and American who the hell is going to buy that crap over Lexus?Japan Rules when it come to cars over america, so Cadillac SRX sucks.
You misunderstand, 2009 RX350 has a 3.5L 270hp V6, 2010 RX350 has a 3.5L 275hp V6. And I'm Glad to see GM dong things right, and in this case better, more fun. :)
I don't think Lexus is much better than Cadillac. I think Cadillac wins the most Refined Luxury Car Company this year. Cadillac has been building excellent cars. Both automobile companies are leading class.
Though I am in India, I am a great fan of Cadillac. The CTS sedan, CTS coupe, CTS-V and the SRX are world beaters. They are simply so superior to others. When are you going to enter the Indian market CADILLAC? I would surely like to buy one of the SRX Turbos when I trade in my BMW X5 XDrive .
It just depends on the person. Sure some people just want a comfy cabin to carry them from point A to point B, but others actually want something that they 'enjoy driving'. Driving can either be a necessary chore, or a source of pleasure. I have a Cadillac SRX because I needed the utility of a crossover, but still wanted something that I enjoy walking up, turns a few heads, and gives somewhat of a thrill on the road. The Caddy is more of a driver's car, the Lexus is just nice transportation.
I'm from Germany, and i have to say that Cadillac is an amazing car brand. I saw a lot of German reviews about some Cadillac models, and the Cadillacs always got the better results, even in the German carshows. The CTS has beaten the BMW 5-Series and the Mercedes E-Calss. The CTS-V set a new record time in its class on the Nurburgring. So big respect to Cadillac, they are better than any european car maker.
its all about whats important to you. If you want comfort,reliability and refinement go with lexus-for old people. If you you want style, gagets, and performance go for the srx-young people
Dude you do realize these are made in Canada right? I don't understand why people always say "buy american". With globalization, car makers are starting to make cars everwhere. Mercedes benz will start making cars in America. Toyota has some huge plants in America so when you say buy America, I don't understand what you mean. It's not a bad thing to be patriotic, but toyota is practically just as american as GM now...
you know, i never got why people question reliability on a brand new car when they haven't once owned the car yet to experience any problem the car has. so where do you get off saying that this is unreliable when you haven't even owned one?
Ive driven a 09 CTSV and Trust me it was amazing. Magnetic selective suspension ( same as a 599 GTB has) Track tuned Limited Slip diff designed by American and German engineers at the Nurburgring. And that Extemely powerful 6.2 liter LSA V8. And its interior is just amazing co desinged with Recaro.
You all really do not know what biased is, how the hell is the SRX is a Chromed up Equinox really, stop hating on GM and Motor Trend. Shit I want a luxurious car and I want it sporty not boring and dull and to soft.
If it's all "based on the fun to drive part" as they have stated, the award really would go to anything else but these two. The Infinity FX comes to mind; among others.
What's your point? You don't even know anything about Motor Trend, do you? If anything they are often accused of being biased against American cars, but if you'd like my opinion, Motor Trend is the single most objective "mainstream" automotive magazine. Now if you don't like American cars and it disappoints you that the American won I don't even know why you're watching the video... go watch Jeremy Clarkson. He is the unbiased one, right? He wouldn't ever take nationality into account, would he?
You have obviiously never seen an XTS then. And their interior's are now co designed with Recaro, with alcantara and sueded leather accents with the double stiched high quality leather. The CTS is aimed at Merc, BMW, Audi etc.. The XTS is aimed at Bentleys
just dont take him too seriously and his words to heart and you'll be fine. about the objective bit, i dont really care much who they pick for the winner as much as i care about the comments. a good magazine is a magazine that writes reviews good enough for you to know almost exactly how it feels to drive the car and use its features. then, you could compare and pick the winner for yourself...
near the middle? how about near the top? just 2 weeks ago, Consumer Reports posted up the 2009 Initial Quality survey results.... Cadillac placed 3rd behind Porsche and Lexus with Lexus being 1st. Cadillac only had 91 problems out of 100 cars while Lexus posted an 84/100, which isn't that far off. just because a manufacturer is #1, doesn't mean every other manufacturer RIGHT below it is unreliable. you should learn to realize that.
I'd have to go with the RX. I'm never an early adopter, even though the SRX is 2nd generation, it still feels like a freshman attempt. Maybe the next generation I'd go with the Cadillac. And what did you expect? Motor Trend will always go with Cadillac.
Did you check Top gear???? What did they say???? If you are a old lady picking up the kids from school you will buy the merc BUT if you are a man, who knows what he wants you will drive a BMW. Dude M3 is the legend and no car in its class ate it yet! Not even the new IS F.
The Caddy looks soooooo much better than the Lexus, but the Lexus is a nicer performer and has a more comfortable interior. Still though, I'd rather own the Caddy.
stupid review, the very reason why RX is the benchmark of this segment, is BECUZ ppl who buy cars in this segment, mostly lookin for luxury, comfort, & safety, if anyone wanted to get a "fun to drive" small cross-over, they would most likely get Q5 or GLK, or even X3, that's also why you RARELY see any SRX, or Cadillac for that matter. Lexus will WIN this and dominate this segment until other companies start to understand what the buyers want when buying such a car - luxury, comfort, safety.
I see huge amount of Lexus, BMW, Benz, and the RX is EVERYWHERE, I live in a major city and one of the richest cities in the world, only few OLD ppl and ppl who cannot afford Lexus, Benz, BMW and Audi drive Cadi. the look of new Cadi is cool, but they simply cannot complete with those true luxury cars when it comes to luxury, and the look wise is very subjective, thus we can't really argue that.
why is the "fun" factor what they are mainly looking for in a SUV. I'm sure the SRX is more sporty to drive but that's not the most important factor in a SUV. Why not just get a CTS instead if you're looking for a "fun" vehicle? I personally think the RX350 is the all-rounder.
What is true luxury...and don't say quality, because if they were the exact same thing there wouldn't be two different words for them. Luxury is a lavish combination of comfort (which Cadillacs definately have) and beauty (which all Cadillacs also have, says the majority again). I'm not gonna call a material cheap because it's firm.
I prefer the SRX over the RX. The Lexus is a solid truck but the Cadillac is just better. People can call it an overpriced GM if they want but as long as GM is pumping out cars of that level they can call them "turds" and I will take one. I drive a 2010 Equinox and its GREAT. GM really stepped things up with this truck. So my next move will be the SRX of the Traverse. My BFF has a RX and the steering is TERRIBLE Its FEELS electronic. As if its pulling in the opposite direction that your stirring
Well no, most japanese cars are made in america, but with japanese parts. They ship the parts here and now assemble them and so its "american." On the other hand, the new Cadillac CTS for example is completely American (as long as you buy the 3.0 liter). The car is made in America to the very button and stitch. American design, American made, etc. The new SRX is made in Mexico, with American parts. See what I mean? You can get an American car, you just have to look.
Wow, such a poised response to my harsh sarcasm, I can't believe this is UA-cam :p I don't consider myself an American car enthusiast, and I do think American companies have made brutal mistakes over the last years, but I believe Cadillac has made a valiant effort with its last two cars, which, as you can see here, can perfectly rival the top dogs of their respective segments. They may not be perfect, but they are by no means a failure. I just can't see why someone would hate on the new Caddys
I hate how the headlights on the RX were positioned so far inward in the car. . . but I just checked and it looks like Lexus did an emergency restyling of sorts, because if you look you will see some with the reversed headlight positioning and some with the BETTER headlight positioning.
So many people are entitled to their own opinions. So I'll throw mine out there, I'd be happy with either cars but I'd take the lexus since I'm a long time loyal American customer.
Americans that are REAL Americans will buy this incredibly handsome SRX made by Cadillac. The rest of the "Americans," aka the Sheeple, will opt for the Lexus. Yeah, I know it looks like the latest crossover from a Korean automaker, but it really is a Lexus....NOTE- a 2.8 L turbocharged V6 engine that produces 300 HP will soon be available for the SRX as the optional engine....
GM makes my favorite american cars, i have nothing against them. but Cadillac does NOT have better resale value compared to Lexus. Lexus is better in every way(as a daily driver). now if i was looking for performance i would never touch lexus. some reason. also cadillacs still cant beat lexus in overall quality/reliablity. btw you can vote this comment down cuz its siding with lexus. just shows how immature fan boys are.
what am i gonna say to you now when you ignore all the facts!!! Lexus has won the neatest panel gap awards, best paint award many years in a row, also ranking number on JD power 15 yrs in a row, they use the best leather with the best attention for example, they only use one side of ONE tree to ensure the same color and pattern from the wood trim, two stage hand sanding, ONLY from Lexus in the industry, laser measure and correction to ensure the smoothest pain and panels...
True, especially when you can't understand the criteria they use to pick a winner (they compare the Mustang and the Camaro and declare the Camaro the winner, then the Mustang and the Genesis and the Mustang wins, and then the Camaro and the Genesis and the... Genesis! wins), but I feel like other magazines don't give cars the same exact chances to win a comparison as MT does... As for Clarkson, I try not to take him seriously, but if I can't, then how will I ever consider him a good source?
CTS is killing the 5 series in sales. And The CTSV is totally insane in performance. And is Faster and equally or better equipped than: BMW M5 Mercedes E63 AMG Audi S6 Jaguar XFR Porsche Panamara The CTS V had better HP better MPGS and a better Warranty than all of those cars. The CTSV fully loaded with everything is still less than one of those in their cheapest form. The only reason they cost more is for the badge.
"blazed a trail" as in Trailblazer, by Chevy? lol. Im srry, but Lexus hav to b the most boring cars in the world, then to make it worse, they buy them in colours like silver ugh(which i dnt consider a colour...) i think Id rther drive neither of the and get an M class, but in this comparison the SRX wins. also, this is the clearist most HQ vid ive ever seen.
we own a car dealership and I have driven every car there is, I always go back to the Lexus. Best vehicle on the road.
I don't get how fun to drive gives it a win. The Lexus has a better interior, softer cabin, more comfortable seats, and better isolation. When you're driving normally who whips the car around corners? And when you're on an 8-hour trip, I'm sure people would take comfort over whipping it around corners for that long.
Cadillac has better seating position. Sitting unnatural on all toyotas/lexus is no fun.
I pick Lexus for higher quality!
I have both of those vehicles and the Cadillac has a more mean sport drive and the Lexus has a relaxed and grocery getter drive
I prefer the Cadillac for its' bold styling, but both cars are fundamentally great.
Love Lexus, great car!
I test driven both I bought the Lexus RX 150k miles later looks and drives like new !!!!!
A smooth isolated ride is the way to go!
GM Just can't do a good interior always looks and feels CHEAP.
If I had to choose in this class - I`d go with Infiniti FX everytime!
Looks fantastic, feels fantastic and outperforms both in this video
I love our SRX. My wife found a loaded 2011 version with only 21,000 miles on it.
If it's performance, the Cadillac wins, if it's about luxury, then the Lexus does. I would say the two are aiming at two different niches. Lexus doesn't focus on performance with the RX, but at least they don't claim it to being sporty. What it is, is a luxury SUV and it does executes that pretty damn well!
really the best looking cadillac so far
Motor Trend you are so predictable. Lexus is largely known for cars that are smooth , quiet, and sophisticated. Ever since the first LS and every Lexus after that has had the same verdict: not fun to drive. Thankfully Lexus philosophy has always been to coddle the passenger with its charms ( smoothness, quiet, sophistication, fantastic ride quality, excellent sound system, and of course reliability/build quality. There's a reason why the RX is so successful, and that Lexus will continue to dominate. Cadillac ....nice try
consumer verdict is lexus
Motor trend is so biased as usual the whole world knows the Lexus is a better vehicle especially when it comes to quality and longevity...most people want a smoother car especially on bad roads who wants to get tossed around in the cabin...Lexus all the way for me it has a better resale value and we all know American cars cant go the distance when it comes to reliability.
Cadillac all the way ! it's a classic american motoring.
The Lexus is everywhere. I see like at least 3 of them on any road I go. Good luck to Caddy, it's going to be tough.
I test drove EVERYTHING I could get my hands on for 2 years looking for my 1st luxury vehicle. Found a 2011 SRX black on black that was a ONE OWNER !! I test drive cars with a TON of knowledge per its VIN long before I even sit down in one. I knew instantly that THIS WAS IT 2 weeks ago as soon as I pulled off the lot. Couldn't be happier !! I LOVE IT !!
No one buys Cadillac. In the best cities of u.s., like NYC, Boston, or LA, you will see merc, bimmer, lexus and audi all over the streets, but not so many cadillac. Very likely, you may not run into one for the whole day, because this car is not good enough and mid-class just don't buy american cars.
That’s where you’re wrong because I’m a part of a middle-class family considering the SRX as a used car for my first car from this 2nd 2010 onwards generation for college, among the Lincoln MKX, along with other Lincoln & Cadillac sedan contenders
Along with a 2006 Lexus IS 250 AWD or 2006 Lexus GS 300 AWD/ 2007 onwards GS 350 AWD
As usual motor trend is biased towards a gm product
As usual motor trend is biased towards gas-only cars
Cadillac is soooooo beautiful !!!!
Lexus .. You are old school
The SRX uses a unique platform that combines bits and pieces from the Theta platform that underpins the new Chevrolet Equinox and the Epsilon II platform that sits beneath the 2010 Buick LaCrosse. Company officials insists that it mainly uses components found on no other GM vehicle. This vehicle sits on a platform also reffered to as "Premium Theta" or "Theta Premium". SO U BOTH WERE RIGHT! LOL! I love Caddy talk. IM THE KING OF IT! Next Caddy topic please? :D
Still waiting for Yugo to create the SUV called Wego! We will of course be purchasing the "LX" version. 🙄
I must say my SRX is a nice driving crossover.
I like the SRX better almost everyone has a Lexus RX
You've driven the 2010 Cadillac SRX for a year? AMAZING!
Blessed to have Lexus RX and Cadillac SRX . Lexus is the better car in my view.
But now let's talk general engineering quality of build and build material....the Cadillac is a disaster in there are none of them on the road anymore compared to the Toyota....Cadillac actually developed so many problems so early on that it was an absolute disaster believe it or not....
The new SRX has grown on me and I really like it now!
I am still driving my 2008 SRX4 V6. I inherited it from my grandfather in 2010. It has 160k on the odometer. It gets crappy gas mileage and it uses a quart of oil every 300 miles. But other than that the only maintenance performed on it has been regular oil changes and replacing the spark plugs and changing out the transmission fluid at 100K.. It has been a very reliable car. I love my black on black SRX4.
@dunemoonbeam3 Caddies and Aston Martin are my two favorite car companies but yea Caddy has come a long ways.Believe it or not Caddy invented alot of car accessories that alot of people don't know about.
We have a 2013 SRX AWD and we love this SUV and it runs on E85!
Now, I'm just gonna break it down to you like this. The comment with the highest amount of thumbs up says "I'll take the Cadillac SRX thanks." and the second highest talks about American car companies reclaiming their throne as the world's prime. If that isn't enough proof that a majority of people prefer the SRX, then you're just ignorant. All you do is talk about quality because that's all the RX350 has. As for the other two major elements, design and performance, the Cadillac prevails, 2:1.
I love the blues on both of these test vehicles
Lexus has won many awards however Cadillac has been building excellent cars. Their workmanship reflects in the 2011 SRX. Quality and Attention to detail has outdone Lexus.
One major problem with the SRX, and the reason why I chose the Lexus over the SRX: LACK OF POWER. This is not something I would ever imagine criticizing a Cadillac for, but unless you're willing to pay a hefty premium for the turbo, the engine is lackluster even compared to the Lexus. It's 0-60 time is almost a second slower than the Lexus.
I don't think Lexus is an overpriced Toyota. Lexus interior is high quality. Lexus is the Passionate Pursuit of Perfection.
I dont agree with the verdict at all Cadillac SRX is ugly and American who the hell is going to buy that crap over Lexus?Japan Rules when it come to cars over america, so Cadillac SRX sucks.
Gotta love that Lexus!
That lexus has noo eye popping exterior design ...
Rumor has it the Lexus is still going strong and the caddy is long gone.
Hell yeah they are.
Go Cadillac!
You misunderstand, 2009 RX350 has a 3.5L 270hp V6, 2010 RX350 has a 3.5L 275hp V6.
And I'm Glad to see GM dong things right, and in this case better, more fun. :)
The Cadillac SRX looks awesome, the Lexus still looks like a jacked up mini van.
I don't think Lexus is much better than Cadillac. I think Cadillac wins the most Refined Luxury Car Company this year. Cadillac has been building excellent cars. Both automobile companies are leading class.
Though I am in India, I am a great fan of Cadillac.
The CTS sedan, CTS coupe, CTS-V and the SRX are world beaters. They are simply so superior to others.
When are you going to enter the Indian market CADILLAC? I would surely like to buy one of the SRX Turbos when I trade in my BMW X5 XDrive .
It just depends on the person. Sure some people just want a comfy cabin to carry them from point A to point B, but others actually want something that they 'enjoy driving'. Driving can either be a necessary chore, or a source of pleasure. I have a Cadillac SRX because I needed the utility of a crossover, but still wanted something that I enjoy walking up, turns a few heads, and gives somewhat of a thrill on the road. The Caddy is more of a driver's car, the Lexus is just nice transportation.
I'm from Germany, and i have to say that Cadillac is an amazing car brand.
I saw a lot of German reviews about some Cadillac models, and the Cadillacs always got the better results, even in the German carshows. The CTS has beaten the BMW 5-Series and the Mercedes E-Calss.
The CTS-V set a new record time in its class on the Nurburgring. So big respect to Cadillac, they are better than any european car maker.
It's not like you've driven the Caddy!
its all about whats important to you. If you want comfort,reliability and refinement go with lexus-for old people. If you you want style, gagets, and performance go for the srx-young people
Dude you do realize these are made in Canada right?
I don't understand why people always say "buy american". With globalization, car makers are starting to make cars everwhere. Mercedes benz will start making cars in America. Toyota has some huge plants in America so when you say buy America, I don't understand what you mean. It's not a bad thing to be patriotic, but toyota is practically just as american as GM now...
they're forgetting this is a luxury car comparison, not a sports performance one.
you know, i never got why people question reliability on a brand new car when they haven't once owned the car yet to experience any problem the car has.
so where do you get off saying that this is unreliable when you haven't even owned one?
I'll take the Lexus on quality and reliability alone.
When you buy a SUV in this class, you don't want to take it to the shop every minute.
considering the RX and SRX are both the one who basically started the CUV movement, then yes, they are the kings whether you like it or not.
Lexus all the way
Ive driven a 09 CTSV and Trust me it was amazing.
Magnetic selective suspension ( same as a 599 GTB has)
Track tuned Limited Slip diff designed by American and German engineers at the Nurburgring.
And that Extemely powerful 6.2 liter LSA V8.
And its interior is just amazing co desinged with Recaro.
I find the Cadillac much more appealing and less boring than the Lexus.
Yet Cadillacs lose value so quickly and will look like crap in a few years the Rx is the best in the business
You all really do not know what biased is, how the hell is the SRX is a Chromed up Equinox really, stop hating on GM and Motor Trend. Shit I want a luxurious car and I want it sporty not boring and dull and to soft.
If it's all "based on the fun to drive part" as they have stated, the award really would go to anything else but these two. The Infinity FX comes to mind; among others.
What's your point? You don't even know anything about Motor Trend, do you? If anything they are often accused of being biased against American cars, but if you'd like my opinion, Motor Trend is the single most objective "mainstream" automotive magazine. Now if you don't like American cars and it disappoints you that the American won I don't even know why you're watching the video... go watch Jeremy Clarkson. He is the unbiased one, right? He wouldn't ever take nationality into account, would he?
Cadillac is stepping it up with their vehicles, first the Escalade(EXT and ESV), then the CTS(V, coupe and station wagon) and now the SRX.
You have obviiously never seen an XTS then. And their interior's are now co designed with Recaro, with alcantara and sueded leather accents with the double stiched high quality leather.
The CTS is aimed at Merc, BMW, Audi etc..
The XTS is aimed at Bentleys
oh and btw whether clarkson is biased or not(he obviously is....at least verbally), he has a point most of the time and he's quite entertaining.
just dont take him too seriously and his words to heart and you'll be fine.
about the objective bit, i dont really care much who they pick for the winner as much as i care about the comments. a good magazine is a magazine that writes reviews good enough for you to know almost exactly how it feels to drive the car and use its features. then, you could compare and pick the winner for yourself...
near the middle? how about near the top? just 2 weeks ago, Consumer Reports posted up the 2009 Initial Quality survey results....
Cadillac placed 3rd behind Porsche and Lexus with Lexus being 1st. Cadillac only had 91 problems out of 100 cars while Lexus posted an 84/100, which isn't that far off. just because a manufacturer is #1, doesn't mean every other manufacturer RIGHT below it is unreliable. you should learn to realize that.
haha not yet, Cadillac is back and has been rated higher than any lexus in every review you wanna dig up.
I'd have to go with the RX. I'm never an early adopter, even though the SRX is 2nd generation, it still feels like a freshman attempt. Maybe the next generation I'd go with the Cadillac.
And what did you expect? Motor Trend will always go with Cadillac.
Did you check Top gear???? What did they say????
If you are a old lady picking up the kids from school you will buy the merc BUT if you are a man, who knows what he wants you will drive a BMW.
Dude M3 is the legend and no car in its class ate it yet! Not even the new IS F.
the lexus is MILES ahead of that piece of shit
I feel sad for people who think Cadillac's are more luxurious than Lexus, or are luxurious at all...
The Caddy looks soooooo much better than the Lexus, but the Lexus is a nicer performer and has a more comfortable interior. Still though, I'd rather own the Caddy.
you do realize that they chose the Cadillac, right? dont knock it till u drive it, smart guy.
stupid review, the very reason why RX is the benchmark of this segment, is BECUZ ppl who buy cars in this segment, mostly lookin for luxury, comfort, & safety, if anyone wanted to get a "fun to drive" small cross-over, they would most likely get Q5 or GLK, or even X3, that's also why you RARELY see any SRX, or Cadillac for that matter.
Lexus will WIN this and dominate this segment until other companies start to understand what the buyers want when buying such a car - luxury, comfort, safety.
I see huge amount of Lexus, BMW, Benz, and the RX is EVERYWHERE, I live in a major city and one of the richest cities in the world, only few OLD ppl and ppl who cannot afford Lexus, Benz, BMW and Audi drive Cadi. the look of new Cadi is cool, but they simply cannot complete with those true luxury cars when it comes to luxury, and the look wise is very subjective, thus we can't really argue that.
why is the "fun" factor what they are mainly looking for in a SUV. I'm sure the SRX is more sporty to drive but that's not the most important factor in a SUV. Why not just get a CTS instead if you're looking for a "fun" vehicle? I personally think the RX350 is the all-rounder.
3:42 ha ha ha the caddy doesn’t even have a power tilt and telescopic steering wheel. The RX has that standard
YUP AND BETTER RELIABILITY, BETTER RIDE, MOAH SAFETY AND BETTER INTIERIOR SPACE
Oh yeahhh I love the srx in white pearl or jet black color!
The RX simply is not nice to look at now where as the Caddy looks quite nice.
What is true luxury...and don't say quality, because if they were the exact same thing there wouldn't be two different words for them. Luxury is a lavish combination of comfort (which Cadillacs definately have) and beauty (which all Cadillacs also have, says the majority again). I'm not gonna call a material cheap because it's firm.
The Cadillac SRX wins this one. However don't give up on the RX350. After all, its a Lexus.
I prefer the SRX over the RX. The Lexus is a solid truck but the Cadillac is just better. People can call it an overpriced GM if they want but as long as GM is pumping out cars of that level they can call them "turds" and I will take one. I drive a 2010 Equinox and its GREAT. GM really stepped things up with this truck. So my next move will be the SRX of the Traverse. My BFF has a RX and the steering is TERRIBLE Its FEELS electronic. As if its pulling in the opposite direction that your stirring
Well no, most japanese cars are made in america, but with japanese parts. They ship the parts here and now assemble them and so its "american." On the other hand, the new Cadillac CTS for example is completely American (as long as you buy the 3.0 liter). The car is made in America to the very button and stitch. American design, American made, etc. The new SRX is made in Mexico, with American parts. See what I mean? You can get an American car, you just have to look.
Wow, such a poised response to my harsh sarcasm, I can't believe this is UA-cam :p
I don't consider myself an American car enthusiast, and I do think American companies have made brutal mistakes over the last years, but I believe Cadillac has made a valiant effort with its last two cars, which, as you can see here, can perfectly rival the top dogs of their respective segments. They may not be perfect, but they are by no means a failure. I just can't see why someone would hate on the new Caddys
I hate how the headlights on the RX were positioned so far inward in the car. . . but I just checked and it looks like Lexus did an emergency restyling of sorts, because if you look you will see some with the reversed headlight positioning and some with the BETTER headlight positioning.
So many people are entitled to their own opinions. So I'll throw mine out there, I'd be happy with either cars but I'd take the lexus since I'm a long time loyal American customer.
Americans that are REAL Americans will buy this incredibly handsome SRX made by Cadillac. The rest of the "Americans," aka the Sheeple, will opt for the Lexus. Yeah, I know it looks like the latest crossover from a Korean automaker, but it really is a Lexus....NOTE- a 2.8 L turbocharged V6 engine that produces 300 HP will soon be available for the SRX as the optional engine....
Based on fun to drive we give it to Cadillac... YEAH RIGHT!!! Based on biased opinion Cadi was given "the winner" as it is American car.
Uh. At the beginning he says "The Lexus handles better." Then, at the end, "The cadillac handles better." O.o
GM makes my favorite american cars, i have nothing against them. but Cadillac does NOT have better resale value compared to Lexus. Lexus is better in every way(as a daily driver). now if i was looking for performance i would never touch lexus.
some reason. also cadillacs still cant beat lexus in overall quality/reliablity.
btw you can vote this comment down cuz its siding with lexus. just shows how immature fan boys are.
what am i gonna say to you now when you ignore all the facts!!! Lexus has won the neatest panel gap awards, best paint award many years in a row, also ranking number on JD power 15 yrs in a row, they use the best leather with the best attention for example, they only use one side of ONE tree to ensure the same color and pattern from the wood trim, two stage hand sanding, ONLY from Lexus in the industry, laser measure and correction to ensure the smoothest pain and panels...
True, especially when you can't understand the criteria they use to pick a winner (they compare the Mustang and the Camaro and declare the Camaro the winner, then the Mustang and the Genesis and the Mustang wins, and then the Camaro and the Genesis and the... Genesis! wins), but I feel like other magazines don't give cars the same exact chances to win a comparison as MT does...
As for Clarkson, I try not to take him seriously, but if I can't, then how will I ever consider him a good source?
Cadillac is stepping up their game, but the XC60 is better than both.
Don't get your hopes up. But I like seeing people get their dreams crushed, so KEEP DREAMING
CTS is killing the 5 series in sales.
And The CTSV is totally insane in performance. And is Faster and equally or better equipped than:
BMW M5
Mercedes E63 AMG
Audi S6
Jaguar XFR
Porsche Panamara
The CTS V had better HP better MPGS and a better Warranty than all of those cars. The CTSV fully loaded with everything is still less than one of those in their cheapest form.
The only reason they cost more is for the badge.
yay caddy won
"blazed a trail" as in Trailblazer, by Chevy? lol. Im srry, but Lexus hav to b the most boring cars in the world, then to make it worse, they buy them in colours like silver ugh(which i dnt consider a colour...) i think Id rther drive neither of the and get an M class, but in this comparison the SRX wins. also, this is the clearist most HQ vid ive ever seen.
thats why its called a sports utility vehicle