GamingSins: Everything Wrong With Red Dead Redemption

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 26 гру 2018
  • Welcome to GamingSins, where I nitpick the hell out of video games.
    I’m gonna level with you guys. Rockstar’s reputation is…..somewhat exaggerated. Clearly, I was a different person back in 2010, cause coming back to play this game with a new set of eyes...it's a bit over appreciated. Is it a great game? Yes. Is it the masterpiece that many claim it is? Nope.
    --------------------------------------------------------------------------
    If you wish to support Jaki Rose and download the end credit 'Video Game Song'
    itunes.apple.com/us/album/vid...
    And of course, don't forget to check out The Originals, CinemaSins.
    / cinemasins
    #GCN #gamingsins #reddeadredemption
  • Ігри

КОМЕНТАРІ • 1,5 тис.

  • @VinceDPad
    @VinceDPad  5 років тому +582

    WARNING: There are spoilers for Red Dead Redemption II in this video. Don't watch if you haven't played it.
    Clearly, I had too much faith that some of you had already played it.

    • @FireFox64000000
      @FireFox64000000 5 років тому +9

      I honestly didn't plan on playing it.

    • @TylerPourteau
      @TylerPourteau 5 років тому +6

      GCN by the way sin number 57 where John dies when he comes near water it is revealed in red dead redemption 2 that John cannot swim and in the epilogue will drown if he comes intact with water

    • @maestro1417
      @maestro1417 5 років тому

      mafia or Vampyer ??

    • @stardestroyer4041
      @stardestroyer4041 5 років тому +3

      Hey man , how about a video to sin TWD : The final season ep 1 😁
      Btw: whenever i'm upset i watch one of your sins video , it makes my day 😂 love ur vids

    • @darth_flaviousplays2838
      @darth_flaviousplays2838 5 років тому +1

      blame game devs for excluding PC master race.

  • @MrZomBie775
    @MrZomBie775 5 років тому +923

    Doing the Mexico section without wearing the pancho outfit? That's a sin right there.
    Edit: poncho

    • @javierandreszunigagarcia8791
      @javierandreszunigagarcia8791 5 років тому +7

      Pancho?

    • @MrZomBie775
      @MrZomBie775 5 років тому +30

      @@javierandreszunigagarcia8791 ok I'm American what do you want from me. Lol

    • @957kakashi
      @957kakashi 5 років тому +17

      Poncho. Poncho man. Not that hard. Lol.

    • @MrZomBie775
      @MrZomBie775 5 років тому +19

      @@957kakashi Yeah your right. A pancho would be a poncho made of pans.

    • @detrogamus2619
      @detrogamus2619 5 років тому +3

      Shit. I didnt. I am a sin.

  • @FireFox64000000
    @FireFox64000000 5 років тому +953

    Smoking was advertised as being good for you until about the 1950s.

    • @justinbayless8284
      @justinbayless8284 5 років тому +42

      Not good for you but they definitely played it as a cure all for things like tuberculosis and whatever the fuck lumbago is

    • @Livi2112
      @Livi2112 5 років тому +56

      @@justinbayless8284 No, actually they were said to be good for you and to prevent respiratory problems as well as cure many diseases.

    • @justinworley5075
      @justinworley5075 5 років тому +30

      Justin Bayless until around the 1950s they legit said it was good for you, helping literally every facility of the body. Even saying smoking slowed aging and hairloss

    • @oathkeeper65
      @oathkeeper65 5 років тому +16

      Justin Bayless lumbago is actually a real thing. It’s essentially chronic lower back pain.

    • @emutv4100
      @emutv4100 5 років тому +4

      lumbago isnt serious though, over 3 million cases in the US alone, its treatable with rest, and rarely ever requires a visit to the doctor

  • @zentazym1
    @zentazym1 5 років тому +488

    Why is John not cheating on his wife considered a sin?

    • @justinbayless8284
      @justinbayless8284 5 років тому +51

      Because hes doing the right thing?

    • @FranklinXVI
      @FranklinXVI 5 років тому +26

      Because he never cheats on his wife

    • @dextertoast764
      @dextertoast764 5 років тому +6

      John is a criminal so I guess it's a sin.

    • @Crazelord91
      @Crazelord91 5 років тому +43

      My only issue with it is you have the option to be the biggest criminal douche in this world, like how you can kill nuns collecting for charity by tying them to train tracks, but you're not allowed to cheat on your wife bc John is too moral for that.
      Feels limiting and breaks some immersion in an open world choose how you play game

    • @gongusdeedeetow1510
      @gongusdeedeetow1510 5 років тому +2

      @@FranklinXVI well he did.

  • @yourmom7748
    @yourmom7748 5 років тому +530

    West Dickens Oil isn't supposed to activate deadeye. The point of the mission is selling the oil by demostrating johns natural skills as its effect. False advertisment, nothing more.

    • @fimble_wimble
      @fimble_wimble 5 років тому +13

      And for some reason it levels up your dead eye

    • @jedikraft1655
      @jedikraft1655 5 років тому +7

      fuit123 you shoot a hat betterer

    • @Lilbunnialice404
      @Lilbunnialice404 5 років тому +4

      Damnit I'm ruined I bought so much oil

    • @yazidefirenze
      @yazidefirenze 3 роки тому

      @@Lilbunnialice404 o i l

    • @ashwath5733
      @ashwath5733 2 роки тому +1

      @@fimble_wimble and snake oil refils your deadeye

  • @cjv8522
    @cjv8522 5 років тому +616

    “Thot patrol is considered dishonourable.”
    Haha

  • @natanfk2
    @natanfk2 5 років тому +591

    "This tonic should enable you to use dead-eye, but you can use it since the beginning of the game"
    Uh, pretty obviously the tonic isn't real, he just used John's own skills (dead eye) to make it look like it works.

    • @stupid90able
      @stupid90able 5 років тому +4

      I was just about to comment on that.

    • @nessesaryschoolthing
      @nessesaryschoolthing 5 років тому +108

      Don't you hate it when sins come from just not paying enough attention?

    • @ginge641
      @ginge641 5 років тому +26

      @@nessesaryschoolthing That's most of these.

    • @anthonycorradini7998
      @anthonycorradini7998 5 років тому +14

      I was about to say the same thing. At least pay attention if youre giving a sin dude

    • @nicholasvandergeest7808
      @nicholasvandergeest7808 5 років тому +6

      @@nessesaryschoolthing happens when you wanna copy cinema sins

  • @Alex_FRD
    @Alex_FRD 5 років тому +506

    That Duck Hunt segment killed me.

    • @logicaloverdrive8197
      @logicaloverdrive8197 5 років тому +4

      Alex FRD that was great though.

    • @bigbruno2232
      @bigbruno2232 5 років тому +3

      Sweet revenge for me after they treat my car as a toilet.

    • @agrey832
      @agrey832 5 років тому +2

      Agreed!!!

  • @Th3HyroMan
    @Th3HyroMan 5 років тому +356

    Not So Subtle Foreshadowing That A RDR2 Video Will Exist

  • @aswallace88
    @aswallace88 3 роки тому +53

    24:39 I think he's saying "Dammit, Dutch!" because he knows that it's Dutch's charismatic misleading of the three natives that you meet up with that leads to Nastas' death.

  • @SomeAustrianGuy_
    @SomeAustrianGuy_ 5 років тому +250

    *_Tuberculosis... Damn you!_*

  • @AustinTheDestroyer1
    @AustinTheDestroyer1 5 років тому +94

    "Javier and John had no meaningful interaction in Red Dead 2"
    ain't Javier the one that wanted to go save John....................

  • @jayfolk
    @jayfolk 5 років тому +63

    2:13
    "It's over John! I have the *high ground!* "
    - William "Bill" Williamson

    • @jayfolk
      @jayfolk 5 років тому +1

      also, fuck Obi Wan Kenobi telling Anakin this in ep3 when Obi Wan defied the very meaning of his own infamous quote in ep1 with Darth Maul...

    • @41_orizaferishpriyono99
      @41_orizaferishpriyono99 4 роки тому +5

      His real name is actually Marion , Marion "Bill" Williamson

    • @joaqu7002
      @joaqu7002 3 роки тому

      It’s Marion “Bill” Williamson

  • @retrobat153
    @retrobat153 5 років тому +70

    I think the reason the government didn't go after jack and abagail is because they didn't want to kill any women and children and since there is no proof that mary beth or tilly died in RDR its safe to say that the government wouldn't kill women and jack was technically a kid so they probably didn't think he would seek revenge 3 years later because remember jack and john's relationship wasn't that good to begin with

    • @maximaldinotrap
      @maximaldinotrap 5 років тому +3

      No proof most of the people who survived RDR 2 died either. Charles and Sadie could still be alive.

    • @retrobat153
      @retrobat153 5 років тому +4

      @@maximaldinotrap I mean its heavily implied that pearson is still alive

    • @terminallumbago6465
      @terminallumbago6465 5 років тому +9

      I think it was just the fighting members that the Bureau was going after. At no point did Jack, Pearson, Tilly, Mary Beth, etc. actually fight in RDR2. Charles and Sadie could have easily been dead by that time too (considering their lifestyles and the time period itself), as there was a four-year gap between the end of RDR2 and the beginning of RDR1.

    • @SpinningTurtle66
      @SpinningTurtle66 5 років тому

      Jack, Charles, Sadie, Abigail, Tilly, Susan and all of the other girls in the gang survive.

    • @jorgeanta2912
      @jorgeanta2912 5 років тому +2

      Shadow Of Light not all the other girls apparently. In a letter Mary Beth said Karen drank herself to death moms grimshaw does dies as well

  • @LeSensuel
    @LeSensuel 5 років тому +47

    Holy crap, I had never noticed Nastas was voice by the same actor as Dutch! To be fair, it’s obvious now after having heard Dutch talk so much in RDR 2.

  • @inebriationconversation4526
    @inebriationconversation4526 5 років тому +272

    You cant sin the first game with the prequel, you just cant. Its like saying kingdom hearts 1 sucks because of the proceeding games

    • @steepsort6905
      @steepsort6905 5 років тому +26

      But if the story of the prequel leaves inconsistencies in the story of the original game, then it is a continuity error. Doesn't mean the game sucks though. Still a good game regardless.

    • @inebriationconversation4526
      @inebriationconversation4526 5 років тому +28

      @@steepsort6905 i hear what youre saying, but you have to look at a game in the time it came out. Red Dead Redemption is good or bad on its own merits and since this information wasnt available at release then thats basically making up fake issues. For instance
      In Kingdom Hearts 1, the keyblade is a special sword that can only be given to pure hearted warriors, but later games retconned that and made it so that theyre so common that you can find literally billions of them in later games. This isnt a plot hole for kingdom hearts 1, but for kingdom hearts birth by sleep.

    • @inebriationconversation4526
      @inebriationconversation4526 5 років тому +12

      More so, im upset that he's doing rdr but not rdr2

    • @inebriationconversation4526
      @inebriationconversation4526 5 років тому +7

      Even further, to reference the sequel as though we, the audience, have played it, also doesnt work well.
      But at the end of the day, it makes no difference to entertainment value

    • @maheruddinahmedalve1420
      @maheruddinahmedalve1420 5 років тому +2

      @@inebriationconversation4526 check the end. Hes doing rdr2

  • @flamingmonkey7712
    @flamingmonkey7712 4 роки тому +123

    20:20 You shouldn't sin RDR1 because the scene is contrary to RDR2. You should sin RDR2 for it because it's made later.

    • @privateerbouncher9622
      @privateerbouncher9622 3 роки тому +11

      Because lots of review UA-camrs doesn't have the brain to consider it.

    • @alle_6297
      @alle_6297 3 роки тому +7

      Yeah, and John had been a part of the Van Der Linde gang since he was a kid and Javier joined in 1895 so that's at least 4 years of bonding that could have happened before Red Dead Redemption 2

    • @themadtitan7603
      @themadtitan7603 3 роки тому +4

      @@alle_6297 RDR1 still implies they grew up together under Dutch when Javier only joined the gang in it's last 4 years. Now that's fault of RDR2's retconning RDR1's information not the former's.

    • @krmaryo
      @krmaryo 2 роки тому

      Well the entire squad of Arthur Bill John Javier And all other men was known as the sons of dutch, that was told in rdr2. Being a brother doesnt necessarily mean they had good relations.
      Hell even Micah called Arthur his brother, allthough both hated each other, micah said that they are brothers and brothers make mistakes, after you rescue him from strawberry.

    • @themadtitan7603
      @themadtitan7603 2 роки тому +1

      @@krmaryo But John says they all grew up together in RDR1, despite that only being true of Arthur as the rest of them only joined in the last five years of the gang.

  • @ericvcod2133
    @ericvcod2133 5 років тому +31

    To be fair regenarative health makes sense in a game where your character can't avoid taken damage, its random whether or not the enemy hits you in a open space, since the bullets are hit scan and there is no option of steath.
    If that wasn't the case the game would need a big amount of health kits every where (or make It unlimited)to not make it feel unfair.

  • @MrKickasskam
    @MrKickasskam 3 роки тому +51

    You’re wild. The mission where you save Bonnie was really good & the raid on Fort Mercer was amazing. The game was definitely good before you got to Mexico.

  • @jasminedragon3315
    @jasminedragon3315 5 років тому +43

    Seriously tho do u rly think they planned for a prequel? How is jack supposed to know the names of people that only appeared in a game that came out 8 years after this one?

    • @SithDestroyerVideoProductions
      @SithDestroyerVideoProductions 5 років тому +11

      The Proto The second game’s script was being written during production of the first game. The first draft was completed in 2012.
      EDIT: While Arthur and the rest weren’t named in the first game, they were thought up at the time.

    • @jasminedragon3315
      @jasminedragon3315 5 років тому +2

      Sith Destroyer I didn’t know that, I retract my comment

    • @957kakashi
      @957kakashi 5 років тому +3

      I mean even if you were right and they hadn’t thought of the prequel/sequel yet (I know it’s a pre but it’s a pre that came after) it still doesn’t make sense because you’d expect someone to know the names of their dads former outlaw gang years later if you were aware enough to still remember the others he didn’t mention. Like even in retcons or other sequel situations, it just always throws off the immersion or breaks the storytelling when new stuff is added later they don’t make characters aware of in previous entries when those events chronologically happen after said new details. I try to ignore it myself and I get that sometimes when building lore and this whole timeline / other world people have creativity that doesn’t let them think of everything in enough advance which creates this situation. But it’s still a valid argument that the creator or creators behind these works should try and plan it out earlier to address this stuff so it can be better or at least not break us out of the story when we know more. Like a simple mention of “you think I didn’t hear Dutch, bill, and Arthur tell those stories?” Like one or two names from the gang besides just the two we saw would be enough. If the rest weren’t thought of, that alone would be enough to say “okay maybe those are the ones jack remembers most” and not that he just neglects to mention anyone else besides the 2-3 we saw in this game out of the 20+ gang members.

    • @JuicyRedskin
      @JuicyRedskin 5 років тому +2

      @@jasminedragon3315 To easy to retract. Come on, he didn't even have a link to back his statement up.

  • @Canwehitsubscriberswitho-sr1id
    @Canwehitsubscriberswitho-sr1id 5 років тому +47

    20:21
    ..."John and Javier barely had any interactions"
    Using evidence from less than a year of john/Javiers time in the van der lin gang when they were both in it for about a decade. It is also specifically shown that Javier and John were friends during the first chapter if rdr2

  • @henrichvonruben9114
    @henrichvonruben9114 5 років тому +116

    There is so much wrong in this video.
    Sin 1: dude its 1911, a time period where you were more likely to die from getting shot by your bestfriend than die from smoking. 2nd its 2018 now and we have a ton of ignorant people now let's go back to 1911 where most people didn't even know how to read or write and you honestly expect most of them to know common sense? Hell 2018 now and people are still heavy smokers and we have, vapes, juuls, e-igarettes, and they say they're safe and whatnot and people still believe it.
    Sin 2: that's not a sin that's literally an opinion.
    Sin 3: valid for the most part.
    Sin 4: I doubt she's "just now coming home" since she would have mentioned her brothers deaths like Drew did. However your excuse "she isn't getting supplies because she isn't carrying any" my guy have you seen the trains back then? They had a specific car for cargo and luggage, for all we know her baggage was in another car. No proof either way about it.
    Sin 5: valid
    Sin 6: if you remember the next scene John is laying on the ground with Vultures ready to eat his corpse so the only reason he did survive was cause Bonnie found him in time.
    Sin 7: yes however you must have forgot Bill Williamson was the most wanted Bandit in the county, he had no reason to expect someone to come up to Fort Mercer or even willingly ride by and happen to pick up John thus saving his life.
    Sin 8: Valid
    Sin 9: no if John died the government would have no reason to hold Abigal and Jack hostage anymore. If John died they'd be free. Now you're probably thinking, "well they come to their house at the end to kill them" no they showed up to kill John, when John died they never went after Abigal or Jack.
    Sin 10: she means repay them for saving his life. "Hey I scratched your back now you scratch mine"
    Sin 11: game came out in 2010 neither gta5 or rdr2 have this so it is gone. Also most times there's always 3 or 4 available missions so if one isnt at the right time go do another
    Sin 12: valid
    Sin 13: for the most part valid, except 90% of everyone back then owned a gun so gun shops could raise their prices severely and people would still buy them to be safe.
    Sin 14: no the Marshal knows, the deputies don't. And yes that was stupid of John to say that
    Sin 15: valid
    Sin 16: seriously?
    Sin 17: ha
    Sin 18: a cowboy game that simulates being a cowboy. Better sin it for being accurate
    Sin 19: valid
    Sin 20: valid
    Sin 21: John does know the Government is a threat, the only reason he's doing any of this is cause they're holding his family hostage.
    Sin 22: except you have bounties, poker, blackjack, liars dice, horseshoes, hunting, target practice, five finger fillet, etc yeeeah the ONLY fun in the game is to kill people. You might wanna see help if that's your honest opinion.
    Sin 23: for the most part yes, but you do get a special horse for having very low honor
    Sin 24 and 25: valid
    Sin 26: valid
    Sin 27: valid
    Sin 28: valid for the most part
    Sin 29: valid.
    Sin 30: valid
    Sin 31: valid
    Sin 32: what?
    Sin 33: Valid
    Sin 34: except it is there it's behind the scene you show.
    Ding you didn't change the number: never seen that happen but I suppose that's valid.
    Sin 35: valid
    Sin 36: valid
    Sin 37: valid
    Sin 38: you mean that tonic that the whole game jokes around saying is fake, by a Snake Oil sales man lying about what it does thus, by proving that it doesn't work means he's a fraud because it didn't help John at all he was already that good which was why West Dickens wanted him to be the "random guy" he picked from the crowd cause he knew everyone else would believe it? Pretty sure that's a win there.
    Its 2am now I'm going to bed I'll finish the list when I wake up

  • @Maac32
    @Maac32 5 років тому +90

    “... In this time period where diseases like t u b e r c u l o s i s were common” R.I.P. I cry every time...

  • @MrBossley
    @MrBossley 4 роки тому +18

    1:59 wtf?
    Look at the guy in the window.

  • @fatman1730
    @fatman1730 5 років тому +272

    Half of these points are bull

    • @ThatOldSchoolMagic
      @ThatOldSchoolMagic 5 років тому +20

      Fat Man
      Seems like nothing but a bunch of Nitpickin

    • @kuhpunkt
      @kuhpunkt 5 років тому +22

      Just like CinemaSins.

    • @isaacmelendez2241
      @isaacmelendez2241 5 років тому +25

      Madara Senpai .-. You clearly don't pay attention then. He has never shied away from admitting that he nitpicks. I mean hell dude, it is literally the first thing in the description. If you don't like nitpicking, then don't watch the video.

    • @slooshgaming5669
      @slooshgaming5669 5 років тому +2

      Yup and the she'd he said wasn't there when you arrived is there... It's there for the whole game... and the point about fort Mercer being out of the Marshall jurisdiction despite Ridgewood farm being the same distance away is moot too because fort Mercer is in Rio bravo, another county and Ridgewood farm is still in Cholla springs. This dude has no clue what he's talking about.

    • @SpinningTurtle66
      @SpinningTurtle66 5 років тому +14

      He’s trying to be cinema sins, but he’s just not charming, entertaining, funny or imteresting

  • @smithwesson1896
    @smithwesson1896 5 років тому +92

    You never mentioned the Strange Man questline

    • @harryobyrne2806
      @harryobyrne2806 5 років тому +6

      Exactly

    • @spelareNR14
      @spelareNR14 4 роки тому +1

      Because it's not a part of the main story? It's a stranger questline?

    • @dragonmaster5106
      @dragonmaster5106 4 роки тому

      BTW, could the Strange Man be Arthur's ghost, considering he knows John, the things he did that John himself doesn't remember, and that he wasn't effected by the bullets. GHOST!

    • @cptfreeman8966
      @cptfreeman8966 3 роки тому +1

      Nils Elmquist that doesn’t mean it isn’t part of the main story. Literally the final mission of the game is a stranger quest

    • @spelareNR14
      @spelareNR14 3 роки тому +1

      @@cptfreeman8966 true, i sort of forgot it actually was a stranger mission. But the Strange Man questline isn't a part of the main questline. That's what I meant.

  • @PewPewBeets
    @PewPewBeets 4 роки тому +14

    About the honor system: there are a few things it does. 1. It affects the prices of store items. Low honor is expensive with the exception of Thieves' Landing where the worse you are the cheaper the items. And 2: you get a low honor specific horse that looks cool, but it's the slowest one in the game.

  • @emreustun1461
    @emreustun1461 5 років тому +157

    Will you ever make a video on Detroit: Become Human?
    And if yes, will it only show one playthrough or multiple?
    And do you ever want to make videos on the remaining BioShock games/DLC? I'd love to see you sin those games and hear your thoughts about the rest of the games

    • @VinceDPad
      @VinceDPad  5 років тому +71

      Been working on Detroit for months now. And yes, I will show multiple playthroughs to get the full context.
      Definitely getting around to those other Bioshock games.

    • @emreustun1461
      @emreustun1461 5 років тому +3

      @@VinceDPad awesome, I can't wait to see them. I'm mostly excited to see what you think of Infinite's story, Elizabeth & Booker and Detroit. I played both of them for the first time this year and love both of them to bits

    • @IamaPERSON
      @IamaPERSON 5 років тому +1

      @@VinceDPad I feel bad that you did Detroit, only because of how many routes and endings there are.

    • @emreustun1461
      @emreustun1461 5 років тому +2

      @@ccainum5971 Infinite truly is amazing. That ending blew my mind and feels away more than any other game has so far. The credits made it even more sad.

    • @Ch50304
      @Ch50304 5 років тому +1

      @@VinceDPad That is amazing. I look forwad to it.

  • @massiveoverlay
    @massiveoverlay 4 роки тому +18

    This dude mentioned TB in the start & it's killin"me

  • @ThatOldSchoolMagic
    @ThatOldSchoolMagic 5 років тому +21

    Sin #2 is Subjective as everyone thinks differently when things get interesting/Good. I personally believe it starts picking up as soon as you meet the Martial. Picks up even more once you take down fort Mercer and once you’ve got The ability to paint your targets with Deadeye in Mexico. You’ve pretty much got the rest of the game in the bag.

  • @princebrayyy4111
    @princebrayyy4111 4 роки тому +32

    A year later and I still can’t tell if this video is a joke or if he’s actually slamming the game 😐

  • @Cheddarhead7
    @Cheddarhead7 5 років тому +155

    'Doesn't get good until the Mexico section'
    The Mexico section is literally the worst bit m8

    • @okami7847
      @okami7847 5 років тому +40

      I loved the Mexico section however I did enjoy the beginning of the game more.

    • @deezooliveros2978
      @deezooliveros2978 5 років тому +1

      A lot of people really enjoyed exploring Mexico

    • @justinbayless8284
      @justinbayless8284 5 років тому +13

      Yeah, other than seeing older Javier Escuela, Mexico was pretty boring

    • @cannibalbunnygirl
      @cannibalbunnygirl 5 років тому

      Yes. That was exactly what I said

    • @detrogamus2619
      @detrogamus2619 5 років тому +4

      Just like guarma.

  • @Exmotable
    @Exmotable 5 років тому +128

    overrated is just a buzzword for "thing i don't like as much as everyone else"
    why is being unable to t-bag effectively a sin

    • @starshape6650
      @starshape6650 5 років тому +35

      Not really. There are things people praise more than they are worth. For example this, FF7 and GTA 5 (there are people who treat those games like they are the second coming of Chirst).
      Also the t-bag sin is a joke.

    • @aylmaoxdxddd5687
      @aylmaoxdxddd5687 5 років тому +8

      Dev, it's a dumb joke like the apple one and "scene does not contain lap dance"

    • @BoleDaPole
      @BoleDaPole 5 років тому +12

      This whole series is built upon the nitpicking of games.

    • @copiumhsrgi
      @copiumhsrgi 5 років тому +4

      Because it's a joke.

    • @arthuralmeida.g8511
      @arthuralmeida.g8511 5 років тому +4

      @@copiumhsrgi not so much, he says it's a overrated game,no joke intended.

  • @bi0hazard921
    @bi0hazard921 5 років тому +136

    Cant wait till the release undead nightmare 2

    • @jaybrielrosales9191
      @jaybrielrosales9191 5 років тому +5

      Here's to hoping

    • @enshine5445
      @enshine5445 5 років тому +1

      Same

    • @kieranmcccccc995
      @kieranmcccccc995 5 років тому +6

      Autismo I’m not saying it is certain, but if they don’t it would be an insanely stupid decision, that shit is a gold mine

    • @nicholasvandergeest7808
      @nicholasvandergeest7808 5 років тому +1

      They are going a different direction
      Adding in more online modes and a side arc sorry to burst your bubble.

    • @thatlemonguy1107
      @thatlemonguy1107 5 років тому

      I hope it doesn’t come out, to be perfectly honest.

  • @Mr-Geist-Bong
    @Mr-Geist-Bong 5 років тому +34

    I wish people would put spoiler warnings up for games that are mentioned because i just had some rdr2 moments spoiled for me

    • @trialbyfire4763
      @trialbyfire4763 5 років тому +10

      How?
      Edit: Never mind. He did spoil RDR2; a lot.

    • @antheunis011
      @antheunis011 5 років тому +1

      Poor baby.

    • @Irreverententity
      @Irreverententity 5 років тому +7

      Thank god I decided to read some of the comments before watching. You just saved me from some spoilers so thanks.

    • @nicholasvandergeest7808
      @nicholasvandergeest7808 5 років тому +1

      Awwwww is the little liberal spoiled does he want his bink bink and a nap nap.

    • @josejimenez731
      @josejimenez731 5 років тому +4

      I mean you guys should know, if it’s a video about everything wrong with the game, it’s gonna show spoilers.

  • @Faidos
    @Faidos 5 років тому +397

    Who clicked so fast to watch this?

  • @BigMac87963
    @BigMac87963 5 років тому +28

    Looking forward to Everything Wrong with Red Dead Revolver 3

  • @large_n_widetm2116
    @large_n_widetm2116 5 років тому +39

    Wow you uploaded

  • @Turkce_Oyun
    @Turkce_Oyun 5 років тому +107

    I can't wait to watch your Mortal Kombat 11 sins video!

    • @IamaPERSON
      @IamaPERSON 5 років тому

      @@Grandmastergav86 bonus sins every second that song plays, and double everytime I can't understand what he's saying (idc if that's the point of mumble rap, if I wanna sing along to a song, I wanna hear the lyrics)

    • @fckedupshit8428
      @fckedupshit8428 5 років тому

      Same

    • @rainwater1770
      @rainwater1770 5 років тому +2

      @@Grandmastergav86 21 Savage isn't even Mumble rap you can understand everything he's saying. it's just that it's in the background so you don't hear that clearly or you just choose not to listen

    • @TheMilkMan905
      @TheMilkMan905 5 років тому

      Lml what a nice 2 years

    • @vadci.
      @vadci. 5 років тому +1

      @@rainwater1770 wrooong, fake news- Donald Trump

  • @Pidgeadin
    @Pidgeadin 3 роки тому +2

    12:37 if you try and cross the bridges before the Irish raft mission, they’re “under construction” and you can’t get across. I know because I’ve played this game multiple times and tried to cheat my way to Mexico

  • @bekleedee
    @bekleedee 3 роки тому +4

    RDR1- Nigel West Dickens- WE NEED MONEY!
    RDR2- Dutch Van Der Linde- WE NEED MONEY!!!

  • @themetalone7739
    @themetalone7739 5 років тому +8

    "One could say, Red Dead...nah, fuck that. I'm not making that joke."
    Now THAT was fuckin' funny.

  • @nybxcrotona
    @nybxcrotona 5 років тому +2

    Y'know, looking at your videos makes me enjoy the differences between your style of sins and Dartigan's. Keep up the good work.

  • @cloudman5788
    @cloudman5788 5 років тому +11

    Want to see GCN sinning the Dishonored series.

  • @YChromosome99
    @YChromosome99 5 років тому +13

    18:51- 19:08 😂 I couldn't breathe!! That's what made the game SO MUCH FUN!!! At least it wasn't a "game over".

  • @frankwest8869
    @frankwest8869 5 років тому +8

    0:30 did he literally sin the game cause he doesn’t personally enjoy it?

  • @Ian_Paneque
    @Ian_Paneque 3 роки тому +2

    01:59 So no one noticed the floating dude outside the train? Just me?

  • @calpone6399
    @calpone6399 5 років тому +20

    Plus Hosea, Tilly, Mary-Beth, Sean, Lenny, Susan, Pearson, Uncle, Abigail, Jack and even Javier. All of these people would not want John dead so Bills statement is invalid.

    • @FranklinXVI
      @FranklinXVI 5 років тому +1

      Prequel effect

    • @iamslightlybetterthanyou2679
      @iamslightlybetterthanyou2679 5 років тому

      How I explain is maybe he is just so drunk he forgets all the events in rdr2

    • @IamaPERSON
      @IamaPERSON 5 років тому +3

      So that's like most of the gang, right?

    • @calpone6399
      @calpone6399 5 років тому +2

      Yep most of the gang

    • @garrysmith1029
      @garrysmith1029 4 роки тому

      I think Bill was talking about the men like Michah and Dutch and Michah's friends after the other people died the wanted him to die because they though he was the rat.

  • @Doctor_snw
    @Doctor_snw 4 роки тому +4

    11:44 John can't swim that's why he died. And I'm actually being serious he actually can't swim

  • @sabmu757
    @sabmu757 5 років тому +68

    Red dead redemption isn't overrated, I actually prefer it to the sequel.

    • @MrFusion
      @MrFusion 5 років тому +12

      I like both games equally, even though they both have faults. John does some really stupid things in the first game, and there are some weird plot moments. The second game has some spotty controls that are inconsistent, and I wish Arthur had a more concrete personality, instead of sometimes a good gu, sometimes a bad guy.

    • @ThatOldSchoolMagic
      @ThatOldSchoolMagic 5 років тому +7

      daniel Shah
      I considered RDR1 to be a Masterpiece and RDR2 the Somewhat Flawed Masterpiece.
      I have my reasons why i believe this. Such as some control issues, some mechanics not being explained correctly or early enough in the game and some areas could have been polished a bit more but for the most part its only about 5% that I believe is flawed to the game. Nothing big.

    • @justinbayless8284
      @justinbayless8284 5 років тому +3

      I like rdr2 more. Only because ive been having a lot of problems with the first game recently. And 2 is a prequel

    • @justinbayless8284
      @justinbayless8284 5 років тому +1

      Not a sequel

    • @Game-Now
      @Game-Now 5 років тому +1

      I prefer Red Dead Revolver.

  • @suryagading4568
    @suryagading4568 5 років тому +35

    You uploaded a video huh... Finally!

    • @PoorEdward
      @PoorEdward 5 років тому +2

      Yeah who can't wait for some degenerate making shit content for sheep to eat up! Yum!

    • @gerard22
      @gerard22 4 роки тому

      Don't Reply why are you here then

  • @RyucioFade
    @RyucioFade 5 років тому +2

    Before you pointed it out, I thought Nastas was Dutch for a second. 23:40

  • @1985toyotacamry
    @1985toyotacamry 5 років тому +23

    I'm glad you are back

    • @inebriationconversation4526
      @inebriationconversation4526 5 років тому +2

      Id say this is more like "dad forgot his wallet on the way to get cigarettes"

    • @8ballmoe
      @8ballmoe 5 років тому +2

      MERTIMER WESLEY
      Is that the best you can do?

  • @Crazelord91
    @Crazelord91 5 років тому +38

    I feel compelled to say this on every "sins" type video: To everyone who is actually triggered by this, please lighten up. It's a joke. These aren't meant to be highly regarded critical analysis; It's basically pretensious shit posting.

    • @blackraptormoses6838
      @blackraptormoses6838 4 роки тому +8

      But it isn't funny.

    • @UkiWarBoy
      @UkiWarBoy 4 роки тому +11

      You can't pretend to be shitposting and acting high and mighty at the same time, gaming sins is just bad content

  • @sawyerhackett5997
    @sawyerhackett5997 3 роки тому +1

    Little detail in rdr2 when doing a bounty with Sadie a bear comes and attacks you but it gets away and that is the bear that attacks Jack in rdr

  • @RIPObamacare
    @RIPObamacare 5 років тому +11

    You should've put spoiler warning for RDR2 at the beginning. Spoiled the epilogue for me and there were other big spoilers in there as well.

    • @fallenwolf3368
      @fallenwolf3368 5 років тому

      You shouldn't even have watched the video. You can tell that your new to his channel. Because I already know if he does a game and if there is a sequel you can bet a dollar he will mention something about it in the video.

    • @onefortunateson6345
      @onefortunateson6345 5 років тому +2

      FAllEn OnE Okay that doesn’t Change The fact that he’s still didn’t give a warning and is thus an asshole

  • @JayHog1992
    @JayHog1992 5 років тому +6

    27:13 This segment made me laugh and cry.

  • @wyatth4866
    @wyatth4866 5 років тому +4

    6:43 As for honor level, you get paid more on bounties with high honor and get the Duster’s Coat. With low honor, you pay lower prices at Thieves Landing, and get the Dark Horse.

  • @jimpickens4983
    @jimpickens4983 3 роки тому +1

    the thing with honor: you can get the duster coat and you can even when your in max honor you get a necklace that decreases the chance of being hit by enemies

  • @austinrose1960
    @austinrose1960 3 роки тому +2

    21:30
    Bill is not referring to Sadie, Charles or Arthur as wanting John dead. When he said we all wanted you dead he is referring to Micah, Micah's butt buddies, Dutch, Bill and Javier. Dutch wanted John dead because he thought he was a traitor for doubting him.

  • @cagkiller0786
    @cagkiller0786 5 років тому +3

    24:50 there’s always law enforcement everywhere. They only show up on the map when someone does a crime.

  • @dkincorporated3060
    @dkincorporated3060 2 роки тому +3

    i cant be the only one who saw that floating man at 1:58

    • @VictorLdVS
      @VictorLdVS 2 роки тому

      Finally someone says it

  • @Titan-db3yk
    @Titan-db3yk 5 років тому +2

    Yay another video! I'd be so happy if you guys made a The Evil Within gaming sins, please

  • @jmw9904
    @jmw9904 4 роки тому +1

    On stopping the train, it's interesting that even if you stop the train way before the bridge, it still goes to that cut scene.

  • @Anonymous-xt8zu
    @Anonymous-xt8zu 5 років тому +17

    No you didn't just sin it

    • @trethestar
      @trethestar 5 років тому +4

      He did.The Fuck you gonna do about it?

  • @hydrazzz9047
    @hydrazzz9047 4 роки тому +3

    Also in Red Dead Redemption 2 when you complete American Venom You get $20,000 but in like the first mission just a couple years later in Red Dead Redemption John cannot pay Bonnie $15

    • @Thatguy-ki3po
      @Thatguy-ki3po 3 роки тому +2

      Well, at least my John spent ALL that money😂

    • @franciszekklintonowski
      @franciszekklintonowski 3 місяці тому

      I was also wondering,and what happened to my horse that I had from the beginning to the end of the epilogue

  • @BadJuJu93
    @BadJuJu93 3 роки тому +2

    For sin 50, the elixir didn't actually work. John just has that ability and they were making the customers think they would be able to do they too

  • @Jake_Tucker
    @Jake_Tucker 5 років тому

    As always, this video gave me a good laugh.
    One minor nitpick that I don't think anyone else commented on, the sentence is "Hang 'em High", but you used the dialogue from "Unforgiven".

  • @sakersami1783
    @sakersami1783 5 років тому +8

    Took me eight goddamn years to realize that " first American woman to ever be friendzoned" thing, you sir are certainly what we call a genius

  • @milkcurator3127
    @milkcurator3127 5 років тому +5

    Literally in the 80s they thought smoking was good for you lol

  • @zerstorungform
    @zerstorungform 5 років тому

    God I missed that voice so much. Awesome video and keep the fun going.

  • @Sam-256
    @Sam-256 4 роки тому +1

    10:46 you may not have met Irish at that point but west Dickens still brought him up and told you about him a few missions before hand

  • @Q19484
    @Q19484 5 років тому +3

    Gcn can you do an old one for me the entire sly Cooper games plz love your channel.(and you should upload more)

  • @theheromans
    @theheromans 5 років тому +5

    "It's over John! I have the high ground!"

  • @bobbyserrano3872
    @bobbyserrano3872 4 роки тому +2

    Actually the instant death when falling into water started in gta 3 and vice city

  • @nutbuttersammich
    @nutbuttersammich 5 років тому +1

    Also in the epilogue you can roam New Austin as you like, even clearing out Fort Mercer while in RDR1 he needs Jake (the guide from Armadillo) to even find the seemingly unknown place lmao

  • @dgjedi3
    @dgjedi3 5 років тому +7

    I need more GCN videos in my life!!!

  • @aliciaxdiaries
    @aliciaxdiaries 3 роки тому +3

    12:37 if u try to go across the bridge early, there are workers still building on it, the same for Blackwater, but Blackwater's is stupid because u can easily cross the lake near McFarlane's ranch but when ur not allowed to go over there yet, u just die when u cross (like it shows u falling through the water) even tho the lake is VERY shallow XD
    Plus 1 sin

    • @mrsspiritwolf
      @mrsspiritwolf Рік тому

      @xXsmitten_KittenXx i always got to blackwater early, there is a spot you can stand on near the waterfall at bonnies ranch that says tall trees, commit a crime, get seen and wait for the law to chase you, ride to said spot dismount and surrender and you end up in blackwater jail, when they let you out you can explore everywhere.

  • @loganeversolr1488
    @loganeversolr1488 4 роки тому +1

    Actually they kept pushing the health benefits of smoking all the way up to the 1950's

  • @PewPewBeets
    @PewPewBeets 5 років тому +2

    I'm guessing Box Canyon was the original name for Pike's Basin and was changed after Rockstar did the voices.

  • @DS-xr6cr
    @DS-xr6cr 5 років тому +7

    Finally. And btw are you going to sin the walking dead final season?

  • @ComicWriter-ml3qt
    @ComicWriter-ml3qt 5 років тому +3

    Nice to see someone finally make an everything wrong with for this game. It’s one of my favorites.

  • @ucchientran4620
    @ucchientran4620 5 років тому +2

    Did u guy actually wait after the release of RDR2 to post this video?
    I'm actually impressed!!

  • @flamingmonkey7712
    @flamingmonkey7712 4 роки тому +1

    I think John said "Damn you Dutch". And he means he don't want to fight or kill any of the natives, but he blames Dutch for using them against him and the agents so he has to do this.

  • @leescomics8075
    @leescomics8075 5 років тому +3

    Hey gcn what did you think of red dead redemption 2?

  • @AlexLee-dc2vb
    @AlexLee-dc2vb 5 років тому +7

    I remember going all out during that crow level with a 22 shot repeater

  • @Fitzftw7
    @Fitzftw7 3 роки тому +1

    I can’t find the RDR 2 video. Did it get taken down, or did he never make it?

  • @spookubus
    @spookubus 3 роки тому

    12:36 the bridges leading into mexico are all either blocked off or broken until after you reach Mexico

  • @Arclightning
    @Arclightning 5 років тому +3

    i knew there would be an Unlimited Ammo sin, that always makes me laugh

  • @Q19484
    @Q19484 5 років тому +3

    I've waited too long for this

  • @dragosstoica8682
    @dragosstoica8682 5 років тому

    Good to have you back :) I was a little worried about what happened to you in the last monts ?

  • @Pidgeadin
    @Pidgeadin 3 роки тому +1

    27:28 anyone else notice that Dutch said “you can’t fight nature, you can’t fight change, you can’t fight.. gravity” and he said that in red dead 2 when he and Arthur jumped off the cliff to escape the army

  • @LEBRONJAMESVICKERS
    @LEBRONJAMESVICKERS 5 років тому +27

    Where you been man? Lol I missed you 😭.....

  • @real_airgot
    @real_airgot 4 роки тому +3

    GamingSins makes a Red Dead Redemption video.
    Me: Look at how they massacred my boy.

  • @wolfo9322
    @wolfo9322 3 роки тому

    25:02 always makes me laugh bc of the way Mr Davis delivered that line 😂 he lowkey sounds like Dr Phil

  • @Lyra_87
    @Lyra_87 2 роки тому +1

    The only issue to be had with this is that there was never the RDR2 sins video : (

  • @FrostTheHobidon
    @FrostTheHobidon 5 років тому +3

    What took you so long

  • @djkori5521
    @djkori5521 5 років тому +5

    I'll let your opinion on the ending slide because opinions but it just makes me feel like you weren't paying attention. I mean hey decent video still despite some easily checkable sins and like brief plot confusion you experienced. Not all things are pretty though so make up for it in the next one. Oh definitely should have "*" spoilers because you included some spoilers from red dead 2 m8 good day ✌️
    Edit: I just offered the spoiler thing because people are complaining honestly I don't care

  • @eugenewilliamson6267
    @eugenewilliamson6267 5 років тому

    Can you please answer my question what is the relation between Caiman Care Network in the gaming scenes Channel there is quite two of them and they were on this channel before what happened I have been wondering for a whole year now

  • @popcornegg4405
    @popcornegg4405 5 років тому +2

    1:58 hey, you missed a guy floating in the background through one of the windows.