@@Trial-watcher2023 for sure! Lots of kids needing mental health assistance and killing their parents, going to schools and shooting kids or making threats. The kids need some serious help! Hope everyone is adulting!
9/17/14 Imo, she should be charged as any other teen shooter who has taken a life and attempt to take a life! Premeditated, thinking clear had time to stop, not call friend text stepdad!! Idc, how young she looks or dressing. Cameras inside home, troubling. She goes into mental health hospital, can manipulate the Dr’s. Murder 1st
HOW DOES THIS P.O.S. AFFORD A DEFENSE TEAM? WITHOUT A J O B? Step- Dad (victim) is definitely Not going to pay for it. Pro - Bono?!?! Did you see Carly slice the pie and turn the corner of the Kitchen entrance, before her cold - blooded Murder, or execution...!!!!!!!!!!
I wish your female panelist would stop being accusatory toward the stepdad when there is absolutely no evidence that he sexually abused her. That is unfair and unprofessional in my opinion!
It's unprofessional and inappropriate to suggest the stepfather may have been sexually abusing her when the defense itself hasn't even raised that idea. Shame on you! This is the definition of defamation by reckless disregard for the facts.
Exactly! To be fair, it's only that female psycho expert's the one who's been pushing her narrative about SA. If that's really the case, it could have been laid out from the start. Her irresponsible words already built some people's mind as shown on the latest VPI episode's comment section. Some people now were convince it's already a fact & assumed the stepdad have a romantic relationship with the child suspect. Even their exchange of smiles were so negatively analyzed, more their daily communication.
all that guys going through....and now this freakin dingbat with the what ever she can come up with theories....and when 1 out the many hits , she'll claim to have been right all along .......!!
if you work with kids you would most likely have that in the back of your mind , something is not right such anger towards the mother ,,,, and that smirk between the step father and her , very fishy
An apology needs to be made to the stepfather. He is a victim! To speculate about SA with zero evidence makes Court TV a lot less credible. Fix it, Vinnie. When your guest makes wild, unfounded accusations, you need to remind the audience of the truth. Starting rumors is not the sign of reliable news reporting.
For that lady to even suggest sexual abuse with absolutely zero evidence is completely abhorrent & quite frankly unethical. In my book she lost any & all credibility.
She didn’t actually accuse anyone of assault. Vinnie asked her opinion and she gave it. She merely gave examples of what could have happened. She did nothing wrong. So many ❄️’s
AMEN. That REALLY pisses me off. She’s a cold blooded killer, despite her Little Bo Peep outfit. May she rot in prison for the rest of her miserable life. PS I’m glad to know you…another person who just ain’t fallin’ for the bull sh$t.
@@JimmyMac717 maybe she would have chosen to stab her mother instead?Better chance of surviving a stab wound than two shots to the face, wouldn’t you say….?
No, Carly was in her own bedroom, when Carly shot her mother 3 times, in cold blood. Three shots to her mother’s face She shot her mother in Carly’s bedroom. Her mother was going through Carly’s personal items and removing some of them. That made Carly angry and that’s what Carly’s motive was. She retrieved the gun from her mother’s bedroom. The friend stays there and actually waits for the stepfather to arrive, so Carly can kill him too. So bizarre. I don’t understand where these kids come from. It’s pure evil. They both knew exactly what was happening. There’s no insanity here. That’s crap.
@@updownstate You’re misunderstanding. I don’t believe I said that, anywhere in my comments. Why would the friend need to be there? Carly shot her mother 3 times in the face, and killed her, without her friend. Lol!! My point was, the friend stayed there and waited for Carly to ambush the father, with the knowledge of what was to happen. The friend should’ve went to a neighbor to call police, after she witnessed the mother’s bullet ridden dead body . The man could’ve easily been unalived, like her mother. He was lucky, Carly wasn’t the best shot.
She has that tell-tale psychopathic facial expression. It's strange affect that's hard to describe but easy to read.There's always this weird combination of 'dead' or challenging eyes alongside a slight smirk, as though the person finds the world of other people both inferior/contemptible and amusing.
@@MomMom-ys1oc like seriously I am 56 I would be scared AF to share a cell with her. She gives me the creeps like that Clarie Miller that killed her disabled sister they are demons.
I think accusing the stepdad of sexual abuse by Dr is outragust.This is a serious accusation when they're is no proof.Being smart doesn't mean you have no problems.This Dr is pissing me off.
💯. It’s entirely possible she was born evil . Nature or nurture ? Showing the dead mother to her friend speaks volumes . No one likes to hear it, but she could just be outright evil .
I dont think I'll watch if Dr whats her face is on again. I think the fact she doesn't know better than to throw baseless accusations around makes her some one with nothing to say I want to hear. Very disappointed in court tv. When did court tv become The National Enquirer?
Just because someone is smart doesn't mean they aren't mean spirited. She told kids she was going to kill her mom and she did it. I don't understand why the lady says the stepfather was the demon he was innocent and for this lady to insinuate she is the type of person who would accuse an innocent man and have him put behind bars. This is an evil little girl, she thinks because she's a teen she will get away with it and be allowed to go back to school. The fact that she called her friend over to see the dead body and said "I told you I was gonna do it" let's me know she wanted to do this for fame. This is horrible. She doesn't need to be around other kids.
her absolute lack of stress arousal, singing to the dog, tricking the stepfather to come home, call and get a friend over etc. is psychopathic display and that together with smiling in court shows a smart individual as described that understands mentally but are careless about consequences, and smiling when others would be anxious or remorseful. The enjoyment here is very psychopathy, and contrary to normal people. Most interesting would be what she says herself about this, in initial interrogations.
My ex was a psychopath (she told me this, though I pretended I didn't hear her. She was a Law abiding version, as far as I know). We were involved in a car crash on vacation, car was badly damaged by another car that crashed into us, but we were OK. It was a shock for me but it was like chipping a nail for her, absolutely not bothered, appart from annoyed her car was damaged. The other driver was in a deep state of shock, kept apologising in a loop for 20-30 minutes. While he did that, my gf got him to admit it was entirely his fault to her insurance (he wasn't capable of rational thought), organised a tow truck and got us free bus ticket home (she wanted a rental car but the insurance company didn't emmidiatly provide one, she did try though). And as our broken car was getting dragged onto the tow truck and we were departing to the bus station with our luggage, Mr apologising in a loop snapped out of his state of shock, and said "I think I have to ring my insurance". I knew this moment was illustrating the stark difference between a psychopath and a "normal". She dumped my after the vacation, was bored with me by then.
She absolutely wants to be famous. She rejected the plea deal. She wants the trial to be famous and to relive the murder again and again. She's a psychopath.
this comment needs to be pinned at the top and this is why 90% of kids are shooting people hell eve adults this is all for fam and fortune i said to my wife that this reminds me of that one killer that gypsy one all for the media and we need to stop making this all over the screens and try to leave it as low profile as possible
She may have psychopathic tendencies, maybe enhanced by the meds she took. I'm no criminal, but I think I wouldn't have accepted the plea either. 40 years of your best years is a long time.
“Why didn’t the friend call 911?” Seriously? The girl just walked into a murder scene and saw her friend’s - the killer’s - mothers dead body after she was shot and killed…how are you even asking this question? She was in shock! Who WOULDNT be??
@@MyDestinyDear I would be terrified of that demon, shocked out of her mind to say the least. She and father did call I just don't no when exactly. I 100% would have called ASAP when I got out of that house. It makes you wonder why so eger to show friend did she Dare Her is she afraid she will get in trouble??? There is alot to uncover.
How irresponsible to say the step father was sexually assaulting her without any evidence to that. This lady needs to be sued for defamation of character and her license revoked
Strongly agree! It’s irresponsible to be so quick to make such a terrible suggestion that might have the potential to ruin someone’s life. I know it’s a possibility, but without any evidence pointing to that it’s incredibly dangerous.
HOW SAD. Her mom genuinely looks like she'd be the kindest and sweetest lady ever. 🥺💔 This young woman is going to have an awaking someday when she's older and will be utterly shattered by what she has done to her own loving mom. I can't imagine having to live with that level of mental torment for the rest of my days on earth.
@@jogordon1530 as a 56 year old with wisdom finally. I do not trust Doctors my hand to God. I know people that died in their care. They always what to put screws and bolts in your body. They Famous words it was the way you fell. Every heart attack you get a Stent 95% of the time. Everybody gets cancer I call BS !!!!!!!!!!! I trust my trash collectors more then them !!!!!!
You gotta love it how the doctor don’t want the blame on the meds but she don’t mind the blame on the victims, I guess only the killer knows the truth.
I might consider the connection between the medication & what she did, but the problem with that is she's been telling people she was going to kill her mom before she switched medication.
@@lori679 I know she clearly premeditated the murder of both parents she was just waiting for the right excuse to do it since they think the mother grounded her and was looking for something in her room when she went get the gun from the parent bedroom. I think she was gonna take the vape pen from her.
Why would the forensic psychiatrist put that narrative out there that the stepfather could have been sexually abusing Carly, and that could be the reason for her shooting him and her mother?!? I think that is very irresponsible of her to even speculate about that when there isn’t any evidence of that. This man was almost murdered. His wife WAS murdered, and now this woman has put out into the universe that he may have been sexually abusing his stepdaughter?!
I think she was shocked when she shot & missed her step dad, lost her confidence & bolted. When she killed her mom it emboldened her enough to drag her friend into it & enjoyed showing her mom's dead body but it wasn't so quick & easy the 2nd time. For all we know she planned on setting up her friend to take the blame. She was able to excel in school, student of the year, etc. & is probably a next level psychopath. Her body language is unsettling, apparently posing for the camera & in all her court appearances she listens intently to everything word being said. Calculating.
Agree. At least she listened and paid attention in court unlike Amber Turd who as a grown woman and Mother, doodled, wrote, ignored witnesses’ testimonies while court was in session the entire elongated trial. 😅 I think Carly should’ve gotten life with parole or sent to a mental institution. Killing her Mom wasn’t the right choice due to not getting her way, self entitled, calculated, and rebellious but ultimately her parents should’ve locked all guns in the house and kept ammo stored separately. Too many kids getting a hold of their parents’ weapons with deadly consequences.
Am I the only one here asking “how did she have access to a gun?” In what sane mind do you have a gun sitting around with a kid with mental health problems in the house?!?!?!
@@fannygo6673 I understand the concern & yes I agree guns shouldnt be easily accessible but I grew up in the same county this happened in & im just saying no one around here takes gun safety serious.
There is a very evil vibes I'm getting from this young lady , she cry's but then can stop in a instant !! I love children but this child I just can't even find myself to feel badly for her , There was a precious , innocent good life taken away from a mother that lived her and this is what she does for that love , Really !
How can the doctor suggest the stepfather sexually abused the girl? You really have to be cautious accusing somebody. Very unprofessional. It doesn't surprise me the girl said something like that. It doesn't make it true.
I have so much to say about this. The issue isn't the medication she was taking, but rather the condition it was prescribed to treat in the first place. Studies have examined the potential link between aggressive behavior and Lexapro, and the worst they found was that, in extremely rare cases, it might cause irritability. It doesn’t make someone pick up a gun, shoot a parent, and put the body on display to show your friends. Violent behaviour is much more likely to be tied to untreated or poorly managed mental health conditions than to the medications prescribed to treat them. And lastly, being intelligent and having a high IQ doesn’t make someone a redeemable member of society. She might be able to solve algebra equations faster than the average kid but that doesn’t mean she can go out and be a socially responsible, empathetic adult with the necessary social skills to not harm others. Thank you for coming to my Ted Talk.
Are you aware that psychiatric drugs have a higher risk of causing ending their life or others? These medications can have significantly adverse consequences and they keep giving them to teens … very dangerous.
@@NadineDelange-dx8ol I can't believe that Vinnie (or anyone) would bring up her so called intelligence like it was some kind of moral prerequisite. Vinnie & company are forgetting that there is a fine line between genius & mad(wo)man. Plenty of examples throughout history.
They are trying to make her look like a school girl. It's disgusting, she did the crime and needs to do the time. Maximum sentence, no mercy, no excuse. Children don't dress like that .
As soon as I heard she was on Lexapro at 13 yos it stopped me in my tracks. I tried Lexapro at 29 for anxiety/depression and it turned me into a psycho. I was insanely irritable, angry and unreasonable at all times. Like little things would make my blood boil. Can't imagine what that would be like at 13, when you don't understand that these feelings are temporary and things get better once you stop taking the meds. She could also just be a sociopath but that's my opinion on Lexapro 🤷🏼♀️
This show is run like a cheap expose, like a tabloid show. Didn't care for the forensic psychiatrist supposing maybe the stepfather was abusing the girl.when there was no evidence of that. Not professional at all.
They treat her just like they treat everyone else that has committed the crimes she did!! She's smart enough to know what she did and seems to have enjoyed it to this day...life with no parole
If they start blaming this on medication or supposed child abuse.... There's going to be a whole lot of bad happening everywhere. You learn from day one not to mess with guns she was very aware of what she was doing!
Remember she's a very smart girl that knows exactly what to say like she's hearing voices in jail I'll bet she never was hearing voices before she was in jail
44 minutes of drivel, speculation and unsubstantiated accusations. Presenter and guests think they're way more intelligent and important than they are. Don't waste your time.
I'm so thankful that my life didn't go in that direction. My parents were alcoholics & I gew up neglected in a home with DV. At 15 I wanted to get away from my parents but I never thought about k*lling them. My parents didn't get along, either & I always wanted them to get a divorce instead of slugging it out every weekend after getting drunk.
@ SweetUniverse~ I am so sorry that you went through that as a child. I think that you saying that you never thought about killing your parents is exactly what needs to be said because clearly not every abused child kills their parents. I hope your parents are good ones to you now ❤
17:50 Carly's friend... I realize she's technically a minor but, she's 15 y/o and old enough to have common sense. The court should order a Psych Eval (friend): She SAW the Mom AND KNEW Carly was waiting to kill her stepfather. She waited outside (20 mins) then heard multiple gunshots... She NEVER called 911 !?! That's not reasonable behavior. Mind boggling and scary😞 Was it medication induced? Was her Doc actively making medication changes?
Having Mrs. Lieberman on is just irresponsible at this point. Court TV needs to take a step back and analyze their content instead of being so quick to put out media.
That’s therapist is so annoying OMG ! That little girl is a psychopath and her friend should be charged as well for being complicit! She planned this out and the friend told nobody to stop that tells me , she was in on it and probably encouraged it ! I can’t stand watching some of these people on this channel
Yes, and in teenagers, suicide and homicide is also a symptom. Even more, if a teenager is prescribed a different antidepressant, these too can cause horrendous symptoms. That is why a doctor's care is paramount as well as the parents. Parents controlling the administration of the medication can help as well.
I came to bring this issue up! In teenagers the risk of self life ending or others is a BIG risk with psychological medications. A much bigger risk than with adults. Suddenly stopping will cause severe reactions- worse than before the person had before the medication.
@@louisewright8769I’m not sure about other states but where I live, doctors are permitted to prescribe antidepressants to kids without parental consent or knowledge. They will also arrange transportation to appointments. So…
Suggesting the step dad was sexually abusing her is kinda lame. Sounds like shes a spoiled brat , whos mom was trying to dicipline her and she went phycho.
What emergency could a schoolmate have that a parent would drive their child and drop them off without questions. And why did said child and her parent not report anything until later?
I mean you’re assuming the kid told the parent the truth. Maybe she just lied and said her friend needed help on a school project. Then when news hit of the murder the parent presses the kid on the truth.
@@shaun5047 no, I was following what I guess was the child’s statement. There was no mention of the parent’s statement.: nothing that said the dad contradicted the”emergency” story. As a parent, though, I’m going to say her behavior when she got home was not “normal.” Perhaps that is why they finally went to the police
Fancy Carol lederman saying the stepfather was up to something with her Why would you šay he is the Demon, when there's no proof What a terrible thing to put out there
She didn't say he was abusing her. She raised it as a possibility along with a couple of other named possibilities, and unarmed possibilities. I imagine any health professionals would also consider those possibilities, but whether they would verbalise them to the media is another question
I wish I had received SSRIs as a kid. Would have helped a lot. The issue is giving pills without the proper therapeutic care. Especially in kids and young adults, those meds can have different side effects than it has in adults.
The Lexapro very well could be the issue. If she has bipolar disorder, prescribing an SSRI like Lexapro could have set her off and pushed an already troubled kid over the edge. She still murdered her mother. There is no evidence her step father abused her, and this Dr is very irresponsible for alleging that.
Exactly! And it is irresponsible of the judge & defense not to have her mentally evaluated!ost anti depressants have homicidal thoughts for teens on the label!! She is best student in the whole school! Lexapro did it
So true, especially since she's on a high dose of Abilify now and is apparently doing much better. An anti psychotic leading to an improvement in mental health is a pretty clear sign she actually is dealing with a severe mental illness.
A different kind of evil. An absence of empathy. This kid is twisted, flip city. But not insane. She may be only 15, but she will kill again to get her way.
Right?? Her friend should be charged for not immediately telling her dad or calling 911. The friend knew she was about to shoot her step dad and she did nothing and just waited.. friend sounds sick also
@@LEXI1083 according to the story, the friend went over to see the body & then went home and told her father she saw it , and he took her to the police…she went over first!!
Over in the UK a seventeen year old boy stabbed to death four little girls, 6 other children and two adults were injured by the stabbing at one time. If someone to kill they will.
So the girl who wanted to see a dead body will be traumatized for life? Can society stop making excuses for terrible decision making? It’s not aging well for us
does that matter, I once took everything out of my daughter's bedroom (she had done something dangerous, nothing big but still), and she had to earn her things back with good behavior over the weeks....what on earth does that mean ? That my daughter should have shot me...we call that "if you don't do your best, you lose everything education ,it's better than hitting your child or something" But can you call that a reason??
@@sannywicca7504and you're not wrong, but there have been reports of kids going violent when their phone is taken. They, including girls, beat up mothers, teachers
Apparently she's been talking about killing her mother for some time though. I really don't think medication turns you into a homicidal maniac..children are just about soulless as it is these days.
There it is, the war on kids. You like watching 13 year olds get locked up cause "things arent like they were in my days". No one knows why she did what she did, but kids have pliable minds and a decent justice system would have a shot at rehabilitation given her age, depending on the diagnosis. But that wont happen. Cause of you, kimberly, and all the myrtles and gretas who are terrified of "super predators". Such heroes, fighting the little guy.
@kimberleydavis it's not the guns. Do guns shoot people? No, people shoot people. Should we outlaw butcher knives too? Last year my neighbor was killed by her friend with the butcher knife they were using when an argument broke out. They were cooking and her friend just snapped.
Over in the UK a seventeen year old boy stabbed to death four little girls, 6 other children and two adults were injured by the stabbing at one time. If someone to kill they will. A knife!
My question is why did it take the step father to call 911.... why didnt the friend run out of the house and tell her dad what Carly had done ? Like they dont even say what this friend did or how she reacted
@@Coffeeinthecourtroom I know that these types of medications are not recommended for people under 18 my personal opinion is all these medications are bad for people of any age but their is a clear warning so who takes blame and if their underage is it swim at your own risk? When your under care of a doctor?
Not really. It takes at least $1 million to sue a doctor and parents have to agree to what they’re willing to put their child on. Some parents complain antipsychotics cause various side effects like “zombie,” weight gain etc. Plenty of doctors undermedicate and fatalities happen with kids and adults.
About the stepdad, I watched his testimony, and I tell you there’s something wrong between her and him. He was defending her to the hilt and didn’t seem to care that she murdered his wife! Something ain’t right there
That thought crossed my mind as well. That said, there are numerous reason why he defended her; tie to his diseased wife, might have ignored clear warning signs, blames himself?
Maybe he still hadn't recovered from the shooting while in court. So he stayed calm and tried to think positive. He probably just wanted to think about good memories with his stepdaughter and his wife. Maybe they didn't have a lot of fights with each other before, just have hobbies that are not the same as normal people like being interested in and buying knives that look beautiful.
I was prescribed Lexapro about 18 years ago and I had a severe and unexpected reaction. I don't know how I was even able to drive my vehicle back home from a Fall Festival at our church. The scary part is my then young grandson was with me and I was absolutely NOT in my right mind. I am sharing my experience not making excuses for this young girl.
Violence in this country gets worse every single day. The number of very young children that commit very adult crimes is but one of the many issues in my opinion of not having stable, structured households. I'm old fashioned but I believe having a parent in the home when school is out at the end of the day would certainly help. With the cost of rent, groceries and pretty much everything these days both parents are pretty much forced to work outside the home; some working both full and part-time jobs. I was a single parent during my son's teen years (20 years ago) and it was a struggle making ends meet then but I have no clue how single parents make it work financially these days. If kids have issues now days they are just put on a medication of some sort and we all know ALL medications have side effects. Instead of teaching our children how to deal with life's difficulties, we medicate them. Some genuinely need meds but it's not the answer to basically medicate society, I certainly don't have all of the answers but I see things getting worse everyday and it's beyond sad and scary. Let your kids know they are loved, listen when they want to talk and be the role model they need you to be. That's a start in the right direction at least. And pray daily. Pray for our country , pray for our children and pray for each other.
Wow, i’m not sure I’m understanding why this woman continues to put the blame on the stepfather when she doesn’t even know if that was the case or he had anything to do with it. Why do we continue to look for justification for these peoples actions and blame it on mental health or the person was abused when sometimes it’s just pure evil and there’s just nothing else to it.
This is not someone who kiIIed out of desperation because of s/a. The girl showed her friend and IMO that tells me that she was saying "look see I DID do it" after telling others she was going to. If she was terrified and/or angry at her step-dad...he would have been her main target. I don't like that you even brought that to the table without any proof of it whatsoever!
Over in the UK a seventeen year old boy stabbed to death four little girls, 6 other children and two adults were injured by the stabbing at one time. If someone to kill they will. A knife!
The friend "leaves with her father". Then the friend "jumps the back fence" with Carly. Which is it? And the friend's dad supposedly waits in his car for her. Wouldn't he get out and speak to the step dad?? Hummmm.
#CourtTV - What do YOU think?
MORE HERE: www.courttv.com/trials/vinnie-politan-investigates/?
@@CourtTV lots of trials about guns that have been used, USA needs new gun laws.
@@Trial-watcher2023 for sure! Lots of kids needing mental health assistance and killing their parents, going to schools and shooting kids or making threats. The kids need some serious help! Hope everyone is adulting!
9/17/14 Imo, she should be charged as any other teen shooter who has taken a life and attempt to take a life! Premeditated, thinking clear had time to stop, not call friend text stepdad!! Idc, how young she looks or dressing. Cameras inside home, troubling. She goes into mental health hospital, can manipulate the Dr’s. Murder 1st
Baffled by her actions and demeanor. What is Wrong with her?
HOW DOES THIS P.O.S. AFFORD A DEFENSE TEAM? WITHOUT A J O B? Step- Dad (victim) is definitely Not going to pay for it. Pro - Bono?!?! Did you see Carly slice the pie and turn the corner of the Kitchen entrance, before her cold - blooded Murder, or execution...!!!!!!!!!!
I wish your female panelist would stop being accusatory toward the stepdad when there is absolutely no evidence that he sexually abused her. That is unfair and unprofessional in my opinion!
I was thinking possibly she was in love with him
So put sexual assault thoughts by the step father into people's minds with absolutely no proof is not cool
Lol I also thought that was crazy. Imagine getting shot and then someone makes that accusation on you.
Unbelievable right, lady is really something! Defamation of character!!
Yeah, I did a doubletake at that nonsense.
I agree that was my first thought, you are giving fuel to a small flame. Media cannot do this any more.
It's easy to see her as a victim of the step father. Why he isn't under arrest is just amazing...
The father should be on trial and not her.
It's unprofessional and inappropriate to suggest the stepfather may have been sexually abusing her when the defense itself hasn't even raised that idea. Shame on you! This is the definition of defamation by reckless disregard for the facts.
I thought the same thing. There is no evidence.
100%. Maybe her real dad, maybe her pastor, her gym teacher....no one. Probably someone...
Sensatilism, sloppy reporting and neglecting the actual time of events .
Exactly! To be fair, it's only that female psycho expert's the one who's been pushing her narrative about SA. If that's really the case, it could have been laid out from the start. Her irresponsible words already built some people's mind as shown on the latest VPI episode's comment section. Some people now were convince it's already a fact & assumed the stepdad have a romantic relationship with the child suspect. Even their exchange of smiles were so negatively analyzed, more their daily communication.
I thought the same thing. That’s a terrible thing to suggest. Very unprofessional.
To even suggest a sexual abuse angle purely on speculation, is the definition of irresponsible journalism.
Absolutely! It’s incredibly unethical and irresponsible
Yeah, even if it's why 99.99% of the time, for the .01% you can't do that.
Well sadly, that’s where we are with journalists now. Many are a total JOKE.
all that guys going through....and now this freakin dingbat with the what ever she can come up with theories....and when 1 out the many hits , she'll claim to have been right all along .......!!
if you work with kids you would most likely have that in the back of your mind , something is not right such anger towards the mother ,,,, and that smirk between the step father and her , very fishy
An apology needs to be made to the stepfather. He is a victim! To speculate about SA with zero evidence makes Court TV a lot less credible. Fix it, Vinnie. When your guest makes wild, unfounded accusations, you need to remind the audience of the truth. Starting rumors is not the sign of reliable news reporting.
Thank You. Well said.
For that lady to even suggest sexual abuse with absolutely zero evidence is completely abhorrent & quite frankly unethical.
In my book she lost any & all credibility.
So not okay. Not something to speculate about with no evidence to back it up!
Agree 100%
So AGREE to this👆
That's why I can't stand listening to these talking head sensationalists
Lady?
She's wearing a Catholic school uniforman in court, give me a break!
It’s laughable right?! 😂 As if we are stupid and can’t see through the facade.
Yes it's laughable.
Her lawyers
And her kid's haircut too...
Yea that Jumped out at me too!!!
She is Dangerous. She killed, premeditated to kill step father, and bragged to friend. She told friend prior she was gonna kill Mother. 100% Guilty.
WOW there ha go! They should just have you decide all cases so no more judges or juries!! FFS 🤦🏻
🎯
How should the system treat her? Like a PSYCHOPATHIC KILLER!!
@@Beeezkneeezwould you let her babysit?
I say "no" to insanity.
very unfair to throw the step father under the bus, that is libel, carol liberman needs a reality check ...gross
I find that happens with her a lot. I am surprised they continue to have her on.
A lot of so called experts jump on the sexual assaults wagon.
She didn’t actually accuse anyone of assault. Vinnie asked her opinion and she gave it. She merely gave examples of what could have happened. She did nothing wrong. So many ❄️’s
Family homicides are on the rise, kinda dumb to suggest SA out of nowhere.
I thought the same thing.
Defence dressing her up like a 10 year old to invoke sympathy 🙄
AMEN. That REALLY pisses me off. She’s a cold blooded killer, despite her Little Bo Peep outfit. May she rot in prison for the rest of her miserable life. PS I’m glad to know you…another person who just ain’t fallin’ for the bull sh$t.
That was wild 😬
@@sandracann I see right through that little girl image. She is scary AF. She has no soul, zero emotions, she is a shell.😳😰
Interesting, she is dressed in a school uniform.
Yeah it’s doing the opposite. You can see the devil shining through like a beacon from hell.
STOP having GUNS accessible to CHILDREN!!!
Absolutely, especially during their teen years, hormones make them act irrationally without forethought about the devastating consequences!
Exactly
Seriously!!
So it was the gun, not murder in the heart of Carley? Ridiculous.
@@JimmyMac717 maybe she would have chosen to stab her mother instead?Better chance of surviving a stab wound than two shots to the face, wouldn’t you say….?
No, Carly was in her own bedroom, when Carly shot her mother 3 times, in cold blood. Three shots to her mother’s face
She shot her mother in Carly’s bedroom. Her mother was going through Carly’s personal items and removing some of them. That made Carly angry and that’s what Carly’s motive was.
She retrieved the gun from her mother’s bedroom.
The friend stays there and actually waits for the stepfather to arrive, so Carly can kill him too. So bizarre. I don’t understand where these kids come from. It’s pure evil. They both knew exactly what was happening. There’s no insanity here. That’s crap.
I would have ran to the car & told my dad immediately not waiting until the dad came home & then run away with her!
"I don't understand where these kids come from"
Beaudelaire did. These kids are the result of Les fleurs du Mal.
@@HiroshimaMS Touch’e! Beaudelaire was quite controversial in his time; also a genius.
It wasn't necessary for the friend to be there for the stepfather to be murdered.
@@updownstate You’re misunderstanding. I don’t believe I said that, anywhere in my comments. Why would the friend need to be there? Carly shot her mother 3 times in the face, and killed her, without her friend. Lol!!
My point was, the friend stayed there and waited for Carly to ambush the father, with the knowledge of what was to happen.
The friend should’ve went to a neighbor to call police, after she witnessed the mother’s bullet ridden dead body . The man could’ve easily been unalived, like her mother. He was lucky, Carly wasn’t the best shot.
Her affect is sociopathic and she presents a clear danger to society. The fact that she was a good student means diddly squat. She is beyond scary!
She has that tell-tale psychopathic facial expression. It's strange affect that's hard to describe but easy to read.There's always this weird combination of 'dead' or challenging eyes alongside a slight smirk, as though the person finds the world of other people both inferior/contemptible and amusing.
Are people really using the argument that she can’t be bad because she’s a good student? Ted Kaczynski was a good student too and look what happened.
@@MomMom-ys1oc like seriously I am 56 I would be scared AF to share a cell with her. She gives me the creeps like that Clarie Miller that killed her disabled sister they are demons.
@@rosbel4119lol it’s hilarious because genius borders on insanity
Time after time proven true...r@MoosefromCanada
To accuse the stepfather of sexual abuse, without there being any indication of it, is libel.
Libel.
@@mdcs1992 Thanks, English is not my native language.
🤣😂🤣😂🎪🤡
She didn’t accuse him of- she said it was possible - still horribly irresponsible, but not illegal
That was disgusting!
I think accusing the stepdad of sexual abuse by Dr is outragust.This is a serious accusation when they're is no proof.Being smart doesn't mean you have no problems.This Dr is pissing me off.
Outrageous*
💯. It’s entirely possible she was born evil . Nature or nurture ? Showing the dead mother to her friend speaks volumes . No one likes to hear it, but she could just be outright evil .
Is this where SA started? ML channel chat ran with it
I dont think I'll watch if Dr whats her face is on again. I think the fact she doesn't know better than to throw baseless accusations around makes her some one with nothing to say I want to hear. Very disappointed in court tv. When did court tv become The National Enquirer?
Just because someone is smart doesn't mean they aren't mean spirited. She told kids she was going to kill her mom and she did it. I don't understand why the lady says the stepfather was the demon he was innocent and for this lady to insinuate she is the type of person who would accuse an innocent man and have him put behind bars. This is an evil little girl, she thinks because she's a teen she will get away with it and be allowed to go back to school. The fact that she called her friend over to see the dead body and said "I told you I was gonna do it" let's me know she wanted to do this for fame. This is horrible. She doesn't need to be around other kids.
Do any of these experts research the cases before accusing a person of sexual abuse
So so sad. Hardworking mother trying to provide every opportunity for an ungrateful, evil daughter.
her absolute lack of stress arousal, singing to the dog, tricking the stepfather to come home, call and get a friend over etc. is psychopathic display and that together with smiling in court shows a smart individual as described that understands mentally but are careless about consequences, and smiling when others would be anxious or remorseful. The enjoyment here is very psychopathy, and contrary to normal people. Most interesting would be what she says herself about this, in initial interrogations.
Regardless of the meds, she is definitely a psychopath who should never be set free. She'll always be a danger to society.
My ex was a psychopath (she told me this, though I pretended I didn't hear her. She was a Law abiding version, as far as I know).
We were involved in a car crash on vacation, car was badly damaged by another car that crashed into us, but we were OK. It was a shock for me but it was like chipping a nail for her, absolutely not bothered, appart from annoyed her car was damaged.
The other driver was in a deep state of shock, kept apologising in a loop for 20-30 minutes. While he did that, my gf got him to admit it was entirely his fault to her insurance (he wasn't capable of rational thought), organised a tow truck and got us free bus ticket home (she wanted a rental car but the insurance company didn't emmidiatly provide one, she did try though).
And as our broken car was getting dragged onto the tow truck and we were departing to the bus station with our luggage, Mr apologising in a loop snapped out of his state of shock, and said "I think I have to ring my insurance".
I knew this moment was illustrating the stark difference between a psychopath and a "normal". She dumped my after the vacation, was bored with me by then.
This is one evil kid😡who needs locking up
She looks evil lol
Possessed by demons
No just a bad human @@leslievasquez2645
She absolutely wants to be famous. She rejected the plea deal. She wants the trial to be famous and to relive the murder again and again. She's a psychopath.
The opportunity for fame is a serious consideration in our “Look at me!” culture…🤢
this comment needs to be pinned at the top and this is why 90% of kids are shooting people hell eve adults this is all for fam and fortune i said to my wife that this reminds me of that one killer that gypsy one all for the media and we need to stop making this all over the screens and try to leave it as low profile as possible
She may have psychopathic tendencies, maybe enhanced by the meds she took. I'm no criminal, but I think I wouldn't have accepted the plea either. 40 years of your best years is a long time.
“Why didn’t the friend call 911?” Seriously? The girl just walked into a murder scene and saw her friend’s - the killer’s - mothers dead body after she was shot and killed…how are you even asking this question? She was in shock! Who WOULDNT be??
O melhor comentário! 👌🙌
Maybe just a bit afraid also.
@@cindys9858 right??
I would be scared she was gonna shoot me next if I didn’t do whatever she wanted
@@MyDestinyDear I would be terrified of that demon, shocked out of her mind to say the least. She and father did call I just don't no when exactly. I 100% would have called ASAP when I got out of that house. It makes you wonder why so eger to show friend did she Dare Her is she afraid she will get in trouble??? There is alot to uncover.
How irresponsible to say the step father was sexually assaulting her without any evidence to that. This lady needs to be sued for defamation of character and her license revoked
Yeah, that took me off guard
I think that's why they cut her segment and cut to someone else.
I agree! Worst guest on this channel I’ve ever seen.
Strongly agree! It’s irresponsible to be so quick to make such a terrible suggestion that might have the potential to ruin someone’s life. I know it’s a possibility, but without any evidence pointing to that it’s incredibly dangerous.
What if he was. You don't know.
HOW SAD. Her mom genuinely looks like she'd be the kindest and sweetest lady ever. 🥺💔 This young woman is going to have an awaking someday when she's older and will be utterly shattered by what she has done to her own loving mom. I can't imagine having to live with that level of mental torment for the rest of my days on earth.
I'm curious if she is already feeling that. I read somewhere that her step dad is supporting her.
Lieberman should be banned after unsubstantiated aspersions. Absolutely disgusting.
I agree with you
Agreed!!!
Does this doctor know anything?! She said absolutely nothing as an EXPERT!
The doc is negligent in her speculations (without a shred of evidence).
I agree. She sounded ridiculous.
Agreed! She’s just up there gossiping and speculating!
@@jogordon1530 as a 56 year old with wisdom finally. I do not trust Doctors my hand to God. I know people that died in their care. They always what to put screws and bolts in your body. They Famous words it was the way you fell. Every heart attack you get a Stent 95% of the time. Everybody gets cancer I call BS !!!!!!!!!!! I trust my trash collectors more then them !!!!!!
Agree. Many of these doctors are a health hazard themselves
You gotta love it how the doctor don’t want the blame on the meds but she don’t mind the blame on the victims, I guess only the killer knows the truth.
Why would anyone blame the antipsychotics? Medication doesn't cause someone to kill.
And no one ever blames it on the availabiliy of guns, semi-automatic guns to everyone.....thanks to NRA and republicans and Vance...Trumpsters.
I might consider the connection between the medication & what she did, but the problem with that is she's been telling people she was going to kill her mom before she switched medication.
@@lori679 I know she clearly premeditated the murder of both parents she was just waiting for the right excuse to do it since they think the mother grounded her and was looking for something in her room when she went get the gun from the parent bedroom. I think she was gonna take the vape pen from her.
@@jayjoy331it has before yes, it has aided. She sure didn't mind blaming the victims did she?
Why would the forensic psychiatrist put that narrative out there that the stepfather could have been sexually abusing Carly, and that could be the reason for her shooting him and her mother?!? I think that is very irresponsible of her to even speculate about that when there isn’t any evidence of that. This man was almost murdered. His wife WAS murdered, and now this woman has put out into the universe that he may have been sexually abusing his stepdaughter?!
I think she was shocked when she shot & missed her step dad, lost her confidence & bolted. When she killed her mom it emboldened her enough to drag her friend into it & enjoyed showing her mom's dead body but it wasn't so quick & easy the 2nd time. For all we know she planned on setting up her friend to take the blame.
She was able to excel in school, student of the year, etc. & is probably a next level psychopath. Her body language is unsettling, apparently posing for the camera & in all her court appearances she listens intently to everything word being said.
Calculating.
Agree. At least she listened and paid attention in court unlike Amber Turd who as a grown woman and Mother, doodled, wrote, ignored witnesses’ testimonies while court was in session the entire elongated trial. 😅 I think Carly should’ve gotten life with parole or sent to a mental institution. Killing her Mom wasn’t the right choice due to not getting her way, self entitled, calculated, and rebellious but ultimately her parents should’ve locked all guns in the house and kept ammo stored separately. Too many kids getting a hold of their parents’ weapons with deadly consequences.
Dressed in a school girl uniform. SMH
Surprised they didn't give her a
Lollipop 🍭 2 hold !
exactly what I thought.
If this was a boy, it would be completely different!!!! SMH
Why would they dress her like that?
@@BobSmith-tn2qp her lawyers dressed her like that so she appears to be a naive young child who is innocent. It's a tactic.
@@rooder8827Some defense lawyers really do think people are stupid don’t they 😂
Her defense not getting a psyche exam is telling.
They’re getting one now apparently.
Am I the only one here asking “how did she have access to a gun?”
In what sane mind do you have a gun sitting around with a kid with mental health problems in the house?!?!?!
Amurrrrrica
Its Mississippi, it’s abnormal to not have guns in your home.
@@alexanderyoakum1287well, change must come.
@@alexanderyoakum1287 the question is not about having a gun at home; is about how a kid has ACCESS to the gun.
@@fannygo6673 I understand the concern & yes I agree guns shouldnt be easily accessible but I grew up in the same county this happened in & im just saying no one around here takes gun safety serious.
I have never felt scared by the most violent murderers on all these true crime trials. This little girl actually scares me. She’s pure evil.
Lizzie Borden jr
Carly looks 10 years old
@@ritayoung6040 9/19/24 Only dressed like that by defense to gain sympathy! Cold 🥶
@@AlessiaBlue agree
There is a very evil vibes I'm getting from this young lady , she cry's but then can stop in a instant !! I love children but this child I just can't even find myself to feel badly for her , There was a precious , innocent good life taken away from a mother that lived her and this is what she does for that love , Really !
How can the doctor suggest the stepfather sexually abused the girl? You really have to be cautious accusing somebody. Very unprofessional. It doesn't surprise me the girl said something like that. It doesn't make it true.
Even if it were true, that's no excuse for murder.
I have so much to say about this. The issue isn't the medication she was taking, but rather the condition it was prescribed to treat in the first place. Studies have examined the potential link between aggressive behavior and Lexapro, and the worst they found was that, in extremely rare cases, it might cause irritability. It doesn’t make someone pick up a gun, shoot a parent, and put the body on display to show your friends. Violent behaviour is much more likely to be tied to untreated or poorly managed mental health conditions than to the medications prescribed to treat them.
And lastly, being intelligent and having a high IQ doesn’t make someone a redeemable member of society. She might be able to solve algebra equations faster than the average kid but that doesn’t mean she can go out and be a socially responsible, empathetic adult with the necessary social skills to not harm others.
Thank you for coming to my Ted Talk.
Are you aware that psychiatric drugs have a higher risk of causing ending their life or others? These medications can have significantly adverse consequences and they keep giving them to teens … very dangerous.
Wow! That was the shortest TED talk in the history of TED talks. People have such short attention spans nowadays.
She is an entitled madam who did not think of the consequences. 100 percent agree intelligence doesn't make you socially competent.
@@NadineDelange-dx8ol I can't believe that Vinnie (or anyone) would bring up her so called intelligence like it was some kind of moral prerequisite. Vinnie & company are forgetting that there is a fine line between genius & mad(wo)man. Plenty of examples throughout history.
Excellent points!
They are trying to make her look like a school girl. It's disgusting, she did the crime and needs to do the time. Maximum sentence, no mercy, no excuse. Children don't dress like that .
She literally is a child
@@Epic-so3ekno excuses
💯
@@Epic-so3ekShe’s a murderer
You said it
Imo she showed her friend because she wanted to show off
Disgusting behavior.
.
As soon as I heard she was on Lexapro at 13 yos it stopped me in my tracks. I tried Lexapro at 29 for anxiety/depression and it turned me into a psycho. I was insanely irritable, angry and unreasonable at all times. Like little things would make my blood boil. Can't imagine what that would be like at 13, when you don't understand that these feelings are temporary and things get better once you stop taking the meds. She could also just be a sociopath but that's my opinion on Lexapro 🤷🏼♀️
I take lexapro and nothing happened to me.
@@LCx829 Me too. It really helped me.
@@LCx829Same. I'm on it and it's helped me tremendously.
Omg at 13 that's why psychologist are so much better than shrinks.
@@LCx829I still can't imagine a 13 yr old on it my gosh😮
I absolutely think that in this case they should lock her up and throw away the key, regardless of how young she is.
I agree ☝🏻
I think they should give her the death penalty.
This show is run like a cheap expose, like a tabloid show. Didn't care for the forensic psychiatrist supposing maybe the stepfather was abusing the girl.when there was no evidence of that. Not professional at all.
Thank You!! My exact thoughts, how unprofessional to spout nonsense right off the bat!!
People will hear this and then repeat it like it’s the truth!!
Yeah I dont care for the fact these shows are what judges and prosecutors cater to when they charge a 13 year old as an adult.
How can this woman talk about sexual assault by the father wothouth a shred of evidence on it? Scary
USA? metoo?
Yeah it is. Even if the allegations were true, it's no excuse for murder. Why not just run away from home??
They treat her just like they treat everyone else that has committed the crimes she did!! She's smart enough to know what she did and seems to have enjoyed it to this day...life with no parole
Yes!!!! 😤😤
They’re going to have to have a Miller hearing before they do that.
What state is this in? Shes 15. Life might be off the table because she’s a minor
She was 13 at the time and being charged as an adult. Its depraved, but dirtbags like you fight the war on kids and ig you get what you want.
@@deydirkarjerb7309 The judge clearly said "life means life" in reference to her probable sentencing. He also stated she will be tried as an adult.
This psychopath needs to be put in prison for the rest of her life.
Blah blah blah enough of the excuses, She's a murderer and needs life no parole.
@@Truth-f2q 9/19/24 Exactly!👍
She did an adult act, therefore she should be treated as an adult. Punishment for this awful crime must be given
What the hell kind of scuzzy, messed up kid friend runs right on over to see the mother their 'friend' just murdered?
Calling 911 would have been wiser, but I guess kids don't always make rational decisions.
Her friend probably didn't believe her. She had to come over and see it for herself.
If they start blaming this on medication or supposed child abuse.... There's going to be a whole lot of bad happening everywhere. You learn from day one not to mess with guns she was very aware of what she was doing!
Remember she's a very smart girl that knows exactly what to say like she's hearing voices in jail I'll bet she never was hearing voices before she was in jail
Maybe the jails are haunted. Some of the other killers report hearing voices while jailed.
44 minutes of drivel, speculation and unsubstantiated accusations. Presenter and guests think they're way more intelligent and important than they are. Don't waste your time.
Vinnie Politan Speculates
And he says that he is. He asks questions.@@Elyssa_Wyld
@mdcs1992~ I agree!
I'm so thankful that my life didn't go in that direction. My parents were alcoholics & I gew up neglected in a home with DV. At 15 I wanted to get away from my parents but I never thought about k*lling them. My parents didn't get along, either & I always wanted them to get a divorce instead of slugging it out every weekend after getting drunk.
I hear ya @SweetUniverse
@ SweetUniverse~ I am so sorry that you went through that as a child. I think that you saying that you never thought about killing your parents is exactly what needs to be said because clearly not every abused child kills their parents.
I hope your parents are good ones to you now ❤
17:50 Carly's friend... I realize she's technically a minor but, she's 15 y/o and old enough to have common sense.
The court should order a Psych Eval (friend):
She SAW the Mom AND KNEW Carly was waiting to kill her stepfather.
She waited outside (20 mins) then heard multiple gunshots...
She NEVER called 911 !?!
That's not reasonable behavior.
Mind boggling and scary😞
Was it medication induced?
Was her Doc actively making medication changes?
I couldn’t agree more!
She only went to the police later that evening, after it was way too late. If you ask me, just to cover her posterior.
If that doesn’t qualify as accomplice, I don’t know what would.
@@angelasome9044I completely agree!
why suggest he was abusing her if it was not proven or there was no evidence ???
The defense is desperate.
The alleged murderer looks rather happy with herself.
Having Mrs. Lieberman on is just irresponsible at this point. Court TV needs to take a step back and analyze their content instead of being so quick to put out media.
Children on anti depressants w/ a gun in the house…..not a good combination. Shocked child is on an adult drug. She’s blinking non stop on film.
your a doctor.?
When she's not winking to her friend(s). She's a cold calculated killer.
@winkieblink7625 100% agree
They dressed her like a horror movie character lol
My first reaction. WHAT is she wearing?
Looks like The Shining lol
She is a nightmare that is why 😂😂😂
That’s therapist is so annoying OMG ! That little girl is a psychopath and her friend should be charged as well for being complicit! She planned this out and the friend told nobody to stop that tells me , she was in on it and probably encouraged it ! I can’t stand watching some of these people on this channel
And not to be rude, but her hair 😅
@@KathleenHopper-o3jas if she put her finger in a power outlet. 😂That doggo in the background looks super spiffy in comparison.
I agree. She planned this and the friend is complicit.
These kids are out of control !
Yeah the super predators. You really do love watching children getting locked up. You people...
Some Doctors are given commission for several medications and they would push for a particular drug , for greed despite its harmful effects.
Psychiatric drugs often cause mental problems.
Thanks for the info I’ll spread the word and if someone asks how I know I’ll say I got it from a random UA-cam comment. Jk
Yes, and in teenagers, suicide and homicide is also a symptom. Even more, if a teenager is prescribed a different antidepressant, these too can cause horrendous symptoms. That is why a doctor's care is paramount as well as the parents. Parents controlling the administration of the medication can help as well.
I came to bring this issue up! In teenagers the risk of self life ending or others is a BIG risk with psychological medications. A much bigger risk than with adults. Suddenly stopping will cause severe reactions- worse than before the person had before the medication.
I totally agree with you , putting children on medication because you do not want to address the issues is appalling . its called bad parenting !!!!
@@louisewright8769I’m not sure about other states but where I live, doctors are permitted to prescribe antidepressants to kids without parental consent or knowledge. They will also arrange transportation to appointments. So…
Suggesting the step dad was sexually abusing her is kinda lame. Sounds like shes a spoiled brat , whos mom was trying to dicipline her and she went phycho.
What emergency could a schoolmate have that a parent would drive their child and drop them off without questions. And why did said child and her parent not report anything until later?
Parents are nothing more than an ATM and Taxi to these young kids these days!
And parents obey! That's what's crazy! I would've told my kids too bad!
That's the problem.None of these kids are ever told no anymore. They don't fear their parents.They don't fear the police.They don't fear anybody.
I mean you’re assuming the kid told the parent the truth. Maybe she just lied and said her friend needed help on a school project. Then when news hit of the murder the parent presses the kid on the truth.
@@shaun5047 no, I was following what I guess was the child’s statement. There was no mention of the parent’s statement.: nothing that said the dad contradicted the”emergency” story. As a parent, though, I’m going to say her behavior when she got home was not “normal.” Perhaps that is why they finally went to the police
Fancy Carol lederman saying the stepfather was up to something with her
Why would you šay he is the Demon, when there's no proof
What a terrible thing to put out there
She didn't say he was abusing her. She raised it as a possibility along with a couple of other named possibilities, and unarmed possibilities. I imagine any health professionals would also consider those possibilities, but whether they would verbalise them to the media is another question
People throw drugs at their kids instead of getting to the root of the problem, theses are mind altering DRUGS!
Agree! Google Akethesia to get an understanding of this potential horrible side effect of Lexapro and most other psychotropic medications.
I wish I had received SSRIs as a kid. Would have helped a lot. The issue is giving pills without the proper therapeutic care. Especially in kids and young adults, those meds can have different side effects than it has in adults.
The Lexapro very well could be the issue. If she has bipolar disorder, prescribing an SSRI like Lexapro could have set her off and pushed an already troubled kid over the edge. She still murdered her mother. There is no evidence her step father abused her, and this Dr is very irresponsible for alleging that.
Exactly! And it is irresponsible of the judge & defense not to have her mentally evaluated!ost anti depressants have homicidal thoughts for teens on the label!! She is best student in the whole school! Lexapro did it
So true, especially since she's on a high dose of Abilify now and is apparently doing much better. An anti psychotic leading to an improvement in mental health is a pretty clear sign she actually is dealing with a severe mental illness.
@@Sulynne-v5xlmao 😂always excuses. She’s an evil little psychopath
This female doctor is insufferable
That's why they are on these shows. They can't get a real job being a Dr
I agree
Why did she say that about the stepfather? So iresponiible. Good job on stopping that lady quickly.
A different kind of evil. An absence of empathy. This kid is twisted, flip city. But not insane. She may be only 15, but she will kill again to get her way.
I cannot believe the friend who was invited to see the body, didn’t notify an adult or authorities! SMH
Right?? Her friend should be charged for not immediately telling her dad or calling 911. The friend knew she was about to shoot her step dad and she did nothing and just waited.. friend sounds sick also
Or that she had been saying for sometime that she wanted to kill her Mum, no one said a word.
Who said she didn't? A lot is left out here.
@@LEXI1083 according to the story, the friend went over to see the body & then went home and told her father she saw it , and he took her to the police…she went over first!!
She told her dad, and they went to the sheriff. Listen to the whole thing.......
This is what happens when you let your kids have access to a gun.😮 All parents should lock their guns up away from their children NOW!
I don't know why children know that their parents have guns in the first place.
Over in the UK a seventeen year old boy stabbed to death four little girls, 6 other children and two adults were injured by the stabbing at one time. If someone to kill they will.
So the girl who wanted to see a dead body will be traumatized for life? Can society stop making excuses for terrible decision making? It’s not aging well for us
I don't think it's fair to bring up SA, by the father. .. When there is no proof .. this little girl definitely isn't stupid....
It is both fair and CRITICAL to mention the accusation of child sexual abuse in these cases as long as it isnt misrepresented as a proven fact.
Anti depressants have suicide and homicide side effects, READ the label. This doctor was doing some fast dancing defending the drug.
Excuse and there would have been red flags beforehand
Don't make excuses for this self centered sociopath brat.
Apparently she had homicidal ideations already.
They also affect teenagers differently. The risk is higher with teens.
@@jrelevates1574 I absolutely agree and they just switched her meds ,2 days before.
26:45 Get this lady off my screen.
And then she goes on to deflect away from the medicinal issues. Is she paid by the pharmaceutical industry?
Vinnie give the guests a chance to speak
He is the definition of a LOUD MOUTH
There is an obvious delay with live video/audio it’s not vins fault
I want to know what the items were that Mom removed from Carly's room. My guess: those items played a part in this tragedy.
Yes, the phone.
does that matter, I once took everything out of my daughter's bedroom (she had done something dangerous, nothing big but still), and she had to earn her things back with good behavior over the weeks....what on earth does that mean ? That my daughter should have shot me...we call that "if you don't do your best, you lose everything education ,it's better than hitting your child or something" But can you call that a reason??
Maybe something that shamed her? The guy seemed to stumble over...items
@@sannywicca7504and you're not wrong, but there have been reports of kids going violent when their phone is taken. They, including girls, beat up mothers, teachers
@sannywicca7504 with our curiosity, we're on a different track
The timing of the medication change is very interesting
Apparently she's been talking about killing her mother for some time though. I really don't think medication turns you into a homicidal maniac..children are just about soulless as it is these days.
@@KimberlyBishh has she really? I haven't seen that.
There it is, the war on kids. You like watching 13 year olds get locked up cause "things arent like they were in my days". No one knows why she did what she did, but kids have pliable minds and a decent justice system would have a shot at rehabilitation given her age, depending on the diagnosis.
But that wont happen. Cause of you, kimberly, and all the myrtles and gretas who are terrified of "super predators". Such heroes, fighting the little guy.
@@KimberlyBishhChildren have been killing for a long time…even when you were young there were cases. It’s not a “these days” phenomenon
Well said@@Epic-so3ek
Nearly 500 million guns in the USA. What a country!
Exactly, its a numbers game, they will never reduce gun deaths until gun laws are changed, most other countries can do this
@kimberleydavis it's not the guns. Do guns shoot people? No, people shoot people. Should we outlaw butcher knives too? Last year my neighbor was killed by her friend with the butcher knife they were using when an argument broke out. They were cooking and her friend just snapped.
Psychopaths can not be rehabilitation duuhh
What daughter doesn't have issues with their mother?
Where does a teenager get a gun. Whoever gave her a gun is responsible
She took it out of parent’s room, it was not sitting in plain site.
Could've just as easily been a knife. Would you blame walmart for selling kitchenware too?
@@Bettinasisrg at 56 I never even held a gun, it seems like alot of people on guns. I have alarm system and 911 to call.
Over in the UK a seventeen year old boy stabbed to death four little girls, 6 other children and two adults were injured by the stabbing at one time. If someone to kill they will. A knife!
I AGREE
My question is why did it take the step father to call 911.... why didnt the friend run out of the house and tell her dad what Carly had done ? Like they dont even say what this friend did or how she reacted
Thanks Vinny for covering this case. Please keep digging! I appreciate both of your guest!!
Can a patient sue a psychiatrist for homicides that are committed under the influence of these types of meds...
Yes, anyone can sue anyone for anything. They may not be successful, but they can.
@@Coffeeinthecourtroom I know that these types of medications are not recommended for people under 18 my personal opinion is all these medications are bad for people of any age but their is a clear warning so who takes blame and if their underage is it swim at your own risk? When your under care of a doctor?
Not really. It takes at least $1 million to sue a doctor and parents have to agree to what they’re willing to put their child on. Some parents complain antipsychotics cause various side effects like “zombie,” weight gain etc. Plenty of doctors undermedicate and fatalities happen with kids and adults.
About the stepdad, I watched his testimony, and I tell you there’s something wrong between her and him. He was defending her to the hilt and didn’t seem to care that she murdered his wife! Something ain’t right there
That thought crossed my mind as well. That said, there are numerous reason why he defended her; tie to his diseased wife, might have ignored clear warning signs, blames himself?
Maybe he still hadn't recovered from the shooting while in court. So he stayed calm and tried to think positive. He probably just wanted to think about good memories with his stepdaughter and his wife. Maybe they didn't have a lot of fights with each other before, just have hobbies that are not the same as normal people like being interested in and buying knives that look beautiful.
Can't believe that friend (and father) didn't warn the dad! That's crazy.
Medications with a teen sounds sus? Mental status is important!!!!
I was prescribed Lexapro about 18 years ago and I had a severe and unexpected reaction. I don't know how I was even able to drive my vehicle back home from a Fall Festival at our church. The scary part is my then young grandson was with me and I was absolutely NOT in my right mind. I am sharing my experience not making excuses for this young girl.
Violence in this country gets worse every single day. The number of very young children that commit very adult crimes is but one of the many issues in my opinion of not having stable, structured households. I'm old fashioned but I believe having a parent in the home when school is out at the end of the day would certainly help. With the cost of rent, groceries and pretty much everything these days both parents are pretty much forced to work outside the home; some working both full and part-time jobs. I was a single parent during my son's teen years (20 years ago) and it was a struggle making ends meet then but I have no clue how single parents make it work financially these days. If kids have issues now days they are just put on a medication of some sort and we all know ALL medications have side effects. Instead of teaching our children how to deal with life's difficulties, we medicate them. Some genuinely need meds but it's not the answer to basically medicate society, I certainly don't have all of the answers but I see things getting worse everyday and it's beyond sad and scary. Let your kids know they are loved, listen when they want to talk and be the role model they need you to be. That's a start in the right direction at least. And pray daily. Pray for our country , pray for our children and pray for each other.
Wow, i’m not sure I’m understanding why this woman continues to put the blame on the stepfather when she doesn’t even know if that was the case or he had anything to do with it. Why do we continue to look for justification for these peoples actions and blame it on mental health or the person was abused when sometimes it’s just pure evil and there’s just nothing else to it.
This is not someone who kiIIed out of desperation because of s/a. The girl showed her friend and IMO that tells me that she was saying "look see I DID do it" after telling others she was going to. If she was terrified and/or angry at her step-dad...he would have been her main target. I don't like that you even brought that to the table without any proof of it whatsoever!
Why the friend didn't get help
She did, watch the full thing...
she is probably evil as well
Why adults don’t keep guns locked?
I don’t get it and never will!
They are to blame aswell!
Over in the UK a seventeen year old boy stabbed to death four little girls, 6 other children and two adults were injured by the stabbing at one time. If someone to kill they will. A knife!
I child that young should not bevon those meds. The brain is not fully developed till 25. I dont care what sny dr says about that.
Friend sounds like an accomplice to me.
Kid got mad overreacting nw off to jail
The look on her face is like “ Hang on! That’s not how I planned it. You’re supposed to feel sorry for me let me go home. “ imho🤦♀
The friend "leaves with her father". Then the friend "jumps the back fence" with Carly. Which is it?
And the friend's dad supposedly waits in his car for her. Wouldn't he get out and speak to the step dad?? Hummmm.
Yes, the question is, why the friend didn't leave asap. Why wait for the shooting of the step father. That is super wierd.