The main problem is that all of the good talents leave early to go to Europe, when U see all the best players who won the world for Brazil, they atleast spent 5+ years at senior level at Brazil
Back when Brazil was winning world cups, the players spent most of there careers in Brazil. That's why the Brasileiro was the best league in the world during Pele time
@@Sportelligence in national football Brazil has all the chance to be as strong as ever, but club football is a lost cause. The top European leagues are on totally another level when it comes to money and prestige, we will never be able to retain our best talent as we did in the past again. At least we dominate in South America, FWIW
Se vc gosta de um campeonato que mal tem 50% do tempo com bola rolando problema seu, agr achar q todo mundo tem q gostar dessa piada q é o brasileirao é loucura
It'll be impossible over here in Brazil to compete with the PL due to a couple factors: 1 - The tickets are too expensive for the average wage of a working class citizen, so they of course prioritize things like food, rent, electricity, etc, and if they can just watch the matches on the television. 2 - The clubs that have more fans are stupid and want 5~20x more in tv/sponsor deals than all the other clubs, their reasoning is: "We bring more revenue due to our massive fans, so we deserve more", and that is stupid, because in time it'll transform the league in a farmers league, with only 2 or 3 teams really posing as title contenders, and others just being there doing nothing, like we see in leagues like Bundesliga, La Liga and Ligue 1. 3 - Our talent leaves the country too soon. We can't reveal any new generational talent that a club in Europe, usually Real Madrid, buys them and we don't see them again until they want to retire. 4 - The referees are a joke, there's actually a police investigation going right now, because it's obvious something shady is going on due to terrible decisions, VAR errors, wrong red cards, and so much more. Not to mention when our referees work in another country they are heavily criticized and even suspended, because they're that bad. The worst part is that CBF is against a professional referee system. 5 - The states federations have too much power, this means it's almost impossible to end the states championships, or even transform it in a U-23 tournament, and with that our calendar is insane. There's more reasons, but with that you can get a glimpse of the shit show we have around here.
I'd add the relatively outrageous barriers between amateur and professional football in Brazil, with the main issues being the rather massive affiliation fees (to the point that i'd say affiliated "amateur" clubs are more like semi-professional rather than truly amateur), the forced profissionalization of clubs to even compete in the state leagues (in a stark contrast to the aformentiomed ref issue), so that amateur clubs cannot compete alongside professional ones unlike most other football federations, poor management of the championships thenselves (from Série A to Série D, up to the state championships eg. Amapá and Maranhão), among many other things at the structural, financial, and fundamental level.
I just looked at one of my Football Manager saves, Flamengo played 75 games in a season getting to all the finals (state, copa lib & brasil cup). No wonder the young players burnout. Definitely need to change the state championship in my opinion, maybe Serie A & b teams enter under 22's or something
Brazilian League is like Premier League in South America, they have the best and richest teams of the continent while the Argentinian League is like La Liga with only two powerhouses(Boca and River) to compete against brazilian teams in Libertadores.
@@crosh7851 idk much about this league tho. Maybe Jupiler League (Belgium) or even Eredivisie, cuz of the Olimpia that can be compared to Ajax in Latin America
For me, the Brasileirão is better than the Premier League in terms of competitiveness. Of course the Premier has some of the best teams in the world, but it's very predictable.
@@SirloucoPiano mas só é competitivo por causa da inconsistência dos clubes brasileiros no geral (o famoso "nivelado por baixo), mas eu ainda acredito que no mundial de clubes os brasileiros vão surpreender e ganhar jogos desses timecos europeus
@@blackeye1304 sim, é muito disputado por serem muito parelho, mas o brasil vem dominando a america do sul nos ultimos anos... não é uma disputa baixa... mas não é a nivel PL.
One huge factor not mentioned is the size of Brazil, a country as big as the USA, while the league isnt divided in two, like the NBA or MLS. Several times, clubs have to waste a day going/returning to the other side of the country, while in the UK the longest trip wouldnt take more than an hour flight/train.
Por isso que não faz sentido impor campeonato de pontos corridos com turno/returno e querer abolir os estaduais. Os estaduais surgiram da característica e necessidade do nosso país, fazem parte da história e cultura nacional. Campeonatos estaduais/regionais podem ser a solução.
@@irwingbrasilFaça os times grandes entrarem só nas quartas de final. Os estaduais serviram em sua época, hoje podem ser reformulados. Os estaduais no Brasil poderiam ser o que já foram com a Taça de Prata, que é de fato a antiga copa do Brasil, um campeonato regional onde o campeão joga com os outros campeões estaduais. Os estaduais surgiram da carência de capacidade de transporte no Brasil, e mesmo com essa capacidade é uma quantidade insana de viagem. O campeonato deveria ser dividido em conferências como a NBA/NFL, até financeiramente os clubes poderiam conseguir mais investimento, já que um time que jamais ganharia o brasileiro poderia, pelo menos, ser campeão da conferência e disputar o título. Faz SP+SUL e RJ+MG+nordeste
A resposta é muito simples. O Brasil só não tem o maior campeonato do mundo por falta de dinheiro. À partir do momento que injetarem dinheiro no nosso campeonato, seja por meio de patrocínios ou por compradores árabes, o Brasil será imparável. A questão é que isso é muito difícil de acontecer.
Brasileirão n precisa de investimento de fora. A liga já tem muito reconhecimento do país, não precisa de investimento de fora, mas ninguém rejeitaria se tivesse
Acho que não, acredito que na verdade o Brasileirão B e inferiores são os que mais precisam de investimentos financeiros. Mas para o campeonato principal, eu acredito que seja realmente a questão de manter as suas preciosas jóias em solo nacional.
Na verdade é uma visão limitada achar que é apenas isso. Nem no exterior excesso de dinheiro é sinônimo de êxito. Excesso de dinheiro aqui só vai fazer jogadores ruins ganharem 500mil por mês (e isso já está acontecendo). Se o Brasil se inspirasse na EPL, certamente priorizaria 2 coisas essencias para valorização do produto futebol : Velocidade e Tempo de Jogo de Qualidade. Isso eliminaria : - Cera dos jogadores - Grama sem padrão ou de baixa qualidade - Usar o desconforto pro adversário no dia do jogo como vantagem competitiva - A Necessidade do juiz parar o jogo inteiro para proteger seu "emprego" Além disso, se organizando como Liga, eles podem juntos escolher o melhor formato de distribuição desse "produto" e com isso não ficar dependendo de uma única emissora para distribuição dos jogos. Isso torna o produto mais acessível, mais rentável e menos dependente de influencia de grandes grupos de midia. Também pode ser capaz de exportar o campeonato como nunca antes foi possível. Com streaming o publico pode ver o jogo inteiro em outro horário e a questão do fuso horário é atenuada. As polemicas nunca serão extintas nem os erros. Ainda existem muitos erros de arbitragem na EPL, sobretudo no VAR, que dado o tempo limitado de decisão, eles ainda cometem erros bobos. Mas acredito que com o tempo a tecnologia e os processos do VAR vão evoluir sem comprometer o tempo do jogo e vai acrescentar mais justiça nas partidas.
O principal problema é o câmbio. 1 real pra 6.56 libras. Nos anos 90 o real chegou a ser 1 pra 1 com dolar e euro. Ficou muito tempo tbm na paridade 1 pra 1 pra 2/ 1 pra 3. A nossa moeda foi se esfarelando e os melhores jogadores foram indo embora. Nos anos 90 dava pra segurar os jogadores, hoje é impossível competir. Ainda mais com a PL. 2 jogadores top’s do Liverpool equivalem a folha inteira do Palmeiras, atual Bicampeão. A liga brasileira nunca vai chegar nem perto da Premier League
Pra conseguir isso precisa de um produto bom kkkkkk por isso o modelo de negócio da Premier League funciona. Não é magicamente que aparecem investidores.
I actually felt this was the opposite of "giving respect" to Brazilian tournaments and clubs. Saying local state championships are meaningless and hosting the FA Cup is a contradiction in itself. It's like saying no country that plays UCL should play their own national championship. Even knowing that there are Brazilian states that are bigger in territory and population than European countries, and have GDP that matches a few of them. That's actually doing us dirty in comparison.
@@estouaquipraaprenderEngland has 7 divisions and definitely don't have UEFA standards on every pitch they play in. We may have pitches in terrible state in Brazil, but so do they in England. Stop trying to make us look bad in comparison.
The quality of football is not the same, nowadays. It started to derail completely when the rule of only three foreigners per team was abolished in Europe. We couldn't keep the best talent, now we can't keep the "medium" talent too. But it's still one of the most balanced leagues in the world.
Not to mention the countless world-renowned players who have played in Brazil over the last 12 years, Forlan, who was the best player at the World Cup in 2010, was here playing for Internacional, along with Sedoorf at Botafogo, Ronaldinho champion of the Libertadores at Atlético Mineiro, with Neymar still at Santos, all of this in 2013, that's crazy, not to mention others, like Luis Suárez, Payet, Juanfran, Daniel Alves, Marcelo, Diego Costa, Douglas Costa, Lucas Moura, James Rodríguez, Fernandinho, Hulk, Vidal, Coutinho and Thiago Silva returning now, Honda, Medel, Borré, Bolasie, David Luiz, Pato, Ener Valencia who played an incredible cup with Ecuador, and others who were trained here but shine in Europe such as Paqueta, Vinicius Junior, Alisson, Casemiro, Gabriel Jesus... and the local stars who may not be recognized in Europe, but in South America there are a lot, such as De La Cruz, Arrascaeta, Raphael Veiga, Arboleda, Gustavo Gomez, Piquerez, Viña... Anyway, the rest of the world doesn't know what it's missing.
I'm Brazilian. The Brazilian championship have passion, but not good quality or skills. The players are very limited, the fields are worst than European second division - the top teams have better fields, of course. Guys who are second options in Europe are absolute top player if comes to here. Is the "most competitive competition", more than Premier, but with a ULTRA LOW LEVEL. Common, the intensity of the game, the time of ball in match is other world. Brazil has no money and capacity to maintain great players anymore... We are a country become older and older, with a decline population and poverty.
@@sr_ryoadm So I'm watching another Brazilian championship, because in the Brazilian championship I saw, the players in the league have a very good technical level, it's no wonder that many from there are exported to Europe, you must be watching the Venezuelan championship, you must have gotten confused.
In Brazil we know we are certainly behind main Europeans leagues, our best players always leave too early and come back too late but our league is not amateur as many Europeans think, a fair comparison today would be, French Ligue 1 without PSG. In the 70's, 80's and 90's our league was top 3 in the world.
thomas donohoe teve seu primeiro jogo de futebol no brasil um ano antes do charles miller "Thomas Donohoe, the "Father Of Brazilian Football", was a master dyer in the calico printing industry. Thomas emigrated to Brazil in 1894.[1] He organized football matches in Bangu (now a suburb of Rio de Janeiro) that year with fellow employees of the textile company Progresso Industrial Do Brazil. Charles Miller, who some others claim to have brought football to Brazil, arranged his first match in April of the following year in São Paulo".
essa estória de charles miller é coisa de paulista... todo mundo sabe que os britânicos quando vieram pro Brasil prá construir hidrelétricas, estradas de ferro, pontes, instalar industrias muito antes desse tal de charles miller já jogavam futebol em terras brasileiras... conta ess tua aí prá outro paulista otário.
@@fernandoroberts3591 Há registro de jogos de futebol aqui em Juiz de Fora em 1893!! Essa discussão é meio sem fim, mas Charles Miller entrou no mito da chegada do futebol ao Brasil
Brazilian Serie A is already better than Italy Serie A and Portuguese League and a all the rest of the european leagues: greek, turkish, ukranian, scottish, danish, belgian, etc. It only won't beat Premier, La Liga and Bundesliga, by this order. The problem here is money: taxes and the value in comparison with euros and dollars. Period.
In fact i would say the same. Even the italian serie A clubs being richer, like in transfermarkt, what happens is: the same player playing to a Brazilian club worths 10m euro, when he's sold to any of the major european league clubs, their price grows at least 3x just by changing club, for no other reason than the fact that now they can clash against the best clubs in the world, and being able to handle a game against them improve their price. I don't see fairness in that, but it is what it is, meanwhile our players that keep in Brazil only plays agains other south american clubs, which is like the 3rd tier of europe, like east european leagues. That being said, if Brazil were in Europe, or Brazilian clubs play with european clubs more often in friendlies or even in some cups, surely their revenue and market price would be bigger than Ligue 1 in France and Serie A Italiana
I'm Brazilian. The Brazilian championship have passion, but not good quality or skills. The players are very limited, the fields are worst than European second division - the top teams have better fields, of course. Guys who are second options in Europe are absolute top player if comes to here. Is the "most competitive competition", more than Premier, but with a ULTRA LOW LEVEL. Common, the intensity of the game, the time of ball in match is other world. Brazil has no money and capacity to maintain great players anymore... We are a country become older and older, with a decline population and poverty.
I think the problem is that since the 90s, brazilian players go to europe in their prime (and now they barely play in Brasileirão) because of the financial gap between Europe and Brazil. Anyway, beside Brasileirão having a lower level than Premier League, Serie A, Bundesliga and LaLiga, I think is a funnier league because of that's so balanced, competitive and unpredictable. Btw I think Brasileirão has a similar level to Portuguese, French and Netherlands league, but I hope so much in the future Brasileirão can be the highest level of football in the world as it was in the 60s~70s
🤣🤣 if you think the Brasileirão is the same level as the Portuguese, Dutch or French league, you have no clue what you're talking about dude I mean, I'm brazilian but I'm not delusional to say our league is at Premier League or La Liga standards yet (although I think it's already the most unpredictable and fun league out there), but the French, Dutch or Portuguese leagues are WAY below our level overall; they all have like 1 or 2 decent teams each, and the rest of them would have a hard time even in our second division league 😂
Amigo o brasileirao já é melhor que o campeonato francês é português fácil... basta vir aqui e ver de perto. Acho que você não assistiu o Brasileirao de 2023 para está falando uma loucura dessas... 😂😂
Brazilian footbal has huge potential, but we still have barriers that we can't get along: 1- The local time is too late for other countries to watch live games. We are like +4-5h of most european countries, and even more to arabic countries, what makes them not so attractive to watch. 2- Brazil's currency (BRL) worths less than 1/5 EUR and almost 1/7 Sterlings (from UK). That's a huge gap. Even thou Brazil has the highest amount of money investing at football in South America, it's way less than european top leagues. 3- More money, more power. This causes our biggest talents to leave the country too early. By the recent example of Endrick and Estevao, both from Palmeiras, and both sold for 60 million EUR to Real Madrid and Chelsea respectively. Naming those, but not forgeting about Neymar, Ronaldinho Gaúcho and many other brazilian stars. 4- Most of Brazilian people don't have money to spend with and support their favorite clubs. A regular brazilian club's jersey costs like almost 500 BRL, which is almost a third of minimum salary. 5- And, as you mentioned, there are clubs with way less support and relevance than other, which makes even more unbalanced. And these are just to mention a few barriers. There are others.
Brazilian here, I'm 100% in favor of making teams in higher leagues stop playing the state championships, at least, with their main teams, make it that Serie A teams can only play their U17, B their U18, C their U20, or just stop playing it altogether, the main team doesn't need that, and the U17/18 teams would keep the state leagues relevant so supporters can still watch their beloved team. Another thing that I don't like in the Brasileirão, is the limitation of players from other countries, last time I checked, it was 5 or 7, for teams that have 32-36 players, having only 5 or 7 foreigners is bad, as you can see in the PL, having tons of foreigners increase the quality of the game.
The main problem is that the organizers and owners of soccer in brazil don't want to solve the problems that keep the league average.There is talent, passion and room for growth, but we don't see the will.
O Campeonato Brasileiro é o único de vinte clubes que rebaixa quatro times todo ano por isso vários grandes cairam como 17, além disso hoje são pelo menos 13 equipes que participam de campeonatos da CONMEBOL
Until the early 2000s, club football in South America maintained commendable competitive standards. The Brazilian, Argentinian and Mexican leagues, as well as the MLS, could compete with the top European leagues, but faced structural obstacles in terms of management, transparency and systematisation. Despite having historic clubs, fanatical supporters and substantial investments, these leagues are plagued by inconsistencies. Whilst they excel in some areas, they falter in others. Examples include Argentina's preferential treatment of the big teams, Brazil's insular global vision and the tendency to Americanise the MLS, calling into question a centuries-old tradition. In addition, Mexican leaders prioritise commercial interests over sporting ones, thus hindering the evolution of football. Perhaps internal improvements, collaboration and better continental tournaments could remedy these problems, boosting football and investment.
The MLS it’s a young league that doesn’t even have 28 years of existence, You don’t get all the league titles to be divided btw 17 of your teams by following following tradition, and what you people call Americanized it’s the reason why there is parity in the league instead of being 1-2 race horse like in most league in the world. What you call Americanized it’s the reason why all our mayor sports have more parity in their teams and the league titles than all the European leagues. It’s why we had been so successful in all sports and why we have almost 3000 Olympic medals in all sports but soccer, it’s so easy to come and judge what we are doing with MLS while ignoring the fact that all our leagues are successful and we are the most dominant sport country in the world in all sports but male’s soccer. Still the collaboration part it’s a good idea that I wished we all in America were opened to do.
Brazilian and Argentine league could compete against any european league until early 2000s, Mexican and MLS, no! They have never had a good enough league to do that. We could add some clubs from Uruguay, Paraguay, Colombia, and maybe 1 or 2 from Mexico, besides of that, no, they couldn't handle any of the major leagues in europe
@@nel186 I agree that the American model of sports development has been very successful, as demonstrated. However, although the MLS is fairly new, football has been in the US since the 19th century. After many advances and setbacks, and various reformulations, football stabilised professionally with the start of the MLS. The MLS is a young league and has managed to achieve a great balance that many European leagues no longer have. I even think that its revenue distribution system is more efficient than the European one. However, a totally "Americanised" model can overlook important cultural and historical aspects that are significant for football in other parts of the world. For example, not having a promotion and relegation system, which is common in football leagues around the world, can reduce motivation and competitiveness in some cases. This system allows smaller teams to rise to the top, encouraging more dynamic and fair development, as well as valuing cultural aspects that are essential to the football experience globally. So, while the success of the American model in various sports is clear and applying it to the MLS has its benefits, it's important to think about and respect the traditions and structures that are fundamental to football. International co-operation, exchange of experiences, training, and adaptation of successful parts of the American model, while keeping local traditions in mind, can be a more balanced and effective way of developing football in the USA.
In nations with deeply-rooted football traditions, people passionately embrace the game from a young age, with communities getting involved, fans showing dedication, and a lively culture of national and continental rivalries. This creates an environment where football thrives naturally. While the MLS can rely on the vast American economy, if it wants to go global, it needs to make some changes and really understand the established football culture. So, criticisms aimed at the MLS aren't just surface-level attacks, but genuine reflections. Unlike what some Americans might call European snobbery, personally, what I love most about American football is its fans. They might have their own way of doing things, but every nation has its own unique style of supporting their teams. The goal is to offer a different perspective that could help the league move forward, by borrowing from what works in other places while still respecting local quirks and needs. By taking these criticisms on board positively, the football leagues of CONCACAF and CONMEBOL can find a balanced path to growth and success, incorporating aspects that honour both football tradition and the innovation and fairness that defined the sport before the 2000s.
@@AlberichHasegawaVonSlyntheryin you can look it up this way when it comes to the relegation system, the mls it is bound to have at least a soccer team per state in the long run, with 50 teams in the league with relegation be added but.. in all honesty what would be the point if that’s what the play offs are for, any team that doesn’t reach the play off Can say bye bye to the league while taking a vacation trip of 4 months without playing soccer, that in itself it’s brutal. Also you have to take into consideration that MLS does not have a second division to relegate into, it works in Europe since they have a pyramid of soccer while mls doesn’t have as many teams and more importantly, MLS must make sense to Americans before anyone’s, since we are the only one that will trully support our product before anyone’s
I hope we'll never see the Série A become something like the Premier League. God forbid having a team dominate for years while the other only keep fighting for continental spots. The brazilian football have many problems, but I don't think copying the english way is the answer.
You should do a story abaut santa cruz a club that in 2006 was in top division then fell to the last division then came back shining in 2016 with name like grafite and even got be the for two round but ended up relegated back and fell of again but still having the most beloved team fans thay never let santa cruz down
You forgot to mention that Brazilian league have 20 teams, which 13 are GIANTS and even at minimum 3 are great clubs, which in other countries isn’t even close. Only in premier league it comes close, but there are only at most 6 big clubs… Being relegated doesn’t jeopardize a thing, ask locals before doing a video about others country….
Sadly there are tons of thing that ruins our league right now. 1. Bad management - there are a lot of big clubs here, that get tons of money, but manage it poorly. So because of it, there are lots of scandals involving the clubs' behind the scenes... 2. Referees - Like some people said, our referees are very bad, so there's a lot of scandals involving bad decisions favouring the big clubs, the VAR around here is a joke. 3. VAR - VAR is very disappointing here, because it takes a lot of times to make a decision (sometimes it goes from 3 to even 10 minutes of constant reviews of a goal or foul), also, the VAR is controlled by pretty much the same bad referees we have here, so it's pretty bad. 4. Prices - anything related to brazilian clubs are very expensive. For example, a regular Brasileirao team's jersey goes between 200 (in some promotions) to even 390 BRLs, and our current salary goes between 1300-1400BRLs, so it's very expensive, so a lot of people buys counterfeit stuff. Also ticket prices are pretty high. 5. Player Agents - Like some people said, our best players leave the country pretty young, with high expectations to became the next Pele and so on, so a lot of them don't live up to this expectations, so they end up in smaller teams, or coming back to Brazil to play in other clubs, but with a higher salary since "they've played in Europe" 6. Calendar - Like you've said, our calendar is very bad for the sport, like, more than 56 games besides the Copa do Brazil and Sulamericana/Libertadores is both insane and dumb. But the brazilian clubs don't give up on the smaller cups, our "Estaduais", like Paulistao, Cariocao and so on, which doesn't add anything to the big clubs, just for the smaller ones. It would be smarter to just create another division, like a 5th or even 6th division, to include the smaller teams.
Man, football has become a reflection of the history and economy of today's society, the Brazilian is the most fun championship in the world, but we have our financial limitations due to our currency, which makes it very difficult to compete with Real Madrid that pays in euros, not to mention European society, which is extremely Eurocentric and doesn't pay much attention to what happens outside of there
@Lia-dx9hg I'd disagree. The only reason behind brazils domesic league not being on top of the global game is the lack of investment, and that is basically it
Heard about colonialism? You’d be amazed how that affects even football leagues outside of Europe. Definitely not the only problem in ours, but the biggest one for sure.
Anos e anos de macaquil independente e a culpa é sempre do europeu. O latino vive da demagogia e estadolatria, mas ainda não sabe porque está na latrina atual.
@@sr_ryoadm O Governo Milei na Argentina vai provar que você está errado e que o problema não é só isso oque você diz, veja os Clubes Grandes da Europa nenhum deles seriam oque são com a Próprias Pernas eles dependem do Investimento e Patrocínio dos Árabes, além de quase sempre pegarem Treinadores e Jogadores estrangeiros(não sou contra isso, até pq o Brasil faz a mesma coisa com os Países vizinhos).
In Brazil, football is played mostly by brazilians. While in europe, the football is played by…well…saudi arabia money. The fact that Brazilian clubs are able to beat European teams (with its squads composed of multi-nationality players) - as Corinthians did against Chelsea in Japan in 2012 - just shows how huge our football is.
El Brasileirão es una de las ligas más competitivas del mundo, conocida por el equilibrio entre los clubes y la imprevisibilidad de los resultados. Varios equipos tienen posibilidades de ganar el título, y la diferencia de puntos suele ser pequeña. Aunque otras ligas, como la Premier League, también son altamente competitivas, el Brasileirão se destaca por su imprevisibilidad y diversidad de campeones.
Brazil has a lot of problems: - Our economy is inferior, making any dispute between us and the rich countries for players almost impossible to win. Also this causes less people going to the stadiums and a poor infrastructure, which is really bad considering the size of Brazil. - The Brazilian football pyramid is not good. We only have four main divisions in a continental country, the lack of regional leagues is a big disadvantage for small teams. Meanwhile, England, a country smaller than many brazilian's states, has 10 tiers on its pyramid, segmented to each of England's regions. - The league TV money division is poorly divided. Last season the four relegated didn't gain anything, and the difference between the first and 16th place was tremendous. What have saved Brazil a lot in recent times is the fact that here teams also can be sold, and Company Teams are alowd, otherwise only the already rich teams with a lot of fans would thrive.
Actually, I think it is the structure of the Brasileirão, to be honest. If you notice, from Brasil's second of 5 World Cups (1962 to 2002), our league actually had knockout tournaments to define the champion, and 2002 was the last Série A with a knockout stage, with 2003 until now being league format only. And 2002 was the last World Cup with Brasil holding high the World Cup. Coincidence? I think not.
I think the fact that BIG teams like santos, vasco da gama, gremio and internacional getting relegated in recent years is not a big problem and actually makes the league nore exiting as at the start of the season you dont know if your tean will be chamapion or be in a relegation battle, dont belive me take a look at the current table.
Fluminense won the Copa Libertadores last year, but currently they are fighting to not be relegated in the National League... It is just crazy how Football works here.
There's only one reason for Brasileirão downfall of quality, economic power and looking how things are here today, I have no hope of a better future for us.
tenso que também é muito mais tenso as viagens aqui do que as que tem na Europa, na PL eles viajam no máximo a distância de São Paulo até o RJ até pq SP já é um pouco maior que o reino unido, enquanto aqui não é incomum precisar ir de fortaleza até o RJ por exemplo pra um único jogo
PL only has more money and can buy worldwide talent with south Arabia money. How many British players are in the top 5 PL teams? In Brasileirão there are more brazilians playing.
Honestly, until Brazil as a country can become economically competitive with Europe, the brazilian league will not compete, better players go to Europe because it plays better and there's nothing anyone can do while the Real is worth 1/6 of the Euro
@@Lmitinh0 but that's not all that counts, it's important to consider power of purchase, currency value, all those things. BRL is worth roughly 6 Euros, it's virtually impossible for brazilian teams to hold on to the best players.
Claro, mas a Saudita também tem uma moeda com quase o mesmo valor da do Brasil, se o Brasil quisesse investir no futebol dos grandes clubes como a arábia, teriam dinheiro tanto quanto, mas o problema não é a moeda em si, e sim pela a Europa ser a Europa, por que se você não joga a Europa, você pode ganhar tudo, fazer 2.000 em um mês que você não é melhor do mundo, o problema do Brasil é a América do sul@@gabacontri468
Very simple, foreigners can turn up their noses and say no, but it is undeniable that the Brazilian championship, the ``Brasileirão``, is the best championship in the world. Where the big teams lose to the small teams, where there is no favorite, everyone can be champion, where the championship leadership always changes from one round to another, the games are always exciting even in the last minutes. Tell me where in a championship there is this. In Spain there are only two teams, in England two or one team, in Germany only one, and so on, in France the championship is bad. Without discussion, the Brasileirão is the best championship in the world. We already have our talents by nature, our creation adding up, but the talents that are arriving from abroad, the foreigners there, are unmatched.
Actually Brasileirão Serie A is a good league, but the ref's uses everytime VAR, the young brazilians go too young for the europe or other continents, etc. But its a good league, i said this because im brazilian too, and i know that Brasileirão got potential to be better. (Also rn its the last match that Endrick is doing for Palmeiras).
State championships count as pre-season, and have bragging rights between their fanbases, which generates more revenue to their clubs in the long run of the year's season.
cara não vale a pena sacrificar a qualidade do futebol para ter mais jogos no ano, o jeito é tornar os estaduais semi profissionais e unir a libertadores com a concacaf pra gerar mais engajamento com os clubes sul americanos, também seria bom ter 18 clubes na seria A ao invés de 24 e só forem rebaixados 2 e o 15° fosse para uma repescagem com o 3° da serie B, isso faz um afunilamento melhor dos times
A little error: At 4:00 the logo of the Bundesliga is the wrong one. It is the logo of the Austrian Bundesliga ,as you can see fromm the Ball made of three Austrian flags. Not of the German Bundesliga, wich you were talking about and the text besides the logo describes.
Main problems are the lack of agreement among the teams about league terms and poor management of teams, a country with almos 200 milion of population should be self sufficient, our teams should be much bigger on economic terms, but social inequality plays a part, we can take for example my team, Ceará, northeast Brazil, we have much more fans than a lot of clubs world wide with some expectations about 3 milion fans throughout the country, close numbers have our rival Fortaleza, still we are considered rising clubs, we are now engaging on international matches and gaining relevance inside and outside the country, we have a lot of supporters, we share a 60000 capacity stadium and we are recognized inside the country with one of the best "fan party on the stadium" with chants, instruments, mosaics and stuff. Flamengo and Corinthians are both said to have about 30 milions fans each, that's crazy, and we are still relativeli unknown league.
Some comments about it: Zico is not from 50s or 60s but from 80s. Football clubs are just part of the equation to explain the money but there is also the huge contribution of a law related to sports gambling (bets), like in Premier League
people said about the young player that leaves too early, but in my comprehension, the main trouble are the field quality, we need create any tecnology to change this, and we have capacity, such as we did on agroindustry change all the solo of cerrado...
It's a matter of time for us in Brazil to start having money to compete. The other and most important issue is our calendar, which has a state championship there, together with libertadores, copa do brasil and brasileirão. We need to change the format to make clubs in higher divisions stop playing those useless championships and reduce the number of matches per year. That would help with the quality of the matches. The money part is on its way nowadays because of the new rules as well as some great management projects, such as Flamengo's, which were able to pay their debts and start having a revenue of over 1b. We are on our way to make it happen, we just need those changes. If you stop for a while to watch some high level matches like the top 5-6 facing each other you'd see that our level is great right now.
Good video, although a consideration about the Copa do Brasil: teams from all parts of the country participate in the tournament, and the first few rounds are the most entertaining, cause there's always some upset, like Internacional, a big and established team, being knocked off the competition by a team of literal amateurs that doesn't even have a club crest on Google when you search for them, or the day Palmeiras got destroyed 4x1 by Água Santa or 6x2 by Mirassol, clubs from the third and fourth division, some didn't even have a division at the time.
Football is not alien to the economic-political system that predominates on the planet, it is part of capitalism and its entire global form. With this we have leagues in the center of capitalism (Europe) with enormous potential to extract young players from countries on the periphery of capitalism, where Brazil is located. We also see European clubs buying or joining clubs from peripheral leagues, such as Bahia (Manchester City) and Bragantino (Red Bull). We can draw a parallel with any other type of commerce in capitalism, where foreign companies invest in the exploitation of resources and especially human labor in countries. What is factually an imperialist practice of the richest nations through their companies, something inherent to capitalism that requires continuous and inconsequential expansion. The consequences of this practice have been very damaging to Brazilian football and the periphery of capitalism as a whole. Brazilian clubs focus on developing and promoting athletes increasingly suited to the European market rather than developing those with "more Brazilian" characteristics. Coaches also go through this colonization process, adapting their teams due to the type of athlete and the influence of exposure to media information from European teams. Argentina winning the 2022 World Cup was practically a miracle compounded by Messi's presence in the lead and the "short tournament" factor that doesn't always reward the best team but rather that brief moment. If the World Cup were a league of all against all, we would never see a champion other than the countries at the center of capitalism. /////////////// PT BR O futebol não está alheio ao sistema econômico-político que predomina no planeta, ele está inserido no capitalismo e em toda a sua forma global. Com isso temos as ligas do centro do capitalismo (Europa) com um potencial enorme para extrair jovens jogadores dos países da periferia do capitalismo, onde o Brasil está inserido. Também vemos clubes europeus comprando ou se associando a clubes das ligas da periferia, como no Bahia (Manchester City) e Bragantino (Red Bull). Podemos fazer um paralelo como qualquer outro tipo de comércio no capitalismo, onde empresas estrangeiras investem na exploração de recursos e principalmente de trabalho humano nos países. O que é factualmente uma prática imperialista das nações mais ricas através das suas empresas, algo inerente ao capitalismo que necessita de expansão contínua e inconsequente. As consequências dessa prática têm sido muito danosa ao futebol brasileiro e da periferia do capitalismo como um todo. Clubes brasileiros focam em desenvolver e promover atletas cada vez mais adequados ao mercado europeu do que desenvolver aqueles com características "mais brasileiras". Os técnicos também passam por esse processo de colonização, adequando seus times devido ao tipo de atleta e à influência da exposição às informações midiáticas dos times europeus. A Argentina ter ganho a copa de 2022 foi praticamente um milagre composto pela presença de Messi na liderança e o fator "torneio curto" que nem sempre premia o melhor time e sim aquele breve momento. Se a copa do mundo fosse uma liga todos contra todos, jamais veríamos um campeão que não fossem os países do centro do capitalismo.
Sim, o macaquil é pobre e nos últimos 100 anos jamais adotou políticas econômicas relevantes e sustentáveis para criar riqueza. Água molhada, como diriam os ângulos.
@@sr_ryoadm Além de racista, é burro. Não entende que capitalismo é internacionall e países do sul global ocupam uma determina posição na divisão desse sistema político-econômico. Um país fora do centro do capitalismo erguer-se contra o imperialismo é logo posto como uma ameaça, vide a Venezuela que, mesmo não sendo socialista, é tratata como um país terrorista por se opor ao imperialismo dos EUA.
Meio sem nexo (pra não falar totalmente). Ao mesmo tempo que ele cita que a liga brasileira está a frente de todas as outras da América do Sul por questões financeiras, ele simplesmente ignora o gap financeiro entre o Brasil e a Inglaterra. kkkkkkk Assim fica fácil.
Brazil is too big for small teams to compete on a national level, that's why you need local state tournaments. Think of it like this: the UK is smaller than 12 of the 27 Brazilian states. This means that even in state championships alone, distances are often already bigger than national level distances in the UK.
The problem or the solution is money, that's why the Brazilian league is above the other South American leagues and that's why the English league is above the Brazilian one! Whoever has more can earn more! 🤷🏽♂️😎
All the problems for Brazil come down to: Creating a league! Yes, Brazil does not have a league. This will end the state 300, and other rubbish and unfair financial Fair Play!
I'm Brazilian. The Brazilian championship have passion, but not good quality or skills. The players are very limited, the fields are worst than European second division - the top teams have better fields, of course. Guys who are second options in Europe are absolute top player if comes to here. Is the "most competitive competition", more than Premier, but with a ULTRA LOW LEVEL. Common, the intensity of the game, the time of ball in match is other world. Brazil has no money and capacity to maintain great players anymore... We are a country become older and older, with a decline population and poverty.
Pra quem é brazuca ja sabe que o Brasileirão ta acima da premier porque os times não são tão dependentes de dinheiro para a fama dos clubes e porquê somos br né, não faz sentindo a gente prezar uma competição internacional no mesmo nível da nacional
The Brasileirão will never be the next Premier League for one simple reason: money. It's impossible to compare the economic realities. Similarly, leagues like those in Argentina, Uruguay, Paraguay, and Chile will never reach the level of the Brazilian league. However, I dare say that no other league in the world has the same level of competitiveness and excitement as the Brasileirão. While in other leagues you already know who the 2-3 title contenders will be, in Brazil it's impossible to predict, even though some teams have stood out in recent years. When it comes to excitement, the Brasileirão is unbeatable!
Brazil was the best league not long ago, a matter of 25 years when it began to deteriorate, this is because Brazilian talents go to Europe very early, because they removed restrictions on the limit of foreigners and made it easier to cast more players outside the club's country. . With restrictions on foreigners like before the 2000s, European clubs had no chance against South Americans, so much so that after they changed the rules for European leagues there was never a UEFA final without a Brazilian, do you know how crazy that is? the only nationality present in all UEFA finals is not from Europe but Brazil, Spanish are not in all finals, Germans are not present, English etc. This is because European players do not count as foreigners in the union's clubs, which would be much easier to repeat a European nationality in the finals. However, only Brazil has this brand
Futebol e famoso no brasil pq é facil de jogar, no tenis precisa da raquete, no volei da rede, no basket a cesta. Mas no futebol n precisa de nada disso, com 4 pedras vc consegui fazer 2 gol, esta pronto a partida.
Copa do Brasil >> FA CUP. Quem discordar e muito Zé oreia. Inclusive a premiação da CdB é muito atrativa e todos os grandes clubes se interessam em vencer a competição.
90 minutos sentando para ver 1, 2 ou na melhor das hipóteses 3 gols. Depois não sabe porque esse campeonato é deprimente e os mais jovens preferem assistir a premier league
brazil has only 4 national divisions, a very little quantity if compared to much smaller countries like italy or germany, where more than 10 professional/semi-professional leagues are hold at the same time this is a consequence of brazil's continental size, wich coincides in hard times for poorer clubs when it comes to transportation matters so the states competitions are very important, with each one of them having multiple divisions by itself. the only problem is that the biggest clubs in the country are forced to play these competitions, that extends for 4 months in the brazilian calender, (equivalent to a year) this not only ends with the competition of smaller clubs trying to succed around already giant clubs, but seriously affects the calendar of these bigger clubs, that are just forced to play due to these state federations pressure so brazil has multiple talented teams, with very big wasted potential, harmed due to an elitism inside the competitions that were meant to be the "entrance door" for smaller clubs into the national competitions.
The Brazilian league isn’t as big as the other leagues for two main reasons that aren’t even tied to football, which are: 1- Money: Brazilian clubs, and the entire country for that matter, can’t pay as much as the European clubs and Arabian clubs. The entire economic scenario of Brazil is vastly different than that of the EU and Europe, which makes it difficult for players to choose to come or to stay in Brazil. Less money also means the entire league is less professional, with horrible referees, subpar VAR and league equipment, bad pitches, bad training grounds, etc. Safety and quality of life: Brazil is very dangerous at the moment when compared to Europe and the international media makes it seem even worse. This makes it so world-class players never even consider coming to Brazil, as it could put their families and themselves in danger. No world-class players = no world-class league, no international interest(such as tv broadcasts, kit sales, etc.). I believe those are the two main reasons for the league not to be up there with other leading European leagues. Those issues aren’t really solvable by the league itself or the clubs as they involve the entire country’s situation. It’s still a very competitive league and very fun to watch due to its unpredictability and drama.
Indeed Brazilian League is the unique who have 12 or 13 clubs considered big ones, off couse, someone greater than others but with high level. Brazilian League could'n to be richer but is much harder than PL. Greatest Clubs from Brazil : SE Palmeiras 18x wins national CR Flamengo 14x wins national SC Corinthians 11x wins national Cruzeiro ES 10x wins national Santos FC 9x wins national São Paulo FC 8x wins national Grêmio FBPA 8x wins national CR Vasco 5x wins national Fluminense FC 5x wins national SC Inter 4x wins national C Atlético Mineiro 4x wins national C Athletico/ PR 3x wins national Botafogo FR 2x wins national EC Bahia 2x wins national Sport Club Recife 2x wins national
The main problem is that all of the good talents leave early to go to Europe, when U see all the best players who won the world for Brazil, they atleast spent 5+ years at senior level at Brazil
Back when Brazil was winning world cups, the players spent most of there careers in Brazil. That's why the Brasileiro was the best league in the world during Pele time
Great point of view! Do you think now is the EU and PL era and that maybe we could get another era where Brazilian Football comes back at forefront?
@@Sportelligence in national football Brazil has all the chance to be as strong as ever, but club football is a lost cause. The top European leagues are on totally another level when it comes to money and prestige, we will never be able to retain our best talent as we did in the past again. At least we dominate in South America, FWIW
@@Sportelligence Europe has that thing🤑🤑, so yeah, it's not happening. At least not for now.
@@Sportelligence I hope so, the more competitive football in the world the better
O duro não é discutir sobre o brasileirão e a premier league. O duro é escutar a portuguesada falar que o campeonato deles é melhor que o brasileirão.
Se vc gosta de um campeonato que mal tem 50% do tempo com bola rolando problema seu, agr achar q todo mundo tem q gostar dessa piada q é o brasileirao é loucura
O campeonato português deveria ser um estadual brasileiro kkkkk
@@Haterinsano123 quando algum jogo do campeonato português tiver relevancia tu fala!!!!! ate la o campeonato pt n chega nem aos pês do paulistão....
@@Haterinsano123Até a taça Guanabara é melhor que o campeonato português kkkkk
a qualidade tatica do campeonato eh muito superior mesmo
It'll be impossible over here in Brazil to compete with the PL due to a couple factors:
1 - The tickets are too expensive for the average wage of a working class citizen, so they of course prioritize things like food, rent, electricity, etc, and if they can just watch the matches on the television.
2 - The clubs that have more fans are stupid and want 5~20x more in tv/sponsor deals than all the other clubs, their reasoning is: "We bring more revenue due to our massive fans, so we deserve more", and that is stupid, because in time it'll transform the league in a farmers league, with only 2 or 3 teams really posing as title contenders, and others just being there doing nothing, like we see in leagues like Bundesliga, La Liga and Ligue 1.
3 - Our talent leaves the country too soon. We can't reveal any new generational talent that a club in Europe, usually Real Madrid, buys them and we don't see them again until they want to retire.
4 - The referees are a joke, there's actually a police investigation going right now, because it's obvious something shady is going on due to terrible decisions, VAR errors, wrong red cards, and so much more. Not to mention when our referees work in another country they are heavily criticized and even suspended, because they're that bad. The worst part is that CBF is against a professional referee system.
5 - The states federations have too much power, this means it's almost impossible to end the states championships, or even transform it in a U-23 tournament, and with that our calendar is insane.
There's more reasons, but with that you can get a glimpse of the shit show we have around here.
I'd add the relatively outrageous barriers between amateur and professional football in Brazil, with the main issues being the rather massive affiliation fees (to the point that i'd say affiliated "amateur" clubs are more like semi-professional rather than truly amateur), the forced profissionalization of clubs to even compete in the state leagues (in a stark contrast to the aformentiomed ref issue), so that amateur clubs cannot compete alongside professional ones unlike most other football federations, poor management of the championships thenselves (from Série A to Série D, up to the state championships eg. Amapá and Maranhão), among many other things at the structural, financial, and fundamental level.
I agree. Someone that understand reality. Yes, the football of Brasil is also bad
I just looked at one of my Football Manager saves, Flamengo played 75 games in a season getting to all the finals (state, copa lib & brasil cup). No wonder the young players burnout. Definitely need to change the state championship in my opinion, maybe Serie A & b teams enter under 22's or something
Estadual não precisa acabar
@@AmazinJ89flamengo em 2022 fez 77 jogos e olha que faltou o mundial de clubes que ficou pro outro ano.
Brazilian League is like Premier League in South America, they have the best and richest teams of the continent while the Argentinian League is like La Liga with only two powerhouses(Boca and River) to compete against brazilian teams in Libertadores.
And Equador or Colombia we could compare to Bundesliga n Serie A. League One is the only league I can't find an equal in South America
@@nonameOwhat about Paraguay?
@@crosh7851 idk much about this league tho. Maybe Jupiler League (Belgium) or even Eredivisie, cuz of the Olimpia that can be compared to Ajax in Latin America
@@nonameO oh yeah thats true maybe Eredivisie
Brazil and Argentina have a lot of wasted potential. The fan base is huge for many clubs, its a shame they are so poorly managed.
For me, the Brasileirão is better than the Premier League in terms of competitiveness. Of course the Premier has some of the best teams in the world, but it's very predictable.
Premier League = Farmers League at hand of Landlord Guardiola 😅
Em competitividade e imprevisibilidade o Brasileirão é a melhor liga do mundo
Se não fosse pelo Guardiola a Premier League seria um campeonato muito mais imprevisível.
@@SirloucoPiano mas só é competitivo por causa da inconsistência dos clubes brasileiros no geral (o famoso "nivelado por baixo), mas eu ainda acredito que no mundial de clubes os brasileiros vão surpreender e ganhar jogos desses timecos europeus
@@blackeye1304 sim, é muito disputado por serem muito parelho, mas o brasil vem dominando a america do sul nos ultimos anos... não é uma disputa baixa... mas não é a nivel PL.
One huge factor not mentioned is the size of Brazil, a country as big as the USA, while the league isnt divided in two, like the NBA or MLS. Several times, clubs have to waste a day going/returning to the other side of the country, while in the UK the longest trip wouldnt take more than an hour flight/train.
Por isso que não faz sentido impor campeonato de pontos corridos com turno/returno e querer abolir os estaduais. Os estaduais surgiram da característica e necessidade do nosso país, fazem parte da história e cultura nacional. Campeonatos estaduais/regionais podem ser a solução.
@@irwingbrasilFaça os times grandes entrarem só nas quartas de final. Os estaduais serviram em sua época, hoje podem ser reformulados. Os estaduais no Brasil poderiam ser o que já foram com a Taça de Prata, que é de fato a antiga copa do Brasil, um campeonato regional onde o campeão joga com os outros campeões estaduais.
Os estaduais surgiram da carência de capacidade de transporte no Brasil, e mesmo com essa capacidade é uma quantidade insana de viagem. O campeonato deveria ser dividido em conferências como a NBA/NFL, até financeiramente os clubes poderiam conseguir mais investimento, já que um time que jamais ganharia o brasileiro poderia, pelo menos, ser campeão da conferência e disputar o título.
Faz SP+SUL e RJ+MG+nordeste
A resposta é muito simples. O Brasil só não tem o maior campeonato do mundo por falta de dinheiro. À partir do momento que injetarem dinheiro no nosso campeonato, seja por meio de patrocínios ou por compradores árabes, o Brasil será imparável.
A questão é que isso é muito difícil de acontecer.
Brasileirão n precisa de investimento de fora. A liga já tem muito reconhecimento do país, não precisa de investimento de fora, mas ninguém rejeitaria se tivesse
Acho que não, acredito que na verdade o Brasileirão B e inferiores são os que mais precisam de investimentos financeiros. Mas para o campeonato principal, eu acredito que seja realmente a questão de manter as suas preciosas jóias em solo nacional.
Na verdade é uma visão limitada achar que é apenas isso.
Nem no exterior excesso de dinheiro é sinônimo de êxito. Excesso de dinheiro aqui só vai fazer jogadores ruins ganharem 500mil por mês (e isso já está acontecendo).
Se o Brasil se inspirasse na EPL, certamente priorizaria 2 coisas essencias para valorização do produto futebol : Velocidade e Tempo de Jogo de Qualidade.
Isso eliminaria :
- Cera dos jogadores
- Grama sem padrão ou de baixa qualidade
- Usar o desconforto pro adversário no dia do jogo como vantagem competitiva
- A Necessidade do juiz parar o jogo inteiro para proteger seu "emprego"
Além disso, se organizando como Liga, eles podem juntos escolher o melhor formato de distribuição desse "produto" e com isso não ficar dependendo de uma única emissora para distribuição dos jogos. Isso torna o produto mais acessível, mais rentável e menos dependente de influencia de grandes grupos de midia. Também pode ser capaz de exportar o campeonato como nunca antes foi possível. Com streaming o publico pode ver o jogo inteiro em outro horário e a questão do fuso horário é atenuada.
As polemicas nunca serão extintas nem os erros. Ainda existem muitos erros de arbitragem na EPL, sobretudo no VAR, que dado o tempo limitado de decisão, eles ainda cometem erros bobos. Mas acredito que com o tempo a tecnologia e os processos do VAR vão evoluir sem comprometer o tempo do jogo e vai acrescentar mais justiça nas partidas.
O principal problema é o câmbio. 1 real pra 6.56 libras. Nos anos 90 o real chegou a ser 1 pra 1 com dolar e euro. Ficou muito tempo tbm na paridade 1 pra 1 pra 2/ 1 pra 3. A nossa moeda foi se esfarelando e os melhores jogadores foram indo embora. Nos anos 90 dava pra segurar os jogadores, hoje é impossível competir. Ainda mais com a PL. 2 jogadores top’s do Liverpool equivalem a folha inteira do Palmeiras, atual Bicampeão. A liga brasileira nunca vai chegar nem perto da Premier League
Pra conseguir isso precisa de um produto bom kkkkkk por isso o modelo de negócio da Premier League funciona. Não é magicamente que aparecem investidores.
finally some respect for our league
I absolutely LOVEEEEE Brazilian football! So much more exciting than EU leagues if you follow it closely
@@Sportelligence A big problem here is the terrible quality of the pitches. Just Neo Química Arena and Morumbis have a descent pitches
@@Sportelligenceloving is not living. But glad you love it
I actually felt this was the opposite of "giving respect" to Brazilian tournaments and clubs.
Saying local state championships are meaningless and hosting the FA Cup is a contradiction in itself.
It's like saying no country that plays UCL should play their own national championship. Even knowing that there are Brazilian states that are bigger in territory and population than European countries, and have GDP that matches a few of them.
That's actually doing us dirty in comparison.
@@estouaquipraaprenderEngland has 7 divisions and definitely don't have UEFA standards on every pitch they play in.
We may have pitches in terrible state in Brazil, but so do they in England.
Stop trying to make us look bad in comparison.
The quality of football is not the same, nowadays. It started to derail completely when the rule of only three foreigners per team was abolished in Europe. We couldn't keep the best talent, now we can't keep the "medium" talent too. But it's still one of the most balanced leagues in the world.
Ouvir gringo falando que estadual tem que desaparecer dá um nojo que não tem como descrever.
Not to mention the countless world-renowned players who have played in Brazil over the last 12 years, Forlan, who was the best player at the World Cup in 2010, was here playing for Internacional, along with Sedoorf at Botafogo, Ronaldinho champion of the Libertadores at Atlético Mineiro, with Neymar still at Santos, all of this in 2013, that's crazy, not to mention others, like Luis Suárez, Payet, Juanfran, Daniel Alves, Marcelo, Diego Costa, Douglas Costa, Lucas Moura, James Rodríguez, Fernandinho, Hulk, Vidal, Coutinho and Thiago Silva returning now, Honda, Medel, Borré, Bolasie, David Luiz, Pato, Ener Valencia who played an incredible cup with Ecuador, and others who were trained here but shine in Europe such as Paqueta, Vinicius Junior, Alisson, Casemiro, Gabriel Jesus... and the local stars who may not be recognized in Europe, but in South America there are a lot, such as De La Cruz, Arrascaeta, Raphael Veiga, Arboleda, Gustavo Gomez, Piquerez, Viña... Anyway, the rest of the world doesn't know what it's missing.
all that being said I still prefer watching a brasileirão match over a premier leagye one any day
Tá maluco, Brasileirao só vejo jogo do meu time, Premier League qualquer jogo vale a pena assistir
@@tiagozimermann9028muito divertido assistir um campeonato que ja tem um campeão definido (Manchester city)
@@nsueti mano, a pergunta não foi sobre qual campeonato é mais disputado e sim sobre qual jogo é mais legal de assistir, um de PL ou um de Brasileirao
The only real disparity is money, that’s it.
I'm Brazilian.
The Brazilian championship have passion, but not good quality or skills.
The players are very limited, the fields are worst than European second division - the top teams have better fields, of course. Guys who are second options in Europe are absolute top player if comes to here.
Is the "most competitive competition", more than Premier, but with a ULTRA LOW LEVEL. Common, the intensity of the game, the time of ball in match is other world. Brazil has no money and capacity to maintain great players anymore... We are a country become older and older, with a decline population and poverty.
@@sr_ryoadm all of these would be solved with more money
@@sr_ryoadmThat's only true bc all the good players leave and go play in Europe. The point stil stands, it's basically just a money difference.
@@sr_ryoadm So I'm watching another Brazilian championship, because in the Brazilian championship I saw, the players in the league have a very good technical level, it's no wonder that many from there are exported to Europe, you must be watching the Venezuelan championship, you must have gotten confused.
In Brazil we know we are certainly behind main Europeans leagues, our best players always leave too early and come back too late but our league is not amateur as many Europeans think, a fair comparison today would be, French Ligue 1 without PSG. In the 70's, 80's and 90's our league was top 3 in the world.
You should also consider the geography of Brazil and the time and money teams spend with travelling a continental country
No one in Brazil ever heard about Thomas Donohoe. The man who brought football to Brazil was called Charles Miller.
thomas donohoe teve seu primeiro jogo de futebol no brasil um ano antes do charles miller
"Thomas Donohoe, the "Father Of Brazilian Football", was a master dyer in the calico printing industry. Thomas emigrated to Brazil in 1894.[1] He organized football matches in Bangu (now a suburb of Rio de Janeiro) that year with fellow employees of the textile company Progresso Industrial Do Brazil.
Charles Miller, who some others claim to have brought football to Brazil, arranged his first match in April of the following year in São Paulo".
essa estória de charles miller é coisa de paulista... todo mundo sabe que os britânicos quando vieram pro Brasil prá construir hidrelétricas, estradas de ferro, pontes, instalar industrias muito antes desse tal de charles miller já jogavam futebol em terras brasileiras... conta ess tua aí prá outro paulista otário.
@@fernandoroberts3591 Há registro de jogos de futebol aqui em Juiz de Fora em 1893!! Essa discussão é meio sem fim, mas Charles Miller entrou no mito da chegada do futebol ao Brasil
Thank you for this video as a Brazilian I love my league and I hope more people watch it.
The gap 💲💲💲
That’s another easy way to put it 😅😂
We do not have a league or a high-level professional organization. I didn't know that the CBF now had fans.
💷💷💷💷💷💷💷💷💷💷
@@psiutubemano tu é brasileiro?
Brazilian Serie A is already better than Italy Serie A and Portuguese League and a all the rest of the european leagues: greek, turkish, ukranian, scottish, danish, belgian, etc. It only won't beat Premier, La Liga and Bundesliga, by this order.
The problem here is money: taxes and the value in comparison with euros and dollars. Period.
Perfectly Resumed the video in one sentence. Thank You Eric ;)
In fact i would say the same. Even the italian serie A clubs being richer, like in transfermarkt, what happens is: the same player playing to a Brazilian club worths 10m euro, when he's sold to any of the major european league clubs, their price grows at least 3x just by changing club, for no other reason than the fact that now they can clash against the best clubs in the world, and being able to handle a game against them improve their price. I don't see fairness in that, but it is what it is, meanwhile our players that keep in Brazil only plays agains other south american clubs, which is like the 3rd tier of europe, like east european leagues. That being said, if Brazil were in Europe, or Brazilian clubs play with european clubs more often in friendlies or even in some cups, surely their revenue and market price would be bigger than Ligue 1 in France and Serie A Italiana
I'm Brazilian.
The Brazilian championship have passion, but not good quality or skills.
The players are very limited, the fields are worst than European second division - the top teams have better fields, of course. Guys who are second options in Europe are absolute top player if comes to here.
Is the "most competitive competition", more than Premier, but with a ULTRA LOW LEVEL. Common, the intensity of the game, the time of ball in match is other world. Brazil has no money and capacity to maintain great players anymore... We are a country become older and older, with a decline population and poverty.
Zico is from the late 70's, I think you mean Zito, another brazilian legend
middle 70's.
I think the problem is that since the 90s, brazilian players go to europe in their prime (and now they barely play in Brasileirão) because of the financial gap between Europe and Brazil. Anyway, beside Brasileirão having a lower level than Premier League, Serie A, Bundesliga and LaLiga, I think is a funnier league because of that's so balanced, competitive and unpredictable. Btw I think Brasileirão has a similar level to Portuguese, French and Netherlands league, but I hope so much in the future Brasileirão can be the highest level of football in the world as it was in the 60s~70s
🤣🤣 if you think the Brasileirão is the same level as the Portuguese, Dutch or French league, you have no clue what you're talking about dude
I mean, I'm brazilian but I'm not delusional to say our league is at Premier League or La Liga standards yet (although I think it's already the most unpredictable and fun league out there), but the French, Dutch or Portuguese leagues are WAY below our level overall; they all have like 1 or 2 decent teams each, and the rest of them would have a hard time even in our second division league 😂
@@guilhermejurgensen5068vdd
Amigo o brasileirao já é melhor que o campeonato francês é português fácil... basta vir aqui e ver de perto. Acho que você não assistiu o Brasileirao de 2023 para está falando uma loucura dessas... 😂😂
Brazilian footbal has huge potential, but we still have barriers that we can't get along:
1- The local time is too late for other countries to watch live games. We are like +4-5h of most european countries, and even more to arabic countries, what makes them not so attractive to watch.
2- Brazil's currency (BRL) worths less than 1/5 EUR and almost 1/7 Sterlings (from UK). That's a huge gap. Even thou Brazil has the highest amount of money investing at football in South America, it's way less than european top leagues.
3- More money, more power. This causes our biggest talents to leave the country too early. By the recent example of Endrick and Estevao, both from Palmeiras, and both sold for 60 million EUR to Real Madrid and Chelsea respectively. Naming those, but not forgeting about Neymar, Ronaldinho Gaúcho and many other brazilian stars.
4- Most of Brazilian people don't have money to spend with and support their favorite clubs. A regular brazilian club's jersey costs like almost 500 BRL, which is almost a third of minimum salary.
5- And, as you mentioned, there are clubs with way less support and relevance than other, which makes even more unbalanced.
And these are just to mention a few barriers. There are others.
Brazilian here, I'm 100% in favor of making teams in higher leagues stop playing the state championships, at least, with their main teams, make it that Serie A teams can only play their U17, B their U18, C their U20, or just stop playing it altogether, the main team doesn't need that, and the U17/18 teams would keep the state leagues relevant so supporters can still watch their beloved team.
Another thing that I don't like in the Brasileirão, is the limitation of players from other countries, last time I checked, it was 5 or 7, for teams that have 32-36 players, having only 5 or 7 foreigners is bad, as you can see in the PL, having tons of foreigners increase the quality of the game.
Zico played from the middle 70' till the 80' final. Then he moved to Japan and became the father of japanese football
We got the best and most passionate league in the world, but those bastards players prefer money.
Not their fault, honestly
The main problem is that the organizers and owners of soccer in brazil don't want to solve the problems that keep the league average.There is talent, passion and room for growth, but we don't see the will.
O Campeonato Brasileiro é o único de vinte clubes que rebaixa quatro times todo ano por isso vários grandes cairam como 17, além disso hoje são pelo menos 13 equipes que participam de campeonatos da CONMEBOL
Until the early 2000s, club football in South America maintained commendable competitive standards. The Brazilian, Argentinian and Mexican leagues, as well as the MLS, could compete with the top European leagues, but faced structural obstacles in terms of management, transparency and systematisation. Despite having historic clubs, fanatical supporters and substantial investments, these leagues are plagued by inconsistencies. Whilst they excel in some areas, they falter in others. Examples include Argentina's preferential treatment of the big teams, Brazil's insular global vision and the tendency to Americanise the MLS, calling into question a centuries-old tradition. In addition, Mexican leaders prioritise commercial interests over sporting ones, thus hindering the evolution of football. Perhaps internal improvements, collaboration and better continental tournaments could remedy these problems, boosting football and investment.
The MLS it’s a young league that doesn’t even have 28 years of existence, You don’t get all the league titles to be divided btw 17 of your teams by following following tradition, and what you people call Americanized it’s the reason why there is parity in the league instead of being 1-2 race horse like in most league in the world. What you call Americanized it’s the reason why all our mayor sports have more parity in their teams and the league titles than all the European leagues. It’s why we had been so successful in all sports and why we have almost 3000 Olympic medals in all sports but soccer, it’s so easy to come and judge what we are doing with MLS while ignoring the fact that all our leagues are successful and we are the most dominant sport country in the world in all sports but male’s soccer. Still the collaboration part it’s a good idea that I wished we all in America were opened to do.
Brazilian and Argentine league could compete against any european league until early 2000s, Mexican and MLS, no! They have never had a good enough league to do that. We could add some clubs from Uruguay, Paraguay, Colombia, and maybe 1 or 2 from Mexico, besides of that, no, they couldn't handle any of the major leagues in europe
@@nel186
I agree that the American model of sports development has been very successful, as demonstrated. However, although the MLS is fairly new, football has been in the US since the 19th century. After many advances and setbacks, and various reformulations, football stabilised professionally with the start of the MLS.
The MLS is a young league and has managed to achieve a great balance that many European leagues no longer have. I even think that its revenue distribution system is more efficient than the European one. However, a totally "Americanised" model can overlook important cultural and historical aspects that are significant for football in other parts of the world.
For example, not having a promotion and relegation system, which is common in football leagues around the world, can reduce motivation and competitiveness in some cases. This system allows smaller teams to rise to the top, encouraging more dynamic and fair development, as well as valuing cultural aspects that are essential to the football experience globally.
So, while the success of the American model in various sports is clear and applying it to the MLS has its benefits, it's important to think about and respect the traditions and structures that are fundamental to football. International co-operation, exchange of experiences, training, and adaptation of successful parts of the American model, while keeping local traditions in mind, can be a more balanced and effective way of developing football in the USA.
In nations with deeply-rooted football traditions, people passionately embrace the game from a young age, with communities getting involved, fans showing dedication, and a lively culture of national and continental rivalries. This creates an environment where football thrives naturally. While the MLS can rely on the vast American economy, if it wants to go global, it needs to make some changes and really understand the established football culture. So, criticisms aimed at the MLS aren't just surface-level attacks, but genuine reflections. Unlike what some Americans might call European snobbery, personally, what I love most about American football is its fans. They might have their own way of doing things, but every nation has its own unique style of supporting their teams. The goal is to offer a different perspective that could help the league move forward, by borrowing from what works in other places while still respecting local quirks and needs. By taking these criticisms on board positively, the football leagues of CONCACAF and CONMEBOL can find a balanced path to growth and success, incorporating aspects that honour both football tradition and the innovation and fairness that defined the sport before the 2000s.
@@AlberichHasegawaVonSlyntheryin you can look it up this way when it comes to the relegation system, the mls it is bound to have at least a soccer team per state in the long run, with 50 teams in the league with relegation be added but.. in all honesty what would be the point if that’s what the play offs are for, any team that doesn’t reach the play off Can say bye bye to the league while taking a vacation trip of 4 months without playing soccer, that in itself it’s brutal. Also you have to take into consideration that MLS does not have a second division to relegate into, it works in Europe since they have a pyramid of soccer while mls doesn’t have as many teams and more importantly, MLS must make sense to Americans before anyone’s, since we are the only one that will trully support our product before anyone’s
I hope we'll never see the Série A become something like the Premier League. God forbid having a team dominate for years while the other only keep fighting for continental spots. The brazilian football have many problems, but I don't think copying the english way is the answer.
You should do a story abaut santa cruz a club that in 2006 was in top division then fell to the last division then came back shining in 2016 with name like grafite and even got be the for two round but ended up relegated back and fell of again but still having the most beloved team fans thay never let santa cruz down
Its a bit saddening to see Santa Cruz's current decade-long downward spiral - from being a giant in the early 2000s to losing to *Íbis* of all teams.
You forgot to mention that Brazilian league have 20 teams, which 13 are GIANTS and even at minimum 3 are great clubs, which in other countries isn’t even close. Only in premier league it comes close, but there are only at most 6 big clubs… Being relegated doesn’t jeopardize a thing, ask locals before doing a video about others country….
Brasil vai chegar lá, aguardem!
Sadly there are tons of thing that ruins our league right now.
1. Bad management - there are a lot of big clubs here, that get tons of money, but manage it poorly. So because of it, there are lots of scandals involving the clubs' behind the scenes...
2. Referees - Like some people said, our referees are very bad, so there's a lot of scandals involving bad decisions favouring the big clubs, the VAR around here is a joke.
3. VAR - VAR is very disappointing here, because it takes a lot of times to make a decision (sometimes it goes from 3 to even 10 minutes of constant reviews of a goal or foul), also, the VAR is controlled by pretty much the same bad referees we have here, so it's pretty bad.
4. Prices - anything related to brazilian clubs are very expensive. For example, a regular Brasileirao team's jersey goes between 200 (in some promotions) to even 390 BRLs, and our current salary goes between 1300-1400BRLs, so it's very expensive, so a lot of people buys counterfeit stuff. Also ticket prices are pretty high.
5. Player Agents - Like some people said, our best players leave the country pretty young, with high expectations to became the next Pele and so on, so a lot of them don't live up to this expectations, so they end up in smaller teams, or coming back to Brazil to play in other clubs, but with a higher salary since "they've played in Europe"
6. Calendar - Like you've said, our calendar is very bad for the sport, like, more than 56 games besides the Copa do Brazil and Sulamericana/Libertadores is both insane and dumb. But the brazilian clubs don't give up on the smaller cups, our "Estaduais", like Paulistao, Cariocao and so on, which doesn't add anything to the big clubs, just for the smaller ones. It would be smarter to just create another division, like a 5th or even 6th division, to include the smaller teams.
Calendário ser grande não é uma burrice.
Zico is from the 80s
Final do anos 70 e anos 80
Oh, if ALL teams from Brazil were 2019 flamengo every season 😍.
👃👃👃👃👃
👃👃👃👃👃👃👃
Man, football has become a reflection of the history and economy of today's society, the Brazilian is the most fun championship in the world, but we have our financial limitations due to our currency, which makes it very difficult to compete with Real Madrid that pays in euros, not to mention European society, which is extremely Eurocentric and doesn't pay much attention to what happens outside of there
Some of the facts in this video are wrong. Not every state in brazil has a pre season competition, also Brazil has 26 states, not 27
Wrong.
Brazil has a state championship for each state + one exclusively for the capital, Brasilia. So, 27 championships.
He may not have explained it correctly, but the message he gave is 100% right
@vitoraugusto9596 the federal district of brazil is not a state, just like in the United States
@Lia-dx9hg I'd disagree. The only reason behind brazils domesic league not being on top of the global game is the lack of investment, and that is basically it
Also he said that zico played in the 60s???
Heard about colonialism? You’d be amazed how that affects even football leagues outside of Europe. Definitely not the only problem in ours, but the biggest one for sure.
Anos e anos de macaquil independente e a culpa é sempre do europeu. O latino vive da demagogia e estadolatria, mas ainda não sabe porque está na latrina atual.
@@sr_ryoadm O Governo Milei na Argentina vai provar que você está errado e que o problema não é só isso oque você diz, veja os Clubes Grandes da Europa nenhum deles seriam oque são com a Próprias Pernas eles dependem do Investimento e Patrocínio dos Árabes, além de quase sempre pegarem Treinadores e Jogadores estrangeiros(não sou contra isso, até pq o Brasil faz a mesma coisa com os Países vizinhos).
In Brazil, football is played mostly by brazilians. While in europe, the football is played by…well…saudi arabia money.
The fact that Brazilian clubs are able to beat European teams (with its squads composed of multi-nationality players) - as Corinthians did against Chelsea in Japan in 2012 - just shows how huge our football is.
Mano no futebol brasileiro tem muitos Uruguaios e argentinos e chilenos cara
@@Nícolasborusssiadortmund faz o seguinte, vai em um Google tradutor da vida e pesquisa o significado da palavra “mostly”
@@NícolasborusssiadortmundPega a quantidade de gringo por time e compara.
El Brasileirão es una de las ligas más competitivas del mundo, conocida por el equilibrio entre los clubes y la imprevisibilidad de los resultados. Varios equipos tienen posibilidades de ganar el título, y la diferencia de puntos suele ser pequeña. Aunque otras ligas, como la Premier League, también son altamente competitivas, el Brasileirão se destaca por su imprevisibilidad y diversidad de campeones.
Brazil has a lot of problems:
- Our economy is inferior, making any dispute between us and the rich countries for players almost impossible to win. Also this causes less people going to the stadiums and a poor infrastructure, which is really bad considering the size of Brazil.
- The Brazilian football pyramid is not good. We only have four main divisions in a continental country, the lack of regional leagues is a big disadvantage for small teams. Meanwhile, England, a country smaller than many brazilian's states, has 10 tiers on its pyramid, segmented to each of England's regions.
- The league TV money division is poorly divided. Last season the four relegated didn't gain anything, and the difference between the first and 16th place was tremendous.
What have saved Brazil a lot in recent times is the fact that here teams also can be sold, and Company Teams are alowd, otherwise only the already rich teams with a lot of fans would thrive.
Actually, I think it is the structure of the Brasileirão, to be honest. If you notice, from Brasil's second of 5 World Cups (1962 to 2002), our league actually had knockout tournaments to define the champion, and 2002 was the last Série A with a knockout stage, with 2003 until now being league format only.
And 2002 was the last World Cup with Brasil holding high the World Cup.
Coincidence? I think not.
UK is the size of a single state in Brazil, the teams spend alot of money to move the team through the country
I think the fact that BIG teams like santos, vasco da gama, gremio and internacional getting relegated in recent years is not a big problem and actually makes the league nore exiting as at the start of the season you dont know if your tean will be chamapion or be in a relegation battle, dont belive me take a look at the current table.
Fluminense won the Copa Libertadores last year, but currently they are fighting to not be relegated in the National League... It is just crazy how Football works here.
@@RNvideosedits i support flumimense...
There's only one reason for Brasileirão downfall of quality, economic power and looking how things are here today, I have no hope of a better future for us.
tenso que também é muito mais tenso as viagens aqui do que as que tem na Europa, na PL eles viajam no máximo a distância de São Paulo até o RJ até pq SP já é um pouco maior que o reino unido, enquanto aqui não é incomum precisar ir de fortaleza até o RJ por exemplo pra um único jogo
@@vlone323 exatamente a gente tem bem menos dinheiro e ainda precisa de uma logística muito maior, simplesmente n tem o q fazer
PL only has more money and can buy worldwide talent with south Arabia money. How many British players are in the top 5 PL teams? In Brasileirão there are more brazilians playing.
Honestly, until Brazil as a country can become economically competitive with Europe, the brazilian league will not compete, better players go to Europe because it plays better and there's nothing anyone can do while the Real is worth 1/6 of the Euro
Brazil is the 9th largest economy in the world...
@@Lmitinh0 but that's not all that counts, it's important to consider power of purchase, currency value, all those things. BRL is worth roughly 6 Euros, it's virtually impossible for brazilian teams to hold on to the best players.
Claro, mas a Saudita também tem uma moeda com quase o mesmo valor da do Brasil, se o Brasil quisesse investir no futebol dos grandes clubes como a arábia, teriam dinheiro tanto quanto, mas o problema não é a moeda em si, e sim pela a Europa ser a Europa, por que se você não joga a Europa, você pode ganhar tudo, fazer 2.000 em um mês que você não é melhor do mundo, o problema do Brasil é a América do sul@@gabacontri468
Além do Flamengo* (clube brasileiro*) faturar mais de 1 bilhão por ano, muito mais q grande clubes da Europa
Very simple, foreigners can turn up their noses and say no, but it is undeniable that the Brazilian championship, the ``Brasileirão``, is the best championship in the world. Where the big teams lose to the small teams, where there is no favorite, everyone can be champion, where the championship leadership always changes from one round to another, the games are always exciting even in the last minutes. Tell me where in a championship there is this. In Spain there are only two teams, in England two or one team, in Germany only one, and so on, in France the championship is bad. Without discussion, the Brasileirão is the best championship in the world. We already have our talents by nature, our creation adding up, but the talents that are arriving from abroad, the foreigners there, are unmatched.
Actually Brasileirão Serie A is a good league, but the ref's uses everytime VAR, the young brazilians go too young for the europe or other continents, etc.
But its a good league, i said this because im brazilian too, and i know that Brasileirão got potential to be better.
(Also rn its the last match that Endrick is doing for Palmeiras).
State championships count as pre-season, and have bragging rights between their fanbases, which generates more revenue to their clubs in the long run of the year's season.
cara não vale a pena sacrificar a qualidade do futebol para ter mais jogos no ano, o jeito é tornar os estaduais semi profissionais e unir a libertadores com a concacaf pra gerar mais engajamento com os clubes sul americanos, também seria bom ter 18 clubes na seria A ao invés de 24 e só forem rebaixados 2 e o 15° fosse para uma repescagem com o 3° da serie B, isso faz um afunilamento melhor dos times
Brasileirão is the best in the world!
I get you point, but just wanted to add: we do have an "FA Cup" it's called Copa do Brasil.
A little error:
At 4:00 the logo of the Bundesliga is the wrong one.
It is the logo of the Austrian Bundesliga ,as you can see fromm the Ball made of three Austrian flags.
Not of the German Bundesliga, wich you were talking about and the text besides the logo describes.
Main problems are the lack of agreement among the teams about league terms and poor management of teams, a country with almos 200 milion of population should be self sufficient, our teams should be much bigger on economic terms, but social inequality plays a part, we can take for example my team, Ceará, northeast Brazil, we have much more fans than a lot of clubs world wide with some expectations about 3 milion fans throughout the country, close numbers have our rival Fortaleza, still we are considered rising clubs, we are now engaging on international matches and gaining relevance inside and outside the country, we have a lot of supporters, we share a 60000 capacity stadium and we are recognized inside the country with one of the best "fan party on the stadium" with chants, instruments, mosaics and stuff. Flamengo and Corinthians are both said to have about 30 milions fans each, that's crazy, and we are still relativeli unknown league.
Some comments about it: Zico is not from 50s or 60s but from 80s. Football clubs are just part of the equation to explain the money but there is also the huge contribution of a law related to sports gambling (bets), like in Premier League
Only 4 world cup tittles?. Well played mate... you created a way to make people come here and comment in anyway.
Não, ele falou da de 58 também....
zico nos anos 50 e 60 kkkkkkkkkkkkk
Acontece, um errinho leve
people said about the young player that leaves too early, but in my comprehension, the main trouble are the field quality, we need create any tecnology to change this, and we have capacity, such as we did on agroindustry change all the solo of cerrado...
As a brazilian I say is the lawn
It's a matter of time for us in Brazil to start having money to compete. The other and most important issue is our calendar, which has a state championship there, together with libertadores, copa do brasil and brasileirão. We need to change the format to make clubs in higher divisions stop playing those useless championships and reduce the number of matches per year. That would help with the quality of the matches. The money part is on its way nowadays because of the new rules as well as some great management projects, such as Flamengo's, which were able to pay their debts and start having a revenue of over 1b. We are on our way to make it happen, we just need those changes. If you stop for a while to watch some high level matches like the top 5-6 facing each other you'd see that our level is great right now.
as fan of two teams one in each competition (Liverpool and São Paulo) The Brasileirao is funnyer to watch, the games are too unpredictable
Good video, although a consideration about the Copa do Brasil: teams from all parts of the country participate in the tournament, and the first few rounds are the most entertaining, cause there's always some upset, like Internacional, a big and established team, being knocked off the competition by a team of literal amateurs that doesn't even have a club crest on Google when you search for them, or the day Palmeiras got destroyed 4x1 by Água Santa or 6x2 by Mirassol, clubs from the third and fourth division, some didn't even have a division at the time.
claro! aumentar as chances de conversão de gol vai com certeza elevar o patamar do brasileirão às principais ligas europeias🔥
Vai deixar o campeonato menos chato, pelo menos.
com todo o respeito…
o brasileirão é o campeonato mais disputado e emocionante do mundo
Football is not alien to the economic-political system that predominates on the planet, it is part of capitalism and its entire global form.
With this we have leagues in the center of capitalism (Europe) with enormous potential to extract young players from countries on the periphery of capitalism, where Brazil is located.
We also see European clubs buying or joining clubs from peripheral leagues, such as Bahia (Manchester City) and Bragantino (Red Bull). We can draw a parallel with any other type of commerce in capitalism, where foreign companies invest in the exploitation of resources and especially human labor in countries. What is factually an imperialist practice of the richest nations through their companies, something inherent to capitalism that requires continuous and inconsequential expansion.
The consequences of this practice have been very damaging to Brazilian football and the periphery of capitalism as a whole. Brazilian clubs focus on developing and promoting athletes increasingly suited to the European market rather than developing those with "more Brazilian" characteristics. Coaches also go through this colonization process, adapting their teams due to the type of athlete and the influence of exposure to media information from European teams.
Argentina winning the 2022 World Cup was practically a miracle compounded by Messi's presence in the lead and the "short tournament" factor that doesn't always reward the best team but rather that brief moment. If the World Cup were a league of all against all, we would never see a champion other than the countries at the center of capitalism.
///////////////
PT BR
O futebol não está alheio ao sistema econômico-político que predomina no planeta, ele está inserido no capitalismo e em toda a sua forma global.
Com isso temos as ligas do centro do capitalismo (Europa) com um potencial enorme para extrair jovens jogadores dos países da periferia do capitalismo, onde o Brasil está inserido.
Também vemos clubes europeus comprando ou se associando a clubes das ligas da periferia, como no Bahia (Manchester City) e Bragantino (Red Bull). Podemos fazer um paralelo como qualquer outro tipo de comércio no capitalismo, onde empresas estrangeiras investem na exploração de recursos e principalmente de trabalho humano nos países. O que é factualmente uma prática imperialista das nações mais ricas através das suas empresas, algo inerente ao capitalismo que necessita de expansão contínua e inconsequente.
As consequências dessa prática têm sido muito danosa ao futebol brasileiro e da periferia do capitalismo como um todo. Clubes brasileiros focam em desenvolver e promover atletas cada vez mais adequados ao mercado europeu do que desenvolver aqueles com características "mais brasileiras". Os técnicos também passam por esse processo de colonização, adequando seus times devido ao tipo de atleta e à influência da exposição às informações midiáticas dos times europeus.
A Argentina ter ganho a copa de 2022 foi praticamente um milagre composto pela presença de Messi na liderança e o fator "torneio curto" que nem sempre premia o melhor time e sim aquele breve momento. Se a copa do mundo fosse uma liga todos contra todos, jamais veríamos um campeão que não fossem os países do centro do capitalismo.
Sim, o macaquil é pobre e nos últimos 100 anos jamais adotou políticas econômicas relevantes e sustentáveis para criar riqueza.
Água molhada, como diriam os ângulos.
@@sr_ryoadm Além de racista, é burro.
Não entende que capitalismo é internacionall e países do sul global ocupam uma determina posição na divisão desse sistema político-econômico. Um país fora do centro do capitalismo erguer-se contra o imperialismo é logo posto como uma ameaça, vide a Venezuela que, mesmo não sendo socialista, é tratata como um país terrorista por se opor ao imperialismo dos EUA.
@@sr_ryoadm Além de r4c1sta, é burr0!
Meio sem nexo (pra não falar totalmente).
Ao mesmo tempo que ele cita que a liga brasileira está a frente de todas as outras da América do Sul por questões financeiras, ele simplesmente ignora o gap financeiro entre o Brasil e a Inglaterra. kkkkkkk
Assim fica fácil.
Brazil is too big for small teams to compete on a national level, that's why you need local state tournaments. Think of it like this: the UK is smaller than 12 of the 27 Brazilian states. This means that even in state championships alone, distances are often already bigger than national level distances in the UK.
behind in structure, logistic and organization
far ahead in talent and dedication/vocation
The problem or the solution is money, that's why the Brazilian league is above the other South American leagues and that's why the English league is above the Brazilian one! Whoever has more can earn more! 🤷🏽♂️😎
All the problems for Brazil come down to: Creating a league! Yes, Brazil does not have a league. This will end the state 300, and other rubbish and unfair financial Fair Play!
I'm Brazilian.
The Brazilian championship have passion, but not good quality or skills.
The players are very limited, the fields are worst than European second division - the top teams have better fields, of course. Guys who are second options in Europe are absolute top player if comes to here.
Is the "most competitive competition", more than Premier, but with a ULTRA LOW LEVEL. Common, the intensity of the game, the time of ball in match is other world. Brazil has no money and capacity to maintain great players anymore... We are a country become older and older, with a decline population and poverty.
Pra quem é brazuca ja sabe que o Brasileirão ta acima da premier porque os times não são tão dependentes de dinheiro para a fama dos clubes e porquê somos br né, não faz sentindo a gente prezar uma competição internacional no mesmo nível da nacional
The Brasileirão will never be the next Premier League for one simple reason: money. It's impossible to compare the economic realities. Similarly, leagues like those in Argentina, Uruguay, Paraguay, and Chile will never reach the level of the Brazilian league. However, I dare say that no other league in the world has the same level of competitiveness and excitement as the Brasileirão. While in other leagues you already know who the 2-3 title contenders will be, in Brazil it's impossible to predict, even though some teams have stood out in recent years. When it comes to excitement, the Brasileirão is unbeatable!
If they are already comparing the Premier League with the Brasileirão, then why is the Brasileirão at least the second best league of the world ?
Beside the problem that was pointed out in the video, the brasilerao needs to fix the second major problem: Th pitch.
Brazil was the best league not long ago, a matter of 25 years when it began to deteriorate, this is because Brazilian talents go to Europe very early, because they removed restrictions on the limit of foreigners and made it easier to cast more players outside the club's country. . With restrictions on foreigners like before the 2000s, European clubs had no chance against South Americans, so much so that after they changed the rules for European leagues there was never a UEFA final without a Brazilian, do you know how crazy that is? the only nationality present in all UEFA finals is not from Europe but Brazil, Spanish are not in all finals, Germans are not present, English etc. This is because European players do not count as foreigners in the union's clubs, which would be much easier to repeat a European nationality in the finals. However, only Brazil has this brand
the Brazilian league, the 4th largest in the world. the most difficult championship on the planet.
O Brasileirão é uma locomotiva em pura decadência. Cada vez mais fundo do poço
Brazilian football is very strong.
Futebol e famoso no brasil pq é facil de jogar, no tenis precisa da raquete, no volei da rede, no basket a cesta. Mas no futebol n precisa de nada disso, com 4 pedras vc consegui fazer 2 gol, esta pronto a partida.
Tickets in Brazil are only cheaper than in Europe if you are european
Brazilian here, The answer is No.
It's a case of europe getting ours goods early, like in colonialism
Copa do Brasil >> FA CUP. Quem discordar e muito Zé oreia. Inclusive a premiação da CdB é muito atrativa e todos os grandes clubes se interessam em vencer a competição.
1:15 do you know that's Maradona and that he was not Brazilian?
This video is very biased and you got the information and the criteria out of your ass lol
"they have to improve chances of conversion" why??? I mean, why?? Football is about playing the game, not a about goals.
90 minutos sentando para ver 1, 2 ou na melhor das hipóteses 3 gols.
Depois não sabe porque esse campeonato é deprimente e os mais jovens preferem assistir a premier league
brazil has only 4 national divisions, a very little quantity if compared to much smaller countries like italy or germany, where more than 10 professional/semi-professional leagues are hold at the same time
this is a consequence of brazil's continental size, wich coincides in hard times for poorer clubs when it comes to transportation matters
so the states competitions are very important, with each one of them having multiple divisions by itself.
the only problem is that the biggest clubs in the country are forced to play these competitions, that extends for 4 months in the brazilian calender, (equivalent to a year)
this not only ends with the competition of smaller clubs trying to succed around already giant clubs, but seriously affects the calendar of these bigger clubs, that are just forced to play due to these state federations pressure
so brazil has multiple talented teams, with very big wasted potential, harmed due to an elitism inside the competitions that were meant to be the "entrance door" for smaller clubs into the national competitions.
We could level the gap if europe didn't buy our players when they are 16 years old.
If the Brazilian players stay in Brazil, ye, it will be the next premier
We have no englishmen playing in our teams, so we're ahead by default.
Brazilian football is becoming the Spanish league, in recent years only Palmeiras and Flamengo are winning the championship
BRAZIL MENTIONED!!!!!!!!
zico played in the 80s, study more before making a history video
parei de ver quando ele falou que tinham 27 campeonatos regionais
To be honest, i dont know.
"Will the Brazilian League become the next Premier League?"
*Look at the list of the last few Premier League champions*
Well, I hope not
The Brazilian league isn’t as big as the other leagues for two main reasons that aren’t even tied to football, which are:
1- Money: Brazilian clubs, and the entire country for that matter, can’t pay as much as the European clubs and Arabian clubs. The entire economic scenario of Brazil is vastly different than that of the EU and Europe, which makes it difficult for players to choose to come or to stay in Brazil. Less money also means the entire league is less professional, with horrible referees, subpar VAR and league equipment, bad pitches, bad training grounds, etc.
Safety and quality of life: Brazil is very dangerous at the moment when compared to Europe and the international media makes it seem even worse. This makes it so world-class players never even consider coming to Brazil, as it could put their families and themselves in danger. No world-class players = no world-class league, no international interest(such as tv broadcasts, kit sales, etc.).
I believe those are the two main reasons for the league not to be up there with other leading European leagues. Those issues aren’t really solvable by the league itself or the clubs as they involve the entire country’s situation. It’s still a very competitive league and very fun to watch due to its unpredictability and drama.
Just giving some thanks for recognizing our league🇧🇷👍
Deserves more credit
Indeed Brazilian League is the unique who have 12 or 13 clubs considered big ones, off couse, someone greater than others but with high level. Brazilian League could'n to be richer but is much harder than PL.
Greatest Clubs from Brazil :
SE Palmeiras 18x wins national
CR Flamengo 14x wins national
SC Corinthians 11x wins national
Cruzeiro ES 10x wins national
Santos FC 9x wins national
São Paulo FC 8x wins national
Grêmio FBPA 8x wins national
CR Vasco 5x wins national
Fluminense FC 5x wins national
SC Inter 4x wins national
C Atlético Mineiro 4x wins national
C Athletico/ PR 3x wins national
Botafogo FR 2x wins national
EC Bahia 2x wins national
Sport Club Recife 2x wins national
One problem, Brazilian clubs play twice a week
Obviosly the money isso in Europa, if you have money you have the best players. Thats is the fact.