Alternate write-up: Chan Marshall, aka Cat Power, gave a stellar performance that gave me the kind of chills I get only once in a while when I see or hear an amazing piece of art. The End. There. Use that.
Whoever wrote that ? Have they ever performed ?.. do they know the magnitude of this artist Chan ? Such a misguided illustration of such a wonderful set … well said sir @Mark Blackwell 👍🏼
I agree with you! She Influenced The Majority Of Vocalists' Who Are Just Now Popular Today, Both Male And Female... She Created A Vocal Sound mimicked by Everyone Else I can Think of Whose Voices Have Great Resonance With People Now! Without judgement, It might be possible that the original poster was unaware of how great her influence IS On Todays' Singers...
It just shows that they didn’t have an understanding of her as an artist. They probably thought they were being high brow by calling her out (all the rage for people hiding behind anonymity these days). And also, it’s very obvious that she is placing her hands underneath her chin to get a feel of her pitch.
@@vinwulff Apparently not we could see them as a radio station with videos where musicains can expose their music and talent in the simplest and realest way
@@Jfg-SoundsThat old chestnut ‘doing the work IS getting paid’. Imagine if you were a plasterer and you did a woman’s kitchen and she said she wasn’t going to pay, but she’d tell all her friends 😂
100% Way to write up and NOT bother to research the artist at ALL. To perform such beautiful music with such anxiety is amazing and inspirational to let that light shine no matter what. She's gone through SO MUCH and is a beacon. This writer is an idiot. Doesn't get more brave or real than Chan.
@@omgxwtf what was that Karen? Your entitled nonsense isn’t being accepted by everyone? Starting to panic? shouldn’t you be calling for a boycott or getting a waitress fired?
I agree, the description is actually pretty cringey, and it misguidedly misinterprets the gorgeous emotional fragility and delicate nature of Chan's delivery and mannerisms- something that all of her long time fans deeply appreciate as part of what makes her such a captivating performer and singer. Chan's rapid blinks when she approaches an emotion or idea at depth are so sublimely sensitive and sensual. Sure, she has anxiety too, but it is not the entirety or the ending of the story. It's merely one layer of her superb complexity as an artist.
I was really surprised and put off by the description and the narrative it was trying to tell. I watched the performance twice before even reading the description right now as I'm watching her performance for a third time (it was just that good), and she didn't come across uneasy at all. She seemed so calm and at peace with herself. As I'm reading through the other comments, I'm glad that I'm not the only one who felt this way about the jarring and rather insulting description.
she said, basically, that the woman was nervous....since when is this some kind of put down? It's funny how we all try to be so supercool all the time these days (and probably it has always been so). I would not be at all surprised if the writer showed this to CP and got her OK before she published it. It would be suicidal for a channel to start posting descriptions of performances that offend the performers.
Robin Hilton, often provides descriptions of things you may not notice, and may give you a hint of the mood since he's normally present before, during, and after the performance at Tiny Desk. Please reason, if you think Robin means to put down one the performers.
I've seen her half a dozen times... she definitely has struggled with anxiety while performing over the years, but also despite that, she's become a better and better performer. As someone with anxiety who also plays music, I find it very relatable and wonderful to see her do that.
chan's music got me through my teens and saved my life when i was suicidal. i have terrible social anxiety and if i read a description like that about myself it would be very painful. when i saw her play in melbourne i just felt so grateful to see her okay and so proud of her. thank you so much chan. you are so loved.
cat power was the first "alternative" artist i got into in college& i fell in love with everything about her. cat powers music is for the pure of Heart. she is a Legend.
That description is ridiculous. I am a shy person myself and I would *hate* if someone wrote this about me in an yt channel or magazine. I'm sure Chan *hates* this kind of judgement - and most of all, you guys are music critics you should be writing about music!!
This NPR description is so out of focus! She's been performing for more than 20 years, and yes, she's particular, but that's what she is... if she doesn't fit in your standards and preconceptions of how a singer should behave maybe is just you who's missing the point.
That first paragraph is insensitive. Make it even worse for a nervous artist by noticing AND writing about it in the description, why don't you? I would never even have noticed if it weren't for that pre-empting the performance.
Agree with all the comments on the description. She went there and did what she had to do, which is sing, and that she did amazingly well. Talking about her being nervous is showing how little you know about her circumstances.
Chan Marshall, I've been in love with your music for sixteen years. Happiness tears are running down my cheeks whenever I watch this video. Thank you so, so much.
She is iconic. What's the deal with the description tearing her apart? I'm honestly surprised she even did a tiny desk as someone who's been in the music biz for so long and could literally play any venue she wanted.
Agreed. I read Cat Power: A Good Women. Her story and her performances are very much herself. Very frantic and kind or Neurotic. It's a cool look into qn artist that really does their own thing.
Beautiful soul with an amazing voice who has to fight her own demons each time she decides to share herself with us. I am always thankful when she is able to grace us with her gift.
Totally agree! Her sets are always like medleys and it was obviously planned that way, not a result of her being miserable and anxious and in a hurry to get through it (which the description implies). The description here is insulting to the artist.
dang, what a treat. also, if she was indeed moving towards the pianist, it could have been to get away from the vibes of the person who wrote that uncouth description...
i hear what you’re saying. it’s just that anyone who has ever seen her perform, or knows her story, knows very well this is just her, and that she has struggled publicly in the past to the point where venues wouldn’t really want to book her. they’d say things like, boy does that girl know how to clear a room, because her anxiety was so bad, it’d propel her to drink to a point of sobbing sadness that was truly hard to watch. remarks over the difficulties she still struggles with, even after all these years, is a tired talking point that has really hurt her in the past and it’s so unnecessary. she’s able to connect with her audience in a way her fans can appreciate and love her for. she’s deserving of an opportunity to not be criticized over it. i’m happy for her. it appears she has a supportive team around her nowadays and that can make all the difference. all the while, upon rereading it, it could also add to the intrigue of her performances. it’s hard not to get defensive about an artist you really care about and have been following since the 90s and basically shaped your musical interests of today. she’s my favorite and hold her and her music close to my heart.
I went to see Cat back in 2007/2008, she was so frightened that she drunkenly cried and sang only from the wings of the stage. I could understand her fear and sympathized and felt her pain. That being said, I had tickets for this most recent tour and wasn’t feeling so well the night of the show. I chose not to go knowing the likelihood of a good performance from her was not probable. I am happy with my decision, because somehow I prefer an emotionally raw Chan to a distant and highly uncomfortable performance shown here. To me, an artist needs to connect to her audience...it makes me uneasy to listen to a singer who doesn’t really want to sing for me. Her current place is much healthier though, and I am happy she is doing better then she did all those years ago. Her voice on record moves me more than most artists and her lyrics are pure poetry. Love you Chan, even though I don’t want to see you perform for us live. ❤️
As good...possibly better than ever. Incredibly polished. I can see why this setting would be stressful for anyone. But she has every right to take any stage with the height of all confidence and prowess. Yet it is her personality and gratitude, her gentle nature that is the ultimate statement. This why we love her and her music.
Why bother giving negative feedback ??!! ( 59 at present ) Tiny Desk Concerts are neutral ground for music with a certain level of quality and I for one am so grateful for having been and still being introduced here to all kinds of music I possibly never would come across otherwise. Sacré nom tonnerre - Nom de Chien !
the description is in very poor taste....cat power is amazing!!! Her voice is so unique💕💕💕....please revise the caption. It should be the music your focusing on!!!
I am so thankful this came up on my feed. I really needed this today. Her song meets my heart on a level of frequency that is hard to put into words but so very deeply felt. I was feeling sad and built up over the world today. And i cried tears of sweet sadness to see her face and hear her sing again. It has been a while....she always has my heart. 💜
How brave and wonderful is the fact that, even dealing with stage fright, you accept doing a live show in plain daylight facing the audience? Chaaaan ♥♥♥♥
I saw her again last night. Last time I saw her she was so nervous, she got through it amd of course it was amazing. This time, with each song she came more out of her shell,making jokes between songs and full on laughing. For the last song, she had all the lights turned on so she could see every face in the crowd, it was so special ❤️
Chan is a most beautiful artist, she is an inspiration on so many levels. She is soulful, beautiful and amazing. Her music speaks to my soul and elevates me.
Chan Marshall is the greatest voice of our time. This performance is Intimate and vulnerable and .... real ..... the writer of this description has no sense of respect for the amazingly nuanced performance that Chan is giving. I am a long time fan of Cat Power, and from my point of view; I want more music from the heart. So much music is just glam and BS..... Chan Marshall is beautiful and her records are considered gospel in my house because of her bravery to be such a beautiful and vulnerable artist. I love her work and this performance brought me to tears. I love it. Thank you Chan !!!!
The writer of the description would do well to challenge their bias toward 'extrovert' and 'confident' behaviours being the norm, and something else being lesser. Let people be themselves if they're not harming others. Thanks to Cat Power for sharing her enormous talent with us ❤️
Exactly. This performance was so beautiful, I just keep listening over and over acts that idiot focuses on her standing close to the pianist. Must have a wooden ear
Amazing..intimate...transparent....rich and full, honest, beautiful voice...that speaks deep to deep. Listened twice...This description? Seriously? Never would've connected the description to this performance had it not been attached. Didn't realize Tiny Desk was more about superficial glitz, cheap showmanship and glitz vs authentic music & artistry. Artist?100% + NPR quality. The description? Tabloid quality.
This description is very insulting to her and her artistry and is like they just drank from the cup of toxic Koolaid that has followed her much of her career, undeservedly. VERY VERY disappointed in NPR for this. Shame on you - you should edit this post haste!!!!
I can inform those who are not musicians that being forced to perform in a tiny space can be anxiety inducing! Many artists shed nervous energy with their movements, and Chan uses that mechanism to great effect on stage.
CHAN & CO - THANK YOU FOR SHARING YOUR HEALING MAGIC WITH THE WORLD 🌎. I SAW YOU IN PORTLAND. YOU ROCKED THE HELL OUT OF IT. I JUST CANNOT GET ENOUGH OF YOU. 💫🤩
WTF with that description, man? Chan is awesome, each artist perform as they please is their performance. So weird that npr guys describe an artist in such rude manner .
Beautiful beautiful ....and so good to see that she’s in a good place now. And her voice, which has aged, is still amazingly beautiful. As for the description, as far as I know Chan has always had issues performing live, especially video, so this is actually a great accomplishment.
I am so grateful for this performance because it shows a level of whimsy and cold and depth that I've not found in other performances. Thanks to Chan and thanks to NPR for making it happen.
Very beautifull!!! Cat is beautiful! has a heavenly voice, made me excited a lot, thank you very much you're very good! 👏👏👏👍😊😘💕💕💕Greetings from Italy! 🇮🇹
I've always loved NPR for playing different artist and different sounds. The description almost makes it sound as if the writer has a problem with the way Chan is acting and is making her behaviour sound negative. Wtf? You're supposed to enjoy and feel the performance not criticize her every movement. And now instead of us writing a positive comment we have to write about YOUR rude description. I can't imagine Catpower feeling good about this or being excited about performing for you any time soon.
This seems like old news, performing has been a struggle for her despite the beauty she projects. She sounds great, would love to hear Cat Power Live! NPR had a strange approach to describing (old news) the ensemble!
What a gorgeous performance. I have listened to her since 1996 and her voice is more beautiful than ever! The piano is also so lovely here. Mesmerizing ❤
This performance is a seemless wave of songs that all flow into one another, she didn't "run through the songs" Cat Power simply did what she does best- make you feel as though you could listen to her forever, her raspy voice a comforting lullaby.
The description was in poor taste. As if this person was having a bad day, I normally dont have anything negative to say even if the music isnt my cup of tea. This person seems to have confused a description with criticism. Hopefully npr notices how this might detour other guests from ever attending.
Narrator (Troy Jimenez disgustedly takes a sip of his lukewarm chai tea latte extra foam and ponders how stupid people are and how unaware they are of that dipshittedness.)
Anyone familiar with Cat Power knows that Chan has suffered from varying degrees of stage fright throughout her career, paralyzing in some instances. The description NPR put here is indefensibly in bad taste, cruel and frankly insulting.
Why is it bad taste? I am a huge cat power fan and it sounded right on the money. She is not perfect and that's ok. They seemed ok with it. Maybe they expected it to be longer? They are entitled to have expectations. It didn't seem to be resentful.
Chan Marshall aced it, once again. Super cool and inspirational lady, and the description is a pursed lip farce that does her performance no justice. Love this video, she's in control and it's very pleasant to see
WOW, amazing performance. But yeah, whoever wrote this really fell down on the job and it needs to be fixed. "Rather than taking center stage, close to the audience, she stepped back and to the side to be closer to her pianist" You all know Miles Davis often performed with his BACK to the audience, right? Not every musician wants to be right up front facing the audience.
Alternate write-up: Chan Marshall, aka Cat Power, gave a stellar performance that gave me the kind of chills I get only once in a while when I see or hear an amazing piece of art. The End. There. Use that.
What a condescending outline of this beautiful set.
Agreed. I really didn’t appreciate the description.
Absolutely agree - she is a magnificent artist and shame on whoever wrote/agreed on the description.
Whoever wrote that ? Have they ever performed ?.. do they know the magnitude of this artist Chan ? Such a misguided illustration of such a wonderful set … well said sir @Mark Blackwell 👍🏼
I agree with you!
She Influenced The Majority Of Vocalists' Who Are Just Now Popular Today,
Both Male And Female...
She Created A Vocal Sound mimicked by Everyone Else I can Think of Whose Voices Have Great Resonance With People Now!
Without judgement,
It might be possible that the original poster was unaware of how great her influence IS On Todays' Singers...
It just shows that they didn’t have an understanding of her as an artist. They probably thought they were being high brow by calling her out (all the rage for people hiding behind anonymity these days). And also, it’s very obvious that she is placing her hands underneath her chin to get a feel of her pitch.
She's your guest. Doesn't get paid. And gets disparaged for a beautiful performance.
Shame on whoever wrote and okayed the description.
tiny desk guests dont get paid?!?!!
It’s not at all disparaging. I think it says more about you than anything if you think that is offensive…
@@vinwulff Apparently not we could see them as a radio station with videos where musicains can expose their music and talent in the simplest and realest way
@@Jfg-SoundsThat old chestnut ‘doing the work IS getting paid’. Imagine if you were a plasterer and you did a woman’s kitchen and she said she wasn’t going to pay, but she’d tell all her friends 😂
100% Way to write up and NOT bother to research the artist at ALL. To perform such beautiful music with such anxiety is amazing and inspirational to let that light shine no matter what. She's gone through SO MUCH and is a beacon. This writer is an idiot. Doesn't get more brave or real than Chan.
Chan deserves so much respect. There is no description required (certainly not a disparaging one like this) we listen to and feel her music.
Disparaging how? Grow up. Isn’t there an actual victim you could be defending instead of inventing one?
@@John-uz4et go troll somewhere else
@@omgxwtf what was that Karen? Your entitled nonsense isn’t being accepted by everyone? Starting to panic? shouldn’t you be calling for a boycott or getting a waitress fired?
@@John-uz4et you sound like you need some serious help.
What's wrong with the person who wrote the description?
Chan is always so beautiful, and a great songwriter/performer.
that's NPR for you
Chan was painfully nervous, and I guess the writer felt to defend her, in case she would be attacked.
Exactly, that is the way she always is and it is a perfect expression of her unique shyness and beauty.
I guess the description was written by a young person, they always get things wrong. Chan seemed brilliant and perfectly normal to me :)
I agree, the description is actually pretty cringey, and it misguidedly misinterprets the gorgeous emotional fragility and delicate nature of Chan's delivery and mannerisms- something that all of her long time fans deeply appreciate as part of what makes her such a captivating performer and singer. Chan's rapid blinks when she approaches an emotion or idea at depth are so sublimely sensitive and sensual. Sure, she has anxiety too, but it is not the entirety or the ending of the story. It's merely one layer of her superb complexity as an artist.
I was really surprised and put off by the description and the narrative it was trying to tell. I watched the performance twice before even reading the description right now as I'm watching her performance for a third time (it was just that good), and she didn't come across uneasy at all. She seemed so calm and at peace with herself. As I'm reading through the other comments, I'm glad that I'm not the only one who felt this way about the jarring and rather insulting description.
she said, basically, that the woman was nervous....since when is this some kind of put down? It's funny how we all try to be so supercool all the time these days (and probably it has always been so). I would not be at all surprised if the writer showed this to CP and got her OK before she published it. It would be suicidal for a channel to start posting descriptions of performances that offend the performers.
Robin Hilton, often provides descriptions of things you may not notice, and may give you a hint of the mood since he's normally present before, during, and after the performance at Tiny Desk. Please reason, if you think Robin means to put down one the performers.
Isn't mentioning stage fright kind of de rigueur when talking about her? Like, they're gonna say something about it no matter how she really acted.
Sometimes journalists have different opinions. Make your own show if you want to write the blurb.
I've seen her half a dozen times... she definitely has struggled with anxiety while performing over the years, but also despite that, she's become a better and better performer. As someone with anxiety who also plays music, I find it very relatable and wonderful to see her do that.
Here’s the new description: Captivating. Sensational. Electrifying. The Goddess Chan.
chan's music got me through my teens and saved my life when i was suicidal. i have terrible social anxiety and if i read a description like that about myself it would be very painful. when i saw her play in melbourne i just felt so grateful to see her okay and so proud of her. thank you so much chan. you are so loved.
same, moon pix literally cured my unhealthy sleep schedule, and saved me from suicidal thoughts as well
The same here and I said it to her! Thank you Universe for people like you for like her!
cat power was the first "alternative" artist i got into in college& i fell in love with everything about her. cat powers music is for the pure of Heart. she is a Legend.
I love CATPOWER! her voice got me through some of the rough parts of my life. Thank you Chan Marshall for changing my life in so many ways.
That description is ridiculous. I am a shy person myself and I would *hate* if someone wrote this about me in an yt channel or magazine. I'm sure Chan *hates* this kind of judgement - and most of all, you guys are music critics you should be writing about music!!
god I love this woman. keep her safe
So trancendent, so natural, such talent. Like a conversation with the wind, emotional and real. Just beautiful.
The Moon is one of the most elegant and beautiful songs ever written. Every time I hear it, it's a revelation.
This NPR description is so out of focus! She's been performing for more than 20 years, and yes, she's particular, but that's what she is... if she doesn't fit in your standards and preconceptions of how a singer should behave maybe is just you who's missing the point.
Perfect. Just perfect .... always moves me.... always moving.
Chan Marshall! Still as captivating as when I discovered her through Moon Pix back in '99. An underappreciated treasure.
That first paragraph is insensitive. Make it even worse for a nervous artist by noticing AND writing about it in the description, why don't you? I would never even have noticed if it weren't for that pre-empting the performance.
Chan is so endearing and I love her vulnerability. I still doubt she realises just how special she really is. Her voice, like slow molasses. Love her.
This woman's words got me through some bad times many times and she continues to be great much love
Agree with all the comments on the description. She went there and did what she had to do, which is sing, and that she did amazingly well. Talking about her being nervous is showing how little you know about her circumstances.
One of the greatest songwriters of our generation.
Her voice is still so beautiful and haunting ❤️
Still?
Chan Marshall, I've been in love with your music for sixteen years. Happiness tears are running down my cheeks whenever I watch this video. Thank you so, so much.
She is a rare and authentic gemstone
I’m crying I adore this woman
She is iconic. What's the deal with the description tearing her apart? I'm honestly surprised she even did a tiny desk as someone who's been in the music biz for so long and could literally play any venue she wanted.
Such a disappointment to read that description. That NPR writer should be ashamed of himself.
Agreed. I read Cat Power: A Good Women. Her story and her performances are very much herself. Very frantic and kind or Neurotic. It's a cool look into qn artist that really does their own thing.
Jesus... Yeah this description is almost oddly scathing
He clearly is an idiot. Anyone worth their measure would recognise Cat as an incredible artist
Beautiful soul with an amazing voice who has to fight her own demons each time she decides to share herself with us. I am always thankful when she is able to grace us with her gift.
Please change the description Tiny desk. I agree with many here.
when she did the moon
wow tears
This new slow version of "The Moon" is even better than the original. Takes me back to 2014 when i first heard it
Vasco Barbedo LoL. Wow, all the way back to 5 years ago? Don’t you mean 2004? That’s closer to when it was actually recorded.
Unacceptable. The description is really low.. can you get rid of it?
Chan is AMAZING
the guy who wrote this doesn't know Chan's gesture and way to be. And probably doesn't know what is Cat Power... That's why.
Totally agree! Her sets are always like medleys and it was obviously planned that way, not a result of her being miserable and anxious and in a hurry to get through it (which the description implies). The description here is insulting to the artist.
She was nervous. There's no crime in that.
I love how her songs are ever evolving. Each performance is totally unique.
dang, what a treat. also, if she was indeed moving towards the pianist, it could have been to get away from the vibes of the person who wrote that uncouth description...
Good one!
THIS 1000% !
Exactly.
chan marshall🥰
the description tho, not here for it. they sound like they’re complaining, and it was a beautiful performance.
I can see that actually, but I do not think it was meant to sound that way.
i hear what you’re saying. it’s just that anyone who has ever seen her perform, or knows her story, knows very well this is just her, and that she has struggled publicly in the past to the point where venues wouldn’t really want to book her. they’d say things like, boy does that girl know how to clear a room, because her anxiety was so bad, it’d propel her to drink to a point of sobbing sadness that was truly hard to watch. remarks over the difficulties she still struggles with, even after all these years, is a tired talking point that has really hurt her in the past and it’s so unnecessary. she’s able to connect with her audience in a way her fans can appreciate and love her for. she’s deserving of an opportunity to not be criticized over it. i’m happy for her. it appears she has a supportive team around her nowadays and that can make all the difference.
all the while, upon rereading it, it could also add to the intrigue of her performances. it’s hard not to get defensive about an artist you really care about and have been following since the 90s and basically shaped your musical interests of today. she’s my favorite and hold her and her music close to my heart.
I went to see Cat back in 2007/2008, she was so frightened that she drunkenly cried and sang only from the wings of the stage. I could understand her fear and sympathized and felt her pain. That being said, I had tickets for this most recent tour and wasn’t feeling so well the night of the show. I chose not to go knowing the likelihood of a good performance from her was not probable. I am happy with my decision, because somehow I prefer an emotionally raw Chan to a distant and highly uncomfortable performance shown here. To me, an artist needs to connect to her audience...it makes me uneasy to listen to a singer who doesn’t really want to sing for me. Her current place is much healthier though, and I am happy she is doing better then she did all those years ago. Her voice on record moves me more than most artists and her lyrics are pure poetry. Love you Chan, even though I don’t want to see you perform for us live. ❤️
It was... Wish Metal Heart was done..
It's like birds singing in my ears! What beauty of voice, what beauty of band! 👏👏
What I see here is a beautiful performance by Chan and her band. Cat Power, awesome.
I LOVE U CHAN AND especially drawn to your sense of awkwardness.. so lost in your own space and soul 🔥
I just love her. She sings with so much passion. This made me cry. Love you CP. Always loved the name Chan. Charlie Parker’s wife was Chan.
As good...possibly better than ever. Incredibly polished. I can see why this setting would be stressful for anyone. But she has every right to take any stage with the height of all confidence and prowess. Yet it is her personality and gratitude, her gentle nature that is the ultimate statement. This why we love her and her music.
Why bother giving negative feedback ??!! ( 59 at present ) Tiny Desk Concerts are neutral ground for music with a certain level of quality and I for one am so grateful for having been and still being introduced here to all kinds of music I possibly never would come across otherwise. Sacré nom tonnerre - Nom de Chien !
How I fell in love with this woman's voice and soul.
the description is in very poor taste....cat power is amazing!!! Her voice is so unique💕💕💕....please revise the caption. It should be the music your focusing on!!!
I love her so much. I've been a fan for about 19 years now. She's been w me through some tough stuff
I am so thankful this came up on my feed. I really needed this today. Her song meets my heart on a level of frequency that is hard to put into words but so very deeply felt. I was feeling sad and built up over the world today. And i cried tears of sweet sadness to see her face and hear her sing again. It has been a while....she always has my heart. 💜
How brave and wonderful is the fact that, even dealing with stage fright, you accept doing a live show in plain daylight facing the audience? Chaaaan ♥♥♥♥
I saw her again last night. Last time I saw her she was so nervous, she got through it amd of course it was amazing. This time, with each song she came more out of her shell,making jokes between songs and full on laughing. For the last song, she had all the lights turned on so she could see every face in the crowd, it was so special ❤️
Chan is a most beautiful artist, she is an inspiration on so many levels. She is soulful, beautiful and amazing. Her music speaks to my soul and elevates me.
My dad has been playing her ever since I can remember can’t wait to show him this
Rybreadsandwich how old is your dad? That’s awesome
As I look for the Northern Lights tonight I can't think of a better song to fill the night sky with. Beautifully haunting.
She's amazing, beautiful voice...
She's a true legend ❤
Chan Marshall is the greatest voice of our time. This performance is Intimate and vulnerable and .... real ..... the writer of this description has no sense of respect for the amazingly nuanced performance that Chan is giving. I am a long time fan of Cat Power, and from my point of view; I want more music from the heart. So much music is just glam and BS..... Chan Marshall is beautiful and her records are considered gospel in my house because of her bravery to be such a beautiful and vulnerable artist. I love her work and this performance brought me to tears. I love it. Thank you Chan !!!!
Man, Her eyes are magnetic and magnificent while matching her mane.
The writer of the description would do well to challenge their bias toward 'extrovert' and 'confident' behaviours being the norm, and something else being lesser. Let people be themselves if they're not harming others. Thanks to Cat Power for sharing her enormous talent with us ❤️
Well said.
Her voice gives me chills
Your beautiful guided wings saved my life and many others your soul is to see the lost.. The true meaning of real love.
why review (judgingly describe) her body language? She shouldn't be critiqued in this way.
Exactly. This performance was so beautiful, I just keep listening over and over acts that idiot focuses on her standing close to the pianist. Must have a wooden ear
Cat, you're beautiful and your musicians too. Thank you!
Amazing..intimate...transparent....rich and full, honest, beautiful voice...that speaks deep to deep. Listened twice...This description? Seriously? Never would've connected the description to this performance had it not been attached. Didn't realize Tiny Desk was more about superficial glitz, cheap showmanship and glitz vs authentic music & artistry. Artist?100% + NPR quality. The description? Tabloid quality.
This description is very insulting to her and her artistry and is like they just drank from the cup of toxic Koolaid that has followed her much of her career, undeservedly. VERY VERY disappointed in NPR for this. Shame on you - you should edit this post haste!!!!
Yes, you put it perfectly
I can inform those who are not musicians that being forced to perform in a tiny space can be anxiety inducing! Many artists shed nervous energy with their movements, and Chan uses that mechanism to great effect on stage.
Awwe I am 67 yrs old and I Love Cat power . Chan Is a Beautiful Person .
CHAN & CO - THANK YOU FOR SHARING YOUR HEALING MAGIC WITH THE WORLD 🌎. I SAW YOU IN PORTLAND. YOU ROCKED THE HELL OUT OF IT. I JUST CANNOT GET ENOUGH OF YOU. 💫🤩
What I didn't know I needed until I heard it. Cat Power is just amazing😍
you should listen to Sea of love By Cat Power
@@PreviousOne oh I referring to seeing her on Tiny Desk. I have loved her music for ages❤
Totally
WTF with that description, man? Chan is awesome, each artist perform as they please is their performance. So weird that npr guys describe an artist in such rude manner .
Loved her since Myra, and I’ll never stop. She’s perfect at every stage, and on every stage. Cheers to Chan
re/Chan Marshall: never explain yourself
re/Robin Hilton: you might have to
^^^This 1000 times
I don’t know how many times I’ve listened to The Greatest recently! Missed you Cat😂
Beautiful beautiful ....and so good to see that she’s in a good place now. And her voice, which has aged, is still amazingly beautiful.
As for the description, as far as I know Chan has always had issues performing live, especially video, so this is actually a great accomplishment.
I have been listening to her albums for more than 10 yrs.❤️
Chris Meya 20 here😀
I am so grateful for this performance because it shows a level of whimsy and cold and depth that I've not found in other performances. Thanks to Chan and thanks to NPR for making it happen.
So beautiful. Thank you Chan and other musicians.
Very beautifull!!! Cat is beautiful! has a heavenly voice, made me excited a lot, thank you very much you're very good! 👏👏👏👍😊😘💕💕💕Greetings from Italy! 🇮🇹
Robin Hilton, your description’s first paragraph was unnecessary and in poor taste.
Yeah, it makes no sense at all. The person who wrote this was definitely having a bad day...
How can a real person be so beautiful and sound so great
Ok but the support beaming from the drummers eyes ❤
I've always loved NPR for playing different artist and different sounds. The description almost makes it sound as if the writer has a problem with the way Chan is acting and is making her behaviour sound negative. Wtf? You're supposed to enjoy and feel the performance not criticize her every movement. And now instead of us writing a positive comment we have to write about YOUR rude description. I can't imagine Catpower feeling good about this or being excited about performing for you any time soon.
It's not a criticism. But you think it is.
I love her
You've helped me through so many times miss Chan. Don't usually comment, but just love you & your gift so much ❤️
Thank you, Cat! You and your music are blessings from the gods. ❤️
Evidently some at Tiny Desk have Tiny Brains. Beautiful performance from an exceptional artist.
This seems like old news, performing has been a struggle for her despite the beauty she projects. She sounds great, would love to hear Cat Power Live! NPR had a strange approach to describing (old news) the ensemble!
What a gorgeous performance. I have listened to her since 1996 and her voice is more beautiful than ever! The piano is also
so lovely here. Mesmerizing ❤
I love her so much. Seeing her live has always been a beautiful experience. ❤️
This performance is a seemless wave of songs that all flow into one another, she didn't "run through the songs" Cat Power simply did what she does best- make you feel as though you could listen to her forever, her raspy voice a comforting lullaby.
A great voice, a great sound, a great presentation. Thank so much for the feeling and experience you gave to me and the other listener
Warm, narrative, and beautifully graceful.
Cat Power has always been legendary to those who know, and this performance delivers
The description was in poor taste. As if this person was having a bad day, I normally dont have anything negative to say even if the music isnt my cup of tea. This person seems to have confused a description with criticism. Hopefully npr notices how this might detour other guests from ever attending.
Right. I can't understand why they felt compelled to add their two cents. None of that is relevant information.
Narrator
(Troy Jimenez disgustedly takes a sip of his lukewarm chai tea latte extra foam and ponders how stupid people are and how unaware they are of that dipshittedness.)
Her voice is gorgeous and 100 unique and instantly recognizable
Anyone familiar with Cat Power knows that Chan has suffered from varying degrees of stage fright throughout her career, paralyzing in some instances. The description NPR put here is indefensibly in bad taste, cruel and frankly insulting.
drownsoda I couldn’t agree more... I’ve never heard them EVER describe someone in this way. Really rubbed me the wrong way.
I didn't get that from it at all.
Why is it bad taste? I am a huge cat power fan and it sounded right on the money. She is not perfect and that's ok. They seemed ok with it. Maybe they expected it to be longer? They are entitled to have expectations. It didn't seem to be resentful.
Sounds very much like how men write about women
Yeah.. NPR screwed up big time..
They shouldn't have done that
Chan Marshall aced it, once again. Super cool and inspirational lady, and the description is a pursed lip farce that does her performance no justice. Love this video, she's in control and it's very pleasant to see
WOW, amazing performance. But yeah, whoever wrote this really fell down on the job and it needs to be fixed.
"Rather than taking center stage, close to the audience, she stepped back and to the side to be closer to her pianist"
You all know Miles Davis often performed with his BACK to the audience, right? Not every musician wants to be right up front facing the audience.
She's incredible💜
her voice is a gift from Heaven.
When she smiles... it lights up the world. Like her voice. Love.
Wow, an emotional performance. Beautiful.
That was actually so fucking beautiful oh my lord
Agreed!
Their music is absolutely beautiful, great job!!
I listen to this on loop. Thank you for sharing your talent with us Chan.