VNM Sim Racing Shifter Review: A Worthy Competitor to FANATEC?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 21 лип 2024
- In this video, I'll review and compare the VNM Sim Racing Shifter to the popular Fanatec Clubsport Shifter. Both are highly regarded among sim racers, but which one will stay on my rig?
By the end of the video, you should better understand which shifter might be best for your Sim Racing Setup. Whether you're a seasoned Sim Racer or just starting out, this video is for you. So, please sit back, relax, and let's dive into the ultimate comparison: VNM Shifter vs Fanatec Clubsport SQ V1.5.
VNM SHIFTER geni.us/3AGuqu
FANATEC CLUBSPORT geni.us/KUA6D
Chapters:
00:00 Intro
01:49 Pricing
02:00 Build Quality & Design
04:05 What's Included
05:05 Performance
10:23 Switching Modes
13:55 Compatibility & Mounting
15:10 Final Thoughts
18:14 Outro
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Curious to know what's currently on my sim racing rig? Check out the dedicated page on my website: www.thesimracingden.com/my-si....
If you're interested in the gear I use, I've compiled handy lists for you:
Sim Racing PC Build: kit.co/simracingden/sim-racin...
Desk/Editing Setup: kit.co/simracingden/desk-setup
Filming Equipment: kit.co/simracingden/filming-e...
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
DISCOUNT & AFFILIATE LINKS
www.thesimracingden.com/affil...
LOOKING FOR NEW SIM RACING GEAR? Using the affiliate links below, send a small commission my way without costing you anything extra and sometimes giving you a discount!
SIM SPORT GADGET: Your one stop shop for sim racing accessories. GET 5% OFF your entire order by using our affiliate link: simsportgadget.com/thesimracin... or checkout code: THESIMRACINGDEN
ASETEK SIM SPORTS geni.us/KdEDjDA
GRID ENGINEERING geni.us/E2QP
ADVANCED SIM RACING: geni.us/mCqK
Receive 5% OFF selected collections: Advanced Sim Racing Cockpits, Racing Seats & More
TURN RACING geni.us/aXOcD
SIMRACING4U BUTTON BOXES 5% OFF CODE: THESIMRACINGDEN geni.us/gPB6c
MORADNESS SIM RACING & KARTING GLOVES 10% OFF CODE: SIMRACINGDEN geni.us/RgOJl
TRAK RACER geni.us/dHWuL
MOZA RACING geni.us/kdko8
DIGITAL MOTORSPORTS geni.us/yeC6b
IRACING MEMBERSHIP geni.us/sRyb
CAMMUS RACING 5% OFF Code: SIMRACINGDEN geni.us/nE15
SIM LAB geni.us/yiDIX
GETAIL DESIGN geni.us/k60Rlq
SIM RACING BAY geni.us/J5coeAN
AMAZON geni.us/5O0ye
#vnmshifter #fanatec #clubsport #shifter #simracing #sequential #hpattern #vnmshifter #vnm APEX SIM RACING 5% DISCOUNT CODE: SIMRACINGDEN geni.us/Ok3vzh7
LIKE THE MUSIC IN THIS VIDEO? I use EPIDEMIC SOUND for all my video music; sign up for a 30-day free trial here: geni.us/uomG
TRIPLE SCREEN AND ULTRAWIDE DESKTOP WALLPAPER: www.thesimracingden.com/deskt... - Ігри
DO NOT forget, if you are using a PC, the USB-adapter to the Fanatec shifter €19.95 (and €20 extra for postage if you have to order it later on)
Yes so true I meant to mention this and forgot. Thank you good catch! Pinning your comment.
that’s only if connecting to wheel base right? o could just connect to of and be fine?
@@awoodhouse17Vice versa. The USB adapter is to connect it via USB instead of proprietary Fanatec connection.
Great review and opinions. Thanks for the shoutout!
My suggestion for the vibration rattling issue would be to wrap a single layer of felt tape or even electrical tape around the shaft where it's contacting the gates. That should eliminate the metal contact and reduce the noise substantially if not eliminate it completely.
Thanks great suggestion!
I have the vnm shifter and absolutely love it. Highly recommend if someones willing to drop that kind of money into a shifter. You can also adjust the stiffness of the shifts so tight you have to really force it into gear, way tighter then anyone will ever realistically run.
As far as the vibrations while using a buttkicker, i will say im still using my fairly basic, but trusty gtomega art cockpit, with 4 dayton audio transducers, and i have never had that issue with the shifter personally.
So, with that said i do think that issue will only come up in a very specific circumstance. There are so many variables there, from the location and strength of your shakers, to the tightness of the shifter. And that of course is if your running shakers at all.
As far as swapping the sequential plate, its really not that bad. You can realistically do it in like a minute. How annoying it would be to you would depend on your patience, and how often you actually switch between sequential and H pattern. A plus on the plate is you can seperately adjust the shifting strength like you can with the H pattern.
The vnm also has a usb passthrough for truck sim shift knobs, if your into ats/ets.
I love my fanatec shifter, it works and feels great especially after I installed a short shifter shaft which gives it shorter throws
Where did you get the short shifter shaft? I've been looking for one for a while now.
You can cut the gate swapping time down to around 90 seconds if you use a "T" bar type Allen key. Once lose you simply spin the screw out of it's hole in a few seconds and the same to refit. - far less fiddly too.
While more expensive I believe you would of been happier with the Simagic DS-8X shifter. It has the closed top like you like and it goes from H-pattern to sequential with just a flick of a switch. Simagic is a $100 US more then the VNM so maybe not worth it if you don't use it that much.
Glad to see more Canadian Sim channels out there!
Thanks been meaning to check that one out will hopefully pick one up soon for a review. Thanks for watching.💪🇨🇦
Just checked the price on the Simagic DS-8X wow $619 before Tax and shipping in Canada quite steep in comparison.
Some additional thoughts. You mentioned misshifting with the vnm. This is because the spring for side to side motion is too weak. There are some videos about replacing it. Makes the shifter much better - you dont even have to take it apart. Also, there is no lockout for reverse and when you are shifting to 5th you get caught up in the gate for reverse :(. THe modified spring and muscle memory also help with this or just get the 6 gate plate and forgo reverse. I personally found the fanatec to feel better but was tired of having to open it every week to clear up the misshifting :( I ended up going with the ds-8x which is close to perfect in feel (the length of the shifter could be an inch shorter). Btw, you can use other shift knobs for the vnm, you just need one of those grub screw based adaptors used for stalks without threading.
Thanks so much for these additional points! I'll look into the stronger spring. I do want to try the DS-8X and looks really nice.
You're not the 1st reviewer I've heard mention the vibrations while in gear because of haptics
Wow, u work fast
🏎️💨
Wouldn't let me respond to your last comment on the Simagic shifter price for some reason. It's 530 CAD at SimRacingPros including shipping.
Thanks will order one.
The vibrating noise from the shafte sounds like an easy fix. Put a little peice of electrical tape around the shaft in level with the shifter plate it'll cut down that noise
For sure, but I feel like a $400 CAD shifter shouldn't require me to slap tape on it.
Can you tell me how you connected your ButtKicker Gamer Pro directly to your rig? I just got one and connected it to my ASR6 with an ASR crossmember designed for the ButtKicker that I put under my seat. But the effects feel very dampened. So if there is a way of direct mounting that creates a more direct effect, I’d love to know about it. Thanks. Jon
Check out the Trak racer buttkicker mount that’s what I use I attach directly to one of the profiles my seat sliders are mounted too underneath. Here’s the link trakracer.com/?ref=Yhvdp_5RM04bsP it’s an affiliate link.
Clubsport shifter for me to be honest
Same still the best bang for buck IMO
The time switching between H and SQ would have been much quicker if you just used a drill or electric screwdriver too, just saying...
Yes, of course, but I just wanted to demo the worst-case scenario using the included tools.
Wow, thank you for the great video. Sorry. I did not know it made that much noise with haptics. I thought of the horrible idea of dipping it in Maker's Mark wax😂😂😂( And if you weren't born into a family of alcoholics. Congratulations. Maker's mark is a bourbon, and they sealed the top with a red rubberized wax)
Thanks! I am wondering if the noise is an issue with my particular unit. I checked inside to make sure nothing was loose. Everything looked ok. I'll probably contact VNM to see what they say, but it could be how it is. LOL on the wax 🥃 cheers!, but I shouldn't have to modify a $300 shifter IMO
@The SimRacing Den I think that's how it is. I have their handbrake, and It has a rubber stopper. I can let go of it and not hear it. Why they didn't do the same with this shifter is kind of crazy.
Interesting, I thought at first that I was missing something like a rubber stopper or it fell off, but when I looked back at other reviews and looked closely at photos, I didn't see one. It seems like that might be an easy fix to the issue, but I wonder if it hinders shifting. I may try If I have a small one lying around somewhere.
@The SimRacing Den We'll personally I like hearing the clink when I shift,but it seems i'm in the rare sim racing position that I don't have to worry about noise. Even so, if I had haptics that rattling would be a deal breaker
@@bearsjunky23hof88 Me too. I don't mind a bit of clink when shifting.
Sure wish my Fanatec shifter didn't mis-shift, wouldn't be considering throwing it in the trash for something else right now.
Way to loud. Im researching for a quiet one, im gaming late in the night... Problematic with neighbour's
The Fanatec shifter I find is not as loud.