$500 MARKERS vs $1500 DIGITAL ART | Cheap vs Expensive!! Which STYLE is WORTH IT..? | Scarlet Witch
Вставка
- Опубліковано 6 жов 2024
- She's got the Magic, But is she..... worth it? erm.....
Traditional art VS Digital art, the ultimate showdown, whichever side of the fence you sit, I hope you will come away from this video with just a little more information and respect towards the other side.
This is so much fun and switching between styles felt, weirdly awesome. I may just do this again.
Which side is your Worth it winner? Let me know down below.
If you would like to see anything from me in the future please don't hesitate to leave those requests in a comment but most importantly I hope you'll enjoy the videos i have planned.
Especially a VERY special one arriving in a week.
Have a great week, see you then.
BYE
I still prefer the traditional side but I can appreciate the digital one too!
for me traditional, there is something beautiful in mistakes and imperfections, I enjoy the process also a lot more and tend to scan and adjust colors in a program. Also I just love to see all the art supplies in front of me. Also putting tral textures instead of mimicking the appeal of textures is very satisfying to me
Agree. It has more of the human element to it, where digital can look so seamless that it feels less unique. I personally love ADC’s style of shading and coloring and I think traditional mediums showcase it very well
Ducks are peopleto
how have I not come across this channel before??
it is so much fun!!
Im a traditionl artist mostly (with a digital tablet that i got very recently) and digital seems the way to go...Yes markers are only $500 compared to 1000+, but markers get used up pretty quickly, especially if you don;t buy expensive high quality paper, and you have to keep buying them, or refills. The PC will last you 4-8 years easily depending on how you take care of it
And lets not forget the fack that there are some realey awesome artprograms out there for free, like krita. And when you wana have a phisical artwork you can just print it. But to be fair, I´m my self still a bit better in traditional art^^ So I love both
100%, if you spend over a thousand on a pc it should last you at least 5 years without an upgrade, assuming there's no faulty parts
My pc is surviving from 9 years and still going, but I use an iPad for digital art
Still waiting for someone to do realistic digital artwork, it's fine but it looks cartoony every time.
@@scottman572 art dosent need to be realistic to be good
One could also bypass the overhead for the PS program ($20 monthly) subscription by using Krita ($0 at all), especially when coming at it from the beginner angle.
You need to do 10 styles of Bob lol
He has
@@tinietilt7233 no he hasnt
Great idea 💡
y e s
DAS A GRATE IDEA
The only times I'm ever like "Damn, wish I was doing this digital" is when I run out of a marker and have to buy a new one. And when I want to do effects. I think if I ever went with a digital method I would still sketch and ink traditionally and only really use digital for certain projects for coloring and effects. I like the traditional piece from you better
I personally prefer the markers because i like to take my time and really enjoy it and i dont get that feeling with the tablet however i do prefer the tablet affects i also prefer using markers because i like making the colors myself instead of using photoshop but i still love both good job adc
I finally found a marvel artist I actually like
This guy is amazing.... I wonder if he does comic books?
no but hes a good artist
I definitely suggest using free art programs when starting out. Ones like Gimp, Medibang, and Fire Alpaca. Then when you are ready get a paid program like Clip Studio Paint or Photoshop.
Personally I prefer digital art, I even have a desk dedicated to my digital set up now. Mainly because I had issues finding the right things(markers n paper) because the art stores are too far away. So when one ran out Id have to wait months until I could go to the store.
What about Microsoft Paint?
I really love the finished result of the digital side, but as far as enjoying the process goes, I'd go with the markers every time! Giz a button then!!
Adcartattack: “Ducks are people too “
Guy watching: “what have I done”
Does that count for the giveaway I mean I did say it
Both looks awesome! Your a pro at digital art too! Its good to see the finished Scarlet Witch!🔥🔥
Your care free nature make these video's so watchable, they're jam packed with awesome content ( I basically learnt to colour again watching your videos) and they're just so easy going you can't help but have fun watching them!
As you said, the digital side is "the most eye-catching, most appealing,"' and the clear winner for its clean execution but the traditional side has more charm.
The shading in the digital is really really off putting and unnatural
I can never decide between traditional or digital...I guess it depends what mood I'm in that day lol. Also I love your marvel art!
#ducksarepeopletoo
So true
@@amogus830 yeah
Just learned about you from Jazza. I’ve rekindled my love for physical media to work with. The truth is #ducksarepeopletoo
Same!!!!! :D
Just going to say it. The digital looks 10 times better it looks like 5 years of progress challenge or something
I love digital art...I do it myself, there are a lot of alternatives to digital art as well, you can use an iPad, tablet, pc, a phone even...I use an iPad and Apple Pencil and use a professional free software.
I always come back to analog art even though I always admired the limitless effects of digital art
Me forgetting I’m watching ADC instead of Jazz’s: *waits for him to pull our Huion tablet*
The digital version is cleaner, more precise, and the skin tone has smooth blending. However, I prefer the way you coloured the costume in the traditional version because the colours feel more natural, and the paper gives it extra texture. Generally, Traditional might not be as clean, but I think that often gives them more life and dynamism.
I've entered your giveaways before, just for fun, but I think I'd be more scared of winning now because I'd probably get charged a small fortune in custom fees 😂
Holy hell...long time subscriber but I was blown away by the digital side. It was simply staggering how amazing it looked. The marker side was still superb as always but...wow...just wow. That digital side blew me away.
My favorite is the $500 Marker drawing. but both are very beautiful!
I have a tendancy to prefer digital art, although i do both a lot. I love doing like realism with coloured pencils, and I love the tools that digital gives me. I have a Huion tablet, that functions as both a tablet, and one of my main monitors, so it serves that dual purpose for me.
Love the hand drawn one because the artist's " fingerprint " is on it. The digital drawing is aesthetically more impressive because you were able to punch more effects into it. I'd like to see you do this again, reversing hand drawn and digital.
Alternative title: expensive vs expensive
Not expensive for Swaggy Duck
I really like the digital as well, but I'm far more jealous of the skill with physical medium.
Advantages that digital has over traditional are
-Layers
-U can add any colour over any other(light over dark won't mix)
-redo
-various brushes(tree,bushes etc)
-colour picking
-warping
-the liquify tool
-duplicate tool(no need to draw it again)
-move and change size
-fill colour
You can simply buy gaming glasses (they protect against eye strain from screens) to draw on a tablet comfortably. Also if you have an IPad and Apple Pencil then you can download a drawing program and draw straight, allowing you to draw outside if you want to.
there are some gaming glasses that help protect your eyes when doing stuff like that
Yeah blue filters, though I'm not entiiiirely convinced with them lol
Yeah LoL.
@@ADCArtAttack also digital art may not be there but it’s relatively easy to print it, and if you want to make a profit on a piece duplicate, not hating just saying
@@ADCArtAttack to my knowledge blue light filters have been proven to be a hoax they don’t actually do anything
Nobody gonna talk about the fact that she’s not wearing any bottoms? No? Okay.
SHES NOT
He cut the image off at a visual boundary point. It works well for the image :) but yeah I guess technically her bottoms aren’t shown. Didn’t bother me as the solid line clearly indicates she *is* wearing a bottom (it just isn’t shown).
Right?? Also, the old lady arms keep stealing my attention.
@@makeitkate3240 what old lady arms?
@@makeitkate3240 is called muscle 💪💪💪💪
Keeba says, “Ducks are people too, Dad!”
So excited to see this video as a digital artist myself. I just bought a display tablet earlier this year for under $600 CAD, a Huion Kamvas 16 Pro, a great upgrade for my over my Wacom Intuos Pro. I already had a laptop and a CC subscription so no extra cost for me there. I think when you consider with traditional you always have to buy replacement pens when you use them up and paper cost wise it’s not a bad trade off. However it can be expensive to print depending on how you get them printed. I’ve had a few of my paintings printed on canvas and that’s a bit pricey but worth it!
I love your marker side, however I do prefer the digital side in this side by side pic due to the special effects of her powers, that glow is amazing
“Ducks are people too”
Mah BORODAH
I was also in the livestream
Ducks are people too?
Me next time i go to the park: hey! Hey duck u wanna be my friend
Duck off, that's my friend! Get u own
TRADITIONAL ART ALL THE WAY BABY, LETS GOOOOO xD
lol
You always say that you’re not “great” at certain styles or mediums. But you always rock it. I def appreciate your honesty. I like the digital better but I understand you’re preference for the marker. It’s like appreciating reading an actual paper book more than reading a tablet. But stop selling yourself short, you’re awesome at what you do. Keep it up.
I must say my choice will change by the distance between my eyes and this final painting. If I'm close, I prefer traditional one. The texture is just exquisite, there's no comparison point. But if I'm far, I can't choose... They both look amazing. Thank you for sharing this videos 😊
Textures can be simulated by the brush you choose in the software. Traditional tools can also be simulated via the brush you pick. I have seen digital artworks where you cant tell if its digital or traditonal just by looking at it. Everything is possible with digital art. And its much cheaper because you dont have to rebuy supplies. They are infinite in digital art.
Procreate is a good example he didnt mention. All you need is an iPad (~600) to be able to use it and create beautiful art with it. No need for a tablet that needs a PC to work.
I'd argue that digital art is cheaper to make in the long run.
aspacaly if you just get a free program. I´m using krita and its realy great. It evan has an animation setting. all for completley free
@@terracorvus5280 you feel you're better drawing or painting?
@@Joe-ud1de I would say drawing. Aspacaly in digital art. I still have a lot to learn in this medium but I enjoi it as nutch as the other mediums^^
@ADC I watched the stream with delay so couldn't comment live as the stream has ended by then.. You don't need to ask anybody to write any code that will choose a random comment for your giveaway. There's a tool for that already :) try with commentpicker. If you google 'random comment picker' it should be the top result. Seen others use it, might help.
LOVE UR ART! keep the good wok up
Finally, a video that actually explain the process step by step and their reasons. Thanks dude!
Left side is best, like you said...its tangible...its art you can actually feel.....cant be beat
These videos always inspire to get back to art even if I’ve only paused it for a couple days #DucksArePeopleToo @_darkmaelstrom
Trying to think of something funny to comment because I’m early
I'm still waiting ,it's been three hours.
@@juriaan13 eh keep waiting
@@count1572 ok can do, good luck.
@@juriaan13 Yeah could potentially take another 17 years but I’ll get there eventually
@@count1572 I can't wait. I assume it will be super funny.
I’ve been trying to figure out “digital art” and I’m just to big of an idiot to get the hang of it.
No keep going dude. It took me a while. Now it's easy
Master pencil and paper first, because then you can transfer your style onto digital.
@@luke_Citino I think learning them both together is better then mastering one because you go to master one your just gonna be more reluctant to do the other because amazing traditional skill doesn’t translate to amazing digital skill and vice versa
@@Prince_-vu4wu I believe that you can learn the fundamental skills on paper and develop your style, that can be easily transerable digitally, in fact a lot of artists tebd to stick to the traditional method then scan to colour digitally.
@@luke_Citino you said to master pencil and paper first which I think when a person masters a medium they are more likely to not switch to a new one plus even with digital you can understand the fundamentals but it doesn't mean you will produce good results, drawing in general on a pen or display tablet is different than paper and it takes people time to adjust to it, along with being able to perform at the same standard as their traditional
I like the saturation of the colors of the digital art, but I like the feeling of the physical art.
Couldn't possibly pick one; love them both. I may be a bit biased for both though, being a (very) amateur digital colorist/artist for just over 4 years now who started using alcohol based markers a few months ago, and I love both mediums equally. Much more than any other mediums I've tried.
I get more eye strain working traditionally than I do digitally. The digital zoom feature helps a lot with that, I think. (Hilariously, on more than one occasion, I have caught myself doing the two-finger zoom gesture on paper. :P )
Really happy to have been directed to your channel from your collab with Jazza - that was awesome!
there goes my dog... I'll be giving away another one soon.. it's official! ADC's next giveaway is a dog xD
#DucksArePeopleToo 🦆
Instagram: @thespeedartist_08 🎨
The thing with the PD1560 to consider is that it lacks the color bit depth of most normal computer monitors. The average monitor is 8bit depth (~16.7M color display capability) while the screen of the PD1560 is only 6bit (~262k color display capability). Trying to go between a normal monitor and the tablet display with this particular pen display you end up with a noticeable green bias and lacking reds versus what you'd see on your computer screen assuming working/correct calibration. It will make many colors seem washed out compared to what's on your computer monitor. It's also worth noting that pen displays do allow you to adjust the output light and temperature (warm vs cool white) to best accommodate your eyes and needs.
To bring up that you also need a computer, while true, ends up being a nonissue most of the time as even a low-end computer can use a tablet and a computer isn't such a high luxury as it might have been 20 years ago. A $400 laptop can run your tablet driver and a decent art program without issue and can likely do many other things as well, so it's not necessarily an art supply as much as just being something you can also use for art. Chances are, if someone is watching this video, they already have something that can be used with a tablet. Photoshop is also not the only thing out there by any means and many quality softwares are cheap, if not completely free. Photoshop might be the best known, but it's far from the only thing out there. On lower-end systems you're actually better off getting and using something else as Photoshop is an absolute resource pig and you'll likely find that you'd only use about 20% of what Photoshop even has to offer, so why not spend your money (assuming you'll actually buy software) on something you'll use more to the fullest?
It also goes without saying that you don't need a $400 (or higher, especially for Wacom) pen display to make art. Even the larger-size low-end Wacom tablets are half that price and they're not the only brand out there. Huion and many other brands make tablets of competitive quality for even less. Just about any surface tablet will get you just as far with the same internals as every other tablet, you just won't have a screen and you'll need to look at your monitor-- the mental disconnect goes away pretty quickly. Lighting should be adequate in your workspace whether you're working digitally or traditionally, so if you're dealing with eye strain you should probably consider your ambient lighting first.
You mentioned macro vision. I can see cells on a flower petal and a lot of minuscule details on everything. It’s what hinders my artwork because I can see ALL the mistakes in great detail.
I used to make Cartoon Dolls in pixelated forms (I know this dates me but it was popular in the early 2000s.) This is a digital art form by placing pixels originally in MS Paint and creating gradients and such pixel by pixel. Like a digital pointillism. It made my vision of cells very useful.
I wish however I could be better at Art. I use my super vision plus the 4th cone in my eye to dye yarn instead of draw. Keep on making these videos and you’re just awesome!
I love traditional art for ever. Digital feels like cheating some how.
No it isn’t. It is easier in ways though.
@@thephilosopher5799 he just saying it feels like cheating that's his opinion, of course it isn't cheating
It is cheating.
@@kanarcydalive1579I am also a traditional artist but I respect everybody doing digital art and I don't get how it's cheating 🤷🏾♂️
@@svenlechtenberg8119
Because its the machine doing the work period. U can make mistakes galore without it ever showing or worrying about wasting materials(major benefit) . Basically you could do digital art without a care.
"ducks are people too"- dcortes7337
Got to admit, I prefer To mark a set because I like the fact that you can actually touching a piece of art weather than just having on a screen
I love the marker side more. Its, like you say, touchable. I can feel it just by looking at it and I am a photoshop "Pro" in my work life. I love PS.
I gotta go with traditional. It's as you said, you can see the love and care that is put into a traditional piece, because there is no CTRL+Z. Every stroke of marker, pen, paint, or pencil matters, and it's very difficult to adjust a mistake.
I am looking your videos now,liked your Battle with Jazza, your artwork is incredible 👏 🙌 👌 especially with the trashbox from Jazza. I am a follower now. Love your videos, I learned a lot about shading and coloring. Thanks a lot.
I prefer the digital side myself *except* for the eyebrow! The hand drawn eyebrow is much better and really evocative of the Scarlet Witch. Bravo for both sides.
Having started as a traditional artist I love it more! I worked for quite a few years as a "digital" Graphic designer and I said digital as if you do not know how to work on a computer you can not get a job! I also love having a paper copy an "original" artwork to have and hold! Yes I know you can print many copies of a computer generated artwork. it is just not the same! I hope the winner enjoys their prize!
I love traditional art but I live in a very small apartment and do not have room for $500 more of art supplies but I do have a computer and Photoshop so I can't wait to get a tablet soon, great job on both sides
Use Gunnar Optiks! They will help so much with eye stress/strain when looking at a monitor or anything for long amounts of time. I used to wear them when playing video games, helped me focus and not get a headache.
I love ur music man🤘🏼 Rock is 100% my favorite genre. Keep it up!🔥
Blue light filters help with eye strain from screens. My glasses has a blueish film thing on them and they save me from migraines with screens and fluorescent lights
I experience eye strain as well but I’ve found a type of glasses that’s great at combating it. Blue light glasses. They’re built to block radiation from the screen which is what causes the eye strain. You can get multiple pair off of Amazon really cheap
I like how the face looks on the marker side much more, but the rest of it looks better on the digital side.👍
If price point is the determining factor I would have to side with digital. Everything that has to do with traditional involves consumables. You're constantly needing to replace the paper, the markers and any other supplies like erasers and such while the digital process remains for as long as the equipment doesn't break down period and in this day most everyone already owns a computer
Really enjoyed the left side, I liked the effect you have done on her hand.
i think that which one is better really depends on your circumstances. For example, if you already own an tablet, it’s less expensive, since you only need a stylus (and their prices very a lot) and an art program (again, varies from cheap to expensive), but if you don’t own a laptop or tablet, it can be quite expensive. Also, some of the downsides you mentioned (specifically the issue of lack of portability) also depends on the type of digital tablet you have. like, if you have an ipad (or something similar) that you use for digital art, you can take it pretty much anywhere.
edit: i’m personally more of a digital artist, but i used to be a non-digital artist, and have transitioned recently
Digital _seems_ like the way to go because you will never run out of inks nor will you ever be missing that color that would make it perfect. You have the full range of everything, as long as you buy the right software at the beginning. To be completely honest, though, there is something more impressive and satisfying about actual tangible artwork. Even though there is still a real skill and knowledge level needed to produce quality work digitally, the fact that you can layer and erase, or go back and change sections you aren't as happy with later makes it seem like anyone could do it if they were given enough time. That isn't quite true, but it feels that way, and physical art just requires a "get it right, or start over" aspect that just makes it into a choice between two completely different worlds. If you are doing it for a job and need repeatable results that others have to approve or offer changes to the digital is the only way to go, but if you are wanting to produce one of a kind artwork for others to admire and display it absolutely must be done in the real world with actual supplies, bought and restocked, from a store or ordered.
To be honest, I am a digital artist myself and I do prefer to do stuff digitally, but!
Traditional artworks have much more life in them and that is incredible to be able to feel the way it was drawn and all the emotions given to it.
And as for choosing a side on a drawing you've made, I'd go with traditional. It really does look breathtaking. As always, very great job done. (:
I prefer the physical. Forme nothing beats the grain exposure and how you blend effects.
It worth mentioning that huion has a 13" display tablet that you can connect to a android phone for $250 there is also clip studio paint that a lot of artists are migrating to which runs about $50 USD for the base program, or 0.99 for mobile subscription
Digital is my choice but I’m biased because I’m an advanced graphic designer, and create digital art as my only source of income. A tablet like this would be beyond amazing for me, I wouldn’t be able to afford one for myself, but it would allow me so many more options for digital art.
Just found your channel and subbed! I’m a traditional artist but decided to take on digital work as of late and although I’m gaining a lot of work doing digital, it’s definitely different. I’m proud of my digital work but I do feel disconnected to it versus when I finish a traditional commission. I literally feel like my traditional works are like my little kids going off to college every time I send them to their new homes lol. Anyways, this video was great!!
I'm really not sure about if like the digital side more over the traditional side or otherwise. I always feel that traditional work is more like "alive" and digital is almost to perfect.
I like them both do.
Based solely on the results I prefer the digital side. But as for the mediums themselves, they both have their place and which you choose should be based on what your trying to do.
Computer tablets are nice, I have one without the screen and it's gotten a lot of use in the last year. However, I ended up buying myself an IPad and getting the program "Procreate". In total, It's a digital method that you can take anywhere as long as the tablet is charged and it still costs less than your markers. It's easy to use and only cost me a little over 400. And personally, I feel it's easier for me to translated planned detail in a traditional sketch, so being able to take a picture and put it into my art program for the colors helps a lot. But between traditional and digital, I can't decide honestly. I've only been a digital artist for maybe five years now, and I still love the texture of pencil on paper. I love both methods of art honestly.
How should I put it? Hmm The 500 marker side the power itself wasnt that big or glowing, but the lighting effect on the body seem very strong. It kinda make it a bit unreal. If the power is drew stronger, then it make sense. Digital art as you say blend it even better and I see a bit darker shading. The power and lighting effect on body is balance and wonderful. Both are unique, and man thanks for sharing. I learn a lots
Interesting comparison.
I think the digital side is more dynamic and the marker side is warmer. In my opinion one isn't intrinsically better than the other, but each it better for specific jobs.
As for which is a better value, though more expensive, i think the digital suite offers more versatility.
However, i personally like the look of the marker side better. It has more humanity.
Of course the ducks are people too! Nice art great work man!
Your Scarlet Witch is JACKED!! And I love that!
I like the marker side better.
but be sure to look into ohuhu brush markers, at less than 1 dollar a piece they are soooo close to copics and very amazing!
Shoulder pain if you work with a wacom because you look up at the screen instead of down at your hand. I just got a wacom. As I become more used to it I hope that I can be less tence.
I love the editing style in these videos
I choose the traditional art side,because i am a traditional artist. The blends are flawless, dnt get me wrong the digital side is beautiful as well,awesome video ADC, love to another video like this. I am new to digital art,like haven't a clue on how.
I LOVE WANDA VISION! a ducks are people too!
As a professional digital artist, there are so many amazing and free art programs to use that I actually tend to prefer.
Ducks are people too! Bro I am going into graphic design in highscool so that tablet would be helpful.
They are both beautiful 👏 great work most of my life I used markers until I bought Apple Pencil it so intuitive and well aware of how to use digital in a long run like almost forever my art won’t fade with time nor rip or tear and save a lot on paper
But on the other side the feeling you get and the touch sensory with pencil and paper is a very different feeling rant over but they both look amazing 🤩
For mobile digital drawing, the iPad pro is awesome :) I work professional with it as an illustrator.
I like how stylish Scarlet Witch looks "Ducks are people too"
you can use color mixer brush instead of smudge tool. (for Photoshop users)
Aaaaaaay just hopped onto this channel and I love it, but I do have a couple disagreements here as a person that often does digital art. You can do digital art pretty cheaply, and I would argue that you can do it cheeper than traditional art. You can use free art programs, or cheep ones like Clip Studio Paint most people own a computer and if you don’t, you can actually use your phone/iPad, and again, most people have a phone. FireAlpaca and Ibis Paint are also great programs if anyone with a low budget want to try out digital art themselves.
Another thing, you can get a really cheap tablet (not one you draw directly on) for less than 100$
Her special handy power...but ducks are people too;)
I can’t do that tablet. I’ve been working off the iPad Pro and Procreate for a couple years now. It’s drawing on a tablet and you only need that tablet and the app for $10. Ultimately cheaper than markers and other tablets. I’ve been designing tattoos, sticker designs, commissions, shoe custom designs, made my children a book, etc…. All off procreate and it has all paid my bills since I have bought it. It’s paid for itself more than 100 times over. I’d like to try one of these some day with photoshop an all that but, I’m more than fine with what I have. It’s simple and I can do high quality work without an issue nor does it take long to learn.
Definitely the markers for me, since youve been doing it longer it looks like it has more depth and... Ducks are people too