Best Electric Scooter? Ather 450X vs Ola S1 vs Simple Energy One | MotorBeam

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 31 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 152

  • @DhanilVira
    @DhanilVira 3 роки тому +31

    Which one would you pick and why?
    We are desperately waiting to ride all the scooters together for a proper ride comparison

  • @lakshmiprasadbodireddy6421
    @lakshmiprasadbodireddy6421 3 роки тому +11

    Simple one
    236 km
    Less than 5 hours charging
    Cost one lakh ten thousand
    Portable batteryand fixed battery
    So I think it better

  • @rmenonp
    @rmenonp 3 роки тому +30

    A real-world review would have been more authentic than reading off from secondary research data, especially for electric vehicles..humble suggestion

    • @shreeshaphebbar5623
      @shreeshaphebbar5623 3 роки тому +4

      2 are not launched still....
      So they cannot do that 😄

    • @rmenonp
      @rmenonp 3 роки тому +2

      @@shreeshaphebbar5623 i know...a little waiting won't do any harm...

    • @shreeshaphebbar5623
      @shreeshaphebbar5623 3 роки тому +1

      @@rmenonp I was saying that to you 😄😄😄

    • @asifmohammed5436
      @asifmohammed5436 3 роки тому

      agreed. also you forgot service centers and battery quality (replacement, etc..) , idk why it is not mentioned in any of the reviews here.

    • @Aconspiracyofravens1
      @Aconspiracyofravens1 3 роки тому

      @@rmenonp yes well they decided to release it early, anyways they are not allowed to lie on the documentation anyways

  • @fazerv8504
    @fazerv8504 3 роки тому +6

    Any information about the ground clearance of these scooters, as now a days this has become a factor of consideration.

  • @kunalsalunke7486
    @kunalsalunke7486 3 роки тому +16

    I am so eagerly waiting for the your drive reviews, coz simple and ola are better than each other in many aspects(atleast on paper) but huge plus point for ola is that it is an stable multinational company quick production and better service is guaranteed

    • @onesujeet
      @onesujeet 3 роки тому +2

      Simple has removable battery and higher range

    • @techiezed6682
      @techiezed6682 3 роки тому +4

      @@onesujeet bro but they are not established ...they don't even have a proper production facility ...it's just a prototype and they need more funds to collected and to get established....but Ola has the largest factory also it's a big corporate so after service will also be better

    • @arjunarun9147
      @arjunarun9147 3 роки тому

      @@techiezed6682 well simple energy has a larger factory now

  • @gabrielleraul
    @gabrielleraul 3 роки тому +6

    simple reminds me of that ringing bells freedom phone scam.

  • @YashRockzz26
    @YashRockzz26 3 роки тому +3

    I thought this guys get paid from Ather Every time they are talking about 450x why?
    Meanwhile this guy forget the 72nm torque from simple one it's comparison along with Ather Advertising....

  • @srinivasyadavalli373
    @srinivasyadavalli373 3 роки тому +2

    You were incorrect.
    Ola S1 charges in 4.5 hours which is comparable to Ather 450X which charges in 5+ hours. The 6.5 hours charging time is for the Ola S1 pro variant which has a much bigger battery pack.

  • @Pixel_Mechanic
    @Pixel_Mechanic 3 роки тому +5

    At the moment, we only know the numbers quoted on paper for both Simple and Ola. Ather is the only brand among these three which is tried and tested by a lot many users. We'll only get to know more about Ola and Simple once it tried and tested out in an uncontrolled (real world) environment. Until then it's just a spec competition 😊

  • @saurabhmeshram972
    @saurabhmeshram972 3 роки тому +4

    Ather is not even available in most of the major cities today, that gives ola edge over any brand considering they r launching in 1000 cities.

  • @farulahmed7644
    @farulahmed7644 2 роки тому +1

    The prices are ridiculously high for electric automobiles…! Saving fuel doesn’t compensate for the price difference

  • @hakimuddinmistry5172
    @hakimuddinmistry5172 2 роки тому

    Which one will you suggest

  • @neoaryan1266
    @neoaryan1266 3 роки тому +2

    Very good and exhaustive info 👍
    Expecting a comparison ride review soon after they will be available in the market.

  • @kausarbarisadriwala2873
    @kausarbarisadriwala2873 3 роки тому

    In simple one normal charge how time to take for charging and when continuously drive sonic mode in highway so how much get range last

  • @theodoroskotronas460
    @theodoroskotronas460 3 роки тому

    This scooters is only for India market or global?

  • @manishdewal
    @manishdewal 3 роки тому

    Why they been refraining to use ABS, any guess ? It's very useful I'm waiting for this system as is currently installed in my CBR 250R

  • @vigneshb9351
    @vigneshb9351 3 роки тому +14

    Simple one is just copy of Ather I don't have any trust in this company it is very clear from their presentation itself but ola looks promising

    • @ajaykukreti3268
      @ajaykukreti3268 3 роки тому +4

      Their presentation was decent. It was decent and to the point info rather than masala movie type presentation by ola ev. I guess that's what you prefer.

    • @Mechrider
      @Mechrider 3 роки тому

      Thats true. Simple one is a clear scam.

    • @nytroxnikko1532
      @nytroxnikko1532 3 роки тому

      I wouldn't mind if they copy Ather. Ather is class.

  • @avinashm6049
    @avinashm6049 3 роки тому +1

    Great observation you have made about the top speed! I keep reading about how great the top speed the Ola scooter has. No one has thought about where are they gonna hit such speeds? Definitely not inside the city for sure.

  • @vasusingh2894
    @vasusingh2894 3 роки тому +1

    I don't want to take call while ride i wanna better performance and range. And essential feature

  • @rohantikhe7661
    @rohantikhe7661 3 роки тому

    hi dhanil...can you jut tell me what will be the price of Ola S1Pro in Maharashtra, Pune on road after applying state subsidy ??
    also want to know how much units it will consume for full charge ??

  • @amritansumitra
    @amritansumitra 3 роки тому

    When will Ola offer test drives for reviewers and media personnels? You guys have any idea?

  • @ashwinbhat8826
    @ashwinbhat8826 3 роки тому

    What about the price ranges of ola in Karnataka?

  • @suchismitapal9652
    @suchismitapal9652 3 роки тому

    Which one is better Rugged or Ola?

  • @TheMahesh1437
    @TheMahesh1437 3 роки тому

    Pls correct few mistakes you have said in this video like simple one also have call answering feature and ola weights only 80kgs not 125kgs

  • @vijaywalikarvlogs17
    @vijaywalikarvlogs17 3 роки тому

    Ye gadi kaha milegi,,,,muje leni hai lekin shorom pata nhi

  • @himanshupatel9065
    @himanshupatel9065 3 роки тому

    Wah dhanil bhai.wait kari raya ta aa review mate

  • @shreeshaphebbar5623
    @shreeshaphebbar5623 3 роки тому +3

    Have booked Ola S1 Pro.....
    They are saying that showrooms and purchases will open from 8th September....
    Eagerly waiting for scooter to come..... 😄😄

    • @amritansumitra
      @amritansumitra 3 роки тому +1

      I too have booked the S1 Pro. Called Ola and they said purchase will start from 8 September. But test drives will begin in October.
      So I just don't understand, how are we supposed to pay the full price without even looking at the scooter physically?
      This is really stupid.
      What if we don't like it or it doesn't suit our needs? I don't think they'll allow cancellation post full purchase since by October the RTO registration would have been done before we get test rides.

    • @shreeshaphebbar5623
      @shreeshaphebbar5623 3 роки тому

      @@amritansumitra I read in the website that the showrooms may open from 8th September and we may have a test drive...
      If we like that,we can pay the amount and the delivery will be done in October..
      But if we don't like it,the 499 what we had paid to reserve the scooter will be refundable....

    • @amritansumitra
      @amritansumitra 3 роки тому

      @@shreeshaphebbar5623 no bro. I got confirmation from Ola itself. No test rides before October.
      Even on the website they've updated October.

    • @shreeshaphebbar5623
      @shreeshaphebbar5623 3 роки тому

      @@amritansumitra oh...any info about the showroom openings????

    • @amritansumitra
      @amritansumitra 3 роки тому

      @@shreeshaphebbar5623 Nope. They said they'll update through their website.
      But I haven't seen even 1 photo of Ola showroom in India so far. And it's almost September.
      Maybe they'll just use their Ola cabs offices as an office for Ola Electric as well for final payment and paperwork since we haven't seen any leaked photos of any showroom in India and just home deliver the scooter.

  • @rushikeshmungekar
    @rushikeshmungekar 3 роки тому

    Whats the charging cost

  • @Fun_facts_Zzz
    @Fun_facts_Zzz 3 роки тому +1

    I don't why you are little biased towards ather, clearly the other two dominate

  • @funfact1604
    @funfact1604 3 роки тому

    When will simple energy launch

  • @asifrahman907
    @asifrahman907 3 роки тому +12

    Simple energy is the 2021 version of freedom 251🔥🤮
    Please dont pre book

    • @jj_1512
      @jj_1512 3 роки тому +4

      Bro its start up let the company settle down let youtubers get production model for testing dude. Like cant you support a start upp dude.

    • @asifrahman907
      @asifrahman907 3 роки тому +5

      @@jj_1512 yes, i would love. Infact i was going to pre book the scooter, but there were many confusions. Like registration info inthe launch of the model bike was an ather 450x, and they dont even have plant, and they are planning to deliver the bikes in jan 2022.
      1.a guy asked to the ceo whether it has a cruise control this was the reply
      "It is not exactly a cruise control. It is a mix of things, which is not really a very highlighting point for us. It's just a feature there. It's not going to be a selling point for us, something that I don't think customers would even like to use. If it's there or not there I can't confirm because we're working on the OTA update for that. Not sure if we'll be involving that but we're working on it. I have to consult my team", says Rajkumar, when pressed on the topic of cruise control availability on the One
      2.they changed the full reveal 3 times but not revealed yet
      3.their site is registered in Indonesia why a indian brand register in Indonesia
      4.the pre booking cannot be cancel
      5. The customer service is terrible, you see it in their insta comments
      5.many people are complaining that the money has debited but thay havent got a confirmation letter
      6.they changed the specs in site many time. Why?

    • @jj_1512
      @jj_1512 3 роки тому

      @@asifrahman907 Understandable Have a great day

    • @namanjain5763
      @namanjain5763 3 роки тому +1

      I don't know but I think that 245km is due to using the eco mode at best case and can be limit speed of 20-30km else why for a range of 110 max why so many modes
      In ola 2 modes may make the normal mode max to be 50 or 60 limit that is very much ideal and if want overtake or go speed can use other options like hyper or sports.
      I personally have booked ola and will wait till atleast 1-2 review are there.

    • @jj_1512
      @jj_1512 3 роки тому +1

      @@namanjain5763 Buddy its already revealed that its gonna do 48 kmph in eco and get upto 203 with a passenger. But if we think that these are not accurate the and we keep our speed upto 60 kmph then we would be able to get atleast 165-185! And thats super great!!!

  • @jojorice4594
    @jojorice4594 2 роки тому

    Why do you need it?

  • @kshitijdwivedi7063
    @kshitijdwivedi7063 3 роки тому

    The revolution is here... 🔥. Would love to see electric vehicles on road 🙂

  • @mayyuchape7195
    @mayyuchape7195 3 роки тому

    Maharashtra state Govt is offering an additional early bird incentive of up to Rs 15,000 for those who purchase the two-wheeler before December 31, 2021. if battery capacity of close to 3 kWh, buyers will be eligible for a total benefit of Rs 25,000 this year.
    Then S1 pro price Should be 105000 but ola website shows 125000 Why

    • @yogeshtiwari4081
      @yogeshtiwari4081 3 роки тому

      Hi dear Badri I am a Pune localite, can you suggest where is this additional incentive offering mentioned by Maharashtra state govt, so that we can do some pro cess of claiming it with Ola I have booked pro S1. Also if you know some more info about how can we avail this additional incentive what can be the process for it, please suggest. Btw great info suggested by you to our customer benefit per se. Cna share your phone no. And we can talk also

  • @bewatch_0
    @bewatch_0 3 роки тому

    Thanks for interesting information ✌️

  • @saishprabhudesai3998
    @saishprabhudesai3998 3 роки тому

    wat abt restrosa

  • @godfather5563
    @godfather5563 3 роки тому +11

    Simple, is the bigggest scam bro , pls don't go for it

    • @Nobody-xp6ip
      @Nobody-xp6ip 3 роки тому +2

      How can you say that?

    • @godfather5563
      @godfather5563 3 роки тому

      Am in the ev scooter manager in Hyderabad in such 3 years I have never seen that cheap built, once if u get into either a small accident it goes into pieces,

    • @rajb6822
      @rajb6822 3 роки тому +2

      @@godfather5563 oh crap ,hav u atleast seen that scooter in person, u cant comment shitting in your home and seeing these videos,
      Still many auto journalists havent got a chance to ride it, and u r comment some bull shit over here😂

    • @rajasankar390
      @rajasankar390 3 роки тому +1

      @@godfather5563 oh so you own that scooter in your home ?

    • @godfather5563
      @godfather5563 3 роки тому

      @@rajasankar390 oh boy, are u in another Universe

  • @asishmishra3236
    @asishmishra3236 3 роки тому

    overally simple energy one is practically worth buying it

  • @premmeena3666
    @premmeena3666 3 роки тому +1

    Simpel one is best 👍💯

  • @kspranav7782
    @kspranav7782 3 роки тому +4

    Is Simple energy a scam 🤔

    • @rithwikprajwal5979
      @rithwikprajwal5979 3 роки тому +3

      Yes, seems like it's a scam like freedome 251 mobile.

    • @nytroxnikko1532
      @nytroxnikko1532 3 роки тому

      You just wait and see. Test ride and then book it. People who are comparing it to Freedom 251 are idiots.

  • @cathyvanlalhmangaihzuali8244
    @cathyvanlalhmangaihzuali8244 3 роки тому

    Can I get it this year

  • @premmeena3666
    @premmeena3666 3 роки тому

    Marked me kab aayega

  • @kamsam6789
    @kamsam6789 3 роки тому +1

    Features are the claim
    Reality are totally different 🍸

  • @shashiwarrier110
    @shashiwarrier110 3 роки тому +1

    What is the life of the battery?
    What is the replacement cost of the battery?
    What are the environmental problems associated with battery disposal?
    Without answers to these questions, the rest of the information you present is meaningless.

    • @namanjain5763
      @namanjain5763 3 роки тому

      I really doubt any of them have battery recycling and for that there is Tata chemical already in works to do so.
      Most of them don't want to boder with it and right now most of them use foreign countries to do so.
      And using the plans we can even sell the battery to them in future and get some money back as they also will make Tata motors battery and for others also so may get cheaper matterial.
      But it may take 3-5 years and most of us who use them will face battery swap at that time only.
      Hope Tata chemical do implement there plan quicker as else battery replacement may cost more.

    • @shashiwarrier110
      @shashiwarrier110 3 роки тому

      @@namanjain5763 Thanks very much. Any idea of the cost of replacing the battery?

    • @namanjain5763
      @namanjain5763 3 роки тому

      @@shashiwarrier110 ola is saying 40-50k as ather say they charge that only.
      But they also provide subscription plan to deal with it like 1699 a month to see no change in battery.
      And realistically if you see battery replacements as the real major cost as no other services like engine oil or other expenses like air filter is there and break change cost could be less due to regenerative breaking.
      But in short battery cost is near half or atleast 1/3 of total vehicle cost

    • @shashiwarrier110
      @shashiwarrier110 3 роки тому

      @@namanjain5763 Thanks. I was guessing that battery cost would be around 40 per cent of vehicle cost. Rs 1,699/- pm is Rs 20,000/- a year. No real advantage in maintenance cost.

    • @namanjain5763
      @namanjain5763 3 роки тому +1

      @@shashiwarrier110 actually the estimate differ according to drive.
      As if we see ather they state it don't matter on years but km.
      And battery reduce so if ola claim of 120-180 are very close to reality then people can easily manage in 50% of the capacity so they state there battery looses 20% charge capacity in 30k km and loose 2-4% in every 7k km (k=1000).
      So make it accordingly if you can charge daily and run is around 30km max and buy s1 pro and it deliver even 150km then even if battery loose 50 or even 60% of capacity most people will not mind and for that if we see ev car figure they coat atleast 500k miles+.
      My cousin use hero ev optima and he have driven it well atleast nearby for last 4-5 years and his earlier best km and todays best km are very close only 20% reduced.
      So it might be a lesser concern then people imagine.
      That's why people say 150 is to much if we charge daily but it also solve future problems.
      And if you think then simple is better then I really think the number is a scam that can only be achive in Eco mode and seeing no of modes I really think it would not be more then 40km/hr max speed that is like not even usable in my opinion.

  • @sauravbasu8805
    @sauravbasu8805 3 роки тому

    Can OLA scooter start without the help of a mobile phone ?

  • @haneefapk4129
    @haneefapk4129 3 роки тому

    Simple one will take full charge 4 hrs only from normal charger.

  • @jabercn
    @jabercn 3 роки тому

    Unless and until ola and simple are not available physically to test drive in the real world this comparison analysis doesn't hold any value.

  • @sujithsanjith9455
    @sujithsanjith9455 3 роки тому +1

    go for spark energy electric bike

  • @hakimuddinmistry5172
    @hakimuddinmistry5172 2 роки тому

    Simple energy is just on paper can't compare to other

  • @pradeeprakkiyappan7199
    @pradeeprakkiyappan7199 3 роки тому +1

    Don't go for simple one. It's a scam😑

  • @BlackpearlAbu
    @BlackpearlAbu 3 роки тому

    Ola looks simple & classy 😍❤️

  • @rahulkanojia8883
    @rahulkanojia8883 3 роки тому

    Bhaiyo itni costly scooty le rahe ho wo bhi coal se chalne wali ...... Isse better toh cng Alto 800 h ..... 🙏🙏this comment is not for people who are buying electric scooter because of hiked petrol prices .... I m just saying is there any difference between burning coal and petrol ...?????

  • @TheTylerWhit
    @TheTylerWhit Рік тому

    Work well

  • @jasvedsinghahluwalia1691
    @jasvedsinghahluwalia1691 2 роки тому

    i have paid the balance amount on 21st jan but still didnt recieved even a single call for registration process otp etc. I have not reicieved the invioce too. please dont consider purchasing ola. Their service is third grade. Better consider other options rather than spending money on this bullshit.

  • @avcreations7991
    @avcreations7991 3 роки тому +5

    Simple is best

  • @sudeepgupta9508
    @sudeepgupta9508 2 роки тому

    हिंदी में बनाते तो मैं भी देख लेता भाई ✌️

  • @saishprabhudesai3998
    @saishprabhudesai3998 3 роки тому

    Speed limit is only when cops r at road

  • @amar19861003
    @amar19861003 3 роки тому

    Simple energy is a fictional scooter?

  • @tarunn99able
    @tarunn99able 3 роки тому

    Mere ko lena hai par yeh saale drama laga rakha jadoo ki tarah na launch kar rahe na doosra lene de rahe ather lene gaya ola aagaya ola ka socha hi tha simple aagaya uska pata hi nahi

  • @ayushk4099
    @ayushk4099 3 роки тому +1

    Bajaj Chetak is best
    It is iconic and reliable without any gimmick

    • @anirudhhhh
      @anirudhhhh 3 роки тому +4

      It is slow and has lesser range

    • @ayushk4099
      @ayushk4099 3 роки тому

      @@anirudhhhh range will be same as Ather or OlaS1

    • @anirudhhhh
      @anirudhhhh 3 роки тому +2

      @@ayushk4099
      Ather will easily do 100+ range if ridden between 40-50km/hr and is Aria rated at 116
      I couldn't find Aria rating for Chetak.
      Bajaj seems to have played it safe with specs and looks.

    • @philpsdi4051
      @philpsdi4051 3 роки тому +2

      Chetak won’t climb my road slope... Chetak and I cube are waste bodies in my road steep slope

    • @ayushk4099
      @ayushk4099 3 роки тому

      @@anirudhhhh how can range be more in Ather if both Chetak and 450 has same size battery

  • @sudeepgupta9508
    @sudeepgupta9508 2 роки тому

    जिसको अंगेजी न आती हो वो क्या करे आपके वीडियो का

  • @kushyadav8269
    @kushyadav8269 3 роки тому

    *Koi chutiya hi hoga jo ab petrol* ⛽ *scooter lega*
    *Petrol 117 ₹*

  • @mikerock9207
    @mikerock9207 3 роки тому

    Ola is like getting shares. Have put money for allotment. Now waiting to get it in hand. Don't know how much the risk is involved untill it launches in market completely and get the real world reviews. 😄

  • @kittu999c
    @kittu999c 2 роки тому

    Ather back seat really sucks

  • @DanElgaard9
    @DanElgaard9 3 роки тому

    Please, don't have annoying music - please, don't have annoying music - please, don't have annoyinh music...
    ...damn - bye !!! (and downvote)

  • @ArunKumar-pm1cd
    @ArunKumar-pm1cd 3 роки тому +2

    Let's see how many are going to loose Rs 1947 by pre booking simple. It's obviously a scam and still good number of people paid money.

  • @najibuddin9175
    @najibuddin9175 3 роки тому

    I think simple one is frauds

  • @xzeiboi9125
    @xzeiboi9125 3 роки тому +2

    First

  • @santhoshpjohn
    @santhoshpjohn 3 роки тому

    Simple energy is a SCAM. DONT PUT MONEY

  • @sayedmohdarif9700
    @sayedmohdarif9700 3 роки тому +1

    First