@@fwefhwe4232 yeah, no worries of mileage getting down every few year and little to no maintenance with cheap electricity and subsidy 🤔 looks steal deal . but it would be problem for people living in flat. how would they charge. they better invest in infrastructure for charging
Still more competition is expected , once established players will bring their mass appealing models. But till that time dont wait -enjoy with present ones.
@@ArdhenduChakraborty621 and yet they broke even just now.after 4 strong years.I don't see them competing in price with ola and simple although quality wise bldc motor , every part of ather screams expensive. Single alloy frame. Ather is the apple of scooters no doubt. Their subscription model is shady though.
@@ArdhenduChakraborty621 plus don't fall for these companies claim.simple one is not going outside bangalore in large scale for a really long time and ola's claim won't come close to what they are promising.although would still be better than ather.point in note ola uses lfp batteries while ather uses more expensive one's with cobalt , nickel , manganese. Tbh ather is still the king if you can afford it.
Great info! Thanks! I am EV scooter user for 2 years. You know that speed, torque and all those fancy terms do not really matter in the long run. Mostly what matters is 1. RANGE 2. Runing Cost 3. Spares Quality & availibility 4. Customer Support. I dont know what to expect from these scooters regarding these.
Very true. I think OLA with its huge factory is committed and has the infrastructure to provide support, parts and upgrade in the longer run. Aether and simple will fade away and vanish in a couple of years.
There scene is quite like nokia they don't want to inovate much as there was no completion just running there old scooter but now race has begun with leader like ola
@@ramendragupta5482 see the running cost.. even if you take a petrol scooter you will end up paying 3 times.. the amount you will use for petrol you can use thst for EMI.. the problem with us Indians is we do not see the long run.. abhi ka abhi profit chahiye sabko hatho hath
I have 4 questions 😁👉 1- Is it completely waterproof? 2- Can we charge it with normal electric socket? 3- How many years does its battery work properly and where and how can it be replaced in case of problem? And how much can it cost? 4- How much is its loading capacity, because scooty is not used for sitting only one person in a normal Indian society , and sometimes in the empty space in front of the seat, we keep heavy things.
Simple is not behind though,they also producing 10lakh vehicles a year which is btw more than Bajaj and tvs production and unlike ola they r only focused on 13states and they are opening showrooms
simple one has removable battery so u can charge that everywhere, and it’s launching only in few cities and production is less so doesn’t need infra that much. With Ola u will have to change your route and eat at third class restaurant because chargers are there only, what if location of charger restaurant is closed? Simple one u are free to rest anywhere without having to change ur route, if u take 75min brakes every 3 hours then u can get unlimited range as u can charge simple one while taking breaks, Olas funding went is launching in 6months, scale and marketing. Simple one is also 20k cheaper so u can buy speakers with the saved money
Did you notice that BENGALURU has become a gaint of startup companies 💥 Even Tesla head office is going to situate in Bengaluru....... Silicon valley of 🧡🤍💚
Range is not a problem for me as we have to not travel 200km on a scooter but still an important thing. I will choose ola scooter just because it has a boot space that can accommodate 2 helmets. Simple decreased the boot by adding removable battery pack and so it has more range. Simple has good boot space but it cannot hold 2 helmets so I like ola also ola will be having the best infrastructure
@@JaspreetSingh-yx4lt Well it's personal preference but in my city both driver and pillion are are required to wear helmet and 2 helmets in a scooter is just amazing and useful for me
The battery will at least last 8 years if people charge upto 80 percent and discharge upto 20 percent. I travel 20km between my home and office every day. It would amount to 25,000 km per year If we add another 20 km for my every day Grocery shopping and other travels. So if we charge upto 80 percent and discharge upto 20 percent it at least last Upto 1200 cycles. ( Can last upto 2000 cycles ). For OLA S1 pro 181km × 1,200 = 217,000km 217,000km ÷ 25,000 km/year = 8.6 years. The electricity rate in my city is ₹ 7 per kWh , Ola S1 pro has a 4 kWh battery So , cost of one full charge = 7 × 4 = Rs. 28 As I mostly travel 40 km every day So , price per km = ₹ 28 /181km = ₹ 0.15 So , electricity price per day = ₹0.15 × 40km = ₹ 6. Suppose I travel 40 kms every day for 365 days , So , electricity price per year = ₹6 × 365 days = 2,190. So , electricity cost in 8 years = 17,520. Where as , Petrol scooter mileage is 40 - 50 km per /litre. So , fuel price per km = Rs.100 ÷ 50 km = Rs.2 per Km. Suppose I drive my scooter for 50 km every day for 365 days. So , fuel price per year = Rs.2 × 50km × 365 days = ₹36,500. So fuel price for 8 years = ₹36,500 × 8 years = ₹ 292,000. Money saved by using electric scooter for 8 years = ₹ 292,000 - ₹ 17,520 = ₹ 274,000. Now , By the time you need to replace a battery Tesla 4680 battery will already be available for Ola S1 at an price $ 45 - 50 /kWh. ( Not for the battery pack) Where as the current prices are $ 110 / kWh. Ola S1 pro has 4 kWh battery so , current battery price = ₹35,000 - ₹40,000. And the future price ( 3 years tentative) = ₹15,000 - ₹20,000.
installed 5k solar On Grid system and I am running 2 AC moderately, refrigerator, Lights, TV, Mixer and " Tata nexon EV " all free of cost I mean Zero rupees power Bill🤩😍
My personal pick would be Simple one, because the main thing here is range and charging time what else do you want in a scooter, people will mainly be using this scooters in city and I don't think many of them will use so many of the features in the screen which ola provided.
Btw cruise is not that important for city riders, its better for highways, but most scooter don't give good mileage in its max speed (and for more information - both simple one {only confirmed by ceo not announced} and ola as cruise control)
Simple one also has it simple one has removable battery so u can charge that everywhere, and it’s launching only in few cities and production is less so doesn’t need infra that much. With Ola u will have to change your route and eat at third class restaurant because chargers are there only, what if location of charger restaurant is closed? Simple one u are free to rest anywhere without having to change ur route, if u take 75min brakes every 3 hours then u can get unlimited range as u can charge simple one while taking breaks, Olas funding went is launching in 6months, scale and marketing. Simple one is also 20k cheaper so u can buy speakers with the saved money
Waiting for these scooters to come into market and bring a healthy competition in electric vehicles especially one like Ather which is priced high without actually competing with their rivals in any manner except the price.
Very good Crisp yet Comprehensive comparison. Inclusion of Tyre size, warranty on battery and bike and yearly cost of ownership would have made it even better.
Thank so much you for the detailed comparison.. love your blogs. However one concern I have is, as you know how the whether we have here in Mumbai, during the rainy season most of the areas there are water logging issues. How would these electric bike work in those condition and other aspects?
Yes always specs are present on book but there is always a difference between practical working and company tested conditions, we need to check on their quality of shocks, how they handle regular roads with humps and potholes.
Would still choose Ather any given day! Here's why: For me personally, Ather is all about reliability and safety. It's been well "tested for years" unlike ola S1, Simple Energy.. whatever, which I guess have not yet even been given clearance by the government (maybe wrong here). Can't compromise on safety of my loved ones.. it's not a phone! Also, what Simple Energy is trying to do today (Showcasing a demo model).. Ather did it well 5-6 years ago! Clearly not sure when will they be a able to release a reliable product. Sometimes it may be just the marketing being done for years. And am sure Ather will come up with better lucrative propositions! Nevertheless kudos to all the competitors to spark the way ahead.
Sir ji make a detailed analysis compression video 1. Bajaj chetak 2. Tvs Icub 3. Hero ecetric 4. Ola s1/s1 Pro 5.simple one 6. Anther all mode 7. E pure 7g 8. Aprilia ev etc...
1.What about battery warranty ? 2.What about battery life ? 3.What about battery cost ? 4.What is the water damage cost and does warranty covers ? 5.What about monthly/yearly subscription price ? 6.What is IP rating ? 7. What is service cost ? 8. What is the cooling technology ola ,simple and ather used ? 9. What about heat emitting by motor and battery also ? I think ather have vents and simple also but what about ola ? 10. What about the tires does it satisfies the latest tire norm ?
But Ola is the best Because extra futures and sound 🔊 My best future in Ola which I feel is that the vehicle would have been unlocked in its own name. 😍
hello sir, can you also tell something about the weight carrying capacity of these scooters? how much weight can these scooters carry giving out the same performance and features listed by these companies?
In simple one should we surely remove the removable battery to charge it or can we charge it with non removable battery without removing removable battery out of ev??
Well as I've understood through other sources, you can charge the removable battery along with the main battery when you plug in the scooter. But not sure which one does the scooter prefer to charge first.
I you have cleared all my doubts thanks for valuable information. But I have 1 question. Is it can recharge Like mobile example if our phone get 40% we charge immediately. To complete 100% like that can we charge in scooters or we have to wait till empty
1)After sales service kessi h.. 2) Maintenance and parts cost ..?? 3) Battery cost after renwal.. 4) Battery Life span?? 5) what if we stuck in between..of interior road??
At the end of the day I still think Ather is beautiful. Can't help thinking all this over juicing of battery will just create more and more lithium waste. The question to ask at this juncture of EV adoption is how much does one need ? Range, top speed, battery juicing.
most of the people think that beating ather will be good but that is also a pure INDIAN company that is of bangalore comapany we should also support that keep that in mind because of these a nice startup shouldn't be getting down
Huge problem is with those who don't own a house and who stays in appartments how wil they charge it's still a big concern which is not letting me go for electric bike
I have used okinawa scooter for 3 years with acid lead battery . On paper - Range/Top speed - 1) Economy class 90km/35 kmph 2) sports mode- 65 km/55 kmph On Road For 6 months- Range/Top speed 1) Economy Mode - 80Km/ 35kmph 2) Sports - 55km/55 kmph After 6 months Range starts decreasing and reached 35Km after 2.5 years.Top speed remains same.
simple one has removable battery so u can charge that everywhere, and it’s launching only in few cities and production is less so doesn’t need infra that much. With Ola u will have to change your route and eat at third class restaurant because chargers are there only, what if location of charger restaurant is closed? Simple one u are free to rest anywhere without having to change ur route, if u take 75min brakes every 3 hours then u can get unlimited range as u can charge simple one while taking breaks, Olas funding went is launching in 6months, scale and marketing. Simple one is also 20k cheaper so u can buy speakers with the saved money
I have ' Yo egde ' ev 1)0.35kw waterproof motor 2) 70km range 3) lithium ion battery 4) charging time max-(3.5hr) 5) price - 60,000 INR Iam using from 1.5 yr no difference in range and power, I travelled 6000 km, My experience is very nice🤗 without subsidy
Ppls prefer on road record's performance not on papers,, appreciate if you update us accordingly,,, subscribed for sort term and wait for your next update
#1 ⭕LA as u have not mentioned the Geo fencing feature AI ENABLED voice greeting KEYLESS LOCK n UNLOCK feature & 3 types of metre consoles in OLA... Is the display waterproof? What's the IP rating?
Sir no doubt .......Ola hi leni h ....... Coz ...... 1 brand value 2 resale value 3 fair price 4 good battery 5 looks 6 demand ........ Or bhi bahut sari cheeze ho sakti h .....or jitni Ola bikengi mera hi fayda h ..... I m from stock market.....
Which One Will You Pick?
How much weight they can carry
Please reply
Ola
OLA because it can accomodate 2 helmets
Sir pls do a video on which electric car to buy- MG ZS Ev, Hyundai Kona electric or Nexon Ev
Love from Nawabon ka Lucknow
Ather is lagging behind in everything except the price 😂
True that 😂 .. and I suppose they've filled their pockets enough to spend on some new tech/innovation
450x top speed is 90, not 70
@@vijethakornaya9379 u need not to spend much on tech...Just spend on marketing
@@golusharma3291 but Ola S1 pro top speed 115km/hr and simple one 105km/hr
😂😂
Hope one day we see all EV's in India 😌😌
Ola & Simple One really gave a big blow to Ather 😂😂
Yes before 2030 Definitely
Ab toh AKMKB Bolna Padega 😂
@@myselfroyal6924 not till 2035
@@arpitthakur45 how you know ?
@@maazkagdi148 seeing how fast things work in our country...2035 atleast...more electronic cars as well
Please make a video on running cost of electric scooter. Battery life. Screen cluster life after using in monsoon. Overall experience
10 times cheaper than petrol
all electric scooters cost 10-15 paisa per km
all electric cars cost 80-100paisa per km
@@fwefhwe4232 yeah, no worries of mileage getting down every few year and little to no maintenance with cheap electricity and subsidy 🤔 looks steal deal . but it would be problem for people living in flat. how would they charge. they better invest in infrastructure for charging
Shi kha bhai
@@reed1hiragar422 main expense is lithium battery every 5 years for 2 wheelers and every 15 years for cars
Simple one is not simple.. It's Beast.. ❤️❤️
😄😄😄😄
👍
शिंपल वन ..☑️ एक नंबर भेंचो 👌😍🤗🤗
Still more competition is expected , once established players will bring their mass appealing models. But till that time dont wait -enjoy with present ones.
Ather is out of the race now 😂😂😂
True, ab unko updates lane padenge
Right
Ather was WAYYYY too over-pricing their scooters. Now they'll go out of league until they re-look into their pricing model.
@@ArdhenduChakraborty621 and yet they broke even just now.after 4 strong years.I don't see them competing in price with ola and simple although quality wise bldc motor , every part of ather screams expensive. Single alloy frame. Ather is the apple of scooters no doubt. Their subscription model is shady though.
@@ArdhenduChakraborty621 plus don't fall for these companies claim.simple one is not going outside bangalore in large scale for a really long time and ola's claim won't come close to what they are promising.although would still be better than ather.point in note ola uses lfp batteries while ather uses more expensive one's with cobalt , nickel , manganese. Tbh ather is still the king if you can afford it.
OLA : At a hyper charging station, the batteries can charge up to 75 km range in just 18 minutes for both variants.
Nice!
Many points of ola are missed in this video, by using fast chargers ola can be charged 100% in just 1.5 hours.
Yes
Cruise control and voice navigation in ola s1pro its best I think paid vedio by simple one
@@buraque7973ha bhai isi kaaran aag lg jata hai sayd😂
Great info! Thanks! I am EV scooter user for 2 years. You know that speed, torque and all those fancy terms do not really matter in the long run. Mostly what matters is 1. RANGE 2. Runing Cost 3. Spares Quality & availibility 4. Customer Support. I dont know what to expect from these scooters regarding these.
Very true.
I think OLA with its huge factory is committed and has the infrastructure to provide support, parts and upgrade in the longer run. Aether and simple will fade away and vanish in a couple of years.
OLA has at home service... that's 👍
OLA raised 200 millions mate they will kill other competitors
Jin logon ko website padhna nahin aata woh yeh video dekhyen 😆
Agar aap real product ka comparison dekhna chate ho toh koi dushra video dekho
Awaiting for Yo bykes to comeback and join the race!! Oldest player though. Ancient one! 🔥
Who would have imagined Ather would be destroyed like this.....
This is what we want. Competition. So that they can launch their bikes at competitive price with good features🔥
@@pranav9851 well said
It is required just like cheap internet
OLA AND SIMPLE ONE HAVE MADE HISTORY and thanks to trakinAuto for the knowledge and input. Thanks Arun
I think ather did a grt job, but now they really need a new electric scooter.
There scene is quite like nokia they don't want to inovate much as there was no completion just running there old scooter but now race has begun with leader like ola
wat great job 1.5 lkh price range ....60 km....good for show case in exbhition and tech fest
@@ramendragupta5482 see the running cost.. even if you take a petrol scooter you will end up paying 3 times.. the amount you will use for petrol you can use thst for EMI.. the problem with us Indians is we do not see the long run.. abhi ka abhi profit chahiye sabko hatho hath
What is so great about Ather? They are the worst and most greedy of them. I can't wait for them to perish along with their ego.
Ather thought they had leverage in india Market considering slow growth, and now they r in oblivion
*Simple one is best* 👍
Young people like this
👇👇
Mee too🙃
Points which are unanswered:
1. Battery type, Can they be charged at home?
2. Carrying capacity in Kgs.
3. Charging cost.
Absolutely correct brother, i also have same questions
I have 4 questions 😁👉
1- Is it completely waterproof?
2- Can we charge it with normal electric socket?
3- How many years does its battery work properly and where and how can it be replaced in case of problem? And how much can it cost?
4- How much is its loading capacity, because scooty is not used for sitting only one person in a normal Indian society , and sometimes in the empty space in front of the seat, we keep heavy things.
That '89 years ago' shocked me for a second.. 😂😂
I think in service Ola will be superior than all. For long term Ola could be best as they've huge budget & future plans
Simple is not behind though,they also producing 10lakh vehicles a year which is btw more than Bajaj and tvs production and unlike ola they r only focused on 13states and they are opening showrooms
With scale, home service becomes difficult. They need to open service centers to serve their millions of scooters,if sold.
simple one has removable battery so u can charge that everywhere, and it’s launching only in few cities and production is less so doesn’t need infra that much.
With Ola u will have to change your route and eat at third class restaurant because chargers are there only, what if location of charger restaurant is closed? Simple one u are free to rest anywhere without having to change ur route, if u take 75min brakes every 3 hours then u can get unlimited range as u can charge simple one while taking breaks,
Olas funding went is launching in 6months, scale and marketing.
Simple one is also 20k cheaper so u can buy speakers with the saved money
Toyota is biggest car maker do they have good after sales? Money goes in ads and scale
@@slick-2410 you can also charge the battery at your house?
Simple One also has Reverse Mode, Cruise Control & Parking Assistant.👍
@Kya bhai kyu janna hai mera naam I never said that Ola don't have these features.🌝
Ola's 181 km range is not real range. The real range is around 145 to 150 kms.
still better than ather
It will be if you drive 45k per hr.
Arre mujhe agar 140 ke aas paas bhi mila, to mai khush hu. Honestly, I would pick Ola only because of infrastructure
@@86Rifty 0
Bro it has 2 model ...The higher range is for S1 pro
Finally I fell proud because I live in Bangalore
Imagine all have EV vehicles...
No pollution , No noice
😌😌
India has a plan to stop selling petrol vehicles after 2025
Thats a fake news!
@@mrcuriosity777 it's not...
That's why Gov't has started giving subsidies on Ev's companies are setting up thier plans ..
Bro,80 percent electricity comes from coal....black coal...petrol engine greener than these highly subsidised evs
@@nilanjanpramanik3587 That's True...But It's far better than use of petroleum. &
Government also increases green energy sources.
Namma red is available across PAN India not limited to Karnataka, just the name is dedicated to Karnataka 🤨
ಹೌದ ಬ್ರೋ ❤
Dedicated to kannadigas.
What is Namma ?
Namma means Our in Kannada 😊
@@chromaxetian496 means our
The editor need a raise ❤️
Did you notice that BENGALURU has become a gaint of startup companies 💥
Even Tesla head office is going to situate in Bengaluru.......
Silicon valley of 🧡🤍💚
But all their Factory in Hosur
Sir, Gurgaon is also a silent killer in terms of startup culture. But no one is really talking about it.
@@sachithshetty1001 he dint say about beauty of Gurgaon.....he said gurgaon is also a startup hub....
@@prasannaik8604 👍🙏
Being an ola s1 pro owner I can say that this scooter is a beast
Why can't the charging station be standardized irrespective of your EV scooter ?
I remember old mobile phones used to have their own custom charging cables and ports. What an electronic wastage it was. Hope it doesn't happen now.
Everyone wants to grow individually, sad 🧐
This is business
Range is not a problem for me as we have to not travel 200km on a scooter but still an important thing. I will choose ola scooter just because it has a boot space that can accommodate 2 helmets. Simple decreased the boot by adding removable battery pack and so it has more range. Simple has good boot space but it cannot hold 2 helmets so I like ola also ola will be having the best infrastructure
But I don't care about boot space :)
That much
I have already booked ola s1 white colour
@@JaspreetSingh-yx4lt Well it's personal preference but in my city both driver and pillion are are required to wear helmet and 2 helmets in a scooter is just amazing and useful for me
@@ankitarsh1917 hmm but in villages no one wear helmets(at least in our)
What about battery replacement?!
Like after how many kms or year we need to replace the battery?
No one has mentioned that
They will never. Hope it doesn't look like YOYO scooter. That scooter battery last only 2 year after that 14k
@@SajalKundu ya the battery is quite big as well so the replacement cost will also be quite high i guess
@@karan_thetravellingdoctor yup 60% of total cost
After warranty
The battery will at least last 8 years if people charge upto 80 percent and discharge upto 20 percent.
I travel 20km between my home and office every day.
It would amount to 25,000 km per year
If we add another 20 km for my every day
Grocery shopping and other travels.
So if we charge upto 80 percent and discharge upto 20 percent it at least last
Upto 1200 cycles. ( Can last upto 2000 cycles ).
For OLA S1 pro
181km × 1,200 = 217,000km
217,000km ÷ 25,000 km/year = 8.6 years.
The electricity rate in my city is ₹ 7 per kWh , Ola S1 pro has a 4 kWh battery
So , cost of one full charge =
7 × 4 = Rs. 28
As I mostly travel 40 km every day
So , price per km = ₹ 28 /181km
= ₹ 0.15
So , electricity price per day = ₹0.15 × 40km = ₹ 6.
Suppose I travel 40 kms every day for 365 days ,
So , electricity price per year
= ₹6 × 365 days
= 2,190.
So , electricity cost in 8 years = 17,520.
Where as ,
Petrol scooter mileage is
40 - 50 km per /litre.
So , fuel price per km = Rs.100 ÷ 50 km
= Rs.2 per Km.
Suppose I drive my scooter for 50 km every day for 365 days.
So , fuel price per year
= Rs.2 × 50km × 365 days
= ₹36,500.
So fuel price for 8 years
= ₹36,500 × 8 years
= ₹ 292,000.
Money saved by using electric scooter for 8 years = ₹ 292,000 - ₹ 17,520
= ₹ 274,000.
Now , By the time you need to replace a battery Tesla 4680 battery will already be available for Ola S1 at an price $ 45 - 50 /kWh. ( Not for the battery pack)
Where as the current prices are $ 110 / kWh.
Ola S1 pro has 4 kWh battery so , current battery price = ₹35,000 - ₹40,000.
And the future price ( 3 years tentative)
= ₹15,000 - ₹20,000.
Ola's scooter looking so classy & premium..😍
Ather 450 x I love that thank you for the information 💥❤️❤️🙏
installed 5k solar On Grid system and I am running 2 AC moderately, refrigerator, Lights, TV, Mixer and " Tata nexon EV " all free of cost I mean Zero rupees power Bill🤩😍
My personal pick would be Simple one, because the main thing here is range and charging time what else do you want in a scooter, people will mainly be using this scooters in city and I don't think many of them will use so many of the features in the screen which ola provided.
Amazing as always 😍
Bhai I am new in this field...pls also view my video on comparison btw ola S1 and s1 pro
One ground breaking feature in Ola is Cruz control which was missed during the video coverage and sets Ola apart from the competition
He did mentioned it
Btw cruise is not that important for city riders, its better for highways, but most scooter don't give good mileage in its max speed (and for more information - both simple one {only confirmed by ceo not announced} and ola as cruise control)
Simple one also has it simple one has removable battery so u can charge that everywhere, and it’s launching only in few cities and production is less so doesn’t need infra that much.
With Ola u will have to change your route and eat at third class restaurant because chargers are there only, what if location of charger restaurant is closed? Simple one u are free to rest anywhere without having to change ur route, if u take 75min brakes every 3 hours then u can get unlimited range as u can charge simple one while taking breaks,
Olas funding went is launching in 6months, scale and marketing.
Simple one is also 20k cheaper so u can buy speakers with the saved money
Meanwhile Bajaj Chetak electric went into depression after watching Simple 1 and OLA S1.
Waiting for these scooters to come into market and bring a healthy competition in electric vehicles especially one like Ather which is priced high without actually competing with their rivals in any manner except the price.
Very good Crisp yet Comprehensive comparison. Inclusion of Tyre size, warranty on battery and bike and yearly cost of ownership would have made it even better.
सब लोग भगवान से🙏प्रार्थना करना हमारे शहीदों🇮🇳जवान कि आत्मा को शांति दे🇮🇳🙏🏻..
🙏🙏
Simple one is my favorite ❤️😍
Two minutes silence for the buyers of ather 450x 😂
😂
Perfect meri jaan
Why ?
Please make a video on simpel one with test drive and actual situation of simpel one
This video was indeed needed!💯🔥❤️
#trakinauto 💙
Bro I am new in this field...pls also view my video on comparison btw ola S1 and s1 pro
Thank so much you for the detailed comparison.. love your blogs. However one concern I have is, as you know how the whether we have here in Mumbai, during the rainy season most of the areas there are water logging issues. How would these electric bike work in those condition and other aspects?
How does petrol vehicles work in these seasons
Yes always specs are present on book but there is always a difference between practical working and company tested conditions, we need to check on their quality of shocks, how they handle regular roads with humps and potholes.
Thanks for the video sir about ola simple one and Atheras good explanation and good compared
Would still choose Ather any given day!
Here's why:
For me personally, Ather is all about reliability and safety.
It's been well "tested for years" unlike ola S1, Simple Energy.. whatever, which I guess have not yet even been given clearance by the government (maybe wrong here).
Can't compromise on safety of my loved ones.. it's not a phone!
Also, what Simple Energy is trying to do today (Showcasing a demo model).. Ather did it well 5-6 years ago!
Clearly not sure when will they be a able to release a reliable product. Sometimes it may be just the marketing being done for years.
And am sure Ather will come up with better lucrative propositions!
Nevertheless kudos to all the competitors to spark the way ahead.
sir i want a second part of this video where u need to compare all the 3 in real life
Simple one and ola not yet started selling
@@prajwalgowda7518 I know man...I was just asking to get a part 2 ...cuz I believe in practical stuff than theoretical one
@@pradeep.bhuvanagiri ha ok
I also want 2nd part as you. Review in practical life.
Yaa
Ola's 181km range is idc and simple ones idc is 236km
range depend on bttry pack ......ola provide u ....max 80 km @ 65 kmph.....and simple one provide u 110 km@65
@@ramendragupta5482 if you go by that then ather would give 20-30km
@@chvejk-34543werghn ather range is 55 km
all making fool revolt says 150 km in co mode .....in real it go max 70 km ...in ride mode @60
main is battry pack for good range atleast 5kwh is must
Namma red will be available everywhere.. It's just colour dedicated to bangalore n Karnataka.
This is the changing time to electric scooter. Good effort
Sir ji make a detailed analysis compression video 1. Bajaj chetak 2. Tvs Icub 3. Hero ecetric 4. Ola s1/s1 Pro 5.simple one 6. Anther all mode 7. E pure 7g 8. Aprilia ev etc...
Simple one great work as their first product
Superb comparsion Arun Bhai 👍 when can we expect on road performance from your side ???
1.What about battery warranty ?
2.What about battery life ?
3.What about battery cost ?
4.What is the water damage cost and does warranty covers ?
5.What about monthly/yearly subscription price ?
6.What is IP rating ?
7. What is service cost ?
8. What is the cooling technology ola ,simple and ather used ?
9. What about heat emitting by motor and battery also ? I think ather have vents and simple also but what about ola ?
10. What about the tires does it satisfies the latest tire norm ?
Bhai Saheb Bina Scooter Ke Hi comparison kar dete hai. Talent hai!
Ola and simple one outclassed Ather 😀
Namma RED
ನಮ್ಮ RED
🔥🔥🔥
But Ola is the best
Because extra futures and sound 🔊
My best future in Ola which I feel is that the vehicle would have been unlocked in its own name. 😍
hello sir, can you also tell something about the weight carrying capacity of these scooters? how much weight can these scooters carry giving out the same performance and features listed by these companies?
Simple one 110 kg. And ola s1 125 kg
Good detailing bro...mobile ke baad automobile main aap accha kar rahey ho good bhai keep it up.wish u best.
Arun be like: ather bech du?
Any one with the right mind wouldn't buy it 😂
What is the battery life & replacement cost?
About battery life mentenance...
Most important factor.. Everyone forgets..
No company is telling battery replacement cost...This is bcoz betteries market is going thru a developmental stage and yet to stabilize
By the time we will need a replacement batteries will be much cheaper.. these days a lot of companies have started making EV batteries
@@DipanjanDas23 haan true..
In simple one should we surely remove the removable battery to charge it or can we charge it with non removable battery without removing removable battery out of ev??
Normal charging
Well as I've understood through other sources, you can charge the removable battery along with the main battery when you plug in the scooter. But not sure which one does the scooter prefer to charge first.
Removable battery means unlimited charging points, no need to go off course like ola
I you have cleared all my doubts thanks for valuable information. But I have 1 question. Is it can recharge Like mobile example if our phone get 40% we charge immediately. To complete 100% like that can we charge in scooters or we have to wait till empty
You have analised in best and impartial way thanks and best presentation
Ather has got very tough competition from these 2.🔥🔥
Ather is dead already
Simple one and Ola S1 pro much much better
its not even a competition.!!!!! its totally dead ! over! khatam! tata! bye bye!
no one will ever buy ather. they have to launch another model.
Wanted this type of comparison. Thankyou Arun Sir ❤
Sir kya mobile me jaise 20% to 80% battery charging ideal hota vaise e-scooter me hai kya?
Nhi bhai 100 kar sakte ho
What would be best to buy hero optima or ola s1 pro electric
According basic need and availability.
Would you share information regarding this ???
1)After sales service kessi h..
2) Maintenance and parts cost ..??
3) Battery cost after renwal..
4) Battery Life span??
5) what if we stuck in between..of interior road??
Waiting for this video ❤️
Nice video for sure.. 👌🏽👏🏽
One question, what would be the arrengment to change tyre when it puncture or rip off.? How can we remove or replace it?
Simple one🔥🔥❤️
Thank you for this video. I was about to buy ather 450x...you saved my money.
1st time in trakinauto channel ☑️☑️☑️☑️
At the end of the day I still think Ather is beautiful. Can't help thinking all this over juicing of battery will just create more and more lithium waste. The question to ask at this juncture of EV adoption is how much does one need ? Range, top speed, battery juicing.
Sir please make video on features difference between OLA S1 and S1 Pro 🙏🤔
S1 me voice assistant nahi hai, hill hold nahi hai and cruise control nahi hai bas bakee same hai. Already booker s1
@@HDRPC Top speed Range bhi kam S1 pro sa
But i think cruise control hai
@@HDRPC ua-cam.com/video/mHL-5Zq-0p0/v-deo.html
@@ankuryadav4147 yes features batae maine. Jo maine bataya vo sahee hai. Cruise control pro me hi hai
@@HDRPC but Bhai bhaut kuch cheeze s1 pro mein bhaut aachi haib ....ek baar aap video dekh lijiye 🙏
Time period of warranty on battery?
And cost of battery replacement after warranty period
most of the people think that beating ather will be good but that is also a pure INDIAN company that is of bangalore comapany we should also support that keep that in mind because of these a nice startup shouldn't be getting down
Its helpful info buy to electric scooter comparison,i like to choose simple one
Huge problem is with those who don't own a house and who stays in appartments how wil they charge it's still a big concern which is not letting me go for electric bike
ua-cam.com/video/ylHrGFAIxIk/v-deo.html
Ola's design 🤩 like vespa classic touch
Simple One 🔥
I have used okinawa scooter for 3 years with acid lead battery .
On paper - Range/Top speed - 1) Economy class 90km/35 kmph
2) sports mode- 65 km/55 kmph
On Road For 6 months- Range/Top speed
1) Economy Mode - 80Km/ 35kmph
2) Sports - 55km/55 kmph
After 6 months Range starts decreasing and reached 35Km after 2.5 years.Top speed remains same.
For good range which should buy hero or ather 450x, now days battery removal or non removal should buy. Kindly suggest.
Great ola
simple one has removable battery so u can charge that everywhere, and it’s launching only in few cities and production is less so doesn’t need infra that much.
With Ola u will have to change your route and eat at third class restaurant because chargers are there only, what if location of charger restaurant is closed? Simple one u are free to rest anywhere without having to change ur route, if u take 75min brakes every 3 hours then u can get unlimited range as u can charge simple one while taking breaks,
Olas funding went is launching in 6months, scale and marketing.
Simple one is also 20k cheaper so u can buy speakers with the saved money
Ola looks 🔥
Please make a drive Video of all this 3 vehicles please your reviews are Awesome...👍🏻😇
I have ' Yo egde ' ev
1)0.35kw waterproof motor
2) 70km range
3) lithium ion battery
4) charging time max-(3.5hr)
5) price - 60,000 INR
Iam using from 1.5 yr no difference in range and power,
I travelled 6000 km, My experience is very nice🤗 without subsidy
Ppls prefer on road record's performance not on papers,, appreciate if you update us accordingly,,, subscribed for sort term and wait for your next update
#1 ⭕LA as u have not mentioned the Geo fencing feature AI ENABLED voice greeting KEYLESS LOCK n UNLOCK feature & 3 types of metre consoles in OLA...
Is the display waterproof? What's the IP rating?
From start I felt Simple One was favoured.. For me it was Ola Winner
Sir no doubt .......Ola hi leni h ....... Coz ...... 1 brand value
2 resale value
3 fair price
4 good battery
5 looks
6 demand ........
Or bhi bahut sari cheeze ho sakti h .....or jitni Ola bikengi mera hi fayda h ..... I m from stock market.....
Surprisingly all "TRADITIONAL" scooter makers still lagging behind these brands...
Do you think we should go for EV now or wait till more charging stations come out
I think one part missed in video I.e. body structure n strength..
How many years vehicle body can survive is very important in long lifetime
Bhai aap mobile k siva or b kaam krta hai. Muje to aaj pta lga. Keep it up
Nice informative video sir, waiting for simple one,
On road test between ola s1 pro and simple one. We need a video on it
What a kick u get😂 sorry pickup....nice video