Dua is ibadah, hence it is only for allah. Do not throttle your mind in the things that are super clear by MUHAMMED PBUH. Hence do not put yourself in risk.
Dua is ibadah Ibadah is only for Allah So dua to anyone is shirk Isn't it? So anyone in the 1200 year of islam not acknowledge this (except ibn taymiyya and ibn qayyim rahimaullah) but after ibn abd al wahab Dua's "Definition" in both situation is different in first one allah is independent in second one the one asked is not independent of allah (correction- no alim i know (who says it's permissible) call saying ya Nabi madad is dua) (Many if not all salafi ulama define saying ya Nabi madad as dua ) 2-Quraish of mecca were same, as someone asking prophet today They don't acknowledge that quraish were of the view that Allah has full power but Allah has "GIVEN" his power "COMPLETELY" and now is not interested in human beings except the pious or his daughter (quraish have kind of this aqeedah) nauzubillah This is shirk Understand you are not the only one who has understood deen of Allah and no one before you have known it Understand this when you hear argument of both side the black and white picture of shirk atleast become somewhat grey This is one of the reasons many scholars call it haram but not shirk. May Allah guide us
@@nsayyed5469 Exactly this was my point that Barelvi ulama say saying ya Nabi madad isn't dua But this same act is called dua by salafi ulama So, different defination give different conclusions
@@subhankhan7514 those salafi say that asking help and worship are the same thing But, they re also seeking help from living creature Which means theyre also mushriks according to their own standard
Dua is ibadah, hence it is only for allah. Do not throttle your mind in the things that are super clear by MUHAMMED PBUH. Hence do not put yourself in risk.
Watch : ua-cam.com/video/T3aKsPbxKSg/v-deo.html
Dua is ibadah
Ibadah is only for Allah
So dua to anyone is shirk
Isn't it?
So anyone in the 1200 year of islam not acknowledge this (except ibn taymiyya and ibn qayyim rahimaullah) but after ibn abd al wahab
Dua's "Definition" in both situation is different in first one allah is independent in second one the one asked is not independent of allah (correction- no alim i know (who says it's permissible) call saying ya Nabi madad is dua) (Many if not all salafi ulama define saying ya Nabi madad as dua )
2-Quraish of mecca were same, as someone asking prophet today
They don't acknowledge that quraish were of the view that Allah has full power but Allah has "GIVEN" his power "COMPLETELY" and now is not interested in human beings except the pious or his daughter (quraish have kind of this aqeedah) nauzubillah
This is shirk
Understand you are not the only one who has understood deen of Allah and no one before you have known it
Understand this when you hear argument of both side the black and white picture of shirk atleast become somewhat grey
This is one of the reasons many scholars call it haram but not shirk.
May Allah guide us
No one makes dua other than Allah it's your kizb on muslims even show that Barelvi fatawa that say doing dua other than Allah is not shirk
@@nsayyed5469
Exactly this was my point that Barelvi ulama say saying ya Nabi madad isn't dua
But this same act is called dua by salafi ulama
So, different defination give different conclusions
@@subhankhan7514
those salafi say that asking help and worship are the same thing
But, they re also seeking help from living creature
Which means theyre also mushriks according to their own standard