u were weird but in a cute sweet way and he was also a little nervous I think too/ GREAT chemistry and definitely a love match …..his smile when he looks at u is so great :) so happy for u
What exactly are you talking about? she's the same to me.... The whole time I was smiling and thinking how great it must be to find someone you can be fully yourself with and just relax....
Doesn’t anyone think it’s weird to make a comment like this like I get it you’re just making a comment for her video and I’m not trying to be a troll but like you don’t know her you’ve never met her and it’s a relationship you know nothing about it’s just really weird to pretend like the person in the video is like your actual real best friend 🤷♀️
I'm genuinely obsessed with how he maintains physical touch with you during most of this but it never feels forced or uncomfortable or possessive literally ever. It's just how he cares for and relates to you and it shows how much he enjoys sharing experiences with you. Presh. ALSO at the end when you told him to go back out because you needed to add another line, and he gladly and kindly said "Sure." He didn't make you feel like you were a bother because you're not to him-you're a gift and he genuinely cherishes you. You don't know how encouraging this is for all of us to see, and to be reminded to not settle for less! Thank you both of you!
@@IzzyBee24 oh my gosh, forgot to reply but wow this warmed me so much to read. I'm glad that other people notice the beauty here too; it just struck me so much and gave me such hope, I had to talk about it haha
From beginning to end I just love him for you. The way he looks at you talking to us is the sweetest thing. He couldn't take his eyes off of you. Also at the beginning when he said, "My little cutie" with such a nice voice, can I add. Can we please all get an AMEN for him. Gurl I approve lmao. Happy for you :)
Not to make this about myself, but I just want to tell you. I'm about a year out from a very traumatic breakup: we were engaged, ended things a couple months out from the wedding, and it became very hostile very quickly. I've been working through everything in therapy, processing a lot of abuse and trauma, and one of the more odious side effects of all this has been a sweeping sense of hopelessness about finding a partner. Like there's no good guys out there, no such thing as a healthy relationship/marriage, and like I don't bring enough to the table (whatever that means). Seeing how wonderful he is to you, how happy you both are, how easily you two compliment each other... A little spark of hope. Thank you for sharing this beautiful little glimpse into your world, I needed the reminder that not everything sucks. SO happy for you!!❤
As a straight dude who is watching interior design to help my wife with the home buying/decor process, he explained my spartan 20s very well. It was good enough and I spent the money on motorcycles and travel. I had the map on wall. Never heard of the drivefast, feel like I need that in my garage now. Justin seems like a nice guy.
Ahhhh Justin is definitely a keeper. I love how he made contact with you to calm you. I’m sure putting your personal life and ppl you on camera is scary. This was a cute segment! Any trolls if present… go play in traffic! We love Justin!
@@Caroline_Winkler I was just going to post something similar … he is definitely a keeper! You are absolutely together! ❤❤❤ you were both funny and interesting, and absolutely enjoying each other! Love it!
Aww just finished watching this and my cheeks are sore! I realized I been grinning ear to ear the whole video! 😂 such a happy couple you seem to be. Hope to see more of you together. All the very best going forward and big hugs. 💜
Can we just take a moment to recognize how incredibly sweet and romantic Justin is that he keeps touching Caroline's knee, holding her hand, kissing your hand and essentially reassuring her. Where did you find this man and where can we find one like him?
The contrast between your boyfriend and your sister is shocking and hilarious. Truly polar opposites on the commentary delivery and willingness to be nice about home decor 😂😂 Can we get a panel of decor reviews of all three of you judging home decor full throttle? Pleaseee
I can say that as fun as it is to watch Caroline and her sister, if he came out here and had that same personality, I would worry about Caroline daily. Funny, how it works for Elizabeth, but wouldn't for Caroline and I am glad that she has chosen such a kind and grounded confident man who will also mesh well with her sister.
Yesss! The 3 of them sitting around her parents dining room table, roasting peoples decor, and little cameos from brother and/or parents, definitely family dog makes an entrance. This would be sooooo good!!
Can I just say (and probably on behalf of most of us detective girlies) that the insertion of the reference clips at 1:40 is VERY appreciated - otherwise you 100% know we'd be spending time on past vids to piece together the full context but rn I'm too tired for detective mode and wanna rest with my dinner LOL🥲
Internet family approval! Excellent boyfriend choice. This video was hilarious. Your boyfriend has a great sense of humor, he's low-key but so funny. The two of you had me laughing the whole time. And you had some gorgeous design clips (no, not the recliners, fishing paraphernalia, lighted beds 😂).
While I am no longer a bachelor, I am a man who went through many bachelor living phases throughout his life and feel like Justin is a good spokesperson for our demographic - close enough to that phase to still emphathize and understand, but removed enough to provide perspective. Also, I totally get his horse girl vs girls who ride horses comparison.
He seems great! He matches you in wit, intelligence, quick mind and thoughtfulness. AND....he listens without interrupting. I wish all the best for you!
@@Caroline_Winklerthat is what we wanted for you, a genuine person who can hold his own but also give you space for you to be you…there will be bumps in the road, but if you hold each other’s hand and keep kissing, it will be a wonderful life!! ♥️
He's so soft and supportive I can't 🥹🥹, U bagged a cutie, miss cutie!! Also as someone who was homeless, then couchsurfing, then sleeping on a mattress on the floor under an unzipped sleeping bag to sleeping on a full bed this year!!! Genuinely your bachelor videos are a fun and cheeky way to help me see that all the shit ways I've normalised needing to live *can* be opted out of, one at a time. Adore your content, you inspire me and make me laugh in so many ways 💗💗💗
Funny because in France the most basic decor is not about Paris but a random New York city street (or sometimes even Times Square) with a yellow taxi in the front
I like that Justin doesn't swear. I'm so tired of swearing. Constantly. People swearing in every other sentence. Including you, Caroline!! But I adore you anyway.
Those words are only bad because you think they're bad. Have fun pondering that concept for a while. Cupcake could be bad. But you didn't think it was bad, so it's not. But fuck is bad because you think it is. You could think it's not, and then it wouldn't be. Also, i think the problem with swearing is the people who think it's a problem. It would no longer be bad if you all stopped agreeing that it's bad. You and people like you, make that word bad. If you stopped making it be bad, it could no longer hold this power over you. It's just mouth sounds you hear and get upset by. You could get upset by apple if you truly wanted to. And you could smile when you hear a swear. These are things you literally could actually do. Just like how the word fuck has a power over you that you acknowledge every time you hear it. It can literally make you feel certain ways simply because you allow it to do so. If you chose to no longer allow that, it wouldn't be able to make *FUCK* you cringe when you read it... Fuck Cringes like supposed to. Fuck Cringes again Fuc.... Shia Chooses to get angry while cringing. You don't have to cringe and get upset. You can choose not to. Or you can choose to do so And the beauty of it and the irony of it, is its all up to you.
@@thehuntressdanni2972 Ever considered that people who don't like casual swearing maybe think _there's a value in words having power_ ? Lot of people who don't like swearing would still want to swear when they get into a car accident, fail a class, get broken up with, find out their loved one is pregnant/has cancer etc. depending on where that line is for them, they're just not a fan of words being watered down to a point where they lose their original meaning/weight?
I had a room mate in college who saved all her empty wine bottles. Her parents paid a surprise visit to our dorm room and she told them they were mine. They sent me AA brochures until I graduated. Be careful what gets collected as a young adult.
I was just talking to my husband about this very thing. I was an offender in my past. Tonight as I was recycling an empty wine bottle, I felt the need to announce, I’m recycling the cork too! 🎉
He’s wonderful and the goofy part of your personality seems to make him very protective. Thank you for a fun video and the courage to introduce him to us.
I’m just going to pause here quickly to tell you that the chemistry between you and Justin is adorable and thank you for sharing his handsome face with us. I am very happy for you ❤
First of all congratulations Caroline you look so happy! Second of all let's all give a shout out to bachelors for single-handedly leading the way with a low carbon footprint, using things that work, not consuming unless necessary lol
I'm three weeks fresh from a terrible breakup and having watched your previous videos on dating and how amazing you and Justin look it's making me think I shouldn't give up just yet. Thanks for this unexpected wonderful gift, Caroline.
I wish you well for this next chapter of your life. I’m starting over after 32yrs. Painting and soon to decorate my home is helping me to stop ruminating and completely changing the energy in here. Seeing wonderful guys treat women well gives me a lot of hope too. Take care of your heart. ❤
Aw bb. I’m sorry to hear it. That is true pain. You absoLUTELY shouldn’t give up. Dating often made me feel so crazy, as did breakups. But you’re actually getting closer to yourself, a step at a time. Hang in there, I’m excited for you ❤
Babe same here, give or take a couple weeks! I'm not even looking right now but as soon as I saw these two together I was like omg swoon, I have to start looking again soon
Caroline, I'm just so happy for you. Justin seems to "get you" and he's appreciative of your particular sense of humor. Not only is he good-looking, but he also seems comfortable and confident and into you. And you love each other!!! You deserve it girl - you're a lovely human being..
Serendipitously, this video comes just days after my dad asked me to help him decorate his new bachelor pad. The place just looks bit sad, all the pillows, couch, even bath mat are worn and pitiful. I can't wait to dive into this video tonight and get some tips on how to make his first bachelor pad in 30 years feel like home. Your videos are always exactly what I need right when I need them. Thanks, C!
I’m making a bachelorette pad in what was the family home and painting and recovering furniture to throw off the old life. It’s hard on no budget but I’m so glad you’re helping your Dad reinvent his pad. He’ll appreciate it I’m sure. I can safely say that hand painting the walls (as opposed to the roller) has stopped me ruminating and totally made it a completely different home and atmosphere. It’s exactly what I’ve needed. I hope you have fun and wish you both the best. ❤
You guys made me smile for 26 minutes straight. I love the way he meets your humor. And calling out the American Psycho decor is a service to humanity 👏❤️
He’s a sweetie who called out so many women about Paris and I think that’s beautiful. He’s very much giving Jess energy and that’s such a good balance. So supportive and reassuring!!!
IM SCREAMING STOP IT CAROLINE how dare you guys be so eternally beautiful together. Playful, witty and comforting - may it last a lifetime 🥹🤍 brilliant, it’s so nice to see you being so purely loved and appreciated
I have no clue when/where you said adding a rug into your space makes it look like a room -- but hot damn, just added a rug and it makes a world of difference. Thank you Caroline!
I actually got emotional seeing this, after having experiencing you be so vulnerable (aka HONEST) about your dating trials. It’s all so relatable and I know I don’t speak for myself when I say we are SO happy for you. He also happens to be a doll, so good on you ! ❤😊
Omg we love him❤❤❤ The eye contact! The hand holding! The kisses! The hand on your leg!! The smiles when you're feeling nervous or awkward! He's so perfect for you Caroline- 100% need more of him on the channel😍
Watching this felt like the moment when my best friend first told me about the guy who she ended up marrying. I got butterflies for you, girl! Even though you were nervous, you were absolutely glowing and looked so joyful and at peace around him. So happy for the both of you! ❤️ ❤️ ❤️
Literally smiling at my screen and kicking my feetsies at this video - the way he looks at you so full of love, smiling with his whole face at everything you say, so intently looking at you and listening🥹
So happy for you! You guys have a lovely banter, and a comfortable vibe together. What fun we get to share in your happiness! This is coming from someone married to the same person for 22 years. Fun to remember the early days!
Wow. Justin’s tenderness toward you brought literal tears to my eyes. I am genuinely happy for you, especially after listening to your past experiences on your podcast. Thank you for sharing (part of) your life with us and for introducing us to this sweet kind man.
I felt seen when you said ‘every little body movement is analysed’. I couldn’t take my eyes off Justin, as he looked at you all the time. It’s perfect. You deserve nothing less.
Omg! He's adorable with a great sense of humor and clearly smitten. ❤ Your bachelor pad photos are hysterical. I predict this one goes viral - on to 1m subscribers. I may watch more than my usual twice. 😊
omg visceral response to him calling you his little cutie. after obsessively watching your channel of late i am beaming to see just that first interaction.
Caroline: "First let me just say, I love you 😁" Justin: "OK, not a great start 😅" This KILLED me. You are two freaking adorable dorks & I wish you all the love.
The way he has that Golden retriever energy, omg he seems like such a keeper, so happy for you 🥹 he matches your energy and humor so much too, love this for youuu. Especially since You both seem so happy and he could not stop looking at you, the absolute sweetest 🥰
Absolutely love Justin. Your personalities compliment each other. You may have been nervous, but he was very relaxed & natural. So happy for both of you.
Lol this is so cute. And such a great example of how to communicate with your significant other about a touchy subject. I didn't do it right in my last relationship and we were talking about moving in together but I hated his house and he was easily offended at any change suggestions I brought up. Giving a compliment first is a great idea! I got a lot out of this episode. Thank you and congrats on your awesome boyfriend!
Heart-melting, serotonin-boosting adorably-edited episode in your life. Like someone else commented, I was trying to imagine a guy that would match your wit, charm, warmth (and looks! that's important!), and it's wonderful you've found each other. I liked how he was appreciating and building off your jokes; you are too funny to not be seen and appreciated for it!
That was the coolest video you nervously risked doing! Getting a male’s true perspective wins my respect for you. It was cute honest and vulnerable. Your guy is definitely into to you. His love language is physical touch for sure and can’t be denied!🥰
Ok the fact that he was just normal and well adjusted and introduced you as his gf because DUH y’all were hanging out all the time! Is such a green flag. Don’t listen to ANYONE about ANYTHING if this man feels like home - he is. You’ll know 💕🙏🏼
I swear to god my boyfriend keeps talking about getting a bunch of maps and framing them. I couldn't have laughed louder at "I like the world." Fucking dead 😂 Oh oh oh ALSO he just mentioned American Psycho being iconic and how every guy wanted that look. HELLO? He's a murderer what is wrong with you men. I refuse to allow gray into our home.
I'm a girl and I have a map of the world, but you scratch off where you've been so it's functional. Also I studied geography so I have an excuse to like them 😂 but funny on the psycho reference! 😂
This must be one of your funniest and most charming videos ever, Caroline. I've watched it twice and laughed each time at the repartee. It's joyous to see the delight you two take in each other's company, and the creative and witty sparks you generate from each other. May this love grow ever stronger❣️
I do respect the way people roasted you in the comments of the last video for saying "boyfriend" too much and then your next video is entirely about your BOYFRIEND in capital letters, haha. Also, I like your outfit. I might have to copy that.
This is gonna sound so weird but I just went through a breakup and was feeling down about dating, and I watched this video and the way your bf just glows when he looks at you, and I was like, “that. That’s how it should be!” And I realized that I was settling for a lot less. So thanks for giving me hope again unintentionally 💙
Aaah I love Justin already. Lucky guy to get to love you! Thank you for sharing your wonderful wacky world with us. We all feel a personal connection with your family - and even the family dog - and are so happy to welcome Justin into the fold. Wishing you a happy forever.
Caroline, you two are so sweet together. The chemistry is absolutely magnetic - what a perfect match! I'm so happy for you. Welcome to the beach house Justin! 🥰
Oh Caroline, he seems like a great match for you. Kind, caring. He looks at you with love. Obviously he enjoys all your quirky ways! Relax, be yourself like you want us to be 😁.
I just realized I was smiling the entire video 😊😂 so fun to see you interacting with your boyfriend. You have such a lovely and natural interaction. And his sense of humor fits right in with your family.
Caroline, I am SOOOO HAPPY for you sweetheart! Thank you for introducing us all to your man! Justin looks like an awesome catch! What a gentleman! As for the pillows, I have 8 on my bed! Lol… 4 for each of us. 1 under our heads, 1 at my back, 1 between my legs for back support, and 1 to hug. If we don’t use them, we toss them to the foot of the bed. Totally functional pillows! As always, great content! ❤
You two are adorable together!!! So nice to see someone who gets you, girl, and loves the things about you that you probably think make you challenging.
You were weird the whole time and he is great!
Ty someone is keeping it real in the comments 🙏
u were weird but in a cute sweet way and he was also a little nervous I think too/ GREAT chemistry and definitely a love match …..his smile when he looks at u is so great :) so happy for u
What exactly are you talking about? she's the same to me....
The whole time I was smiling and thinking how great it must be to find someone you can be fully yourself with and just relax....
@@michelleg.8190agree
@@Caroline_Winkler He smiled about you when you weren't even there!
Sprinting here to see caroline be super goofy in 10 million cute ways about introducing her bf! Girl we love you and we love him, go OFF
THIS. YES. ❤
YES 💕
Well. You called it ❤
Your boyfriend is a lovely human…he seems kind, intelligent, and is clearly in love with you. Yay!
Doesn’t anyone think it’s weird to make a comment like this like I get it you’re just making a comment for her video and I’m not trying to be a troll but like you don’t know her you’ve never met her and it’s a relationship you know nothing about it’s just really weird to pretend like the person in the video is like your actual real best friend 🤷♀️
Paige coming through with that final edit of Justin smiling to himself!!! How cute!
I think Caroline edited this one no? 😊
caught that too - well done Paige.
Aw I’m glad u liked it. This video was me - but Paige will be back with her magic for the next one!
That was him giving the velvet pillow a look!
Yes I loved that little touch so much! He’s so sweet 🥲
I'm genuinely obsessed with how he maintains physical touch with you during most of this but it never feels forced or uncomfortable or possessive literally ever. It's just how he cares for and relates to you and it shows how much he enjoys sharing experiences with you. Presh.
ALSO at the end when you told him to go back out because you needed to add another line, and he gladly and kindly said "Sure." He didn't make you feel like you were a bother because you're not to him-you're a gift and he genuinely cherishes you. You don't know how encouraging this is for all of us to see, and to be reminded to not settle for less! Thank you both of you!
I'm totally NOT sitting here crying because your comment is so eloquently what most of us our thinking. 😍
@@IzzyBee24 oh my gosh, forgot to reply but wow this warmed me so much to read. I'm glad that other people notice the beauty here too; it just struck me so much and gave me such hope, I had to talk about it haha
I feel violent about this: I AM SO HAPPY FOR YOU CAROLINE !!!!
your internet family approves
Lol. Violent 😂😂😂
You sound unstable.
wow! I verbally said 'aww' a million times just watching you two together! Justin has such a nice energy that matches yours!! 💗💗
natachaaaa 😍 so cool to see that one of my favorite youtubers watches another one of my favorite youtubers 😊
Same here! How sweet are they practically finishing each other's sentences.
Doh! 🥹 how dare you give me such a big smile with this comment. You are just the sweetest❤
couldn't stop smiling, meself
I’m noticing how each of you really listen to one another and the eye contact is adorable! And the laughter is soooooooo cute! 😀
From beginning to end I just love him for you. The way he looks at you talking to us is the sweetest thing. He couldn't take his eyes off of you. Also at the beginning when he said, "My little cutie" with such a nice voice, can I add. Can we please all get an AMEN for him. Gurl I approve lmao. Happy for you :)
AMEN!
Amen! 😅❤
AMEN & THANK YOU JESUS
I give my amen too. He is very sweet and engaging. Johns wife I think he’s a keeper for you. Check to see that he’s not a serial killer just Incase.
He's so smart, well-spoken, diplomatic and relaxed! I am so happy for you two!
He is sooo cute🥰
And sarcastic and quick...the best!
I'm pretty sure Caroline knows by now, but his voice? His voice? Nice.
You two are adorable!
Yessss!! His voiceeeee! 🫶🏽
Yep I noticed his voice! Definitely a keeper!
His voice 😍. Just yes.
yaaaaaaas
I love this. I actually didn’t really think about it until editing this video, but the voice is good ❤
Not to make this about myself, but I just want to tell you. I'm about a year out from a very traumatic breakup: we were engaged, ended things a couple months out from the wedding, and it became very hostile very quickly. I've been working through everything in therapy, processing a lot of abuse and trauma, and one of the more odious side effects of all this has been a sweeping sense of hopelessness about finding a partner. Like there's no good guys out there, no such thing as a healthy relationship/marriage, and like I don't bring enough to the table (whatever that means). Seeing how wonderful he is to you, how happy you both are, how easily you two compliment each other... A little spark of hope. Thank you for sharing this beautiful little glimpse into your world, I needed the reminder that not everything sucks. SO happy for you!!❤
Ow ow ow! I hope 4 months on you're feeling better! Better ending it before the wedding than after. Best wishes, internet stranger !
HE'S SO CALM AND GROUNDED I LOVE HIM
I just smiled like an idiot for 26 mins... You two are ADORABLE
Same here! So adorable.
The three of us now
As a straight dude who is watching interior design to help my wife with the home buying/decor process, he explained my spartan 20s very well. It was good enough and I spent the money on motorcycles and travel. I had the map on wall. Never heard of the drivefast, feel like I need that in my garage now. Justin seems like a nice guy.
Ahhhh Justin is definitely a keeper. I love how he made contact with you to calm you. I’m sure putting your personal life and ppl you on camera is scary. This was a cute segment! Any trolls if present… go play in traffic! We love Justin!
Wish u could hug you for this one. Feeling v seen
i am stealing this go play in traffic phrase and adding to david's eat glass which is my current favourite 😂
@@Caroline_Winkler I was just going to post something similar … he is definitely a keeper! You are absolutely together! ❤❤❤ you were both funny and interesting, and absolutely enjoying each other! Love it!
@@sushreeshashwataI’m so obsessed with Schitts Creek 🥰 “Eat glass!” is top tier!
Aww just finished watching this and my cheeks are sore! I realized I been grinning ear to ear the whole video! 😂 such a happy couple you seem to be. Hope to see more of you together. All the very best going forward and big hugs. 💜
I remember feeling this silly smitten way with my BF…that was 20+ years ago and he still looks at me the way Justin looks at you❤❤
I love hearing that he still does. That’s the dream ❤️congrats to you both ❤️❤️❤️
That candid smile Justin makes at the very end of the outtakes is so sweet! ❤
Can we just take a moment to recognize how incredibly sweet and romantic Justin is that he keeps touching Caroline's knee, holding her hand, kissing your hand and essentially reassuring her. Where did you find this man and where can we find one like him?
Idk it’s so wack but I love him ❤
I know right?!?!
@@Caroline_Winkler ok but how can we find one?
@@loosilu not finding the affiliate link. I'd like one, too!
I wish all of us a boyfriend as quality as Caroline's
The contrast between your boyfriend and your sister is shocking and hilarious. Truly polar opposites on the commentary delivery and willingness to be nice about home decor 😂😂
Can we get a panel of decor reviews of all three of you judging home decor full throttle? Pleaseee
I can say that as fun as it is to watch Caroline and her sister, if he came out here and had that same personality, I would worry about Caroline daily. Funny, how it works for Elizabeth, but wouldn't for Caroline and I am glad that she has chosen such a kind and grounded confident man who will also mesh well with her sister.
Yesss! The 3 of them sitting around her parents dining room table, roasting peoples decor, and little cameos from brother and/or parents, definitely family dog makes an entrance. This would be sooooo good!!
The way you two look at each other melts my cold dead Gen X heart.
😂 me too
Same
and mine 🥰
He absolutely adores her. I hope to find someone who looks at me the way he looks at her. So happy for you Caroline
@Juviosa_: Are you also hoping to look at someone the way he looks at her?
OMG, he is wonderful. He’s adorable, handsome, quick witted and doesn’t take himself too seriously. And he LOVES Caroline so we love him!
The sweetness you and Justin share MELTS my heart. He's a good egg. What a fun video!
THE WAY HE SMILED AT THE VERY VERY END ❤❤❤ I'm so happy to meet him, thank you both for being here and doing this and supporting each other ❤
Right?! That was just so sweet and wonderful.
I literally squealed
I coundn't handle the lovelyness 😭❤️
I watched his smile at the end 3 times and yes I choked up! 🥲
Can I just say (and probably on behalf of most of us detective girlies) that the insertion of the reference clips at 1:40 is VERY appreciated - otherwise you 100% know we'd be spending time on past vids to piece together the full context but rn I'm too tired for detective mode and wanna rest with my dinner LOL🥲
Internet family approval! Excellent boyfriend choice. This video was hilarious. Your boyfriend has a great sense of humor, he's low-key but so funny. The two of you had me laughing the whole time. And you had some gorgeous design clips (no, not the recliners, fishing paraphernalia, lighted beds 😂).
While I am no longer a bachelor, I am a man who went through many bachelor living phases throughout his life and feel like Justin is a good spokesperson for our demographic - close enough to that phase to still emphathize and understand, but removed enough to provide perspective. Also, I totally get his horse girl vs girls who ride horses comparison.
He seems great! He matches you in wit, intelligence, quick mind and thoughtfulness. AND....he listens without interrupting. I wish all the best for you!
Isn’t it wonderful when you finally have someone who gets you and the love is effortless? 💕
'Pictures of Paris....' - I stopped dead in my tracks. So called out. Well done, Caroline - someone as funny and kind as you.
Lol that was so accurate. I was hoping he'd list more design faux pas.
Your boyfriend is so sweet. I loved meeting him.
he is genuinely a wonderful person
@@Caroline_Winkler did you meet him online?
@@Caroline_Winklerthat is what we wanted for you, a genuine person who can hold his own but also give you space for you to be you…there will be bumps in the road, but if you hold each other’s hand and keep kissing, it will be a wonderful life!! ♥️
He's so soft and supportive I can't 🥹🥹, U bagged a cutie, miss cutie!!
Also as someone who was homeless, then couchsurfing, then sleeping on a mattress on the floor under an unzipped sleeping bag to sleeping on a full bed this year!!! Genuinely your bachelor videos are a fun and cheeky way to help me see that all the shit ways I've normalised needing to live *can* be opted out of, one at a time. Adore your content, you inspire me and make me laugh in so many ways 💗💗💗
Hey, congratulations.
Funny because in France the most basic decor is not about Paris but a random New York city street (or sometimes even Times Square) with a yellow taxi in the front
I figured it would be a bottle of wine and grapes laying in a grassfield.
😅😅😅 I LOVE this!!
That's so funny. Simone de Beauvoir wrote 'America Day by Day', could that have something to do with it? Here's hoping, ha ha
😂😂😂😂 wow
I like that Justin doesn't swear. I'm so tired of swearing. Constantly. People swearing in every other sentence. Including you, Caroline!! But I adore you anyway.
Those words are only bad because you think they're bad. Have fun pondering that concept for a while.
Cupcake could be bad. But you didn't think it was bad, so it's not. But fuck is bad because you think it is. You could think it's not, and then it wouldn't be.
Also, i think the problem with swearing is the people who think it's a problem. It would no longer be bad if you all stopped agreeing that it's bad.
You and people like you, make that word bad. If you stopped making it be bad, it could no longer hold this power over you.
It's just mouth sounds you hear and get upset by.
You could get upset by apple if you truly wanted to. And you could smile when you hear a swear. These are things you literally could actually do.
Just like how the word fuck has a power over you that you acknowledge every time you hear it.
It can literally make you feel certain ways simply because you allow it to do so.
If you chose to no longer allow that, it wouldn't be able to make *FUCK* you cringe when you read it...
Fuck
Cringes like supposed to.
Fuck
Cringes again
Fuc.... Shia
Chooses to get angry while cringing.
You don't have to cringe and get upset. You can choose not to. Or you can choose to do so
And the beauty of it and the irony of it, is its all up to you.
@@thehuntressdanni2972 Ever considered that people who don't like casual swearing maybe think _there's a value in words having power_ ? Lot of people who don't like swearing would still want to swear when they get into a car accident, fail a class, get broken up with, find out their loved one is pregnant/has cancer etc. depending on where that line is for them, they're just not a fan of words being watered down to a point where they lose their original meaning/weight?
I had a room mate in college who saved all her empty wine bottles. Her parents paid a surprise visit to our dorm room and she told them they were mine. They sent me AA brochures until I graduated. Be careful what gets collected as a young adult.
What a story 😂
🤣🤣🤣
😂
that was lovely ❤ l love you Caroline and am so happy you found a lovely man who loves you. i love him now too ❤
I was just talking to my husband about this very thing. I was an offender in my past. Tonight as I was recycling an empty wine bottle, I felt the need to announce, I’m recycling the cork too! 🎉
He’s wonderful and the goofy part of your personality seems to make him very protective. Thank you for a fun video and the courage to introduce him to us.
Doh. V perceptive. Can confirm ❤
Dude, wife her up! She is smart, hilarious, honest and dependable. She is assertive and a handful, u won’t ever be bored. U guys mesh really well.
I’m just going to pause here quickly to tell you that the chemistry between you and Justin is adorable and thank you for sharing his handsome face with us. I am very happy for you ❤
So nervous to put it out, appreciate this a lotttt❤
@@Caroline_Winkler I know you are but the “nerves” came across beautifully ☺️ more like butterflies on a second date.
His little smile at the very end! So. Cute. Happy for you, Caroline!
Yessssssss Oh My Goodness I love them together.
First of all congratulations Caroline you look so happy! Second of all let's all give a shout out to bachelors for single-handedly leading the way with a low carbon footprint, using things that work, not consuming unless necessary lol
Hahahaha, I was thinking this too!
Nice job, Caroline! Looks like you hit the jackpot with this tasteful, respectful, funny, intelligent man. He’s damn lucky too. 😊
I'm three weeks fresh from a terrible breakup and having watched your previous videos on dating and how amazing you and Justin look it's making me think I shouldn't give up just yet. Thanks for this unexpected wonderful gift, Caroline.
I wish you well for this next chapter of your life. I’m starting over after 32yrs. Painting and soon to decorate my home is helping me to stop ruminating and completely changing the energy in here. Seeing wonderful guys treat women well gives me a lot of hope too. Take care of your heart. ❤
Aw bb. I’m sorry to hear it. That is true pain. You absoLUTELY shouldn’t give up. Dating often made me feel so crazy, as did breakups. But you’re actually getting closer to yourself, a step at a time. Hang in there, I’m excited for you ❤
Babe same here, give or take a couple weeks! I'm not even looking right now but as soon as I saw these two together I was like omg swoon, I have to start looking again soon
Lot's of love your way :)@@HappyHarryX5
Thank you@@Caroline_Winkler ! I'm currently using your calendar tool and it's been super helpful! Lots of love :)
The way he touches you so gently and reaches for your hand... He genuinely loves you. Gave me vicarious butterflies. ☺️
Caroline, I'm just so happy for you. Justin seems to "get you" and he's appreciative of your particular sense of humor. Not only is he good-looking, but he also seems comfortable and confident and into you. And you love each other!!! You deserve it girl - you're a lovely human being..
Serendipitously, this video comes just days after my dad asked me to help him decorate his new bachelor pad. The place just looks bit sad, all the pillows, couch, even bath mat are worn and pitiful. I can't wait to dive into this video tonight and get some tips on how to make his first bachelor pad in 30 years feel like home. Your videos are always exactly what I need right when I need them. Thanks, C!
I’m making a bachelorette pad in what was the family home and painting and recovering furniture to throw off the old life. It’s hard on no budget but I’m so glad you’re helping your Dad reinvent his pad. He’ll appreciate it I’m sure. I can safely say that hand painting the walls (as opposed to the roller) has stopped me ruminating and totally made it a completely different home and atmosphere. It’s exactly what I’ve needed. I hope you have fun and wish you both the best. ❤
HE CALLED YOU A LITTLE CUTIE OMG ❤STOP I CANT HANDLE IT
You guys made me smile for 26 minutes straight. I love the way he meets your humor. And calling out the American Psycho decor is a service to humanity 👏❤️
He’s a sweetie who called out so many women about Paris and I think that’s beautiful. He’s very much giving Jess energy and that’s such a good balance. So supportive and reassuring!!!
I loved and laughed out loud at Justin's input on what the girl equivalents to the alcohol decor is and his Paris girl analogy. Couldn't agree more.
IM SCREAMING STOP IT CAROLINE how dare you guys be so eternally beautiful together. Playful, witty and comforting - may it last a lifetime 🥹🤍 brilliant, it’s so nice to see you being so purely loved and appreciated
It gives me hope to see how well Justin matches your chaotic energy and just takes it into happy stride 😁
I have no clue when/where you said adding a rug into your space makes it look like a room -- but hot damn, just added a rug and it makes a world of difference. Thank you Caroline!
So, it really tied the room together is what you're saying, right?
I actually got emotional seeing this, after having experiencing you be so vulnerable (aka HONEST) about your dating trials. It’s all so relatable and I know I don’t speak for myself when I say we are SO happy for you. He also happens to be a doll, so good on you ! ❤😊
This might be the cutest thing I've seen in months 😊 Justin's little smile right at the end 😍
Omg Caroline he's adorable and you look so good together! Thank you for introducing us to him - that's so kind of you x
The way he is just gazing at you with soft heart eyes the entire time.... So pure!
The "I like the world" line about the maps MADE ME SPIT OUT MY DRINK. Yall are so cute... so happy for you guys!
I am sickeningly obsessed with this. I feel like a friend I know personally just found their person
Omg we love him❤❤❤ The eye contact! The hand holding! The kisses! The hand on your leg!! The smiles when you're feeling nervous or awkward! He's so perfect for you Caroline- 100% need more of him on the channel😍
Watching this felt like the moment when my best friend first told me about the guy who she ended up marrying. I got butterflies for you, girl! Even though you were nervous, you were absolutely glowing and looked so joyful and at peace around him. So happy for the both of you! ❤️ ❤️ ❤️
Literally smiling at my screen and kicking my feetsies at this video - the way he looks at you so full of love, smiling with his whole face at everything you say, so intently looking at you and listening🥹
So happy for you! You guys have a lovely banter, and a comfortable vibe together. What fun we get to share in your happiness! This is coming from someone married to the same person for 22 years. Fun to remember the early days!
It’s palpable that you’re both so stoked to be together. Glad he can throw down in this corner of your life ❤
Wow. Justin’s tenderness toward you brought literal tears to my eyes. I am genuinely happy for you, especially after listening to your past experiences on your podcast. Thank you for sharing (part of) your life with us and for introducing us to this sweet kind man.
I felt seen when you said ‘every little body movement is analysed’. I couldn’t take my eyes off Justin, as he looked at you all the time. It’s perfect. You deserve nothing less.
Omg! He's adorable with a great sense of humor and clearly smitten. ❤
Your bachelor pad photos are hysterical.
I predict this one goes viral - on to 1m subscribers.
I may watch more than my usual twice. 😊
A great match!
His kind and gentle nature pairs very well with Caroline’s whimsical personality. So happy for y’all.
I love him. I'm so happy for you. What a sweet guy. The real key is the way he looks at you THE ENTIRE TIME. Love it. You deserve this.
I love Justin's energy! You two are so complementary.
omg visceral response to him calling you his little cutie. after obsessively watching your channel of late i am beaming to see just that first interaction.
Caroline: "First let me just say, I love you 😁"
Justin: "OK, not a great start 😅"
This KILLED me. You are two freaking adorable dorks & I wish you all the love.
My face hurts from smiling so much. He's so funny, and that voice! I'm glad you two found each other. ❤
Smitten is a good word for him; and that last smile when she wasn't even there tells us everything about how much he adores you.
The way he has that Golden retriever energy, omg he seems like such a keeper, so happy for you 🥹 he matches your energy and humor so much too, love this for youuu. Especially since You both seem so happy and he could not stop looking at you, the absolute sweetest 🥰
He is clearly so smitten and it couldn’t be more adorable! Fun video!!
One of the most clearly articulated demonstrations of the different ways men and women view perceive their living spaces, I loved this so much.
Absolutely love Justin. Your personalities compliment each other. You may have been nervous, but he was very relaxed & natural. So happy for both of you.
You two are hilarious!! 😂
You and Justin complement each other so well, so sweet.
Thank you for introducing Justin to us. We absolutely approve 🙌
Lol this is so cute. And such a great example of how to communicate with your significant other about a touchy subject. I didn't do it right in my last relationship and we were talking about moving in together but I hated his house and he was easily offended at any change suggestions I brought up. Giving a compliment first is a great idea! I got a lot out of this episode. Thank you and congrats on your awesome boyfriend!
Well aren't you two just darling?!! Love the banter and chemistry. So happy for you!
Heart-melting, serotonin-boosting adorably-edited episode in your life. Like someone else commented, I was trying to imagine a guy that would match your wit, charm, warmth (and looks! that's important!), and it's wonderful you've found each other. I liked how he was appreciating and building off your jokes; you are too funny to not be seen and appreciated for it!
That was the coolest video you nervously risked doing! Getting a male’s true perspective wins my respect for you. It was cute honest and vulnerable. Your guy is definitely into to you. His love language is physical touch for sure and can’t be denied!🥰
Ok the fact that he was just normal and well adjusted and introduced you as his gf because DUH y’all were hanging out all the time! Is such a green flag.
Don’t listen to ANYONE about ANYTHING if this man feels like home - he is. You’ll know 💕🙏🏼
Green flag! So used to red flag but green flags do happen and I think Justin is Mr Green Flag.
I swear to god my boyfriend keeps talking about getting a bunch of maps and framing them. I couldn't have laughed louder at "I like the world." Fucking dead 😂
Oh oh oh ALSO he just mentioned American Psycho being iconic and how every guy wanted that look. HELLO? He's a murderer what is wrong with you men. I refuse to allow gray into our home.
Lmao
I'm a girl and I have a map of the world, but you scratch off where you've been so it's functional. Also I studied geography so I have an excuse to like them 😂 but funny on the psycho reference! 😂
This must be one of your funniest and most charming videos ever, Caroline. I've watched it twice and laughed each time at the repartee. It's joyous to see the delight you two take in each other's company, and the creative and witty sparks you generate from each other. May this love grow ever stronger❣️
This was cute AS HECK, I love how you kept making each other laugh
So important!!
I do respect the way people roasted you in the comments of the last video for saying "boyfriend" too much and then your next video is entirely about your BOYFRIEND in capital letters, haha. Also, I like your outfit. I might have to copy that.
haha you know i cant help but lean into peoples complaints
Right? It was like, drink a shot everytime Caroline says boyfriend 😂
@@beans_thecat I think in reality she only said it like 3 times, you guys were doing too much lol
Yes 3. Yes I counted. It's a title. Should be capitalized. Followed by a . Name.
Ooooo that made me smile!
This is gonna sound so weird but I just went through a breakup and was feeling down about dating, and I watched this video and the way your bf just glows when he looks at you, and I was like, “that. That’s how it should be!” And I realized that I was settling for a lot less. So thanks for giving me hope again unintentionally 💙
bravo girl! be you
Aaah I love Justin already. Lucky guy to get to love you! Thank you for sharing your wonderful wacky world with us. We all feel a personal connection with your family - and even the family dog - and are so happy to welcome Justin into the fold. Wishing you a happy forever.
Caroline, you two are so sweet together. The chemistry is absolutely magnetic - what a perfect match! I'm so happy for you. Welcome to the beach house Justin! 🥰
OBSESSED with the chemistry you two have together!!!!! So happy to see you happy!
I love that he's said he's never seen this side of you! We need more of these!
Oh Caroline, he seems like a great match for you. Kind, caring. He looks at you with love. Obviously he enjoys all your quirky ways! Relax, be yourself like you want us to be 😁.
Why did I actually CRY at his smile at the end??? That made me tear up! So sweet!
Such a thoughtful, articulate guy! Justin is a good catch Caroline.
I just realized I was smiling the entire video 😊😂 so fun to see you interacting with your boyfriend. You have such a lovely and natural interaction. And his sense of humor fits right in with your family.
Biggest smile ever watching you 2 together, so freaking happy for you Caroline 💗
Caroline, I am SOOOO HAPPY for you sweetheart! Thank you for introducing us all to your man! Justin looks like an awesome catch! What a gentleman!
As for the pillows, I have 8 on my bed! Lol… 4 for each of us. 1 under our heads, 1 at my back, 1 between my legs for back support, and 1 to hug. If we don’t use them, we toss them to the foot of the bed. Totally functional pillows! As always, great content! ❤
This was so fun! I have literally never been so happy for someone I've never actually met 💑🏻 What a good sport. We stan Justin! 💜
100% approve of Justin, you two are a wonderful couple. thanks as always for sharing your world!
You two are adorable together!!! So nice to see someone who gets you, girl, and loves the things about you that you probably think make you challenging.