@@beyondviolet Yes it's been a long time, forgive me. I'm a baritone to top tenor. I am thoroughly impressed by Scott's range. Don't be put off by know-it-all trolls.
Dropping octaves is actually one of the easier intervals, especially when you practice part singing a lot. You learn to audiate the difference between octaves very naturally. Harder intervals would be 7ths or 6ths.
Kirstin is so so bright and sounds so "full" in her part, just gorgeous. Mitch is obviously flawless and clean and just to die... Scott and Matt both SHOWING OUT in this. Some of the best stuff they've ever put out
I would say that the Disturbed version of this is ominous, but this one is defiant and even hopeful. Both are incredible renditions of the original (which is great in its own regard). Thanks for reacting to them both!
Exactly! I love both versions, and both are incredible in their own way. Even my mother (who listens to nothing 'modern' and only oldies/country/Elvis loves Disturbed's version and really enjoyed Pentatonix's version, too.
Yes, both are great while being so different versions. Or maybe that's why they are both so great. Disturbed's version is quite dark, anxious even and this builds up to a sort of "gospel choir uplifting praise" style. I guess thr reason why both versions work is that they have the passion and emotion in it. The lyrics include emotions in them and after hearing Disturbed covering this I realised that S&G originally didn't get everything out from this. But of course we have to remember that time wouldn't have been ready for Disturbed's style version. And I'd think that this choir type thing wouldn't have gotten much attention either.
dude that's literally no comparison but the fact that it's the same song. It's an acapella operatic-like group versus a metal solo vocalist, I don't get why y'all even bringing this up
As someone with ADHD and Asperger's, emotional logic is a concept, I can't completely grasp. The reason I watch you and no other, is because you explain why they made, the choices they have made logically. You use the logic of the English sentence structure and linguistics to explain why certain notes hit a consonant or vowel and I can follow that. I am in tears every video you post because with your explanations, I can grasp emotional connotation. Thank you so much, for your patience and technically impartial critiques. Thank you again, because of you, I understand musicality logically.
slimydick23 Dude what the heck? ADHD and Aspergers are serious disorders, don’t call someone a dork because they have them. I’ve seen you before, you tend to comment some odd stuff. Seriously, think before you comment. Be kind.
One of the things that makes Pentatonix so special to me is their diction and annunciations are so clear and crisp (you can understand the words to everything they sing) as a side note there's the backstory to the song (yes I'm that old that I remember when it first came out. anyway here ya go What is the story behind the sound of silence? 'The Sound of Silence' by Simon and Garfunkel is a song written in the 1960's about the extent to which people suppressed their true views about the Vietnam War. The poetic voice is the poet himself and it is through his vision that we are made aware of the great disappointment that he feels at the peoples inability to say what is on their minds.
There is nothing more beautiful than a cappella vocals done by people with beautiful voices! You get to hear the human voice used, not only for delivering the lyrics, but also as musical instruments.
Pentatonix is an example of how to have succes with talent and hard work.These people don't need a band or instruments, because all they need are THEIR VOICES! Every time i listen to them, i have goosebumps. They are fantastic!
When I first heard the start of the song, I did a double take because at first I thought it was a guest shot of Avi. Matt is good, but I still miss Avi.
@@DennisKovacich I know that, but what I was referring to was that I think Avi has a larger vocal range from what I've heard so far compared to Matt. It was obvious that it was Scott when I looked up at the video from my desk
@@severusreynolds5247 No actually, Scott cannot sing deeper than Matt, otherwise Scott would be the "new" bass man in Pentatonix😂. So does for Mitch, he cannot "sing" higher than Bb5. From that aspect, Scott do have the widest range in PTX, at least that's what himself, Mitch and Avi said in some interviews years ago. I believe from their understanding, vocal range = the notes you can apply into singing. If let the vocal range = any pitch you can hit, then I don't think thier vocal range will be so impressive for so many people. Because many people can shout or squeak a really high pitch sound, or bubble a quite low note. But when it comes to singing, everyone knows that there is no way somebody can sing so beautifully at that high as Mitch or at that low as Avi.
I found Pentatonix several months ago. I just discovered you tonight. With everything that has happened these past twelve months, I consider these two blessings. My life just got a little better. Thank you.
You are so very correct. Their arrangements are S.I.C.K. Then add in the talent and hard work every one of them brings to the group, and it's no wonder that when they do a song, 99% of the time, it's incredible. They have an amazing ability to wring out the emotion from every song they do: Joyous, sad, dance beat, whatever. You. Will. Feel. It. I will say though that out of the original and remakes of this song, I like Disturb's the most, but this version is still (as you show us) a master-class of how to sing right.
Kirsten is the most underrated member, her high register cuts through the harmony and anchors the high range with a pure, bright female tone. Mitch's counter tenor is amazing too but he's on the falsetto side whereas Kirsten is a bit more natural and pure. Mitch can shine in certain ranges where a high, almost electronic sound is required like Blinding lights and Daft Punk but Kirsten is so rich and solid with her forward voice. Scott is the next underrated, his tone and expression is so rich and smooth, he switches from a softer raspy subdued tone to a rich forward placement effortlessly as well as filling in as bass when Matt or Avi is singing.
Truly one of their best arrangements to date and I get CHILLS everytime Scott sings his verse at the end. I find the analysis of their vocals fascinating and truly enjoy your channel. Thank you for reacting to this masterpiece. It is my favorite arrangement they have put out since Matt joined the group. 🥰
Their video is basically what the last few minutes of earth would look and sound like before the apocalypse hit. It's like they are so into it that they are like singing for their lives. Like someone has a gun to their heads. Just so much passion. I always say if you are gonna sing, sing with your whole being or not at all because I don't want to hear a flat performance of a powerful song. I want to feel the song not hear it. I felt this song. I felt it a lot to the point that it nearly gave me an existential crisis. Love your reactions to them as well Tara. Love your analysis and how you break down the technical side of it all. I would love you to react to more PTX videos and maybe stuff that ate side and solo projects from individual members of the group.
True, im a singer, and my parents always told me to sing with my all. But im not literally doing what they say, im also doing it for myself, because i also want to really feel the song and its message
Your reactions are not just reactions - they're educational sessions. Notes about phrasing, about tone, about stylistic choices and arrangement choices, about embouchure. Really great stuff!
I am far from a musician or even further... but I came here to find out if I am dreaming with the perfection I hear from Pentatonix. You explained it perfectly even for my low knowledge of music you made it very clear to me. Thank you
Scott always did this even with Avi. Check out Carrol of the Bells and you can see he's doing it while Avi is singing. Also during most times when Avi, or now Matt, are singing.
As a person who's not a singer it's really interesting to watch these videos and it makes me appreciate what Pentatonix does even more... Oh I'll definitely be fangirling over and listening to Pentatonix for the next months... Especially over Christmas it's even appropriate for me to put the music on loud without risking people frown at occasionally added christmas songs... C:
I just came across this group yesterday and I’m obsessed. They are so so so so so amazing. I can’t put it into words. Their voices are RIDICULOUSLY AMAZING, wow just wow
My personal favorite part of this cover is the arrangement. It is very smart. A great example of how smart it is can be seen in Mat's verse. On the line voices never shared, there is no way Mat would sound good on the high A in that line. Giving that line to Mitch while Mat took the harmony was a very smart idea.
****IMPRESSIVE DOESN'T EVEN COME CLOSE, TO DESCRIBING HOW INCREDIBLE THIS A CAPELLA GROUP IS, & I CANT EVEN THINK OF A WORD GOOD ENOUGH TO EXPRESS. HOW INSANELY GOOD THEY ARE!!!****
This is actually the first time I watch one of those "vocalcoach reacts ..." videos and actually feel like the person has real expertise to offer. Great Video, Tara. :D
The passion in your reaction Tara believe it or not, brought me to shed a few tears. When your passion for music comes out with that much excitement. Well makes me happy cause I feel that way to.. Brothers and sisters in music. PTX took me too church.
I’m obviously late to the party, but I wanted to leave a quick comment. A few weeks back I had the pleasure of listening to evensong at St Paul’s cathedral in London. The blended harmonics of the choir in that space is something I’ll never forget. In the quieter moments of this rendition when the intensity was pulled back, that same floating sound I heard at St Paul’s was back in my ears. The repeated building and pulling back also allowed me to live more fully in each moment of excellence these singers brought to this performance. Glorious sound!
The Official Video is the only version available right now. There should be live versions available once they start their tour, as I expect this song to be one of the highlights of their setlist.
As someone who went to an overly-snobby classical voice school, I am thoroughly impressed with your attention to detail, both vocally and artistically. You're clearly paying attention to everything without dumbing it down for the audience, and I absolutely love that. Definitely subbed.
Tara Simon, your ability to notice and point out certain things is amazing. I can definitely see your love and passion for music and performance, which is so heart-warming. You are just amazing - Well Done!
I’ve been waiting since Feb 15 for you to do this reaction. For me, this was Kirstin’s best performance to date. But my favorite moment in the song, and this may sound funny, is Scott coming through on a amazing note above everyone else on the very last “Sound” at the end of the song. Gives me chills. IMHO, this is PTX’s best cover yet. 💜
Scott's bass! Kirstin has improved so much. She had some bad technique habits up until fairly recently that she's obviously been working on eliminating with an experienced vocal coach. I haven't seen her infamous side-jaw in ages. Great reaction and analysis as always Tara!
Nope, it’s because she had a vocal coach working with her for her solo Album. That was when it disappeared! I kinda miss it, but it wasn’t good for her singing...
Listening to you sing is so amazing, your voice is so strong and powerful and delicate and graceful, it shows how much you love and enjoy music and those who express themselves through it, thank you for doing what you do and who you are.
Great reaction Tara! I liked how this video featured Scott starting off in his lower register and then Matt and Kirstin singing in their higher registers. Lots of pleasant surprises. As for Mitch and Kevin, ... what can I say? Their talent shines through on this video as it does on every video. All together PTX is a formidable package. Loved it.
I hear something new every time I listen to this song. Today, it’s the backup (Kirsten, I think) who emphasizes the word “light” immediately after Mitch says “flash of the neon light” Sounds like, “flash of the neon light-liGHT” that split the night. So beautiful.
Scott and Mitch both have such amazing voices, I could listen to them everyday. Was stoked to see them live in August, if you get the chance to see them live definitely do it.
I love your commentary and find your analysis highly educational...esp as a non-musician/singer who is deaf in one ear. I appreciate you pointing out what I should listen for so I can "hear" and appreciate their creative genius + technically how they literally create "music for my ears". Cheers!
I went to one of their concerts. IT WAS THE BEST THING IN THE WORLD. I really hope you got to go to one of them and see them live. Best experience of my life.
So glad I saw your reaction to this, you are the first person who explained the why/how their sound is so awesome without making it about you, just the music.
I was waiting for you to react to this. I grew up with the Simon and Garfunkel version and I never thought anyone else could do as good of a job but Pentatonix took it to the next level! Every time I listen to this I am brought to tears! Pentatonix has never disappointed me. Thank you for explaining how they create the sounds and why. I learn a lot from you.
"Yes unison!" It also helps that the main 3 vocalists have known each other since they were kids, so having that connectivity to each other's voices helps with unison. Matt is a wonderful addition to the group as much as we miss Avi! Loved it and your video!
This reminds me of the PTX / Dolly Parton collaboration on Jolene. I've loved Pentatonix since their early UA-cam days. They're amazing. When I watched Jolene and heard how much Parton brought to the song over and above them... I never really appreciated Dolly Parton (a legend most popular before my time) until seeing that contrast.
Woo! I have been a Pentaholic since the Sing-Off. However, this song blew me away. Please react to Citizen Queen - Evolution of Girl Groups. They are produced by Scott Hoying and Ben Bram :)
Please react to the official video of Superfruit's (Scott & Mitch) cover of "The Promise" originally performed by the UK pop band "When in Rome" back in 1988. Both aurally and visually it has a fantabulous '80s pop feel.
Pentatonix has spawned dozens of different youtubers that react to their songs. I have to say that your videos are, by far and away, the most detailed, informative, and enjoyable to watch. Thanks so much for sharing your professional analysis and insights!
I've seen them live twice, once when they first started touring and again last year. I highly recommend it. They are every bit as good live as they are in canned videos.
I think what made it so perfect in the beginning with him focusing on the “N” on friend was that it really kept the resonance very strong and that was just perfect.
They're really amazing. Sometimes you hear certain people and you have to say,they're the best. Each one of them are amazing in their own rite,but together they're quite literally 5 times better.
I literally put notifications on for you because I was waiting for this and you didn't disappoint! I absolutely love how you break things down and I always learn something new from watching you!
Even though I have no idea of vocal education or notes, I had the same reaction of you, I love them, it make me chills, I wish I can sing but I thank to be able to listen to voices like this 💜💜💜
I went to a Pentatonix concert for the 1st time last summer. They are truly "off the chain"! One of the few groups that sound better live than recorded! Definitely going to another one next time they're in town!
Yes! Yes! Yes! I've been waiting for this since you reacted for Disturbed! I absolutely looooove not just your lovely reaction but how you unpack what makes PTX and others singers awesome. I await for your new videos and learn more from you.
I can see that you "FEEL" the music!! There are some special songs that take me through different emotions and this is truly one of them. So for anyone reading this, if you see someone that just gets up and starts to dance, don't shame them.....they are just "feeling" the music and sometimes, you can't do anything except respond to that feeling.
omg I'm so happy that you did a cover of Pentatonix's version!!! I actually JUST last night suggested it on your reaction to the Disturbed version and seeing it up today was like "omg this is meta" THANKYOUTHANKYOUTHANKYOU When I watched it the first time I was just like your reaction right at the start. I never knew Scott to go down to the basement like that! He's usually a lighter singer, but it's so cool to hear his voice that low. I love Disturbed's version and I was excited to see Pentatonix covering it. As someone else in the comments said, Disturbed's version is sounding more ominous, where Pentatonix makes it sound defiant and even hopeful. You know how people say music can affect someone's mental state? I think that if someone who was in depression or pretty down low, if they heard this it may help bring them up gently, hearing this version may make them think, "hey I'm gonna follow this, bust through this crap" and start to be more proactive for themselves.
I love love LOVE your videos on Pentatonix's music! You give such an interesting and in depth reaction! I also love that you give criticism as well because praise is nice, but I personally, like seeing your criticism because not only does it give a new fresh perspective, it's also informative! Which I love cause I'm trying to better my singing voice! So thanks so much for doing these videos, Tara! Much appreciated! :)
I have been waiting for your reaction to this one! 💗 I know you're going to break it all down and I really like it cause I learn about the techniques they're using. I noticed them going to and holding out the "N" instead of the vowel. I just didn't know what it was about. I noticed that Scott didn't do one single riff or run, and I actually liked that choice for this number. I'm so glad you said that Matt fits in well with the rest of the group, and welcomed him! Earlier I heard a reactor say that Matt doesn't fit in with them, and he wished he'd leave. 😠 I thought that was an awful thing to say and completely untrue. I educated him on the error of his ways... he doesn't even know what he's talking about. YOU, however DO know what you're talking about, and you said Matt fits in well in the group! thank you for a lovely breakdown of the techniques and choices they made!
If you haven't dont it already, you should do Pentatonix's Run to You. The harmonies are so, so gorgeous, and the song itself is so emotional and beautiful.
You can REALLY tell how much Kirstin has been working on her tone. So much more rich and full sounding in this one than the thin but pretty tone shes always been known for. Love ittttt
so i came back to ptx after a while and i clicked on sound of silence and that was the best choice ive ever made💀. it was also the first time hearing matts voice and it was beautiful!! matts solo was definitely my favorite
Tara, I appreciate your videos. A lot of singers react to songs but do not teach the viewer. Thank you for explaining the science behind the subtle details of PTX's music. It makes me appreciate what they do even more, Be well!
Want Lessons? Vocal Courses? More? Check Out Everything Here: linktr.ee/tarasimonstudios
Hi Tara 🥺
Would love to see your reaction to Poets of the Fall (Any of their Alexandra Theatre session songs) Angel is amazing :
u are awesome wish i wouldn't have fried my voice or id take you up on some lessions
Woo
How do I know what is my vocal range
I knew Scott could sing bass but Jesus that was impressive
What would you expect for a baritone?
¯\_(ツ)_/¯ I don’t really know tbh, but just occasionally hearing him like that in the background was not enough of a hint for me I guess.
@@beyondviolet Yes it's been a long time, forgive me.
I'm a baritone to top tenor. I am thoroughly impressed by Scott's range. Don't be put off by know-it-all trolls.
@@tillthedawn Some baritones can't hit that low. I'm a baritone, and I was impressed by Matt's range
somebody has to replace Avi
is nobody going to mention that Matt drops a whole octave in one beat??
Holy shi* I just noticed that is insane.
That's really pretty common with bass notes. :)
Matt dropped a whole octave in one beat
First thing I've noticed.
Dropping octaves is actually one of the easier intervals, especially when you practice part singing a lot. You learn to audiate the difference between octaves very naturally. Harder intervals would be 7ths or 6ths.
4:45 "So good let's listen again" That's it. That's Pentatonix
Yes totally sums up all PTX performances 😊
Kirstin is so so bright and sounds so "full" in her part, just gorgeous. Mitch is obviously flawless and clean and just to die... Scott and Matt both SHOWING OUT in this. Some of the best stuff they've ever put out
And of course Kevin is still killing it
She's gotten so much better over the years. Idk what it is but she's so much more clear and better sounding the last couple years. Love her voice.
@@HB-ey2dk She's more confident now too thanks to her broadway show. She has improved a hella lot, love her. 💗
She to me is the anchor to that group. Yes there are incredible voice, but she is just outstanding pulling them together.
They all killed it but Kirstin's part was my favorite! So powerful and beautiful!!
Can't agree more! She's always been amazing, but she's also progressed so much and is so confident now!
her and Scott in the middle gave me chills!
@@Rosannasfriend What about Matt?
Agreed!
agree! i love it too
... her voice is my all time favorite...
That little "hey Kevin" when he started beatboxing 😂😂
I know 🤣
Lol
I would say that the Disturbed version of this is ominous, but this one is defiant and even hopeful. Both are incredible renditions of the original (which is great in its own regard). Thanks for reacting to them both!
Exactly! I love both versions, and both are incredible in their own way. Even my mother (who listens to nothing 'modern' and only oldies/country/Elvis loves Disturbed's version and really enjoyed Pentatonix's version, too.
Well said
Your analysis is so spot on!
Yes, both are great while being so different versions. Or maybe that's why they are both so great. Disturbed's version is quite dark, anxious even and this builds up to a sort of "gospel choir uplifting praise" style.
I guess thr reason why both versions work is that they have the passion and emotion in it. The lyrics include emotions in them and after hearing Disturbed covering this I realised that S&G originally didn't get everything out from this. But of course we have to remember that time wouldn't have been ready for Disturbed's style version. And I'd think that this choir type thing wouldn't have gotten much attention either.
dude that's literally no comparison but the fact that it's the same song. It's an acapella operatic-like group versus a metal solo vocalist, I don't get why y'all even bringing this up
As someone with ADHD and Asperger's, emotional logic is a concept, I can't completely grasp. The reason I watch you and no other, is because you explain why they made, the choices they have made logically. You use the logic of the English sentence structure and linguistics to explain why certain notes hit a consonant or vowel and I can follow that. I am in tears every video you post because with your explanations, I can grasp emotional connotation. Thank you so much, for your patience and technically impartial critiques. Thank you again, because of you, I understand musicality logically.
Amen :)
Wow 😮. That was the deepest thing I think I’ve ever read on UA-cam, legit.
what a beautiful comment!
lol dork
slimydick23 Dude what the heck? ADHD and Aspergers are serious disorders, don’t call someone a dork because they have them. I’ve seen you before, you tend to comment some odd stuff. Seriously, think before you comment. Be kind.
My personal favorite part is Matt octave drop on sound during his solo. She didn't say anything about it and my mouth was hanging open 😂
Kaylee Hooper SAMMEEEEEEEEE
She heard him when after he dropped, but yes, she completely skipped the drop
Totes. Favourite part of the song by far!
Exactly that is one of my favorite parts...
SAME
What I love about Matt is he always looks like he's just happy to be there.
this sums him up i love it 😂
One of the things that makes Pentatonix so special to me is their diction and annunciations are so clear and crisp (you can understand the words to everything they sing)
as a side note there's the backstory to the song (yes I'm that old that I remember when it first came out. anyway here ya go
What is the story behind the sound of silence?
'The Sound of Silence' by Simon and Garfunkel is a song written in the 1960's about the extent to which people suppressed their true views about the Vietnam War. The poetic voice is the poet himself and it is through his vision that we are made aware of the great disappointment that he feels at the peoples inability to say what is on their minds.
Your reaction at 1:25 with Scott and 5:42 with Matt are EXACTLY the same, and it made me laugh so hard - stupidly so. Fantastic reaction!
Thats true
hahaahhahahaha
I am so glad someone else caught that besides me!!! Scott is AMAZING!!!!!!!!!!!!!
DAS IST GAR NICHTS! WOLF WINTER Sounds of Silence DAS IST DER BEST ua-cam.com/video/56FvxRkDx_s/v-deo.html
There is nothing more beautiful than a cappella vocals done by people with beautiful voices! You get to hear the human voice used, not only for delivering the lyrics, but also as musical instruments.
Finally got to hear Matt... Impressed.
New Rules x Are You That Somebody and Attention. If you listen with earphones especially, but even if you don’t, you’all hear him! 😉
How about Scott doing the bass part when Matt is singing lead?? Amazing range!!!
His range is literally superhuman
His range is larger than my
Love for Jesus Christ can I get an amen?
@@dylanbardin965 it's above average, that's about it lol.
Scott is super human
he actually did in hallelujah as well when avi had his singing part.
Pentatonix is an example of how to have succes with talent and hard work.These people don't need a band or instruments, because all they need are THEIR VOICES! Every time i listen to them, i have goosebumps. They are fantastic!
1:25 LOL! That was my reaction when I first heard the beginning of this song too! I was like, "whaaaa??? Scotty going in the basement!" :P
hah BASment xD
@@ponyoponyo576 bass but its ight i see what you two did there
When I first heard the start of the song, I did a double take because at first I thought it was a guest shot of Avi. Matt is good, but I still miss Avi.
theonlymoo5e, that wasn’t Matt, either. That was Scott!
@@DennisKovacich I know that, but what I was referring to was that I think Avi has a larger vocal range from what I've heard so far compared to Matt. It was obvious that it was Scott when I looked up at the video from my desk
Scott In Halleluja: Mitch has a competitor
Scott in Sound of Silence: Matt has a competitor
Respect your opinion but the whole group feeds on Matt now...
@@davelopez7097 ? explain
Mitch have no competitor,he is pure high notes ,Scott have a wide range but not as wide as Mitch, but Scott can sing deeper than matt
@@severusreynolds5247 No actually, Scott cannot sing deeper than Matt, otherwise Scott would be the "new" bass man in Pentatonix😂. So does for Mitch, he cannot "sing" higher than Bb5. From that aspect, Scott do have the widest range in PTX, at least that's what himself, Mitch and Avi said in some interviews years ago. I believe from their understanding, vocal range = the notes you can apply into singing. If let the vocal range = any pitch you can hit, then I don't think thier vocal range will be so impressive for so many people. Because many people can shout or squeak a really high pitch sound, or bubble a quite low note. But when it comes to singing, everyone knows that there is no way somebody can sing so beautifully at that high as Mitch or at that low as Avi.
Scott also was singing Avi'd part during his solo
I found Pentatonix several months ago. I just discovered you tonight. With everything that has happened these past twelve months, I consider these two blessings. My life just got a little better. Thank you.
I'm super impressed by Kirstie's vibrato but nobody ever mentions it lol. She shined in this song. Soooo good.
You are so very correct. Their arrangements are S.I.C.K. Then add in the talent and hard work every one of them brings to the group, and it's no wonder that when they do a song, 99% of the time, it's incredible. They have an amazing ability to wring out the emotion from every song they do: Joyous, sad, dance beat, whatever. You. Will. Feel. It.
I will say though that out of the original and remakes of this song, I like Disturb's the most, but this version is still (as you show us) a master-class of how to sing right.
Kirsten is the most underrated member, her high register cuts through the harmony and anchors the high range with a pure, bright female tone. Mitch's counter tenor is amazing too but he's on the falsetto side whereas Kirsten is a bit more natural and pure. Mitch can shine in certain ranges where a high, almost electronic sound is required like Blinding lights and Daft Punk but Kirsten is so rich and solid with her forward voice.
Scott is the next underrated, his tone and expression is so rich and smooth, he switches from a softer raspy subdued tone to a rich forward placement effortlessly as well as filling in as bass when Matt or Avi is singing.
I don't think any of them are underrated to be honest, everyone knows how awesome they all are
@@ben6993 Sure most people do but there's a tendency to hype up Mitch I've noticed.
3:15 hey Kevin 😂
Truly one of their best arrangements to date and I get CHILLS everytime Scott sings his verse at the end. I find the analysis of their vocals fascinating and truly enjoy your channel. Thank you for reacting to this masterpiece. It is my favorite arrangement they have put out since Matt joined the group. 🥰
Their video is basically what the last few minutes of earth would look and sound like before the apocalypse hit. It's like they are so into it that they are like singing for their lives. Like someone has a gun to their heads. Just so much passion. I always say if you are gonna sing, sing with your whole being or not at all because I don't want to hear a flat performance of a powerful song. I want to feel the song not hear it. I felt this song. I felt it a lot to the point that it nearly gave me an existential crisis. Love your reactions to them as well Tara. Love your analysis and how you break down the technical side of it all. I would love you to react to more PTX videos and maybe stuff that ate side and solo projects from individual members of the group.
True, im a singer, and my parents always told me to sing with my all.
But im not literally doing what they say, im also doing it for myself, because i also want to really feel the song and its message
Your reactions are not just reactions - they're educational sessions. Notes about phrasing, about tone, about stylistic choices and arrangement choices, about embouchure. Really great stuff!
I wish you talked a bit about that vibrato on those crazy high notes that Mitch and Kirstie belted. That's hard, and rare to hear!
Thats cuz she talks a lot about those in other videos
I've never been able to drop vibrato from those notes. It's interesting how people are surprised by hearing it.
I am far from a musician or even further...
but I came here to find out if I am dreaming with the perfection I hear from Pentatonix.
You explained it perfectly even for my low knowledge of music you made it very clear to me. Thank you
Tara Simon looking lovely today great reaction to the song Sound of Silences from the Pentatnoix
Eric Gaudet it’s just Pentatonix, not the Pentatonix
lol were still having to fight the battle. LOL
This feels wholesome
Matt's got such an amazing range (Mitch too, love them all but Matt always impresses me)
Right!
I would love it if you could react to the Penatonix cover of Gold. It is done in a "live" session and is fantastic as always.
Please watch the original Kiiara version first if you arent familiar with it.
YES
Omg yes I love that video I have watched it so many times
YEEESSS
Bro, I found a brand new respect for Mitch on that one. Did the autotune better than the original
I’m glad you recognized Kirsten, she seems to get little attention
Notice that Scott was singing bass during Matt’s part. I think that was really cool!
Y..e..s!!
That's right, cause Matt's a true baritone...
Scott always did this even with Avi. Check out Carrol of the Bells and you can see he's doing it while Avi is singing. Also during most times when Avi, or now Matt, are singing.
As a person who's not a singer it's really interesting to watch these videos and it makes me appreciate what Pentatonix does even more...
Oh I'll definitely be fangirling over and listening to Pentatonix for the next months... Especially over Christmas it's even appropriate for me to put the music on loud without risking people frown at occasionally added christmas songs... C:
Please react to their cover of Gold. It’s live and Mitch is amazing.
Yes. The Kiiara cover for Gold.
Its amazing!!!❤️
YESSS
I have to agree. Sooo good.
Yes please!
I just came across this group yesterday and I’m obsessed. They are so so so so so amazing. I can’t put it into words. Their voices are RIDICULOUSLY AMAZING, wow just wow
My personal favorite part of this cover is the arrangement. It is very smart. A great example of how smart it is can be seen in Mat's verse. On the line voices never shared, there is no way Mat would sound good on the high A in that line. Giving that line to Mitch while Mat took the harmony was a very smart idea.
Firewall Dragon yes!! agreed!
****IMPRESSIVE DOESN'T EVEN COME CLOSE, TO DESCRIBING HOW INCREDIBLE THIS A CAPELLA GROUP IS, & I CANT EVEN THINK OF A WORD GOOD ENOUGH TO EXPRESS. HOW INSANELY GOOD THEY ARE!!!****
These people are talented to a degree that my brain just doesn't get...so good! 😲
7:45 "Yaaas unisonnnn" was the cutest thing I've seen her do
It’s probably my burgeoning “get of my lawn” old man mindset, but I lose respect for anyone who honestly says “yaaas”
The unison, harmony, unison ending was great as well as Scott's use of his lower register in this song.
This is actually the first time I watch one of those "vocalcoach reacts ..." videos and actually feel like the person has real expertise to offer. Great Video, Tara. :D
The passion in your reaction Tara believe it or not, brought me to shed a few tears. When your passion for music comes out with that much excitement. Well makes me happy cause I feel that way to.. Brothers and sisters in music. PTX took me too church.
I’m obviously late to the party, but I wanted to leave a quick comment. A few weeks back I had the pleasure of listening to evensong at St Paul’s cathedral in London. The blended harmonics of the choir in that space is something I’ll never forget. In the quieter moments of this rendition when the intensity was pulled back, that same floating sound I heard at St Paul’s was back in my ears. The repeated building and pulling back also allowed me to live more fully in each moment of excellence these singers brought to this performance. Glorious sound!
The Official Video is the only version available right now. There should be live versions available once they start their tour, as I expect this song to be one of the highlights of their setlist.
As someone who went to an overly-snobby classical voice school, I am thoroughly impressed with your attention to detail, both vocally and artistically. You're clearly paying attention to everything without dumbing it down for the audience, and I absolutely love that. Definitely subbed.
Would love you to react to Pentatonix live performance of Aha! at Singapore, The Star Vista
PLEASE
PLEEEASE
PLEEEEASE
angejka a another must for any Pentatonix fan!
Please
Tara Simon, your ability to notice and point out certain things is amazing. I can definitely see your love and passion for music and performance, which is so heart-warming. You are just amazing - Well Done!
I’ve been waiting since Feb 15 for you to do this reaction. For me, this was Kirstin’s best performance to date. But my favorite moment in the song, and this may sound funny, is Scott coming through on a amazing note above everyone else on the very last “Sound” at the end of the song. Gives me chills. IMHO, this is PTX’s best cover yet. 💜
The +4! Also just visually, he's standing in the middle, which matches where his note sits in the chord. It's pretty great.
Your reactions are always so genuine and you’re so insightful in the way you speak.
Scott's bass! Kirstin has improved so much. She had some bad technique habits up until fairly recently that she's obviously been working on eliminating with an experienced vocal coach. I haven't seen her infamous side-jaw in ages. Great reaction and analysis as always Tara!
Nope, it’s because she had a vocal coach working with her for her solo Album. That was when it disappeared! I kinda miss it, but it wasn’t good for her singing...
I read somewhere that she was born with something that caused it and she got rid of it with surgery
@@dadadunlol6079 yes, she was born with a cleft Palate
@@chandreyeejackson5 what?
Listening to you sing is so amazing, your voice is so strong and powerful and delicate and graceful, it shows how much you love and enjoy music and those who express themselves through it, thank you for doing what you do and who you are.
Great reaction Tara! I liked how this video featured Scott starting off in his lower register and then Matt and Kirstin singing in their higher registers. Lots of pleasant surprises. As for Mitch and Kevin, ... what can I say? Their talent shines through on this video as it does on every video. All together PTX is a formidable package. Loved it.
I hear something new every time I listen to this song. Today, it’s the backup (Kirsten, I think) who emphasizes the word “light” immediately after Mitch says “flash of the neon light”
Sounds like, “flash of the neon light-liGHT” that split the night. So beautiful.
Scott and Mitch both have such amazing voices, I could listen to them everyday. Was stoked to see them live in August, if you get the chance to see them live definitely do it.
I love your commentary and find your analysis highly educational...esp as a non-musician/singer who is deaf in one ear. I appreciate you pointing out what I should listen for so I can "hear" and appreciate their creative genius + technically how they literally create "music for my ears". Cheers!
I went to one of their concerts. IT WAS THE BEST THING IN THE WORLD. I really hope you got to go to one of them and see them live. Best experience of my life.
Every song they sing gives me goosebumps. Legit never fails. They are an absolutely fabulous group.
Kirstin, Mitch, Scott, Matt, Kevin! They are amazing! Best cover for me!
So glad I saw your reaction to this, you are the first person who explained the why/how their sound is so awesome without making it about you, just the music.
Can we talk about Scott's bass while Matt's singing solo?! 😍
I was waiting for you to react to this. I grew up with the Simon and Garfunkel version and I never thought anyone else could do as good of a job but Pentatonix took it to the next level! Every time I listen to this I am brought to tears! Pentatonix has never disappointed me. Thank you for explaining how they create the sounds and why. I learn a lot from you.
Suzanne Cole-Rice, have you seen Disturbed’s rendition? It’s very powerful, especially with his official video.
Their version of Say Something is one of my favorites. It's incredible.
"Yes unison!" It also helps that the main 3 vocalists have known each other since they were kids, so having that connectivity to each other's voices helps with unison. Matt is a wonderful addition to the group as much as we miss Avi! Loved it and your video!
Absolutely love this cover and hearing you break it down! Goosebumps every time!
Their harmony is just out of this world
This reminds me of the PTX / Dolly Parton collaboration on Jolene. I've loved Pentatonix since their early UA-cam days. They're amazing. When I watched Jolene and heard how much Parton brought to the song over and above them... I never really appreciated Dolly Parton (a legend most popular before my time) until seeing that contrast.
What a powerful rendition of this song. The tears fell with this one.
Woo! I have been a Pentaholic since the Sing-Off. However, this song blew me away. Please react to Citizen Queen - Evolution of Girl Groups. They are produced by Scott Hoying and Ben Bram :)
Yesssss!!! Tara, please react to Citizen Queennnn!!!!
Yesss, please react to the girls!
Don't forget producer Shams Ahmed.
YES, we need a Citizen Queen reaction!
YES PLEASE!!!! 👸🏾👸🏻👸🏼👸🏻👸🏾🙌
I need to hear Tara sing. The example lines she sings displays a voice that is perfection to my ears. Surely there is a song out there???
Please react to the official video of Superfruit's (Scott & Mitch) cover of "The Promise" originally performed by the UK pop band "When in Rome" back in 1988. Both aurally and visually it has a fantabulous '80s pop feel.
Pentatonix has spawned dozens of different youtubers that react to their songs. I have to say that your videos are, by far and away, the most detailed, informative, and enjoyable to watch. Thanks so much for sharing your professional analysis and insights!
I've seen them live twice, once when they first started touring and again last year. I highly recommend it. They are every bit as good live as they are in canned videos.
I think what made it so perfect in the beginning with him focusing on the “N” on friend was that it really kept the resonance very strong and that was just perfect.
7:42 would make the cutest GIF 😆
Yeah
To be fair
Yeah that was so cute
They're really amazing. Sometimes you hear certain people and you have to say,they're the best. Each one of them are amazing in their own rite,but together they're quite literally 5 times better.
I literally put notifications on for you because I was waiting for this and you didn't disappoint! I absolutely love how you break things down and I always learn something new from watching you!
Even though I have no idea of vocal education or notes, I had the same reaction of you, I love them, it make me chills, I wish I can sing but I thank to be able to listen to voices like this 💜💜💜
I went to a Pentatonix concert for the 1st time last summer. They are truly "off the chain"! One of the few groups that sound better live than recorded! Definitely going to another one next time they're in town!
They have such compassion and I can feel the hope and their love of music. Yours too.
Yes! Yes! Yes! I've been waiting for this since you reacted for Disturbed!
I absolutely looooove not just your lovely reaction but how you unpack what makes PTX and others singers awesome. I await for your new videos and learn more from you.
I can see that you "FEEL" the music!! There are some special songs that take me through different emotions and this is truly one of them. So for anyone reading this, if you see someone that just gets up and starts to dance, don't shame them.....they are just "feeling" the music and sometimes, you can't do anything except respond to that feeling.
This. Is. So. True!
I freakin love your reactions to pentatonix. We feel you gurl. We feel you.
this is one of the songs that send shivers down your back
Yes! I'm so excited to see this! I love their version.
I love hearing opinions on why I love this version. I also love the disturbed. Version
omg I'm so happy that you did a cover of Pentatonix's version!!! I actually JUST last night suggested it on your reaction to the Disturbed version and seeing it up today was like "omg this is meta" THANKYOUTHANKYOUTHANKYOU
When I watched it the first time I was just like your reaction right at the start. I never knew Scott to go down to the basement like that! He's usually a lighter singer, but it's so cool to hear his voice that low.
I love Disturbed's version and I was excited to see Pentatonix covering it.
As someone else in the comments said, Disturbed's version is sounding more ominous, where Pentatonix makes it sound defiant and even hopeful.
You know how people say music can affect someone's mental state? I think that if someone who was in depression or pretty down low, if they heard this it may help bring them up gently, hearing this version may make them think, "hey I'm gonna follow this, bust through this crap" and start to be more proactive for themselves.
You explain exactly why we love singers. Cos we don’t get it until we see your explanation of why these voices stand out.
Thank you.
I love love LOVE your videos on Pentatonix's music! You give such an interesting and in depth reaction! I also love that you give criticism as well because praise is nice, but I personally, like seeing your criticism because not only does it give a new fresh perspective, it's also informative! Which I love cause I'm trying to better my singing voice! So thanks so much for doing these videos, Tara! Much appreciated! :)
you are so knowledgable and so much fun to watch, Ms. Simon! and respectfully speaking, you are as pretty as you are talented/smart!
YEEES! Thank you, Tara! Love you and Pentatonix!♥️♥️♥️♥️
Beautiful... haunting... yet still bright?!? Crisp and bold.
I have been waiting for your reaction to this one! 💗 I know you're going to break it all down and I really like it cause I learn about the techniques they're using. I noticed them going to and holding out the "N" instead of the vowel. I just didn't know what it was about.
I noticed that Scott didn't do one single riff or run, and I actually liked that choice for this number.
I'm so glad you said that Matt fits in well with the rest of the group, and welcomed him! Earlier I heard a reactor say that Matt doesn't fit in with them, and he wished he'd leave. 😠 I thought that was an awful thing to say and completely untrue. I educated him on the error of his ways... he doesn't even know what he's talking about. YOU, however DO know what you're talking about, and you said Matt fits in well in the group!
thank you for a lovely breakdown of the techniques and choices they made!
If you haven't dont it already, you should do Pentatonix's Run to You. The harmonies are so, so gorgeous, and the song itself is so emotional and beautiful.
6:34
"I know I'm making a funny face"
Yes you were 😂😂😂❤️
You can REALLY tell how much Kirstin has been working on her tone. So much more rich and full sounding in this one than the thin but pretty tone shes always been known for. Love ittttt
so i came back to ptx after a while and i clicked on sound of silence and that was the best choice ive ever made💀. it was also the first time hearing matts voice and it was beautiful!! matts solo was definitely my favorite
Tara, I appreciate your videos. A lot of singers react to songs but do not teach the viewer. Thank you for explaining the science behind the subtle details of PTX's music. It makes me appreciate what they do even more, Be well!
Simply put. Thank you. Best reactor on UA-cam.