Hindu Nationalism Could Breakup India but Ultimately People Will Resist Modi's Fascism-Arundhati Roy
Вставка
- Опубліковано 11 лют 2022
- In a comprehensive interview to Karan Thapar for The Wire, Arundhati Roy says the present situation in the country is “extremely depressing” but she believes there are signs that the Indian people are climbing out of the hole they’ve fallen into. She said she has faith in the Indian people and believes the country will emerge out of the dark tunnel its presently within.
00:15 - 01:11 - Introduction
01:12 - 07:02 - Arundhati Roy on what has become of Indian democracy under Modi; the corporate-political nexus.
07:03 - 10:49 - Hindu majoritarianism in India and the role of the state machinery.
10:50 - 13:48 - The idea of a ‘Hindu nation’ threatens to break India apart.
13:49 - 17:22 - India’s (and the BJP’s) brutal treatment of minorities.
17:23 - 22:25 - Roy’s checklist on signs of fascism.
22:26 - 25:56 - ‘The people of the country are stopping India from becoming a fascist state.’
25:57 - 28:47 - Roy claims that the BJP losing the 2022 Uttar Pradesh election could be a dangerous prospect.
28:48 - 30:47 - The role of ‘liberals’ in facilitating fascism in India; how that has changed.
30:48 - 37:06 - Resonances of Nazi Germany can be seen in India today, but fascism will be failed experiment
37:07 - 41:46 - Fascism, fake news and falsified history
41:47 - 50:47 - The ongoing suppression of the narrative of Kashmir
50:48 - 52:42 - Is the picture of India improving?
Join The Wire's UA-cam Membership and get exclusive content, member-only emojis, live interaction with The Wire's founders, editors and reporters and much more. Memberships to The Wire Crew start at Rs 89/month. / @thewirenews
Like our work? Click here to support The Wire: thewire.in/support
The founding premise of The Wire is this: if good journalism is to survive and thrive, it can only do so by being both editorially and financially independent. This means relying principally on contributions from readers and concerned citizens who have no interest other than to sustain a space for quality journalism. As a publication, The Wire will be firmly committed to the public interest and democratic values.
We publish in four different languages!
For English, visit www.thewire.in
for Hindi: thewirehindi.com/
for Urdu: thewireurdu.com
for Marathi: marathi.thewire.in
If you are a young writer or a creator, you can submit articles, essays, photos, poetry - anything that’s straight out of your imagination - to LiveWire, The Wire’s portal for the young, by the young. livewire.thewire.in/
You can also follow The Wire’s social media platforms and engage with us.
Facebook
/ thewire
/ thewirehindi
/ thewireurdu
/ thewiremarathi
Twitter
/ thewire_in
/ thewirehindi
/ thewireurdu
/ thewiremarathi
/ livewire
Instagram
/ thewirein
/ livewirein
Don’t forget to hit the subscribe button to never miss a video from The Wire!
Hello, the break-up of India actually happened in 1947.... "Intolerant" folks who didn't agree made their choice to no to be a part of our India. Live with my new India
Yes we need to be hardliner with kinds of roy
@@parthsarthi2667 oo😁😄💏😄😭😭🤼🐹😋💏🤼😄🤼😄😄💏🤼😁🐹💏😄💏😚🤼😚😄😋😄😚💏😁💏😚😄💏😄😚💏😄🤼😄😄🐹😁🚣😚💏😄😚😚🤼🐹😄💏😆👨👨👦🐹😄💏😄😚🤼😆😄🤼😆😄😄💏💏🤼😁🙄😄🐹💏😆💏😄💏😁😄💏😭💏😄😁🤼💏😆🐹😄💏😁😚🚣😅🤼😅😅😁🙄😅🧖😅🧖😅🧖🤼😅🧖🤼😆🙄🧖😅🚣🧖💏😅🤼😅💏🧖😅🧖🤼🤼💏🤼😆😘🙄😅😙😙😚🙄🙄😚💏😘🙄😅😙🥰🚶🥰🥰😀😘🚶🥰🐋🙄🥰🥰🙄🙄🥰🤼🚶⛹️😘🚶🥰🚶🥰🚶🥰🙄💏😆😄💏🚶💏🤼😄😚😙💏😄🚣🤼😄💏💏😄💏😄🤼💏😄💏😄🤼😆👨👨👦😁😄💏😄🤼😁😆😉🤬🧐🥺🚸🥰😛🐋😝😛😍🥰🐋🥰🚸🥰
@@parthsarthi2667?
@@parthsarthi2667?
Its very telling how you went from our india to my india
My grandmother used to tell me stories of mythical people with supernatural powers, Magical land and form an imaginary connection between two separate events in the past. Arundati Roy is that grandmother who has conspiracy theories for every thing. She is living in fairy land. But democracy allows her and everyone else to have and say their opinions. Only thing is she has a good following which believes whatever she says.
She is mad
@@nikhilkondapalli1430 yes early ecosystem where people are directly controlled by the system. today in information era they can't survive, thanks to internet, now every fact in on our palm. other wise they would have been brainwashed all of us.
@@nikhilkondapalli1430 I think she is funded to do so. If no then she would have spoken about humanity when ppl was massacred during emergency, TMCs killing of Bengalis or even Kashmir genocide
That's a good way of describing that you want to keep your eyes closed .....blame your grandma's stories for your present communal perspective...well done
She's a writer
No doubt her fictions are better
Who says Hinduism is non secular, we were more secular before the constitution was established, otherwise there would not have been do many muslims snd Christians in India .
She is wonderful women ❤️...
She is great thinker..
Not only is she one of the tallest intellectuals, she has such a beautiful and compassionate mind! Who else can otherwise write: 'To love and be loved. To never forget your own insignicance...To seek joy in the saddest places. To pursue beauty to its lair...To respect strength, never power...To never look away. And never, never to forget."
Her hatred for Hindus stems from the fact that her Bengali hindu father abandoned her keralite catholic mother. It forced her to go live with her mother in Kerala. I sympathize with her.
The fact that she can spew venom sitting in India illustrates India's tolerance. But my liberandos will disagree.
@@asheravi9328 Stop spamming over here and go to school.
#DumbAndDumber
@@asheravi9328 Islam itself is an ideology of hatreds. They even kill themselves by bombing , not even speaking about the infidels. Few days ago a Shia mosque was blown up in Pakistan this urban naxals are mute on these. Is RSS behind that too?
@@asheravi9328 Islam itself is an ideology of hatreds. They even kill themselves by bombing , not even speaking about the infidels. Few days ago a Shia mosque was blown up in Pakistan this urban naxals are mute on these. Is RSS behind that too?
One of the few Indians with a spine, and probably the rarest of the breed to have won praise of Kashmiris for standing up against grave injustices inflicted upon us by the establishment. May God give her utmost satisfaction and peace of mind.
If all people from every province starts thinking like you then you are in bigger trouble. Think Punjabi's/ Bihari's attacking and plundering you on a monthly basis ...ask me how
Good comment
@@luvkush123 they can attack only above vindyas ranges
Great interview.!!!
In this world of hate spread by the bjp and often threathened, India has got people like you who still has the guts to take on an upcoming dictator
The tragedy is that only a very few public of India is able to understand the differences between democracy and fascism. The difference between a industrialist and a businessman. Jai Hind.
only librandus like you. hmm?
Modi was democratically elected,.... failing to understand this basic truth raises questions about your cognitive ability
@@sagnikdebsarkar169 yet we choosed a mass murderer thats the harsh truth we are becoming like Nazis
Between islamic science and real science
@@sagnikdebsarkar169 While it is true that depending on interpretation, Modi could be seen as democratically elected, do not forget the numerous accusations of malpractices against BJP. This combined with their influence over social and mainstream media and their use of religion in politics (which in itself is a violation of the code of conduct) may present a picture which is uglier than you think.
"If you are an activist you can never be a journalist" - Late Shri Vinod Dua.
The Wire I think you can do better as a NGO than a media house .
Start with Freepublic and Doorknob Goswimming
@@EdilbertFernando India is already broken. WHy people forget 1947?
Why do we keep talking breaking India by Hindutva etc blabla??
@@whocares3132 Dude the people of what is today Pakistan and Bangladesh wanted a separate nation. Self-determination is a thing. We talk about Gandtuva because it follows the same pattern as the Muslim League ideology. Hate will never keep a society united and intact.
@@EdilbertFernando yeah right? Hindu, buddhists of Pak, Bangladesh was wanting seperate nation? Israel got a Jewish state run by Jewish law because they are secular? hahahaha your logic is pathetic. and recent pew research shows 78% of muslims want shariah law in India. Look this time im not just gonna roll over and get rap$d You are also on our list. Keep enjoying till the proper time comes. you really thing we will not take revenge of 1947? We want our land Thats land will be ONLY OURS
Sad, this lady needs to live in Afghanistan
Wow she's not at all diplomatic, very very Frank, Honest, truthful n fearless, I am just in awe of this intelligent woman,..
absolutely no mincing of words
well said.....she is, its my first time saw her interview, heard too much of her good work but sure she is...sad part our great india going down with only few gujratis .....even more sad is my wife is gujrati .....lol
@@samisiddiqui6803 You are right- 60 years up to 2014 we were in Golden era, no poverty, everyone has jobs,happy farmers no suicides, no Naxals no corruption, no scams, ( BOFORS, 2G/3G CWG , AUGUSTA helicopters were all lies), no black money,no communalism , Rahul and ANTONIA Maino (FAKE GANDHIS ) were paying their taxes, and we as Indian had very good reputation. BUT once Modi became PM we all lost job, people are dying because of food, infact everywhere is dark and doom and gloom and no hope etc etc..
@@samisiddiqui6803 Even Gandhiji was Gujaratti....so njoy!
@@samisiddiqui6803 lol! You should get a 2nd wife from West Bengal or Kerala.
@@samisiddiqui6803 There is good n bad in every aspect of life brother, ... I have Gujarati friends who are wonderful human beings / genuinely lovely people to be associated with... take care bhai 😍
Mrs Roy is a great lady having courage to speak truth boldly thnks
What a superb quote she mentioned "UP farmer said it perfectly - desh ko char log chalate hain, do bechte hain do khareedte hain charo Gujarat se hain" 😂 hahaha superb and bang on!
I am gujarati... Small business man in India and all over the world are also gujarati mam.... Is it bang on????
@@harshitdesai9631 Hi harshit, it is not about Gujarat or Gujaratis. It is infact indirectly hinting at the people who are buying and selling and ruling the country and hint is that they all four are from Gujarat. Waise. It is nothing to do with Gujarati people. Please don't take offense. I am from Bombay and I have grown up with Gujarati neighbours and colleagues. She is mentioning the place Gujarat as a hint to who those four people are.
@@nehaparkar some sources and how do you sell a country?
a country which thinks freebies as a real development, no wonder you think businessman are buying india, they have money so they are buying it otherwise people are just jealous of them
Learn about american billionaires, bill gates has bought majority lands in america, i don't see indians hating them instead we all know
Hypocrisy is an integral part of indians😂😂
@@shivam_nagar69 oh bhai..one means is means privatizing otherwise public sectors and the other is people of his preference for one person on the fore front (which will soon burst). Bahi why will anyone be jealous. If all are progressing and the country is progressing then why should anyone be jealous..but the point is that is not happening..the Rich are getting richer and poor are in a deep mess. Unemployment has been highest, crimes high, crimes against women high, social fabric ruptured at its highest..toh what progress are we talking about. Remove your rose colored glasses and see. Unless if you are an andh bhakt then all the best to you :)
@@harshitdesai9631 she is a commie from JNU what more can u expect from them?
Brave lady , talk fearless truth 👍
👍🙏
You are right- 60 years up to 2014 we were in Golden era, no poverty, everyone has jobs,happy farmers no suicides, no Naxals no corruption, no scams, ( BOFORS, 2G/3G CWG , AUGUSTA helicopters were all lies), no black money,no communalism , Rahul and ANTONIA Maino (FAKE GANDHIS ) were paying their taxes, and we as Indian had very good reputation. BUT once Modi became PM we all lost job, people are dying because of food, infact everywhere is dark and doom and gloom and no hope etc etc..
Your reply " brave lady" is so true ...as anyone who speaks out against this snooping government is slapped with UAPA. Speaking the truth should not be considered as being brave ,like in the west ,our constitution guarantees freedom of expression....but sadly what you said is true.
yes true
Karan Sir, please talk about Sikhs too. We aren't happy either the way they are trying to dilute Sikhism.
Canada chale ja wahan gand mara ...
@@observerdownunder3999 tumhe sab se taklif kya he. BJP ke for me Muslim, sikh, dalit Christian khus kuin nahi he. Answer me
@@observerdownunder3999 that's your profession . Good for u . 😭💯
After Muslims & Christians you will be next. If you guys don't throw out of power then we are doomed.
"To the Muslim 'ibi bene ibi patria' (Ubi panis ibi patria is a Latin expression meaning "Where there is bread, there is country") is unthinkable. Wherever there is the rule of Islam, there is his own country. In other words, Islam can never allow a true Muslim to adopt India as his motherland and regard a Hindu as his kith and kin. That is probably the reason why Maulana Mahomed Ali, a great Indian but a true Muslim, preferred to be buried in Jerusalem rather than in India.”
- Bhimrao Ramji Ambedkar on book 'Pakistan or the Partition of India'
the people who used to get royal treatments for their anti-national work are now feeling like this mada
This is the best of all interviews of Karan because only Aurndatti Roy cud answer clearly all questions that Karan asked in her own words rather than just agreeing to what Karan wanted her to say. Hats off to Aurn datti Roy for be so open n Frank in sharing her views. ❤👍👌👏👏
And what about the brutality of other religions on hindu. What about Brutally killed kashmiri pandits , Brutally killed and Brutal hindus conversion to Islam at the time of mughal invasions ??
Can you answer me?
When we have ppl living with us who went through brutality in last few decades but still these secular ppl deny saying nothing such happened then how will they believe the brutal conversions happened few centuries back.
Our history books in schools and colleges and in public libraries needs to be changed to truth. For example Kashmir was discovered by Mughals which we all know is a bull s...
This bit..h arundhati talks about Gujarat riots but she forgot why the riots took place firstly. She should speak about the train full of hindus being burnt.
Of course, she can't answer that. She has a one track mind which
is filled with hatred for Hindus lndia, and Modi
For the world kashmir might be disputed territory so citizens are responsible for that not leader but for india it is integral part of India.
Your second question made no sense, will you question Mughal now for killing hindus?? UN system work in democracy not king system. There was no force conversation please don't be victim of bjp propaganda.
Don’t expect truth or honesty from this treasonous ,poisonous, venemous snake who facilitated and enables terror agenda in india . She is the biggest Fascist totally indifferent to the Christian Islamic collaboration genocides atrocities injustices waged on Hindus . Yes the massacres and machinery in Gujarat was the Pakistan Islamic backed genocide of Hindus with the planned attack and arson on the sabarmati express murdering and burning 58 Hindu pilgrims mainly women and babies ( women threw their babies out of train to save them but Islamist mob pushed babies and children back into the burning bogey) peacefully returning from Ayodhya . This wicked witch 🧙♀️ is an instrument of the imperialist and Islamic supremacists with her twisted perversion of truth .
benefits of Karan thappar's interviews:
1. you get to bulid vocabulary ....( cocophony is todays word )
2. you get to know whats happening in country
3. you can learn how to be a very good journalist- he does so much homework before every interview
4. you can watch an interview where in the end you dont wanna bang your head and abuse someone
5. Questions are sharp and incisive
6. He can make you drink water sometimes ...so all his panelist are in someway or the other be always worried whats he gonna shoot next .
7. when karan thappar is trying to drill into your answer ...panalists know that they are in trouble
8. even countrys smart lawyers sometimes get dumb stuck
And Dosti bani rahe
@@stillunknown5785 hahaha I'm reading your comment in Modi voice 😂😂
You are right- 60 years up to 2014 we were in Golden era, no poverty, everyone has jobs,happy farmers no suicides, no Naxals no corruption, no scams, ( BOFORS, 2G/3G CWG , AUGUSTA helicopters were all lies), no black money,no communalism , Rahul and ANTONIA Maino (FAKE GANDHIS ) were paying their taxes, and we as Indian had very good reputation. BUT once Modi became PM we all lost job, people are dying because of food, infact everywhere is dark and doom and gloom and no hope etc etc..
It's cacophony
@@sjraniga jali re jali kali mata ki kali kali gaand jali yay 😁
First time I heard to Arundhati Roy. How elegant her voice is!!! I fall in love with her voice....exciting to know more her writings n achievements!!!
Facts and logic clearly took a back seat in this interview
Ikr 😂
That’s the only thing that was consistent in this masterpiece- logic , facts and brilliance by a great human - Ms Roy
Andhbhakt
@@cHinduCrusher the issue is you cant even argue with these asses . These guys are deeply brainwashed . You cant do anything but watch these people bark
@@cHinduCrusherando n$mozi
Sweetness of her voice catches you the firsthand then you come to the beautiful words and then the meaning… she’s enchanting!! 🙏🏻
Really, True
So true..🌹🌸
Please convert to islam
@@tirthankarmandal1410 Ok
@Drac UU Ha ha ha… because yourself is a snake 😝
Arundhati Roy is always forthright in her thought process, she is a beacon of hope and peace in the Difficult times we are passing through. She gives her views without hate and rancour, and gives the people of India a positive approach to follow to fight back against the fascist forces knocking on our society.
ARUNDHATI ROY YOU ROCK!!!!!!
"To the Muslim 'ibi bene ibi patria' (Ubi panis ibi patria is a Latin expression meaning "Where there is bread, there is country") is unthinkable. Wherever there is the rule of Islam, there is his own country. In other words, Islam can never allow a true Muslim to adopt India as his motherland and regard a Hindu as his kith and kin. That is probably the reason why Maulana Mahomed Ali, a great Indian but a true Muslim, preferred to be buried in Jerusalem rather than in India.”
- Bhimrao Ramji Ambedkar on book 'Pakistan or the Partition of India'
Tell me you are a communist without telling me you are a communist.
Tell me you're a isi-lamic t-err0-rist support without telling me you're isi-lamic t-err0-rist support.
Living in a country happily & work against that country.many in india doing this & living happily here.... Hats off to congress. Thd person who shared everything ( everything ) with terrorist of Kashmir is living happily in India.
She's bold and brave indeed. Not scared to put forward her thoughts on the current governance and administration of India .
Subcontinent didn’t learn from partition riots.I hope people of this region learn to live with harmony.
Pluralism is a blessing
❤️ 🇨🇦
Complete exchange of population is good solution
you can read all the violence in our religious texts. Think of the life under the kings and nawabs.
It’s a lot better than it used to be. Foreign fundamentalist religious ideologies have been trying to break India for 800 years now!
"To the Muslim 'ibi bene ibi patria' (Ubi panis ibi patria is a Latin expression meaning "Where there is bread, there is country") is unthinkable. Wherever there is the rule of Islam, there is his own country. In other words, Islam can never allow a true Muslim to adopt India as his motherland and regard a Hindu as his kith and kin. That is probably the reason why Maulana Mahomed Ali, a great Indian but a true Muslim, preferred to be buried in Jerusalem rather than in India.”
- Bhimrao Ramji Ambedkar on book 'Pakistan or the Partition of India'
Harmony kabhi bhi nhi thi. Sablog apne face pe mask lagaye the secularism ke name pe. Lekin itna fix hain ki ye country ab nhi tutne wali. Jinko pasand nhi hain rehna yha wo jayege apna boriya bistar utha kar, kyuki ye mitti hamari MAA hain lekin kuch logo ko bas ye geography dikhta hain. But haan is dharti ko MAA manne walo ka numbers jyada hain, isliye country to kabhi bhi nhi tutegi. Tutege log jinko is desh se pyar nhi hain aur mazboori me yha pe gujar basar kar rahe hain.
The guest author Arundhanti Roy is right. Things change. Some 10 years ago nobody imagined that people would praise Gandhi's killer unopposed. BVB, USA.
@Lou Smith , RUBBISH
@Lou Smith breed more violence and you'll live long enough to realize your phobia come to life.
You will not enjoy freedom as long as your mind is filled with hate. Freedom means a free mind and that is beautiful. I pity you that you are not enjoying it. By the way, there are 160 million Muslims in India who were all born in India. That is half the population of USA and no single Arab country has those many Muslims. They are not going nowhere. It is heartening that Indian Muslims have adopted peace as weapon.
You are right- 60 years up to 2014 we were in Golden era, no poverty, everyone has jobs,happy farmers no suicides, no Naxals no corruption, no scams, ( BOFORS, 2G/3G CWG , AUGUSTA helicopters were all lies), no black money,no communalism , Rahul and ANTONIA Maino (FAKE GANDHIS ) were paying their taxes, and we as Indian had very good reputation. BUT once Modi became PM we all lost job, people are dying because of food, infact everywhere is dark and doom and gloom and no hope etc etc..
@Lou Smith kya aap whatsapp graduate hai??
I truly admire you Arundhati🙌🙌 so brave 100% facts
If one really wants to break up India, all they need to do is to produce a few more Arundhati Roys. No country needs enemies if they have "wellwishers" like Arundhati Roy.
Thats because u hv no critical thinking and no individuality and can only exist as puppet!
🤣🤣🤣
India is fast tracking under modi towards break 💔 up..
Wire must arrange similar debates with CJI of SC OR HC by Mr Karan Thapar .
"To the Muslim 'ibi bene ibi patria' (Ubi panis ibi patria is a Latin expression meaning "Where there is bread, there is country") is unthinkable. Wherever there is the rule of Islam, there is his own country. In other words, Islam can never allow a true Muslim to adopt India as his motherland and regard a Hindu as his kith and kin. That is probably the reason why Maulana Mahomed Ali, a great Indian but a true Muslim, preferred to be buried in Jerusalem rather than in India.”
- Bhimrao Ramji Ambedkar on book 'Pakistan or the Partition of India'
Not possible?
"India is a best democracy that money can buy" brutally honest assessment.
Ravinder Banal. Very true but I would put India behind the USA.
USA , UK , CANADA are pretty far ahead .
In practice, these countries are more socialist than India
Arundhathi is blaming Adani and Ambani for taking financial support to bjp.Iam asking Arundhathi as in Kerala,how much she got from Jihadis
@@asharafikkapadath255 Arundhati gave examples of Ambani and Adani. Big money plays a big role in politics. You could be asked the same question how much were you paid by Ambani or Advani to pose such a question. It will at least be plausible because 'Jihadi' is a myth created by some unscrupulous Hindu Indians.
Best thing about karan that you always want to touch the sky, and sometimes it does, and sometimes he falls. Arundhati is not on his fray , she is one of the best, and the rest is the rest, lightning and sparkles her is actually too much to handle, she goes Hammer and tong despite giving deceptive apperances , one of the true revolutionaries, and I am a fan of both.
It is so fortunate to have a person like Arundhati who can speak out against Modi and his divisive politics.
Roy is ☝️ woman 👩 in Indian ✌️freedom fighter 👍👍
Thaper a ghiadi psycho a Roy his psycho partner
Mr.Karan Thapar, even though I like your incisive questions, please have the patience to listen to answers to the questions which YOU have asked, without interrupting !!
Karan wants non stop criticism of BJP...if the guest deviates from that agenda for 1 second, he loses patience. It's annoying.
Mr Thapar, the basis of your interviews are reaching to us and we are now profoundly vigil about each step the country takes.
Nothing in this world has emerged without a revolution and I urge every Indians to propagate soft revolts to eradicate the stained fabric of democracy and wash it from each corner so that the stains in the centre are visible.
Chal chal aave
Great that Arundhati called out Karan when she was speaking about caste, Karan was trying his best to navigate out of that subject and was quite successful.
She said it...a true bengali and malayalee blend, you can imagine ..
Majoritarianism: What happens if we allow the majoritarianism of BJP's HINDUTVA to continue now. Afraid we may land up like Yugoslavia which got split into 6 Republics, independent Nations.
The six constituent republics are Croatia, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Macedonia, Montenegro, Serbia and Slovenia.Yugoslavia disintegrated after a series of wars and conflicts (including genocide and ethnic cleansing of Bosnian Muslims) between 1991 and 2001, which led to the killing of nearly two lakh people.
A Croatian woman said the reason for this breakup. “There were many reasons. But the main reason was the majoritarian mindset of Serbians. We in Croatia were not allowed to keep our Croatian identity, sing Croatian songs, celebrate Croatian festivals, and so on. We were simply asked to follow what Serbia decided.”
She cannot speak a WORD of Bengali , hated Hindu Bengali's all her life BUT still a blend :-)
@@Bandhu241 she never said against hinduism.
She answered every question perfectly and loved the way Arundhati Roy said," it will end". Amazing 🙌❤️
"To the Muslim 'ibi bene ibi patria' (Ubi panis ibi patria is a Latin expression meaning "Where there is bread, there is country") is unthinkable. Wherever there is the rule of Islam, there is his own country. In other words, Islam can never allow a true Muslim to adopt India as his motherland and regard a Hindu as his kith and kin. That is probably the reason why Maulana Mahomed Ali, a great Indian but a true Muslim, preferred to be buried in Jerusalem rather than in India.”
- Bhimrao Ramji Ambedkar on book 'Pakistan or the Partition of India'
@kb go for it mate. Go get extreme
@kb lets better understand whats happening in india for last 25 years and see which side is getting extreme and which one needs to be studied and understood first. Good luck time will tell where we heading. Not a good place i can see it from afar
@kb key is to have justice and fair rule for everyone. India is fuckedd tbh too many issues, different races, cultures and casts and poverty. It's not 1942 and it's not Germany. You guys are opening a Pandora's box. Think about it where it is going to go.
As a Country and as an Indian. This dream of India where I grew can and will shatter with the amount of hate, toxicity and propaganda being spread and consumed at this time and age. Language, food and culture changes every 50 miles and even the way people dress. Thats the real India. Muslims and all other minorities have been a part of India and will always be a part of India. No matter where this goes
We are always with neutral and intellectual media and Karan Thapar.
Continue with your ignorance. This guy is neutral....joke of the century. Intellectual...hahaha
The wire is definitely not neutral. The wire is left- liberal Media.
Godra event never recalled but retaliation is explained irritating accent.
It would be nice for the audience if Karan does not interrupt the guest constantly & gives them the space to make their points
Salute to the most versatile Arundhati Roy Madam.
"To the Muslim 'ibi bene ibi patria' (Ubi panis ibi patria is a Latin expression meaning "Where there is bread, there is country") is unthinkable. Wherever there is the rule of Islam, there is his own country. In other words, Islam can never allow a true Muslim to adopt India as his motherland and regard a Hindu as his kith and kin. That is probably the reason why Maulana Mahomed Ali, a great Indian but a true Muslim, preferred to be buried in Jerusalem rather than in India.”
- Bhimrao Ramji Ambedkar on book 'Pakistan or the Partition of India'
Wow.. What an ending.. 🙂 Let's hope more and more Indians climb out of the delusional paradise.. And may God help us. Thank you Mr. Thapar for bringing Ms. Roy on your show.
What a Joke!
😂😂... What an ending? You still orgasming about some crap ? Babu, apne mathe ka level badhaiye...
I NEVER HAD A CHANCE BEFORE TO LISTEN N UNDERSTAND THIS VERY SOFT SPOKEN N INTELLECTUAL LADY MS. ROY ON MR. THAPPAR'S SHOW. AT TIMES, I DIDN'T LIKE MR. KARAN INTERRUPTING HER, WHEN SHE HAS NOT COMPLETED, WHAT SHE HAS TO SAY. WE NEED MORE INTELLECTUAL LADIES LIKE MS. ROY. JAI HIND. 👍🙏
@@hyd916 Mino, you seriously need to rethink your decisions in life of you consider Arundhati Roy as a "soft spoken intellectual"... Also, you name seems fake, like your thoughts....
@@patil_siddhant Yeah & whats next ban Gaumutra drinking.. These people....
for the past 2 decades i have been hearing the same thing from her
A great author and a true journalist building the nation in the real sense it needs wisdom to understand such discussions......
People like them are real Nationalists
In these very dark times,Roy is true inspiration because despite being aware of the crisis we are in,she is hopeful and also encourages us to be hopeful.
Thanks Karan for another wonderful interview.
She is very cunningly Avoiding the Genocide of Kashmiri Pundits where the pundit women ended up getting Brutally Raped and slaughtered. She is an extremely Dangerous woman who is hell bent on Dividing India. She has hidden her actual name of Susana Roy to cover her Christian identity
Anybody for whom Roy is hope, I guess she or he is a very hopeless person at the first place.
@@krishnanb.s.5581 Are Modi giving justice to Kashmiri Pandit?
What Modi did for Kashmiri Pandit?
@@pingwinoff5442 Punished those responsible for what happened to kashmiri pandits i.e. treating radicalization in kashmir valley .
Question still remains the same - why arundhati roy and her ilk ignores kashmiri pandit genocide as if it never happened ?
@@RahulSharma-xb4ob because Kashmiri pandit genocide never happened and it is a big lie.
2nd Gujrati genocide and after babri Masjid genocide and dozens of riots done by political and religious extremist.
I do not want to inhale the air where these two lived/living.
They stink
Fortunately they feel the same way about you, mostly because of the bad smell.
Same ...
I don't think no one cares about them now .....
You can't afford to even if you wish to. These people are successful enough to not use public transport and stand in queues.
She looks lost when Karan deep dives into a question. She has created a narrative in her head, hangs out with people who think alike and belive its a reality. Kudos to Karan though that he was less biased on this one and kept pushing her which exposed her.
A little too obsessed with Modi
I am an admirer of Karan Thapar, BUT I was disappointed that Mr. Thapar WOULD NOT let Arundhati Roy talk about the Hindu Caste system ! Many " low Caste " Hindus left Hinduism to follow BUDDHA when Buddha walked the Earth . YES , contrary to the LIES of ABHIJIT CHAVDA the Caste system of India ( which is based on the lightness / darkness of a person`s skin ) pre-dates the Buddha !! The Caste system WAS NOT started by the Briish like CHAVDA outrageously claims !!
Arundhati Roy---a lucid , articulate and compassionate intellectual who is brutally honest and patriotic--a great Indian ! I completely agree with her prediction that not only India is fast becoming a fascist state but India will be balkanized due to the stresses of hyper nationalism being placed on it by the BJP/RSS led government.
But it was bound to happen. That’s the whole point. If not bye bjp/rss than by some entity.
Arundhati Roy ---- a communist maoist urban naxal zombie, brutally honest about her intentions and a great anti India person ! Completely disagree with her prediction since she is an ultra pro anti hindu and anti India and a pro maoist who is trying to get muslims and Dalits on her side only to get her anti India objectives done and so she would never have a positive opinion about India specially when masses of India have ditched her ideology.
@@prashantp2029 Ahh yess, welcome to getting your ego hurt.
You should remember that honest politicians and media do not exist in this monetory world.
Arab countries have lot of money and they spread Islam and radicalization for tourism and weaponisation of religion.
As Quran itself is inhumane(watch exmuslim sahil for instance)
These countries gives money to fringe anti national like her in so that they can appease minority and serve their masters to the dawn of islamization in India.
RSS is fighting that force.
Therefore everyone gonna defame them.
But no one of this leftists like dhruv rathee and her talked about kishan bharwad(shooted)and many other on communal violence.
@@cool5122read what I said below
Correct 💯 m,am,, u r the inspiration for us to bring a change in modi ji '' reign,,. How long modi will frighten the common people,, people are disgusted with him,
Except wokes like you & people of books nobody else is frightened... Don't worry modi will back to power....these people are modern mir sadhiks of India...they have sold themselves to some masters..
@@dkmanju And you've sold yourself to Hindutva, no different than an IS recruit. You hate muslims, and all minorites, and its unfortunate because you may have been a good person. You unfortunately allowed Hindutva hate to become your master, instead of accepting true Hindu Civilizational values of Pluralism and accepting love to become a true Sanatani. Shame
We very passionately listen her , she is a great author and perhaps she is a Human Rights activist also.
Karan saab must understand that too much interruption ruins it all.
She's absolutely right. She can clearly see where india is headed but infact she hopes sanity will prevail. 🤞
You should remember that honest politicians and media do not exist in this monetory world.
Arab countries have lot of money and they spread Islam and radicalization for tourism and weaponisation of religion.
As Quran itself is inhumane(watch exmuslim sahil for instance)
These countries gives money to fringe anti national like her in so that they can appease minority and serve their masters to the dawn of islamization in India.
RSS is fighting that force.
Therefore everyone gonna defame them.
But no one of this leftists like dhruv rathee and her talked about kishan bharwad(shooted)and many other on communal violence.
"To the Muslim 'ibi bene ibi patria' (Ubi panis ibi patria is a Latin expression meaning "Where there is bread, there is country") is unthinkable. Wherever there is the rule of Islam, there is his own country. In other words, Islam can never allow a true Muslim to adopt India as his motherland and regard a Hindu as his kith and kin. That is probably the reason why Maulana Mahomed Ali, a great Indian but a true Muslim, preferred to be buried in Jerusalem rather than in India.”
- Bhimrao Ramji Ambedkar on book 'Pakistan or the Partition of India'
Thanks wire for this fantastic interview with arundati roy
"To the Muslim 'ibi bene ibi patria' (Ubi panis ibi patria is a Latin expression meaning "Where there is bread, there is country") is unthinkable. Wherever there is the rule of Islam, there is his own country. In other words, Islam can never allow a true Muslim to adopt India as his motherland and regard a Hindu as his kith and kin. That is probably the reason why Maulana Mahomed Ali, a great Indian but a true Muslim, preferred to be buried in Jerusalem rather than in India.”
- Bhimrao Ramji Ambedkar on book 'Pakistan or the Partition of India'
Leftist Propaganda at its best. Hypocrites
Hindu Nationalism will strengthen the country killing appeasement and governing with real secular manner. She recalls gujrath massacre which succeeded godra event. She prefer to forget Godra event. These media is responsible for trouble in country being selective in narrating.
And you seek support for your growth.
Very brave wire.👍🙏
When every media become cowards 😜😜😜
You will know the value of democracy and freedom only when you loose it .
She is a Mighty Think Tank who had the Guts to speak.. God bless you madam
she is destructive women for India, Just send her to Pak
She does not believe God she believes only mecca brigade
I am with you bro
I have always loved her opinionated interview. Loved the Way she said “ You promised you won’t interrupt “ to him.. yet he did.
"To the Muslim 'ibi bene ibi patria' (Ubi panis ibi patria is a Latin expression meaning "Where there is bread, there is country") is unthinkable. Wherever there is the rule of Islam, there is his own country. In other words, Islam can never allow a true Muslim to adopt India as his motherland and regard a Hindu as his kith and kin. That is probably the reason why Maulana Mahomed Ali, a great Indian but a true Muslim, preferred to be buried in Jerusalem rather than in India.”
- Bhimrao Ramji Ambedkar on book 'Pakistan or the Partition of India'
@Hearts N Eyes OpenWide Eyes OpenWide Let me deport you to Pakistan, then you will get the value of India when Muhammadans will treat you like that Lankan factory guy from Pakistan.
still Karan is one of finest.
@kb You said nothing different to what others have been saying for years. That is called extreme brahminical logic.
@kb You still don't understand. The anti muslim element make loader noise backed by their media and organisational structure.
You persecute them so much and when some of them retaliate you declare all of them terrorists. That is brahmanical logic. We think muslims in Inda are like a mountain between Brahmans and rest of us. You think one they are removed you can get to rest of us but be careful we are also ready and well organised.
You give me hope for my Muslim brothers and sisters in India. Greetings from South Africa
Lol
lol all muslims are pakistani and bangladeshis
Firstly take care about your 2 times meals. And Don't think beyond your c0untry's borders, Cuz it doesn't matter at all .
Likes of Arundhati Roy ( one who was seen with Yasin Malik and also supported disintegration of Kashmir ) will definitely find the current govt tyrannical as they removed Art. 370 only for the benefit of not only common people of Kashmir but Jammu and Laddakh as well.
I am an upper caste tyagi. But now I have realized BJP and RSS will take us to doom. they have no development agenda only hatred agenda and imaginary superpower nation.
I never thought I would say this but following Ambedkar and nehru can only save India and make it a superpower..
You're not alone bro, I'm an Upper caste, Brahmin (TIWARI) and I totally believe you. MODI led BJP government is probably the worst government we've ever witnessed. Congress-BJP are two sides of the same coin ( excluding the Fake hindutva part and the worst governance part of BJP which I think is even worse than Congress. Congress definitinely had better governance. I think the only alternative now is the AAM AADMI PARTY, because they do have lived up to their promises. Thoughts!? Anyone!?
How explain !!!! What is the vision
@@observerdownunder3999 couldn't understand this question.
@@observerdownunder3999 couldn't understand this question.
@@brishnevk4823 ok, I understand what you're trying to say. If you talk about right, and who gave me this superiority of caste, so the Hindu Community is divided in four castes Brahmin Kshatriya Vaishyas Shudras . I was born in a brahmin family, hence I'm a brahmin, but that doesn't mean that I hold any sort of sense of pride associated with it. No. Insaaniyat ka dharm aur jaati sab se badi hai. And I believe in Vasudev Kutumbakam like a true Hindu should.
Well put by Arundhati. She rightly flags even the army falling in Modi’s lap (without even a whimper).
Could u explain me how ?
@@chandrakanthveluri9860 watch the whole video
She explains clearly
@Vijay Manjrekar - Quite unnecessary and foolish.
@@chandrakanthveluri9860 Senior army officers today are today making political statements. Just 8 years back, they would’ve been packed for uttering even 5 words of the long, uncalled statements they are making today with total impunity.
Armed forces have very effectively been destroyed. And they lumped it.
@@AlokAsthana1954 Oh so u army officers should be mum coz it is the policy that was being maintained by the previous government. I don't think u have seen the interview of General Manekshaw. Kindly watch it and tell me if he was also wrong in opposing Indira Gandhi's orders in 1971.
A grand grand salute to Karan Thapar sir. You are a true journalist sir. You in English and Ravish Kumar in hindi
She never comented corruption of congresss, fammily ruling, never opposed of Mamata cruelty, never accused of Lalu family package of corruption, never opposed taliban demolishing ancient culture, never talked of minorities in pakistan getting down to 3% ftom 23% in 1947. BUT COULD SEE FACISM OF MODIJI. Wonderful.
Because they're talking about the current government, and if it was some other party in power they would critize them as well
"Kashmir is not integral part of India" who said this ?
Who ever said that could probably be right ?
Ask to kashmiris
Someone whose middle name is Suzanne....masquerading as hindu but secretly dreaming of queen Victoria to rule Hindustan 😃
@@royandrews4980 Few activist and few sickulars with TV shows and news articles can keep shouting from roof tops, few UN resolutions will not help them. Hindus are awaken after 70 years of sick rules of Congress, Muslims pleasing party's are trying to prove they are Hindus. Lets see how much 'Free' left will offer for vote. Its Indians who will decide. Some Pakistan mullah by name Roy may keep crying!!
@@raeesasultana3236 Sure, India requests Kashmiri Muslims to leave country of infidels India and go to citadel of Islam Pakistan. OR any 57 peace loving rich countries! Just get out!
The points of fascism she gave matches with only one party in India...TMC of West Bengal
It matches with brahmanism
Yes, the TMC and she can't see that because her thinking is warped
Absolutely
I have loved Arundhati for years, have often wept over her words. After watching this, if I could ask her one question I would ask her this. Why the hope? What, just what, made her believe with so much light in her eyes that the Indian people will save themselves? I feel like I need that answer now more than ever. We all do. So many young people do, more than ever.
"Any country that practices caste in the way we do is a brutal country"... So true, can't agree more. 😞
True bro but this women is the worst ... said such stupid stuff ....... saying stupid things against kashmir and india ...
You must be living in alternate communist propaganda world to form such opinion. Why not you first emulate your ideals in your life it self. Start applying for sanitation department and encourage your friends and family to marry or make oyo partners someone who cleans toilets of the nearest neighbourhood. Caste is communist creation.
Bengali Detected,Opinion Rejected.
@@rathoref2336 Do you have any research backed evidence that Caste is created by communists? By the way, I am not a communist.
@@pratyushsingh9507 nazi detected
After Indhira Gandhi, i could have seen the same glazing face with sharp eyes such a gorgeous 😍 n stunning personality.
How can you compare with Indira, this lady looks devilish.
Division of India in 1947 on the basis of religion is single most important factor for the present state of our country.Majority community will always be suspicious about the motive of minority community.The only solution is to give quality education to our children,teaching them to respect each other regardless of caste ,religion.We Indians should keep our religion at home when we come out of our houses .
Ban caste first. Love mother tongue not caste.
@@keralanaturelover196 What happened to Aborigines in Australia, Native Indians in America is the same as caste in India. Are the first two because of their religion? or the third because of Hinduism? Hinduism talks about Varna Profession. Caste is a social phenomenon.
Only solution, states going independent. Only question is when will this happen. Broken country and creaking infrastructure. Drives of indians migrating
The 2nd partition is coming. Either from the South or from the East...
India is a vast diverse nation.
Muslims are around 15% & Jews were only 2% in Hitler's era. RSS know this state and they always have had acted accordingly.
Ms Roy has a good point. She is more informed than those who we think as educated. Brave personality too.
She is nothing more than a doomsday predictor.
She made Hindus realised the need to be mindful of Hindus..
Tell her that, there is no uniform in legislative assembly but uniform in school
Every act to suppress muslims is justifiable whether through uniform or anything else
Caste name there
I salute you that you uttered that Kashmiries want freedom.
"To the Muslim 'ibi bene ibi patria' (Ubi panis ibi patria is a Latin expression meaning "Where there is bread, there is country") is unthinkable. Wherever there is the rule of Islam, there is his own country. In other words, Islam can never allow a true Muslim to adopt India as his motherland and regard a Hindu as his kith and kin. That is probably the reason why Maulana Mahomed Ali, a great Indian but a true Muslim, preferred to be buried in Jerusalem rather than in India.”
- Bhimrao Ramji Ambedkar on book 'Pakistan or the Partition of India'
"अधर्म कितना भी बलवान क्यूँ न हो अंततः उसकी मृत्यु धर्म के हाथों ही होती है" यही सत्य है और यही स्वासत है यही सनातन है, आदि के साथ अंत भी जन्म लेता है
Whatever she said makes so much sense now, we can see how people and different states have already started to break up, punjab people are demanding for a separate nation hood, people from south are breaking up on the basis of language and they don't want to be a part of this hindu nation theory ,it is a disastrous future we are moving ahead for and people are not understanding it, the idea of India as a hindu extremist nation is not gonna benefit anyone instead it's only gonna create barriers between the people of the nation
Lol khalistani were already asking their nation after 84 riots
That was a very comprehensive interview looking at the immediate future of India..so finally as Ms Roy said, the hope lies with us.. we citizens. Thks Mr Karan you have brought out something the Nation needs.
HAHA.
The more you bash Mr Modi, the more he becomes endearing to many!
Modi is liked by andbhakats and illiterate and businessman (big ones)
😂
15:07 - 16:12 , The most Anti Indian statement. The tolerance about Indians is still she is able to say that it in India .
She made up complete BS stuff there.
then why do we keep hearing about crimes and rapes against Dalits if Indians are tolerant, I think hindu rashtra can get rid of communal violence but bringing back the oppresive caste system and not allowing lower caste into schools and colleges will lead to a weak India
@@mathsociety8712 those rapists are idiots
stop blaming all
@@mathsociety8712 Crimes and rapes are against almost evrry community girls and which is a serious issue which needs special attention . Why crime against only dalits get attention? All rape case victims irrespective of their surnames needs justice . Its not that certain surname girls are made of steel and others of flesh .
@Truth always Arundhathi Roy is half Bengali Half Mallu brought up in Britidh style environment learning communist ideology which is the best combination for an anti Indian .
This show being aired and available for public is itself an indication that Indian democracy Is intact.
Ha ha ha 😂😁😀😁 👌Very true !!👍
😂😂😂 what a simplistic comment! The fact that Western technology enables Indian conversations when they should be on our on media is a pathetic testimony of the state of the country.
@@asifriyaaz9145If this was China, this couldn't have been viewed in the country. Nor would the interviewer remain breathing after this aired. That's what the comment indicates.
@@abhay_csDon't worry, considering the way things are going in india, you guys will get there soon as well.
Remember, india is trying to ban many websites, and already has banned movie and anime sites, and even tried to ban youtube a few years ago.
In hindu rashtra ,all obc hindu will be shudra and won't be allowed to become ias ips . 😭 That would be scary
Finally I found the voice! Love from Sikkim
Why do we keep putting such mad fake people on the pedestal. Completely mad. Thank you for the interview for letting us know what a Hinduphobic she is.
I don't why Upper Castes always sees themselves as the victim. Why upper castes Brahman Hindus are always afraid of the Truth. You fuckers were with Britishers when our great leaders were fighting for the freedom of this nation.
@@bikkeychhetri5722 do yourself and the world a favor and read Dr. Elst’s views on brahminism to know a thing or two about so called upper and lower castes. He’s not a Brahmin, he’s a Belgian historian, so you’d probably believe him more.
Not sure who is mad here, one who is giving sane advice or those adamant to listen anything. Don't you think Kashmir will bleed India to death. Class system will be the main ingredient India's demise. Why don't you fix it before blaming someone else for your failures. Why you need to introduce disgusting laws to suppress minorities. You all Indians should listen to Dr. Wayne Dyer who had very close relationship with Indian people and was a bit impressed but never converted to Hindu.
2:51:35 Life is not meaningful unless it is serving an end beyond itself, unless it is value to someone else. You will not find meaning through your ego. - Abraham Joshua Heschel (Book: Man Is Not Alone)
ua-cam.com/video/RIqVhwWmj5I/v-deo.html
@@bikkeychhetri5722 name any 10 freedom fighters....7/ 8 of them will be upper cast hindus..... get some education
She's a total crackpot, Hindu hater India hater, twisting facts to support her anti National views.
Karan Thapar is no better.
He shd be sacked, for having her on the channel and egging her on to speak her lies.
What a narrative! Only Smt. Arundhati Roy can explain what is happing in India in the name of majoritarian government of India.Thank you Smt. Arundhati Roy for being so clear thinking.
WTF😂
Mr. Karan Thapar, it would be appreciated if intellectuals, political scientists, and journalists were allotted a few extra minutes to articulate their points. You consistently mentioned 'deflecting,' cutting him short, but I believe he was presenting facts and not just substantiating but also providing perspective. As part of your audience, I believe that in discussions about important matters and during times like these, our focus should be on learning and conversing rather than engaging in debates and being rigid in our conventional approach to discussions
Your interview is very good, but Hindi speaking people do not know Karan Thapar and Arundhati Roy. It would be great if this interview is translated into Hindi.
Although I don't disagree with Ms. Roy, I as an Indian am really
Worried about what will happen in the near future. Arrogant leaders poor economy, unemployment, poverty etc etc.
Has destroyed this nation to a great extend.
@Vijay Manjrekar wow nice script .. !! Movie may act kon kar rah hai .. vivek Oberoi ya anupam kher .. produced by amabni and adani ..
Kuch sense k sath story likh lo be .. I mean seriously.. 5th std can come up with better story than this
@Vijay Manjrekar well anyone can write better than you..
If you had studied well, you wouldn't have to work for an IT cell .. 😉
In a world of blind people.. one eyed man was the God.. !!!
No worry, when you are thrown in the street you will realise ..
You get paid for this .. I don't
You people are beneath me and pure waste of time ..
After people dying left and right during covid ..people still for him .. should speak volume..
@Vijay Manjrekar well who raped dailt in unnao or in hatras .. or even asifa for that matter ..
I'm aganist violence of any sorts .. but for before asking me go ask bjp members, have any of them prisoned .. rather you took a support march .. shame on you ppl
The wire owner tweeted that south India should be cut off from India .
Just understand under which mindset this people are spreading propoganda.
BJP has enter karantaka, Pondicherry. In Andhra Pradesh BJP got big push in Municipal election.
This anti India gang is worried that TN and Kerala shouldn't unite with Hindu.
This is what their plan is which Rahul Gandhi was emphazing in the parliment.
This bullshit portal are advertising agency which promotes congress divide and rule policy in India
They will never report any story from Rajasthan or Punjab
They will only focus on UP
@@anantraj3247 Thapar must be arrested for running anti India propaganda
The realistic Arundhati&Karan interview
You are right- 60 years up to 2014 we were in Golden era, no poverty, everyone has jobs,happy farmers no suicides, no Naxals no corruption, no scams, ( BOFORS, 2G/3G CWG , AUGUSTA helicopters were all lies), no black money,no communalism , Rahul and ANTONIA Maino (FAKE GANDHIS ) were paying their taxes, and we as Indian had very good reputation. BUT once Modi became PM we all lost job, people are dying because of food, infact everywhere is dark and doom and gloom and no hope etc etc..
@@sjraniga We had, between 1998-2004 , seen party presidents , ministers accepting bribe on camera ,attack on Indian parliament y terrorists , visiting president of a neighbouring country insult Indians on India's soil , agricultural distress . if that regime had continued there would have been a civil war as seen in Gujarat in2002 . Besides , IPCL, Ashoka Hotels, BALCO, Hindustan ZInc , Centaur Hotels were gifted at a throw away price to cronies . The only difference isat that time there were many cronies and today only two or three
If Kerala has everything why are more than half the malayalees living outside Kerala ?!
Every billionaire across the world became rich. It's interview like these that makes me vote for MODI!
He will be back again in 2024
That’s why saffron fanatics like you are called andh bakts.
If a stupid statement by some academic and you vote Modi solely on that then it shows you are not capable of critical thinking.
@@jackhoward5822 First learn how to write English then only come here to get insulted 😅
@@abhishekkumarrathore let me finish his sentence.
If a stupid statement by some academic scholar is enough to make you vote for modi then it really shows your critical thinking skills
@@nebresser9440 I am as upset as you are my friend. I don't like Modi anymore. But it's also annoying when people just cribb about everything.
Unity in diversity is what made India possible. People today are much more educated emotionally discerning to fall prey to divisive politics played around by all players. It's the compassion which has made India what it is.
There was never any unity among the masses. The unity of religions that you are talking about is a minority phenomenon. Most people from different religions don't want interference from others and want to live individually in peace. They just mind their own business
@@AnkitKumar-sn8hqyes I agree more with your comment.
What a legendary interview it was from Roy. I saw that long time back, i have seen again and how true it was her views. People fought back and bring back the democracy constitution to rule this country again.
Wow! Great respect to both! People like you give hope to democracy in India.
Funny people
Agar democracy khatam hoti to ab Tak to arundhati ki gardan kat ke usi ke bhai ke haath me padi hoti
Salute her forthrightness, courage, love for India. Never give up hope
She is a joke.
@@prashantp2029 obviously 😂😂
Salute to your understanding 😂😂😂
No courage to question radicals on one particular side
She denied the Bangladesh genocide 1971....
Half knowledge is dangerous. Arundhati is perfect example
Chaddi comment.
@@muhammedimran7186 At least reply to the correct person.
that's the reason she won 1st booker prize for india. Wake up sangi wake up. Fill something other than gober
@@muhammedimran7186 She is a communist bigot, she has been crying sice 1990s (liberalisation privatisation) these communist bastards don't understand that capitalism is the only way forward even China(A communist country) choose capitalism. She sided with nexals and even with jihadis like bitta karate (Murderer of Kashmiri hindus).
Booker praise winners are not economists or geniuses they have a narrative and they write that narrative that's all they are not gods.
Even though I don't like Modi, I hate communists, they are termites who stoped the country to capture the manufacturing race where China is the first mover now China captured max Manufacturing sector.
Modi bhakth...grow up
First time that I see her in an interview..endorses the fact that she lacks grey matter .. she needs to live in UP to see the difference between the past and present
Apne itna achha interview liya
Aur poora english me.
Agar mai ise apne friends ko forward karna chahu to wo dekhenge hi nahi.
90%to unke upar se nikal jayegi.
To kya fayda is interview ka.
.
.
.
Ha muze kafi nayi lines aur jaankari mili, un bhakto ko sunane ke liye.
Lekin meri baat kahne me aur aap logo ki baat kahne me jameen asmaan ka antar hai.
I really want my india to listen this interview.
But.. its wasim akram bouncer.
Please sir, try to use either simpler english or hindi, so that i can forwards it to my friends.
Thank you🙏🙏🙏
Karan seems to be trying a bit too hard to contradict her on many points, even though he would perfectly agree to most points she is making,
I think he was calmly picking holes in her logic. I may agree with the guests sentiments, but she did not explain herself well in this interview and he naturally gravitated to the lacunae in her thinking..
That is investigative journalism.
India getting disintegrated by religious chaos may be the ultimate interest of US politicians and of the Chinese. Therefore large amount of US moneys are liberally donated to the RSS subsidiaries working in various names in the US. Nobody know as to how such enormous moneys are transferred to India and used to suppress other religions and create a political and social Hindu majority.
@@9443141690 Can you cite a source to support your stance? I would really like to read about what you're saying
@@9443141690 RSS activists in UK and US are big donors but as far as I have been told some rival groups have compiled a register of key RSS activists, there will be something interstings to see.
She is brutally honestly courages n speak the truth "Hats off to Arundhati Roy” just nailed it… 👏👏
Hindu Nationalism is a response to the business model of Islam and Christianity. India will remain beautiful and diverse even without Islam and Christianity. The rise of Islam and Christianity can only be at the cost of Dharma and vice-versa.
Why did Afghanistan & Iran became 100% Islamic? After all there was no caste system in Buddhism and the relgion followed by Zoroastrians? The fact these self claimed liberals ignore the islamic concept of "Saza and Jaza" for mass conversion into Islam prooves what they are upto.
@@avinashmishra7735 Hinduism is another name for caste oppression & a vertical hierarchy based on birth . If you remove caste there is no Hinduism. In fact ,the name itself was given by a British judge and that is the originality . Until the British gave the name Hindu people would claim their respective castes as their religion -Dwaita religion, Adwaita religion etc . Even Geeta & Vishnu Sahasranama uphold casteism and extoll it
@@sivaramanmudaliar9728 Varna System is never birth based. By the way ask Pasmanda Muslims what are Ashraf-Ajlaf-Arzal. I as a Hindu want to eradicate Caste System, but that would be considered a threat for the mission tactics of Islam and Christianity.
Hindu Unity is a threat to rice bag converts
@@avinashmishra7735 Then instead of feeling threatened of by Islamic and Christian missions pl give Hindus of all communities the right to study the Hindu scriptures as well as become priests to serve in the Temples. Everybody have equal rights for the quest of Truth and knowledge of God through the scripture knowledge which Hinduism can never accept and promote. The political and power structures of contemporary India has taken in its rein exactly this. Instead of finding the dust in another faith, it would be wise for Hinduism to take its plank of casteism it so gravely holds on to.
@@judybhaskaran5721 , nobody is stopping to learn anything in Hinduism.
Aaj tak mein BJP ka Bhakt tha.
Lekin Adani matter, BBC issue, Notebandi court decision aur EC ka galat Shivsena faisla...iske baad Modi sabke nazar me gir gaye.
Na bro I support BJP
Karan needs to stop interrupting. I can see how most Indians if not many will hate the truth of Arundhati - she is great and what you call an outstanding Indian
Hats off to KT for asking the question about ethnic cleansing call to every single guest of him..
The wire owner tweeted that south India should be cut off from India .
Just understand under which mindset this people are spreading propoganda.
BJP has enter karantaka, Pondicherry. In Andhra Pradesh BJP got big push in Municipal election.
This anti India gang is worried that TN and Kerala shouldn't unite with Hindu.
This is what their plan is which Rahul Gandhi was emphazing in the parliment.
This bullshit portal are advertising agency which promotes congress divide and rule policy in India
They will never report any story from Rajasthan or Punjab
They will only focus on UP
Majoritarianism: What happens if we allow the majoritarianism of BJP's HINDUTVA to continue now. Afraid we may land up like Yugoslavia which got split into 6 Republics, independent Nations.
The six constituent republics are Croatia, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Macedonia, Montenegro, Serbia and Slovenia.Yugoslavia disintegrated after a series of wars and conflicts (including genocide and ethnic cleansing of Bosnian Muslims) between 1991 and 2001, which led to the killing of nearly two lakh people.
A Croatian woman said the reason for this breakup. “There were many reasons. But the main reason was the majoritarian mindset of Serbians. We in Croatia were not allowed to keep our Croatian identity, sing Croatian songs, celebrate Croatian festivals, and so on. We were simply asked to follow what Serbia decided.”
@@manchikantimurty7375 Well said
@@manchikantimurty7375 if leftist will live in india then it will happen
Ms. liberandu, urban naxal, tukde-tukde, anti-national, ghaddar. Thank You.