Hoi4 What if EVERYONE did Nothing Wrong in WW2

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 12 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 306

  • @kaey6105
    @kaey6105 18 днів тому +670

    all I want for christmas is peace,peace! A little piece of Poland, A little piece of France, A little piece of Portugal, And Austria perchance, A little slice of Turkey, And all that that entails, Und then a piece of England, Scotland, Ireland, and Wales

    • @pejj300gamer2
      @pejj300gamer2 18 днів тому +18

      Why would anyone want whales haha

    • @Fenneken141
      @Fenneken141 18 днів тому

      @@pejj300gamer2 lovely chaps and hospitality

    • @Anders_Lund
      @Anders_Lund 18 днів тому

      Ja, all the Führer wants is a little Austria; ja, he was a little greedy and took all. Next, a little Sudetenland, and followed by a slice of Danzig and...oh Stalin wants some Poland for himself? That is fine, he can have it in exchange for some dessert later. Now, to top it up with some Elsaß-Lothringen

    • @wuxiagamescentral
      @wuxiagamescentral 18 днів тому +10

      I can't believe the only one who sang that in my head

    • @sumedhmayekar6580
      @sumedhmayekar6580 18 днів тому

      ​@@wuxiagamescentralI literally sang it

  • @Hirpeeda
    @Hirpeeda 18 днів тому +111

    stak: this time everything will be finee
    stak: *turns off historical AI*
    hoi4: five hundred civil wars

  • @spirosgreek1171
    @spirosgreek1171 18 днів тому +316

    Stakuyi: Peaceful democratic Christmas special
    Hoi4: ... and then I started blasting

  • @novustempestus3389
    @novustempestus3389 18 днів тому +188

    In the most peaceful world, the balkans and the middle east explode into conflict.
    "it's like poetry. It rhymes."

  • @pieceofschmidtgamer
    @pieceofschmidtgamer 18 днів тому +47

    Stak: I'm just trying to have a peaceful HoI4 game!
    HoI4: And I took that personally.

  • @Nerathul1
    @Nerathul1 18 днів тому +163

    What we've learned: Somehow the Mustache Man and the Duche were the stabilizing factor in the world

    • @doraemon61377
      @doraemon61377 12 днів тому

      They were, in real life. They were against the communist threat in the East. Too bad the West had to start war with Hitler. Hitler wanted to invade the East. He had no interest in French territory.

  • @Thesenateexe
    @Thesenateexe 18 днів тому +65

    I love how it start with "Let's all live in a peacefull world." to "F*ck it ! Peace was never an option."

  • @maxthetube8466
    @maxthetube8466 18 днів тому +37

    It’s funny how by making everybody democratic, the world was even more chaotic, like a time traveler messing up the future even harder

  • @MrLabowski
    @MrLabowski 18 днів тому +262

    What if Steiner’s attack was carried and successful?

    • @556_mt
      @556_mt 18 днів тому +5

      Yes please !!!

    • @Detr0niX
      @Detr0niX 18 днів тому +4

      Yes!!

    • @Josephgoebblez
      @Josephgoebblez 18 днів тому +19

      Soviets would get pushed back from Berlin, reorganize and conquer It few days later than OTL
      If somehow Steiner and his Soldiers had unlimited Luck and superpowers at the Point of inflicting a decisive defeat,Western allies would Take berlim

    • @nathanplays5514
      @nathanplays5514 18 днів тому +10

      @@Josephgoebblezthe allies still wouldn’t have taken Berlin, the soviets and the allies had an agreement to let the reds take Berlin, the only way the allies would’ve actually decided to enter the city is if Steiner was god and pushed the soviets back to Moscow or smth.

    • @Ponziani_Guy
      @Ponziani_Guy 18 днів тому +2

      ​@Josephgoebblez you heard this form the man him self💀💀💀

  • @nonverbalpie8151
    @nonverbalpie8151 18 днів тому +112

    What if the US joined the Central Powers?
    Also Merry Christmas to Stakuyi, his family and everyone else watching this video.

  • @ApplesGhost
    @ApplesGhost 18 днів тому +16

    Japan has issues fighting civil wars because the combat AI doesn't know how to deal with the way their islands are set up. They often just totally abandon certain fronts and then have to reinforce them, making it hard for them to push anywhere. It's essentially a four-front war with serious supply issues on every single front that constantly opens up its new fronts by pushing even a little.

  • @WindHaze10
    @WindHaze10 18 днів тому +46

    Everyone did nothing wrong? I guess US torpedoes will finally work now.

  • @JahJah-CleverHandle
    @JahJah-CleverHandle 18 днів тому +28

    What if Stakuyi played EaW again?
    Jokes aside, Merry Christmas to all of you!

    • @Anders_Lund
      @Anders_Lund 18 днів тому +4

      That is no joke. More EaW videos

  • @OTucanChannel
    @OTucanChannel 18 днів тому +8

    Merry Christmas Stak! I hope you and y'all here in the comment section have an great time and can enjoy the festive last week of 2024. For the next year be a better year for everyone!
    ~ OTucan, Bavaria
    Also, I love the way your calm voice sounds in these christmas videos

  • @fallenknighttyler8695
    @fallenknighttyler8695 18 днів тому +55

    Merry Christmas!
    What if the Afghan Monarchy was restored after the U.S. invasion (or after the Soviets left)?

  • @daniellovestortoises3044
    @daniellovestortoises3044 18 днів тому +16

    What if the Soviets under Malenkov were just as Interventionist during the Cold War
    Merry Christmas Stak I wish your family a Merry Christmas

  •  16 днів тому +1

    "I want peace in the world."
    Well, there will be eternal peace after everyone is dead from the 56 civil wars.

  • @hydronpowers9014
    @hydronpowers9014 18 днів тому +31

    What if Germany has bigger ovens...
    For Pizzas
    Merry Christmas

    • @Gnowimaster
      @Gnowimaster 18 днів тому +1

      Then we would have bigger ovens... and I would eat more pizza... sounds like a happy end for me :3

    • @robertlombardo8437
      @robertlombardo8437 18 днів тому +2

      Better ingredients. Better pizza. Papa Johann's.

  • @henriquemachado9941
    @henriquemachado9941 18 днів тому +12

    What if the Soviets were, y'know... Prepared? Could they have stood their ground well against Germany?

  • @polishscribe674
    @polishscribe674 18 днів тому +6

    Staykui forgot one thing, and it's called "Greater Greece"

  • @taraldomland8657
    @taraldomland8657 18 днів тому +1

    Truly loved your message in the start of the video. I feel we all have lost our way and forgotten how awesome peace and the potential life that’s all about love is

  • @alexkudzin4980
    @alexkudzin4980 18 днів тому +6

    What if at the start of the Siberian intervention the Japanese find either Alexieve, installing him as a puppet ruler, or one of his sisters whom is then married into the royal family, to give them enough legitimacy to remain in Siberia?

    • @aaronreynolds1717
      @aaronreynolds1717 17 днів тому

      Or what if monarchy returns to Russia after the collapse of the USSR

  • @MandalorV7
    @MandalorV7 18 днів тому +3

    As a wise king once said: “Death!”

  • @dominicanemperor28
    @dominicanemperor28 18 днів тому +7

    Ok, What if Germany sides with the allies in WW1? (I don’t care if it’s unrealistic, I just want to know what happens)

  • @rando9363
    @rando9363 18 днів тому +5

    What if the Christmas truce ended WW1

  • @TheCoLDKanadian
    @TheCoLDKanadian 18 днів тому +2

    Merry Christmas and dear lord this was probably one of the crazier videos you've made in recent times.

  • @EscapismFanatic9231
    @EscapismFanatic9231 18 днів тому +6

    merry christmas, stakuyi!
    what if the carlists won the spanish civil war?

  • @vahlen5281
    @vahlen5281 18 днів тому +1

    A small tipp: If you don't take the decision to set up your headquarter in Chita, it will be randomly assigned; possibly putting you much closer to all the VP in the western part of the SU.

  • @Norbert_Sattler
    @Norbert_Sattler 18 днів тому +3

    Well, looks like Belgium did once again Resist and Bite. ^^

    • @anisvadjian5142
      @anisvadjian5142 18 днів тому +1

      And then the Sabaton Fans arrived, coming down the mountainside…

  • @alexanderalex577
    @alexanderalex577 18 днів тому +1

    Merry Christmas, Stakuyi!

  • @cubert13
    @cubert13 14 днів тому

    Stakuyi: *Tries to make a peaceful world.*
    The world: *Immediately descends into multiple wars.*

  • @bigcat359
    @bigcat359 12 днів тому +1

    what if the franco british union formed after the great war?
    Plus great work on thw videos and happy new year!

  • @ErikZehms
    @ErikZehms 4 дні тому +1

    What if turkey was not neutral in ww2, and joined the axis?

  • @corruptg5914
    @corruptg5914 18 днів тому

    Merry Christmas Stakuyi! Unironically you're content has always been a joy man, hopefully your resting well with your family now.

  • @Prestiged_peck
    @Prestiged_peck 18 днів тому

    Stak, thank you for being there for all of us through what for some of us was one of our worst years ever, myself included. I know things are looking up for me now, I hope that is the case or soon to be the case for many of the rest of us. Merry Christmas and a happy new year to you, Stak, and every single one of you, my fellow viewers, and a toast to a better future in 2024, whatever that may mean for you.

  • @panachevitz
    @panachevitz 18 днів тому +1

    When you mentioned that we would be spreading democracy, I did give you the Super Earth salute.

  • @OttoIncognito
    @OttoIncognito 17 днів тому

    Very relatable Christmas video. Drunken relatives starting family drama everywhere

  • @stangerdeath9555
    @stangerdeath9555 11 днів тому

    Germany: doesn't start WW2
    UK: fine ill do it myself

  • @andresdominguez4914
    @andresdominguez4914 18 днів тому +3

    (Video 35) What if the United Arab Republic was a success? (Egypt/Cold War mod)

  • @marckerns22
    @marckerns22 18 днів тому +2

    10:40 none of this would have happened if historical AI was enabled

  • @GermanWehrmacht
    @GermanWehrmacht 18 днів тому

    Thank you for this content. No peaceful Christmas, but I certainly hope you had a peaceful Merry Christmas!

  • @mr.lizard464
    @mr.lizard464 18 днів тому +3

    What if Ireland fought in world war II on the side of Germany?

    • @masterjj6613
      @masterjj6613 18 днів тому

      Ireland technical didn’t exist in ww2 bc the uk controlled it as a puppet

  • @Oscar92839
    @Oscar92839 18 днів тому +3

    6:16 yeah Franz Ferdinand and Franz joseph

  • @adambenes647
    @adambenes647 18 днів тому

    Merry christmas Stakuyi, Love Watching your content

  • @kaltaron1284
    @kaltaron1284 18 днів тому +2

    What if Japan managed to solve their conflict with the USA diplomatically and established an idealistic Greater East Asia Co-Prosperity Sphere?

  • @jimtalbott9535
    @jimtalbott9535 18 днів тому

    The world in 1936 in this TL: (entire regions, almost at one, stops all productivity, and engaged in civil war).
    Spain: “First time?”

  • @LanternOfLiberty
    @LanternOfLiberty 14 днів тому

    🎶Do they know it's Christmas time at aaaallll?!"🎶
    😂😂😂😂😂😂

  • @marademedici
    @marademedici 14 днів тому

    Austria fighting Switzerland, truly a Christmas special

  • @braize6279
    @braize6279 18 днів тому

    "Let's make everyone a Democracy!"
    *entire world immediately goes to war

  • @alexhuynh1066
    @alexhuynh1066 18 днів тому

    Merry Christmas History Buffs!!!

  • @aksuper4969
    @aksuper4969 18 днів тому +4

    Feliz navidad 🎄🎁

  • @yubiee_
    @yubiee_ 8 днів тому

    kinda just found ur channel, love it already, hope your new years and christmas was awesome. hope ur family had a awesome holidays!

  • @lucabuchwald9744
    @lucabuchwald9744 18 днів тому +2

    The fact that you say that going democratic is the way to do nothing wrong is hilarious.
    Edit: Stalin has more in common with Santa than any other people.

  • @masterofgreymog5751
    @masterofgreymog5751 17 днів тому

    This is one of the funniest HOI4 videos I've seen in ages

  • @josephdragunov374
    @josephdragunov374 18 днів тому

    This proves that true peace could have been achieved if you simply went to war with the True Heir of the Empire.

  • @Xariama
    @Xariama 18 днів тому

    Those weren't bombs, they were giant Christmas lights!

  • @Vodka2051
    @Vodka2051 18 днів тому

    This has been the greatest X-mas gift! :D

  • @ernestohurtado6358
    @ernestohurtado6358 18 днів тому

    Feliz Navidad Stakuyi 🎉❤

  • @dolcethesmorse1890
    @dolcethesmorse1890 6 днів тому

    OH MY GOD YOU DO HOI4! I only know you from Insta shorts content so I'm syked to watch a bunch of your Hoi4 videos now [:

  • @bamacopeland4372
    @bamacopeland4372 11 днів тому

    This just proves a point that no matter how peaceful people say they want it Peace will never come. There's always going to be one thing that some people want more than other and will fight for it

  • @RyanChristianDude
    @RyanChristianDude 18 днів тому

    Merry Christmas Stak

  • @Striiiider
    @Striiiider 18 днів тому

    not too sure how well it could be done in hoi4 (maybe one of the WW1 mods has it) but id love to see something from you about the green corn rebellion. merry christmas king

  • @foxalpha09
    @foxalpha09 3 дні тому

    Gotta love paradox games. The AI loves to pull funnies.

  • @FredFish99
    @FredFish99 17 днів тому +1

    Video 71 of asking you to play Comoros millennium dawn.
    Also I hope you had a very merry Christmas 🎄

  • @andreasmuller4666
    @andreasmuller4666 17 днів тому

    Premise "nobody does anything wrong", reality, "everyone fucks up" even harder.

  • @unreal771
    @unreal771 18 днів тому +1

    What if the Northern Germany confederation lost the Franco-Prussian War and was never unified?

  • @tweetert.9978
    @tweetert.9978 18 днів тому

    Merry Christmas Stakuyi.

  • @Dradolan
    @Dradolan 18 днів тому

    I would have thought that Right Opposition would have been the peaceful path.

  • @rubenwittingen7048
    @rubenwittingen7048 11 днів тому

    maybe a bit late but potential fun idea for alt history in the no mistake category: what if Troelstra didn't make a mistake?
    I don't even know if it would be possible in HoI4 (his mistake was in 1918) but it might be fun to explore
    also Happy New Year

  • @AlexiNico-nj5oo
    @AlexiNico-nj5oo 14 днів тому

    Trots are essentially just spicy socdem to be fair

  • @davidjensen1221
    @davidjensen1221 18 днів тому

    St. Nicholas is the Patron Saint of Greece. He might have been born in Anatolia, but he lived in the Greek parts of the Roman Empire.

  • @misterangel8486
    @misterangel8486 17 днів тому

    Stakuyi looking at the "peaceful" map...
    *WHAT HAVE I DONE!?!* 😱😱😫😵‍💫😵‍💫🤣🤣🤣🤣

  • @Guy28428
    @Guy28428 16 днів тому

    Merry Christmas and a happy new year

  • @Notexactlydat
    @Notexactlydat 18 днів тому +1

    YESSIRR ANOTHER ONE OF THIS!

  • @faelirra
    @faelirra 18 днів тому

    Nono Stakuyi, you see St Nicholas was Greek in Turkey, it was a rescue operation that got out of hand.

  • @Iron_Blood_Enjoyer1933
    @Iron_Blood_Enjoyer1933 18 днів тому +20

    Attempt 20: (Using the Great War Redux again) What if Italy honored the Triple Alliance and eventually joined the Central Powers when WWI comes around?

  • @jammonkey6249
    @jammonkey6249 День тому

    I was legit expecting pure peace lol

  • @Azriel1124
    @Azriel1124 18 днів тому

    Merry Christmas Stakuyi

  • @TheEpictrooper
    @TheEpictrooper 11 днів тому

    Should have done the Kaiserredux mod and played as Santa Clause. He emerges via an event if you turn it on in the game settings. XD

  • @bepikz-s2n
    @bepikz-s2n 18 днів тому

    Missed opportunity to do Christmas truce

  • @1221shadowdragon
    @1221shadowdragon 18 днів тому

    And here's to another year my good man

  • @davidyellope6078
    @davidyellope6078 18 днів тому

    what if everyone did a crazy alternate path to break stakuyi's mind while playing as the USA.

  • @YugoslavForever
    @YugoslavForever 18 днів тому

    another Stakuyi classic

  • @Jugglet
    @Jugglet 14 днів тому

    I think a good video idea would be restoring a greek empire and retaking constantinople, just ideas throwing out there

  • @WilliamMcleod-q2o
    @WilliamMcleod-q2o 10 днів тому

    It would be interesting to see in hoi4 if china beat japan and turned its focus westward

  • @TheSacredRight
    @TheSacredRight 18 днів тому +3

    Good ending?

  • @AdErOlEl
    @AdErOlEl 18 днів тому +1

    What if the german blitz in through the ardeans failed

  • @allenyork3239
    @allenyork3239 18 днів тому

    What if the Emperor of mankind took control of a random country to conquer the world.

  • @IchBinEnte
    @IchBinEnte 18 днів тому

    I hope you had a great charismas stakuyi

  • @playstationakcurate8292
    @playstationakcurate8292 17 днів тому

    You're going to have to go to Stellaris for 2025.

  • @robertlombardo8437
    @robertlombardo8437 18 днів тому

    Sequel video: What role would a restored Byzantine Empire play in the second world war?

    • @Anders_Lund
      @Anders_Lund 18 днів тому

      I guess it would depend on when the Eastern Roman Empire was restored. Yeah, I am not using that other name

  • @Bruh71734
    @Bruh71734 10 днів тому

    I got hoi4 as a christmas present this year

  • @onurkneezb
    @onurkneezb 18 днів тому +1

    War is inevitable...

  • @hklassehutten1476
    @hklassehutten1476 3 дні тому

    Rimmy would be proud

  • @kristofevarsson6903
    @kristofevarsson6903 18 днів тому

    Might have been made already, but what if war was declared immediately upon Remilitarizing the Rhineland?

  • @surrealsadi841
    @surrealsadi841 18 днів тому

    Merr Chrismas! and that was a very spicy game!

  • @Corn_Bread7274
    @Corn_Bread7274 9 днів тому

    you couldve done the trosksty path and do the "bring democracy back to the party" focus

  • @09piklerik
    @09piklerik 18 днів тому

    im guessing greece did the conference that leads to a war with turkey causing all the chaos

  • @foregonerocket7077
    @foregonerocket7077 18 днів тому

    The fallout mod for hoi4 has santa in it

  • @SageCinnamon772
    @SageCinnamon772 18 днів тому +2

    No St. Nicolas is from Greece