Star Trek: Romulan Star Empire

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 14 лип 2016
  • A brief history of the Romulan Star Empire from their days as exiles to their rise as a superpower and the devastation that followed the Dominion War. Based in the Universe of Star Trek, created by Gene Roddenberry.
    Resistance is Futile! So support Civilization Ex with a Monthly Pledge of your choice at:
    / civilizationex
    **Please be aware, this video series is based on Common Canon, that is to say, all Star Trek TV Shows and Films. Books, games and comics will generally not be used, though some minor crossover will occur from time to time.
    EX: The Preservers and the Progenitors have not officially been designated as the same species, however it was left open to interpretation in the Shows and famed Star Trek writer Ron Moore has hinted that they are indeed the same. Further confirmation came in the Star Trek Online video game which finally linked the two and made it clear they are the same. While Star Trek Online is not Common Canon, it, along with the other available evidence, is enough, in my opinion, to state them as the same species.
    It is important to note that many Star Trek fans differ greatly on what is and is not Canon, as well as how to handle the many contradictions that have arisen over the years. Civilization Ex will do its best to remain faithful to Common Canon, however these videos will only ever reflect an interpretation of Star Trek lore, and not official Canon in any way.**
    Music By RFGB: / @rossbugden
    "Parallel"
    • ♩♫ Epic and Emotional ...
    Follow us / civilizationex
    Visit our Site: www.civilizationex.com/
    If you would like to show your support, please Donate! :)
    www.paypal.com/cgi-bin/webscr...
  • Розваги

КОМЕНТАРІ • 498

  • @linkheroofhyrule9364
    @linkheroofhyrule9364 6 років тому +164

    I feel like I'm in a history lecture class in the Federation Academy.

  • @andrewclary4496
    @andrewclary4496 8 років тому +417

    Deep Space Nine rarely gets the credit it deserves for telling a layered, nuanced political story in the space opera format. It was character-driven, carefully plotted, and probably the best overall written Star Trek. It deserved a movie. It deserves a movie.

    • @michaelmcghee6594
      @michaelmcghee6594 8 років тому +6

      +Gary Dorgan I agree that it was lacking in the exploration which died but wasn't really noticed because it was so weak from the start. however in the grand scheme of things trek it is a pivotal point in which much of the politics etc of the trek verse got a really big fleshing out I'd wager without it videos like this wouldn't be worth the effort making as the back story would be so weak behind the main races

    • @AeneasGemini
      @AeneasGemini 7 років тому

      technically way of the warrior was a tv movie, but I get what you mean, still though it's done and any more would diminish it

    • @zoppie
      @zoppie 7 років тому +4

      I enjoyed DS9 very much. It was a welcome change of pace from all the space ship based Treks. But it had time enough to tell its story to the very end, and did. Any revisiting now would be anticlimactic and would also damage sales of the post TV series novels.
      In fact, any new 24th century based shows would be set in a no win universe, where androids, holograms, and other devices are being declared sentient and demanding equality, if not superiority over biological beings. Add to that the fact that the Borg have assimilated much of the galaxy and will continue until all beings are either Borg or destroyed. It makes any stories set during that era futile at best.
      The timeline does need a reboot. But JJ Trek and Discovery are not the way to do it. But that's the way the owner's of the franchise have chosen, in addition to shutting down any fan efforts that show the right way, leading to Trek's death as both a cult phenomenon and a cultural icon.
      The ONLY path now is for creative fans to create a new shared universe devoid of Trek trappings, but guided by Trek philosophies.

    • @markdavidson1049
      @markdavidson1049 7 років тому +7

      Gary, that is a very narrow-minded view. Considering all the various races and corresponding issues, Star Trek can't ONLY be about "trekking and exploration". There are far too many races/factions out there with their own agenda for it to ONLY be about trekking and exploration. DS9 shown light and detail that many Trek fans craved for whether it was more detailed politics, larger combat scenes and combat info, intricacies of various intel agencies like the Obsidian Order to more details about the histories of Klingon houses or the Romulan-Federation relationship. Contrary to what you think, had DS9 never existed, it would've done Star Trek lore a DIS-service.

    • @Zuriki09
      @Zuriki09 7 років тому +1

      There is little hope of a shared fan timeline, the nearest equivalent would be the C0DA of The Elder Scrolls. The result of which is an official timeline which is directionless and homogenized and a fan-timeline which likes to declare itself as cannon but is both directionless and also utterly asinine taking - if you know TES, it's a game series set in a medieval fantasy, well C0DA currently has space-faring elves living on a mechanical planet.
      C0DA is a warning that no cobbled together fannon will ever be well structured enough to functionally replace the official cannon(s) and no matter how bad the official cannon appears to be, it's several steps better than an overall fannon.
      The best you could hope for is a singular fannon architect to gain some sort of cult following, but it is unlikely to ever gain any real traction.

  • @Holypikemanz
    @Holypikemanz 8 років тому +177

    "Something bad was gonna happen but then the Enterprise...." lol.

    • @katakisLives
      @katakisLives 7 років тому +15

      And usually the Enterprise is barely spaceworthy when its forced into service!

  • @PureLimbic
    @PureLimbic 7 років тому +81

    I've always wish the Romulans were a bit more fleshed out. Also wish Trek would explore more of the non-humanoid races. Seeing the Tholians return in Enterprise was kinda nice.

    • @andysahs1599
      @andysahs1599 3 роки тому +1

      The Gorn too as well not much about them after TOS.

  • @TheModernMartialArtist
    @TheModernMartialArtist 7 років тому +102

    Just now realized the Romulans were based on the Romans. Derp.

    • @SunnyIntervalsORG
      @SunnyIntervalsORG 3 роки тому +9

      Does that mean the Vulcans are based on the ancient Greeks?

    • @RandomYT05_01
      @RandomYT05_01 3 роки тому +2

      I knew that when I binged TOS.

    • @ortherner
      @ortherner 3 роки тому +3

      duh lol

    • @cameronfielder4955
      @cameronfielder4955 3 роки тому +6

      Romulus and Remus didn’t give it away?

    • @KlaussMarcellus
      @KlaussMarcellus 2 роки тому

      This and the ''divide et impera'' espionage, and the slavery ofc

  • @connorohlander6683
    @connorohlander6683 4 роки тому +9

    Romulans are my favorite Star Trek race

  • @emilenarud3203
    @emilenarud3203 7 років тому +36

    Romulans were so cool and Sela was a great character, sucks Romulus got destroyed in the new movies.

    • @ATeaDaze
      @ATeaDaze 7 років тому +15

      The movies have nearly ruined the Romulans as an interesting and morally ambiguous antagonist. First, they introduced the stupid Reman retcon in Nemesis and then they blew up the entire planet in the reboot.

    • @tonywhite9873
      @tonywhite9873 6 років тому +6

      You should check out STO the did a Romulan storyline after Romulus and Remus blow up.

    • @LumTheAlien
      @LumTheAlien 6 років тому +14

      Could not agree more, Nemesis and J.J Abrams really messed with the Romulans.

    • @jonaswille4485
      @jonaswille4485 2 роки тому

      Kinda Agree with the nemesis part but not because of the story line, more because of how they did it..
      The Stoy is actually very fitting, Romulan old guard military Commanders disagreeing with the new pro Federation sentiments in the senate fearing the romulan star empire to loose its place among the super powers trying to overthrow the goverment?
      Sounds as romulan as it gets
      And the destruction of Romolus is giving us a nice possibility to have a view in the Romulan culture, more then just seing a warbird commander but actually learning about how they think, rituals and stuff and if you continue with the very interesting but unfortunatly non Canaon books you get a super interesting story line, where the newly formed Romulan Republic supported and recognized by the federation and its allies is struggling in a fight for power agains the old self proclaimed empress Sela witch is stillt having major influence duo to most romuland not trusting an Republic (wich is kinda semi democratic) leading to the brink of a civil war (and I think it continues, just didnt read the next book, know back on the list)
      Just realized I wrote all of that to an 4 year old comment, lol

  • @nickolasschieber239
    @nickolasschieber239 7 років тому +36

    The reboot series needs more politics and meaningful messages. Next generation left you with something to consider about, the battles to enjoy, and the politics!

    • @aloneinthedark99
      @aloneinthedark99 4 роки тому +2

      My sweet summer child

    • @q31544
      @q31544 2 роки тому +1

      @@aloneinthedark99 I wish I could return to that blissful ignorance and hope

    • @jamie2487
      @jamie2487 4 місяці тому

      There are few comments that have aged as poorly as this one

  • @Fenris77
    @Fenris77 Рік тому +2

    0:55 "Romulus" and "Remus" That allways gets me...

  • @Peizxcv
    @Peizxcv 7 років тому +38

    The destruction of Romus in the new Star Trek movie makes no sense. We have seen it many time that Romulan have some of the best scientist and engineers as they often surprise the Federation with devious technologies. It is hard to imagine the Romulan wouldn't notice their sun is going supernova and have no time to evacuate.

    • @nickolasschieber239
      @nickolasschieber239 7 років тому +1

      I see your point

    • @flatheadgg2443
      @flatheadgg2443 7 років тому +10

      Nickolas Schieber everyone sees it except JJ

    • @TheNinjaMarmot
      @TheNinjaMarmot 7 років тому +3

      Peichen01 Exactly. That was stupid. They should have enough ships and time to evacuate before leaving to chance.

    • @mikegallant811
      @mikegallant811 7 років тому

      It wasn't the Romulan system's home star that supernovaed it was that of the nearby Hobus System.caused by A protomatter device used by Taris and Colonel Hakeev.

    • @Peizxcv
      @Peizxcv 7 років тому +1

      Mike Gallant I don't know if Star Trek Online is canon or not.

  • @TriAngulumStudiosAudioComics
    @TriAngulumStudiosAudioComics 6 років тому +21

    Also the NX-01 was not the USS Enterprise, merely The Enterprise!

    • @MKDumas1981
      @MKDumas1981 6 років тому +3

      TriAngulum Studios Audio Comics Not even "the" _Enterprise_ . Just _Enterprise_ .

    • @TheCharlesJackson
      @TheCharlesJackson 2 роки тому

      Fancy seeing you here 😎

  • @TOFKAS01
    @TOFKAS01 7 років тому +7

    The illogic in that story: The vulcans were capable to build FTL-ships thousands of years ago. And in an amount to transport thousands of individuals. And 2000 years later they were still sitting on vulcan without beeing totaly technical superior to others.

    • @boooster101
      @boooster101 7 років тому +4

      TOFKAS01 if you lock up 99% of your creativity behind a metric ton of mental barriers and fanatic conservatism...
      progress is probably looked down upon

    • @jackjersawitz3937
      @jackjersawitz3937 4 роки тому

      @@boooster101 cringe

  • @Queensage77
    @Queensage77 8 років тому +1

    OMG so cool. I love how you incorporated everything!!

  • @marksherwood2947
    @marksherwood2947 2 роки тому +4

    The war between Earth and Romulus was fought with impulse powered craft. Negotiations to end hostilities was conducted over sub space, way before Archers Enterprise. Watch Balance of Terror, where Kirk and the Bridge Crew are astounded and surprised at the first visual of a Romulan and the ensuing animosity from one member of said crew towards Spock

  • @g.b.1224
    @g.b.1224 7 років тому +5

    Awesome series, looking forward to videos about the Dominion.

  • @misterbeans3590
    @misterbeans3590 3 роки тому +2

    I love the romulands so much, these dark elves are very interesting

  • @drowjack
    @drowjack 8 років тому +19

    Would make a video about the Cardassians??

  • @barcased
    @barcased 6 років тому +7

    "A brief history of the Roman Empire from their days as exiles to their rise as a superpower."
    FTFY

  • @iplaygws
    @iplaygws 8 років тому +1

    I never saw this video coming! Awesome work!

  • @pythiasibyls6269
    @pythiasibyls6269 7 років тому +1

    This is an amazing vid! Keep up the good work!

  • @jgiledw
    @jgiledw 7 років тому +14

    Commander Riker will always be my favorite character from Star Trek

    • @darthjimmi1481
      @darthjimmi1481 5 років тому

      i like him, but i find he's really quite a dick to everyone outside of the bridge staff, even himself (or Thomas, rather).
      The only friendly interactions he has throughout the series is with the bridge staff (a.k.a main cast)

    • @aspeltaofkush3540
      @aspeltaofkush3540 4 роки тому +1

      Mine is Worf

    • @davincerica7232
      @davincerica7232 4 роки тому +2

      Mine is Q, Data, Picard, Spock

  • @daric_
    @daric_ 8 років тому +2

    Love your vids! Keep em up!

  • @ejungleska
    @ejungleska 8 років тому +8

    I read one theory that Romulus was the actual original homeworld of the Vulcans/Romulans; 1) Romulus looks more hospitable compared to the desert-like world of Vulcan. 2) You have one side that is more pacifist while the other is more war-like. Which side is more likely to have been able to force the other off a planet?

    • @tonywhite9873
      @tonywhite9873 6 років тому

      I read a book on the History of Vulcan, Vulcan started out has a jungle like planet with a more richer oxygen. Then there was a major accident their moon, it blew up, some of it fell to Vulcan. Most lifeforms died out fast, some died slowly. Vulcans live by had to adapt to their new home. A desert-like world, Vulcans became fearful of the outsider, the unknown. They weren't the pacifist they later become, they were more war-like than the Romulans who learned to control themselve.

    • @tonywhite9873
      @tonywhite9873 6 років тому

      memory-alpha.wikia.com/wiki/Vulcan_history#Ancient_history

    • @richterman3962
      @richterman3962 6 років тому +1

      It was stated in tos that they fled Vulcan because they didn't want to. Follow the teachings of Surak,

    • @Raja1938
      @Raja1938 6 років тому +1

      Not in TOS, but in the novel "The Romulan Way". Surak's philosophy eventually prevailed on Vulcan, leaving a dissident group led by S'task to leave the planet on an exodus to the stars. S'task was essentially the first Romulan.

    • @squidman22
      @squidman22 6 років тому

      Thought Vulcan was like that because it was all nuked out and turned into a wasteland.

  • @mikegallant811
    @mikegallant811 6 років тому +8

    The Kelvin Timeline exists in an alternate universe anyway, the prime universe is unaffected by the Kelvin timeline.

  • @Brando64
    @Brando64 8 років тому +2

    Gods! you just keep getting better and better, I'm gonna try and help you get through your long to do list.

  • @Lardon2
    @Lardon2 7 років тому +1

    Very interesting vid about the Romulan Empire! ;)

  • @CaptainCafe
    @CaptainCafe 5 років тому +2

    These are just so fantastic.
    It's crazy to think 1 race was able to become so many great forces in the alpha and beta quadrant.

  • @VerbenaComfrey
    @VerbenaComfrey 5 місяців тому

    the fact that being asked about equality his immediate thought is "BUT Where WILL IT END? How MUCH DO WE HAVE TO GIVE YOU TO GET YOU TO SHUT UP AND DO WHAT WE TELL YOU?" instead of even considering what equality is is SO TELLING

  • @Raja1938
    @Raja1938 6 років тому +3

    No mention of the Mintakans (TNG "Who Watches the Watchers")? I like to think they descended from some lost landing party of the Romulans or the Debrune, which would explain their similar forehead ridges.

  • @Leroyteam
    @Leroyteam 8 років тому

    Great video!

  • @troy9477
    @troy9477 7 років тому

    Nice summary. Clears things up somewhat

  • @TraciPeteyforlife
    @TraciPeteyforlife Рік тому

    The Romulans just always pulling crazy power moves.

  • @trekkienzl2862
    @trekkienzl2862 8 років тому +7

    Pls do a video about the:
    * Dominion - Star Trek
    * Cardassian Union/Empire - Star Trek
    * First Order - Star Wars

  • @louisiananlord17
    @louisiananlord17 7 років тому +1

    I wish they would do an episode or write a story on the Debrune in Trek. Flipping great video.

    • @Raja1938
      @Raja1938 6 років тому

      Looks like they did, at least in novels. memory-beta.wikia.com/wiki/Debrune

  • @danielshottopics8187
    @danielshottopics8187 7 років тому

    This is all very fascinating.

  • @vt31008
    @vt31008 8 років тому

    Great video

  • @lokycat79
    @lokycat79 7 років тому

    amazing!!!
    I love it!

  • @Zardas11
    @Zardas11 8 років тому +18

    More Star Trek pls

    • @possessed258
      @possessed258 8 років тому +1

      Omg yes please

    • @blacktallsmart1914
      @blacktallsmart1914 8 років тому +2

      Yeah. I love game of thrones, but your Star Trek playlist is very lacking

  • @garba88
    @garba88 8 років тому

    Great videos! With the new series Star Trek Discovery I hope to see more videos dedicated to Star Trek :)

  • @balderdasq8987
    @balderdasq8987 3 роки тому +1

    1:31 Ah yes, “highly encouraged”. I suppose that’s one way of putting it.

  • @VIV292
    @VIV292 7 років тому +13

    Romulans where based upon the Roman Empire > hence the the senate and proconsul praetors

    • @Patrick-wy4op
      @Patrick-wy4op 6 років тому

      GuyOfTheUniverse and reem is the second planet or his brother

    • @FuckGoogle2
      @FuckGoogle2 6 років тому

      No shit Sherlock, Remus & Romulus the mythical founders of Rome, shit writing honestly.

    • @richterman3962
      @richterman3962 6 років тому

      And they share a star system with the Remans saying something

    • @franciscomm7675
      @franciscomm7675 5 років тому

      and the romans also thought their people were superior to all others.

  • @Kaptnkrnch
    @Kaptnkrnch 7 років тому +2

    I enjoyed the trilogy by Sherman and Shwartz "Vulcan's Soul" wherein the Remans were actually genetically modified Vulcans left there to be the slave labor.

  • @GoodVideos4
    @GoodVideos4 7 років тому

    I liked many of the Romulan outfits, especially that large grey top.

  • @deamonnedula9568
    @deamonnedula9568 8 років тому +12

    i love the romulans

    • @warriorgaming1604
      @warriorgaming1604 6 років тому

      question how many romulans does it take to change a light bulb

    • @darthjimmi1481
      @darthjimmi1481 5 років тому

      @@warriorgaming1604 wow, a whole year and nobody took you up on that joke...

    • @warriorgaming1604
      @warriorgaming1604 5 років тому

      @@darthjimmi1481 every star trek fan knows that joke

  • @zulioner7880
    @zulioner7880 6 років тому

    very nice m8 u deserve a sub

  • @jasonbean7296
    @jasonbean7296 7 років тому

    well done.

  • @gothicshark
    @gothicshark 3 роки тому +1

    According to canon, the Remen was never established as a separate species from the Vulcan/Romulans. In fact, they gave several clues that Remen might be the result of Romulan genetic experimentations on their own people, as they display several Vulcan features, including green blood.

  • @kimberly6663
    @kimberly6663 7 років тому +14

    I hope they'll somehow have Romulans in the upcoming series. Always loved when they showed up in an episode. Tomalak was my favorite
    Ever thought of doing a video on the Soong family?

  • @RomLoneWolf23
    @RomLoneWolf23 8 років тому +18

    Any chance of you doing historical notes from Star Trek Online?

    • @QuatroDoesGaming
      @QuatroDoesGaming 8 років тому +5

      I'm not sure if STO is cannon

    • @CivilizationEx
      @CivilizationEx  8 років тому +1

      Not likely no :(

    • @Cythil
      @Cythil 8 років тому +6

      Honestly canon has always been very iffy with Star Trek. So it up to you as a fan if you want to see it as canon or not I guess. I like STO so I see it as canon. Which also mean that the JJ trek stuff is a separate time line (Called the Kelvin timeline in STO)

    • @Zeakthecat
      @Zeakthecat 8 років тому

      most fans of the shows and movies don't like the games because they think its not canon and only based off of the views the fans made. star trek online has a canon history and has mentioned janeway, picard, and kirk on many occasions. it has also mentioned the new timeline but only making it sound like rumors or sperate events, which in my opinion is a good thing. ive liked the shows and the movies but im not biased on shit on star trek, since i am also a player of sto myself and a avid gamer and anime casual. i don't understand why the STO part, since it extends into the 25th century, isn't considered to be canon by most trek fans. maybe it needs to have a show to be considered canon?

    • @Zeakthecat
      @Zeakthecat 7 років тому

      Yu Yu Neko Daisuke you are a disgrace to anime fans/otakus everywhere. get off the internet before someone dox's you and sends someone to beat your ass.....

  • @Estigmax
    @Estigmax 7 років тому

    very good :D

  • @xxSeanVxx
    @xxSeanVxx 8 років тому

    Awesome

  • @keonwestpsychology
    @keonwestpsychology 8 років тому +2

    Brilliant stuff!! Would you be able to do one about the Soong-type androids?

  • @aspeltaofkush3540
    @aspeltaofkush3540 4 роки тому +2

    I’d like to know more about the Raptor Faction of Vulcans.

  • @Zeithri
    @Zeithri 7 років тому +3

    And in STO, the Romulans are now a fractured shell of their former selves.

    • @warriorgaming1604
      @warriorgaming1604 6 років тому

      except the talsiar lead by tasha yar bitch daughter Sela is a major pain in the ass tash was captured on the Enterprise C forced into harem had a daughter tasha attempted rebel was" killed" but a investigation/ rescue mission late in the game proves the father lied tasha died on a prison planet with rest of survivors at last encounter she request you come to the prison cell she is in you give her the hologram of tasha she asks to be told about her mother although i wish i could put her on a shuttle craft and launch a high yield quantum torpedo spread at it

  • @dirkthewrench
    @dirkthewrench 3 роки тому +1

    According to Q, the 100 war between the Vulcans and Romulans was started by Q.
    As stated to captain Janeway by Q in the Startrek Voyager episode deathwish

  • @lexluthor3125
    @lexluthor3125 7 років тому +2

    Could you do a video about the Ferengi?

  • @Shawn-pk8qc
    @Shawn-pk8qc 8 років тому +21

    Is the Dominion war covered in Deep Space 9?

    • @CivilizationEx
      @CivilizationEx  8 років тому +17

      Yes it makes up the last 3 or 4 seasons.

    • @Shawn-pk8qc
      @Shawn-pk8qc 8 років тому +2

      +CivilizationEx awesome, thanks

    • @smcneal057
      @smcneal057 8 років тому +5

      Anyone who loves Star Trek agrees that DS9 is the best Star Trek series to date. Mainly because of the Dominion War. I suggest you watch it if you have Netflix.

    • @kermit8897
      @kermit8897 8 років тому +5

      you need to watch the dominion stuff on ds9. it's great. the character arcs of Sisco and Gul Dukat are fantastic.

    • @Max_Pilgrim
      @Max_Pilgrim 8 років тому +1

      Voyager has always been my favourite.. Such a good series

  • @templerman1
    @templerman1 6 років тому

    Interesting and informative. I am curious about the art you employed. The drawing of Vulcan with ice caps and oceans (seas) was great. Especially, having the southern ice cap appears to be feeding that Southern sea. It's similar to the subsurface melt sea under the Southern pole of Saturn's moon Enceladus. Do you by any chance have a place on the web where I could see a larger version of the drawing? I have always wondered what the ecology of Vulcan would be like. I remember a novel written back in the 80's or 90's. I can not recall the author, or the title, but it described early Vulcan's prior to a star flair that did terrible damage in a burn over. It may have been "STRANGERS FROM THE SKY",
    and I think it was written by the same author. I hope you do more such video's. Great work, and best of luck in your future endeavours. Please, contact me by email if you do.

  • @possessed258
    @possessed258 8 років тому +4

    DO MORE STAR TREK VIDEOS PLEASEEEEE!!!

  • @terrencehineshines242
    @terrencehineshines242 Рік тому

    Wow your models look great

  • @Rabbiddog333
    @Rabbiddog333 7 років тому +6

    'Ree-man' not 'REmun'

  • @shadowtango
    @shadowtango 8 років тому

    Love it good job are who now going to do the Cardassasions

  • @Gwingfield
    @Gwingfield Рік тому

    Why do I find Star Trek mildly boring but these videos as the coolest thing ever 😅

  • @D.M.S.
    @D.M.S. 8 років тому +4

    Will there be a history of the Dominion episode?

    • @MKDumas1981
      @MKDumas1981 6 років тому +1

      D.M.S. I don't know that there was enough information onscreen. In one episode, Weyoun says The Dominion has been around for 2,000 years; in another, he says 10,000. The female changeling says that they're timeless, so, it can't be established when they came into existence. In "Treachery, Faith, and the Great River", Weyoun tells the story of the Vorta, but, I don't think he says when (correct me if I'm wrong).

  • @MetallF
    @MetallF 7 років тому +8

    Uh, this video stops at 5:57, wonder why...

    • @mikapoful
      @mikapoful 4 роки тому

      no it does not

    • @buffalojoe78
      @buffalojoe78 3 роки тому

      mikapoful you’ll have to forgive him. He seems like one of those guys who doesn’t like the Kelvin Alternate Timeline

  • @rayden120
    @rayden120 5 років тому

    So the remens are not all related in some way to romulans or vulcans thought kinda look like them in a way?

  • @RBweb24
    @RBweb24 8 років тому

    Where did the romulan head rigges from TNG come from? Any explanation for that in universe?

    • @Raja1938
      @Raja1938 6 років тому

      The apparent distinction between Vulcans and Romulans may be just a natural variation among individuals in both populations. Pronounced brows may just be more prevalent among Romulans than Vulcans. The proof? Before The Next Generation, the Romulans we saw on screen had no brow ridges (the lower ranked centurions wore helmets that obscured their foreheads--maybe they had ridges!). According to the producers, they wanted a different look for Romulans when TNG started. However, even after TNG’s fourth season, there’s the example of Romulan ambassador Nanclus from the movie “The Undiscovered Country” who very clearly had no ridges. Also, Spock was able to travel about in public on Romulus without prosthetics and without attracting any apparent attention (other than from Romulan intelligence).
      So then are there any Vulcans with brow ridges? In TNG “Gambit”, there was the Vulcan revolutionary T’Paal who was acting undercover as a Romulan but there’s nothing in the episode to indicate that her brow ridges weren’t natural. Also, if you look back at the original series episode “Amok Time”, Spock’s wedding party had helmets that, like the Romulan centurions of the same era, covered their foreheads (maybe some were Vulcans with brow ridges!)

  • @brooklyn560
    @brooklyn560 7 років тому +4

    I'm surprised that there is no Federation video

    • @darwinxavier3516
      @darwinxavier3516 7 років тому

      It would be way too long since they're the stars of the show.

  • @Makeyourselfbig
    @Makeyourselfbig 7 років тому +7

    What would the federation do without the crews of the various USS Enterprises who always appear to on hand to save the day?

    • @user-kj2fj8qr9l
      @user-kj2fj8qr9l 7 років тому +3

      If I recall correctly, the title Enterprise is given to Starfleet's Flagship, hence it caries the most acclaimed crew.

    • @darwinxavier3516
      @darwinxavier3516 7 років тому +1

      And gets sent on the most ridiculous bullshit problems to solve.

    • @tonywhite9873
      @tonywhite9873 6 років тому

      Fedareration would of existed without Archer and the Romulans who tried to stop it's birth.

    • @leroybrown9143
      @leroybrown9143 6 років тому

      Darwin Xavier so you don't realize this is all fiction huh? Be a real cool Sci fi show if it would only limit itself to science fact.

  • @DarthDracquos
    @DarthDracquos 8 років тому +11

    There is more.............Romulan Republic, Iconanians, Empress Sela

    • @tusalakthesandwichking132
      @tusalakthesandwichking132 8 років тому

      Isn't Romulan Republic and the Iconanians versus Romulan republic just part of STO ?

    • @DarthDracquos
      @DarthDracquos 8 років тому +3

      im not really sure, they've never really said anything about it. seeing as how there is no show that picks up after TNG, i would think all STO content should count.
      Adds more to the Star Trek story

    • @tusalakthesandwichking132
      @tusalakthesandwichking132 8 років тому +3

      From what i got from the wiki. Star trek online is a part of expanded universe. But I hope too that it is part of the cannon.

    • @DarthDracquos
      @DarthDracquos 8 років тому

      T0R10US CZ its like star wars all over again

    • @tusalakthesandwichking132
      @tusalakthesandwichking132 8 років тому +1

      Yes. It is

  • @madmonkee6757
    @madmonkee6757 6 років тому +1

    Romulus never fell, and it never can.

  • @albinhakansson1086
    @albinhakansson1086 8 років тому +3

    The Romulan Empire is basically the Roman Empire

    • @oso2400
      @oso2400 8 років тому +4

      I don't know what could have given you that insane idea...

    • @portewan4684
      @portewan4684 8 років тому +1

      do they even attempt to explain this in the shows?

    • @blacktallsmart1914
      @blacktallsmart1914 8 років тому

      +Ecaf Tnuc Hell, Kirk and company found a planet that actually was a modern day Roman Empire

  • @ploppysonofploppy6066
    @ploppysonofploppy6066 6 років тому

    Succinct very interesting. My inner nerd would question whether Romulans and Klingons had an alliance. If so their common hatred of the Federation would have had significant impacts . More likely their mutual hatred would have kept them away from the federation. They have traded technologies;D7 cruisers, cloaking, Warp etc. But this could occur during conflict, capturing derelict ships for instance. Are there any Canon references to this alliance?

  • @desiguy55
    @desiguy55 6 років тому +1

    I agree with much of the star trek universe except all stories dealing with time travel.

  • @cutchyacokov
    @cutchyacokov 8 років тому +31

    Don't listen to the haters, keep doing Trek and Tolkien alongside ASOIAF. I, personally, could do without the Star Wars videos as I never have found that universe very coherent outside of the original trilogy but I'm sure there are others who like it so I'm not complaining. :)

    • @grantwilson4506
      @grantwilson4506 8 років тому +11

      Star Wars is my favorite source of lore, well it was. Before they cut the EU.

    • @randyrhoades8751
      @randyrhoades8751 8 років тому +9

      People are complaining about Trek Lore!? Come on, how many youtube pages do Trek Lore? That is an awful thing to complain about in my opinion.

  • @magnusingi9384
    @magnusingi9384 8 років тому +1

    will you ever do videos on starcraft ,mass effect, witcher or elder scrolls

    • @CivilizationEx
      @CivilizationEx  8 років тому

      Maybe one day, but probably not for awhile

  • @markdavidson1049
    @markdavidson1049 7 років тому +7

    Aren't you mixing cannon with non-cannon towards the end. Aren't the latest movies with JJ Abrams considered not part of the "real" Star Trek timeline?

    • @CivilizationEx
      @CivilizationEx  7 років тому +4

      All my info is canon, the JJ Abrams universe is also canon, but it is set in an alternative dimension. However the events that led to Spock crossing over and entering the new universe are all canon.

    • @logansmith2703
      @logansmith2703 7 років тому +3

      Mark Davidson that's the elitist attitudes from some Trek fans. Both are canon just in different timelines.

  • @JimboShogun0686
    @JimboShogun0686 7 років тому +222

    I do not consider JJ Abrams star trek as cannon

    • @katakisLives
      @katakisLives 7 років тому +20

      Whomever owns the rights to the star trek franchise and makes tv series and movies has canonical authority! it could be God awful but its canon nonetheless.

    • @JimboShogun0686
      @JimboShogun0686 7 років тому +8

      katakisLives With protest I see your point

    • @GoodVideos4
      @GoodVideos4 7 років тому +2

      Shoot the canon at it.

    • @GoodVideos4
      @GoodVideos4 7 років тому +25

      JJ Abrams ruined Star Trek.

    • @brooklyn560
      @brooklyn560 7 років тому

      Aquarius1011 how?

  • @9skyman945
    @9skyman945 8 років тому

    This has probably been suggested, but can you make videos on the Cardassians in the future?

    • @CivilizationEx
      @CivilizationEx  8 років тому +1

      Definitely will at some point, but I am debating doing the Ferengi first, I really love them.

  • @jonathanfornwalt4919
    @jonathanfornwalt4919 3 роки тому

    Since it would appear that Romulus was more hospitable than Vulcan, it would make sense for the Romulans to have lost some of the physical strength of their Vulcan cousins. It would make sense that the Romulans would still be stronger than humans, but generations on Romulus would no longer have had to survive on such a harsh planet. It's been mentioned that Romulans have evolved enough that they were no longer physiologically identical to Vulcans. I'd just like to see their physical strength strength addressed since they've emphasized that Vulcans are 3 times stronger and faster than humans, and Klingons are stronger and have more endurance than humans. It would be interesting to know how the Romulans stack up.

  • @NerdWorldEmpire
    @NerdWorldEmpire 8 років тому

    Love the vids but as I understand it and I had to Google it because I couldn't remember properly but the Reman are another subspecies of Vulcan just like the romulans? Though I didn't know about the others Vulcan are such a rich source of story for star trek that has never been fully explored I feel ☺

    • @CivilizationEx
      @CivilizationEx  8 років тому

      The Reman connection to the Vulcans was established in the novels which are not canon.

    • @NerdWorldEmpire
      @NerdWorldEmpire 8 років тому

      +CivilizationEx ah hard to tell what is canon and not now with so many books and comics

    • @warriorgaming1604
      @warriorgaming1604 6 років тому

      they look almost the same in fact in one episode of the original star trek they first exposed what romulans look like everyone looked at spock then back at the view screen

    • @Raja1938
      @Raja1938 6 років тому

      Would make more sense for the Remans to be the aboriginal native species of Romulus and/or Remus, before the ancient Vulcans conquered and enslaved them.

  • @lutherd
    @lutherd 7 років тому +2

    Nit-picking here, but the Starship Enterprise, NX-01 was NOT named "USS Enterprise." It was simply named "Enterprise."

    • @MKDumas1981
      @MKDumas1981 6 років тому

      David L. There was that one incorrect graphic in the episode "Divergence", where _Enterprise_ and _Columbia_ had "USS" in front of them. A possible explanation is that the U.E. Starfleet considered adding USS to distinguish the Warp 5 ships from everything else.

  • @Lokiawa
    @Lokiawa 8 років тому

    Some minor errors (not necessarily with the history just some nitpick things, ex. USS Enterprise NX-01, it's just Enterprise NX-01) but still worth watching, great refresher to my knowledge of STAR TREK.

  • @elliyoutude
    @elliyoutude 2 роки тому

    Where does commander Tabok of the Romulans fit in all this? There was no mention of him. He’s the most badass Romulan there is!

  • @mathewanderson5111
    @mathewanderson5111 8 років тому +1

    Do a video on vulcans please and mention Spock.

  • @shotgunmcshotgun1142
    @shotgunmcshotgun1142 7 років тому

    So how does the lore of Star Trek online fit into this with the Romulan republic etc

    • @CivilizationEx
      @CivilizationEx  7 років тому +4

      STO takes place after the last known events of the Canon Universe and continues the story in its own way but because it is only a game it is not considered alpha canon, so new and future star trek movies and tv shows that want to further the story will not take it into consideration. STO is part of Beta canon which involves novels, games, and comics.

    • @shotgunmcshotgun1142
      @shotgunmcshotgun1142 7 років тому

      That's a shame, I really like the Romulan republic

  • @andysahs1599
    @andysahs1599 3 роки тому

    Some of those planets are also names of the Romulan Warbirds in their fleet too.

  • @Robert15315
    @Robert15315 7 років тому +2

    The Romulans abandoned their plan to have shinzon infiltrate the Federation as Picard when they realized that he looks NOTHING like Picard.... despite him being a clone of Picard.

    • @tonywhite9873
      @tonywhite9873 6 років тому +1

      lol, he was a younger version, also they couldn't cure Shalaft's Syndrome and the caves on Reman weren't good to him.

  • @Gigacom
    @Gigacom 4 роки тому

    Any up date from Picard?

  • @rayden120
    @rayden120 5 років тому

    When you 4th century is that the standard overall 4 century for every race? Or is that 4th century for those races rule of time measurements? Like it's 4th century on Vulcan buts it's like 5 century B.C. on earth.

    • @CivilizationEx
      @CivilizationEx  5 років тому

      All dates are in earth years, so 4th century is from the human perspective, the actual vulcan date is something else.

    • @rayden120
      @rayden120 5 років тому

      @@CivilizationEx ah thanks

  • @shmuli9
    @shmuli9 4 роки тому

    I am not sure what to think of this... It DOES explain a lot (I was somewhat confused), but this sort of sounds like a "future that did not happen", though I am sure that humans will meet someone with Romulan characteristics (if we haven't already). And maybe Vulcans, too, but one can only hope not at the same time... (People seem to be one thing or the other [we are logical, but also emotional], but not both at the same time.)

  • @calebtimes453
    @calebtimes453 7 років тому +1

    Romulan empire has a roman feel to it.

  • @kphan4643
    @kphan4643 8 років тому

    love the star trek lore, boo to the new trek being part of this. great work!

  • @pak40l46
    @pak40l46 4 роки тому

    Try reading, My Enemy, My Ally and The Romulan Way by Diane Duane. The two novels tell a non-canon story about the Rihannsu/Romulans that IMHO is better.

  • @komododragonking6592
    @komododragonking6592 4 роки тому

    The debrune I don’t think I heard of them where did you heard about the debrune

  • @latenights1982
    @latenights1982 6 років тому

    I'm wondering how the Romulan-Earth war ended up in Earth's favor. Shouldn't the Romulan Star Empire tech be far more advanced than Earth tech? Perhaps I missed something somewhere in canon which exlains this.

    • @CivilizationEx
      @CivilizationEx  6 років тому +3

      Earth had powerful allies like the Vulcans.

    • @tonywhite9873
      @tonywhite9873 6 років тому

      Also Rumulans made a mistake that lead to the birth of the Fed.

  • @deadfishy
    @deadfishy 6 років тому

    will you please do one on vulcans alone?

  • @mariolis
    @mariolis 3 роки тому

    Such a shame when Enterprise got cancelled ...
    we never saw the Earth-Romulan war , which was being hyped up in the few romulan scenes

    • @jonmcinnis1645
      @jonmcinnis1645 Рік тому

      mariolis1000 I think the Romulan war could’ve been their answer to Star Wars the clone wars series and I think this series should’ve aired on nickelodeon should’ve been made in 2006 and aired from 2006 to 2009 with three seasons (Who should make and produce the series i vote Steve marmel The former developer of Danny phantom i’m saying it should been made by the same guys that did Danny phantom) and it would be a micro series (similar to the clone wars 2003 microseries) like and comment if you agree

  • @aceofspadesguy4913
    @aceofspadesguy4913 4 роки тому

    All I wanna know is why they’re Space Rome. They have Rome’s government, titles, and much of its culture. Now I know we saw a literal 20th century Rome in TOS, but I still want an actual explanation for space Romulus and Remus.

    • @TheMrPeteChannel
      @TheMrPeteChannel 4 роки тому

      On the way to what became Romulus they observed ancient earth & thought "these Roman guys are cool! One day we'll become fine allies!" But when they finally saw what Earth became they were disgusted because we became space commie/hippies!

  • @cpin1278
    @cpin1278 8 років тому

    Ah, Cannon and the eternal question of what is and what makes cannon cannon. What would we do with out it's ability to screw with our heads?