The BEST Primaris Marine | Warhammer 40k Lore

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 8 вер 2024
  • Follow my Twitter for updates: / chronoharlequin
    My Meme Channel: / @chronotheharlequin
    Warhammer 40K and Warhammer Fantasy are owned by Games Workshop
    #gamesworkshop #gamesworkshop40k #warhammer40000 #warhammer40k #warhammer #warhammercommunity #40k #wh40klore #warhammerlore #warhammer40klore #40klore #spacemarine #spacemarines #imperiumofman #warhammer40k10thedition #adeptusastartes #warhammermemes #warhammermeme #comicdub #comicdubs #podcast #podcasts #40k #warhammerpodcast #40kpodcast #40kmeme #40kmemes #chaosspacemarines #horusheresy #primarch #primarchs #lioneljohnson #fulgrim #perturabo #jaghataikahn #whitescars #darkangel #darkangels #emperorschildren #perturabo #lemanruss #spacewolves #imperialfists #rogaldorn #konradcurze #nightlords #bloodangels #sanguinius #ferrusmanus #ironhands #angron #worldeaters #robuteguilliman #ultramarine #ultramarines #mortarion #deathguard #thousandsons #magnusthered #horuslupercal #lunawolves #sonsofhorus #lorgaraurelian #lorgaraurelian #wordbearers #vulkan #salamanders #corvus #corvuscorax #ravenguard #alphalegion #alpharius #omegon #alphariusomegon #spacemarinelegions #legions #ironwarriors #loyalist #loyalists #astartes #adeptusastartes #theemperor #theemperorofman #godemperor #asmr #40kasmr #heretic #heresy #novamarines #novamarine #plaguewars #justinian #justinianparris

КОМЕНТАРІ • 273

  • @BarelyDecentProduction
    @BarelyDecentProduction 5 місяців тому +292

    Obviously the best primaris marine would be *insert homebrew marine here*

    • @livefromtheblacklibrary
      @livefromtheblacklibrary  5 місяців тому +73

      The best primaris is chapter master Hogus Blogus who single-handedly beat a hive fleet to death

    • @AngryHomunculus
      @AngryHomunculus 5 місяців тому +20

      Sorry your comment reminded me of my want to create a Blood Angels successor with the word "haemoglobin" in it

    • @jonwest3136
      @jonwest3136 5 місяців тому

      @@AngryHomunculus ”The dim kin of hemoglobin”

    • @Prophetofthe8thLegion
      @Prophetofthe8thLegion 5 місяців тому +2

      Kitten of the Kitten Warriors, Primarch: Emperor

    • @alpha-1redrighthand829
      @alpha-1redrighthand829 5 місяців тому +2

      @@livefromtheblacklibraryit would be Titus.

  • @ottovonbismarck7094
    @ottovonbismarck7094 5 місяців тому +148

    To be fair if the first thing trapped civilans think to do when help comes is to blow their cover and make a shitload of noise I wouldnt want anything to do with them

    • @livefromtheblacklibrary
      @livefromtheblacklibrary  5 місяців тому +48

      Ok that’s fair

    • @estebanatachaoarguedas6321
      @estebanatachaoarguedas6321 5 місяців тому +15

      Like "GOD-EMPEROR-DAMMIT! We are NOT CUSTODES to resolve this instantly!".

    • @Prophetofthe8thLegion
      @Prophetofthe8thLegion 5 місяців тому +11

      But at that point if the enemy isn’t immediately aware of your position, the loud sound of bolter fire is going to alert him so not only did the Nova Marines waste ammunition they probably screwed themselves over in the process.

    • @unnamedenemy9
      @unnamedenemy9 5 місяців тому +1

      fair, but murdering them all as your first response is pretty psychotic and callous.

    • @ottovonbismarck7094
      @ottovonbismarck7094 5 місяців тому +10

      @@unnamedenemy9 their first response was repeatedly telling them to be quiet and not to do that

  • @benjamintrejo9307
    @benjamintrejo9307 5 місяців тому +72

    A moral renegade space marine would be a sick ass book series. One can dream…

    • @livefromtheblacklibrary
      @livefromtheblacklibrary  5 місяців тому +23

      GIVE ME THE RONIN PRIMARIS

    • @g.sergiusfidenas6650
      @g.sergiusfidenas6650 5 місяців тому +7

      Even just a true indepent Renegade would be cool, pretty much all of them go "Damn, we f*ck up, well guys let's go straight to the Eye". I know technically some Alpha Legion are in this category and then we have the Ashen Claws and that's kinda it the rest are all Chaos' pawns to some degree. I would like to see more stuff like non-Chaos non-Loyalist empire one of the founders of the Grey Knights had for a while during the Heresy before becoming an agent of Malcador; pirates, renegades, freedom fighters, a lot of roles to be played for an independent group of Astartes that are no longer Imperium-affiliated but don't sell their souls to the 4 satans of Chaos either.

    • @marcialhd
      @marcialhd 5 місяців тому

      @@g.sergiusfidenas6650 yeah, frankly i feel that is an avenue that GW should explore more, a renegade faction of humans (likely with some Astartes members) that realize "hey the imperium and all of its organizations are shit, lets get the fuck out while we still can!" and simply go their own way without falling to Chaos (and that's another thing i'm freaking tired of the "everyone who leaves the imperium either dies or goes to chaos" attitude that GW FORCES upon the story, if the freaking Ashen Claws could still be piratical assholes for over 10k years then it is more than possible to survive uncorrupted without the impeirum).

    • @travelingspartan2035
      @travelingspartan2035 5 місяців тому

      RIP Soul Drinkers

  • @nekomancer4641
    @nekomancer4641 5 місяців тому +87

    I'm just dying at the picture of a Space marine doing air quotes while saying "brother"

    • @livefromtheblacklibrary
      @livefromtheblacklibrary  5 місяців тому +26

      THATS HOW IT FELT IN THE AUDIOBOOK

    • @brotherhoodofsteel4751
      @brotherhoodofsteel4751 5 місяців тому

      ​@@livefromtheblacklibraryin that case you should check out the Flesh Tearers novels plenty of sass

    • @Vincent_A.
      @Vincent_A. 5 місяців тому

      A memorable quote from Brother Dramaticus

  • @phantomwraith1984
    @phantomwraith1984 5 місяців тому +186

    He feels like a Salamandwr who got attached to a bunch of Marine Malevolent. The Nova Marines are absolute assholes with stupid tradiations, whereas Paris is a genuine nice guy who just wants to do good and is getting frustrated with getting shafted all the time

    • @livefromtheblacklibrary
      @livefromtheblacklibrary  5 місяців тому +30

      YEAH! I wanna see where is leads

    • @Nyghtking
      @Nyghtking 5 місяців тому +15

      I think it's a bit different then that, because the marines malevolent actively dispise regular humans, the nova marines feel like they just don't care.

    • @travelingspartan2035
      @travelingspartan2035 5 місяців тому +5

      That's an oversimplification. The Novamarines are pragmatic enough to be willing to allow (or commit) civilian casualties when they think it's really necessary, but at a baseline level that's normal for Astartes chapters. And they don't do it without remorse, as shown in Godblight. They're nowhere near as heartless as Marines Malevolent, or Iron Hands, or Minotaurs, or any others that are reputed for it. Nor does not wanting to commit war-crimes make you a Salamander; there are levels of compassion and morality, and few chapters can be sorted into a binary where they are equal to those two extremes.

  • @stingblademaster
    @stingblademaster 5 місяців тому +108

    Dante was this kind of character for me. His personal struggle on the thirst. Opposing views with Seth another great character and the sense of loss and abject failure after the DoB despite having won

    • @livefromtheblacklibrary
      @livefromtheblacklibrary  5 місяців тому +20

      Yeah he's one of the standout characters imo

    • @Lord_Inquisitor_Ignis
      @Lord_Inquisitor_Ignis 5 місяців тому +5

      Damn beat me there but I completely agree

    • @wailmerpail
      @wailmerpail 5 місяців тому +3

      blood angels in general having to juggle both the thirst and the black rage makes them feel more humble and compelling to me

    • @thisgoddamusernamestoodamnlong
      @thisgoddamusernamestoodamnlong 5 місяців тому +1

      Same with Lamenters for me.

    • @cntipede1000
      @cntipede1000 5 місяців тому

      Dante's story made me a 40k fan and was the deciding factor for what army I was going to build and play.

  • @CrayonosaurusRex
    @CrayonosaurusRex 5 місяців тому +13

    I always kinda liked the idea of the Deathwatch being this honored and experienced brotherhood of veterans, but also as a "this astartes failed to adapt and may cause issues in the chapter...send him to the Watch, at least they can use the meat" type unit

  • @MrPedroleiria
    @MrPedroleiria 5 місяців тому +27

    That Black Templar dude and his historitor friend are also an interesting duo.

  • @RecoilGunnerStudios
    @RecoilGunnerStudios 5 місяців тому +26

    Justinian maxantius and felix are really great examples of primaris marines
    Yes felix feels like a privillaged kid at times but he isnt arrogant
    Being that privilaged and being so humble is great!
    And theres a chance Guilliman will never see him again due to his lifespan.

    • @livefromtheblacklibrary
      @livefromtheblacklibrary  5 місяців тому +2

      I'm almost done Cawl: The Great Work and while it's not an AMAZING book I do think it fleshes out Felix a lot

    • @RecoilGunnerStudios
      @RecoilGunnerStudios 5 місяців тому

      @@livefromtheblacklibrary now i need to read it too.
      Such a heavy burden on a single "young" Astardes

  • @vontheunknown7982
    @vontheunknown7982 5 місяців тому +26

    I wish we saw this more with Primaris Marines, and to see that there changing with their chapters as well.

    • @livefromtheblacklibrary
      @livefromtheblacklibrary  5 місяців тому +4

      I feel like this is why a lot of people don't care for the A Dawn of Fire series of Space Marine Conquests. While I haven't read them myself, I've heard that that's where a lot of negative p[erceptions of Primaris come from

    • @caseymay5449
      @caseymay5449 5 місяців тому +4

      The space marine that took command of the Emperor's Scythe had a good story.
      I can't remember his name but he had a lot of emotion. He hated Call and he felt bad for the shame his family felt because he disappeared for the Primaris project.

    • @SoftyDR
      @SoftyDR 5 місяців тому +3

      ​@@caseymay5449
      You are referring to Decimus Felix in 'Belisarius Cawl: The Great Work'.
      He wasn't commanding the Scythes per se, but checking his quadrant of Ultramar as he is the Tetrarch (Space Marine ruler) of that area.
      I love the fact that he is called Decimus (10) & his brother Nonas (9) because their parents wanted 10 kids and they were counting down from the first.

    • @caseymay5449
      @caseymay5449 5 місяців тому +2

      @SoftyDR thanks it has been awhile since I read it and I even forgot that part.

  • @blackhelmetnova7753
    @blackhelmetnova7753 5 місяців тому +10

    Personally I’m a huge fan of Decimus Felix. He’s a child who was chosen for his potential and had to deal with Cawl being his nightmare even into his Astartes life. Felix also has this immense weight of being a Tetrarch despite being so ‘relatively’ young as a marine. Given so much responsibility by your demigod father and asked to help fix a galaxy that’s on fire. All Decimus can do is put on a strong face and order others around who have either been around the setting far longer or are just straight up 10x older than him.
    He has a different kind of melancholy that I enjoy from the Ultramarine characters in recent years. Almost like a mini version of his father, Decimus remembers a better time and is now in hell struggling to impose some sort of order in a galaxy that is in chaos. Maybe that’s the reason he was chosen by Guilliman himself to be a Tetrarch. And just like Justinian, Decimus was taken by Cawl and his family who he loved is ripped away and essentially tortured by Belisarius who then goes on to affectionately call Decimus his “son”.

    • @TKUltra971
      @TKUltra971 5 місяців тому +4

      Yeah, I can totally relate with him as a reader. He's the perfect P-SM because he puts the reader directly in the seat to what exactly it is to be one and become one with the struggle of fitting into M42. I really think they don't deserve all the hate that they get but its still incredibly grim dark and its actually supported by old canon as to why they exist in the first place.

  • @arstotzka9088
    @arstotzka9088 5 місяців тому +11

    Cato Sicarius is another character thats getting a positive revamp. His more recent novels like knights of Macragge have actually started to make me like the arrogant bastard. The rivalry between Cato and Agianman over who succeeds Calgar js not talked about enough. Cato, the areogant yet strategic mastermind who understands the Codex is a foundation, like Titus, not something to be adhered to religiously while Againman is the opposite and has a very Ultramarine view of the codex.

  • @jeffboberson8588
    @jeffboberson8588 5 місяців тому +85

    I still can’t get over how the marines in dark imperium were called Justin and felix the most normal un war hammer names ever

    • @nicolashelbig2142
      @nicolashelbig2142 5 місяців тому +29

      Hes called justinian and These are latin names which have many Marines throughout other Legions

    • @andresperedo1275
      @andresperedo1275 5 місяців тому +21

      Felix is one of the most warhammer names, as it is the name of one of the most iconic characters in warhammer history (which I do not care for, but that is not relevant).
      And if you just care about 40k (or 30k), there was a Imperial fist called Felix Cassander (poor guy btw)

    • @jeffboberson8588
      @jeffboberson8588 5 місяців тому

      Ye but it sound like Justin tho

    • @StonedTuna
      @StonedTuna 5 місяців тому +4

      @@nicolashelbig2142 fun fact, there were no j’s in ancient Latin. Any place that you would’ve had a J they pretty much used a Y instead. It was much later with “church Latin” that the letter J was added in.

    • @HeilSol
      @HeilSol 5 місяців тому +3

      @@StonedTuna you mean "I", not "Y" as that didn't exist in "ancient" Latin either, technically called "archaic Latin".

  • @akumaking1
    @akumaking1 5 місяців тому +14

    Who thinks GW has already forgotten about this guy?

    • @livefromtheblacklibrary
      @livefromtheblacklibrary  5 місяців тому +11

      He was last mentioned in Godblight which came out on May 29, 2021, so it's been less than 3 years. Let's not count him out yet

  • @onairwithjarvis
    @onairwithjarvis 5 місяців тому +3

    Dude definitely needs a model. Both because it would be a Primaris model character that wasn't originally a first born, and because we can see more of the Nova Marines. Their colour scheme slaps.

  • @BearCavalryWasTaken
    @BearCavalryWasTaken 5 місяців тому +9

    I feel like they’d fit in with the Redacted, loyalist but also traitor at the same time comprised of different legions like the unumbered sons

    • @livefromtheblacklibrary
      @livefromtheblacklibrary  5 місяців тому +5

      THATS SO TRUE! Though I can't see him wanting to filter out loyal assets to strengthen the imperium. He wouldn't have the stomach for that

  • @Book_worm.75
    @Book_worm.75 5 місяців тому +12

    The thing that's boring about some loyalist space marines is that they are mostly one note and especially ultramarines and their successors. Always sticking to the codex astartes and such. However we do have a lot of great loyalist space marines who I would argue rival the traitors when it comes to writing.....in the era indomitus that is, we have Uriel Ventris, Dante of the blood angels, Gabriel Seth, Titus, Ragnar Blackmane. Who all have their personal struggles and stand out when it comes to writing.

  • @crashinallguard
    @crashinallguard 5 місяців тому +4

    I'm so glad someone's talking about Justinian!!

  • @sonicwingnut
    @sonicwingnut 5 місяців тому +5

    Just to be that guy.. Zephon survived the Heresy. He was the first chapter master of the Charnel Guard.

  • @captainteutonica5474
    @captainteutonica5474 5 місяців тому +56

    I despise the Traitors, because I abhor disloyalty and treachery. So I never could get myself to like any of the Traitors, but I do agree with you that most Loyalists are generic at best.

    • @caseymay5449
      @caseymay5449 5 місяців тому +8

      Stoic

    • @everythingsalright1121
      @everythingsalright1121 5 місяців тому

      Im more interested in normal humans in most cases with regards to 40k, with a few space marine exceptions. However me like demons and slaanesh so im biased

    • @Hugme778
      @Hugme778 5 місяців тому +1

      Tthen you would love the night lords

    • @billybob-zk9nm
      @billybob-zk9nm 5 місяців тому

      Alpha legion too 👉👈?

    • @captainteutonica5474
      @captainteutonica5474 2 місяці тому

      @@billybob-zk9nm especially the Alpha Legion Alpharius, Hydra Dominatus.

  • @andresperedo1275
    @andresperedo1275 5 місяців тому +13

    The thing of the Wolfspear is that ALL OF THEM are primaris, as the SW could not have second foundation chapters (BTW, incredible mistake of GW introducing succesors to the SW. I think that is part of the reason we are not getting absolutely no relevant news from their side... GW fucked it up and they do not know how to fix it)

    • @livefromtheblacklibrary
      @livefromtheblacklibrary  5 місяців тому +4

      YEAH PROBABLY XD

    • @lachlanevans5013
      @lachlanevans5013 5 місяців тому +2

      Well one thing I figured might help is have those successor chapters be organised to fulfill the role equivalent to the great companies. Giving them less independence but ultimately more unity and a longer reach amongst the whole line of Russ, with each chapter master taking orders from Logan Grimnar.
      I imaging it sort of like the dark angels various wings but with some more independence but ultimately they are just a bigger version of a great company.

    • @NP3GA
      @NP3GA 5 місяців тому +1

      Didn't they get a short story?

    • @andresperedo1275
      @andresperedo1275 5 місяців тому

      @@lachlanevans5013 the issue is that SW gen seed causes problems when used on non-fenrisian people and without canis helix. That is why the chapter cannot really grow (neither the legion) and why it makes sense they do not care about the codex. And also why they keep Fenris as it is

    • @DarkApostleNoek
      @DarkApostleNoek 5 місяців тому +1

      Latest thing we got from them is the short story in Successors anthology, though it feels like that it took place before the last bit of story of them going to the Nachmund Gauntlet to cross it.

  • @parkermaisterra8532
    @parkermaisterra8532 5 місяців тому +2

    Another Primaris Marine who is pretty cool is Decimus Felix who is not only in the Dark Imperium trilogy but is one of the main characters of *Cawl: The Great Work* where we see his relationship and thoughts when it comes to Cawl
    We also meet Alpha Primus and hoh boy that’s an interesting character

  • @o.w.n.1327
    @o.w.n.1327 5 місяців тому +4

    GIVE THAT MARINE A MODEL!

  • @williamwiegand4340
    @williamwiegand4340 5 місяців тому +19

    I'm suprised you didn't talk about the fact that Justin's first tatto was that of one of the humans his "brothers" killed.
    I also recomend "Succesors" its a collection of short stories of the primaris marines. One of them being of that Wolf Spear marine meeting a wolf priest from the Space Wolves. Its really good read

    • @livefromtheblacklibrary
      @livefromtheblacklibrary  5 місяців тому +6

      Ohhhhh thanks for telling me! And yeah I missed that one

    • @caseymay5449
      @caseymay5449 5 місяців тому +1

      Nice

    • @williamwiegand4340
      @williamwiegand4340 5 місяців тому +1

      @@livefromtheblacklibrary You're welcome! Cool! First time a youtuber replied to me lol.

  • @finnphillosa1431
    @finnphillosa1431 5 місяців тому +1

    Bjarni’s tale continues in a short story called Wolfspear in The Successors anthology. It’s basically a tale about the Space Wolves coming to check on the puppies, test their mettle, and show them how things are done in the Aett. The fact that their emissaries’ thunderhawk is mostly filled with hundreds of barrels of Fenrisian Ale should tell you what they had in mind for cultural enrichment.

  • @masonevanson2995
    @masonevanson2995 2 дні тому

    To see justinian be a black shield would be super interesting because I doubt he would be the only primaris Blackshield, so you'd get this perspective of other primaris marines from other chapters clearly not fitting in and learn their struggles as well, which would provide both new characters but also major new interactions because, even though they're primaris and now all blackshields, they're still all probably majorly different.

  • @gergelyosztrogonacz9464
    @gergelyosztrogonacz9464 4 місяці тому

    Guy who made me fall in love with marines and 40k in general was Pedro Kantor, he is golden.

  • @jadebullet3884
    @jadebullet3884 5 місяців тому +1

    I agree. He seems like the embodiment of what I wanted GW to do with the lore. I want a divide between Primaris and their assigned chapters. I want more exploration of the Imperium Nigilus being cut off and essentially abandoned and forced to defend themselves rather than rely upon the Imperium.
    Instead it just seems the Imperium is fine.

  • @wikipediaintellectual7088
    @wikipediaintellectual7088 3 місяці тому

    "Show me one loyalist who gets that much love and appreciation."
    Dante...

  • @hendrik1769
    @hendrik1769 5 місяців тому +1

    I could see Justinian joining the Death Watch if he does not manage to find a place in the nova marines.

    • @amw5288
      @amw5288 5 місяців тому

      Oh. A deathwatch book with Justinian and Maxentius running as a part of a kill team? Sign me up!

  • @DatsVatSheSaid
    @DatsVatSheSaid 5 місяців тому +8

    The Video games have really solid and well known Loyalist Marines, Gabriel Angelos, Indrick Boreale, Captain Titus, the DoW2 story campaign Marines, Malum fucking Caedo.

  • @yamibakura8597
    @yamibakura8597 5 місяців тому +1

    I agree with you, Chrono. Loyalist Marines tend to be rather one-note in the modern Era. I read Storm of Iron and I had to admit that the Iron Warriors were actually quite interesting.
    That being said, I prefer to follow characters who have at least the semblance of morality, so I was rooting for the Guard that entire time

  • @udp1073
    @udp1073 5 місяців тому +1

    I cannot remember the name now but i will find it and edit this message: there is this primaris space wolves that we see on a couple of deployments and then left to stand guard by guilliman to a planet, then there are “traditional” space wolves viaiting them, we see the struggle to identify, we see battle, damn we see them getting drunk.. it is an amazing character

  • @patrickdees5256
    @patrickdees5256 5 місяців тому +1

    Okay here me out: a story where a bunch of primaris marines from each chapter go on to rescue one of their own. Getting to see the different perspectives on the chapter one was placed in. If they made it to the area via backing from their chapter, went rogue, or were allowed to go, but had to do so in secret.
    And we could see how some primaris marines go on this rescue mission, either out of duty or a genuine sense of brotherhood. The drama and struggle that could be made with such a story. The biggest issue would be too many characters though, which would be unfortunate.

  • @GenralG7
    @GenralG7 5 місяців тому +1

    My favorite part is at the end when he gets the tattoo of the girl they killed, and the Chaplain is like "I will not if youre doing this to remind yourself of her death" and hes like "I do it to remember my duty", which can go either way. Originally I thought that was him facing hard facts and accepting it, but now im more convinced he'll wear it as a reminder

  • @MR.LMR1996
    @MR.LMR1996 5 місяців тому +1

    Would be interesting to see how thing could kick off between Chapters who don't fully accept their new First Generation Primaris Brothers. I wouldn't be surprised if there were more instances like that one time with a group of Black Templars who went rouge and tried to purge their Primaris Battle Brothers because they viewed their existance and creation as Heresy.
    What would happen if something like this happened with Chapters like the Nova Marines except the other way around? Where the 1st Generation Primaris Marines like Justin here end-up staging a coup over the Chapter and make an attempt to overthrow and purge the First Born Marines. Not because they wanted to turn traitor, or because they fell to Chaos, but because these Primaris Marines see their First Born Brothers - the Marines who disreguard the lives of the mortals they're supposed to be protecting as Space Marines - as monsters and they can no longer justify themselves in serving alongside such callous people and want to take control of the Chapter and reforge it into something genuinly better.

  • @theangrycarcharodon8120
    @theangrycarcharodon8120 5 місяців тому +3

    Bail sharr from the carcharodons books and his interactions with Te'kahurangi the chief librarian thru out the book red tithe is excellent
    Edit:As far a loyalists are concerned not primaris :)

  • @zeroakira584
    @zeroakira584 5 місяців тому

    It would be interesting to see him meeting the Salamander who no doubt will agree with how he conducted back in the church while roasting the Nova Marine both litterally and metaphortically.

  • @user-oj4ll2bf6k
    @user-oj4ll2bf6k 3 місяці тому +1

    This guy, Justinian, is "literally me" 😢

  • @pedropierre9594
    @pedropierre9594 5 місяців тому +11

    They need to give ADB more leeway with new primaris he will handle it the way he has Nightlords, he already wrote Emperor’s Spears, i would be so excited to hear ADB is writing something with Messinius in it for example

    • @drunknnirish
      @drunknnirish Місяць тому

      The Spears book was so good.

  • @massiverabbit3454
    @massiverabbit3454 5 місяців тому +1

    Damn, I didn’t know all those characters at the beginning of the video are primaris marines, damn

  • @anzaca1
    @anzaca1 4 місяці тому

    16:15 Probably the best thing that could happen is for the Novamarines to develop a grudging respect for him. They still won't "like" him, but they'll at the very least come to respect him. Possibly by him accomplishing something they thought impossible etc. On the flip side, Paris could come to realise that the Novamarines' callousness isn't entirely without merit, because Space Marines routinely find themselves in situations where they simply don't have the time to worry about regular humans.

  • @notribadsvault
    @notribadsvault 5 місяців тому +1

    Based, he was my favorite as well and the first I thought of when I saw the title. Alpha Primis was neat too

  • @fluffywolfo3663
    @fluffywolfo3663 5 місяців тому +4

    The space wolves are some of the most human Astartes in that way - they laugh, they drink, they shoot the shit, they brag to each other, throw feasts. So even if I don’t individually latch onto their characters all the time (Ragnar is fine I guess) it gives them a lot of depth.

    • @andresperedo1275
      @andresperedo1275 5 місяців тому

      Give it a try to Chris Wraight old SW trilogy, you may enjoy it

    • @fluffywolfo3663
      @fluffywolfo3663 5 місяців тому

      @@andresperedo1275I have read it! It's pretty great. Besides Ingvar (I like seeing a Wolf who decided to learn from other Astartes in the Deathwatch) my favorites would probably be Grimnar and Bjorn.

    • @andresperedo1275
      @andresperedo1275 5 місяців тому +1

      @@fluffywolfo3663 I really liked Ingvar, specially in the first book. I am an immigrant, and that feeling of never fitting in, either where you live or where you were born it was perfectly captured.
      I hope he goes back to telling the story of that pack, although not sure how well it would fit with the current events

  • @Ceiling_Gato
    @Ceiling_Gato 5 місяців тому

    There's also a similar story in one of the SM Conquest books about Primaris Dark Angels not really fitting in with the chapter, and actively sabotaging their psycho-indoctrination when they find out about it

  • @unnamedenemy9
    @unnamedenemy9 5 місяців тому +2

    See, I love when loyalists get to be more complex. The first 40k book I ever read (and is still one of my favorites) was Helsreach, largely because it did such a good job with Grimaldus -- we got to see the classic stoic astartes get in touch with his humanity, which he shares with baseline humans. Hell, my favorite moments from that book aren't the last stand (which was *awesome,* don't get me wrong), but the moments he has talking to other people like the titan princeps and the guard sergeant. My favorite by far is at the end, when he repeats and improves his old mentor's motto and says to himself essentially "I am sorry it took me so long to realize that you weren't entirely right and step out from your shadow." Well, that and the very last line, "Hero of Helsreach, as if there is only one."

  • @KronicVayne
    @KronicVayne 2 місяці тому

    I think the "old and new" could be better described as "has history versus lack of history", i'm sure we'll get some stand-out primaris in time, i'm in the "let them cook" camp xD

  • @Cumfart_Inn
    @Cumfart_Inn 5 місяців тому +34

    I think he just sounds like one of those dudes that join the military and get filtered out

    • @livefromtheblacklibrary
      @livefromtheblacklibrary  5 місяців тому +16

      Honestly he would have made a good but unremarkable Ultramarine, it's just because the Novamarines are...like THAT

    • @g.sergiusfidenas6650
      @g.sergiusfidenas6650 5 місяців тому +1

      ​@@livefromtheblacklibrary I get the impression he would had been out of place in almost every chapter but the Ultramarines, those were his expectations, anything but that was a downgrade; the Novamarines though not very likable from his POV are pretty standard marines they are not the most morbid, savage or straight-up malignant chapter even just in Guilliman's lineage let alone the Imperium as a whole. Hope the make a story about that primaris that got sent to the Flesh Tearers and got mauled by Seth.

    • @MR.LMR1996
      @MR.LMR1996 5 місяців тому +6

      @@g.sergiusfidenas6650I for one would love to see a story of a group of Primaris Marines being sent to one of the more morbid and savage chapters, and chose to rebel and overthrow their First Born Brothers. Not because these Primaris Marines want to turn traitor or fell to Chaos, but because these Primaris Marines can't justify themselves in giving themselves over to the command of Space Marines who hold no reguard for the lives of those outside the Chapter. And in their desire to do what they see as the right thing they begin purging the First Born Marine leadership in their desire to reforge these malignant chapters they were sent to join in order to reforge the Chapter into something more noble and fitting to their expectations of what a Space Marine should be.

    • @marcialhd
      @marcialhd 5 місяців тому +1

      @@MR.LMR1996 frankly i would LOVE to see something like this (and even more have those Primaris SUCCEEDING), but this is GW and they love keeping things on the status quo, so it is very likely that if they ever wrote something like this it would not end well for the Primaris (maybe even being the catalyst for a new civil war).

  • @jaimesmiller414
    @jaimesmiller414 2 місяці тому

    Look at what the fandom venerates and you can tell all men want, is to die in glorious battle with their friends for a greater purpose than themselves.

  • @user-cq1cw8xz7f
    @user-cq1cw8xz7f 3 місяці тому

    Here's hoping Justin can be sent to the Deatwatch and make a nice found family there

  • @DerekCFPegritz
    @DerekCFPegritz 5 місяців тому +1

    I absolutely love Solomon Akura. That whole book was awesome, as it showed how the Alpha Legion works after 10,000 years of being overly secretive.

    • @unnamedenemy9
      @unnamedenemy9 5 місяців тому

      I really need to read that book -- I've always had a love/hate relationship with the Alpha Legion because they're cool and interesting but also *waaaaaaay* too deep into the secrecy and the "or did they!?" shenanigans that made them into a meme, so seeing a story where they have to grapple with the problems *caused* by that obsession with secrecy sounds really cool and grounding.

    • @DerekCFPegritz
      @DerekCFPegritz 5 місяців тому

      @@unnamedenemy9 There's still plenty of secrecy and deep-faking in that book as well, but the way it's handled is great.

  • @MandoSki464
    @MandoSki464 5 місяців тому

    Bjarni was awesome and was honestly really cool in the wolf spear short story as well

  • @inductivegrunt94
    @inductivegrunt94 5 місяців тому +1

    He was a black sheep of the chapter. He is an Ultramarine in Novamarine armor. He doesn't have a home or brotherhood anymore. Justinian deserves better, I hope there's a story of him finally separating from the Novamarines, like possibly joining the Deathwatch, and finally finding what he truly wants. Maybe even take his Novamarine friend with him so they can get away from the chapter that doesn't deserve them.

  • @collecter343
    @collecter343 5 місяців тому

    I definitely appreciate how the first tattoo he got was of the girl, making sure he never forgot her or what happened.

  • @chrismorel8613
    @chrismorel8613 5 місяців тому +1

    Great video! I also liked the character of Lucerne from throne of light and his issues with the black Templar's (Same author as Dark imperium so should be too surprised. Guy Haley can write a good conflicted dude 👌)

  • @TKUltra971
    @TKUltra971 5 місяців тому +1

    Dude i'm not even a Space Wolf fan but I ADORE Bjarni Arvisson of the WolfSpear Primaris chapter. He's goofy, savage, serious, a man of complex thought and a loyal wolf brother. We first encountered him in the Dawn of Fire series (original before retcon) then we see him again in current canon with The Wolves* of Rakos shot story. Such a great guy! What wolves should be.

  • @anzaca1
    @anzaca1 4 місяці тому +1

    The issue is that the Primaris don't have many characters with decent screentime yet.

  • @alannatherson7721
    @alannatherson7721 5 місяців тому

    I feel like the best option for Justinian is to go off to the Death Watch as soon as possible, it won't solve anything but would be at least a slight improvement.

  • @fightforaglobalfirstamendm5617
    @fightforaglobalfirstamendm5617 5 місяців тому +2

    Both Guilliman and the Lion should take a chapter of each bloodline not including their own, so 8 chapters. Then take 8 chapters of their own bloodline and combine them into a Division sized Corps to lead their Crusades. Used to crack any problem with the correct tool for the job.

  • @tneal89
    @tneal89 5 місяців тому

    Other than the Space Wolves, the only modern day loyalist Marines I can think of who get that same level of attention and quality of development that you described are probably the Blood Angels. Dante and Mephiston in particular. I'd recommend most of the novels focusing on them.

  • @benciudovchgottdank3460
    @benciudovchgottdank3460 5 місяців тому

    I did think that his relationship with the other Novamarines was improving during the second book though. You mentioned the scene with the Techmarine saying "You Primaris brothers are tough" for one, and I do believe that followed the battle for Galatan, where Firstborn and Primaris marines fought side by side to desperately repel the forces of the Plague God. I distinctly remember Parris feeling respect towards the Chapter Master or Chapter Champion (I don't remember which it was) when he fought Typhus, and if I'm not mistaken he was upset that the CM/CC was killed by Typhus because he would never get to meet him

    • @jaschathane134
      @jaschathane134 5 місяців тому

      Bardan Dovaro is the guy you’re thinking of, Novamarines Chapter Master.

  • @user-BadUsername
    @user-BadUsername 5 місяців тому

    One way they could take Paris, if he does return, that they could probably slowly make him the chapter master of the nova Marines. I just feel that his progression could be that he would slowly and begrudgingly climb the ranks of the novamarines

  • @SillySpudyRocking
    @SillySpudyRocking 5 місяців тому +4

    I must respectfully disagree with the loyalists not having any truly great marines.... they just get killed off consistently! Siggy, Loken, the loyal Iron Warrior I forget the name of, Shadrach Meduson.... or they just don't get enough lore to flesh them out like Tyberos, Crimson fists CM, Seth... orrrrr they are written as Mary Sue's like EVERY ULTRASMURF! Wait... I'm actually agreeing with you and rather noting why we don't have one 😂

    • @TKUltra971
      @TKUltra971 5 місяців тому +1

      Agreed. There are plenty of great loyalists who are dynamic in their approach to the imperial dogma and ways. Not just generic marine #20394 in chapter whatever-dada. The Chaos Mcs always play off the same beat that, they are scattered in mind and have no idea what they really want or what they'd do if they achieved it. A hamsterwheel of contradiction, ego and self importance.

  • @Raist474
    @Raist474 5 місяців тому +1

    >Gathered up many yutes
    Yutes?

  • @deusexstupit7969
    @deusexstupit7969 4 місяці тому

    honestly i think the Primaris are a great way to ad conflickt to the Loial mareans thats more complicated then youst "those are the good guys those are the bad guys"

  • @g.sergiusfidenas6650
    @g.sergiusfidenas6650 5 місяців тому

    A kinda scary thing is that the Novamarines are pretty standard, their traditions are not particularly gruesome and incidents like that massacre are not their usual MO; a Primaris being sent to the Mortifactors, Death Spectres or Doom Eagles really would feel so out of place due their morbid outlook and one sent to the Marines Malevolent, Red Talons and Iron Hands would probably mentally break seeing the way they do things like purposefully harm civilians to prove a point

  • @prophet89
    @prophet89 5 місяців тому

    The unnumbered were a great oppurtunity to make chimeric primaris chapters that blended the best of each blood line working together.

  • @Knownascomic
    @Knownascomic 4 місяці тому

    I forget which book it’s in but theirs a primaris captain who joins the flesh tearers , who tells Gabriel Seth to his face that he hates him and hates being there and misses the unnumbered sons as well

  • @Prophetofthe8thLegion
    @Prophetofthe8thLegion 5 місяців тому

    I’d say in modern 40K characters like Uriel Ventriss and most of the blood angels characters have received some great character narratives.
    That blood angel sergeant in Angels of Death was very interesting with his conflict of resenting his brothers for in his eyes abandoning him and his need for companionship and brotherhood.

  • @sergentharker7182
    @sergentharker7182 5 місяців тому

    I could see a lot of unnumbered sons going off to become Black Shields, there's some chapters with really incongruous cultures I'm sure a lot of them are having trouble getting over. Most Unforgiven would probably assume they're spies or some such, they're not trusting, if any of them ended up in the Dark Hunters, I'm not sure how they'd feel with how not White Scars the chapter is, especially if they'd wanted to be a biker, taking heads for the Khan, or an Iron Hand who finds like The Crimson Hunters to be distasteful or some such. Idunno, i think it's an idea that could be explored

  • @gideonhorwitz9434
    @gideonhorwitz9434 5 місяців тому

    12:51 if only there was a mechanism for chapters to exchange brothers of similar gene lines who might not fit in

  • @grunt1688
    @grunt1688 5 місяців тому

    It would be cool if his story becomes the live action amazon 40k show

  • @chetmanley1885
    @chetmanley1885 5 місяців тому +1

    Justinian is great, and honestly I hope he volunteers for the Deathwatch or becomes a blackshield.
    Dawn of Fire had some interesting moments; from Primaris Marines who come across like actual children (they kind of are) Captain Messinius, Sergeant Lucerne (who appears in Godblight), formerly an Imperial Fists unnumebered son wjo joined the Black Templars due to his religious views. Quality across the series has been up and down though.
    And Tetrarch Felix who you get some more insight into in the Great Work, specifically how messed up the process lf becoming a Primaris marine was for the Awakened.

  • @NightLordShadow
    @NightLordShadow 5 місяців тому

    I believe the wolfspear did indeed get a book or short story. The name is escaping my memory, but it apparently wasn’t bad.

  • @BIGBOSS-bu1jt
    @BIGBOSS-bu1jt 4 місяці тому

    that particular wolf spear is in a short story in the book successors ho does meat up with the VLKA FENRYKA

  • @morshuthemerchant4105
    @morshuthemerchant4105 Місяць тому

    Blackshields should be a single hero unit with a lot of attacks any chapter can take

  • @zfrankhauser4292
    @zfrankhauser4292 5 місяців тому

    I remember reading the Dark Imperium books and thinking "wow, a lot of these scenes seem like they were written to make the primaris seem cook and help sell. The unnumbered sons are cool though"

  • @diobrandocinematicuniverse4450
    @diobrandocinematicuniverse4450 5 місяців тому +1

    Dark imperium was such a good trilogy

  • @nekomancer4641
    @nekomancer4641 5 місяців тому

    Thanks for highlighting this! Unnumbered Sons is definitely the part of Era Indomitus I hope to learn more about!

  • @Bigboy_smooth
    @Bigboy_smooth 5 місяців тому

    I want to see more loyalist characters like him. The way loyalist are written sometimes makes you think that everything is peachy with them and it's not

  • @theforgottenbard8978
    @theforgottenbard8978 5 місяців тому

    If you get a chance to read the successors novel there is actually a short story about him being a wolf's spear & being a one of the few wolfspears from fenris meeting up with the space wolves and they basically tell him that he'll never one of of them in the typical space wolve way.

  • @rexxo4957
    @rexxo4957 5 місяців тому

    That wolfs spear marine shows up in the successors anthology, its a good read too!

  • @chadyoung9934
    @chadyoung9934 5 місяців тому

    If i recall, his first glory tattoo was a child he had to mercy kill, no?

    • @hoyl700
      @hoyl700 5 місяців тому

      yeah

  • @flaggfarson8046
    @flaggfarson8046 5 місяців тому

    I definitely agree Paris was one of the most memorable parts of the trilogy and I love his character. But if you want more loyalist with a bit more personality and struggles I'd recommend some of the dark angels books. I know thy get a bad rep for the whole fallen things but I do think they have some interesting characters I would recommend the dark angels audio collection as a start if you enjoy audio books some pretty good stories.

  • @thisistherevolt
    @thisistherevolt 5 місяців тому

    Justinian should go the Genesis chapter. I think he'd like it there 😂

  • @iiJDSii
    @iiJDSii 2 місяці тому

    Good takes, I was just thinking today while going thru the latest Cawl/Primaris books about how the chaos marines were far more interesting a subplot than the main imperium storyline. Like you said, it comes down to character development, internal conflicts, etc. New Primaris have little to none of that, and this is a problem with the whole Mary Sue nature of Cawl and the magical 'bigger better marines that just came to be'.
    That said, onto the topic, I did very much enjoy Justinian's storyline in the Dark Imperium books, and his relationship with Maxentius, for sure my favorite subplots, and they gave these Primaris marines some interesting characteristics and conflicts.
    But putting everything in context like you've done just makes me remember how much more prefer GW lore of the Horus Heresy and pre-Primaris. I'm really giving them a chance, they're my main army for the tabletop game, but there's a lot to be desired relative to the older lore.

  • @yopoxikeweapescai9066
    @yopoxikeweapescai9066 5 місяців тому

    I remember a schyther i named justinian that i got in a nuzzlocke, bro died like a champe in the last elite 4

  • @Spikedspaget
    @Spikedspaget 5 місяців тому

    Good one from you once again. Thank you.

  • @N1ghtrunner626
    @N1ghtrunner626 4 місяці тому

    I thought Zephon survived because he founds a blood angels successor chapter

  • @drunknnirish
    @drunknnirish Місяць тому

    I really enjoyed Lazarus in the book of the same title (master of the 5th company of the Dark Angels), so far he is really the primaris I have enjoyed the most although he crossed because he literally died.

  • @justinianthegreat1444
    @justinianthegreat1444 3 місяці тому

    And he's named after me!

  • @kurtru5selcrowe607
    @kurtru5selcrowe607 5 місяців тому +2

    I am Alpharius.

  • @Masonicon
    @Masonicon 5 місяців тому

    Mk8 armor users good for any firstborn that refuses to undergoes Rubicon Primaris

  • @Balevolt
    @Balevolt 5 місяців тому

    They really missed out by not doing a space marine civil war when they introduced primaris

  • @Eskeletor_210
    @Eskeletor_210 5 днів тому

    I want to see Pedro Kantor as a primaris

  • @thatonekriegguardsmen6140
    @thatonekriegguardsmen6140 5 місяців тому

    I’m pretty sure that Wolf spear got a shorty story

  • @shadowrobot7708
    @shadowrobot7708 4 місяці тому

    I like the space wolf primaris marine that shit talks them about their dumb practices after they keep saying he’s not fenrisian so he’s not a real space wolf.

  • @mobiusZero2
    @mobiusZero2 5 місяців тому

    Damn... I feel bad for him. Black Dragons chapter knows civilians are important too

  • @k.f.m6901
    @k.f.m6901 5 місяців тому +2

    Hey live, Here is a question:
    What is your Oppinion on AFanWithTooMutchTime's Star Wars Vs 40K project?

  • @GlamdringandOrcrist
    @GlamdringandOrcrist 5 місяців тому

    Decimus Felix deserves a shoutout too. I actually prefer him to Justinian primarily thanks to his depiction in The Great Work.