Comcast Sues Warner Bros Because It Wants To Partner On Harry Potter Series

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 18 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 100

  • @liricascelestiales1765
    @liricascelestiales1765 Місяць тому +11

    I hope they’re faithful to the book…. And not make changes

    • @mightheal
      @mightheal Місяць тому +3

      They'll inevitably have to make changes but hopefully they're not bad ones.

    • @emoney6692
      @emoney6692 Місяць тому

      The best thing they can do is keep to the books as much as possible, that way they can win over all the book readers (of which there hundreds of millions) and also the movie fans because then they won’t feel like they’re just watching the exact same thing again. Everyone wins if they stick to the book.

  • @MackAndrewSA
    @MackAndrewSA Місяць тому +4

    I'd watch a series spread out over years. It was clear that they were stressing what to include from the books in later films as the books grew in size as well. Felt like they were skipping over a lot on content. I haven't read the books so readers can confirm or correct me on that, but the latter films felt like they were screaming through the pages of the original text. One book per season sounds perfect.
    Comcast coming off as precious. Gold.

    • @stephennootens916
      @stephennootens916 Місяць тому

      It has been some time since I read the books but they are as I recall vary episodic and some of it will come of a bit weird. Like there is a whole story line about Hermione trying to free the house elves who are pretty much slaves at the school and everyone thinking she os crazy.

  • @ConnerKent08
    @ConnerKent08 Місяць тому +6

    The series is a guarantee cash cow for both American And British television so it’s understandable that Comcast/Sky want the licenses to charge their customers more money to subscribe to their service.

  • @deathswitch2404
    @deathswitch2404 Місяць тому +10

    I saw somewhere that Peter Capaldi was rumored to play Dumbledore and if that isnt the most perfect casting ive ever heard. Imagine being The Doctor and Albus Dumbledore. You could give me 1000 years and id never get that lucky

    • @YellinInMyEar
      @YellinInMyEar Місяць тому +1

      "You trying to be funny?" 12th with First Doctor by his side

    • @deathswitch2404
      @deathswitch2404 Місяць тому +1

      @@YellinInMyEar don't be lasagna, Harry

    • @YellinInMyEar
      @YellinInMyEar Місяць тому

      @@deathswitch2404 😂🤣 That would just be a big cheesy mess.

    • @spifmcgrif84
      @spifmcgrif84 Місяць тому

      I am just picturing Malcolm Tucker in wizard robes…

  • @emoney6692
    @emoney6692 Місяць тому +2

    9:38 I like how Jon paused for Ray’s cough 😂

  • @mix3k818
    @mix3k818 Місяць тому +1

    And now WB is filing C&Ds at a public library (or was is a school?) for having Harry Potter themed events.

  • @callum1327
    @callum1327 Місяць тому +9

    Sky is so expensive in the uk I only use it for football and some hbo shows but man I wish I didn’t have to can’t wait for MAX to come to the uk

    • @FraExpo00
      @FraExpo00 Місяць тому

      Same here in Italy man!

    • @K.H6751
      @K.H6751 Місяць тому +1

      Was then gunnar comment this ! I pay £25 a month for now tv I mainly want it rn for the penguin 😂

    • @kylelovett6420
      @kylelovett6420 Місяць тому

      Get a hacked fire stick.. ez

    • @techbulb3440
      @techbulb3440 Місяць тому

      Same in canada with crave

    • @Sweet_Karma
      @Sweet_Karma Місяць тому

      I cannot wait for HBO MAX to drop in the UK, it can't come soon enough. I really dislike Sky.

  • @ThunderForce2000
    @ThunderForce2000 Місяць тому +3

    One thing I just realised that could be a problem with trying to do a TV series on Harry Potter is the books and the movies were pretty much 95% told from Harry’s point of view which means that the series will likely do the same thing. Considering each season is going to have about 8 to 10 episodes a season is that asking too much for one actor; particularly a child actor?

    • @slimjimnyc270
      @slimjimnyc270 Місяць тому

      @ThunderForce2000. Depends on the kid actor. The new Percy Jackson actor did a great job on the show so it is possible.

  • @isaacmartinez6904
    @isaacmartinez6904 Місяць тому +4

    Well, we just need to wait to see if the Harry Potter show does well.

  • @robertdavidsanders
    @robertdavidsanders Місяць тому +1

    The same guy who did Wizarding World for Universal, Scott Trowbridge, did Galaxy's Edge.

  • @Maz-h8f
    @Maz-h8f Місяць тому +2

    In terms of the showrunners hired by WBro i wish Amazons had hired the best showrunners for Rings of Power.

  • @Mad_Titan_Paresh
    @Mad_Titan_Paresh Місяць тому +2

    Sky is absurdly expensive in the UK. if they lost the rights to show things like Last of Us, House of the Dragon, Penguin they would probably end up losing thousands of subscribers. I'd definitely cancel.

  • @adriankmita
    @adriankmita Місяць тому +2

    Sounds like Theme Park and merchandising rights is what Comcast’s concern is. Universal have a lot of skin in the game with parks in Orlando, Hollywood, Tokyo, etc - If they have to renegotiate that deal for the new HBO series that is going to be a super expensive endeavour for them!

    • @Jake_5693
      @Jake_5693 Місяць тому

      Nothing to do with the theme park rights.
      It’s all about Warner repeatedly breaking their co-production deal with Sky.

    • @adriankmita
      @adriankmita Місяць тому +1

      @@Jake_5693 well that too… as John already said… but the above still applies. Universal (Comcast) only has the theme park rights for the Harry Potter films… not the books or the new HBO series. The Harry Potter themed lands have been the biggest drivers of attendance and revenue the parks have ever seen! So of course the theme park rights are a concern for them. And merchandising rights, while a chunk of this is going to Warner Bros, you can bet Universal gets a percentage of the Warner Bros. merchandise sold at their parks.

    • @Jake_5693
      @Jake_5693 Місяць тому

      @@adriankmita The Theme park rights are negotiated entirely separately and it’s mostly JK that gives the sign off for the the park rights. Warner have very little to do with the parks.
      If this was the case the new universal park in the UK would have a HP land, they’re not going too because Warner have the official HP studio tour down the road and it goes against the terms of their contract.
      If Warner had a say in the theme park rights they wouldn’t be saying no to universal having HP located at their new park 30 minutes up the road.

    • @adriankmita
      @adriankmita Місяць тому +1

      @@Jake_5693 Yes of course the theme park rights are negotiated separately…
      And of course it’s JK that signs off on that as well. But all the Wizarding World theme park elements at the Universal Parks are Warner Bros intellectual property. The production design is recreated from the Warner Bros films. The actors likenesses in the attractions are from Warner Bros films. Some of the merchandise in the theme parks even has the Warner Bros logo on it - many of which were originally manufactured by Noble Collection.
      JK has rights to the character names, but doesn’t have rights to things like Daniel Radcliffe’s likeness… so of course Warner Bros have licensing arrangements with the Universal Parks.
      Never said they had anything to do with the operating of the parks.
      If the rights were just negotiated with JK then the theme park design would just be based on the books - wouldn’t be based on the films. The same way that the Marvel lands at Universal Orlando have nothing to do with Disney IP - not even the merchandise there.
      As for the proposed Universal Studios park in the UK… a Wizarding World land has been proposed for there. But this is so early in development and nothing has been confirmed or announced. The Warner Bros. Studio tour in Watford is completely separate from this. And there are no contract terms that have been released publicly to state there are any restrictions on other Harry Potter attractions within the vicinity of the Studio Tour.

  • @erikthered25
    @erikthered25 Місяць тому +7

    I think Comcast/Sky should sue. WB signs a contract with them and does nothing with the brand for the duration of the contract but conveniently as the contract is coming to an end all of a sudden comes out with this flurry of announcements. It seems as if Zaslav has been working on these deals in secret without talking to Sky. Sky has terrible attorneys because the contract should have required that Warner Brothers put something in production within the time frame of the contract. But since WB Discovery is broke lol I'd tied them up in court forcing them to either let litigate over the next decade or resign the contract under more favorable provisions.

    • @daudimasinde6280
      @daudimasinde6280 Місяць тому +1

      I mean that’s definitely unethical, but is it illegal?

  • @JMANB5
    @JMANB5 Місяць тому +1

    I wonder if all the seasons are going to be equal length.
    The earlier books are a lot shorter than some of the later ones.

  • @curtis4176
    @curtis4176 Місяць тому +1

    Is a deal to allow cable companies latch on to projects normal practice and if so… why? Sounds like a strong arm coercion someone snuck in

  • @Oo2k10
    @Oo2k10 Місяць тому +1

    I feel like Comcast want the piece of the pie because they are heavily invested in Harry Potter theme world at universal studios.

  • @ScarletPhantom-gv9rg
    @ScarletPhantom-gv9rg Місяць тому +3

    All I want for Harry Potter show is to keep Jude Law as Professor Dumbledore and cast Adam Driver as Professor Snape

    • @lightdarksoul2097
      @lightdarksoul2097 Місяць тому

      They won't keep Jude so no one thinks of the FBI movies

  • @j.j.negrontv1111
    @j.j.negrontv1111 Місяць тому +5

    As I reread the books, I’ve realized that this is actually a great idea. The movies were good, but not great adaptations.

  • @jacobwerman1008
    @jacobwerman1008 Місяць тому +1

    Yeah, the Harry Potter world at universal was designed by former imagineers who were unceremoniously released by Disney.

  • @viktorberg4097
    @viktorberg4097 Місяць тому +1

    This is the most ridicolous thing I have heard of.

  • @rorylumley4727
    @rorylumley4727 29 днів тому

    The reason the remake tv series is happening is doing other movies didn't work.

  • @tylerdantonio7022
    @tylerdantonio7022 Місяць тому

    If you like universal Hollywood you’ll definitely wanna check out universal Orlando, especially since the graphic shown in this video of diagon alley is from there lol

  • @rorylumley4727
    @rorylumley4727 29 днів тому

    wonder if this will end up being on peacock.

  • @thesortinghathouses8413
    @thesortinghathouses8413 9 днів тому

    We need a series because the movies made to many mistakes and I would love to see it more closer to the books with a diverse casting

  • @shawnstark7622
    @shawnstark7622 Місяць тому

    I'm not what would be considered a big HP fan, I watched all of them and only found a few to be really good/enjoyable. My question is why so soon for a reboot? It's not like the OG films are that old that new fans cannot be introduced to and enjoy them. I think the earlier films are still timeless enough that can still be relevant in another 10-20 years even. It's of my opinion that reboots don't really need to happen unless an IP went out on a sour note and it's been a few years in resting phase. And for ones that ended on top should rest even longer because those movies are actually still quite good. IDK, just my thoughts.

    • @stephennootens916
      @stephennootens916 Місяць тому

      The two prequels bombed and they hope to milk the IP for all it is worth. The problem of course is JK Rowling has done a great deal of damage to the IP but the studio is hoping to make more money with it. Their hope is she will shut up and just sear in her rumored to black mold infested house while they make a tv series out of her books.

    • @g3nesisprime183
      @g3nesisprime183 Місяць тому

      The movies are good if you never read the books. They're actually a pretty poor adaptation so a more accurate retelling would be very welcome.

  • @Jake_5693
    @Jake_5693 Місяць тому

    You should really read the whole lawsuit. Comcast are 100% correct and Warner have repeatedly broken the terms of the contract for years.
    This lawsuit was inevitable HP or no HP but the HP issue was arguably the straw that broke the camels back.
    Comcast will win this. Maybe HBO/Warner don’t care and they’re willing to pay a shit too of money, but either way they’re in the wrong.
    HBO have have been paid billions from Sky, it’s a very very lucrative deal. If they expect Max to have any sort of material impact in the UK that will make them more money than what Sky pays them they’re delusional.

  • @Ruben-so7pu
    @Ruben-so7pu Місяць тому

    I remember when you glazed over the Rings of Power team and just take a look at how the show turn out.

  • @factualopinion4275
    @factualopinion4275 Місяць тому +1

    im only looking forward to smile 2 & terrifier 3

  • @joeking88
    @joeking88 Місяць тому +2

    I hate Sky. They have had a monopoly on TV for so many years until recently with the introduction of streaming.
    Really hope HBO max comes to the UK rather than them negotiating further

    • @paddynevs5885
      @paddynevs5885 Місяць тому +1

      Me too I want to watch the penguin show but it’s EXCLUSIVE to sky Atlantic witch I can’t get because I’m with virgin media

    • @Sweet_Karma
      @Sweet_Karma Місяць тому

      Same! Hopefully we get HBO Max in 2025/2026 at the latest.

  • @tidus96
    @tidus96 Місяць тому

    Either way, the Wizarding world in their theme parks are gonna need new content to experience from the show!

    • @DmagicMcDurst
      @DmagicMcDurst Місяць тому

      They have no reason to do this other than forcing a reboot....to REBOOT $$$. They could literally just continue the world and characters established. I will never be able to see other actors as these characters. I would rather see new characters or stories around them and their children. So, my hope is this fails hard enough to where they realize and circle back to the original cast. I think thats what is about to happen with LOTR due to "rings of power."

  • @paddynevs5885
    @paddynevs5885 Місяць тому +2

    Warner owns the potter licence so why is universal wanting to get involved

    • @adriankmita
      @adriankmita Місяць тому +1

      Theme park and merchandising rights would be what it’s about.

    • @lightdarksoul2097
      @lightdarksoul2097 Місяць тому

      The parks and merch

    • @Jake_5693
      @Jake_5693 Місяць тому

      Comcast now own Sky which is the UKs biggest satellite TV company.
      Sky for years has hosted HBO content, paying billions for the privilege whilst also signing a contract to co produce certain content. They produced Chernobyl together.
      The co production deal stated Warner/HBO had to submit at minimum 4 shows up for tender every year that Sky could co-produce.
      Sky had to take on at a minimum 2 of these shows and fund them 20-25% of the overall budget but Sky (Comcast) could take on more if they wished.
      HBO/Warner have failed to delivery every single year this deal has been in place, therefore breaking their contract.
      Sky also believe HP should have been a part of this deal and therefore offered as it hits all of the criteria set out in the contract.
      I’ve read the whole lawsuit. If Sky are correct with what they’re saying and they have the receipts Warner have fucked up long before HP and they have broken the contract.

    • @Jake_5693
      @Jake_5693 Місяць тому

      @@adriankmitaNothing about the theme park at all.

  • @jamespatterson7634
    @jamespatterson7634 Місяць тому +1

    SPEW 😂

  • @vishnuradhakrishnan1167
    @vishnuradhakrishnan1167 Місяць тому +1

    They shouldn't have to reinvent the brilliance of the movies. Like for all Potterheads, those movies live in our hearts along with the magic it brought us. The cast itself is irreplaceable and instead of rebooting the franchise as a cash cow, they rather make other movies surrounding the franchise. Warner Bros. should not ruin what has been built and established

  • @jonbroome314
    @jonbroome314 Місяць тому +2

    I will definitely check it out when it begins to air.

  • @jacobholly2096
    @jacobholly2096 Місяць тому +1

    Waste of time I say that because yeah not much were put in the movies but that's what we have the books for to fill in the missing gaps I say that as one of the true Harry Potter fans.

  • @jimtrue1465
    @jimtrue1465 Місяць тому

    When was the last time Hollywood had an original idea?

    • @goodfella1401
      @goodfella1401 Місяць тому

      I think you meant to say. When is Hollywood gonna make less remakes, reboots, sequels and prequels. They have original ideas but either they're movies you might not enjoy because of the genre or story or they're original ideas but executed horribly

    • @lightdarksoul2097
      @lightdarksoul2097 Місяць тому

      Not that long ago but no one watched it

  • @beardedgeektoyreviews836
    @beardedgeektoyreviews836 Місяць тому +3

    The problem with adapting every single word on the page is that it won’t make for very exciting TV series, they need to realise what works on the page doesn’t always translate to the screen which is why certain sub plots and characters were dropped from the movie adaptation. Even Peter Jackson realised that with his LOTR adaptations. I don’t think enough time has passed for this “retelling”, the movies are still recent and very well loved and brilliantly cast, the moment they miss out a section of the books or cast the “wrong” actors for roles, they’ll have lost the fans.
    A far better idea would be a 5 movie series based on the Marauders at school, alongside the rise of Voldemort, ending with Lilly’s sacrifice and Hagrid dropping off Harry at the Dursleys.
    Then adapt Cursed Child stage play into a trilogy of movies, there’s 8 movies there, all with the potential to gross over a billion each at least.
    Thats the path Warners should be going down with the HP franchise.

    • @juanluismendoza8655
      @juanluismendoza8655 Місяць тому

      Isn’t Cursed Child considered really polarizing among Harry Potter fans? Why even make an adaptation of that?

  • @ngin98
    @ngin98 Місяць тому +1

    I think a bug problem atm w/ max series is wb is cheating out on the budgets, if they can’t dish out the big bucks to properly adapt house of the dragon how could they possibly do harry potter

    • @yedigemagavin1694
      @yedigemagavin1694 Місяць тому +5

      If you think that HP series gonna cost as much money as HOTD you are delulu. It’s just children in a castle for most of it. First year magic is mostly levitation and low powered stuff, easily done.
      And HP gonna bring more money than HOTD. A lot more.

    • @Jasaphire
      @Jasaphire Місяць тому +1

      @@yedigemagavin1694 dude regards to you thinking it’s not going to cost as much you are mistaken . It’ll be similar budget if not more cause they A they’ll have go after a list British creame of the crop of actors to play teachers . 2nd to build sets ( and if you think it’ll be cheaper to just film on location at a castle your wrong cause of the cost of historical preservation and insurance which is why even major tentpole films do not film at these locations . 3) let’s say for something for anything that costs £1 will cost them £20 due to recipient of that money knows they can up the price for it being Harry Potter . Do not be fooled into thinking this will be cheaper the GOT of HOTD

    • @mightheal
      @mightheal Місяць тому +2

      @@Jasaphire I do agree the budget will be close to HOTD but the IP sells itself so they do not need known actors and unless they're coming from the MCU or some other big box office franchise those actors would not be making as much as you think they would since they'll signing multi season contracts. Considering they'll be doing at least 7 seasons the sets will pay for themselves in terms of savings since the upfront costs will all be on the first season for the majority of the sets.

    • @Jasaphire
      @Jasaphire Місяць тому

      @@mightheal you do realise for the teachers they will be going for the creame of the crop of actors . And with tv contracts yes they may sign for 7 seasons but there wage is down to a per episode basis and even in American tv you could have actors earning £1 million pound per episode. And I will be shocked if not going after the same calibre on actors ( ie your maggie smiths , alan rickman , Kenneth Branagh , ) as they did in the movies . And you saying sets will pay for themselves that’s not actually cause they have to pay to keep them up in studio spaces during out of production times .. plus new ones per season . Don’t get me wrong im just saying that none of this endeavour is going to be cheap . And yes the IP may sell itself ( that in itself a little bit silly to think we do live in a world where a Star Wars film lost money at box office and same with Wizarding World ip as well ) however because that ip prices on nearly everything will be up as well because vendors know they’ve got the money to pay more ..

    • @mightheal
      @mightheal Місяць тому

      @@Jasaphire Yes it's a per episode basis but to get 1 million per episode that requires specific conditions and even with the cream of the crop that does not apply. The actors you named did not make a lot of money from the movies until later in the series.

  • @kialyoung3173
    @kialyoung3173 Місяць тому +2

    This might just be the linchpin which makes Comcast buy Warner, as rumoured for some time now.
    The HBO content is too important for Sky to lose and with Warner now also being a major competitor against Sky over sport after buying BT Sports, this is just another reason (among many) that might push Brian Roberts to make his move. Either that, or get gobbled up by someone bigger, like Microsoft.
    Further, Comcast is investing an awful lot of money in the UK. We now have Sky Studios based in North London and the expected Universal UK theme park is expected to get the go ahead at the end of the year. The planning application goes to the government this month. Comcast want HP for their theme parks. It's what Star Wars is to Disney.

    • @goodfella1401
      @goodfella1401 Місяць тому +1

      If Comcast does that they're idiots. If you're in the UK you know that. The Universal UK theme park will be a pathetic version of the one in Florida, even lamer than Disneyland Paris is compared to the ones in Tokyo and Orlando. Also Sky has never been popular in the UK. Football supporters for years even have chants on how much they hate Sky. Warner Bros will be like Newcastle United or Man City and Sky is like Liverpool. Yeah Manchester City has broken a lot of rules and Newcastle United's owner ordered a journalist to be tortured and dismembered but most UK football fans still hate Liverpool the most because of the Liverpool that had Kenny Dalglish, Ian Rush, Graeme Souness and Kevin Keegan over 40 years ago. Once people in the UK start hating something it's extremely difficult to change that. Just ask how they felt when Margaret Thatcher died. They hated her for over 30 years for what she did as the prime minister in the 1980s.

    • @Jake_5693
      @Jake_5693 Місяць тому

      HP isn’t going to be present in the universal park here. They don’t want to pay the money for the rights and the studio tour just down the road prevents them from doing it.

  • @alteregobro4826
    @alteregobro4826 Місяць тому +2

    the only thing warner bros should do with the harry potter series is cancel it

  • @luisquintero7359
    @luisquintero7359 Місяць тому +4

    Name a single moment David Zaslav actually made a good decision in his run at WBD cause honestly there’s nothing good came out of his atrocious management.

    • @trevonpernell0814
      @trevonpernell0814 Місяць тому +6

      Creating DC Studios, sparing us Batgirl, turning Max into a profitable streaming service (first Hollywood-vased service to do so), excommunicate the likes of Ann Sarnoff, Toby Emmerich and several others, blunt transparency, generate profit from icensing, cutting a CRAPTON of dead weight.
      I can go on.

    • @Phoenix-ti6tx
      @Phoenix-ti6tx Місяць тому +5

      ​@@trevonpernell0814 exactly

    • @tommietravis5274
      @tommietravis5274 Місяць тому +3

      Giving James Gunn the reigns over DC studios.

    • @trevonpernell0814
      @trevonpernell0814 Місяць тому +2

      @@tommietravis5274 Creating DC Studios in the first place. It still amazes me that it took ZASLAV to create a DC vertical completely separate from WB Pictures. How that wasn't created ages ago is beyond me.

  • @mark-zuberrodrigues
    @mark-zuberrodrigues Місяць тому +4

    Just make the cursed child with the original cast. Nobody wants this show

    • @mercedesf1fan176
      @mercedesf1fan176 Місяць тому +4

      You don’t understand HP is like an event with particular arcs you can’t get sick of

    • @francescoardizzoni17
      @francescoardizzoni17 Місяць тому +3

      Nobody wants the cursed child either. It fucked the entire story

    • @smcauley600
      @smcauley600 Місяць тому +1

      just cause you don't want it doesn't nobody wants it

    • @toshtao1
      @toshtao1 Місяць тому +2

      Emma Watson and Daniel Radclife won't come back if J.K. Rowling gets paid.

  • @jeebs621
    @jeebs621 Місяць тому +1

    I sure hope the show is cancelled because of this

  • @benjamingauchat5221
    @benjamingauchat5221 Місяць тому

    I think that the Series isn't going forward, i mean that Comcast is probably going to get the rights to Harry Potter because Warner Bros would write it as a Tax write off, Comcast probably wants it for Peacock TV.