I really feel like my character had quite an arc over the course of this game. I started out very low honor. I was a cowboy and a notorious member of a gang, I dressed sharply, and bought expensive things. I did whatever it took to get money, I robbed good people, and didn't think twice about snuffing out witnesses, or sending a message, but I was always loyal to the gang and I did at least give them their share, that said anytime there was a choice to be made revolving around money... I always made the wrong one. Near the end of the game when it gets revealed that I have an uncurbable disease, and after the fiasco in San Denis and watching the gang slowly fall apart after that, I really started to let myself go as I reflected on my actions. I grew out my beard long and unkept, my attire choice looked rugged, and I stopped killing people. I even started looking to help people on occasion when I saw them in need which was something I would just blow past before. And at the end of the game when I was presented with a choice of going back for the money or helping someone important to me, that choice felt really hard, but it felt even more powerful when my character overcame his past behavior and decided I wasn't going to abandon my friend. Yea I got the low honor version but that hit just as hard to be honest. Because my character was not a good man, not one bit and yea I tried my best to atone for all I had done near the end... but it just wasn't enough. That shit was tragic but damn if it wasn't a compelling story. It also made the revenge against Micha feel even better knowing that he personally killed Arthur in my game.
I think that the thing about the low honor way to play the game is that you are accepting your own nature and are decided to go down with it. In the low honor gameplay Arthur is not kidding himself by thinking he has a chance at redemption just because he's doing some good deed here and there. For this reason, his last good deeds ring more true.
@@suleymanbabak1973 Oh yea, that all was definitely at play in my playthrough. I was never under the impression that I was suddenly the good guy, or that I deserved a better ending, I was very happy with the one I got actually. It was more about facing down my own mortality and just going "Why am I doing these things?" The senseless violence just didn't make any sense anymore, it genuinely just felt bad at that point in the story. Slowly coming to the realization that my story was ending, suddenly the only thing that mattered anymore was the gang that I'd been loyal to the whole game.
that has to be one of the best play throughs ive ever heard of. Despite the fact ik the litreal story in and out you still made it feel like i heard it for the first time. Beatifuel. You didn't lie to yourself about how you were a good man like some high hornor players do. You were a man and faced your destiny and stared down the barrel of your own morality. Really really well described. Idk why this got to me so much i just think i really got a new realization for low hornor playthrough. You sir, changed my view on low hornor. Hats off!
Truth be told, all those angles and I wouldn’t be able to relate to them. Hell is my home, it’s where my fellow outlaws reside where else could I possibly want to go?
@@BlackFlash_EDiTZ why don’t you think so, the tragedy of the story is that despite all that Arthur does he lived by the gun and he will die by the gun, Arthur doesn’t deserve a good death after all that happens.
Despite how sad this is? The music is actually really relaxing. Like taking a looooong overdue rest after a marathon of activity and a monsoon of emotions.
I just thought of what happened. Go back for the money is like Arthur's last moments going down hill quite literally and figuratively. With high honor go back for the money, Arthur was a good man, but he always went back down to his ways. Low honor go for the money is like Arthur going way down, without even trying to redeem himself. Helping john is like rising to a higher point, ascending from the outlaw life. High honor help John is like Arthur ascending and fully redeeming himself, taking a chance. Low hinir help John is like Arthur tried in the end to redeem himself, but it was too late. That's why Help john is going to the top of a mountain, and money is going down, it reflects your honor
@@hankhilll4651My first was high honor, had something to do with the shocking realism of the game. Eventually though I got desensitized and now let’s just say it gets interesting.
Losing Arthur to me felt like losing my da. He wasnt a good man for most of his life but he taught me good lessons for life and as I saw him grow from a strong lawless member a of a gang to a weaker more empathetic and regretful man it changed me his death was the first time I ever cried for a video game character. "You Don't Get To Live A Bad Life And Have Good Things Happen To You." -Arthur Morgan
May your dad rest in peace. In the train robbing mission, in Chapter 2, when Sean mentions his Da, did that make you laugh? Sorry if I'm being insensitive, I'm just curious
High honor is more of a realistic ending for Arthur because Micah always wanted to be better than Arthur and he was waiting for Arthur to get more sicker and when he did Micah picked him off. Micah will always be known as a coward and a snake. The difference between a snitch and a snake is that a snitch only gives them information about their whereabouts.. but a snake.. he wants to ruin other's life and only cares for himself. Edit: this comment was from a year ago and I meant high honor not low honor sorry for the confusion lol 😅
Low honor isn't the cannon ending for RDR2 because john get's away safely because of Arthur If arthur would have chosen the money John would have been screwed therefore High honor is the cannon ending.
Meh, if you want to play as an asshole, that’s on you. I believe I’ll play again with the intentions of robbing and killing as I please. But, really. For many it’s so gratifying being a decent character. These decisions are what makes the game feel salient.
Rockstar did amazingly well with rdr2 one of my most anticipated games besides halo and they also did an amazingly job with these songs for each chapter . I can definitely say I made high honor and authors death was a touching one that no other game out there touch us the way red dead redemption did .
He will wipe every tear from their eyes. There will be no more death’ or mourning or crying or pain, for the old order of things has passed away.” Revelation 21:4
Im listening to this while i replay rdr2 and damn it hits different when you know whats gonna happen its just depressing as you know whats gonna happen to arthur
I miss Arthur. I know I can turn the game on whenever and play as him. But I miss him. After losing him in the first playthrough, it's like I'm permanently mourning him.
I could feel nothing but death creeping in my shadow,the portending imminent doom. The feeling that you have lost a battle. This song captures that same feeling
The bad honer version screams to me that Arthur did not stand unshaken amidst a crashing world, instead he succumbed to the evil that was all around him and instead of being a light in the darkness he chose to join in and become part of all the greed, hate, anger, thievery and murder that is wrong in the world of Red Dead and the final relazation that he was no better than Micha, just a wolf feeding off the weak. I never finished the game with the bad karma Arthur because I think he is supposed to be a becon of hope and good in the mostly grim world hes trapped in and "stand unshaken in a crashing world."
Theory: This whole time, the coyote was Micah. If you have low honor, you will dream of the black coyote walking around, as if they were looking for something or someone. Dreams with low honor meant a hidden warning to Arthur that Micah was coming to kill him. That dead bear in the background, it was Arthur who for me, I see him as a bear that defeated and hurt many people.
I think it’s interesting but I personally always thought Arthur was always a wolf. Someone who stalks and prays on the weak and kills without remorse…eh YT ain’t gonna let this pass though the censor
never have i ever cried for anything tv, movie, videogame related......But this, Arthurs death, oh my fucking god I was bawling like a baby then staring at the credits just unable to move or touch the controller.
May I stand unshaken for sure my first run on red dead redemption wasn’t a good one I took my anger on npcs not realizing the story was about Arthurs redemption I regret not taking the story more seriously the first time around
Im currently on my low honor playthorugh. But i don't think i'll finish that. Or continue to be a heartless bastard. Sure, i go for the most kills in a gunfight, wiped out the town of van horn, shot the guy in strawberry who beat me in five-finger-fillet(three times) and robbed+murdered several trains of people...but i still don't steal money from the womens rights activist or kill women lost in the wild. It really feels bad after a while. I also don't wanna do straiss missions because i despise the man and his business. Honest robbing is how i make money. I didn't help mary. I still complete camp requests. I'm nice to most people in camp. I'm just before the mission with sean in rhodes...i don't wanna go on. I want to shove my thousands of dollars into dutchs face, grab everyone except micah(and bill) and leave for the west. *sigh*
![Lp. Сердце Вселенной #60 РОЖДЕНИЕ ЛОЛОЛОШКИ [Финал] • Майнкрафт](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/YoR0pAV9FVQ/mqdefault.jpg)
This song plays like an old wound that keeps being opened up, and all you can do is sit there and let it bleed.
Says the guy with the stage 4 eateot pic
@@Luka2000_ fr
@@Luka2000_ says the guy with Dr.Freeman pic
Better yet its like a cough that slowly kills you, and you cant do ANYTHING to help it
@@dragutintheslav-veliki790 we love the freeman
“Blessed are those who mourn, for they will be comforted.” 💐
yes
And the fish
@@evanlarsky2295 I ate a fish
@@posadist681noooooo!!
@@tales-frontier Hehe 😈
I know he died 124 years ago but... Im still crying for him
125
@@ObamaBinLaden792 now in 2024
same brother same
@@ObamaBinLaden792 no cause they refrance it nearing winter at the end of arthur's run
He's a fictional character 😂
God Damn.. I've never heard something so sad yet it's so good..
Indeed...
@@tgtmeDidn't expect to see you here.
@@tgtmedamn, when's the next edit coming?
@@TrueUnderlier On its way, friend!
I really feel like my character had quite an arc over the course of this game. I started out very low honor. I was a cowboy and a notorious member of a gang, I dressed sharply, and bought expensive things. I did whatever it took to get money, I robbed good people, and didn't think twice about snuffing out witnesses, or sending a message, but I was always loyal to the gang and I did at least give them their share, that said anytime there was a choice to be made revolving around money... I always made the wrong one. Near the end of the game when it gets revealed that I have an uncurbable disease, and after the fiasco in San Denis and watching the gang slowly fall apart after that, I really started to let myself go as I reflected on my actions. I grew out my beard long and unkept, my attire choice looked rugged, and I stopped killing people. I even started looking to help people on occasion when I saw them in need which was something I would just blow past before. And at the end of the game when I was presented with a choice of going back for the money or helping someone important to me, that choice felt really hard, but it felt even more powerful when my character overcame his past behavior and decided I wasn't going to abandon my friend. Yea I got the low honor version but that hit just as hard to be honest. Because my character was not a good man, not one bit and yea I tried my best to atone for all I had done near the end... but it just wasn't enough. That shit was tragic but damn if it wasn't a compelling story. It also made the revenge against Micha feel even better knowing that he personally killed Arthur in my game.
I think that the thing about the low honor way to play the game is that you are accepting your own nature and are decided to go down with it. In the low honor gameplay Arthur is not kidding himself by thinking he has a chance at redemption just because he's doing some good deed here and there. For this reason, his last good deeds ring more true.
@@suleymanbabak1973 Oh yea, that all was definitely at play in my playthrough. I was never under the impression that I was suddenly the good guy, or that I deserved a better ending, I was very happy with the one I got actually. It was more about facing down my own mortality and just going "Why am I doing these things?" The senseless violence just didn't make any sense anymore, it genuinely just felt bad at that point in the story. Slowly coming to the realization that my story was ending, suddenly the only thing that mattered anymore was the gang that I'd been loyal to the whole game.
Same I just can’t play without low honour I don’t get how people have good honour
that has to be one of the best play throughs ive ever heard of. Despite the fact ik the litreal story in and out you still made it feel like i heard it for the first time. Beatifuel. You didn't lie to yourself about how you were a good man like some high hornor players do. You were a man and faced your destiny and stared down the barrel of your own morality. Really really well described. Idk why this got to me so much i just think i really got a new realization for low hornor playthrough. You sir, changed my view on low hornor. Hats off!
Arthur himself wrote this comment
When you force Uncle to do work despite his lumbago.
😂
@@zacy-t2771 its not a joke... its very serious
It very serious
😂😂😂
The reason Uncle drinks:
- Helps him "think"
- Relieves the lumbago
holy hell, this really is the call of the devil…it’s like he tells arthur you had your chance, but you’ve missed it, now, hell awaits…
he would have gone to hell anyway.
the man owed them money, and spit or coughed on arthur intentionally to get him sick.@user-zu8mj5nb1z
@havana80that’s why is redemption
Truth be told, all those angles and I wouldn’t be able to relate to them. Hell is my home, it’s where my fellow outlaws reside where else could I possibly want to go?
@havana9979I know right and those broke bastards still made me go and collect the debt in person!
Arthur: “I tried....in the end...i did".
The Angel of Death getting ready to swing his sythe: “Trying doesn't matter when you always fail".
Bring it on! Ain’t repent alive and ain’t going to now!…you gotta stand by what you lived for…
The contrary, trying is all that matters.
"You're not better than me Morgan..."
Whatever you say you fool….
@@donqpr3387 Damn you...
@@Alex-kq4tn DAMN US BOTH
I Came to take what’s mine…. You… RAT 🐀
@@donqpr3387B O O M
If you have Low honor: YOU HAD YOUR CHANCE YOU FOOL
If you have High honor: you made the right choice cowboy
Low honor is canon lol
@@ralphgilster2767
no it ain’t
@@BlackFlash_EDiTZ why don’t you think so, the tragedy of the story is that despite all that Arthur does he lived by the gun and he will die by the gun, Arthur doesn’t deserve a good death after all that happens.
@@BlackFlash_EDiTZ yes it is, Charles found Arthur dead on the mountain, Low end is cannon
@@RobertPacocha-yu8li that changes depending on how you play it, read what I said and tell me. Does his soul outweigh his actions?
Despite how sad this is? The music is actually really relaxing. Like taking a looooong overdue rest after a marathon of activity and a monsoon of emotions.
“Revenge is a fools game”
-Arthur Morgan 1899
exact reason why I helped john
"IT'S JOHN MARSTON, MICAH!"
I just thought of what happened. Go back for the money is like Arthur's last moments going down hill quite literally and figuratively. With high honor go back for the money, Arthur was a good man, but he always went back down to his ways. Low honor go for the money is like Arthur going way down, without even trying to redeem himself. Helping john is like rising to a higher point, ascending from the outlaw life. High honor help John is like Arthur ascending and fully redeeming himself, taking a chance. Low hinir help John is like Arthur tried in the end to redeem himself, but it was too late.
That's why Help john is going to the top of a mountain, and money is going down, it reflects your honor
"Half as long..."
"Twice as bright "
Makes you regret your choices “what have i done” the remembering every npc you gunned down for a quick laugh
I didn't even know there was a low honor version. I can't bring myself to make Arthur anything but a good man
Me too I’ve played the game three times and I’ve always got the sunrise ending with maximum honor
I've done multiple playthroughs and have never seen a buck vision.
@@Emadrat58 How? I can't help myself, all my playthroughs have been low low honor
@@hankhilll4651My first was high honor, had something to do with the shocking realism of the game. Eventually though I got desensitized and now let’s just say it gets interesting.
I completed this game 4 times and always i had high honor help John ending. Can't be a bad guy
Losing Arthur to me felt like losing my da. He wasnt a good man for most of his life but he taught me good lessons for life and as I saw him grow from a strong lawless member a of a gang to a weaker more empathetic and regretful man it changed me his death was the first time I ever cried for a video game character.
"You Don't Get To Live A Bad Life And Have Good Things Happen To You."
-Arthur Morgan
May your dad rest in peace.
In the train robbing mission, in Chapter 2, when Sean mentions his Da, did that make you laugh? Sorry if I'm being insensitive, I'm just curious
@@RykerSmith-hu9ob ah nah its all good,
it did a little, i absolutey loved sean as a charcater
Well you do actually Arthur, most of men have lived far worse than you gunslinger. Some people even call hero’s
Literally the best melody i ever heard.
Thanks a lot.
You did a masterpiece, goosebumps everywhere here 🔥
goosebumps on my cocco
This is the song that plays when ever you realize you’ve been playing the villain the whole time
"Blessed are those who can mourn for they will be conforted"
Playing this while it rains outside hits different
High honor is more of a realistic ending for Arthur because Micah always wanted to be better than Arthur and he was waiting for Arthur to get more sicker and when he did Micah picked him off. Micah will always be known as a coward and a snake. The difference between a snitch and a snake is that a snitch only gives them information about their whereabouts.. but a snake.. he wants to ruin other's life and only cares for himself.
Edit: this comment was from a year ago and I meant high honor not low honor sorry for the confusion lol 😅
Low honor isn't the cannon ending for RDR2 because john get's away safely because of Arthur
If arthur would have chosen the money
John would have been screwed therefore
High honor is the cannon ending.
@@0THNIEL i wasn't talking about the canon ending
Yeah, finished the game at low honor because good honor is too nice imo.
@@0THNIEL John wouldn’t be screwed Arthur diverted attention away from John lol
Meh, if you want to play as an asshole, that’s on you. I believe I’ll play again with the intentions of robbing and killing as I please. But, really. For many it’s so gratifying being a decent character. These decisions are what makes the game feel salient.
Rockstar did amazingly well with rdr2 one of my most anticipated games besides halo and they also did an amazingly job with these songs for each chapter . I can definitely say I made high honor and authors death was a touching one that no other game out there touch us the way red dead redemption did .
He will wipe every tear from their eyes. There will be no more death’ or mourning or crying or pain, for the old order of things has passed away.” Revelation 21:4
If you listen to this song while imagining Arthur slowly plunging into a void for all the things he's done, it becomes extremely frightening
"You let him damn us all Dutch"
Come on Dutch we gotta go Dutch….. let’s….. go I ….. never…. DUTCH
Well……. ( grab the knife )well I must say Arthur …… is been quite of fun…. ( stab in the back)
CANNOT STAY AWAY HUH BLACK LUNG… ?! You should have fled away with your friend marston ! Let the money be💰
No song gets me sadder than this
Try Guts theme
Boy
This sound better than the one in the game and that’s sayin a lot👍🏾👍🏾
Im still mourning Arthurs death and its been 4 years
i give you all i had Dutch
everybody does.
5 now
@@AndJusticeForAll66 Don't remind Me micah
Rockstar missed a huge opportunity for Arthur to encounter the Strange Man. That would've been interesting.
Arthur always encountered Trelawny
@@NAA81-d5zhe isn't the strange man though
@NBAI823 sure they may look alike but they do not act alike
If I die I want this to play at funeral
The low honor version!?
If?
@@evlogan6543 his goals are beyond our understanding
@@Dan4G oh my bad
"if"? is bro implying he is naturally immortal?
Im listening to this while i replay rdr2 and damn it hits different when you know whats gonna happen its just depressing as you know whats gonna happen to arthur
The chills that run down my spine hearing the darker and evil version of this song.
"You're not better than me, Morgan!"
"Whatever you say , you fool."
"Damn you."
"Damn us both!"
"Tennis boat"
@@KEP1LERmay I stand on chicken
@@William_afton77
Yes, not a problem.
@@KEP1LER or meatttt I miss the passion bold
"Damn us both"
_*TENNIS BOAT_🗣️*
*revolver shot* HAHAHA
You carry the weight of your sins like a burden that never fades. You know what you’ve done, and no matter how hard you try, you can’t forget.
Damn never realized this version is eerie asf but still beautiful
I love this
I miss Arthur. I know I can turn the game on whenever and play as him. But I miss him. After losing him in the first playthrough, it's like I'm permanently mourning him.
Damn this is sad…
This song creeps me as f4 and it makes me think of Arthur more and more makes me more sad
I could feel nothing but death creeping in my shadow,the portending imminent doom. The feeling that you have lost a battle. This song captures that same feeling
"I gave u all I had I did but in the end it doesn't matter"
-Arthur Morgan
REST IN PEACE 🙏 🕊 🧡
The bad honer version screams to me that Arthur did not stand unshaken amidst a crashing world, instead he succumbed to the evil that was all around him and instead of being a light in the darkness he chose to join in and become part of all the greed, hate, anger, thievery and murder that is wrong in the world of Red Dead and the final relazation that he was no better than Micha, just a wolf feeding off the weak. I never finished the game with the bad karma Arthur because I think he is supposed to be a becon of hope and good in the mostly grim world hes trapped in and "stand unshaken in a crashing world."
Replaying this game in low honor felt unreal
Is it messed up I want this song played on repeat at my funeral?
You're Gonna die with Low Honor
Same here brother
Yes unless you mean the high honor version.
@@samreddig8819 You Know Damn Well No Ones Getting The High Honor If They Play GTA And Rdr2
@@Existent_Human 80% of Red dead players: 🫥
a silence minute for who hasn't heard this yet
Theory: This whole time, the coyote was Micah. If you have low honor, you will dream of the black coyote walking around, as if they were looking for something or someone. Dreams with low honor meant a hidden warning to Arthur that Micah was coming to kill him. That dead bear in the background, it was Arthur who for me, I see him as a bear that defeated and hurt many people.
I think it’s interesting but I personally always thought Arthur was always a wolf. Someone who stalks and prays on the weak and kills without remorse…eh YT ain’t gonna let this pass though the censor
This music was the last thing Micah Bell heard before he dropped dead.
imagine if instead of being shot by micah instead of him dying at peace facing the sunset he died facing the thunder and lighting cackling
He never sees the sun in the low honor ending; he dies to Micah instantly from either a knife or gunshot before the sun rises.
Nah I prefer Micah
Low Honor has the best music in this game
Arthur legend red dead redemption 2😭😭😭😭😭😭
the geatest game i've ever played in my life
Geatest
I agree
Imagine hearing this at you funeral
SOMEONE PUT THIS ON SPOTIFY PLEASEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
"Welcome To Hell."
“My kinda people”
Thats my boah
High honor next
I'm a high honor player, but I gotta say, this version of the song sounds so much better
never have i ever cried for anything tv, movie, videogame related......But this, Arthurs death, oh my fucking god I was bawling like a baby then staring at the credits just unable to move or touch the controller.
Me too omggg
I literally have never ever cried from a video game, but the end hit me so damn hard
''DAMN US BOTH!'' -Arthur Morgan 1899
Reminds me of the desert I was raised in....endless sand....endless to the sun departing... with one lonely desert tree
It's 2025. You're still the greatest, Arthur Morgan.
I can't stand unshaken...
Amazing 👏🏿
May I stand unshaken for sure my first run on red dead redemption wasn’t a good one I took my anger on npcs not realizing the story was about Arthurs redemption I regret not taking the story more seriously the first time around
Ohhhhh No
This Song..))))))😭😭❤️
When you ended the Chapter 6 on the lowest honor ever:
I wish Low honor had it's own set of missions.
Arthur I gave you everything I had I did 1899
pov: you see dutch honor
Well fellas glad we’re here together
Just recommending you should do a high honor version.
Pain
Nice bro 😁
The song made me cry
This is theme of my anxiety meets depression.
This is indeed Arthur’s eternal damnation into Hell theme.
"damn us both"
💥💥
This is masterpiece song
I hit max honor after giving the money to Mrs. Downes, it felt cinematic
Do you have the video picture in full quality? I'm considering tattooing it.
I just take a screenshot from a other video
I don't recommend you to do that
tattoo the uncle and when someone asks the meaning, you just say lumbago
@@Ahlem_DMC why? Is cool
Did you did that bro?
“Keep facing the rising sun and the shadows will fall behind you”
Only 1899 kid now this
Tennis boat :(
Its been a hard few months boys..
مستر مورجن 🦅 😓 جون لا يشبهك ابداً
"Looks like I damned us all Frank." Michael De Santa GTA Option D Fan Fiction Ending
“God damn is both!”-Arthur Morgan
When you cant find gavin
💀
masterpiece
Loss is pain to be alone for life is i don't know how to feel
"Welcome to hell, Morgan."
"I ain't changed I'm still a bad man" - Arthur Morgan
When you have lowest honor in the game:
The ending music:
Blessed are the peace makers
amazing...
Thanks
it sounds like like im entering hell
Im currently on my low honor playthorugh. But i don't think i'll finish that. Or continue to be a heartless bastard. Sure, i go for the most kills in a gunfight, wiped out the town of van horn, shot the guy in strawberry who beat me in five-finger-fillet(three times) and robbed+murdered several trains of people...but i still don't steal money from the womens rights activist or kill women lost in the wild.
It really feels bad after a while. I also don't wanna do straiss missions because i despise the man and his business. Honest robbing is how i make money.
I didn't help mary. I still complete camp requests. I'm nice to most people in camp.
I'm just before the mission with sean in rhodes...i don't wanna go on. I want to shove my thousands of dollars into dutchs face, grab everyone except micah(and bill) and leave for the west.
*sigh*
Same here. Dreading that mission and everything else that's aboutta come. +Low honor actions sure do make me feel bad about myself 🙁
This is what Micah heard when he died