I wish the Daleks stayed this scary, I like Moffat's work a little more, but Russel T Davies really made the Daleks work, but their fear factor already started to diminsh after season 1.
@@tarnyowl6068 Nup. A dalek's greatest weapon is it's knowledge. Even with it's newly downloaded internet it still out smarts most species in the solar system and most galaxies
They waited ten years for the callback, but they got there. Doctor: You're gonna get *Rusty*. (Many Seasons Later) Rusty: You are a good Dalek. (Took me a while to get there, but if there's such a thing as a 'good' Dalek, it's The Doctor.)
both lines mean very different things though. in into the dalek Rusty is telling the doctor that they are alike in that they both came from violent roots but eventually turned good (good, as in, nice/kind). in Dalek, the dalek is telling the doctor that he would make an efficient killer.
@@robertslipek7311 in Dalek it's more that the Doctor's words are very similar to the Dalek/Nazi ethos of inferior races. It knows that the Doctor is an efficient killer. It will know of the Doctor's prior encounters, both during and before the Time War.
Anyone find it funny when the Dalek shouts “Where shall i get my orders now?!” It’s like they don’t know what to do with their lives beyond eternal galactic genocide
That’s because they don’t. I’ve heard once that if the Daleks ever actually won, they’d go insane from despair and kill each other, simply because there would be nothing left to aspire to.
@@knightofarkronia9968 Its likely they'd cause another civil war. It's common already for factions of daleks to see each other as impure, not just genetically but culturally, and as not living up to the dalek ideal.
It's not the line that makes this episode so special, it's the episode that comes with it. The Eccleston episode deals with the Doctor's anger and PTSD, and he is a better person by the end of it. The Capaldi episode, the Dalek just says the Doctor is a good Dalek, and neither the Dalek nor the Doctor do anything after that. It feels empty, specially when we have a much better sene to compare it with. Capaldi is the best Doctor yet in my opinion, but Moffat's writting is all about hype and one-shots, it never delievered anything. "I win. How about that?" They don't write these like this no nmore.
the line in 'Into the Dalek' means something completely different. 'good' is used here as in 'functional' or 'efficient'. the doctor would make a good dalek because he's bloodthirsty. in into the dalek, the dalek is telling the doctor that, like him, he is a dalek TURNED good (good, as in, kind, nice, etc). idk why so many doctor who fans completely misread this.
@@SegaNintendoGuy64 other iconoc lines "but do I have the right" "There should have been another way." "In all my travelling throughout the universe, I have battled against evil, against power-mad conspirators. I should have stayed here. The oldest civilisation: decadent, degenerate, and rotten to the core. Power-mad conspirators, Daleks, Sontarans, Cybermen - they're still in the nursery compared to us. Ten million years of absolute power. That's what it takes to be really corrupt." "Homo sapiens. What an inventive, invincible species. It's only a few million years since they've crawled up out of the mud and learned to walk. Puny, defenceless bipeds. They've survived flood, famine and plague. They've survived cosmic wars and holocausts, and now here they are amongst the stars, waiting to begin a new life, ready to outsit eternity. They're indomitable. Indomitable!" and finally "change my dear and it seems not a moment too soon" if you can name every episode then you can have a cookie Lol
Utttly superb. When Doctor Who is this good it is some of the best Sci Fi in the world. Every series has episodes and moments that are memorable TV. Just keep them coming please (when it is eventually is possible!)
I can see why so many people have placed this as there most favorite Eccleston episode and maybe the best Dalek story of the new series But I’m still with The Parting of the Ways for the best Dalek episode of the new series but this is a wonderful and powerful script
I feel like the best scenes with the doctor and daleks happen through a screen or any kind of system where they aren’t physically next to each other. Any scene with the doctor and daleks actually face to face feels wrong to me.
@@jeckjeck3119 There've been plenty of other occasions though where the Doctor and a Dalek have been face to face with one another, and they've not tried killing him (and his survival wasn't some necessary part of a plan).
@@Vlorsutes There is explanation for that too, but it only works up to series 9: The doctor is a part of their history, he saves Davors, without Davros, they don't exist or survive. That's why they are hesitant to kill him, despite their bloodlust, if they kill him (Let's say) in series 5... 12th doesn't go back to save Davros and they all die.
2 of the best moments in Doctor Who, both from the same phenomenal episode, released within a few days of each other! FANTASTIC! Happy 15th "Dalek"! Wish every episode was like this.
Could you imagine if this was actually it. If we NEVER got another Dalek again. The most terrifying foe of old Who and all that's left is one scared little slug
Back when Dalek's were truly threatening and terrifying. The sheer presence of one sent dread and chills down my spine. Now they are a joke. I want to see this kind of darkness and anger again.
Two beings of the last of their kind: one shows anger, hatred to the other, willing to kill it without second chance. The other is a Dalek who only want orders and later one to be free
There's a lesson in this. If you allow yourself to become just as bad as your enemy, then it doesn't matter if you win. Becoming your enemy means they have won, regardless of the outcome. And their essence will outlive them and follow you for as long as you live.
This is still probably the best exchange between the Doctor and a Dalek. For him to argue the Dalek into a corner, trying to force it to accept the pointlessness of its existence because all it has to live for is hatred and then the Dalek to get the psychological upperhand by turning it back on him. Genius writing.
@@fear_cheetah2079 Yes, but the Daleks have been used throughout the show well more often than The Master has. I'm almost certain that every Doctor besides McGann TV-wise has had at least one Dalek story if not more where as alot of Doctors haven't even come in contact with the rival timelord at least in terms of the show.
@Lee227 yeah but the important thing is that the other guy mentioned stalking the doctor. The daleks have never stalked him. In most of the master stories, the master is actively looking for the doctor, in most Dalek stories the meeting is just coincidence
@@fear_cheetah2079 that scene is epic he has alot of great moments but this just tops it as he his able to realese all his hate and anguish he holds against the Daleks and it is thrown right back at him
The darkness that involves the Daleks and the Time War is what also makes this a great episode! This scene is one of the Ninth Doctor’s iconic scenes during Series 1!
“You would make a good Dalek”- Dalek from the episode “Dalek” “I am not a good Dalek, you are a good Dalek” -Rusty Which come to think about it, the Doctor would really be a good Dalek. Since he/she is the most feared person in the universe..
Plus, there’s the intense hatred that flows through the Doctor’s veins. The Daleks only find beauty in hate. Perhaps there’s a reason why they’ve never been able to kill the Doctor...
The genuine sadness and self-pity in the Dalek asking the Doctor "Then what should I do?" is such a beautiful little moment. The Daleks are often characterised as mindless killer robots, but that moment, of the Dalek questioning its existential purpose, asking its worst enemy what to do in the face of the destruction of its entire species, is an excellent reminder of why it is an imperative that writers treat them as thinking beings.
What would’ve been equally as hard is if the doctor despite hate was willing to offer the bot hope of a new purpose, telling it to protect what is good and destroy what seeks to only destroy for the sake of causing destruction but the dalek takes up his offer the wrong way and kills itself, reasoning since it was created for the purpose of destroying simply to destroy that it itself needed to be destroyed
The Dalek told the Ninth "You would make a good Dalek." Then many years later Rusty told the Twelfth "You are a good Dalek." over 1100 years bridged the gap from would make to are.
That realization that your heart is filled with such hate as your enemy tells you that you'd be a good one of them.
One of the best scenes of Eccleston's era, maybe even Davies' era.
@Quinn Thomas that’s not an episode
One of the best of the entire show
The inspiration for this is an audio drama Doctor Who Jubilee
Definitely the best episode to reintroduce the Daleks to a new audience and make them feel huge straight away.
I wish the Daleks stayed this scary, I like Moffat's work a little more, but Russel T Davies really made the Daleks work, but their fear factor already started to diminsh after season 1.
I don’t even Doctor Who and even I know that “You would make a good Dalek” hits so damn hard... chills
Do you even Doctor Who bro?
@@theknightoftheburningpestle I don’t bro, but that scene goes hard bruh! 😂
@@victormgvDoctor Who goes harder than I would of thought, I'm just getting into it. The show doesn't hold back a lot. Lol.
Watch it, it’s really addicting.
The fact a Dalek was smart enough to use its weapon once to combine electricity with water was amazing!
Make Daleks smart again!
Well he did download the internet so the idea probably came from there
@@tarnyowl6068 Nup. A dalek's greatest weapon is it's knowledge. Even with it's newly downloaded internet it still out smarts most species in the solar system and most galaxies
Daleks are always smart, they always thrive on smart ways of killing.
The dalek is extremely smart in Resolution it used the body of a human to get another casing for itself.
@@dubliam8064 Why I Can't Wait to see the Next Dalek Story this holiday Season Scents Chinbail Knows How too Write Them so Far,Don't Mess up Chinbail
I always get chills down my spine when this scene comes up, such a dark and incredible story
Oh Nine, I miss you so. Eccleston was truely fantastic. And that line ... it gets me the chills, each time.
Same
They waited ten years for the callback, but they got there.
Doctor: You're gonna get *Rusty*.
(Many Seasons Later)
Rusty: You are a good Dalek.
(Took me a while to get there, but if there's such a thing as a 'good' Dalek, it's The Doctor.)
That's what I think when the Doctor says that lol
Doctor "You're gonna get rusty"
Dalek "who is rusty ?"
This quality of Doctor Who won't be topped for a long time.
More like ever at this point.
@@dr.feelgoodmalusphillips2475 chibnall pretty much robbed us from ever getting good stories with the whole timeless child thing
@@HarleyCringe I hope to God it gets retconned.
Christopher Eccleston was amazing as the doctor and truthfully he brought Doctor who back
Doctor: "why don't you just DIE !!!"
Dalek: "you would make a good Dalek"
Dalek: You would make a good Dalek
Into the Dalek: You are a good Dalek
Dalek: "You're gonna get Rusty"
Into the Dalek: The Dalek is Rusty
both lines mean very different things though. in into the dalek Rusty is telling the doctor that they are alike in that they both came from violent roots but eventually turned good (good, as in, nice/kind). in Dalek, the dalek is telling the doctor that he would make an efficient killer.
@@robertslipek7311
He/She *is* an efficient killer.
9: You're going to get rusty
12: I'll call you Rusty
@@robertslipek7311 in Dalek it's more that the Doctor's words are very similar to the Dalek/Nazi ethos of inferior races. It knows that the Doctor is an efficient killer. It will know of the Doctor's prior encounters, both during and before the Time War.
Anyone find it funny when the Dalek shouts “Where shall i get my orders now?!” It’s like they don’t know what to do with their lives beyond eternal galactic genocide
That’s because they don’t. I’ve heard once that if the Daleks ever actually won, they’d go insane from despair and kill each other, simply because there would be nothing left to aspire to.
@@knightofarkronia9968 That's Hate for you, it's ultimately self-destructive.
@@knightofarkronia9968 Its likely they'd cause another civil war. It's common already for factions of daleks to see each other as impure, not just genetically but culturally, and as not living up to the dalek ideal.
I promise that Chris' performance in Dalek is the single greatest performance from a doctor in all of Who.
The daleks, Doctor and Van Staten are a tripartite system of superiority in this scene. I love it!
yes
One of the most powerful scene in Doctor Who
Hearing a doctor say kys though
"You would make a good Dalek" CHILLS!!!
Imagine how many memes the Dalek has in it's head
I love the logic of davies. If one dalek can be deadly and absolutely bombastic, imagine an army. Brilliant writing.
"You would make a good Dalek!"
Still a much better powerful line than Into the Dalek.
It's not the line that makes this episode so special, it's the episode that comes with it. The Eccleston episode deals with the Doctor's anger and PTSD, and he is a better person by the end of it.
The Capaldi episode, the Dalek just says the Doctor is a good Dalek, and neither the Dalek nor the Doctor do anything after that. It feels empty, specially when we have a much better sene to compare it with.
Capaldi is the best Doctor yet in my opinion, but Moffat's writting is all about hype and one-shots, it never delievered anything.
"I win. How about that?" They don't write these like this no nmore.
the line in 'Into the Dalek' means something completely different. 'good' is used here as in 'functional' or 'efficient'. the doctor would make a good dalek because he's bloodthirsty. in into the dalek, the dalek is telling the doctor that, like him, he is a dalek TURNED good (good, as in, kind, nice, etc). idk why so many doctor who fans completely misread this.
"you would make a good dalek"
iconic line
@@mrjekyllandhyde9941 Of course it's a iconic line.
@@SegaNintendoGuy64 other iconoc lines
"but do I have the right"
"There should have been another way."
"In all my travelling throughout the universe, I have battled against evil, against power-mad conspirators. I should have stayed here. The oldest civilisation: decadent, degenerate, and rotten to the core. Power-mad conspirators, Daleks, Sontarans, Cybermen - they're still in the nursery compared to us. Ten million years of absolute power. That's what it takes to be really corrupt."
"Homo sapiens. What an inventive, invincible species. It's only a few million years since they've crawled up out of the mud and learned to walk. Puny, defenceless bipeds. They've survived flood, famine and plague. They've survived cosmic wars and holocausts, and now here they are amongst the stars, waiting to begin a new life, ready to outsit eternity. They're indomitable. Indomitable!"
and finally
"change my dear and it seems not a moment too soon"
if you can name every episode then you can have a cookie Lol
Love this scene so much and I miss Christopher ecclestion
he was and is always my favorite doctor, i didnt realise growing up he had like 2 seconds of screen time :\
@@epicwarehouse5003 What do you mean by 2 seconds of screen time?
@Andrew Chapman ever heard of exaggeration?
@@fear_cheetah2079 Okay, just wasn't sure what he meant by 2 seconds of screen time.
There have been many great scenes since this episode but none have ever topped this
Utttly superb. When Doctor Who is this good it is some of the best Sci Fi in the world. Every series has episodes and moments that are memorable TV. Just keep them coming please (when it is eventually is possible!)
1:37 Ouch
I can see why so many people have placed this as there most favorite Eccleston episode and maybe the best Dalek story of the new series
But I’m still with The Parting of the Ways for the best Dalek episode of the new series but this is a wonderful and powerful script
Man that line gives me chills
I feel like the best scenes with the doctor and daleks happen through a screen or any kind of system where they aren’t physically next to each other. Any scene with the doctor and daleks actually face to face feels wrong to me.
Cos he should be dead.
@@nightowl8477
Doctor is Dalek's greatest enemy, Rusty hates daleks. So it makes sense he would keep doctor alive.
@@jeckjeck3119 There've been plenty of other occasions though where the Doctor and a Dalek have been face to face with one another, and they've not tried killing him (and his survival wasn't some necessary part of a plan).
@@Vlorsutes
There is explanation for that too, but it only works up to series 9: The doctor is a part of their history, he saves Davors, without Davros, they don't exist or survive. That's why they are hesitant to kill him, despite their bloodlust, if they kill him (Let's say) in series 5... 12th doesn't go back to save Davros and they all die.
@jeck jeck I don’t think that’s a good explanation tho bc there’s plenty of time where the daleks do try to straight up kill him
Such a good episode and performance from Eccleston. The only season of modern who that I really got in to.
2 of the best moments in Doctor Who, both from the same phenomenal episode, released within a few days of each other! FANTASTIC! Happy 15th "Dalek"! Wish every episode was like this.
That Dalek should have become the Doctor's companion.
Could you imagine if this was actually it. If we NEVER got another Dalek again. The most terrifying foe of old Who and all that's left is one scared little slug
The best Dalek episode in new Who
The best modern doctor with no doubt
The most depressed dalek
This scene always gives me shivers. AMAZING
Back when Dalek's were truly threatening and terrifying. The sheer presence of one sent dread and chills down my spine. Now they are a joke. I want to see this kind of darkness and anger again.
They were threatening in 1966
Hands down one of my favourite scenes in all of Eccleston's run as well as New Who!
Two beings of the last of their kind: one shows anger, hatred to the other, willing to kill it without second chance. The other is a Dalek who only want orders and later one to be free
Love the 9th. 13th sucks. Just had to vent
Truth bombs like Slim Pickens riding a Nuclear warhead.
Eccleston at his best!
Eccleston is super underrated. He was an amazing Doctor.
There's a lesson in this. If you allow yourself to become just as bad as your enemy, then it doesn't matter if you win. Becoming your enemy means they have won, regardless of the outcome. And their essence will outlive them and follow you for as long as you live.
He is actually my favorite new Doctor. Of course Baker will always be #1.
This is still probably the best exchange between the Doctor and a Dalek. For him to argue the Dalek into a corner, trying to force it to accept the pointlessness of its existence because all it has to live for is hatred and then the Dalek to get the psychological upperhand by turning it back on him. Genius writing.
The biggest insult the doctor could ever receive
An amazing doctor 🥺
Love this scene.
Through their lives through the Thousands of years they have lived The Doctor has always had one enemy that stalked them more than any other
The master
@@fear_cheetah2079 Yes, but the Daleks have been used throughout the show well more often than The Master has. I'm almost certain that every Doctor besides McGann TV-wise has had at least one Dalek story if not more where as alot of Doctors haven't even come in contact with the rival timelord at least in terms of the show.
@Lee227 yeah but the important thing is that the other guy mentioned stalking the doctor. The daleks have never stalked him. In most of the master stories, the master is actively looking for the doctor, in most Dalek stories the meeting is just coincidence
Best scene of 9
I think his best line is when he says “no” to the emperor in the finale
@@fear_cheetah2079 that scene is epic he has alot of great moments but this just tops it as he his able to realese all his hate and anguish he holds against the Daleks and it is thrown right back at him
The darkness that involves the Daleks and the Time War is what also makes this a great episode! This scene is one of the Ninth Doctor’s iconic scenes during Series 1!
1:33 Wipe your mouth, Doctor.
Thank Chris for that one. Conscious decision on his part to make the Doctor look ugly as he spews that hatred out.
Classic story!
“You would make a good Dalek”- Dalek from the episode “Dalek”
“I am not a good Dalek, you are a good Dalek” -Rusty
Which come to think about it, the Doctor would really be a good Dalek. Since he/she is the most feared person in the universe..
Plus, there’s the intense hatred that flows through the Doctor’s veins. The Daleks only find beauty in hate. Perhaps there’s a reason why they’ve never been able to kill the Doctor...
Love this scene ❤️
Just as devastating with words as with their guns.
This was the Daleks at their best.
I've never liked Into the Dalek. But then again, the sequel's never as good, is it?
Chris Chibnall would be a good dalek too, irony intended
Apparently writing stories you don’t like is the same was genocide and murder
Very fitting it was raining as he said that huh.
Best Eccleston story hands down
I remember when doctor who used to be good
Doctor who is amazing
Christopher Eccleston was a fantastic Doctor and should have done more. But the star that burns the brightest burns half as long
The genuine sadness and self-pity in the Dalek asking the Doctor "Then what should I do?" is such a beautiful little moment. The Daleks are often characterised as mindless killer robots, but that moment, of the Dalek questioning its existential purpose, asking its worst enemy what to do in the face of the destruction of its entire species, is an excellent reminder of why it is an imperative that writers treat them as thinking beings.
15 years and 2 days ago.
Sheer joy and heaven.
Stay safe, healthy and happy everyone.
This started Tue endless binge watching
Lol backfires it at the doctor lol
Into the dalek feels like a spiritual sequel to dalek
And yet the daleks keep coming back
"Fantastic oh fantastic!"
YOU WOULD MAKE A GOOD DALEK
Right in the feels.
The Dalek recited some cool Lyrics for Hawkwind.
Later regeneration: YOU are a good Dalek.
People wonder why people who grew up with 9 don't like 13. Just look at this, they couldn't even make anything nearly as good as this scene.
I grew up watching reruns of number 4 on Public Access late at night. 13 is great by comparison.
you have to admire the purity of the dalek
Only thing missing is the dalek holding a boombox playing In Your Eyes by Peter Gabriel...
I just love this Scene 😍
Best Dalek story in the Revival, maybe the series.
I've always though with this that the force field that melts the bullets should also turn the water into steam.
I Watched Power of the Daleks after I watch this which gave me a ideal for a story.
I like how he tells the dalek to kill himself
What would’ve been equally as hard is if the doctor despite hate was willing to offer the bot hope of a new purpose, telling it to protect what is good and destroy what seeks to only destroy for the sake of causing destruction but the dalek takes up his offer the wrong way and kills itself, reasoning since it was created for the purpose of destroying simply to destroy that it itself needed to be destroyed
Yes
Ecclestons's arc > Donna's arc > Martha's arc > cat poop > Rose and 10th's arc.
I do see where you are coming from. The love story was cute, but Rose was literally just used as a love interest and exposition device
Strangely the YT subtitles say APPLAUSE when the Dalek starts speaking. That'd be good actually...
Ah. It was all good then it was ruined by that "joddy" doctor blabbering in the inset.
Aww, this makes me miss Rusty.
This is how this scene works properly Moffat.
Moffat doesn't even make doctor who episodes now lol
You mean Chibnall? Moffat is a genius in comparison to that hack Chibnall.
Crash Bash I think she was comparing this to the series 8 Dalek episode
The Dalek told the Ninth "You would make a good Dalek." Then many years later Rusty told the Twelfth "You are a good Dalek." over 1100 years bridged the gap from would make to are.
What is an enemy who will not fight back? Who shall become an allie in the last of thier kind?
Hmmm... Rusty....
The moment 9 because a gamer
Back when Doctor Who was good
I know
HD? Are you sure about that?
No, I am better then that;
back when daleks were stuff of nightmare nd even the doc used to fare it now they jst joke bruh
That line just makes your blood run cold........
Beilliant
Punch me if you want but what is a Dalek? 😅
900th like! The irony is high!